Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Straight Arrow · 16 Jun 2005

SSA and Namastey to all - Can anyone explain to me the difference between Mazhabi Sikhs and jat Sikhs. Thanks! As many as 56 expelled employees of the S.G.P.C. today abandoned Sikhism and gave up articles symbolic of the faith in protest against their not being reinstated in the committee jobs. The drama was enacted at Goindwal Sahib, also referred to as 'Sikhi da Dhura.' Those who rejected Sikhism had all remained baptised for over 20 years. Not only did they abandon the religion, they also announced that due to the indifferent attitude of the S.G.P.C. they, along with families, had decided to join Christianity. 'From now on, we are Christians,' they announced in chorus. The development comes soon after the S.G.P.C.'s announcement of spending crores on 'dharam parchar' in its budget. Earlier, 30 Sikhs from the same area had turned to Christianity. Those who rebelled today were all employed in Gurdwara Bawli Sahib, Goindwal, since 1985 and were expelled by the S.G.P.C. in 2003. Led by former granthi of Gudwara Bawli Sahib, Ranjit Singh, the 56 Sikhs today abandoned their kirpan, kara and other articles signifying the faith and placed these in front of pictures of the 10 Gurus. They said they were leaving the Sikh community due to the unhealthy approach of the S.G.P.C. that still believed in classes in the religion, like Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs. 'As we are Mazhabis, we are discriminated against and that is also why we were expelled,' alleged Ranjit Singh and another rebel Kashmir Singh. They said though the conversion from Sikhism to Christianity was like suicide, the S.G.P.C. had forced them to commit the act by not hearing their appeal for reinstatement. One Balwinder Kaur announced in front of mediapersons that they would replace the suffixes 'Singh' and 'Kaur' with 'Masih.' She said: 'Our families will now look for marriages among the Christian community and conduct the ceremonies according to their traditions.' 'We will meet Christian religious authorities to formally join the faith. We will also build a church at Goindwal Sahib,' she said, accusing the S.G.P.C. of discrimination against Mazhabi Sikhs. [S.G.P.C. President] Bibi Jagir Kaur condemned the incident and termed it as a blackmail attempt. She said, 'They were never Sikhs, as Sikhism preaches sacrifice and honesty.' 'Probably they had joined Sikhism only for jobs. When expelled, they shifted to Christianity for the same purpose.' The incident would not affect Sikhism or the 'dharam parchar' movement, she added.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Khalsa Ek · 16 Jun 2005

Bhai Sahib There is no difference. Guru Gobind Singh Ji created all Khalsa as one. No jaat or paat. These people may have become Sikhs to get jobs w/ SGPC just like many low caste Hindus become Christians to benefit from Christian Charities. Don't fool yourself. These people have no love for the Bible or Christ they only "converted" to benefit from your free hospitals, convent education, jobs etc.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

--- · 16 Jun 2005

it was all a game www.panthic.org/news/125/ARTICLE/1263/2005-04-24.html

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

JARNAIL SINGH GYANI "ARSHI" · 16 Jun 2005

jat "sikhs", mazhbi "sikhs", christian "sikhs"...these people are NEITHER jat, nor mazhbi nor christian..NOR SIKHS...just ordinary "OPPORTUNISTS".

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

kalishnikov · 16 Jun 2005

this article is old news and turned out to be a pumped up event. Perhaps they were opportunists Guru Mahraj knows their intentions. The fact is we do have a caste system that is working more in punjab which sikhs seem to identity themselves with. This caste system places sikhs into categories socially, religiously into seperate gurdwaras, and very much passed onto the next generation. I do not know much about majbis except that they had a regiment in the british army. From my understanding all this caste nonsense comes down to social statuses. One family has it another does not. Rather than the status of the khalsa fraternity and its glorious standards that does not seem to be enough for most. We might like to think we have better values than gorey kaley peele. On a rehti level of singhs there is no jaat paat but generally speaking i think sikhs are far more backward than most cultures in terms of caste outlook and how they view each other. Looking at matrimonial advertisements, muslims will say " seeking practicing sunni muslim" or gujratis " seeking gujrati female or male". When it comes to sikhs whether in india or outside the caste bit is so stuck to us im like where does that come from? how we are bought up? how different are we from each other? its almost like saying there are different types of sikhs. But i must have missed this when i was a kid, and it is a shock as though the religion and community i believed in as a kid somehow turned out to be different when i grew up. This caste system has grown more bolder in the youth with bhangra songs in the last 10 years. Prior to that we had different struggles before us which kept us very knit together. in the 80s the muslims forcibly taking sikh women in midlands lead to shere punjab movement which got to big when it was guided by proper singhs wth sikhs from all castes. The unity there made sikhs fight back, and bring back some spirit and no one cared about castes. When everyone became split into their castes over the past years there has never been a shere punjab on the scale of the 80s ever again. There has never been that spirit or comeback for that reason. What we have now are very very few sikhs out ther. Then came the holy smokes who again started to protect the sikhs of southall from being attacked by gorey. Then the two main players a chacha and paanja had a tiff about the paanja cussing other castes down, the thaiya formed his own offshoot toot e nangs which was dominated by tarkans and few chamars while smokes were jatts. What started as a brilliant movement sticking up for sikhs, became fractuired into caste and eventually died out after becoming criminalised on both sides with gang rivalry. Now the youth of southall are nowehere near the position of what the original holy smokes had, a clear agenda and unity. When both movements were around everyone became scared of sikhs. The sp never saw these differences between each other. Then comes along these jazzy b type singers and new breed of singers from india singing caste songs,no longer do we have sikh movements born but caste movements , caste websites, caste heritage societies, drug gangs in southall and vancouver pumping our own up with heroin and cocaine punjabi pimps turning our women into prostitutes to feed their coke habits. the only ones saved now are the ones who have taken amrit who at least have some knowledge of what their Guru Ji wanted. But the only times sikhs ever kicked axx was when they come together. As people get more materliatic about their bodies the more they believe in caste, but their in for a shock as they live in a 9 to five multicultural society if their kid skanks them and leaves. It is a weird ol contradiction at the moment but the new surrounding will definatly demand changes around the world as different groups of people are thrown together. [%sig%]

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Truth_Sikher · 17 Jun 2005

Jatt = Ethnic group from the Scythian race. Sikh = Religion Mazbhi = Ethnic group from native Dalits. ***admin cut***

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Digusted · 17 Jun 2005

We are only Sikh. The trouble makers create the Jats or Mazahbis.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

A Singh · 17 Jun 2005

Opportunitists maybe, but highlights a significant issue...when others choose to become partisan, then it's very easy to label them as such, however if such people ever become economically more prosperous, like some of the Ravidasias and Ramgarhias, then they are blamed for being caste based and partisan...the cause of all such arguments tends to be the same...

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Bhudysut · 17 Jun 2005

Guru Khalsa Jeo, All threads like these and similar are contrary to those who wish to live the GurSikhi Jeevan. Ignore them and treat them as they should be treated; little children's banter. Bhul Chuk Marf Akaal Sahai Singh

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Truth_Sikher · 17 Jun 2005

Jatt = Ethnic group from Scythian race. Sikh = Religion.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

tikkha barsha · 17 Jun 2005

"Recognise ye human RACE as one" Guru Gobind Singh Mahraj " Ye shall love man as man making no distinction of CASTE or CREED. Ye shall keep forever this flame of life lit in you, unflickering in deep meditation on the One Deathless Being." " Do they despise you?are you LOW CASTE? i will enrobe you in a saffron garment of joy , and i will dissolve that fire of heaven in your blood before which the sun and moon melt in submission. You are the chosen , the divine khalsa (the kings own). Cobblers, tanners, weavers, wahsermen, brewers, heavy laden labourers, farmers, come take this divine light from my hands. It is for you and you alone. It is the ancient light of the knowledge of God hold it is your soul. Meditate on this supreme flame and live in its day glean for this is love. All else is illusion and death. As long as it burns unflickering in you you are the kings rightesnous the khalsa." a manuscript written by Ahmed Shah Batalia in 1818 A.D and partly pblished by Sohal Lal Suri in his history book as an appendix to the first volume mentions the incident of the creation of the khalsa It reads inter alia "I ( Guru Gobind Singh) wish you all to embrace one creed , follow one path, riising above all differences of the religion as now practiced. Let the 4 hindu castes who have different dharms laid down for them in the shastras containing institutes of varnashram dharm abondon them altogether". "Let men of 4 castes recievbe my baptism of the double edged sword eat out of the same bowl, and feel no aloofness from or contempt from one another". Jd Cunningham " Gobind (Guru Gobind Singh) had thus abolished social distinctions by mising all hindu castes and muslim social classes) and had taken away from his followers the useless rituals". C.H Payne " the members of the khalsa were required to carry arms to keep 5 ksto salute waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh to surname themselves as Singhs (ie lions)." Sharam Nash - It gave the khalsa new hope and emancipation from All old proffesional labels like that of priests, teachers, bussinessmen, soldiers, weavers, tailors, barbers and sweepers, etc equal status. C.H Paynes A short History of the Sikhs pp32,35 Sohan lal suri Umadat Tuarikh page 5 also see Bute Shah Tuarikhe Punjab pp405 406 translation Kapoor Singh Parasharprasna pp4-5 Balbir Singh "The Tenth Master" p 42

