Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Eika nari Jati hoye ??

Eika nari Jati hoye ??

Dubidha · 22 Jun 2005

A long standing doubt of mine Gurbani preaches : "Eika naari jati hoye" - Wheras Guru gobind singh ji had 3 wives ? The rehat maryada also talks of one single wife. Can anyone please clear this dubidha.

Re: Eika nari Jati hoye ??

Lahantiai · 22 Jun 2005

Who told you that? Mr Rangeela or Jagadhri Wala. .....or so called Jathedaar of Patana Sahib. Do you think Guru Ji were preaching different than what they were doing?

Re: Eika nari Jati hoye ??

Princess · 23 Jun 2005

None of our Guru Sahibaan had more than one wife. Being sikhs of Guru Sahib jee, first thing we all must have is faith and trust on every single word of our Guru Sahibaan. Gurbani can't be wrong but history is not always true because it's written by different historians and many of them were not faithful to sikhs and tried to make it controvercial.

Re: Eika nari Jati hoye ??

charanjeev singh · 23 Jun 2005

It is very important to understand one principal; as sikhs we do not mimmick the Guru but we folllow the orders of the Guru. We cannot understand the 'rang' of our Guru. It is an order of our Guru that a sikh can only have one wife/husband; and that is all that is needed. My understanding is that Mata Jito Jee was also known as Mata Sundri Jee, a nickname given by Mata Gujree Jee. Mata Sahib Kaur is the mother of the Khalsa. Forgive me if i have made errors. Again i stress; we must only follow the Hukam of the Guru. Guru Sahibs went hunting; do we? no. Guru Gobind Singh Jee was also Kalghidhar Patshah, do we wear Kalgis? Guru Sahib knows His 'Rang'; if we be so blessed His orders are His Grace. bhul chuk mauf

Re: Eika nari Jati hoye ??

stranger · 23 Jun 2005

Here we go again If you had one wife and did something famous - many generations down the road writers would not say 'Mr Singh had 3 wives' or 'Mr Singh had 4 wives'. They would say 'Mr Singh had 1 wife' because that is a fact. As Guru Gobind Singh Ji had more than 1 wife it is stated as that NOT that he had 1 wife. Further the names have been given along with birth/death dates. Many in the past on these postings have tried to give logically argument to facts such as various names for one women!! Get over it - he had his reasons and they should not be questioned

Re: Eika nari Jati hoye ??

dubidha · 23 Jun 2005

Thanks Charanjeev I am very happy to see your relpy. Seems like you have the makings of a good sikh , the rest of them will keep on fighting on "Sarabloh", "Raagmala" and "Sikhi is the only religion for kalyug"

Re: Eika nari Jati hoye ??

Mehtab Singh · 23 Jun 2005

I firmly aree with bhai charanjeev singh jee that Guru Gobind Singh Jee had only 1 wife Mata Jeeto jee who was also called Mata Sundari, and Mata Sahib Kaur jee is referred to as "kunwara dola". "Dola" comes from "doli", the palanquin in which a bride sits and goes to her in laws. And "kunwara" means unmarried. So obviously it means that Mata Sahib Kaur and Gurujee were only the spiritual parents of the Khalsa and not the usual duniyawi husband-wife and never had any physical relations. However some Singhs do believe Sachhay Patshah had 3 wives and they say its there written in authentic historical records. I am sorry to go off topic here, but i have a similar question in mind. From historical records, its stated that 6th patshah, Guru Hargobind jee had 3 wives and 5 kids. Non-Sikhs use this argument to say that our Gurus were like ordinary mortals who married more than once and had number of kids from them. I know the reason why Gurujee married 3 times. It was because the girls were promised by their fathers and as was the case in India back then, if u dont marry the man u r promised to, u stay unmarried forever. So to avoid that, Gurujee married 3 times. This was out of concern for their life and not because He wanted to have wives. What I am looking for is more info on this matter. I cant stand some loser thinking our Gurus were mere mortals and trying to belittle Sikhi. I have my points, just need some more solid ones coz i m a super maha moorakh with less than one ounce of gyaan ([i]i m again overestimating myself[/i]) and want to be able to convince others ([i]if ever questioned on this matter[/i]) that our Gurus were NOT mere mortals, not even close! thanks in advance

Re: Eika nari Jati hoye ??

