Raj Karega Khalsa ? Why
kulmohan · 11 Jun 2005
Friends do you also feel that the lines " Raj Karega Khalsa" are anti gurmat , should these lines not be banned because Gurbani says Raj na chahon mukat na chahon man preet charan kamlarey
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
kulmohan · 11 Jun 2005
Friends do you also feel that the lines " Raj Karega Khalsa" are anti gurmat , should these lines not be banned because Gurbani says Raj na chahon mukat na chahon man preet charan kamlareySinghstah · 12 Jun 2005
because im a moorakh, icasnt really say anything about the gurbani yuk, however, i do know that guroo gobind singh ji said raj bina nahin dharam chale hain, dharam bina sab dhallw malle hainffjeevan singh · 12 Jun 2005
' Raj na chahon mukat na chahon man preet charan kamlarey' THESE LINES MEAN AN INDIVIDUAL DOES NOT NEED RAJ, THE INDIVIDUAL SHOULD SEEK GOD. RAJJ IS FOR THE WHOLE NATION, THE WHOLE NATION NEEDS TO BE FREE AND SHOULD BE SELF-DETERMINED AND SOVERIEGN, WITHOUT SELF RAJJ A RELGION CANNOT PROGRESS !!! '' RAJJ BINA NAHIN DHRAM JALE HAIN DHRAM BINA SAB DALE MALE HAIN '' GURU GOBIND SINGH JI [%sig%]JARNAIL SINGH GYANI "ARSHI" · 12 Jun 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Verr Kulmohan ji this is just one panktee..out of context. Guru Gobind Singh Ji said..Raaj bina na Dharam Chalehn hai... does that "contradict" the panktee you quoted ?? In one Shabad Guru arjun Ji Sahib..asks that SLEEP should INCREASE....as He is able to dream about Waheguru Ji while sleeping... in the next Panktee Guru Ji says...SLEEP GO AWAY....as I am now in wakeful state and i am in communication with Waheguru... some would take this as "contradiction"...Guur Ji first saying one thing and then another ?? The TRUTh is GURBANI is NEVER CONTRADICTORY...there is a time and place for "more sleep"..and NO SLEEP, more food..and NO FOOD..etc etc ONE Panktee in ISOLATION doesnt mean the entire Story. In one Panktee it is said Roti meri Khatth kee...meaning Bread made out of WOOD....so does that mean we are being advised to make wooden rotis or NOT EAT ?? It would be a stupid assertion if we take that way.. Excuse me for saying so but the questions you asked is the type PANGGA types put across to "try and upset"...they see one panktee they understand.out of context and they think they have understood the entire Gurbani.. I am not saying you are Pangga guy...this could very well be a legitimate question..and if it is please dont take offense at my words. Raaj na chahon.... is the ULTIMATE STATE every Khalsa Gurmukh seeks... at the Feet of WAHEGURU is our Ultimate GOAL....BUT we are living in thsi World...and we have DUTIES to perform here....eat, sleep, marry, have children, run for office, take jobs, run governments.rule and be ruled..... Bhul Chuk maafMehtab Singh · 12 Jun 2005
Raj Karega Khalsa can mean more than just a Khalsa kingdom (which would be amazingly an ideal society to live in). Yeah some believe it means so, but didn't Guru Nanak Ji say "mann jeetay jagjeet" ? So it can also be interpretted that the Khalsa will rule their own minds and not fall prey to the 5 vices. The Khalsa will rule over the hearts of everyone else, even non-Sikhs, and that will be the amount of love and respect the Khalsa will get! This is just another interprettation. Lets not forget Guru Gobind Singh Jee said "Raaj bina nahi dharam chale hain. Dharam bina sab daley maley hain".. · 12 Jun 2005
naanak raaj chalaaeiaa sach kott sathaanee neev dhai || Nanak established the True kingdom; He built the true fortress on the strongest foundations (Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee - 966)Akali Fauj · 12 Jun 2005
Ya, well Raaj is not the first priority. However, without Bhagti there is no Shakti and without Shakti, there is no Bhagti. Need both.Bhopinder singh · 12 Jun 2005
no it is not anti gurmat .Yes you are anti gurmatJ singh · 12 Jun 2005
Author: Bhopinder singh Date: 06-12-05 17:24 no it is not anti gurmat .Yes you are anti gurmat ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- Learn how to talk to people!kulmohan · 14 Jun 2005
Veer Jarnail Singh ji, thanks for the recognition (no sarcasm this). Having my own independent thinking makes me a slightly panga type guy, but my aim of writing to this group isn't that mallicious. I only wish that all of us should analyse, question and then correct the anomalies in our religious practices (e.g. when we ask for "Raj Karega Khalsa" in the ardas) by measuring our practises against one single parameter i.e. Gurbani. And when the Gurbani is clearly saying "Raj na chahon, Mukat na chahon", In my opinion, it leaves little room for doubts whatsoever. Whilst Guru Gobind Singh ji may have worded "Raaj bina neh dharam chaley hai , dharam bina sabh daley maley hai" (meaning - Dharam may not be accepted/followed in the absence of rule(Power) and things will be miserable in the absence of Dharam), he has not advised us in black and white to struggle for aquiring the Raj as doing so will be in direct conflict wth Gurbani. As far as the example of "Roti Meri Kaath ki...." goes, well, its only a colloquial expression which even an ordinary craftsman will simulate, by talking of his tools as his bread and butter.. · 14 Jun 2005
i think raj karega khalsa does mean exactly that. If we look at all the problems in the world sikhs face, wouldnt it be easier if we had our own raj? post sep 11 humanity is bitterly divided. In an ideal world perhaps we could rule hearts, but the way it looks with devious sarkars around very qwuickly making religious people look like terrorists together with a white man superiority complex i cant see gorey ever wanting to have their hearts ruled by apney. The sight of desi skin is enough to gain a jelous glare. Gorey ruled over u when we gave them the chance to come in, they tried to change our religion instead. In the process we are the ones who had been ruled over. The beazti episode sikhs protested peacefully, the sarkari run electric media started accusing sikhs of being extremists. This in turn made gorey react differently towards sikhs. One sarkar media paper had stated in giant capital letters on a popular newspaper read by millions " mob rule". Sikhs were then accused of being the new taliban types by the superiority complex ridden british society. In india sikhs had a very heavy shanti towards the hindi film issue where singhs were being mocked for over a decade. When jo bole so nihal took it to another level, and singhs cud take it no longer they protested in the spirit of sikhi and peacefully. The sarkars knew accepting that would mean the mass would believe sikhs had a genuine right to grieve. To counter that they carried out their own shrarta in delhi and blamed it on sikhs thus sikhs were made instead to look like murderous savage beasts killing innocent cinema goers. Our brothjers and sisters in "free india" have been subject to extreme horrors in these long years past. The shaanti of many sikhs has not moved the sarkar, extreme hindu groups, or public opinion of sikhs constantly ridiculed as dumb sardars. the same shaanti in every continent has done jack to change peoples hearts towards sikhs. This is because the sarkars dont want people to live and let live. The divide and rule element keeps their job easier. Beacuse we do not live in an ideal world i very much doubt sikhs will be able rule over others hearts en mass. The best way forward would be to first put ourselves together stop the cowboy mentality, and just hold onto each other and say this is it let us work together in a peaceful way for a united khalsey da ghahr where sikhi may flourish. Where we have a few people falling in love with sikhi and becoming sikhs is entirely their good karms as ordained. But that is not a worldwide pattern. We have to overcome our hurdles and unite. the khalsa is a sovereign spirit that does not accept anybodies rule.Panthic parkarsh · 14 Jun 2005
Sadh Sanghat jee, Please correct me if i'm wrong, but was this line," raj karega Khalsa' is written in the panthic parkash granth? this was never written by our beloved Guru's? Could someone please enlighten us on this....A Singh · 14 Jun 2005
Where exactly did Guru Gobind say the much quoted "raj bina nahin dharam chale hain, dharam bina sab dhallw malle hainff". What is the source for this quote?kulmohan · 14 Jun 2005
Where exactly did Guru Gobind say the much quoted "raj bina nahin dharam chale hain, dharam bina sab dhallw malle hainff *********************** I am not certain if these lines have been worded by Guru Gobind singh ji, I was just going by what Veer Mehtab Singh had writtenlimited · 14 Jun 2005