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

sikh unity · 17 Jun 2005

caste/race = reinvented jargon often relating to economic success and boasting of physical qualities. sikhism = truth, spirituality, liberation from bondage towards our final desination and humbling ourselves before the sangat. One who believes in race and caste distinctions has placed a barrier before themselves and spirituality. They will progress no further than the physical realm unless they relate to the spiritual nature which has no caste or race.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Bhudysut · 17 Jun 2005

Jatt = Ethnic group from Scythian race. Sikh = Rejects above

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Straight Arrow · 17 Jun 2005

Thanks to everyone.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

UK Sikh · 17 Jun 2005

Funny how Sikhs use the common phrase White Sikhs or Chinese Sikhs or Black Sikhs, but when I appropriately refer to myself as Jatt Sikh you have a problem with it. Where does it say because I recognise my ethnic background that I discriminate against other Sikhs or for that matter another human being??? Guru Ji rightly abolished the Hindu caste system as it was an inhumane social order, some members were treated worse than animals and this is what Guru Ji was against. All the Gurus married into Khatri families, if Guru Ji wanted to create some racial mixed society they would of appropriately set an example by marrying out of their "caste" (please note that in no way am I associating caste to Guru Ji - I think everybody understands what I am trying to say). So I am going to follow Guru Ji's example and marry a Jatt. I also think cultural differences exist between different groups. I am VERY strictly against "caste" based Gurdwara and all other such divisions, I have a feeling that the next couple of years are testing times for the whole Sikh panth and we must stand united. I hope some of you understand where I am coming from.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

universal khanda · 18 Jun 2005

JoSikhaKoPucheJaatSohSikhNahiMeroAadJugaad Those who ask a sikh's caste, they are not my sikh, they never were, and they never will be --Sache Patsha Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee In Search of the True Guru (Khalsa Raj chapter) page 373 Visions of khalsa raj Bhai Rama Singh ji "I was amazed to see such a beautiful gurdwara. It was built of stone more beautiful than marble. I went inside and performed mata tekan. The palaki was decorated with many coloured glass. the overhead chanani cloth was decorated with star shapes, rubies and pearls. Two anand karaj ceremonies were taking place in the gurdwara. The only difference was that one panjabi singh was being married to a white singhani while a white singh was being married to a panjabi singhani. there was a lot of sangat here from the two villages of the brides and grooms to bless the marriages. They all seemed to have great regard for each other .... I asked khalsa ji what is the meaning of these mixed marriages? khalsa ji said "in order to eradicate any colour disctinctions such marriages are taking place. Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji is all kniowing. Guru Ji is creating such a khalsa who remain staunch in their belief. " Akal Ustat 15.85 Hindu turk kou Rafji Imam safi maanas ki jaat sabhai ekai pahchanbo. Some r hindus some r muslims some are rafjis Imams and safis but all belong to the one race of humanity. (note no1 is saying marry a safi rafji or hindu but this line shows that Guru Gobind Singh Ji saw humans as one race and not into gorey kaley or jatts.) Akal Ustat 16.86 maanas sabhai ek pai anek ko bhramaau hai. all men are basically the same though they appear different through our mistake. Ekai nain ekai kaan ekai deh akai baan khaak baad aatas au aab ko ralaau hai. All men have the same eyes ears body and figure made out of the compounds of earth air fire and water. Jaap Sri Mukhvakh Patshahi Dasvin Chapai Chand Tav Prasad Chakr chihan ar baran jaat ar paat nahin jih. Roop Rang ar rekjh bhekh kou kah na sakat keh. God hath no mark feature sect caste or sub caste. No one can say about his appearance colour figure and dress. (first two lines of daily jaap sahib ji from nitnem panj bania) Blessings of Holy Glimpses of Christ Mohammed Sahib and Brigh Rishi sant Harnam Singh Ji Rampur Khera page 253 Hazrat Mohammed uttered "you are blessed and lucky person to whom the great Guru Nanak Devji has shown the direct, easy and the best method to attain God in kal yug. But the followers of Great Guru Nanak Dev Ji are not deriving the full benefit out of it. " Sikh Reht Maryada - Published by Dharm Parchar Committee Amritsar page 26 reads "Anand Sanskar a) A sikh man and woman should enter wedlock without giving thought to the prospectives spouse's caste and descent." http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=5826 pairee(n) pai paakhaak hue gurasikhaa(n) vich vaddee samaaee Falling at and becoming the dust of the feet is the great trance for the Sikhs of the Guru (their caste should not be considered). http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=5565guramukh varan avaran hoe niv chalai gurasikh visaekhai|| The special feature of the Sikh of the Guru is that he goes beyond the framework of caste-classification and moves in humility.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

former jattnowcastelessikh · 18 Jun 2005

so i take it it is ok to refer to each other as jatt sikh, chamar sikh nai sikh dirkan sikh saini sikh kamboh sikh cheer sikh, labana sikh, tankshatriya sikh, khattri sikh, choora sikh, ghamar sikh, brahmin sikh ( funny as it sounds take a trip down jammu) and a dozen other groups. i used to think hindus made us believe in the caste system but now im starting to realise its kind of there in us.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

an opinion · 18 Jun 2005

UK Sikh - feel free to marry whomever you like; HOWEVER the justification you offer sounds hollow. Chamar, Jatt, Saini, Lubhana etc are not isolated ethnic identifiers but strongly, and intrinsically associated with caste divisions. Your Gurus have specifically identified and abolished caste - there is no reasonable justification you can offer for adopting caste identification other than manmat. Your term "ethnic identity" is the same as "caste". As for what the Gurus did - are you a Guru or are you a Sikh? If you're at the same level as the Gurus, then please feel free to do whatever you like. If you are a Guru's Sikh, THEN DO WHAT THEY TELL YOU TO DO! One is either a Jatt/Chamar/Saini/etc or a Sikh - one cannot be both. regards. ps. Re your first sentence, consider the following parallel: Funny how Sikhs drink alcohol and then when I drink alcohol, they have a problem with it. Two wrongs do not make a right.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

;;;;;;;;;;;;;;; · 19 Jun 2005

sikhi will never die out and youngbloods will keep coming from 4 corners. But we also cannot deny the overall trend en mass is sikhi is not as popular with nojwaan as it was some years ago. The gradual slowdown does not die off at once. many years ago when our grandfathers came to these foreign lands, anothr apna would come from sona des panjab they would take him in and feed and cloth him until he was on his feet and became like them in a position to be there for another. What caste is today it was not in the 1950s and 60 70s when singhs had to stand shoulder with shoulder. there was no jatt da ghar or mazbi da ghar, apney lokh lived in the same houses, this was the peak of live and love for each other which dissapeared when we had enough money to buy cosy mansions and fast cars and idolising looks. How i can confirm this is my own family, we used to rent the lower half of our house to a mazbhi family in those days. Jatts mazbhis and others wold frequent each others places jappiya bhraa pohndey ne, no one even mentioned caste then. we would have mazbhi guests in our house while we gave them beds we slept on the floor to mark our respect for paroney. This is how it used to be because most of us had some form of sikhi inside our houses. yes it is still thereon smaller scale now but mostly in asali rehetvan sikhs. i do not see the asali form of punjabiat or sikhi anymore much. What i see is pure materialism, filth, lust for power, the urge to put each other down, and all of a sudden we are now jatt trkan saini kombo rajput. We can thank goi, sarkari sponsored singers with increased propaganda on divide and rule caste songs. All these good ol days of 84 unity, sp days, hs smokes/ tuuts, were the times when we had some sikhi instilled into our veins in one form or another. There was enthusiasm amongst sikhs to meet another sikh, to talk in punjabi, a strong sense of identity. These were days when one singh would jump in front of the other in a struggle. the days where sp hs only saw you for being a sikh that was more than enough, no mona sardar jatt dirkan dvides just pride respect and a lot of lion like unity that created this mass energy and aura to kick the whole scene. Now even if we had struggles before us right now the lapse out of sikhi has already fractured one side of our youth. caste and race division has greater a knock on effect on the sikh youth already distant from sikh ideals. In a struggle that requires ekta that ekta does not exist we we no longer see each other as sikhs but as jatts and terkans. We are no longer motivated by Wahegurus awsome shakti dasam Patshahs divine blessings instead our new IDOL GOD is money and power. The urge for material things and human divisions cannot unite sikhs. A lot of sikhs are disheartened bunch blaming gurdwara committees (rightly). But if the same sikhs had their own unity across the scale community, they would sriously kick it in every field you can think of. here and now we call each other jatt chammar terkan, there is no sikh element to it, there is no love for each other, therefore no goal no strentgh noi unity no focus. If you can tacjkle the problems of sikh community with jaat paat i welcome you to try and test your method. You will fail, the chance is there but you cannot succeed. All struggles of sikhi are based on sikh principles. Until we follow Dasam Gurus hukam we are all stuck. I feel sorry for all these young veers on caste vibe who never saw or felt the ekta sikhs had back then, that strentgh was mad, you could feel that same love from your own house and walking into the next. meeting one singh the same as meeting your own dad or brother like you part of a big family. Until we are a family without caste we are gonna be ruled by hindu sarkars. Just look at muslims unity, it does not just exist between muslims. I have good pakistani friends who give you such a unity they cover your back till the end and stand by you in the thick of it. If i did not experience the sikhi or panjabiat i had in my childhood i would most likely have thought it was islam was the reason and more potent force. that kind of unity could benefit sikhi in a lot of ways instead of the usual "ooooo im a this caste". Look inside your heart if your half the man you are go and sort out our problems with your jaat paat if you can. Otherwise understand your patt satt method is not working in this world you need to come to the arms of Guru sahib and embrace your brothers in the sikh dharm and get yourself ready for what is next. build a yard, that yard needs its foundations dug, neeha pardaoh, then make the wall from scratch lower start of bricks first. If your already dreaming about the fancy roof finishings without all the hard labour between you arent gonna get jack in this world or the next. [%sig%]