Lord Singh · 23 Jun 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!! Here is an article I found earlier cocerning this topic which I agree with fully: The myth of Guru Gobind Singh je having more than one wife ! "Why did Guru Gobind Singh have more than one wife? How many marriages did Guru Gobind Singh have? The wrong impression that the Guru had more than one wife was created by those writers who were ignorant of punjabi culture. Later authors accepted those writings regarding more than one marriage of the Guru and presented other important people usually had more than one wife as a symbol of their being great and superior to the common man. Guru Gobind Singh, being a true king, was justified in their eyes to have more than one wife. This is actually incorrect. In the Punjab, there are two and sometimes three big functions connected with a marriage, i.e., engagement, wedding and Muklawa. Big gatherings and singings are held at all these three functions. In many cases, engagements were held as soon as one had passed the baby stage. Even today, engagements at 8-12 years age are not uncommon in some interior parts of the country. The wedding is performed a couple of years after the engagement. After the wedding, it takes another couple of years for the bride to move in with her in-laws and live there. This is called Muklawa. Dowry and other gifts to the bride are usually given at the time of this ceremony to help her to establish a new home. A big befitting function and other joyful activities were held at Anandpur, according to the customs, at the time of the engagement of the Guru. The bride, Mata Jeeto Ji, resided in Lahore which was the capital of the Mughal rulers, who were not on good terms with the Gurus. When the time for the marriage ceremony came, it was not considered desirable for the Guru to go to Lahore along with Sikhs in large numbers. Furthermore, it would involve a lot of inconvenience to the Sangat, young and old, who wished to witness the marriage of the Guru. Therefore, as mentioned in the Sikh chronicles, Lahore was 'brought' to Anandpur Sahib for the marriage instead of the Guru going to Lahore. A scenic place, a couple of miles to the north of Anandpur was developed into a nice camp for the marriage. This place was named Guru Ka Lahore. People going to Anandpur visit this place as well. The bride was brought to this place by her parents and the marriage was celebrated with a very huge gathering attending the ceremony. The two elaborate functions, one at the time of engagement and the other at the time of the marriage of the Guru, gave the outside observers the impression of two marriages. They had the reason to feel like that because a second name was also there, i.e., Mata Sundari Ji. After the marriage, there is a custom in the Punjab to give a new affectionate name to the bride by her in-laws. Mata Jeeto Ji because of her fine features and good looks, was named Sundari (beautiful) by the Guru's mother. The two names and two functions gave a cause to the outsiders to believe that the Guru had two wives. In fact, the Guru had one wife with two names as explained above. There is one more very important function in the life of the Guru and the Sikhs. It took place in 1699 when the Guru founded the Khalsa Panth. For preparation of Amrit, he took a Khanda and a Bata (bowl) and asked Mata Sahib Kaur to bring Patasas (puffed sugar) for adding to the water in the Bata. Thus, Guru Gobind Singh and Mata Sahib Kaur jointly particpated in preparing Amrit. Alongwith firmness like steel, weetness is another great character of the Khalsa, gifted respectively by Guru Gobind Singh and Mata Sahib Kaur to them. Whereas Guru Gobind Singh is recognized as the spiritual father of the Khalsa, Mata Sahib Kaur is recognized as the spiritual mother of the Khalsa. Again, people not conversant with the Amrit ceremony mistakenly assume that Mata Sahib Kaur was the wife of Guru Gobind Singh. As Guru Gobind Singh is the spiritual father but not hte physical father of the khalsa, Mata Sahib Kaur is the spiritual mother of the Khalsa but not the physical wife of the Guru Gobind Singh. Because of their ignorance of the Punjabi culture and the Amrit ceremony, some writers mistook these three names of hte women in the life of Guru Gobind Singh as the names of three wives. Another reason for this misunderstanding is that the parents of Mata Sahib Kaur had decided to marry her to Guru Gobind Singh. When the proposal was brought for discussion at Anandpur, the Guru said that he could not have another wife because he was allready married. The dilemma before the parents of the girl was that, the proposal having become public, no Sikh would be willing to marry her. The Guru agreed for her stay at Anandpur but without accepting her as is wife. The question arose, as every woman desires to have a child, how she could have one without being married. The Guru said, "She will be the mother of a great son who will live forever and be known all over the world." The people understood the hidden meaning of his statement only after the Guru associated Mata Sahib Kaur with preparing Amrit by bringing Patasas. It is, therefore, ignorant to consider Mata Sahib Kaur as the worldly wife of Guru Gobind Singh." Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!! "Bhindranwale Sant Sipahi, Jihna Suthi Kuam Jugaee"

Re: Eika nari Jati hoye ??

stranger · 24 Jun 2005

What about Sri Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji? He had more then one wife??

