Mail from a 'Muslim'
Singhani · 16 Jun 2005
I got this in an email from a 'Muslim' who clearly has lots of issues with Sikhs, would like to see your views, it was upsetting to read. >>How can you honestly sit there and say Islaam is not true just because you don't like something from it. I don't like the Hell-Fire very much, and reading the vivid descriptions of it (and there's plenty unlike Sikhism, as per usual), no one would like it, DOES THAT MEAN I SHOULD LEAVE ISLAAM AND START BELIEVING in reincarnation knowing how unjust this idea is? You didn't do a very good job defending it and I doubt any reincarnationist could. Comparing Sikhi to Islaam in terms of rights. If I asked you to provide CLEAR evidences from the SGGS concerning what rights are afforded to women, you'd be hard pressed. You can sit there, like so many do, writing out your theories and SA papers, but when I ask you to back it up with evidences from the SGGS I promise you you wont be able to. What you will do is go to stories, which are not recorded in the SGGS, and show me from there the alleged equality and rights of women (Gobind Singh had the perfect opportunity to shwo this so-called equality by asking a woman to be from amongst the Panj Pyaarai - and yet he failed. So you play a pretty song, but as they say: The hollow drum sounds the loudest). And religion which has no chain of narration, no way to verify these stories as really being from the original source, and is even unsure about the biography of their first Guru, I would not like to go into the history of Sikhi to verify these stories. The fact of the matter is that Islaam left nothing out and explained everything FROM ITS PRESERVED SOURCES, not through beautiful speeches given by people 100s of years later to try and beguile and fool the masses. If I want stories, the atheists write pretty stories, why dont I follow them. Lastly, if I asked you to produce evidences from the source reference to show that he was lustful and wanted to control women, you'd be hard pressed. In fact, in a cout of law you'd be done for perjury. How can a man want to control women when he gave them there rights and liberated them, and literally gave the likes of Guru Nanak a taste of what it means to establish not this unrealistic idea of equality, but justice. You have a contradictory concept of god, which you dont want to face. Your reincarnation-transmigration hindu concept is laughable and clearly makes god an evil and unjust god (and I feel sorry for the 6 million Jews and the Tsunami orphans). And you have no way of verifying your stories, no methodology of authentication, thats why the Sikhs just lap up stories without even asking: "Is this true"? Why? They have no concept of what this means? You have no answers to the problems of plural marriages, rights of the foetus, many aspects of womens rights, fear of god (thats why you being a so-called Singhanis are so sh*t scared you cant stand up for justice when it really matters or simply stop swearing), and that's why most Sikhs simply are content with the laws made by the atheists (democracy and all that rubbish) because you have nothing. You know it and I know it. And I can show you. Alas, you cannot show anything because as the arabs say: "You cannot give that which you do not have." <<