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Bhopinder Singh · 19 Jun 2005

Straight Arrow namastay what is brahmin khatri vaish and shudra is it by birth and who ma c invented it

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

gg · 19 Jun 2005

castists do a lot of damage. They call you wannabees and try to make you distant from themselves and religion. because they identify with caste and not with religion, they want you to be like that. Then nobody can ever come together because the essence of religion gets lost in being a kamboja jatt a taerkan. Then when we start to only believe we are part of a caste , our castes are overide any sense of religious belonging. So in a way these castists do much more damage than any gov can to sikhs. It is quiet interesting to note how muslim and hindu chroniclers did not mention the castes of sikhs yet the british in their classic divide and rule stratagy have while being more foreign than the moghuls or hindus. Its also interesting to see how the past missals, dals, khalsa forces were organised on sikh theology did not have any caste labels except for ramgharia and and aluwalia who were known to have been mixed caste groups anyway yet under the british we suddenly see an appearance of seperate regiments for castes and a new tailor made history of sikh castes. The british were obsessed with race and have ruling bloodlines. they used their appearance to try to make any foreigners they were in contact with as inferior native species. Another interesting point is to analyse the all encompassing powerful sikh character before the british raj and after eventually to its reduced current condition. On coming in contact with sikhs they were clearly jelous of large bodied, muscular, handsome fine cut, dashing, soldiers the sikhs with beautiful sikh females, large bounties, cheerful spirits. Now how would a ruling bloodline accept the supremacy of those they are supposed to rule as inferior? divide and rule is the answer. Unity against their rule would be intimidating and threat to the rule of the british hence the introduction of caste which in turn means splits, it is unfortunate we let them run punjab and not checking the real damage they have done was a a deadly onslaught against the sikh religion itself. If any of those past praatan singhs or singhanis created any caste affiliated organisation i take back what i say. It is amply clear those sikhs were totally naam imbued and their motivations and life forces generated around unversal khalsa behaviour which is totally unlike any caste or race pride. When the british came we suddenly see a tight administration control never seen in the history of asia before that eventually made this country called india. Now you could not just have thousands of mr "singhs " in controlling the masses they introduced a system where your pind names and ghots were required for admin purposes. The real soddin fact is we are all children inside a matrix of the same species interconnected from God. Some of us in our great pride refuse the connection while others accept. Thats what these energy fields are about when everyone unites, its a part of your soul recognising back to its original form merging in spirit with others sent from God turning into a gigantic force to deal with. thats why they say in punjabi 1 and 1 is not 2 but has the power of 11. but it looks like some of our veers dont like this strentgh of unity instead prefer their ego "mahee mayh ah" no one else like me. From all the writings of the Gurus it appears they wanted that one united force where everyone becomes one. We try to refuse our gurus teachings in our own way. Guru sahib has blessed us with this life to give us a chance to live like sikhs and build the khalsa kingdom made on khalsa values. If we try to refuse some bits and take what we suit then i dont think our Guru will be very happy with us. Hence the results fall vi pauna paina in this very life we the result of this great pride of caste madness we have often pays us back in some way or another. You reap what you sow. Sikhs believe in migration of the soul. Caste system hence means only in this life you will see whatever you seee as a tirkaan jatt kamboja if you believe in caste. Your next life you could be anything? Yet most castists refer to their ancestors (hence ancestor tomb worship) their motives are guided by " live for this life only" how does this affect their own sikhi? and that on collective scale if we all thought of that? so where our outlook changes from community to self only rather than balance whats left?

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

sikh lions · 20 Jun 2005

even if the world most evil people invented the caste system what about those who follow it are they any better than the ones who made it? in fact they are worse for they agree that humans are not equal and agree to abide by it directly opprssing guru mahraj jis sacred dharm after being blessed with having the great good karam of being born into sikh homes with the ability to spread the sikh faith in its original form.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Straight Arrow · 20 Jun 2005

Bhpinder Singh Ji, I am not an expert on this but I will share with you whatever little knowledge I have. There are 5 primary castes: 1. Brahmins - The priests and highly educated people 2. Kshatriyas (or Khatris) - The warriors and the rulers (also some farmers) 3. Vaishyas - Businesspoeple and merchants (also some farmers) 4. Sudras - Labourers 5. Dalits (Or Harijans) - The people who performed the most menial tasks I'm not sure where this foolish system began but yes, to your question, one has to be born into a Vaishya community, for example, to be a vaishya. In the cities, the caste system is slowly being relegated to the background with the advent of inter-caste marriage (and also inter-religious) but in the countryside, it is still very much prevalent. Highly unfortunate, but true. This is my limited understanding of this topic. In case someone more knowledgable on this topic would like to share any pointers, please do so. Thank you.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Bhopinder Singh · 20 Jun 2005

but who invented it?

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Bhopinder Singh · 20 Jun 2005

Straight Arrow ji what is achoot ( untouchable) and who invented this theory? please the last part who invented is very important.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Straight Arrow · 20 Jun 2005

Bhopinder Paaji - I have to plead my ignorance here and apologize to you. I have no idea who invented this system. I tried to do some research on the net but could not get an answer. Sorry. Also, just one correction on a point you made earlier. I said there were 700 million Hindus and you said that Dalits do not consider themselves to be Hindus. I did some research on the net and found the numbers on a credible site (www.nationalgeographic.com) according to which the number of Dalits are 160 million and all other castes (Kshatriya, Vaishya, Sudra and Brahmin) are 64% of India's population (640 million) plus there are about 5 million NRIs ( Almost 2 million in the US alone) so I think 600 million is a good conservative number.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Bhopinder Singh · 20 Jun 2005

Dalits 160 get your facts . They are the reason for reservation or quotas if it is true why no quota for the upper cast Hindus as they have more votes.Something is wrong in your stats. How many moslems? dont plead ignorance Hinduism is the founder of cast systems yor Vaids have done the wonderful and unprecidented work in human history or is there any other faith with such a wonderful work.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Straight Arrow · 20 Jun 2005

Bhopinder Singh - I did tell you where I got my numbers from (www.nationalgeographic.com). Read my posts carefully. I don't think an organization of the strature of NG would post incorrect stats. Muslims are about 15% of the total population. Don't believe NG, do your own research and let me know the numbers and their source. Yes, I agree, the caste system was invented by whoever started Hinduism several thousand years ago. Your question said "Who invented the caste system?" I thought you meant the name of the person which is why I said I did not know but which faith does not have divisions. Muslims have Shia/Sunni conflict, Christians have Catholic/Protestant conflict which in no way justifies the Caste system but since you rather sarcastically mentioned, "is there any other faith with such a wonderful work.", well, all the other faiths have conflicts. Forget that, even two brothers living under the same roof have conflicts at times.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

man it is sad · 20 Jun 2005

hindus might have founded the caste system but it appears sikhs or so called sikhs follow it with even more vigour than their hindu counterparts in the most advanced places on earth right now ie uk canada and america. I will narrate a story of 2 girls. One is attractive walkes down the street, 6 guys ask them both to stop. They start chatting up the atttractive one after a while they ask her number which she gives, then they ask her surname. Upon that they ask her what caste she is, she tells them chmar. They tell her that she is not a sikh, that her kind are used as shoe cleaners in india,they proceed to spit on her shoes, they said a lot more to make her feel bad. Whether this person was tendi kala chardi kala does not matter what does is the way people get treated out there. one of my very own friends a chmar guy loaded, smart looking, driving nice cars would often meet our other friends. Now these other friends were cosher with me and loved me. But with him they would pick up excuses " we are gonna take your alloys away" if this munda tried to defend himself they would straight away start digging into his caste and bully him while the others cheered him on or stood by like "thats our boys". Obviously i was a manmukh them days but to instil respect into him i used to symbolically hug him as a brother, and touch his grandparents feet when i visited their house when i was 16. another guy instead of having nitnem, he praised caste everyday day saying he is a son of so and so. This ego was bolstered more by putting others down. the funniest one was cussing down nais and cheers. then his sister run away with one. The bander still did not learn. But can you imagine how people walk away scarred with that by fellow sikhs? ok they are not sikhs in your eyes the very fact is they are born in sikh houses, in the sikh religion and allow this inhumane system to carry on unguided. this hatred for lower caste people is taken to a level thats inhumane. But most sikhs turn a blind eye. the very same sikhs who either turn a blind eye or use this caste system to bolster their egos get their chitter whacked later by fate, their sister runs off with a tohnda or they suddenly dealing with a heap of things in life they never expected. now i frankly could not care if a rss brahmin , a bnp man, a muslim bin laden type made the caste system. I see apney bandey get treated rough shod for something they cannot help their born. It is apney people taking this caste to a higher level bullying people. [%sig%]