Re: Eika nari Jati hoye ??

cybersingh · 24 Jun 2005

another theory i heard was that infact Guru Ji did have three different wives, but that he was never married to all three at the same time...meaning that he maried one, and she passed away, then he remarried, and she too died, and then he remarried again. i dunno how correct this is. ...infact i heard it on a post :S

Re: Eika nari Jati hoye ??

Mehtab Singh · 24 Jun 2005

<<<<<<<<<<<< Author: stranger Date: 06-24-05 01:58 What about Sri Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji? He had more then one wife?? >>>>>>>>>>>> yes i m waiting for a reply as well... <<<<<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>>>>>>> nah that doesnt sound true

Re: Eika nari Jati hoye ??

Dandilion · 24 Jun 2005

Charanjeev singh you are absolutely right, who are we to question our Guru Sahib Ji. And as for the article by Lord Singh, I have seem many of these articles by people who try to make sense of things with their limited avasta and knowledge. Marriage with Mata Jeeto Ji July, 1677 Marriage to Mata Sundri Ji May, 1685 Birth of S. Ajit Singh Ji to Mata Sundri Ji November, 1686 Birth of S. Jujhar Singh Ji to Mata Jeeto ji March,1690 Birth of S. Zorawar Singh Ji to mata Jeeto Ji 1697 Birth of S. Fateh Singh Ji to Mata Jeeto Ji Mata Sahib Kaur is - mother of Khalsa panth. [%sig%]

Re: Eika nari Jati hoye ??

Manjit kaur · 24 Jun 2005

Guru Gobind Singh Ji at age NINE sent His father to Delhi to be SACRIFICED. He sent his Elder two sons Ajit Singh Ji and Jhujaar Singh Ji to battlefield CERTAIN DEATH in front of His eyes... His Mother and two younger sons also SACRIFICED for KHALSA... When TOLD about all this He said..Chaar MOYEEAH to kia hoooaah JEEWAT KAYEE HAZAAR.... meaning so what IF FOUR DIED...amny THOUSANDS of my KHALSA SONS are still alive. To those in "dubidha" ( ha ha HA !!) who Want to MARRY FOUR wives to COPY GURU JI...(Patna Sahib jathedar Iqbal singh, is ONE of these etc etc) MY DUBHIDHA QUERY to you is..CAN YOU COPY GURU JI in all the other aspects...send your dad to die, your sons into battle, your sons into Walls foundations, your aged mother to death..and then CALL the THOUSANDS khalsa as YOUR OWN SONS and TREAT them all that way ??? SHAME on such DUBHIDHAS.... YOU are nano-millimetres tall compared to the MOUNT EVEREST Guru Ji...marry four indeed ??? I wonder if you can find even one wife !!! a very angry daughter of Guru Ji

Re: Eika nari Jati hoye ??

Mehtab Singh · 24 Jun 2005

Taken from : http://members.dancris.com/~sikh/chap08.html GURU'S FAMILY: The Guru had five sons and one daughter. They were: Baba Gurditta was born to Mata Damodri in 1613. Bibi Viro was born to Mata Damodri in 1615. Baba Surj Mal was born to Mata Marwahi in 1617. Baba Ani Rai was born to Mata Nanaki in 1618. Baba Atal Rai was born to Mata Nanaki in 1619. Baba Tegh Bahadur was born to Mata Nanaki in 1621. Taken from : http://allaboutsikhs.com/history/his0328.htm 1620 Guru Hargobind Ji had to marry Nanaki despite his refusal. This was an unfortunate upshot of the jubilation in Sikh community caused by Guru Sahib's release from seven years of incarceration. Within a few months two brides were pledged to him by their parents. Under the customs prevalent at that time, on Guru Hargobind's refusal, those girls would have remained unmarried throughout their life. So he had to marry Nanaki on March 28, 1620, and Mehrai also called Marwahi on July 10, 1620. The first incident occurred too close to his release. Taken aback at the second incident, he announced that no one should pledge his daughter to him in future. [i]I already know this. I have been requesting more info. Thanks again.[/i] [%sig%]

Re: Eika nari Jati hoye ??