"Raaj Karega Khalsa".... The ones who attain this mindset and realisation of purity (khalas) will rule the whole universe. Why?... because they will realise they are not limited by time, space and matter. How?... because they have realised their oneness with Ik Onkaar, hence prevailing everywhere, therefore doing Raaj.Bhopinder singh · 14 Jun 2005
ok it is not written by the guru .kulmohan and friends why did guru hargobind sahib dressed as a king wearing two swords he was asked by a hindu intelligence agent why in the house off Nanak are you dressing and living like a king cause he thought Nanak is the house of fakiri and i think you know the answer if not i am sorry. why was akal takhat created by guru ji in the holiest of the holy darbar sahib that to right in front not even on side but face to face why was dhadi waran sung on akal takht.(started by the sixth Nanak why did 6th nanak order the sikhs to bring shasters and horses as donation why did the sikh choosen by tenth nanak to lead the panth the personal companion of the guru establish the first sikh kingdom ok should the sikhs be beggars beaten raped killed .A Singh · 14 Jun 2005
bhopinder singh, your comments point towards the need for a man to be armed and a knight, if you will, but do not confirm the point it appears you are trying to make.A Singh · 14 Jun 2005
I do not wish to sound like a broken record, however the possibility for a Sikh Kingdom in Punjab was a very real one under Banda Singh Bahadur, however as stated under the other thread, it is shame that when it came to the crunch that the Tat Khalsa chose to side with the then Moghul power against Baba Ji. As a result of this the Khalsa had to suffer for a further 100 years under the hands of the oppressive regime that followed. The second chance came under the Misaldar period, again upon some united success, we are all familiar with what happened with Sikh fighting Sikh (e.g. Ahluwalia Misl and Bhangi Misal versus the Ramgarhia Misal over “land disputes” over the latter’s acquired property), so again during a period where a number of Sikh kingdoms had developed and the Moghul power defeated, the Sikhs were still unable to maintain their rule with the clarity warranted and not fight amongst themselves. Ranjit Singh Sukerchakia is credited with ‘consolidating’ the Misals through the usual marrying of daughters and sons politics and crowning himself Maharaja. This is often heralded as the golden era and Khalsa Raj, however even here hostilities between Sikhs themselves are apparent and all are well aware of how the Raj subsequently ended and the cultural ills that were brought into play during its reign. This time, rather than side with each other, the Dogra Rajas and the Sikhs that supported them had chosen to be loyal to the “Crown” under the British regime following the collapse of their kingdom, which seems to hark back to the events that occurred during the time of Banda Singh Bahadur with the Tat Khalsa alignment with the then Moghul Government, however I am not too sure where a figure like Baba Ji was during this time. Arguably the character of the Sikh nation was further degraded during this time by the likes of Simranjit Singh Mann’s Nana Jee and his honouring of General Dyer at the Akal Thakt, despite his huge atrocities against the Punjabi people. Many people often speak of third time lucky, clearly not for the Sikhs --nonetheless, a forth chance materialised during partition times, however the leadership of Master Tara Singh did not hold much sway when compared to Jinah or Nehru and here Sikhs chose remain as part of the much touted ‘multi-religious’ India. The events which followed are clearly known to most. And now we have the events of the 1980s, wherein communal politics snowballed together with rising religious revival which sadly resulted in the dark occurrences of 1984. Here again, we see many within the Sikh movements that came to the forefront at loggerheads with each other and of course like the Tat Khalsa during the time of Banda Singh Bahadur, the Sikhs during the British Raj and the in-fighting that occurred during the Misal-period, we again had splits within the Kharkoo movements, Taksal, SGPC and AKJ, Buddha Dal Nihangs and Baba Santa Singh who unfortunately to come to a consensus at a time when the Panth needed it the most, but more importantly internal dhusts like General Brar and KPS Gill (who followed the orders of the Government in power against their own brethren) and many others. Although a quick whizz through, the point is that many events relating to opportunities for Sikh self-rule have come and gone and there are many similarities between these time periods. What can we learn from these events? Why is that Sikhs, perhaps unlike the Muslims who many following the 1980’s try to emulate in political terms and ideals, do not come together under one united umbrella? Or is it that these phrases above, not Mukvak of Guru Sahib as Bhopinder Bhaji now indicates, are perhaps not to be taken so literally or need to be read in full?Hari Singh · 14 Jun 2005
Good Post Bhopinder Singh. I agree completely. Gursikhs follow a higher justice system that centuries of jurisprudence is simply not able to provide. Khlasa Raj is inevitable. Sikhs as a nation have the best karams and those will bear fruit.kulmohan · 14 Jun 2005
Friends we need to Learn to change with the changing times. Our Gurus have acted according to what their times demanded - Whilst the tenth Guru could send his sons to the battlefield in the face of death, he also showed us that there was nothing wrong in his escaping from the fort in the darkness of night. Without sounding sacriligeous, let me pose a question to each one of you - Do you think if it is practically right time to don the miri-piri in this global age of one small world, specially after the post sept 11 scenario. Better still Let me ask another question - Why did Guru Har Rai ji and Guru Harkrishan ji not continue the tradition of Miri-Piri set by Guru Hargobind sahib ji ? Whilst one may see this quest for Khalsa Raaj as the solution, I would rather see it to some extent as the root cause of the problem itself. Had our past years not seen a mention of the words "Khalsa Raj" or "Khalistaan" by our leaders, our history may have seen much lesser bloodshed than it actually did. Friends do you even realize that - "Raaj" is a game of numbers, be it a democracy in parliament or otherwise. The Sikhs and the Akal Takht has to decide now - How many more Hawaras do we want to be arrested and tortured, how many more families do we want destroyed for the sake of this illusive "Khalsa Raaj" I would urge the Akal Takht Jathedaar to ban the use of word "Khalistaan". If anybody is not convinced let them ask the widows of 1984 who lost their husband and sons to the riotous mobs and saw their daughters being raped and they will tell you how much do they like the situation brought about by the words like "Khalsa Raaj" and "Khalistaan" and "the pre 84 media images of flashing of weaponry in the Golden temple complex" . Can the AKAL Takht muster enough courage and ask the people to give up the miri-piri, in the same way as Guru Har Rai ji did after Guru Hargobind Sahib ji. I urge you to give up the demand for Raaj and buy lasting peace if not for the reasons cited above ,then for the sake of gurbani - because Gurbani shows the way "Raaj na chahon, mukat na chaahon ........" daas di bhul chuk maaf karni jiA Singh · 14 Jun 2005
Dear Kulmohan, Changing with the times is not Sikhi –we are beyond time: AKAAL! Wearing the Miri Piri is absolutely essentially and even more after the 9/11 events and you’ll find that Guru Har Rai DID maintain this practice and a had a considerable standing army –please be clear as to what you suggesting, and moreover, Guru Gobind Singh is the standard bearer of the path unfolded and presented to humanity by the Gurus –his hukam on the need to bear arms is clear, do NOT forget this. Is the bloodshed because of Khalsa Raj or “Land Issues” and infighting?HARJ · 14 Jun 2005
KULMOHAN YOUR VIEWS ARE VERY ANTI-KHALSA !!!!!! YOU MAKE OUT AS YOU ARE WISER THAN BABA BANDA SINGH BAHADUR MAHARAJA RANJEET SINGH AND SANT JARNAIL SINGH BHINDRAWALE !! RAJJ IS NEEDED TO STOP INJUSTICE, PERSICUTION, FACISM, GENOCIDE, ETHNIC CLEANSING !!! IF ALL THE SIKHS BEGAN TO THINK LIKE YOU I DREAD TO THINK WHAT WOULD HAPPEN TO THE QUAM AND PANTH !!!!!! LAKHS AND LAKHS OF SIKHS HAVE GIVEN THEIR SHAHEEDI FOR THEIR RIGHTS AND TO ESTABLISH SELF-RULE TO AVOID ETHNIC-CLEANSING ON THEIR OWN SOIL !! AND GREAT SINGHS LIKE BHAI JAGTAR SINGH HAWARA ARE STILL PUTING THEIR HEAD ON THE LINE FOR THE PANTH !! I ASK A QUESTION TO THE SANGAT WHO'S VIEWS DO YOU THINK HAVE MORE VALUE, KULMOHAN OR SANT BHINDREWALE AND BABA MANOCHAHAL ! [%sig%]Balpreet Singh · 14 Jun 2005