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Bhopinder Singh · 20 Jun 2005

so you agree who started jat pat as you can see straight arrow ji this very thing was the reason for t he downfall of your prithvi jiand a 1000 year of subjucation disgrace and cowardice were mere companions of the later. The very foundation is shaky and just like sand, it will never stand unless you change the foundation. also kashmiris want independence so does assam nagaland mizoram punjab and so on.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

man it is sad · 21 Jun 2005

but bhopinder singh whats that gotto do with sikhs following caste in america canada and uk?

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Caste Dil Illaaj Ki Hovai? · 21 Jun 2005

Pela chapter the madness of belief in castes has a very strong hold in Sikhs! In one hand the propagators of the Sikh Dharma mouth platitudes about a casteless society preached by the Masters, but on the other hand, they practice it madly. What a paradox and hypocrisy! Per Gurmat, any one who believes in Jaat-Paat cannot be a true Sikh; for the castes only relate to the body; not to the Self (Soul, Spirit or Truth). In other words, the caste-conscious person is a material being (Manmukh) who has confounded the Self for the physical body The Gurbani (Sri Guru Granth Sahib, SGGS) roars that the madness of false pride of caste results in two things: Sin and corruption. In spite of such strong warnings and consequences, majority of the Sikhs are inflicted with this grave disease of Jaat-Paat. Having said that, it should be of no surprise to see the prevalence of sin and corruption in the society All living entities are under the influence of the three modes of Maya's material nature (illusion, conditioned mind, ignorance, duality, etc.). It clings to everyone except the spiritual beings. It affects mortals many ways. And one of the ways Maya snares us into its illusion or hallucination is through our false pride of caste. Aachaar biyuhaar biaapat ih jaat: It (Maya) impinges upon us through our charactor, occupation, and caste (sggs 182). why so many living entities are engulfed by the razing fire of madness of false pride of caste? It is so because the mortals, due to ignorance, identify themselves with the material body instead of the real Self. A spiritually blind cannot understand this. Why? Because the casteless Infinite Consciousness that the Gurbani talks about is not the subject of unmeaning rituals, lip worship, garbs, ceremonies, mundane history, culture, outer looks, material logic, scholarship, and speculations. Only a Gurmukh or a True Sikh — a Self-realized person — knows it. Jaat ajaat ajonee sambhayu na tis bhayu na bharmaa: The caste of God is castelessness; He is unborn, self-illumined, without desire and doubt (sggs 597). Gurmukh jaat pat sach soi: God is the caste and honor of the Gurmukh (sggs 560). Ekam ekankaar niraalaa. Amar ajonee jaati na jaalaa: The Unique Lord is Peerless, Immortal, unborn, and without caste and involvement (sggs 838). Naari purukh nahee jaat na janamaa naa ko dukh sukh paaidaa: (Before the rise of material consciousness) neither there was female, nor male, nor caste, nor birth nor did any one suffer pain or pleasure (sggs 1035). Varan jaat chihan nahee koee sabh hukme sarist upaaidaa: God has no color, caste and mark; by His Will, He creates the whole world (sggs 1075). Jaanahu joti na pooshahu jaatee aagai jaat na he: Recognize God’s Light within all, and do not inquire or consider caste, as there is no caste in the world hereafter (sggs 349). Jaatee dai kiaa hath sach parkheeai. Mahuraa hovai hath mareeai chakheeai: What merits is in the caste? Truthfulness is measured within. Pride in one’s caste is like poison—he who taste it will die (sggs 142). Manmukh And Jaat-Paat According to the Gurbani, one who believes in Jaat-Paat is a Manmukh (egotistic or material being). He is Spiritually blind; hence, without Intuitive Wisdom. His life is perplexed due to ignorance of his True Nature, which is Pure Consciousness. In such a perplexed state of mind, a materialist thinks that this world is solid or permanent. However, the inside reality is to the contrary. The only thing that is permanent is the Spirit (Infinite Consciousness) that pervades within evrybody and everything. People in material perplexities are called in the Gurbani by different names. Such names include Manmukh, Saakat (faithless cynics), Kusang (bad company), Aatam Ghaatee (self-murderer), Chor (thief), Mayadhaaree (Maya-stricken), Bimukhan (nonbeliever), Jhooth or Koorh (false or fake), nondevotee, demon, beast, idiot, fool, animal, material-being, spiritually ignorant, etc. A Gurmukh is a Self-Realized person. By awakening Divine Grace within, he has killed his inner ego. He is a humble being, who is jealous of no one. Ever engaged in meditaion on the Divine (Japa or Name-Simran), he is completely immersed in the Infinite Consciousness, Waheguru. Hence, a Gurmukh is a casteless being. As the Infinite Consciousness or Waheguru is casteless, so is he. All his actions are selfless; for he is purified in and out. He sees the All-pure in all. Being spiritually wise, he knows the Essence of the Divinity as all there is; in everything, everywhere, and beyond measures. That's his casteless caste! This is the sign of a true Sikh. No other mundane qualification matters. Hari Bhagta kee jaat pat hai Ram: The caste and honor of the Lord's devotees is His Naam (sggs 768). Hamree jaat pat sach naayu: The Name is my caste and honor (sggs 353). Metee jaat hooye darbaar: Effacing my caste, I have become the Lord's courtier (sggs 875).

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

rangretta · 26 Jul 2006

the relationship between a jatt and a mazbhi is a love hate relationship Jatts can be good friends with a mazbhi or a jatt hates the mazbhi because of his or her low caste status but loves the mazbhi when the jatt needs help in a fight. The difference between jatts and mazbhis is very clear, a mazbhi is brave full of dauntless courage (like the two famous mazbhis Botha & Garjha singh) and loyalty. mazbhis make great soldiers as sikh history will tell. Baba deep singh ji fought on with his head severd. he was a mazbhi only a mazbhi could do that guru gobind singh's armies were mostly made up of mazbhis and other sc classes. Guru gobind singh trusted mazbhis more as they would never runaway like the 40 jatts lead by mann singh infact it took a mazbhi woman mai bhago to bring them back. The british preferd mazbhis in the army for obvious qualities, in which jatts have never had and will never have. The sikh Li is one of the best light infantry regiments in the world, even worthy of U.N duty, unlike the sikh regiment. THE MAZBHI HAS BEEN THE BACKBONE OF SIKHISM FOR MANY MANY YEARS. NO BODY FIGHTS LIKE THE MAZBHI PUTT MAZBHIA DE! PUTT MAZBHIA DE!!! This is advice for all the mazbhis out there NEVA TAKE CRAP OF A JATT BEAT THE **** OUT OF THE JATT. MESS WITH A MAZBHI AT YOUR OWN PERIL! AND ALLWAYS REMEMBER OUR WAR HEROS OF WORLD WAR 1 AND 2 . Jatt sikhs like to bask in the glory and accomplishments of mazbhi sikh soldiering. the jatts say to other ppl the soldiers were all sikh but never say mazbhi sikh and then they call us churas. PUTT MAZBHIA DE! I'LL SMASH UP ANY JATT THAT THINKS OTHER WISE!!

