Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

shudh bani uchaaran....

shudh bani uchaaran....

singhee laad · 16 Jun 2005

I have recently been listening to tapes of nitnem to try and get my ucharan correct, I have been doing nitnem for nearly 20 years now and I am conscious that a lot of bad habits/laziness may have crept in. I first listened to a tape of Bhai Jodinder Singh Talwara jee which was beautiful full of raass and quite clear, it was like a conversation with mahraj. I then listened to a CD of Bhai Baldeep Singh from Damdami taksal, the ucharan was very clear and precise, but I did feel it was very robotic and emotionless. This is not a criticism of Bhai Baldeep Singh or damdami taksal. Maybe my perception is wrong and the ucharan Bhai Baldep singh was also full of pyar, but here is my point... Should de we do paath with emotion and pyaar, (obviously with correct pronunciations) or should it be done methodically and exactly the same time each time?

Re: shudh bani uchaaran....

work is boring · 16 Jun 2005

i think our focus should be on listening to the bani and understanding what we're reciting. the pyaar will come from that i think. actually when we listen to bani we'll get whatever it is we are wanting. wether its love for bani or a car or a job or a child. "jo mangay thakur apanay te soee soee davai"

Re: shudh bani uchaaran....

kabadi · 16 Jun 2005

doing nitnem isnt a show... only u will know if u are putting on a show, or if ur doing it from ur heart... do it so u recite each 'line' and listen to it from ur ears at the same time... absorb it, understand it, and feel it, remember god with it... other than that watever works best for u is f ine.,.

Re: shudh bani uchaaran....

**** · 16 Jun 2005

they both do it with pyaar.. who are you to say doing paath fast means you have no pyaar?

Re: shudh bani uchaaran....

JARNAIL SINGH GYANI "ARSHI" · 17 Jun 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Dear Author **** jio, i notice the "pyaar" missing from your post.. Singhee lad's..."observation" has a deeper "understanding". ( here I have no personal like or dislike for either paathi)..BUT i DO NOTICE that shardhaloos when buying CDs at the local Gurdawra stall/vcd shop etc have a PRE-SET notion of whose Paath is Shudh and whose isnt...BASED on their Own Jathebandi. Thus there will be people saying...I want a cd by Damdami taksaal ONLY...their paath is shudh. Once i overheard this request and mentioned to the person.. I have heard a Cd from a Bhai Joginder Singh talwarra..and it is good....IS HE TAKSALI was the next question. NO, he isnt i said..THEN IT CANNOT be GOOD/SHUDH was his reply and he walked away. THAT is why the CD covers have PROMINENTLY displayed DAMDAMI TAKSAAL WALEH..blah blah blah...Flanee jathedbandi walleh blah blah blah. They KNOW that this SELLS...and some "SEE" beautiful Paath IN the NAME on the CD cover !!! not in the actual paath on the CD. Daily i have many requests to burn cds form the NET... and some will very vehemently contend that..Gyani ji I want ONLY taksaali paath as it is shudh...I GIVE them CDs with PAATH i download off other sites...and Since MY CD is WITHOUT COVER ( saying damdami taksaal paathi blah blah) THEY fail to SEE that the "paath is NOT SHUDH !!! and they NEVER COMPLAIN... this is valid proof that all this shudh apath thing is advertising hype. nothing personal just observations.