What a sad sight. Spirtually and mentally enslaved "Sikhs", who are in truth what Baba Jarnail Singh called "chappli day Sikh" are wanting to ban the word "Khalistan" because they are afraid of being beaten again. I guarantee you that the people calling for this ban are not rehitvan Guru Kay Khalsa. Khalsa realises that Raj is his Right, given by the Grace of Vahiguru. "raaj na chaahon mukat naa chahon..." Guru Sahib tells us this. Yes. But have you ever thought that it is the person that has no greed or desire to rule who deserves to rule the most? Plato in his ideal society would have the most enlightened of citizens rule and he realises that they would not want this position but must be compelled for the good of all. In the same way a Gursikh has no desire to be a ruler, but for "sarbat da bhala" will consider it his duty and seva to fulfil this role. Kulmohan, chappli da Sikh #1, has said that Guru Har Rai Sahib and Guru Har Krishan Sahib did not follow Guru Hargobind Sahib's example. It is a fact that Guru Har Rai Sahib kept an army and did indeed have some minor skirmishes. Guru Sahib did not disband the Sikh army and abandon Miri Piri. To suggest they would have done so is to insult Satuguru Hargobind Sahib. A Sikh always prefers peace to war, and so the Seventh and Eighth Gurus did not need to fight and did not. But to suggest they gave up the principle is blasphemous and the mouth that says it is cursed. Guru Gobind Singh showed us how we should sacrifice our everything but not give up the struggle. Would you have given Dashmesh Pita the same advice Kulmohan?? A Singh has tried to rub the Khalsa's nose in past events. So what if we did not succeed? The reason was we did not have Guru Sahib's full kirpa. Does that mean we will stop now? How many hundreds of years were Muslims beaten and how many battles did they lose? Did they give up? So why should we? >>>>>> I urge you to give up the demand for Raaj and buy lasting peace if not for the reasons cited above ,then for the sake of gurbani - because Gurbani shows the way "Raaj na chahon, mukat na chaahon ........" >>>>>> The Panth will not sell its "zameer" for the sake of this false "peace". The Sikhs of Delhi and other cities bought into your "peace" ideal and didn't have any weapons. They forgot Dashmesh jee's orders to always be armed. And look how they were slaughtered and beaten. The day a Sikh accepts slavery in return for "peace" is the day that Sikh's conscience has died and he is no better than a walking corpse. Khalsa jee will continue to struggle for freedom and Khalsa Raj. Khalsa jee's naam da khanda will continue to rattle along with the sarbloh khanda in thier hands. The spirit of sacrifice will never finish. Those cowards who are afraid of this can go hide in their holes in the ground. We don't need you and your advice is NOT welcome. [gurbani]EVk duSt-dmn dsmyS gurU dw dulwrw pMQ swirAW dI bKIey aDyV dyvygw[ Drm dw Kwls hlymI rwj hovygw, koeI duSt mlyC AwkI nhI rhygw[[/gurbani]Bhopinder Singh · 14 Jun 2005
it is the person that has no greed or desire to rule who deserves to rule the most? good point at he ran may tab joojh maroo or shall i say at he ran may jaan save karn da upae karoo kulmohan and a singh are GANGU brahmin as he gave the same argument to mata gujri ji he said i was loyal to you when you were strong now the situation has changed and i can make money and save my life and may be if time come be a moghul but a rich one.These are not sikhs i am sure about that.Panthic parkarsh · 14 Jun 2005
again... Sadh Sanghat jee, Please correct me if i'm wrong, but was this line," raj karega Khalsa' is written in the panthic parkash granth? this was never written by our beloved Guru's? Could someone please enlighten us on this.... Also, Balpreet Singh ji, you said... "A Singh has tried to rub the Khalsa's nose in past events. So what if we did not succeed? The reason was we did not have Guru Sahib's full kirpa. Does that mean we will stop now? How many hundreds of years were Muslims beaten and how many battles did they lose? Did they give up? So why should we?" Don't get too protective when another fellow brother/sister actually states some hard facts...Sikhs have not been able to unite in the past. Maharaja Ranjit Singh did not collectively bring the misels together; they were FORCED together (with the majority of the misels rubbing there hands, awaiting the right time to take revenge.) When will we have Guru Ji's full kirpa? What the Muslims had Mohammed's full kirpa that’s why they expanded there geographical area and religion? What the Christians had Jesus’ full kirpa even when Jesus apparently said, no violence, and to turn the other cheek? If and when Sikhs become rules of a land/dominion...trust me that land will not resemble what our Beloved guru's would have wanted for us...Our current takht’ s are a good example to go by...look at the state of the people running/ruling them... Lets not judge others so easily.... fanatical thinking is what it is...NARROW! Gurfateh,HARJ · 14 Jun 2005
kulmohan kumaR !!! WHY IS HALEMI RAJJ AND BEGUMPURA RAJJ STATED IN GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI ? [%sig%]JAX · 14 Jun 2005
THE FOUNDATIONS OF KHALISTAN WERE SET IN THE BLOOD OF THOSANDS OF SIKHS AT DARBAR SAHIB THE DAY INDIAN GOVT ATTACKED!!! TO SAY BAN THE WORD KHALISTAN AND RAJ KAREGA KHALSA WOULD BE THE BIGGEST COWDLY ACT ONE COULD IMAGINE !! KULMOHAN MUST HAD READ UP ON RSS, CONGRESS STUFF [%sig%]Balpreet Singh · 14 Jun 2005
"panthic parkarsh", Raj Karaegaa Khalsa is written by Bhai Nand Lal and has been read by the Panth for hundreds of years. Khalsa when it follows Guru Gobind Singh jee's rehit will have Guru Sahib's kirpa. Then we will see Khalsa's Halemi Raj. We don't need your dehndi kala comments trying to say that Khalsa cannot rule. You are a mouthpiece of the enemies of the Panth. You in the garb of a Sikh are trying to convince the Sikhs that we are not worthy of rule and are fit only for slavery. No. Guru Sahib's Khalsa is meant to rule the world. [gurbani]sRI gurU rwju Aibclu Atlu Awid puriK PurmwieE ]7][/gurbani] Vahiguru himself has given Satguru Nanak the right of eternal rule. When we become proper Sikhs of Guru Nanak, there is no doubt that Vahiguru will give that rule to us.Hari Singh · 14 Jun 2005
Please consider that as far as Raaj went ... whenever Sikhs had control the general population had nothing to fear... infact even during the days that Singhs lived in Jungles the general population sympathized with the Sikhs. Why wouldn't they? Singhs were the only ones with enough valor to rescue their daughters and wives from the hands of moghuls. Secondly, Muslims have committed great atrocities all over the world and their rule was through forceful conversions... something Sikhs don't belive in... Christians also had the crusades and the Catholic church has deep roots tying it to a lot of the significant cultural/social movements in the European history. So its clear why their are so many chrisitians.. But try and find an example where Sikhs have ever went to war to convert others or to force Sikhism onto others... you won't find a single example. Sikhs suffered through 2 ghallugharas and have always been under attack from Fanatical Hindu/muslim groups and have yet to use the same malicious and cowardly tactics that others have used. Your talking about Khalsa Raaj? Ofcouse it will happen ... Sikhs have shown greater strength of character then any other people. But... we must live up to hukam of our gurus "Jab lag Khalsa rahe NIARA... tab lag tej dio mai sara..." we've lost our niara pan and so we've lost guru sahib's kirpa.daas · 14 Jun 2005
there is no question of IF the question is WHEN the khalsa will rule the world and even that is not a question it is only an unknown to us but it is written by akaal purakh guru gobind singh sahib jee has told bhai nand lal jee directly it is a mukhvaak of guru jee and bhai nand lal jee has written it in his vaars raaj KAREGA khalsa KAREGA WILL & WILL ALWAYS. KHALSA WILL & WILL ALWAYS rule the world. in fact we are KINGS in beggers quarters right now. we ARE the masters of this land, we are just in shackles. a lion in chains is STILL a lion.JAX · 14 Jun 2005
i bet kulmohan kumar will say take the kirpan out of the 5 k's next !! and wear a piece of thread [%sig%].... · 14 Jun 2005