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

sunny. uk · 26 Jul 2006

they say this caste thing was started hundreds of years ago by the ayran race to set a distinction between them and those who they conqured. giving great power to the brahmins .khasatris.but over the years things have changed an this caste thing has been taken over by some jats.who think they are greater than ramgharias.khatris.aroras sikhs.and ravidass sikhs.when infact it is a figment of there imagination.ie.anyone can be a warrior.make lots of money.get a good education.live a nice lifestyle.be they jats. tharkhans.bappes.or chamars.i think that these pindus who came to countrys like england in the 50s an 60s and worked in factorys an foundrys.made money set up there own buisness.then had familys have got too big for there boots they forget were they come from what they was.poor people who was given a opurtunity to prosper in the west.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Singh · 26 Jul 2006

Guru Saab has made all of us equal. In General worldly term, Mazbi Sikhs are very hard working farm labourers of Jatts. Jatts appreciate their hard work and give them food shelter and money for their hard work. Mr Buta Singh who is a senior congress leader is one of the most successful mazbi sikh of modern time. Mazbi's are blessed by God with a beautiful voice also. Most of the top Ragis and Punjabi Singers are Mazbis.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Dalbir · 28 Jul 2006

Author: Bhopinder Singh Date: 06-20-05 09:22 but who invented it? ------------------------------ I heard Aryan invaders invented it to keep indigenous people in India under the heal. Mir Mannu apparently wrote a manual on how it should run so that their "pure" blood wouldn't dilute with others. What is weird about Mazhbi and Jatt relations is that in the past jatts used to take Mazhbi women as wives (ask your grandparents if you have Punjabi roots). The caste system is based on varnas, this word translated means colour. So it tried to keep the dark skinned away from the light. Needless to say, be it through the above situation, or rape or ashqi, the blood has mixed. That is why you get jatts who are really dark. This notion of pure blood is pathetic and untrue. Personally I think caste is the weakest chink in the Sikh armour, growing up in the west, it just seems so backwards. It is also a stick for outsiders to beat Sikhs with, too show how insincere we are. I have a few incidents in my life at work, with muslims and english people talking about Sikhs and caste as if to imply how hypocritical they are. I know a lot of people will not like this, but jatts are to blame for this quite a lot. But they are not the only people guilty, even tarkhans will look down on mazhbis. Caste is so stupid nowerdays that you will get jatts and tarkhans calling khatris, bhappay, as a pejorative (or insult), I wonder if the Gurus were here, would thay call them bhappay too? One big problem is that the majority Sikh (Punjabi) population have no serious desire to eliminate caste as they see it as a loss of status, in teh meanwhile they bring down the status of the panth.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Non-Sikh · 30 Jul 2006

<<>> This is a joke, right? The Sikh Regiment is the highest decorated regiments of the Indian Army, with 72 Battle Honours, 15 Theatre Honours and 5 COAS Unit Citations and 1596 other gallantry awards. <<>> Buddy, what's up with the lies? Baba Deep Singh Ji was a Jatt. He belong to the Sandhu Jatt clan. <<>> Mai Bhago was a Jatti as well. She was born in a Muslim Jatt family. Do you have to make up lies to feel good about yourself? How about you take pride of just being a Sikh instead of being a Mazhabi? Is that too hard to do?

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Non-Sikh · 30 Jul 2006

Jatt is NOT a caste. Even Sir Alexander Cunnigham and Col James Tod agreed in considering the Jatts to be of Indo-Scythian stock. Just read "History of Sikhs" by Alexander Cunningham if you guys don't believe me.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

viv · 30 Jul 2006

a very good post by dalbir and bhopinder singh which is the truth of the caste system among jat sikhs in the western country.and how they look down on ravidass and other sikhs.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Dalbir · 30 Jul 2006

Author: Non-Sikh Date: 07-30-06 01:04 Jatt is NOT a caste. Even Sir Alexander Cunnigham and Col James Tod agreed in considering the Jatts to be of Indo-Scythian stock. Just read "History of Sikhs" by Alexander Cunningham if you guys don't believe me. ------------------------------------- Jatt are you kidding me! There are so many THEORIES regarding scythian movements. Each historian adds his own two cents worth. Are these people so important to you that you want to ignore your own Guru's advice concerning caste in favour of them. What did these guys do for Sikhs compared to the Gurus who freed us and enabled Sikhs to fight overwhelming odds. Jats ARE a caste spread between Hndus, Sikhs and Musalmans. If they were a race why are so-called Sikh jats so different from their Hindu/muslim counterparts. And again why do you have so many jatts that are dark and short whilst others look totally diffeent. Sometimes a jatt and tarkhan can look more similar than two jatts or two tarkhans. Just face it, you are unable to break away from Hindu brahmanistic thinking and your just using your race argument as an excuse. If the cap fits, wear it.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Non-Sikh · 30 Jul 2006

LOL Jatts look down on everyone including Brahmins.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

viv · 31 Jul 2006

the jats look down on other races like the brahmins.khatris.because they have a inferioity complex/ the jats that have come over to countrys like england.canada.u.s.a etc.there the main ones with attitude you can tell that they have seen poverty.its like the attitude of the negros towards the white man.one other thing i have noticed with jats in western countrys is there facination with ie.fair skin .sharp features. light coloured eyes.trying to say there of ayran stock.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Dalbir · 31 Jul 2006

Many jatts fall over themselves to prove and convince that they are the decendents of white people. Does this stem from some sort of awe of these people? I read this book by a gora who was tracing the story of the KohiNoor. He went to Amritsar about the time the queen went there. He has a copy of the plaque given to the queen at that time. On it is was suggesting that all Sikhs are jatts??!?! And they were of common stock to the English??!?! Seems like plain old boot lickery to me....are you more proud of being jatt than Sikh? Do you really aspire to be like goray that much. It is a bit embarrasing.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

nikka · 31 Jul 2006

all thats happened is mainstream sikhs are doing away with religion and attaching onto caste and their so called traditions. this is perfectly described in dasam granth and this is the shortfall that belomngs to sikhs from all sections. What is meant to happen has to happen first and then followed by what must manifest to counter the darkness. Jatts tend to get noticed more because they are still the majority, but there may be bad apples just as there are many good. The good apples including mone can be a great support, well wishers and good friends, and the very good apples take on sikhi and become something worthwhile in life, the bad apples will fulfill themselves wordly and then have an imbalance because their spiritual quest is incomplete and thus find themselves in a situation where they unfortunatly divide and fall into an ego pit, guru granth sahib describes this state. The bad apples come from all castes. Punjabi culture can be a bedrock of ageless values but also in some ways a disease! i would like to point out a small panthic group takes jaat paat very seriously where it is included within its parchar structure. The subject will be talked about on each parchar occasion in a different way where it reaches out to the sangat and ingrains. Jaat paat is actually self destructive to our progress and stops us conveying the world as through guru granth sahib. The sangat, and bhai ajit singh swindon wale are vastly anti caste and anti race divisive not through lip service but through actions that resonate through their parchar and spirit to rid it. The sangat yet came from a 95% jatt background itself. Jatt culture is more promoted through music media because it is a money spinner theres no hidden secret. Half of these bhangra legendsa preserving jatt culture are not even jatt kuldip manak, surinder (bhogal) shinda lal chand yamla jatt( a chamar). Many would argue lal chand yamla jatt began a whole new era of punjabi music, from him sprang a new cradle. This makes a lot of money when you multiply the demand youl find an endless supply in india and pakistan. But let us not despair over caste, it can only satisfy the temnporal needs of man for a while, his spiritual quest for truth will begin one day and we must ensure we stay strong for anyone seeking the shelter of sikhi. Its when our bhais and bhens come back is when it counts.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Non-Sikh · 31 Jul 2006

<<>> Huh? The differences between these jatts are religion and political beliefs. <<>> I don’t know where you live, but here in Canada, most Jatts are big and light skinned. Not that I am saying being dark skinned is bad or anything like that. But you also got to remember that Jatt Punjabis do marry non-Jatt Punjabis as well. <<>> Do you seriously think Jatts accept Brahmins to be their priest even though majority of jatts are not Hindu? These Brahmins are nothing in Punjab. Jatts show more respect to Chamars than they do to Brahmins. Genetics: “A recent study of the people of Indian Punjab, where about 40% or more of the population are Jats, suggest that the Jats are similar to other populations of the Indus Valley.The study involved a genealogical DNA test which examined single nucleotide polymorphisms (mutations in a single DNA "letter") on the Y chromosome (which occurs only in males). (See Human Y-chromosome DNA haplogroups for a listing and explanation.) Jats seem to share many common haplotypes with German, Slavic, Baltic, Iranian and Central Asian groups.Unusually, Jat groups share only two haplotypes, one of which is also shared with the population of present-day Turkey, and have few matches with neighbouring Pakistani populations. This haplotype shared between the two Jat groups may be part of the Indo-Aryan (or Indo-European) genetic contribution to these populations, where as the haplotypes shared with other Eurasian populations may be due to the contribution of Indo-European Scythians (Saka, Massagetae) or White Huns. (These groups may of course all be branches of a larger ethnic complex.) As for mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA), Jats contain haplogroups typical of North India, Pakistan, and West Asia. This suggests that, at least for mtDNA, there is very little connection with Central Asian or northwest European populations, even though Jats share many male Y-SNP markers with these populations. Hence this suggests that there has been male migration in or out of the Jat population in historical times. Alternatively, the formation of the Jat population may have occurred in West Asia or North India.”

