Determinism Free Will
sikhadadaas · 02 Sep 2003
Determinism vis-a-vis Free WillOne of the most interesting and difficult problems to be found in our Scriptures, is the problem of “freedom†and “determinismâ€. Invariably question arises as to what extent we are “determined†in our empirical experience. What effect does “determinism†have upon our quest for and attainment of spiritual experience? How is “freedom†to be understood in empirical and spiritual terms? Sri Guru Granth denies that we have a “free will†over the empirical events or happenings in our life. The main factor is of the environment we are placed by God; we think and act according to the given conditions of that environment. Our brain records whatever we think and act, repetition of those ideas and actions form our habits; a compulsive situation for us to think and act in that manner. Another greatly important factor is the Nature (prakriti or Matter) on which our life is solely dependent to exist. It s the source of the three “strands†or “gunas†(Sattav, Rajas, and Tamas), which operate according to a strict causal necessity. Every one is made to act helplessly by the “gunas†born of “prakriti†or Matter. There is nothing on earth or in heaven or even among gods who is free from these three “gunasâ€, born of Matter. Only God, the Creator, Who created Matter, transcends the “gunas†of the Matter, none else. We can transcend the effect of three “gunas†of Matter (Maya), if we live with God abiding in us. These “gunas†of Matter, are present in special combinations, in all of us, and are of fundamental and involuntary sources of our actions. We qua we humans are never the real doers, but are only expression of an indifferent energetic Nature , which compels us to act in particular fashion. In short, as is our energy system, which we can never originate, but only accept. Therefore, that is the kind and quality of our actions. This is apart when we act prejudicially knowingly, on account of the pressure from powerful ones which make us act selfishly. According to the Law of Karma that every action (whether physical or mental) carries along with it determinants for future action. Each man believes in his Dharma, his order of obligations and duties , his proper place in society, which results from his past actions. We thus work within the restricted domain of or karmic based Dharma. The principles of Karma and Dharma apparently show us some element of non-deterministic choice, but it is not so, as the causal effect of God’s Will play the vital part. Whatever God Wills, such causes are created and we are led by them. Although, all Good and Evil actions takes place according to His Will, but God is immune from such blames, as we have been given separate individuality and responsibility. Man is bound up in every way, it is His Grace only that he lives with Him and accepts Him as the Doer, by completely effacing his Mind or Self. This is repeatedly taught in SGGS. We are, bound by the “gunas†of Matter, and also are bound by our past actions (habits), as this crystallizes into a law (Dharma) of our nature; and we are bound by the Will of God, Who ordains the ultimate course of events. Even Spinzoa, the great philosopher states, “we think we are free, because we are aware of our desires, but we are actually in bondage. Because we are ignorant of the causes of these desires.†Indeed we are in bondage in so far as we are empirical, phenomenal beings centered in our egos. But we can be more than empirical and phenomenal beings, if we become spiritual beings by His Grace, transcend our Self to live with the Divine within us – we shall be free persons in the real sense, which annuls bondage. If we are blessed with Freedom to transcend ourselves to live with Him by His Grace, the “strands†of our material nature can be snapped. We attain freedom from the Omnipotent Will of God of the bondage He created for us, by cooperating and in strict obedience to His Will by living with Him in Oneness. In perfect obedience to His Will, we are truly free. He, who is in perfect accord with the true nature of being is self determined; his actions arise from the fullness of his essential nature. Freedom is possible and meaningful only within the structure of Divine Nature. One is free, when one no longer has an ego centered empirical will of his own. To be an instrument of the Divine means to be rid of everything that narrows one’s nature and one’s field of