Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Rehit and Raag

Rehit and Raag

... · 21 Jun 2005

Kulbir Singh wrote this in another thread: ____________________ I don't think all these sants with all their ridhi sidhis come even close to an ordinary Khalsa who keeps pooran rehit including Sarbloh bibek. None of their ridhi sidhis can work on Real Singhs and I believe Guru Sahib does not accept one's Naam Kamaayee without rehit. The best place is where pure Gurbani kirtan is sung by Guru ke Laal, Guru kee pyaray gursikhs. ____________________ Does pooran rehit include doing pure Gurbani kirtan as sung in Raag? Is raag maryada/rehit not as important as Sarbloh Bibek Rehit? Isn't it an even better place where pure Gurbani kirtan is done in Raag? Is one not keeping pooran rehit if he does not sing kirtan in Raag? Is someone who does ordinary kirtan a lesser Gurmukh than someone who does kirtan in Raag? Does it undermine pooran Khalsa rehit not to do kirtan in Raag? Will Guru Sahib except one's Naam Kamaayee if they do not do kirtan in Raag? I think you get my drift. Answers appreciated, especially from Kulbir Singh. :)

Re: Rehit and Raag

Hari Singh · 21 Jun 2005

Actually I don't get your drift at all... You are assuming that keertan can only be done in raag which isn't true. Although most of the bani's have a raag mentioned in the beginning of them doesn't mean that keertan isn't poora unless it is sung in that raag only. That is like saying paath isn't poora unless you say the numbers of each pauri and announce the ang number of each panna of the guru granth sahib as you are doing paath. Besides Singhs used to do keertan in jail using their karay to make music... that was definitely not in raag and i doubt guru sahib rejected the keertan...

Re: Rehit and Raag

Singhani · 21 Jun 2005

you dont have to use instruments in order to sing in raag hari singh. Using a Kara to keep the beat you can sing almost any ring as long as you have the sur. Its sad how our guru's started of the maryada of singing bani in raags, which is the way its expressed best, and how people try to justify singing them in whatever tune or composition.

Re: Rehit and Raag

Hari Singh · 21 Jun 2005

Oh, don't get me wrong... I love raag keertan and I don't think its possible to express just what I feel when I hear stringed instruments... However, in my lowly opinion, to say that keertan can ONLY be done in raag's is wrong ... because music is a tool and to me personally some of bhai jeeven Singhs' dhuns are much sweeter then any raag's that I've heard.

Re: Rehit and Raag

Singh! · 21 Jun 2005

If Sarblohias believe they are followed full rehit, they are not! Raag Vidya is also part of Rehit and so is Shastar Vidya.

Re: Rehit and Raag

akjgreat · 22 Jun 2005

gurbani in siri guru granth sahib which has been assigned a raag SHOULD be sung in that raag. guru ji hasnt assigned raags for shabads for no reason, there is a TRUTH in the sound of each RAAG which fits the shabad. bhai sahib heard kirtan from 'above' tunes he used were in raag, kare were used just as beat - kare cant be used to make a tune.

Re: Rehit and Raag

sninshg · 22 Jun 2005

veerji dont make up lies to prove your point, bhai sahib did not do kirtam from tunes he heard from above, which then made it in raag. famous tunes of bhai sahib such as har simari din subh raen and mohi gaya bairagi jogi are NOT in raag. if your going to make a point at least dont lie about it!

Re: Rehit and Raag

Anon · 22 Jun 2005

Actually it is a well known fact that on one occasion professional Raagis came to listen to Bhai Sahib and were shocked to see he was performing a very difficult Raag. Bhai Sahib said the tune just "came" to him. Whether this was the case with all his Keertan or only some of it, I cannot say, but certainly what "akjgreat" has said is correct. You do not have to accuse people of "lying" so quickly before you yourself are aware of the facts.

