Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Mail from a 'Muslim'

Mail from a 'Muslim'

Singhani · 16 Jun 2005

I got this in an email from a 'Muslim' who clearly has lots of issues with Sikhs, would like to see your views, it was upsetting to read. >>How can you honestly sit there and say Islaam is not true just because you don't like something from it. I don't like the Hell-Fire very much, and reading the vivid descriptions of it (and there's plenty unlike Sikhism, as per usual), no one would like it, DOES THAT MEAN I SHOULD LEAVE ISLAAM AND START BELIEVING in reincarnation knowing how unjust this idea is? You didn't do a very good job defending it and I doubt any reincarnationist could. Comparing Sikhi to Islaam in terms of rights. If I asked you to provide CLEAR evidences from the SGGS concerning what rights are afforded to women, you'd be hard pressed. You can sit there, like so many do, writing out your theories and SA papers, but when I ask you to back it up with evidences from the SGGS I promise you you wont be able to. What you will do is go to stories, which are not recorded in the SGGS, and show me from there the alleged equality and rights of women (Gobind Singh had the perfect opportunity to shwo this so-called equality by asking a woman to be from amongst the Panj Pyaarai - and yet he failed. So you play a pretty song, but as they say: The hollow drum sounds the loudest). And religion which has no chain of narration, no way to verify these stories as really being from the original source, and is even unsure about the biography of their first Guru, I would not like to go into the history of Sikhi to verify these stories. The fact of the matter is that Islaam left nothing out and explained everything FROM ITS PRESERVED SOURCES, not through beautiful speeches given by people 100s of years later to try and beguile and fool the masses. If I want stories, the atheists write pretty stories, why dont I follow them. Lastly, if I asked you to produce evidences from the source reference to show that he was lustful and wanted to control women, you'd be hard pressed. In fact, in a cout of law you'd be done for perjury. How can a man want to control women when he gave them there rights and liberated them, and literally gave the likes of Guru Nanak a taste of what it means to establish not this unrealistic idea of equality, but justice. You have a contradictory concept of god, which you dont want to face. Your reincarnation-transmigration hindu concept is laughable and clearly makes god an evil and unjust god (and I feel sorry for the 6 million Jews and the Tsunami orphans). And you have no way of verifying your stories, no methodology of authentication, thats why the Sikhs just lap up stories without even asking: "Is this true"? Why? They have no concept of what this means? You have no answers to the problems of plural marriages, rights of the foetus, many aspects of womens rights, fear of god (thats why you being a so-called Singhanis are so sh*t scared you cant stand up for justice when it really matters or simply stop swearing), and that's why most Sikhs simply are content with the laws made by the atheists (democracy and all that rubbish) because you have nothing. You know it and I know it. And I can show you. Alas, you cannot show anything because as the arabs say: "You cannot give that which you do not have." <<

Re: Mail from a 'Muslim'

bsb · 16 Jun 2005

first, a good answer to idiots like this is [url]http://www.whyichosesikhism.com[/url] Next, regarding reincarnation/karma: Muslims have absolutely the most untenable approach to the afterlife and even life itself. They have a view of a super angry God looking down and doing nothing but judging and condemning the "non-believers" (Guru Sahib tells us that [gurbani]jYsw syvY qYso hoie[/gurbani] and Muslims themselves follow this very pattern) The Muslim has said that reincarnation and karma are so very injust to the Jews and Tsunami victims. How is the Islamic approach any more "just"? Before going into this a bit more, I have a question that you should ask the Muslim [i]a baby is born. Screams one scream and then dies. Why was this baby born? Where will it go? Heaven or hell? What was the purpose of its life?[/i] Muslims have no decent answer to this situation. They cannot explain why God would let an infant live and then die so quickly and where it will go and why? A Sikh will answer that the child was born due to some karma and after living out that brief karma, is now headed for a different life. But back to the Jewish Holocaust victims and the Tsunami orphans: why did God punish them? Why did they suffer so much? What will that poor infant who drowned face in the afterlife? Heaven or Hell? What if they were not Muslim and had not chosen a faith? No answers. The Islamic view of God is the biggest example of Injustice you can find. Karma is the ULTIMATE in justice. It means that every action we do, has a reaction. It is downright scientific. The magic of Sikhi is that we are given a way out of the cycle of Karma through naam (unlike other faiths). On Women's rights: Guru Granth Sahib has clearly given women equal rights. The famous salok "Bhand jameeai bhand nimeeai..." is the biggest example, but Guru Sahib has also spoken against the concept of "impurity" for women, against "sati" and speaks to women as sisters. Where Mohammed was marrying little girls under the age of 10, along with his already very full harem, Guru AmarDas made Sikh women preachers in the Manji system. They were made heads of Sangats. He refused to meet women who came in the oppressive veil. I have always wondered, wouldn't the "Prophet of God" have the decency or common sense to know that a girl the age of his grand daughters, is not marriage material? Guru Gobind Singh, according to the idiot who wrote the original email, didn't "choose" any women to be in the Punj Pyaaray. He DIDN'T CHOSE ANYONE! They volunteered. It was the most fair method possible. To show the role of women, Mata Jeeto Jee added the pataasay to the Amrit therefore forever showing the importance of women in Sikhi! And then the Muslim goes on about no chain of narration and how unreliable Sikh documents are. He is certainly one to talk. The Koran wasn't written by Mohammed. It was written many years after his death. And different old versions vary on the verses. There are "Satanic Verses" which Muslims claim were inspired by Satan and had to be removed from the Koran. They have edited their book so many times. Compare this to Sree Guru Granth Sahib which is the most authentic scripture, given straight from the Guru to his Sikhs. Except for Ragmala, there is no doubt on what is our scripture and it has not been edited or changed. Sikhi is a loving religion that takes a soul above heaven and hell. The poor Muslims must face not only heaven and hell but after that, reincarnation too! "[gurbani]nrku surgu duie BuMcnw hoie bhuir bhuir Avqwr ]2][/gurbani] Sikhi teaches us mercy. The Muslims are still doing halal to the goats just like they do halal to human captives (as has been seen over and over). What mercy do they have? Where is their love? There is none. They worship anger and have become anger themselves. Sikhi is the greatest faith to ever be revealed. I have challenged anyone to find a single flaw in it many times and not once has anyone succeeded. You can tell the Muslim emailer that he can ask whatever question he wants, but he should be ready to answer some questions himself (like why Mohammed married a minor and why the Koran makes senseless claims like Mountains are made to prevent earthquakes, etc.)