at the time islam started it faced hostility from pagans and arabs. Maybe balpreet singh ji was just talking about the spirit of keep on fighting against oppression. The same fighting spirit was found in punjab when islam came to the land of five rivers. Uprisings that lasted many hundreds of years continued against turkoh fauja and moghuls. One movement was crushed then another arose. It fell down then came another. One such was the gallant bravery of the khokkar fauja who gathered to wipe ghori out by taking his sehr off in battle and give his fauj a knocking. Although now majority muslim these khokkar fauja managed to at least fight back and show the world some spirit in the face of tyrrany. Punjab itself has a very brave history of resisting . There is a lot more to the spread of christianity than history books acknowledge. Ie, major churches were placed on existing pagan sites around universal magnetic energy grid crossing points called "ley lines" which is similar to meridian points on acupuncture. Secret european societies operated to manipulate christianity towards greater control ie solar knights templers,illuminati etc. A lot of ancient knowledge existed outside what we have been told is christianity. This in no way means christians are just power thirsty. It just means you get people who want power, some who want simple spiritual lives, but a clear defining difference between the two. Same goes for judaism, the aggressive political zion agenda is completly hostile towards jews yet jews end up having to suffer because of zionist policies. But in both christians and jews at least seperate entities exist who seek to control, so it is not the religion itself, or the system of religion that creates weak people, rather entities obsessed with power while religious minded people carry on. If ordinary truly spiritual people from christians or jews were given the chance to rule perhaps we would not have seen so much bloodshed in history. we pick up history books in schools and actually blame sword weilding christian crusades we dont acknolwedge who or what was behind these crusades ie solar knights templer society or how they may have manipulated people into fear similar to the fears of society right now post sep 11.They most likely had no control over politics but were manipulated by entities within them. Muslim raj blatently messed up but again most of these punishments, penal codes, are linked to the 3 caliphs (themselves worldly kings). On this earth there are those obsessed with rule and those who are subjective to it. Those obsessed with power have no love for another human being their objective is solely to rule whatever the process. Such people are geared up with knowledge and skills using a lot of mind trickery, they eventually become kings. Once they become kings, they have a bigger job to hold onto kingship by managing people. They cannot afford dissent or true democracy it means they will gamble their power. They will use every trick in the book to hold onto this power, which can involve propaganda via phycology games, percieved fears, oppression, supressing humans of their natural energy levels, distorting truths, etc. Then the rule enters the despot phase where murder can be justuified, where the enemy appears much larger and greater thus propelling the masses into thinking they are under threat, hence the leader offering a solution to wipe the problem out by wiping a set of people out, slandering them, terrorising them. The world has been soaked in rivers of blood time after time for such selfish people. Sikhi does not permit this, and yes its possible we can have dodgy elements within sikhi, but the whole sikh system is based on democracy , power share, and republican ideals if followed correctly. Sikhs themselves should be leaders of their own destiny, panj pyarey guide in matters related. But this can only happen if sikhs choose to follow sikhi closely to what Guru sahibs ordain. I am afraid sometimes we are hijacked by very dodgy people, but by and large when and where oppression shows its face it is the ordinary simple folk who begin to rise up with their spiritual shakti having already prepared their path towards a higher goal. These dodgy leaders may appear in the light to have outlived the simple folks shaheedia, but their life breaths are very limited they are not invincible and will be held to account when they depart while the sacrifices of true simple folk not only stand out, they inspire others towards greater heights, they make sikhs more weary of dodgy elements around us so we only listen to Guru sahib and not some dodgy leader claiming everyody is an agent. A true sikh will rule after sticking on the path of gurmat. [%sig%]JARNAIL SINGH GYANI "ARSHI" · 14 Jun 2005
Khalistan is our BIRTHRIGHT. NO TWO WAYS about it. I am ashamed that there are so called "singhs" on this Forum who are trying to pin their own cowardice on to Guru har rai Ji and Guru har Krishan Ji. In their haste they even forget that Guru har rai Ji had a well equipped Army of Soldiers ever ready to fight..and if they didnt fight it was not due to cowardice or retreating from the concept of Miri-Piri BUT strategic reasons of conserving their strength and making preparations etc. A KHALSA is NEVER to be SUBSERVIENT..except to WAHEGURU. WE also DONT GRAB, DONT CONQUER, DONT COVERT...what is other's..We ONLY TAKE WHAT IS OURS BY BIRTH RIGHT..and the Khalsa will NEVER give up that RIGHT. A Sikh who is NOT a KHALISTANI is NOT a SIKH...declared Prof darshan Singh Jathedar Akal Takhat and i wholeheartedly agree. Mnay thanks to the many good repleis given especially by Bhopinder Singh. Dhendi kalla dhillarrs must be made aware that not every Sikh is like them.ssingh0 · 14 Jun 2005
some good posts here in response , but just as a heads up, the OP has trolled on another board, just don't want to see that repated herekulmohan Kumar · 14 Jun 2005
Many Thanks my Veeron. I am much pleased, specially with my new name Kulmohan Kumar. To tell you the truth, I am absolutely in love with it. Infact when I die and am having Lekha-Jokha with the Dharam raaj, I will very proudly present my credentials as a Gursikh who takes proud in being identified as a Hindu. pyaareon wait before you plunge ....... I am sure Dharam raaj would be pleased and pardonsome to meet somebody who has learnt rather too well, the lessons of "hindu wadda na musalmanoi......." and "Na ko bairi nahi begana , sagal sang hum ko ban aayi......" As far as my tagging of a "coward" goes, well I humbly accept it because my Kartapurakh hasn't made everybody equally brave. "Coward" is my true identification, and thanks for that. (Other than "cowardice" my personality also has shades of "anti-bloodshed" and "anti-pain", may be they will get noticed next time) Jai Ram ji ki, Kulmohan Kumar "Kaon ko kalank rahyo raam naam leit hi, patit pavit bhayey raam kehat hi.........". · 15 Jun 2005
the riotous mobs were satanic people . It is not khalsa raj that irks delhi riot victims, for their families were murdered in cold blood for no valid reason by shaitani political extremists motivated by hatred and jelousy for "sardars". When someone kills your dad and they do not even know them for no reason , how would you feel? please clarify what khalsa raj has to do with it? I have met delhi riot victims mums n dads who lost their sons yes they are bitter at sikhs and politicians because they were forgotten and given no justice in "free india" the land of "free democracy". They are bitter at these dgpc presidents for being cosher with tytler and sajan. Most of all they have had no justice in indian courts. It is the rioters who took the life away of sikhs therefore full responsibility on their shoulders. However being a morally bankrupt lot i doubt they care. So sikhs are supposed to be raped killed and remain low? kulmohan >>> without miri piri sikhism is nothing almost close to what it is now in india. islam christianity even hindus had their miri piri. So why cant sikhs have theirs? more importantly why do you feel upset at sikhs having miri piri?Blackblueandorange Singh · 15 Jun 2005
'' RAJJ BINA NAHIN DHRAM JALE HAIN DHRAM BINA SAB DALE MALE HAIN '' wheres this from??????????????????????????????????????????????????????A Singh · 15 Jun 2005
The comments above are a very good example of what happens when "Sikhs" today get caught up in their emotions. I have no where denied the right to self-determination, simply given, as only one Veer out of all those on this thread was able to "read" and "understand" clearly, examples of what in the past has happened time and time again preventing this from occuring -i.e. We NEED to learn from our past, that's what's it's there for... ...instead, people see fit to lump with Kulmohan's views on the Kirpan, which I have clearly spoken against and explained in full, in fact twice that we are Khalsa, Knights of Akal Purukh, and hence being armed is essential... ...but what happens here: 1. I'm called "Gangu Brahmin" for NO VALID REASON whatsoever 2. Referred to as 'weak' WHY??? Because you're weak minds can't handle the truth??? HELLOO!!!! I'm not opposing the end goal, simply questioning the method by which to get there... ...of course, people will now, as we can see on other threads, suggest we should move away from historical texts and concentrate on Simran, fine, you do that and again repeat history again and again and again...a fine step towards the self-determination we all desire no doubt! Gur Fateh! Amar "Singh"Panthic parkarsh · 15 Jun 2005