action; it means to participate in, and to reflect, the Freedom of the Divine. Freedom is different in kind from bondage, it is sui generis (of its own kind). It is the ultimate quality of man who realizes himself as a spiritual being. But this entirely is dependent on His Grace. No one can claim as his right to be one with Him. It is entirely by His Grace, whom he chooses to bless to be one with Him. In Slok 35, Sehaskriti Sloks of Sri Guru Arjan Dev Ji, p 1357, it is stated, “It is not difficult to obtain Wealth and beauty. Not so to obtain the sovereignty of paradise. Not so to obtain viands and dainties, nor elegant raiment. Not so, to obtain sons, friends, brothers, and kinsmen, nor to obtain revetments of women. Not difficult to obtain accomplishment in learning, dexterity and cleverness. But it is difficult to obtain the Lord’s Name, O Nanak. It is obtained by the Lord’s Grace, in the saints society.†One has to be extremely humble and totally efface his egocentricity or self and be the dust of all. Following Compositions in Sri Guru Granth are very important to note. Please study them in their depth of the Mythical Stories of Hindu Purans, referred to in these Compositions, which are explained in detail in SRI DASAM GRANTH SAHIB. Such other references in Sri Guru Granth Sahib and in Varan of Bhai Gurdas Bhalla, are of frequent occurrence, and are most lesson giving. Parbhati M.1, page 1343 SGGS - “Ahalyaa was the wife of Gautam the seer. Seeing her, Indra* was enticed. When he received a thousand marks of disgrace on his body, then he felt regret in his mind. 1 O Siblings of Destiny, no one knowingly makes mistakes. He alone is mistaken, whom the Lord Himself makes so. He alone understands, whom the Lord causes to understand. 1 Pause Harichand**, the king and ruler of his land, did not appreciate the value of his pre-ordained destiny. If he had known that it was a mistake, he would not have made such a show of giving in charity, and he would not have been sold in the market. 2 The Lord took the form of a dwarf, and asked for some land. If Bal the king has recognized Him, he would not have been deceived, and sent to the underworld. 3 Vyaas taught and warned the king Janmejha*** not to do three things. But he performed the sacred feast and killed eighteen Brahmins; the record of one’s past deeds cannot be erased. 4 I do not try to calculate the account; I accept the Hukam of God’s Command. I speak with intuitive love and respect. No matter what happens, I will praise the Lord. It is all Your Glorious Greatness, O Lord. 5 The Gurmukh remains detached; filth never attaches itself to him. He remains forever in God’s Sanctuary. The foolish self-willed manmukh does not think of the future; he is overtaken by pain, and then he regrets. 6 The Creator who created this creation acts, and causes all to act. O Lord, egotistical pride does not depart from man. Falling into egotistical pride, one is ruined. 7 Everyone makes mistakes; only the Creator does not make mistakes. O Nanak, salvation comes through the True Name. By Guru’s Grace, one is released. 8 . 4. †*Indra god is stated to have visited the house of Rishi Gautama in his absence, in the form of a sage, to seduce the Rish’s wife Ahalyaa. But althugh Ahalyaa knew him to be Indra, she yielded to his wishes. As Indra was about to leave, Gautaama returned, and knowing what had happened, cursed Indra and his corrupt wife. It is said that a thousand disgraceful marks of female sex organ appeared on his body, that all might know the sin of which he had been guilty. Ahalyaa was doomed by the curse of her husband. ** Raja Hari Chand practiced charity and by donating greatly felt greatly proud of himself. Vishnu god took form of god Bavan, and in the guise of a dwarf Brhman asked the Raja to donate him two and a half steps of ground only from his kingdom, which request was readily granted. The dwarf god expanded his steps that he took possession of the whole of his kingdom as well as the Raj’s body and made him a slave man. Consequently, the Raja was sold as a slave in the market. *** The story of Raja Janmejha has been stated in full detail above. Sr Guru Arjan Dev Ji in Ramkali ki Var M.5, slok at p 959 states - “O you bride of deer like eyes, I tell you the truth that may emancipate you. O beauteous one, hear my glorious word that your Lord is the only Support of your mind. You are in love with the evil minded one. Pray, tell me, why have you strayed away from the Path? O friend, I was short of nothing, yea I had gathered all I could. But I lost my Glorious Friend, the God, and became unfortunate through evil advice. I did not strayed from the Path on my own. O my friend, do not blame me for this. I utter this Truth to you that in the direction my Lord yoked me, so I was yoked. She alone is the loved bride of good fortune, on whom is the Lord’s Grace. The Lord rids her of all her demerits and embellishes her truly, hugging her to His Bosom. The unfortunate bride wails: O God, when will my turn come to see You? All Your brides are enjoying with You: O God spare a night for me also.