Re: Rehit and Raag

... · 22 Jun 2005

The point whether Bhai Sahib did keertan in Raag is not the point of this thread. The issue is ... is someone not following full Khalsa Rehit if they do not do kirtan in Raag? Are they a pooran Gursikh if they do not do kirtan in Raag, as is prescribed by the Bani of Guru Maharaj? Still waiting for Kulbir Singh's response. :)

Re: Rehit and Raag

Kulbir Singh · 22 Jun 2005

------------- Does pooran rehit include doing pure Gurbani kirtan as sung in Raag? Is raag maryada/rehit not as important as Sarbloh Bibek Rehit? Isn't it an even better place where pure Gurbani kirtan is done in Raag? Is one not keeping pooran rehit if he does not sing kirtan in Raag? Is someone who does ordinary kirtan a lesser Gurmukh than someone who does kirtan in Raag? Does it undermine pooran Khalsa rehit not to do kirtan in Raag? Will Guru Sahib except one's Naam Kamaayee if they do not do kirtan in Raag? I think you get my drift. Answers appreciated, especially from Kulbir Singh. --------------- Very good questions but I don’t claim to have answers to all of these questions. I can only write I think is right. In my humble opinion, a shabad written in a certain Raag means that originally when Guru Sahib wrote this shabad, he sang it in that Raag. It does not mean that subsequently no one can sing that shabad in any other Raag. Secondly, simple tunes does not mean that these tune or reets are not in Raags. Just because Pakkay Raag i.e. Saa Re Gaa Maa is not done does not mean that the tune is not Raag. Take the example of Siri Asa kee Vaar. This Vaar is in Raag Asa but at the same time Guru Sahib has instructions to sing it in “Tunday Asraajay kee Dhuni”. This dhuni of Asraaja is like a dhaadi tune and definitely not your typical aaa ooo eee (sorry I did not know how else to put it. I mean no disregard) tune. I even have doubts on whether this dhuni would fall under Raag Asa. If it does not fall under Raag Asa then my point in the previous paragraph makes sense. Originally when Siri Asa kee Vaar was written by Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee he must have sung it in Raag Asa but by the time of Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee it was probably being sung in “Asraajay kee dhuni”. What does this prove? It clearly proves that you don’t have to sing in Pakkay Raag. Also remember, every tune in the world is some Raag or the other. Tell me what tune would not fit in any Raag? There are hundreds of Raags and all tunes fit in one Raag or the other. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Rehit and Raag

Gurus Son · 22 Jun 2005

wjkk WJkf I dought raag is as important and if one does not do it raag is not respecting bani, I recorn keertan could be done in any tune even if u make it up, wat counts is the PIYAR! with out this, u can do keertan in raag all u want but u will not get anytin out of it! Its good to learn the raag as our gurus use 2 do it raag! but if u aint gt da chance then its no biggie dont stop doin keertan only cuz u cant do it in raag! That is not a sin! Wjkk WJkf

Re: Rehit and Raag

Dandilion · 22 Jun 2005

I think this is a bit of a none issue. The reason is that if you are a kirtania who does regular kirtan of course you should learn raag- vidhia and perform kirtan in the correct raags that it was composed in, there is no question here. But say you are an amritdhari and you are inspired to sing a shabad and you press three notes to create a chord on the harmonium and you make a simple tune and sing the shabad, then surely you cannot condemn this person by saying he is now out-of-rehat and should be flogged. He has done a shabad, maybe in the privacy of his home due to his piyare of his Guru in a simple tune should he now be accused of sin? [%sig%]

Re: Rehit and Raag

Singhani · 22 Jun 2005

>>Also remember, every tune in the world is some Raag or the other. Tell me what tune would not fit in any Raag? There are hundreds of Raags and all tunes fit in one Raag or the other.<< You cant make a random mixed composition 'fit' into a raag. A raag has a special set of notes which are used in a particular way which defines its unique personality. We might as well sing bollywood hit tunes too, as they 'fit' into some raag or the other.

Re: Rehit and Raag

akjgreat · 22 Jun 2005

well said singhani, a raag is a particular sequences of notes a tune must fit. there are 31 raags in siri guru granth sahib ji. a specific raag can be found at the beginning of each shabad, the shabad should be sung with a tune which fits the raag assigned. nowadays people are lazy, they dont want to learn raags, thats why few people at rensvais sing in raag, although they should. people get confused, tunes which fit raags dont have to be complicated, kirtan can still be sung in traditional AKJ style of simple kirtan using simple tunes which fit the raag. plea to sadh sangh of akhand kirtani jatha - please start doing kirtan in raag.