Re: Second Golden Temple in the making
Amandeep Madra · 21 Jun 2005
This is being carried out by the same Birmingham based jatha that bodged the "gold" seva at the Darbar sahib. Given their attitude towards fixing the problems there I doubt that this effrot will be any less controversial or damaging to the original structure.
1000kgs of gold woudl buy a great deal of very necessary restoration and conservation on the crumbling sikh material heritaeg around india and pakistan - its a shame that these people cant think beyond almost literally "guilding the lilly"
aman
Re: Second Golden Temple in the making
Heera Singh · 21 Jun 2005
... whats the point??... all that money can be used for USEFUL things... such as making hospitals, schools etc... in towns n cities.... why not put the money to good use??
Re: Second Golden Temple in the making
Gurcharan SINGH Kulim · 21 Jun 2005
This is the most insensible and ignomiusly stupid idea.Building these Gurduaras and beautifying themn with Gold is nothing more than an open declaration of Sikh bankruptcy spiritually.
They do not seem to be concernd about the thousands of Sikhs converting to other religions or the needs of the growing future generations, but bent on spending on Gurduaras.
This must be stopped.The money used for real useful projects that will increase the meaning of Sikhi and its numbers.
That is why I have written elswhere ...the Sikhs are totally confused and LOST kaum.
Re: Second Golden Temple in the making
Amandeep Madra · 22 Jun 2005
There was an outcry by experts in Punjab. Peopl who are word experts in concservation and achritectural historians. People like Patwant Singh tried extremely hard to get the GNNSJ to see that while the seva was welcome it shoudl be doen properly. Peter Poppham an incredibly well respected journalist from the Independant wrote a 1/2 page articel in 1999 titled "Brummies bodge Sikhs’ holy shrine" Peter Popham, 25 September 1999, The Independent. The BBC even carried an investigative piece on the contgroversy titled Gold Service with Dalji Dhaliwal.
Its the GNNSJ that is being pig-headed in not accepting that it is totally unnacceptable to remove the original plates whcih were crafted by Ranjit Singh's expert craftsmen and replace them with shoddy copies and it is not acceptable to plaster over centuries old wall paintings and it is not acceptable to leave the Darbar sahib with a really serious case of rising damp and it is not acceptable to put a 21st century rubber membrane on the roof of the builfding (not letting itr breathe and become increasingly damp) like it was some kind of dodgy indian extension in handsworth.
aman
Re: Second Golden Temple in the making
.............. · 22 Jun 2005
no one can build a harmandar sahib as Guru Ram das ji did......
Re: Second Golden Temple in the making
JSGyani "Arshi" · 25 Jun 2005
OUR Selayang Gurdwara roof is leaking.... we badly need a BABA JI to come here and Cover it all up with GOLD.... any takers ?? Our gurdwara will be first in malaysia to be Golden Gurdwara ???