Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?
................. · 08 Jun 2005
he was a true gursikhs all the time. These stories were made up brahmin writer to give him a bad name.
Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 08 Jun 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh.
It is not only the Brahmin/Bippar Combine that has been twisting our history..it has also been the COMMUNISTS ACADEMICS who have been so heavily infiltrated into the Universities in Punjab. These Communists ( KAUM-NASHATS) were SIKHS in APPEARANCE and LOOKS..BUT Deep INSIDE they are atheists and PURE POISON+HATRED for anything SIKHE/GURMATT.
Therefore many of the so called new History Books and articles. research papers that came out of PUNJAB UNIVERSITIES in the past 50 years or so was TWISTED HISTORY...
Guru Teg Bahadur Ji was also not spared....these new kaumnashat historians called Guru Ji a REBEL, a TERRORIST, a DAKOO etc who was then rightly "captured" by Aurengzeb and beheaded for his "crimes"
In the similar vein..the glorious history of Baba Banda Singh Ji bahadur was MUTILATED and TWISTED by these kaumnashat historians...and now attempts are being made to hijack this Sikh Hero to become Hinduism's hero ( simply because Hinduism DOESNT have a SINGLE HERO !!!) by calling him bairagee !! Earlier they hijacked Bhai Khaniya ji this way..saying he was not a sikh but a hindu samaj sewak !!
Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?
JARNAIL SINGH GYANI "ARSHI" · 09 Jun 2005
Baaba Banda Singh Ji Bahadur established the FIRST SIKH KINGDOM..the KHALSA RAJ..and that is a FACT which many new Hindutva/rss/Communists dont exactly love to relate.
I agree with mitrah that caste was not that important a consideration especially asGURU GOBIND SINGH JI had just established the Khalsa...Singhs wouldnt have RETROGRADED so fast.
I ahve seen MORE books by the so callaed LOW CASTES....trying to GLORIFY their own castes than books by jatt authors trying to prove their superiority. It is a fact that people of "superioruty complex" just behave that way...while those that have "inferiority complex" try and prove themselves as better. Books such as Mazhbhi Sikhaan da Ithihaas, whcih tries to prove that Mazhbhee Sikhs were mentioned BY GURU NANAK in His Gurbani, and then goes on to list Singhs such as Rangreta Bhai Jita Singh and many others...trying so hard to PROVE that Mazhbhee sikhs have ahigh place in Sikh History. The TITLE of the Book and the Subject Matter shows the author feels he has a point to prove...ALL along before I read this book i had no idea about the "caste" of many of the Singhs mentioned in the book..to me they were GREAT SINGHS. Now this author tries to CLAIM these Singhs as MAZHBHEES....and create division.
Similar casea abound where people have Web sites and all GLORIFYING the CASTE of Jassa Singh ramghariah....NOT his SIKHEE..and many books doing the same thing...and now we have memebers of the BAIRAGEE TRIBE..trying to RIDE on the Coattails of baba banda Singh by claiming he was THEIRS and NOT a SINGH...
IMHO all these attmpts are arising out of an INFERIRITY COMPLEX...i may be wrong though.
These "caste" attempts are different from those of the Communist Academics...they have a different agenda...their agenda is to DISCREDIT SIKHE by discrediting SIKHS....ALL SIKHS from GURUS to maharaja Ranjit Singh.
Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?
JARNAIL SINGH GYANI "ARSHI" · 10 Jun 2005
Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh.
Veer A singh writes..
<<
Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?
Truth Sikher · 10 Jun 2005
A Singh you are a ****admin cut- No name calling****.
Jatts are a ethnic group who share same decent as Rajputs from Scythians, Banda Singh Bahadur (Rajput) was heavily supported by Jatts and he his remembered as a great Sikh general no matter what authors may claim.
Secondly you seem to think you are some sort of academic, then you should stop labelling Jatts as a caste instead of a ethnic group, a group which has its own history pre-sikhism.
Thirdly, if you know your history so much you will know that Jatts are and have been the backbone of Sikhs, deny it all you want but the truth remains.
Ambedkar and co wanted political power by becoming Sikhs not for the love of it, nothing can stop millons of Dalits becoming Sikhs if they choose to, actually lets blame the Jatts, just like the 80's. People like you are a joke.
The rest of your post is waffle.
Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?
jugroop singh · 10 Jun 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Veer 'A Singh' Ji,
with Siree Guru Sahib Ji's Kirpa, your last post has shed a very well-substantiated and detailed light upon Baba Banda Singh Bahadur Singh.
much appreciated.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?
wannabesingh · 10 Jun 2005
Truth Sikher,
Are you really a Truth "Seeker" or a False Propagandist ?
There is no such case that an ethnic group or a caste or a clan could be the backbone of Sikhi.
If you believe some CLAN is the backbone of Sikhi, then I wonder where your backbone is ..
Some caste / clan / lineage / ethnic group cannot be the backbone of a religion
and if you mean to say that Jatt People, Jatt Sikhs, were the most prominent contributors to the Sikh faith,
1) When taking khande-ke-pahul a Gursikh rejects all ethnic groups, cultures, and castes for the MAANAS JAATH, for the AAEE PANTHEE SAGAL JAMAATEE, and for the EIK UTHAM PANTH
2) If you believe that only people born as Jatts could be great Sikhs, then you will have to go back to history class because all of the Guru Sahibs were born in non-jatt families.
3) Jatt / non-jatt is not an issue -- ethnic group or not, NOBODY IS HIGHER THAN THE PANTH, and no ethnic group or caste or clan or lineage is the backbone of Sikhi --- Sikhi stands up on its own with the support of the Guru's bani, Naam, the Rehit of the Guru's Sikhs, and Universal Love
wjkk wjkf
Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?
Punjab Shera Di Khomb · 10 Jun 2005
where do jat come from? scythia where do terkaan come from? scythia?
where do we all come from God? so fikkar not we the children of the matrix sit back and rejoice in the wonders of Mahrajs creation as a sikh.
the beauty of being sikh is that we are one. Where you find someone too too much into jat terkhan stuff you find arguments and egos clashing because the truth is they identify their jeevs with external material body from 5 elements than their original connection back to God. They are not doing their simran and bani with dhyaan, if they were they would know life is temporary, the body is a jacket that will come off upon after the limited life breaths after which they may be put into another body for their soul journey.
On the path of sikhi and what bani says one simply cannot have caste if they do they will form a barrier between themself and God.
Whether banda singh was a rajput or jatt i dont think singhs would care about his scythian connection, they fought against oppression and were blessed with a leader with capabilities and good skills.
They had a chardi kala singh on their side. beant singh was a singh from chammar background, if banda singh bahadur supposedely was not there a the time and beant singh was do you think the scythian singhs would have said " no sorry mate you aint one of us we cant have you as ours"?
i think theres two sides to ambedkar episode. But we should not be bitter brothers and sisters, we should continue very sharply on the path of sikhi and help do our bit to unite.
I am happy with sikh history, if we went into jat history what would we go into next? The world is very complex place. I am happy as a punjabi and a sikh.
[%sig%]
Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 11 Jun 2005
ssingh jio,
imho what i am trying to say ( and i may be wrong) is that those at the top of the "heap" (superior !! ones..) dont have to assert or "prove" their superiority...
It is usually those at the perceived bottom trying to climb up, and with "inferirity complex" that try and prove they are equally "good" clever etc... hence the book mazhbee sikhaan da itihas..the author tries so hard to "prove" that historically the so called low castes have been KINGS, rulers, etc etc..they are just as brave as anybody else..blah blah blah. This book is written obviously to REASSERT the "strength" of the so called mazhbees who are perceived to be low class and therefore couldnt be rulers/kings/warriors whatever.
As i said before, before this book, i never for a moment thought about Bhai Jeeta Singh, or many of the famous and dedicated Sikh warriors listed in the book as anything except as SINGHS..I had heard the phrase..Ranghreta Guru ka Beta... ( incidentally NO GURU JI ever said Jatt Guru Ka PUTT )..but never associated it with Jaat.... now even my children know that Ranghreta is a supposed "low caste"..and THIS AUTHOR is the guilty party for spreading that "info" which to me is "useless".... as Ranghreta Guru ka Beta is such a HIGH TITLE in my MIND that any "jatt" would die for...I WOULD.
My sincere benti to all..DONT BRING in caste...into GURSIKHE. Those that GURU JI LOVES are much higher than any jatt or brahmin no matter how highup/clean/pure dna etc he may be... GURU JI's Pyaar Bhariaa Title is out of this WORLD.
Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?
question Singh · 12 Jun 2005
L. Griffin was an idiot with no brain for saying such a proposterous manmat thing. There is no race that is first or second, and anybody who believes in any race superiority other than 'aee panthee sagal jamaathee' and 'ik utham panth sunio gursangat' is a faithless agnostic arrogant ignorant moron !!!!
Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 12 Jun 2005
Dear Ssingh jio,
I Quoted GURU GOBIND SINGH JI...."Ranghretta Guru ka beta"....and also proved that NO GURU ever said" "jatt Guru da Putt"..
BUt you went ahead and quoted me a Gorah, jattworld and other utter rubbish....you have got the correct reply from"ot" above.
Give me a quote from GURBANI or GURU Ji....about Jattas beign "superior" and I may consider a reply. All the other utter rubbish, accounts dont matter to me one iota. I a Guru ka Sikh first, a Punjabi second, and Malaysian third....jatt doesnt come into the equation.
Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?
Taksali Singh · 12 Jun 2005
Khalsa Jee,
Amritworld has new PDF file which has good information regarding Baba Banda Singh Bhadhur. Please download this PDF file and read it.
http://www.amritworld.com/pbi_articles/banda_singh.pdf
Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?
shan e punjab · 16 Jun 2005
a singh paaji what are your own views on zaat paat in sikhi? what best to get rid of it? y is it there in the first place?
i ask you because you seem like a widely read kinda moonda but i do not agree about the tat khalsa bit. sahdei khalsa ne moghula dee shattiah phadeeya sara asmaan da rang lal khoon bich parkhe jinna tikher jitteh nei ja karbani lai.
Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?
Panjabi Dal · 13 Jun 2006
Going back to the original question. I think Rattan Singh Bhangu (whose grandfather apparently fought with Banda), said a schism took place because Banda changed the Khalsa uniform colour to red, changed the Jaikara to "Fateh Darshan" and some other stuff, I think forcing vegetarianism. This made Baz Singh, deputised by Guru Gobind Singh Ji as one of his Punj Piaray advisors, break away from Banda (i.e. the Tat Khalsa). Banda Singh's actions are probably the best documented of early Sikhs and although we are right to be careful to accept everything in Persian accounts, some of it is useful.
They point at largescale influx of all castes in Khalsa under Banda, who seems to have truly achieved a jaatless society in his own time. Plus all the Singhs (whatever their background), sought shahadat. The Persian sources are useful because they contain accounts written by teh very people fighting against Banda, and we can often separate the propaganda from the truth.
[%sig%]
Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?
Panjabi Dal · 13 Jun 2006
Going back to the original question. I think Rattan Singh Bhangu (whose grandfather apparently fought with Banda), said a schism took place because Banda changed the Khalsa uniform colour to red, changed the Jaikara to "Fateh Darshan" and some other stuff, I think forcing vegetarianism. This made Baz Singh, deputised by Guru Gobind Singh Ji as one of his Punj Piaray advisors, break away from Banda (i.e. the Tat Khalsa). Banda Singh's actions are probably the best documented of early Sikhs and although we are right to be careful to accept everything in Persian accounts, some of it is useful.
They point at largescale influx of all castes in Khalsa under Banda, who seems to have truly achieved a jaatless society in his own time. Plus all the Singhs (whatever their background), sought shahadat. The Persian sources are useful because they contain accounts written by the very people fighting against Banda, and we can often separate the propaganda from the truth.
If you want I can try and dig some these accounts out and post them. Let me know.
Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?
holypakore!! · 14 Jun 2006
whats all this jatt biz? most jatts i know are far more liberal and open minded do not even rave on about caste as much as you see it amongst practicing sikhs whether anti jatt or for jatts its you so called sikhs in pagha who have that problem and pass it onto your kids
real jatts have strong spirit simple yet powerful are nice people they are not namesake.
just for the sake of it its jatts who got me a non jatt into sikhi. we can fight and die for each other theres no issues until you meet so called sikhs and sikh politics half of whom do not even resemble the shera prowess of the legends of punjab.
banda singh was a wonderful martyr who filled the pages of sikh history with splendour. he created a new chapter and breathed new life into the hearts of martyrs thus forward a new era of warriors laying their lives flocking to the divine call of sacrifice defining the first sikh kingdom in sikh history. the kettle the sword anything contrary and slanderous should be chucked out.
whats all this crap about lands? outside the punjab we all in the same boat
people had land long before sikhism while others had to fight and die to attain rights where they were abused and treated as labourers on the jagirs of rajputs and moghuls.
why do people have a problem with jatts?
live and let othrs live. th longer you carry this anti or for jatt thing the more stupid you make sikhs look cos no one else has a problem except for so called apney sikhs when their in a bundle together.
Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?
london singh · 14 Jun 2006
Nice post A Singh. I can detect an undertone of anti-Jatness but we all have our biases so that doesn't detract from the relevance of your post to this discussion.
You are quite right that early Sikh writers placed many of their own biases into their works, it's wasn't solely a Jat Sikh preserve but other writers such as Bhai Chaupa Singh who was a brahmin and wrote that Brahmin Sikhs were better than other Sikhs and deserved more respect. This is why literature such as Janamsakhis, Rehatnamas, Gurbilases etc have be analysed through Gurbani and not just taken at face value. It is only the few sanatanists who treat such literature as gospel. So it comes as no surprise when a sanatanist takes an obscure sakhi from Bhai Mani Singh Janamsakhi and twists it in order to involve Sikhs needlessly in the Shia-Sunni controversy. As now it is unlikely that Sikhs at the time of that Janamsakhi cared less whether Abu this or Abu that was the true Imam or not.
The same is true of Baba Banda Singh, the same sanatanist blames Babaji for a number of massacres but chiefly for killing of Shia Sayeeds at Samana. It seems that Shia Sayeed lives are worth more than others. Baba Banda Singh was unique among the Sikh leaders of the post-Guru period, he strove for and singlehandedly created a Sikh kingdom at a time when the Mughal empire was at it's height. Some Shia Sayeeds may have become collateral damage but that doesn't make Babaji into some kind of monster as the sanatanist has been trying to portray him. Babaji is also accused of forcibly converting Muslims to Sikhism. Putting aside the supreme irony of Muslims being forcibly converted there is no evidence that any Muslims were forcibly converted to Sikhism. There were instances of Muslims becoming Sikhs after the fall of Sirhind but there is no proof that it was forcible. In fact the newletters of that time which were reaching the Mughal emperor state that these Muslims were becoming Sikhs as they were impressed by the rising power of the Sikhs.
Unlike other Sikh leaders Baba Banda Singh was not a sentimentalist, he fought against and killed Sher Mohammed the nawab of Malekotla who had protested the treatment of the younger Sahibzadas by Wazir Khan. Sher Mohammed had joined forces with Wazir Khan. Sher Mohammed also incurred the wrath of Baba Banda Singh as he has kidnapped a Sikh Bibi from Amritsar and she had committed suicide in order to save her honour.
Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?
Kulbir Singh · 15 Jun 2006
There is a lot of misunderstanding about Baba Banda Singh jee Bahadur. If he had deserted the Sikh Panth, he would not have been able to have such a glorious shahidi. A person who leaves his Guru can never have the spiritual strength to see his son’s chest ripped apart and heart pulled out it. The heart of Baba jee’s son was forced in his mouth. Baba jee still stayed in Chardi Kala. He did not give up his faith.
Farukhsiyaar the Mughal emperor asked Baba jee what kind of death he wanted. Baba jee said to him that whatever kind of death he (the king) would want for himself. Farukhsiyaar did not know that he was talking to not an ordinary person but a person who had tamed his mind and was a player of high spiritual states. Anything that Baba jee said always came true. He had Vaak-Sidhi i.e. anything he said used to come true. This Sidhi came from his continued kamaayee of Naam and Gurbani.
History is witness that Baba jee’s bachan did come true. Very short time after Baba jee’s shahidi, the emperor was over thrown by the Sayyid brothers. He was thrown in a dungeon and tortured there. His eyes were taken out. He pleaded and cried like a little puppy. No one heard his screams. Farukhsiyaar was eventually murdered after a long agony.
Yes there was some opposition of Baba jee by some Singhs but this is natural in our Panth. We have always had infighting and the times of Baba jee were no different. Heck, Singhs did not even pardon Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj and deserted him at Siri Anandpur Sahib. Same way they deserted Baba jee in his dire need. But, then there were faithfuls too who held up with Baba jee till their last breath. 700-800 of them got shaheed along with Baba jee.
The story of Baba jee’s companions forced to eat pork at Siri Akal Takhat Sahib is a fabrication of Rattan Singh Bhangu who it seems like was very fond of meat.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Did Baba Banda Singh Bahadur turned against the Khalsa?
Harcharan Singh · 21 Jun 2006
To add.
http://www.amritworld.com/pbi_articles/banda_singh.pdf