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Non-Sikh · 31 Jul 2006

<<>> What are you talking about? Only Hindus believe in that Aryan stock crap.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Non-Sikh · 31 Jul 2006

<<>> Jatts want to be like white people? Who is running the Punjabi culture right now? Jatts tend to take more pride of being Punjabi than any other Punjabis out there. It's usually rest of you desis who are sucking up to white people. White people don't even like us Jatts here in Canada.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

rangretta · 31 Jul 2006

non sikh ure gettin on my nerves, as i said mess with a mazbhi on your own peril! i know a JATT SIKH FAMILY that admits that baba deep singh ji and mai bhago were both mazbhi! Jatt sikhs never lived in tribes this is a joke pure joke!!! the only people who lived in tribes especialy in the Punjab area were untouchables! untouchables lived in tribes thats why tribes people are included in the sc act of india stupid! infact tribes still exist in undeveloped parts of india and guess what their untouchable! thick head! you know nothin about army history take it from some one who has war veterans in the family. "the sikh regiment has 72 battle honours" true......... but have u considerd, how many predesessor regiments were combined to make the sikh regiment? huh? plenty, dont forget u recruit all sikhs execpt mazbhi and ramdassia! so naturaly there will be more of u! stupid! The sikh light infantry is a result of only 3 pioneer regiments being combined!(23rd,32nd and 34th sikh pioneers) arnt u thick? plus its easy for a high caste to win an award a mazbhi or ramdassia and other lower castes have to work 10x as hard to win some recognision. You especialy should know how caste pregedist goes! lol there fore in a more realistic approach every award won by a low caste soldier in the sikh li should be worth 10x more in value of blood sweat and effort! Caste discrimination is every where, including the army! Like jatts are proud of being jatts im am proud of being a mazbhi! and if some jatt h8s it then theres only one out come..... me and u fight. Settle the dispute like a jatt and mazbhi would do. Dont pick on a poor mazbhi who gets nothing to eat due to his poverty. Pick on one that gets plenty and is a match for u! i am not a jatt hater, i just tell it as it is. i have jatt friends, and they are not the kind obbessed with the putt jatta de bhangra and self puffed on how jatt sikhs are harder that every one else and how jatt sikhs are the back bone of sikhism. Its about time jatts accept that mazbhis are the back bone of sikhism and we make better soldiers. Its about time jatts accept they are not harder than mazbhis and get real! i dont have a problem with jatts being jatts, but when jatts start proclaiming that many of sikhisms famous warriors were jatt including Baba deep singh ji and mai bhago, and how jatts did every thing, and then call me a chura, then thats where my problem begins! i am well aware in the eyes of many sikhs im just a chura, but its about time mazbhis wake up and realise there is no shame in being a chura sikh! because we have done so many great things in sikhism, many were thought of being impossible but we did them. Hari singh nalua conquering the afgans with an inferior force in terms of numbers! on their land too! The mazbhi has done great things, and i swear some body said maharaja ranjit singh was a jatt, that is very wrong. Infact he was a sansi, and in some places they are reguarded lower than churas. its about time some one promotes MAZBHI PRIDE just like people have promoted jatt pride infact when u think about it mazbhis have done so much more for sikhi (and so have other so called lower castes) than jatt sikhs, the only famous thing jatts have done in sikhism is desserting Guru Gobind Singh ji! dont think of saying Bindranwale as a famous jatt sikh he may have been jatt but many of the sikhs that followed him were jatt and mazbhi! in the end he was betrayed by a jatt! the khalistan movement failed because of a jatt's betrayal! A jatt invited the army to attack harmandir sahib! Jatt sikhs are from tribes and are a different race what a joke!, newsflash that describes untouchables! untouchables are the native race of india and live in tribes! So get real! jatt sikhs are shudras that work on farms and were treated bad by hindus at one point. jatts are 4rth class wow big deal ure one stage higher than us untouchables! there are 3 major casts higher than u lot! vaish, khashatryia and bramin! so ure not that high! many jatt sikhs need to get into touch with reality!

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Singh · 31 Jul 2006

Rangretta, you should be thankfull to Guru Jee For making you guys equal to Jatts. If Guru Jee made u guys equal that does not mean that you guys start talking trash that you guys are the best. Every body in this world is neevi jaati, only people who do naam jap become uchi jaati.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Non-Sikh · 31 Jul 2006

<<>> HAHAHAHAHAHAHA! How can I mess with someone who are scare start beef with me? Mazbhi are the laughing stock in the Punjabi community. These people wouldn't dare to start a war against Jatts. <<>> Huh? By using your logic, if someone said that Sikhs worship Idols, would you believe in that person too? Of course not..... <<>> You seriously are thick head! Do some research on Jatts! <<>> Umm when did I say Jatts run the Sikh regiment? You diss the Sikh regiment and I responded back. <<>> That's got to be biggest B.S. I ever heard on this website. <<>> Do you seriously think I go around start fights with you people? I didn't even know what a "mazbhi" was before I start posting on this website. But if you want to start a war against Jatts, then come to Canada. That’s all the Jatts are at (excluding Punjab). <<>> Buddy, please stop making yourself look like a fool. First of all, don't try to separate Sikhi with your little cult/hindu caste. 2.) If you have a problem with historians like Alexander Cunningham, then deal with them.....They're the ones who said Jatts are the backbone of Khalsa, not us Jatts. <<>> For the love of god, please stop with these lies and do some research on Maharaja Ranjit Singh. HE WAS A JATT IF YOU LIKE IT OR NOT. <<>> How many Mazbhi defended the attacks on Harmandir Sahib? How many of these people contribute to the movement instead of helping out their Hindu brothers? And why do u people worship Hindu gods? <<>> 1. Jatt is NOT a caste. 2. You said, "there are 3 major casts higher than u lot! vaish, khashatryia and bramin!", would that mean Jatts are the last caste (Untouchable) since there are only 4 castes in the Caste system? 3. Stop bringing Sikhi into this....Sikhs don't believe in caste system. 4. If you are the man that you claim to be, how about you join some Jatt website and start talking crap about Jatts there instead of going some Sikh website like this one where most people here don't even care about this issue. [%sig%]

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Dalbir · 31 Jul 2006

Your jatt obsession makes me laugh jatt. I can see nothing is going to convince that being jatt is the best thing since sliced bread, so I'll leave you to it! One warning, don't think that the situation in Canada, represents that with the community globally. Ive met a few Canadians, generally they are very polite and non-aggresive, so I'm not surprised that jatts may be lording it up over there where they have little or no competition. The situation in the UK is a world apart. Besides if what I've read about in Vancouver is true, then you lot should be hanging your heads in shame. What is that? Rich Sikh boys running around like ghetto gangstas killing each other. How did that happen? When the crap hits the fan here, jatts dont hesitate to get help from other non-jatts. Jatt I think that you are confused through brainwashing, inside of you is a Sikh trying to break free. That is why you still have a connection to Sikhi. One day I pray you will be able to see through the illusionary veil and see Sikhs as your brothers and sisters whatever their background.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

AB · 31 Jul 2006

Rangretta - Normally I don't get into any sort of hate mongering, be it Muslim bashing, Hindu bashing etc. but this new JATT bashing thing in Sikhi is of real concern. I think Jatt bashing is the new fashion trend amongst Mazhabis, Ravidasias etc. Why??? I think as the so called Mazhabis, Ravidasias, Tarkhans etc., have become more powerful economically, they have found that they can vent their anger at Jatts for no reason and twisting Sikh history to say this person was not a Jatt, he was a Mazhabi etc. One of the major points of Sikhi is not to break people into castes and this is exactly what has happened here. I asked two of my Hindu friends (one is from Ghaziabad and the other was born and brought up in America itself) and both of them said that they had no idea what their caste is. If you ask two Sikhs the same question, what are the chances that they will say, I'm just a Sikh? I think not more than 10%. Anyway, the whole point of my post is to tell Rangretta to stop his Jatt bashing or be prepared for long posts from me on Jatts and Mazhabis.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

viv · 31 Jul 2006

why dont you face up to the fact that most jats are obbessed with caste.what have the hindus got to do with it were talking about the present.not the past.and not all jats are fair skined in the punjab yes you will find more than you will over in western countrys.were the majority are black.an whats all this bs.about you not being indian.lol

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Non-Sikh · 31 Jul 2006

By the way, here’s a member of Amritworld.com dissing that book, “Dalit Sikh Panth De Raakhe.” By Pritam Singh. The member of Amritworld.com dissing the book because how the writer lies about people like Shaheed Baba Deep Singh Ji being a “Ranghreta” (“Mazahabi”) and show hate for Jatts. I hope all you people take the time read the article from the link. Now I know where this "rangretta" guy is getting all his lies from. http://www.amritworld.com/book_reviews/dalit_sikh_panth_de_rakhe.html [%sig%]