†Page 963, Ramkali ki Var, M 5, Slok (BHANA – IN GOD’S WILL) - “O Nanak, meditate on the Naam, the Name of the Lord; this is the Teaching imparted by the Perfect Guru. In the Lord's Will, they practice meditation, austerity and self-discipline; in the Lord's Will, they are released. In the Lord's Will, they are made to wander in reincarnation; in the Lord's Will, they are forgiven. In the Lord's Will, pain and pleasure are experienced; in the Lord's Will, actions are performed. In the Lord's Will, clay is fashioned into form (the type of persons are created); in the Lord's Will, His Light is infused into it. In the Lord's Will, enjoyments are enjoyed; in the Lord's Will, these enjoyments are denied. In the Lord's Will, they are incarnated in heaven and hell; in the Lord's Will, they fall to the ground. In the Lord's Will, they are committed to His devotional worship and Praise; O Nanak, how rare are these! 2 †Asa M.3, Chund, page 440 – “O my detached mind, unto whom do you show your detachment? Those who sing the Glorious Praises of the Lord live in the joy of the Lord, forever and ever. So become detached, and renounce hypocrisy; Your Husband Lord knows everything. The One Lord is pervading the water, the land and the sky; the Gurmukh realizes the Command of His Will. One who realizes the Lord's Command, obtains all peace and comforts. Thus says Nanak: such a detached one remains absorbed in the Lord's Love, day and night. 2 Wherever you wander, O my mind, the Lord is there with you. Renounce your cleverness, O my mind, and reflect upon the Lord abiding in you. Your Husband Lord is always with you, if you remember the Lord's Name, even for an instant. The sins of countless incarnations shall be washed away, and in the end, you shall obtain the supreme status. You shall be linked to the True Lord, and as Gurmukh, remember Him forever. Thus says Nanak: wherever you go, O my mind, the Lord is there with you. 3 Meeting the True Guru (God’s Light in Man), the wandering mind is held steady; it comes to abide in its own home. It purchases the Naam, chants the Naam, and remains absorbed in the Naam. The outgoing, wandering Mind, upon meeting the True Guru, opens the Tenth Gate. There, Ambrosial Nectar is food and the celestial music resounds; the world is held spell-bound by the music of the Word. The many strains of the unstruck melody resound there, as one merges in Truth. Thus says Nanak: by meeting the True Guru, the wandering soul becomes steady, and comes to dwell in the home of its own self. 4 O my mind, you are the embodiment of the Divine Light - recognize your own origin. O my mind, the Dear Lord is with you; through the Guru's Teachings, enjoy His Love. Acknowledge your origin, and then you shall know your Husband Lord, and so understand death and birth. By Guru's Grace, know the One; then, you shall not love any other. Peace comes to the mind, and gladness resounds; then, you shall be acclaimed. Thus says Nanak: O my mind, you are the very image of the Luminous Lord; recognize the true origin of your self. 5 O mind, you are so full of pride; loaded with pride, you shall depart. The fascinating Maya has fascinated you, over and over again, and lured you into reincarnation. Clinging to pride, you shall depart, O foolish mind, and in the end, you shall regret and repent. You are afflicted with the diseases of ego and desire, and you are wasting your life away in vain. The foolish self-willed manmukh does not remember the Lord, and shall regret and repent hereafter. Thus says Nanak: O mind, you are full of pride; loaded with pride, you shall depart. 