Re: Mail from a 'Muslim'

singhs · 16 Jun 2005

bsb - thanks for that, when i was reading the email i was getting worried about stuff he was saying but u clarified it all for me - thanks alot... sikhi is magnificent man, "Singhani" who is this muslim is he giveing you trouble?

Re: Mail from a 'Muslim'

bsb · 16 Jun 2005

Sometimes I'm not sure what to be more upset about: the fact that idiots like the one above write such nonsense or that so many of us read it and then feel afraid or even believe what is written. When you read something like that, have the faith that Guru Nanak is the Prophet for Kaljug. There is none other. Know that he has left us with a perfect faith. All others are not even able to approach Guru Nanak's perfection. One thing I didn't comment more on was the comment >>>>>> You have no answers to the problems of plural marriages, rights of the foetus, many aspects of womens rights, fear of god (thats why you being a so-called Singhanis are so sh*t scared you cant stand up for justice when it really matters or simply stop swearing), and that's why most Sikhs simply are content with the laws made by the atheists (democracy and all that rubbish) because you have nothing. >>>>>> Guru Sahib has given us so many verses and shabads on looking on all other women besides the wife as daughter or sister. Women's rights have sooo many shabads. Just look over Sri Asa Kee Vaar. Fear of God is somethign covered over and over in Guru Granth Sahib. It is not the terror that Muslims have of being struck down and condemned to eternal pain, it is the kind of fear a child has of not letting his father down or a wife has of not looking anywhere else when she has her husband. It is a very different kind of fear. If he asks for verses, I certainly will provide them. As for justice and law: look on the whyichosesikhism site. It has a very clear description of Sikh law. Unlike the Koran, Sree Guru Granth Sahib is not a rule book or a book of fables. It is devotion. It is love. And yes, it is also guidance. But don't expect the blind to understand this.

Re: Mail from a 'Muslim'

Guru ka Singh · 16 Jun 2005

These guy need to get a life and find something new to give us a hard time (if they can...LOL). They come up with the same thoeries over and over and over again. "Islam has covered everything. You guys got just stories. Ours is more of a practical and scientific religion. We have scientific logic to back everything up". And when you answer them back in a solid way, they try to change the topic by saying "Islam is the fastest spreading religion in the world". At times its not worth wasting time with such people who are out there only to damage your faith. First they come with affection and try to brainwash you, then they plant confusion in your mind so that your faith cracks, and once they know you are vulnerable, thats when they strike! Its an age old strategy thats failing today. I have seen loads of this happen and was myself on the verge of becoming one of them ([i]but Guruji had other plans[/i] :) ). [u]The previous post(s) by bsb jee are too good!! Thanks Guru pyaareyo!![/u] :) To all Sikhs ([i]Singhs and Singhnees[/i]) : Do NOT fall prey to ANY of their appealing / pleasing logics EVER !! Whether its a Hindu or a Muslim or a Christian, respect them as humans, and their religion as THEIR path to perfection, but stay FIRM in your Sikhi. We have had multitudes of Sikhs become martyrs over the centuries rather than convert to someone preaching all this "logic and science". Lets all resolve to live by the following : sir jawe ta jawe mera sikhi sidak na jawe

Re: Mail from a 'Muslim'

Singhani · 16 Jun 2005

Thankyou so much for that reply! You really made me see things differently Jee, you are absolutely right, Il check out that site and pass these replies on to this idiot. :)

Re: Mail from a 'Muslim'

daljit singh · 17 Jun 2005

singhni penji......and all others,i'd like to recommend you all,plz visit following website.....www.faithfreedom.org....and....www.faithfreedom.info.....thease sites are sheding a very good light on islam(religion of peace).....

Re: Mail from a 'Muslim'

UK Sikh · 17 Jun 2005

Also tell the idiot about Sikh women warriors like Mai Bhago - ACTIONS speak louder than words! For more Great Sikh Women refer to: http://allaboutsikhs.com/women/index.htm