General comment.... I was very pleased with the responses to my question re. "Raj karega Khalsa"...but I still feel that it is a DREAM that we Sikhs are living (yes, go ahead and write want you have too). When Guru's Ji's Hukham, there Rehit, there Philosophy is not understood. IMHO I am not and have never been a advocate of khalistan, in the physical sense, as promoted by the 1980's movement... but can proudly say that I am an advocate of the 'Pureland' (khalistan) When, and only WHEN it is the right time, and when WE are ready for it....as per Guru Ji's hukham, not some wannabee leader(s) I know some of you may say that we must start preparing for it, or should have started a long time ago, or even still, that our beloved Guru's actually placed the foundation stone of it...and to the last example I would agree, but here is my personal angle on this: Which physical land will you claim to be yours...Punjab, Northern India, India...? Will the ruling party/people hand this land over to you, no questions asked? We can only prepare for the future based upon our history (Balpreet Singh) and please give me a example, even after one/two decades after our beloved Siri Guru Gobind Singh Ji departed from this earth, of Sikhs being able to REALLY take full control of there destiny and promote Sikhism, and then to succeed.... yes I know, exactly...no such time exists...(don't shoot the messenger!) Then how are we to plan our beloved khalistan? It’s an old saying but, " **** always floats to the top" and this will continue with regards to our leaders.... (Lets not forget the lesson of the masands, at the time of our Guru's...) The Pureland, which we as Sikhs will not ‘snatch’ from anyone, as we do not believe in aggression/converting, can only, fall at our feet, after some natural disaster/nuclear war! (Guru ji's kirpa some may call it!) Have you people actually thought that the slavery that we profess to be in is because of our attitudes? Have you thought that maybe the Khalsa Raj that Bhai Nand Lal recorded is not of this world...? Gurfateh.... PS. Kulmohen brother was simply asking questions, and this is how we respond...Hmmm, the future rulers of khalistan, right...Hari Singh · 15 Jun 2005
Kulmohan Kumar, The gurbani pankti you've quoted is exactly why we need Khalsa Raaj. Because in Khalsa Raaj you will see the true application of the princples of equality and universal brotherhood which haven't been seen anywhere. Gurbani is the light that will lead the world out of Kalyug... remember "Kal taran guru Nanak aya.." and Gursikhs who walk the path of gurmat will lead the world because their hearts will beat with the loving rhythm of guru's hymns. Khalsa Raaj is about self-determination but most importantly it is about love. REmember Guru Teg Bahadur jee saved the Hindu's from being anihilated ... these are the principles that will allow Khalsa to rule. The Hindus owe a huge debt to Sikhs not only for saving their religion and women from Muslism invaders but also because Sikhs have never used the same subversive and cowardly tactics as Hindus have. Sikhs have been abused within India time and time again, and if we're to live with dignity then Khalistan is a must if others deserve to live with the same dignity then Khalsa Raaj is a must.Kulbir Singh · 15 Jun 2005
Raaj na chaahon, Mukat na chaahon, Mann Preet Charan Kamla re|| This Mahavaak does not negate the concept of Khalsa Halemi Raaj. The aforementioned Mahavaak applies to the personal life of a Sikh and does not mean that at Panthak level Sikhs cannot ask for political freedom. this Mahavaak tells the Sikh that at the high Gurmat spiritual state when the mystical Charan Kamal (lotus feet) of Vaheguru appear in one's Hirda, he (or she) is not interested in Mukti or kingdoms. Now being interested is one thing and as Balpreet Singh pointed out, getting Raaj Bhaag as per hukam of Sangat is another thing. When Nawab Kapur Singh jee was given Nawabi, he refused to accept it but at when Khalsa Panth gave him hukam to accept it, he accepted the Nawabi at the condition that he be allowed to continue his sewa in the stables of Singhs. Khalsa Raaj is such a concept that has been promoted by all great Gursikhs of the past. Mahapurakhs like Sant Attar Singh jee Mastuana, Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee and numerous others have made predictions about Khalsa Raaj. Khalsa Raaj will happen for sure. No doubt about that. All Sikhs sing "Raaj Karega Khalsa" at Gurdwaras and this verse is to fundamentalist, communal and enemies of Panth, as snakes sitting on their chest (trying to translate a Punjabi saying). It is true that during the last fight for homeland, Sikhs made many mistakes and these mistakes directly related Rehit. Sikhs did not follow Tatt Gurmat Rehit and this is why we failed in the last battle. Indiscriminate killings, unnecessary harrassments did not help. But we should not forget that most of these incidents were carried out by the intelligence agencies and partly by misled, non-rehit-keeping militants who knew nothing about Nitnem, Bibek and other rehit. Kulmohan, if you are a Kumar, then I invite you to study Sikh faith and understand that Hinduism is obsolete in Kalyug. The Hindus in Kalyug are following the Dharams and rites of Satjug, Treta Jug and Duaapar Jug. These rites and ceremonies are no longer valid in Kalyug. As per hukam of Sat Purakh Vaheguru, Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee started the Dharma of Kalyug and only after following this Dharam can you get somewhere. Come to the real Dharam and forget about obsolete Hindu Dharam. Kulmohan, in case you are from a Sikh family, I ask you to realise that you are a lion and not a lamb. Currently you seem to be hanging out with lambs and have started thinking of yourself a lamb. Once you look inside and realise that you are a lion, you will never hang out with lambs but will find lions to hang out with. Then you will never oppose Lion-land and will never support Lamb-lang. Daas, Kulbir SinghSikhi · 15 Jun 2005
Sat Sri Akaal, "They talk about peace, but I first want Justice! Then we can talk about peace!" The Sikhs should think bout this. There will be peace if we get our own Raj aka Khalistan. How can you live in peace when there is so much injustice around you? Sikhs ar no Buddists!!!Blackblueandorange Singh · 15 Jun 2005
'' RAJJ BINA NAHIN DHRAM JALE HAIN DHRAM BINA SAB DALE MALE HAIN '' i dont beleive these are the words of guru ji i believe in khalsa raaj i do not believe in khalistan where is the above quote from????Hari Singh · 15 Jun 2005
This is why we need Khalistan: http://tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=39535&t=39535Blackblueandorange Singh · 15 Jun 2005
i dnt want to be fed with your brainwashing techniques, just answer my question. we need to fight for justice, when sikhs in past were oppressed by muslims the Gurus faught for justice, to uproot tyranny...........fighting for a country was never mentioned, nor was the concept of khalistan. although muslims were trying absolutley everything to convert sikhs. i dont believe it is part of our religion to fight for a country. in time sikhi will spread across the whole world - RAJ KARE GA KHALSA ANYWAY I DONT WISH TO DISCUSS, IM SET IN MY VIEWS ALL I WANT TO KNOW IS WHERE THAT QUOTE CAME FROM- RAJJ BINA NAHIN DHRAM JALE HAIN DHRAM BINA SAB DALE MALE HAIN ''Jax · 15 Jun 2005
WHEN HINDUSTAN POPPED OUT FOR HINDUS ! PAKISTAN FOR MUSLIMS !! WHY SHOULD SIKHS BE LEFT OUT AND NOT HAVE KHALISTAN !!! WE ARE ALSO A NATION ! ' NA HUM HINDU NA MUSALMAN ' [%sig%]Panthic parkarsh · 15 Jun 2005
Blackblueandorange Singh Ji, Most of these so-called quotes are not by our bleoved guru's but by sanghat members of our Guru's or sikhs after our guru's (panthic parkash..) which basucally means they are irrelevent..... Sikhi has a long way to go....i myself had always thought that we as a people were truly the chosen ones, that somehow sikhi was the greatest path, the fact remains that sikhi is about YOU and GURU JI, no one else......on this level it can be beautiful, but as an organisation, we currently stink....hatred for each other, no tolerance for differeing views, my jatha is better than yours, people following sants, sants committing the worst crimes/acts against our sisters..the list goes on. IMHOshan e punjab · 16 Jun 2005
