please watch this video
charanjeev singh · 26 Jun 2005
http://www.khalsa.tv/?view=19
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
charanjeev singh · 26 Jun 2005
http://www.khalsa.tv/?view=19JSGyani "Arshi" · 27 Jun 2005
a lot of other GOOD STUFF there too. I have seen this DVD as it was sent to me from Canada by a friend. It is the TRUTH. I made many copies and distributed among the sangat. every SIKH who can do so should do so. The FUNNY THING is that when I mailed this dvd to some relatives in PUNJAB...it was sent back immediately with a letter asking me if i wanted them DEAD or tortured by POLICE ??..if they were caught with such material in their house !!! NO wonder they say Punjab is now quiet...they are frightened.....BUT the PHOENIX will RISE AGAIN.098 · 27 Jun 2005
I have listened to Dr. Udhoke Ji personally and meet him. He is a Homeopathic Doctor by proffession but have done a great deal of good work on documenting the attacks on Sikh's in a form of a bookStraight Arrow · 27 Jun 2005
The FUNNY THING is that when I mailed this dvd to some relatives in PUNJAB...it was sent back immediately with a letter asking me if i wanted them DEAD or tortured by POLICE ??..if they were caught with such material in their house !!! NO wonder they say Punjab is now quiet...they are frightened.....BUT the PHOENIX will RISE AGAIN. Gyani jee, When was the last time you went to Punjab? Who are frightened? The Sikhs? Well, if you went to Punjab or Delhi, you will find that 80% of the Sikhs do not want anymore bloodshed. I know you don't believe me and will probably label me as a Brahmin or a communist or a communalist or a RAW agent (I am neither) but I don't care about that. I would rather have a debate with you on this. Some are frighetend yes, but most are at peace with themselves, doing very well economically and getting to the top positions (Dr Manmohan Singh, Gen JJ Singh, Malwinder Singh of Ranbaxy etc.). Can you tell me if the top man of USA, UK, Canda, Australia etc. has ever been anyone other than a White Christian?No, right? Think about that.... · 27 Jun 2005
Straight Arrow aka. Mouthpiece of Hindu India, How is it asking for bloodshed to know the way in which the RSS is trying to absorb Sikhi into its fold and is distorting Sikh history? Why is it offensive to you? You would love it if Sikhs bellied up and accepted that they are Hindus and ended this game. Sorry. It won't happen. At the very least boot-licking India-Bhagats like you should have the integrity to stand up when RSS attacks Sikh principles. Even if you don't have the guts or self-respect to understand that Sikhs have a God-given right to rule, you should at least feel some pain when someone calls Banda Singh Bahadur a Hindu warrior or claims that the Sahibzadey were blessed by Vishnu.Straight Arrow · 27 Jun 2005
Author: ... Date: 06-27-05 12:04 Straight Arrow aka. Mouthpiece of Hindu India, How is it asking for bloodshed to know the way in which the RSS is trying to absorb Sikhi into its fold and is distorting Sikh history? Why is it offensive to you? You would love it if Sikhs bellied up and accepted that they are Hindus and ended this game. Sorry. It won't happen. At the very least boot-licking India-Bhagats like you should have the integrity to stand up when RSS attacks Sikh principles. Even if you don't have the guts or self-respect to understand that Sikhs have a God-given right to rule, you should at least feel some pain when someone calls Banda Singh Bahadur a Hindu warrior or claims that the Sahibzadey were blessed by Vishnu. ...Jee, See, I knew I would be branded something like a raw agent but "Mouthpiece of Hindu India" is a new one but I think most people on this site know that I am a Hindu and haven't tried to hide that fact. In any case, my post was in response to Gyani Jee's post and not a comment on RSS. Now that you do mention in and want my views on it, I have said several times, RSS does NOT represent all of Hindus. It is a hardline organization which has been shunned by the Hindus (BJP was soundly thrashed in the elections). Had you read my earlier posts, you would not have made all these scathing comments but I guess these comments from you have come because of lack of objectivity. Call me boot licking Indian Bhagat. Yes I am. I love India but since when did loving India mean a love for GOI or RSS? RSS is a medieval age organization wrapped up in mythologies which is why it has lost its relevance in today's age and that is why it is trying any desparate tactics at its disposal. I NEVER said that I supported them in any way? What made you think so? Again, you have used several insults at me but I have no problem with that although I did expect better. Anyway, I hope I have been able to clarify my point better. My apologies if I have offended you.Bhopinder Singh · 27 Jun 2005
Straight Arrow ji I respect you and your Hindustan as a Hindu you should be proud of that sameway moslems are proud of pakistan and they should be, But we Sikhs want our own country like both of you.We have different cultre ,language and religion . what if the British had made Nehru the governer gen. and Gandhi the viceroy would you still like to be a colony of British?No Question is you should leave Khalistan for Sikhs and enjoy your life in afree Hindustan we have no problem with that,Its only your hindu army and media that relates our wish for independence with voilence we want it peacefully please understand us and leave Khalistan we still can leave peacefullyStraight Arrow · 27 Jun 2005