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

rangretta · 01 Aug 2006

man if i ever find out who u are ill beat u to the Ground so hard it wont be funny, as i said u shouldn't match ureself with a poor mazbhi ie the majority in india. come and mess with me or some one like me , were economically sound were well built and we get plenty to eat and we have plenty of rage to take out on the likes of u. do u think mazbhis who get plenty to eat and are well built, are scared of jatts?. im so confident ill tell ya now, ill snap ure arms like little twigs! U moron. As for ure comment on how many mazbhis defended harmandir sahib, there were plenty and also in the khalistan movement. Bindranwale was such a basterd, if khalistanis were caught, he would strike deals with jatt sikh police officers and make sure the mazbhi was killed and the jatt went free! U canadian jatts are a pure joke!!! ure all steroid takers, hmm the last time i checked intoxicants are completley against sikhi! and u idiot we dont worship hindu gods! ure thinking about valmikis! and valmikis are stupid, they want to be hindus, u cant get more stupid then that! as for ure comment on sikhs dont beleive in the caste system, u r so stupid read a sikh matrimonial page or are u blind? the fact that u think my military knowledge is pure b.s it shows how much u know about sikh regiments. its easy to quote and copy and paste knowledge and text from other websites but how much do u know from ure own knowledge? i came across this forum by complete chance and after reading some of the crap that people have posted here, it made me post my responses! as for ure war comment i dont enjoy bashing jatts or any other person for that matter and i dont need to start wars with people who are happy to exist along side me equaly and peacfuly this i say because u make it sound like i hate all jatts news falsh, i hate jatts like u! NOT ALL JATTS. i should go to a jatt website and chat **** about them there, listen here looser, i dont need to hide behind a computer and start verbal fights, i fight all of mine face to face! i have a good record, never lost a fight to a jatt! and i never will! the jatt sikhs on jattworld.com are all brain washed into their own pathetic version of sikh history, any sensible sikh with good knowledge would agree. Over here jatt sikhs are the laughing stock, they listen to rap and bhangra rap music very loudly in their cars and look like complete fools when they drive down a street, even white people hold their ribs with laughter! they hang around in massive groups with patkas and big thick karas and yet they cant fight, so much for the lookin tuff! LMAO!(in all fairness i have to say not all jatt sikhs are like that) if there was a war between jatt sikhs and mazbhi sikhs every body with at least half a brain cell will say that the mazbhis will win! its pure common sense. Jatt sikhs like u are self puffed on lies through songs from various artists like natorious jatt (that guy is a pure joke!) on how sikhi has suvived coz of the jatt, jatt this and jatt that. But u couldnt be further from the truth! "Mai bhago was from a muslim jatt family" now ive heard every thing!!! lmao! some say she was a decendent of a dhillon jat some say she is from some made up tribe and now this! it just shows she aint a jatti! jatts like u have to stop distorting and twisting the truth! she was a mazbhi get real! and as for baba deep singh ji being from a sandu tribe that is also lies! baba deep singh ji lived in a village on the out skirts of amritsar, and for ure information in those days churas were not allowed to live inside the city even under mugal rule. churas lived out side cities and towns. Ranjit singh was not a jatt he seriously was a sansi. you say i say lies to make my self feel good well then i guess i could have called maharaja ranjit singh a mazbhi, but i didnt. I said he was a sansi. I tell the truth as it is and if i hurt ure feelings then too bad! as for ure alexander cunningham and co. do u know why after the annexation of the punjab sikh kingdom, all gurdwaras came under the control of bramins? well let me tell u. The British recognised the mazbhi as the back bone of the khalsa and the British knew that all the gurdwaras were controlled by mazbhis. Gurdwaras were a source of income for mazbhis as they used the money to maintain the gurdwaras and they would also use the money to by new weapons and such for the nihangs and military order of the kingdom. The mazbhis put up so much of a resistance to the British that the British realised that they would have to break the grip of the mazbhi in order to keep the british raj safe long term. once they took over the sikh kingdom due to betrayal from dogra sikhs and hindu court members of the sikh raj, they confescated all the gudwaras from mazbhis and gave them to bramhins to look after as they identified them as a priest caste. i dont know where this alex cunningham is comming from but i have read many records and articles including from the actual time itself with plenty of references to the mazbhi sikh. It is quite clear who the back bone was. And here is another known fact. Maharaja ranjit singh was scared of mazbhis and never allowed them to have their own misl. He attached each mazbhi regiment on the back of existing misls. so i think that proves the mazbhi was the back bone of the khalsa forces, as every misl had mazbhis behind it. Also years before, maharaja Ranjit singh reduced the powers of the akali nihangs sevearly as they were also made up of many mazbhis the most famous being Akali phula singh. Nihangs were seen as king makers and breakers. there is so much proof that the mazbhi was thebackbone of the khalsa forces, its undisputable. as for ure comment "singh" "you should be greatful guru ji made mazbhis equal to jatts" it sounds like u would prefer quarel with us. to be very honest, i may be proud of being a mazbhi like a jatt is proud of being a jatt, but i have no intention of quarel with all jatts in fact ive said it before i dont hate all jatts infact i think jatts too should be admired for their hard work and effort. my quarel is with non sikh and other jatts like him. and i dont boast im the best. i tell the truth as it is, thats all, and its bound to hurt some jatt like non sikhs feelings. i eat, shake hands and sit alog side jatts and others i have no problem with any one, i just have a problem with jatts like non sikh and other sikhs who plan on distorting the truth.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

rangretta · 01 Aug 2006

ive read that article months ago and for ure information non sikh ive never read that book, and it will be critisied. Jatt sikhs like u will not like the truth because jatts arnt so gloryfied so naturaly the book will be critisied by jatts and other sikhs who dont like mazbhis getting any glory at all. my knowledge is beyond that book. that book is most probably in panjabi, i cant read panjabi, ure just a stupid over gloryfied canadian jatt, there are many jatts that agree with me i have never at one point said the contribution of the jatt to sikhi is 0% but u wont quite with ure putt jatta de becuase u think every one in sikh history is a jatt. well then too bad looser! i have one thing to say to u wether u like it or not. PUTT MAZBHIA DE!

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Non-Sikh · 01 Aug 2006

<<>> HAHAHAHAHAHA! Can you name me some famous mazbhi shaheeds? <<>> Steroid takers? LMAO! Now I heard it all. Funny part about this is that this guy tries to act his people don't do drugs. <<>> Go to India and visit one of their mazhabi gurdwaras. <<>> Buddy, people here quote people show PROVES to their claims. I doubt you got the balls to fight a jatt. <<>> HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA! <<>> <<<"Mai bhago was from a muslim jatt family" now ive heard every thing!!! lmao! some say she was a decendent of a dhillon jat some say she is from some made up tribe and now this! it just shows she aint a jatti!>>> <<< then i guess i could have called maharaja ranjit singh a mazbhi, but i didnt. I said he was a sansi. I tell the truth as it is and if i hurt ure feelings then too bad! as for ure alexander cunningham and co. do u know why after the annexation of the punjab sikh kingdom, all gurdwaras came under the control of bramins? well let me tell u. The British recognised the mazbhi as the back bone of the khalsa and the British knew that all the gurdwaras were controlled by mazbhis. Gurdwaras were a source of income for mazbhis as they used the money to maintain the gurdwaras and they would also use the money to by new weapons and such for the nihangs and military order of the kingdom. The mazbhis put up so much of a resistance to the British that the British realised that they would have to break the grip of the mazbhi in order to keep the british raj safe long term. once they took over the sikh kingdom due to betrayal from dogra sikhs and hindu court members of the sikh raj, they confescated all the gudwaras from mazbhis and gave them to bramhins to look after as they identified them as a priest caste. i dont know where this alex cunningham is comming from but i have read many records and articles including from the actual time itself with plenty of references to the mazbhi sikh. It is quite clear who the back bone was. And here is another known fact. Maharaja ranjit singh was scared of mazbhis and never allowed them to have their own misl. He attached each mazbhi regiment on the back of existing misls. so i think that proves the mazbhi was the back bone of the khalsa forces, as every misl had mazbhis behind it. Also years before, maharaja Ranjit singh reduced the powers of the akali nihangs sevearly as they were also made up of many mazbhis the most famous being Akali phula singh. Nihangs were seen as king makers and breakers. there is so much proof that the mazbhi was thebackbone of the khalsa forces, its undisputable.>>> 1. There are Muslims that Dhillion as their last name as well. Maybe you should do some RESEARCH on Jatt History. 2. Stop with the lies! I know where you getting your information from. You are getting it from that book which was exposed by an AMRITDHARI. http://www.amritworld.com/book_reviews/dalit_sikh_panth_de_rakhe.html NOW READ THE LINK! YOU GOT EXPOSED MY FRIEND! IT'S FUNNY & SAD HOW THESE JATT HATERS KEEP MAKING UP LIES TO FEEL GOOD ABOUT THEMSELVES....

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Non-Sikh · 01 Aug 2006

<<>> I usually do consider Sikhs to be my brothers and sisters until I join this website read many hate posts about jatts/punjabis made by you guys and I even got into a debate by some native American Sikh lady....since then, I kind of lost respect for you Singhs and Singhnis out there. [%sig%]

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

rangretta · 01 Aug 2006

AB- u say this jatt bashing is a new trend? what about jatt sikhs that look down on others? i find that common enough, dont u? "I think as the so called Mazhabis, Ravidasias, Tarkhans etc., have become more powerful economically, they have found that they can vent their anger at Jatts for no reason and twisting Sikh history to say this person was not a Jatt, he was a Mazhabi etc." AB- Have u ever read articles on sikh websites such as websites made by gurdwaras? or even the website made by the sheromnie comitte espesialy by that filth jagir kaur? let me ask u a question. whos distorting sikh history? I dont mean to target u hear but seriously have u read some of the articles ive suggested?