but u gotto admit it would be a lot easier to be a sikh in a sikh place huna? wel have problems like corruption likely intitial stages but surely thats gotto be better than goin through more 84s 47s or post sep 11 trauma across the world or racism that puts a screen over the ceiling for most sikhs meaning we are forced to push ourselves 2 times harder than a white person . If we had a chance to be independant that would mean we could give our childrens a better tomorow. if sikhism is allowed to grow then i believe even the corrupt will be challanged in one point by singhs.. Or the corrupt bora will be against the proper singh bora with the victory of the singh bora based on popular demand. Without bigging up sant jarnail singh bhindrawale, or any past sikh sikhism have been stopped from growing by govs. So even if we had a corrupt gov that gov would not be able to put down the growth of sikhi, whereas external regimes have no shame in killing sikhs. If that gov tried anything sikhism would be on a much stronger platform to fight back. why would anyone be against a khalsa raj? surely you are aware the british needed brahmins after 47 because they were the most pro sarkari boot licks. Upon choosing them, overnight the assets holdings and large bussiness agricultural houses dropped depreciated by over 60%. This was for "cheap trade" exchange with british empire. So in a way the british raj still exists in economic form. Bit by bit not just sikhs by all desis have been turned into slaves, now we have to leave everything come to a foreigtn place and have our sikhi attacked. So why not have a sikh raj where none of this woul dhappen? wheere would be free to live as a sikh, hold our heads up, give our nyaney a good start, no more bullying,, no more bin ladfen taunts or attacking, racism, no more rapes in delhi, no more killings no more sardar jokes. Sikhi back to its rightful place with pride and respect. We need physical power without that we got jack all but to balance that with spiritualism so we are not talibanis as most will accuse sikhs.Kabaddi Singh · 16 Jun 2005
Khalistan Zindabadh--- · 16 Jun 2005
This dates back to the years before 84 probably sometime in 82 or 83. At that time I was a child of around 6-7 years. One day a young sadhu came to our gates. My mother gave me a 10 paise coin and asked me to give it to him. I ran to the door and saw that sadhu turning away. I called him from behind and he turned back I threw the coin unto him. The coin fell down on the road. He left the coin and was walking off. I got angry and shouted at him to pick that coin. He came back and picked the coin, while he was picking the coin, another develish thought stuck me and I told him that he was "bhookha" (a greedy guy), as he was picking up a "giri hui cheez". He got angry with me and told me that I was nobody to teach him. The two of us started fighting. I should admit that I was the nastier and more cunning amongst the two of us. I was bubbling with anger. I was hurling abuses of the kind that he was bad because he was a sadhu. The sadhu on his part was more balanced and he would say one good thing and follow it with an abusive thing. This Sadhu was equiped with riddhi-sidhiis and inbetween our fight he would tell what I was thinking. He could tell rightly that there was a feeling of extremely strong uneasiness going inside me. For the stupid boy of 6-7 that I was, I was given to think of stupid fanatasies about the clothes of girls who don't sing the prayers the time of school morning assembly. This sadhu by virtue of his riddhi-sidhiis as aware of that. He asked me to behave or otherwise he would tell my mother of what I am thinking during the everyday morning assembly. During our fight, he kept on repeating one thing that I should tell him what I had heard about the sadhus in the gurudwara. I would keep quite on this point but abused him left and right on other things. He then told me that I was being that stubborn, because I was believing in the things that I heard in the gurudwara.I told him yes thats true and all that they speak in the gurudwara is true once again. He then told me that gurudwaras is the place where the most "ninda" of others is being done. He said that talks of people of other religions being fools etc are too common in gurudwaras. He said, you the sikhs don't give regards to other people. He said that you sikhs will never realise that this life is just a game. He narratted his story that he was born into a sikh family in haryana, he used to frequent the gurudwaras on a daily basis. Till some rich and influential guys (sikh guys) raped his sister. After that he was devastated he left his home and didn't find peace anywhere till he reached the company of some sadhus. What he said after that is devastating. He said that he hadn't been able to find peace wherever he went but lastly he found peace only in the company of sadhus - he told me that I was snatching his peace away. He also said that I was doing this to him because I had heard bad mouthing about the sadhus in a gurudwara. He asked me to tell him the name of the speaker who spoke those words. By this time I was frieghtend but seeing the extent of his anger I refused, he said OK tell me the initial letter with which his name starts, I asked him will you kill that person (the gurudwara pradhaan, who in his lecture of gurbani had said the sadhus were bad people and used ridhi-sidhiis for wrong reasons). He then said OK no need to tell him anything - thousands of gurudwaras will be burnt, you people (sikhs) will die in thousands and continued hurling the abuses like that. Hearing all this I started crying and asked him if all that he said was because of me being nasty to him. He was pacified and then he started sympathising with me - He told me that he hadn't said anything from his side, but he had only said this because he was caught into riddhi-sidhii and could forsee the future. And that future of then is the dark past of today.A Singh · 16 Jun 2005
shan e punjab, Yes, they were sakari bootlickers, but what about all the Sikh soldiers during the raj? And those during the period described above when Baba Banda Singh had a real possibility of securing a Sikh Kingdom in Punjab? And similarly with the period during the 1980s and the Akali-Congress splits and the impact it had on dividing Sikh political sentiments and eventually Sikhs themselves?Kulbir Singh · 16 Jun 2005
This story of the saadhoo is a very interesting one. I don’t know what to make out of it. It seems like the Saadhoo said that Sikhs would suffer in great numbers because of the wrong practices going on in the Gurdwaras. Well, to some extent he is right that we have been punished because we left Gurmat but his assertion that Saadhu sect is better than Khalsa Dharam and that there is more peace in his sect is based on ignorance. He probably was never exposed to Gurbani. Kulbir SinghUK Nihang Singh · 16 Jun 2005
This is way we need Khalsa Raj http://tapoban.org/phorum/read.php?f=1&i=40978&t=40978Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 18 Jun 2005
the "sadhoo" story seems more like a hype for the all important "sadhu/sant"...needed to guide us towards GURU JI...as IF GURU JI Himself is incapable of this...another "scare tactic"....SALAAM to sadhusant or..Your Gurdwaras will be destroyed..!!! makes me laugh.--- · 20 Jun 2005
********************* JSGA said : the "sadhoo" story seems more like a hype for .... ********************* It is not a hype, only if it were you in place of me. ********************* JSGA said : "SALAAM to sadhusant.." ********************* I never meant that. You made up that lesson out of the story yourself. I would rather say "should never have met that sadhoo whom I did as a child and am since repenting" The lesson I drew for myself from this happening was " to not do or listen to the ninda of others in gurudwara "singhsation · 20 Jun 2005
does anyone have information on the 23rd prophecy with a total of 24, involving some jewish belief of the saviour not being jesus. its something a brother mentioned in another fourm.singhsation · 20 Jun 2005
^if something of that nature was to occur wouldnt that be khalsa raj right therekulmohan_kumar_singh · 20 Jun 2005
Bhai Sahib Kulbir singh ji, You have given me two different lessons - first one to apply if I am a Hindu and the second one If i am a Sikh ( or probably vice-versae) Guru sahib ji says "Khatri bahman shudra vaish Updesh chau varnan ko saanjha " Pardon me, but this duality of seeing a hindu as different from a sikh is the result of us moving away from the gurmat. Gurbani tells us in many verses that we should see all with similar and equal regards. "Manas ki jaat sabhey eikai pehchanbo..." "Awal allah noor upaya kudrat key sabh bandey.. eik noor teh sabh jag upjeya kaun bhaley ko mandey.." "Ghat ghat mein Harjo basein..." "Ekai Ekai toon raaya........" "Hindu wada na musalmanoi..." "Eik purab main tera dekhya toon sabhna mahein ravanta... "Kulbir Singh · 20 Jun 2005