Dandilion · 24 Jun 2005

Manjit kaur benji, stop rambling and make your point. <<< who Want to MARRY FOUR wives to COPY GURU JI >>> we really are getting hot under the collar and making no sense. The fact is people equate three Mahals to kaam. These people are fools with little knowledge of Guru Sahib Ji. Guru Sahib Ji had complete control over the five chores, infact the five chores are nowhere near Guru Sahib Ji. There are many reasons for Guru Ji's three Mahals but at the nd of the day, who are we to question the divine wisdom of Akal Saroop Guru Gobind Singh Ji and Guru Hargobind Sahib Ji

Re: Eika nari Jati hoye ??

Mehtab Singh · 24 Jun 2005

Manjit Kaur jee Its not that we are having dubidha. Its just that I want some more info/knowledge on matters relating to Guru Hargobind Jee. Not that i dont have faith, but i want a way to shut those up who compare our Gurus to mere mortals by giving them some piece of the truth. bhul chuk maaf

Re: Eika nari Jati hoye ??

Manjit kaur · 24 Jun 2005

GURBANI SAYS: In my thinking this is direct afront to Guruji's Mahawaak: Gur ki karni kahey dhavau? Gur kahyiaa su kaar kamawauo|| It clearly forbids us from EMULATING the Guru, but instead asks us to DO WHAT GURU JI TELLS US TO DO. We need NOT worry about WHAT the GURUS did..we only need to FOLLOW what the GURUS TOLD US to do.....and this is clearly instructed in above Tuk. I rest my case.

Re: Eika nari Jati hoye ??

sahibzaadiyan dee prerna · 25 Jun 2005

Pls. say if you are the same Chiranjeev , now in USA but parents in Patiala. Please do not take it as a personal comment and ignore. Well, this site can make some forgotten faces friends again. Many thanks

Re: Eika nari Jati hoye ??

Buta Singh · 13 Jan 2006

well done my sister/beti (who ever you are) yes you given right answer to them who know nothing about sikhism and the life of our GREATEST GURU SAHIBAN JI, i think the people who make this kind of comments or keep this kind of thaught are not belong to sikhs they are from Dhaian singh dogra and sucha nand family. NO ONE HAVE RIGHT TO RASE FINGER AT OUR GURU JI. THOSE PEOPLE ARE NOT SIKH WHO DONT TRUST IN GURU SAHIBAN AND PURAN SRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI (FROM EAK ONKAR TOON ATHARA DAS BEES) WELL DONE AGAIN.bUTA SINGH (SIR ANANDPUR SAHIB) (U.K)

Re: Eika nari Jati hoye ??

*** · 13 Jan 2006

i dont see the relevance of the post our Guru Is Guru Granth Sahib Ji follow Guru Ji's teachings and see for urself if its rong or right and not just wonder how many wives the other Gurus have had.. If u say its ok to have more than one wife then thats finee its up to you but then dont discriminate If a women wants more than one husband history will always be confusing we have the Guru Granth Sahib to go to if we are confused

Re: Eika nari Jati hoye ??

Manvir Singh Khalsa · 13 Jan 2006

Guru Hargobind Sahib Jee was married to MATA NANAKI JEE, and had children with MATA NANAKI JEE. All Gurus were married to ONE wife (exception of Guru HarKrishan Sahib jee who was physically very young). There is a Gurdwara in Lahore in memory of Mata Damodari Jee. Mata Damodari, was born in a Muslim family. Her father wanted to marry her to Guru Sahib, however Guru Sahib refused. Instead Guru Sahib gave her a house to stay in Lahore, where she stayed and did Bhagti for all her life. Final point, Sri Guru Granth Sahib jee is the LITMUS TEST for the truth. Why are in doubt about Guru Sahibaans jeevan where their jyot is Haazar Naazar with us. Gurbaani describes MARRIAGE as the UNION OF "TWO" BODIES. Yes, TWO. Not THREE, or FOUR. [gurbani]mÚ 3 ] Dn ipru eyih n AwKIAin bhin iekTy hoie ] eyk joiq duie mUrqI Dn ipru khIAY soie ]3][/gurbani] Translation:- "Third Mehl: They are not said to be husband and wife, who merely sit together. They alone are called husband and wife, who have one light in two bodies. ||3||" (Ang 788) Bhai Gurdaas Jee who accompanied the first 6 Saroops of Guru Nanak, and a honourable Gursikh and Maha-purakh (therefore a valuable source of knowledge to understand our Guru Sahibaans) states: [gurbani]eykw nwrI jqI hoie pr nwrI DI BYx vKwxY][/gurbani] Translation:- "Having one woman as wife he (the Sikh) is a celebate and considers any other's wife his daughter or a sister." Bhul chuk maaf, Daas, Manvir Singh Khalsa