what if the British had made Nehru the governer gen. and Gandhi the viceroy would you still like to be a colony of British?No Bhopinder Singh Ji, That is a good point and my answer to that would be NO. I would not like to live in Colonial Britain even with Nehru and Gandhi at the top posts so I will totally agree with you there. I am in no position to decide about Khalistan but I do think that if the majority of the people want Khalistan, may be thats what the decision should be. However, As Mr. Khushwant Singh wrote, 'I have failed to meet a single individual who could rationally explain to me its concept, its geographical boundaries, its religious composition and its proposed political and economic set up . . .' 'However, on a visit to England, I was able to acquire some documentation on the subject which reveals a total confusion in the minds of its supporters. One is a detailed map of Khalistan - the first that I have seen. It is published in England priced at £2 but no date of publication is mentioned. According to the map, Khalistan will include Jammu, the whole of Himachal Pradesh, Haryana, Delhi, chunks of Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan and Saurashtra to give the state an outlet to the sea. Even by a rough estimate, the Sikh population of this state will not be more than 13 per cent of the total population. What kind of a Sikh state would this be? Clearly, far from a democratic one. Nevertheless, a boxed item explaining the concept describes it as a 'a sort of paradise on earth.' ' (My Bleeding Punjab, pp. 155-6) Even if the land is to consist only of Punjab, Sikhs are less than 65% of the population of Punjab. Will Khalistan mean the rest of the communties being kicked out of Punjab? Because they will certainly not support the idea of Khalistan. What about the Sikhs themselves? Is there a guarantee that the entire Sikh population supports Khalistan? What about the more than 1 million Sikhs who live in India outside Punjab? Will they come to Khalistan? Anyway, my point wasn't to prove or disprove the need for Khalistan, just to point out some practicalities (or impracticalities). Also, the "Hindu Army" is being headed by a sikh and even though Sikhs are 2% of the Indian population, they represent almost 8-10 % of the armed forces. Bhool Chook maaf.Bhopinder Singh · 27 Jun 2005
Straight Arrow ji I am sure you know about thr boundries see that is same aproach for theGOI.Present punjab should be the answer. No population should move.Even the Sikh population was not asked the question in1947 it was the question of different entities I think it was a mistake in 1947 Hindus,Sikhs,Moslems should have stayed the place , anyway past is past.I dont mean I am against Pakistan,infact i think moslems were right in their demand atleast they have geopolitical entity aplace that defends them a bastion as Musharaf said. Sameway Hindus are safe and secure in Hindustan and they should be,Yes their are problems but they are a part of life same in Pakistan.Brother you should think positively and allow us the glow of freedom which we deserve.We dont have any illwill towards you or your country same should you Hindus can live in Khalistan same way as they are living in Pakistan and Moslems in Hindustan or as jews are living in america but they have Israel.098 · 27 Jun 2005
Straight Arrow Ji, Do you think India is able to serve justice with victims of 1984 riots or those who were tortured, raped and boiled alive have had any justice from Indian Justice system ? If your answere is NO, then that means there is something wrong in Indian systems and victims have all the right to ask for justice and if justice is not served they have the full right to wage a war. Do you agree ? Manmohan Singh, JJ Singh, etc. are decoration pieces in Indian living room ... nothing more. They do not represent Sikh voice, they are just doing their job's making a living. You must know that many fake encounters took place in Kashmir when JJ Singh was Brigade Command overlooking the fight agains terrorism..... You also must know that Manmohan Singh was Finance Minister of India when majority of Sikh youth were killed in fake encounter's in Punjab by KPS Gill You also must know that Giani Zial Singh wad PRESIDENT OF INDIA (for god's sake) when Indian army attacked Shri Darbar Sahib....... So these so called Sikh figures do not represent Sikh voice or the families of victims......Straight Arrow · 27 Jun 2005