Kulmohan, ---------------- first one to apply if I am a Hindu and the second one If i am a Sikh ( or probably vice-versae) Guru sahib ji says "Khatri bahman shudra vaish Updesh chau varnan ko saanjha " Pardon me, but this duality of seeing a hindu as different from a sikh is the result of us moving away from the gurmat. Gurbani tells us in many verses that we should see all with similar and equal regards. ------------------ You should read what I wrote and then tell me what was wrong with writing separate lessons for Sikhs and Hindus. Below I reproduce what I wrote earlier in this thread: Kulmohan, if you are a Kumar, then I invite you to study Sikh faith and understand that Hinduism is obsolete in Kalyug. The Hindus in Kalyug are following the Dharams and rites of Satjug, Treta Jug and Duaapar Jug. These rites and ceremonies are no longer valid in Kalyug. As per hukam of Sat Purakh Vaheguru, Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee started the Dharma of Kalyug and only after following this Dharam can you get somewhere. Come to the real Dharam and forget about obsolete Hindu Dharam. Kulmohan, in case you are from a Sikh family, I ask you to realise that you are a lion and not a lamb. Currently you seem to be hanging out with lambs and have started thinking of yourself a lamb. Once you look inside and realise that you are a lion, you will never hang out with lambs but will find lions to hang out with. Then you will never oppose Lion-land and will never support Lamb-land. And as for the Gurbani pankities you wrote, none of them applies to our situation. Seeing everyone with one eye does not mean that we cannot preach Gurmat Dharam i.e. the Sikh faith to lost people. Daas, Kulbir SinghStraight Arrow · 20 Jun 2005
<> Kulbir Singh Ji - Why this hatred of the Hindu religion? OK, may be hatred is a strong term. Why this dismissal of the Hindu religion? There are 540 million Hindus in this world (Bhopinder Singh Ji corrected me earlier when I had said that there were 700 million Hindus - 160 million are dalits and "apparently" do not follow the Hindu religion - Data source www.nationalgeographic.com) are you saying they are all following an obsolete religion? I have been studying the Sikh faith and I think it is great but at no point do I think that Hinduism is obsolete. Sure, with changing times, several things do not apply but that would be the same with every religion. Some thing that Christ said 2000 years ago might not be applicable in the modern world but the essence still holds. Similarly, the interpretation of the Ramayan will be different in todays world than when it was written but it is so strong that grown men are moved to tears when they hear of Bharat's sacrifice etc. Anyway, I'm not hear to give a sermon, all I wanted to do was to inject some objectivity into this blind Hindu Bashing. Bhool Chhok Maaf.Hari Singh · 20 Jun 2005
Straing Arrow jee, All Kulbir Singh said was that Hinduism is not the religion for Kalyug. It has no application in Kalyug. Please try to define what a Hindu is ... you can spend as long as you like but will never come up with a definition. This in itself proves that the religion is obsolete and the actual practice of Hinduism is a collection of various rites and rituals which have no application in Kalyug. All that is left of the once great religion of Satyuga is the empty and ritualistic worship of idols. The vedas and puranas have great knowledge contained within them but they can not guide one in Kalyug. How does the religion promote unity with God...? What does one have to do to get a union with the almight? What is the way ... the path? Which mantra does one meditate on? And how does one do it while living in society? How does one rid themselves of ahankar? I mean no offence and have simply stated the truth as I see it. Hari SinghStraight Arrow · 20 Jun 2005
Hari Singh Ji - No offence taken. Infact, these are the kinds of debates that we should have. Totally objective. Let me tackle your points once by one. Empty and ritualistic worship of Idols - yes, it is true that we worship idols, however, since when did this make a religion "empty"? Other religions promote the same thing. Christians have their cross and in every church, you will seeChrists pictures and idols everywhere. The jews have a wailing wall. Nothing but praying to wall. Sikhs have pictures of Guru Nanak Dev Ji Maharaj and Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj in Gurdwaras and in their homes. Buddhists have idols of Lord Buddha in their homes. Also, we believe in the concept of "Kan Kan mein Bhagwan" (Lord dwells everywhere) so if you look at the other side of the coin, you could easily say that we look at God even in a stone See this subtlety - Idols are not mere stones to us. Just a different point of view. As for unity with the Almighty. I can't talk about everyone but I can tell you what I do. Naam simran. I chant the name of "Ram", as often as I can and I can tell you, it is bliss. I'm not saying my path is perfect, I'm just telling you what works for me. What is the path? Well, that is the greatness - Hinduism is flexible. You can become one with Ram, Krishna, Shiv, Durga etc. You learn qualities that are virtually non-existent in today's world. Ram - Discipline, listening to your parents, Krishna - Loving everybody, Shiv - Supreme sacrifice, Durga - courage etc. Like i said, you need to "see" which is what we do. So what seems ritualistic to someone who is not well versed in Hiduism, is a way of life to us because we understand the subtleties and the symbolism in which the religion is steeped in. Again, I am not saying that there are no problems with Hinduism - there are plenty (Casteism being the main one) but it works for me and several million others. Hope that answers some of your questions. Bhool Chook maaf.Kulbir Singh · 20 Jun 2005
“Straight Arrow jeeo, You have misunderstood my post. I have no hatred for the Hindu Religion. As the matter of fact, I have great respect for the religious texts of Hindus and consider the Hindu religious texts superior to all religious books except for Sikh scriptures. -------------- Kulbir Singh Ji - Why this hatred of the Hindu religion? OK, may be hatred is a strong term. Why this dismissal of the Hindu religion? There are 540 million Hindus in this world -------------- Quantity is not important. Just because there are close to 2 billions Christians does not mean that this faith is a true faith. Quantity does not have any meaning. What I said about the Hindu religion was that the rituals and practices of Hindu faith are that of previous jugs and these are no longer valid in Kalyug – the dark age. To some extent some Hindu sects like that of Chataniya Mahaprabhu are somewhat closer to the Dharam of Kalyug but they too are not fully capable of functioning in Kalyug because of absence of Satnaam i.e. the true Naam. All Hindus are destined to become Sikhs and they will surely become Sikhs one day. The day will come and will come very soon. All those places in India where Guru Sahib did parchaar will not go in vain. How can Bihar and Assam not become Sikh when Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee, Siri Guru Tegh Bahadur Sahib jee and Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee spent time there to do parchaar. At one time, a substantial part of Bihar and Assam was Sikh. --------------- Sure, with changing times, several things do not apply but that would be the same with every religion. Some thing that Christ said 2000 years ago might not be applicable in the modern world but the essence still holds. -------------- What Christ said and did not say is not clear. None of his teachings were written by him and Bible was composed many decades after him and as such is not an authentic book of Jesus. There are great statements of wisdom in Bible but it is not a book of God. ------------ Similarly, the interpretation of the Ramayan will be different in todays world than when it was written but it is so strong that grown men are moved to tears when they hear of Bharat's sacrifice etc. ------------- No doubt that the high morals that Bharat and others in Ramayan age had are something we must strive to have. Bharat’s sacrifice, devotion and morality is unmatched. Bharat did not accept the kingdom even though he was given the kingdom by his father. Laxman let go his pleasures of youth to be with his brother Raam. Sita gave the comforts of palace to be with her husband. Great morals Ramayan Yug (Treta Yug) had but we should not forget that the Dharma of Tretha and Duapar is not valid in Kalyug anymore. In Kalyug the age has been greatly reduced and there is an epidemic of evil. The atmosphere is totally contrary to doing Bhagti. In this atmosphere only the true Guru can save us and that true Guru is none other than Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj. The biggest sanctuary in Kalyug is Amrit Baani of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. Read it, japp it, recite it, sing it, ponder it, simar it, urthaar it, Raman it, and again and again utter it. It brings amrit on the tongue. It washes away one’s sins. The great problems that we face disappear in front of Baani. The great achievements that we long for come to Gursikhs who recite baani without much effort. Kulbir SinghStraight Arrow · 20 Jun 2005