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Non-Sikh · 01 Aug 2006

<<>> First of all, there's no such thing a "pure" Jatt anymore due to interracial (not sure if this is the right word to use) has occurred in the Jatt community. But if you compare Jatts to other Punjabis, you can see some notable differences between them based on physical appearances. For the record, you are right, I am NOT an Indian, but instead I'm Canadian. Let me ask you this question: If Jatt is a caste, and then what caste do they come from?

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

stinku lal · 01 Aug 2006

rangretta ji dont despair dude, try not to take it seriously. I do understand how you feel and why you feel that way. But let usnot forget the real sikh jang first is within ourselves and to deal with people the way our guru sahib ji would. A son of Guru ji you are but everyone else comes from the same place too. We are the sons of adam and eve huna? so why the hoo haa? whats a caste? where did the jats come from? adam ji and where did the mazbhis come from adam ji. We have the same origins somewhere. Spiritually each created being is interlinked whether we like it or not. Also from what i understand rangretta are held in high esteem by Guru Gobind singh ji, their origins as far as i read were formed between rajputs and invaders. Please do not forget most malwai jatts have a strong historical connection with rajputs. sant jarnail singh jis line was directly from the sidhu barar family of bhatti jatts who evolved from bhatti rajputs. These strong bonds should in fact hold us all together and we should realise we are one. Just because one is a mazbhi or a chamar doesnt matter, if some jatt feels he is above you let them or challenge their thought based upon gurmat. If they disagree them to their opinion you to yours eventually equality will defeat division, because kal yug will fade. But lets not do blame culture, let us be honest and admit punjabis in general have a progblem with caste because they are too proud. This pride is because they lack bhagti. they need to balance their wordly success with sikhi. So let the sikhi do the talking.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Non-Sikh · 01 Aug 2006

oh shoot....I said, "First of all, there's no such thing a "pure" Jatt anymore due to interracial (not sure if this is the right word to use) has occurred in the Jatt community." I meant to say is, "interracial (not sure if this is the right word to use) marriages" Anyway, "rangretta" you need to stop making up lies. You still haven't back up your claims yet. BABA DEEP SINGH JI: A saint warrior Baba Deep Singh who had received baptism from the hands of Guru Gobind Singh himself was ever ready to sacrifice his life to protect his faith. He was a Jat Sikh. And belonged to village names pahuwind in Amritsar. Born on January 27, 1682, Baba Deep Singh combined the qualities of a scholar with those of a freedom fighter. http://www.siplweb.com/psp/asp/martyrs02.asp Mai Bhago: BHAGO, MAI, the sole survivor of the battle of Khidrana, i.e. Muktsar (29 December 1705), was a descendant of Pero Shah, the younger brother of Bhai Langah, a Dhillon Jatt who had converted to Sikh during the time of Guru Arjan. http://www.sikhiwiki.org/index.php?title=Mai_Bhago_ji Bhai Mani Singh Ji: “Bhai Mani Singh was born at a village named Kailbowal. The village was later destroyed during Nadar Shah's invasion. Its ruins are near Sunam, district Patiala. His father was a Jat Sikh, named Chaudri Kala.” http://www.searchsikhism.com/mani.html [%sig%]

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Non-Sikh · 01 Aug 2006

<<>> Funny you said because like the author of that book, you too consider people like Baba Deep Singh Ji to be a Mazhabi instead of Jatt. YOU REALLY NEED TO STOP MAKING FALSE CLIAMS. FOR THE LOVE OF GOD, I NEVER SAID JATTS ARE THE ONLY PEOPLE THAT CONTRIBUTE TO SIKHI AND I DON'T EVEN LOOK DOWN ON YOUR PEOPLE. IN FACT, I DIDN'T EVEN KNOW WHAT A MAZHABI WAS BEFORE I STARTED POSTING ON THIS WEBSITE. BY TYPING THIS POST IN CAPS LOCK, I HOPE MY MESSAGE GETS THROUGH YOUR HEAD THIS TIME, FOOL.

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Dalbir · 02 Aug 2006

I usually do consider Sikhs to be my brothers and sisters until I join this website read many hate posts about jatts/punjabis made by you guys and I even got into a debate by some native American Sikh lady....since then, I kind of lost respect for you Singhs and Singhnis out there. ------------------------------------------------------------ Seriously jatt you need to stop self hating because you are Sikh. I'm a Punjabi patriot like yourself but I don't even identify with caste. You see I was always taught one of major reasons for the Gurus coming was to destroy caste. I know you know what kind of history India has had for a thousand odd years, pure slavery. It was plainly because of caste. Caste demoralises most people on the receiving end and brings out the oppressor/zulm/ahankar in those who are supposedly on top. If you talk about Khalistan, where is your idealism! What kind of microsm of Bahman India will it be if we have caste! How will it be different then?? All that talk of racial attributes etc. is false, why? Because Guru Gobind clearly showed that when inspired and given the opportunity, even the lowest of the low can turn around and defeat those who have been so called warriors for generations. Thats how Sikhs whooped Afghan, Moghul and Rajput ass when the armies were made up not only of jats, but chamars, tarkhans, lobanas etc. etc. I read an account by a Moghul who was actually fighting Sikhs under Banda and he said EXACTLY that, even how none of them blinked to achieve shaheedi against the moghuls. That was the impact of Sikhism, turning sparrows to hawks. Even if you do still want the jatt mantle, don't you believe that we can all benefit and improve ourselves (individually and on a corporate level), through occasionally required self criticism? Yeah you are right, that Sikh society is not perfect! People are egotistical, hypocritical, narrow minded sometimes. And the same can be said of every society including jatt society. Can you truthfully say that jatt society doesn't maybe need to reconsider its relationship with other Punjabis and face a few things like drugs, crime and whatnot. Same with Sikh society which seems to tear itself apart instead of healing wounds with its own members. Your proposition that jatts made Sikhi great is the wrong way to look at it. Sikhism actually made some jatts great (not other way round). Sikhism inspired jatts to think above clan thinking and provided a mechanism for self government. Plus you know in ALL the east, Sikhism is the best thing going in terms of philosophy/theology, probably because it is so modern. And all this caste thing makes it like some sanatan ancient medieval hindu way of life. Even if you dont agree can you at least see where I'm coming from? WJKK WJKF

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Sardar · 02 Aug 2006

[url]http://www.realsikhism.com/faq/castesystem.html[/url]

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Seeker of the Truth · 02 Aug 2006

<<>> I understand where you are coming from and I do agree some of the things you have said in your post, BUT, if someone is going to bash Jatts and make false claims like Shaheed Baba Deep Singh Ji being a Mazhabi, then I got even right to respond back and correct that person. I am not saying we Jatts are better than rest of you Punjabis and Sikhs, but I am getting sick & tired of reading hateful comments made about Jatts on Sikh forums like this website though. I personally don't take a lot of pride of being a Jatt, but that doesn't mean I am not going to defend my people though. I hope you realize that Sikhs making hateful posts about Jatts are no different than those Hindus who make anti-Sikhi comments like how Sikhi is another sect of Hinduism or like how those Muslims make anti-Sikhi comments like how Guru Nanak Ji was a Muslim instead of a Sikh. I hope you understand where I am coming from. [%sig%]

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Dalbir · 02 Aug 2006

Ok, I get your point. Regarding saying Baba Deep Singh was x or y. Does it matter that much! Why have we made his caste such a big issue. When Baba Deep Singh scored the dirt on the ground with his Khanda and said only those who are ready to sacrifice come forward do you think he cared about the caste of the people or about the desecration of Harmandir Sahib? What I'm going to say now is not going to be popular but truthfully jatts have done a lot of good AND bad for the panth, just like most groups I guess. Yes it is indisputable that a lot of Sikhs from that background did major qurbani for the quam in the past but nowerdays they also produced Brar and K.P.S Gill. The latter is as bad as Massa Ranghar. These guys mass murdered Singhs. That aint to say that other so called castes haven't been complicit i.e Giani Zail Singh etc. Plus jatts being the majority, reflect on the wider panth with a great impact, so if you have murder and stuff say over drugs taking place and Sikh guys are doing it, it reflects on all of us. And in truth it hurts as well that our people are doing this. Nobody is perfect but sometimes things get so bad that we need to raise our heads and say "what is going on!" instead of defending when it actually perpetuates a problem. So it isn't like black and white where jatts are great and the panth should be eternally greatful to them. Jatts who have gone the Sikh way are Sikhs now anyway! Its more like a Sikh saying "whats going" to other Sikhs than dialogue between two distinct entities i.e. jatt and sikh.......jatt and non jatt

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Seeker of the Truth · 03 Aug 2006

You really need to stop labeling Jatt as a caste. Do you seriously think Jatts accept Brahmins to be their priest even though Hindus never made up majority of the Jatt population? Go to the “do you think the caste system in is now part of gurdwaras? (ravidasi. ramgharia) “ Thread and read couple posts there about Jatts and their history. [%sig%]

Re: Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs

Meridian · 07 Aug 2006

I think thats a very valid point, good on you UK Sikh.