6 O mind, don't be so proud of yourself, as if you know it all; the Gurmukh is humble and modest. Within the intellect are ignorance and ego; through living with God abiding in you, this filth is washed off. So be humble, and surrender to the True Guru; do not attach your identity to your ego. The world is consumed by ego and self-identity; see this, lest you lose your own self as well. Make yourself follow the Sweet Will of the True Guru (God in you); remain attached to His Sweet Will. Thus says Nanak: renounce your ego and self-conceit, and obtain peace; let your mind abide in humility. 7 Blessed is that time, when I met the True Guru (God in Man), and my Husband Lord came into my consciousness. I became so very blissful, and my mind and body found such a natural peace. My Husband Lord came into my consciousness; I enshrined Him within my mind, and I renounced all vice. When it pleased Him, virtues appeared in me, and the True Guru Himself adorned me. Those humble beings become acceptable, who cling to the One Name and renounce the love of duality. Thus says Nanak: blessed is the time when I met the True Guru, and my Husband Lord came into my consciousness. 8 Some people wander around, deluded by doubt; their Husband Lord Himself has misled them. They wander around in the love of duality, and they do their deeds in ego. Their Husband Lord Himself has misled them, and put them on the path of evil. Nothing lies in their power. You alone know their ups and downs, You, who created the creation. The Command of Your Will is very strict; how rare is the Gurmukh who understands. Thus says Nanak: what can the poor creatures do, when You mislead them into doubt? 9 †All have have been created by Him from His Own, and all have come from Him and all will necessarily go back to Him. Everyone’s turn will come to be Blessed by Him to get united with Him. But no one knows when. This is All His Wondrous Play. “sagal bistar eik tai bhai – Creaton is All His Manifestation.â€. Also “ khail sankochai tou nanak eikai – When He winds up His Play, then He only ONE remains.†Also “kaei bar pasrio pasara – Several times this dissolution and creation process of Universe has taken place.†THE CREATION IS THROUGH THE WORD UTTERED BY GOD, TERMED AS SABDA IN SRI GURU GRANTH AND THE CREATURES RE-UNITE WITH HIM THROUGH HIS THIS WORD. THIS WORD OF GOD RESOUNDS IN EVERY CREATURE DAY AND NIGHT - ANHAD SABAD. When God blesses a person, the Tenth Door opens, and the Mind enters therein and receives the Sabad. The blessed person gets united with his Creator during the course of his earthly life. Such a person totally effaces his Mind or his self (his ego meets with death), and he lives by his Real Self or the Divine Self in him. Then there is no difference between God and His approved devotee. From the SABADA emanates Nectar Compositions (Gurbani), which the Guru or Blessed One recites to others. It is through the SABDA the universes are created and also dissolved, and again created. IN THIS CONTEXT PLEASE REFER TO Pages 117 AND 125 OF RAG MAJH, ASTPADIS OF SRI GURU AMAR DAS JEE. The SABDA is God’s Light or Soul (SAT GURU) or Naam in all. Naam is received through Soul (SAT GURU) only and none else is capable of giving Naam to any one. One receives it from Soul (Sat Guru), when God Himself is so pleased. ConclusionOur total approach after Sri Guru Gobind Singh Jee to the present times, has been for acquisition of material power by adopting any means, fair or foul. No effort has ever been made to understand the Sikh Teachings in proper perspective, what to say of practicing them! We have NOT realized that God alone is the DOER (Karta Purkh), not the man, and for petty gains have been licking the shoes of wothless persons in power, never having any reliance on the Divne Support. In this mad pursuit of Power, we have been adopting Brahmanic creed, thus totally lost our character, integrity, respect and dignity as Sikhs. This madness in us has led to formation of various Splinter Groups in us. We have not stopped at this even, but in our utter ignorance and madness started vicious campaign to disown Sri Dasam Granth Sahib, the Treasure of Knowledge; thus have totally severed our connections with Guru Akalpurkh! We have been left as Sikhs in name alone and have completely been degenerated. Hindu fundamentalists, assisted by the so called turbaned Sikhs of Splinter Groups; viz Rashtriya Sikh Sangat, Radha Soamis, Nam Dharis, Nirankaris, Nanak Sarias, and varied others, are not the source of danger to our very existence as Sikhs, but we ourselves are the real enemies of ourselves, and SIKHISM! Only Waheguru Jee