Kulbir Singh Paaji - I am very impressed with your knowledge and I am also very impressed by Sikhi. I think I mentioned somewhere that I go to the Phoenix Gurdwara every sunday and the spiritual upliftment is great. I want to be a Hindu who follows the tenets of Sikhism. Is that a paradox? To be both a Hindu and a Sikh? I mean I have read in several posts that wearing a turban does not mean that the person is a Gursikh but you become a Gursikh only when you follow the principles laid down by the Great Gurus. If so, I think it is possible for me to live like a Hindu and think like a Gursikh. Thank you.Kulbir Singh · 20 Jun 2005
Straight Arrow, -------------- I want to be a Hindu who follows the tenets of Sikhism. Is that a paradox? To be both a Hindu and a Sikh? I mean I have read in several posts that wearing a turban does not mean that the person is a Gursikh but you become a Gursikh only when you follow the principles laid down by the Great Gurus. If so, I think it is possible for me to live like a Hindu and think like a Gursikh. ------------- As per the Sikh Rehit Maryada, to be a Sikh one must do the following 5 things: 1) Believe in one almight God – Akal Purakh. 2) Believe in 10 Guru Sahibaan. 3) Believe in Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee 4) Take Amrit of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee 5) To not believe in any other deity than ‘1’, ‘2’, and ‘’ If you currently have faith in Siri Krishna, but you also want to be a Sikh, there is a way to get around it. According to Gurbani, for a Sikh, Guru alone is Brahma, Vishnu, Mahesh (Shiv jee) and Devi. If you come to the protection (sharan) of Siri Guru jee, you will automatically get the khushi of your present deity too because in the worship of Guru, all worships get included. A Pandit in Patna Sahib was a worhipper of Raam Chander jee and at the same time he felt attracted towards Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee too. He in his mind worshipped Siri Raam Chander jee and one day, Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee met him at Patna Sahib. Siri Guru jee was only 5-6 years old at that time. The pandit was surprised to see that in the darshan of Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj, he got darshan of Siri Raam Chander jee. From that day he became a bhagat. If you want to be a true Hindu, you can do so only if you follow the Sikh faith. In the 9th ashtpadi of Siri Sukhmani Sahib, Siri Guru jee have written extensively that a true Pandit is that person who does simran of true Naam. This true Naam can be obtained only if one adopts the true Guru as his Guru. One can adopt the true Guru as his Guru only if one takes Amrit. One can take amrit only if one grows hair, and promises to follow the tenets of Sikhi. As I wrote before, Hindus in India are destined to become Sikhs. A lot of Gurbani is dedicated to preaching Hindus. All this preaching of Sachee Baani cannot go in vain. The Hindus will heed to it and make their lives successful by adopting the true faith – Sikh faith. Only then India will see Raam Raaj. True Raam Raaj will come only if pure Khalsa rules India. Kulbir SinghStraight Arrow · 20 Jun 2005
Waah! Very nice Kulbir Paaji. Thank you. BTW, can you please tell me what city are based at? Don't worry, I will not come to your house ;-))PS · 20 Jun 2005
Kulbir Singh In the Kali-Santaran Upanishad it is stated Harer nam harer nam , harer namaiva kevalam Kalau nasty eva , nasty eva , nasty eva gatir anyatha. Which translates as: In this age of quarrel and hypocrisy [Kali-Yuga] the only means of deliverance is chanting the holy name of the Lord . There is no other way , there is no other way , there is no other way [%sig%]Roopkaur · 20 Jun 2005
Although I agree with the above post, about Sikhism as the dharm and path for kalyug, I wanted to clarify one thing. Straight arrow said: >Sikhs have pictures of Guru Nanak Dev Ji Maharaj and Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj in Gurdwaras and in their homes.< Firstly these pictures are not necessarily a part of the religion, they were started by people who got influenced by other religions. They have no place in Sikhism. Even if they are now placed in homes and such, they are by no means worshipped. A Sikh will never bow down or worship the picture or beleive it is something holy, because it is not.Kulbir Singh · 20 Jun 2005
------ Thank you. BTW, can you please tell me what city are based at? Don't worry, I will not come to your house ;-)) ------- I live in Toronto and you are welcome to visit our home. Kulbir SinghStraight Arrow · 20 Jun 2005
Thank you Kulbir PaaJi. I am in Phoenix and in case you are ever here, we'll catch up. Just one last question - Can one bacome a Sikh without keeping kesh? I mean the other parts (giving up liquor, becoming vegetarian) are not very difficult but the only reason I ask this question is because post 9/11, these goras think that Sikhs are Muslims (due to all the images of Al-Qaeda) being beemed on Fox, CNN etc.Roopkaur · 20 Jun 2005
Straight arrow, A Sikh can never cut his hair, no matter what happens. The ill treatment we get now post 9/11 is bad, but it is nothing compared to what the SIkhs had to go through during the mughal era in India, where they were sawed in half, burnt alive, beheaded, and had their scalp taken off, but did not give up their SIkhi. If a person does any of the four bujjer kurehits, ex, cuts his or her hair, commits adultery, eats meat or drinks liquer and other drugs, they are no longer a SIkh. Hair is basically synonymous with Sikhi because without hair there is no Sikh. Hair is the mohr of Sikhi, there is no comprimising on this. Even Ram and Krishn had hair, as Krishn is also called Keshava, and Ramayan tells us that Ram braided his hair before going off into the jungle. All mahaan shakseeyats of all religions had hair, but it is only Sikhi that has not lost this reet yet because it is reinforced through the rehit maryada. [%sig%]South of Surrey · 20 Jun 2005
The meek shall inherit it all. The best jathedar is the one who has the least desire for the jathedari The best rulers are those who have the least desire to rule. Now consider the Gurbani pangti in this context. For now, all we ask for is our own little land. we're not asking for china, Swedan, Italy or Bengladesh, we're asking for our Punjab where we form a majority...that's all. If the majority of people who live in your house are your famliy members, then i guess you would want that house to be run and owned by your famliy, or do you want someone else to come and own your house?South of surrey · 20 Jun 2005
Straight arrow, Take it slow...one step at a time..the most important act being repeating Naam. As you progress, you'll be GIVEN the strength to practice more and more of Sikhi (ie. keeping kesh, doing Nitnem, taking Amrit) But it won't happen overnight. So continue to do your inner cleansing by repeating Vaheguru, and trying to practice the lifestyle as much as possible. Don't worry, someday you will have the strengh to keep hair and eventualy take amrit. Just don't give up and stop, keep moving. Sikhi is the religion of kalyug. We don't disrespect anybody, not Vishnu Brahma or Shiva...and hence, we don't disrespect avtaars of Vishnu ji like Sri Krishna and Sri Ram Chandar ji. They were sent by Parameshwar to do their duties, and they were wonderful bhagats of God. In kalyug, Parameshwar took sargun roop in the form of Guru Nanak. All rishis, munis, sadhus of the ancient times have been reborn as Sikhs....everyone who has performed well in their previous life (from all religions) are given the chance to take Amrit by being born Sikhs. (p.s. by "Sikh", i don't mean the idiots who drink, cut their hair, never do bhagati, but call themselves Sikhs).