Bhopinder Singh Ji and 098 Ji, Totally agree with you and I know that you don't have any ill will towards me and it is directed towards the govt. of India and I think it is TOTALLY justified and yes, you are right, justice has NOT been served to the victims of 1984 riots. Also, I am not trying to butt in between important discussion, my only point is that my voice may be gives you a slightly different perspective and I think 99% of the time, the debates have been very objective and I have been able to see your side as well. My only take on Khalistan would be that in case it happens, what are the three four things that you think would be better than the present scenario. Not just for the Sikhs but also for other communities because remember, 30-35% of the population would be non-Sikh if the present scenario holds. You don't have to answer it, just think about it. How can you make Khalistan better than the present Punjab.AVTAR · 28 Jun 2005
straight arrow veer ji, already 21 years still the sikh have not received justice.not even apologize for hindustan govt for attacking sri darbar sahib. but murder of cows in haryana has given justice. how can we continue to stay with india? india is hell for all the minority. it is sad when it come for independent of hindustan,sikh never question about hindustan but today you (hindu) are question about khalstan. look at history,in khalsa raj., non mandir, mosque or church was distory and now under hindustan you are aware what happing. you say you agree sikh yet to receive justice .but what you (hindu) have done.21 years already none of hindu speak for us.and yet you want us stay in hindustan. but when come to us we save your religion,hindu girls from mugal in return we are murder and humiliate daily.please think before, just replying this mail. we (sikh) have no choice. we cant stay in the country that murder our guru ( shri guru granth shaib) and is duty of all sikh to defend any insult to our guru.so khalistan is must.and it will be no matter how many live will be shaheed in the hand of this hindustan gov.JSGyani "Arshi" · 28 Jun 2005
staright arrow ji, Wonder why you are bringing in "self proclaimed accusations" of being RAW Agent, Brahmin etc etc. WHO mentioned RAW Agent ?? are you "baiting" someone to call you that in a self fulfilling prophecy of sorts..I told you so... The DVD was sent to 21 different Villages in kapurthala, Ropar, Amrtisar, Ferozpur, Sangrur, Bhatinda, Jullundur. 18 came back...some in PLAIN Envelopes without return addresses, 3 came back with letters requesting not be sent such. Any reasonable person can draw his own conclusions as to are the Punjabis really "free" or enslaved people afraid even to think./keep such materials in their homes. so much for "democracy... Straight Arrow is aimed at Sikh HEARTS...or it is not as staright as it tries to portray. TRUTH comes out sooner or later and in this case it has come staright out as William Tell's Arrow.Straight Arrow · 28 Jun 2005
Gyani ji, The reason I came to this site and joined the message board was to have discussions about the greatness of Sikhi and how to achieve spiritual upliftment through Naam simran and that is how it started off. I had several enlightening discussions with the likes of Kulbir Singh Ji. Unfortunately, I'm getting drawn into unnecessary debates and controversies. Don't get me wrong, they are extremely important issues and should be dealt with as such. My only point of contention with myself is that this is not what I was looking for from this website. Therefore, I apologize to the sangat for any wrongdoing and in future, will only comment on the spiritual messages on this website. Warm regards,Bhopinder Singh · 28 Jun 2005
Straight arrow ji Let me ask you the same question in the timeframe of 1947 and i am asking you as a Brit. your answer will be leave it for us you mind your own buisness. Exactly the same question was raised in the British parliament before 1947 with regards to Indian independence ,I HOPE YOU REMEMBER THE ANSWER of WINSTON churchil the then Prime minister of England if not i will write them in next posteBhopinder Singh · 28 Jun 2005
This discussion is very spirtiual please keep on going as you can see Iam answering all your questions and now you can tell the same to fellow Hindus.Bhopinder Singh · 28 Jun 2005
My only take on Khalistan would be that in case it happens, what are the three four things that you think would be better than the present scenario. Not just for the Sikhs but also for other communities because remember, 30-35% of the population would be non-Sikh if the present scenario holds. You don't have to answer it, just think about it. How can you make Khalistan better than the present Punjab. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Straight arrow ji Let me ask you the same question in the timeframe of 1947 and i am asking you as a Brit. your answer will be leave it for us you mind your own buisness. Exactly the same question was raised in the British parliament before 1947 with regards to Indian independence ,I HOPE YOU REMEMBER THE ANSWER of WINSTON churchil the then Prime minister of England if not i will write them in next poste.. · 04 Jul 2005
It is very true that sikhs in India now feel they are just fine and do not want bloodshed. If sikhs could get khalistan without bloodshed than in one second they would take it. That is unlikely to happen as India will never just hand over Khalistan, and majority of sikhs simply see there lives as just fine right now and no need to bring up Khalistan as of yet. This is the truth.Bhopinder singh · 05 Jul 2005
.. ji They will leave just like the British did.