Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

BehTaal and/or BehSur

BehTaal and/or BehSur

Question Bhai · 05 Jun 2005

There are many references to BehTaal and BehSur people. Should they be allowed to do Kirtan ? IMHO many Kirtanees should do "Teyaree" ( preparation ) first. After all isn't it insulting to sing GurBanee with "beyadbi" to the Raag and Taal ( Kar ) for that Shabad ?

Re: BehTaal and/or BehSur

k l · 05 Jun 2005

in music behsura is tolerated but behtaal is not tolerated

Re: BehTaal and/or BehSur

Gurpreet Singh · 06 Jun 2005

i totally agree with this post , and this topic....

Re: BehTaal and/or BehSur

JARNAIL SINGH GYANI "ARSHI" · 06 Jun 2005

imho..a lot of people are also Betaal and Besur in LIFE.. should they be "allowed to live " ? In KIRTAN....GURBANI is PARDHAAN...and in GURBANI..LOVE is PARDHAAN. LOVE+GURBANI=KIRTAN... a betaaal besura singer would be BOOEED off stage or even pelted with rotten eggs and tomatoes...BUT such WILL NEVER HAPPEN in a GURDWARA....no matter how betaal or besura a kirtaniya is. On the other hand..anyone intending to do kirtan to SANGAT..MUST be well prepared ( Gurbani Kaanth as a first step)... THOSE who dont have GURBANI KAANTH are "insulting" Gurbani...just like a Prof. who desnt have his matter well prepared and alwyas fumbling with his notes..a kirtaniya always turning the pages of his Amrit Kirtan booklet /pothi...looks bad and sloppy. "insulting" raag...i have no opinion as i am no raagi.

Re: BehTaal and/or BehSur

Bundha · 06 Jun 2005

<<< a betaaal besura singer would be BOOEED off stage or even pelted with rotten eggs and tomatoes...BUT such WILL NEVER HAPPEN in a GURDWARA....no matter how betaal or besura a kirtaniya is. >>> Arshi Ji, when a person first starts out doing kirtan no matter how prepared he/she is they are not going to be perfecr, do you intent to “BOO” then off stage. Do you really want to “BOO” Guru-ka-kirtania off stage. I don’t see you up on the stage doing Kirtan ?? it takes time and dedication and you are not going to get it right first time. What a beautiful picture you paint Giani Ji, of people throwing ROTTEN EGGS and tomatoes at some one in Guru Sahib Ji’s hazuri. Giani Ji, what would you be doing with ROTTEN EGGS in the Darbar Sahib anyway ??? or do you take them along with you just in case? <<<< a kirtaniya always turning the pages of his Amrit Kirtan booklet /pothi...looks bad and sloppy. >>> At least they have the guts to get up on stage and do kirtan. [%sig%]

Re: BehTaal and/or BehSur

Bundha · 06 Jun 2005

It is slightly strange when someone posts a reply that encourages people to throw ROTTEN EGGS in Guru Sahib Ji’s hazuri at Guru-kay-kirtania and that is allowed but when some one points this out the post is cut. I suppose this is what happens when you have power. [%sig%]

Re: BehTaal and/or BehSur

fff · 06 Jun 2005

i don't do this often, but i'm gonna defend arshi ji... he said ":singer" not keertani.. he was refgerring to stage singers.... performers... who when tey go besur or betaal , get eggs and tomatoes pelted at them NOTT keertanis in guruji's darbaar.. [%sig%]

Re: BehTaal and/or BehSur

S Singh · 06 Jun 2005

Bunda Ji >><<< a betaaal besura singer would be BOOEED off stage or even pelted with rotten eggs and tomatoes...BUT such WILL NEVER HAPPEN in a GURDWARA....no matter how betaal or besura a kirtaniya is. >>> >>Arshi Ji, when a person first starts out doing kirtan no matter how prepared he/she is they are not going to be perfecr, do you intent to “BOO” then off stage. Do you really want to “BOO” Guru-ka-kirtania off stage. I don’t see you up on the stage doing Kirtan ?? it takes time and dedication and you are not going to get it right first time. Read what Arshi Ji wrote. He was not advocating booing peopel off stage. He was making a point about the need for preparation. Just like most people prepare for many things in life. Why do you have to take htis out of context. Do you have a problem with Arshi Ji. It appears form your posts that rather than constructive debate you like to nit pick on things he posts. Rather sad if that is all you can do.

Re: BehTaal and/or BehSur

Bundha · 07 Jun 2005

You are right guys, my mistake. I apologise. [%sig%]

Re: BehTaal and/or BehSur

Question Bhai · 07 Jun 2005

"Raag, Ratan Parwaar Pareeyan, Sabad Gavan Ayeyan" Seems to me that a spiritual stage exists where "Sabad" is heard in "Raag" form. Everything in life has a balance. Therefore, being "in tune" and "in rythm" seems to be traits of a person that is in balance. And vice versa -- a person that is in balance spiritually naturally becomes "in tune" and "in rythm". My minor irritation comes when a tabla player does not "tune up" perfectly before playing. 8^)

Re: BehTaal and/or BehSur

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 07 Jun 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. My veer Bundha ji is so filled with hate for me that he completley went off his rocker this time...and is also laying the blame on the admin for not letting his "complete" tirade through. He has said it so many times that he hates me using CAPITALS...yet he completley misssed that i wrote...using capitals..A KITANIYA NO MATTER HOW BESURA/BETAALAA .... WILL NEVER BE BOOED OFF STAGE...becasue Kirtan is about LOVE. I have attended kirtan all my life. My dad had his own Jatha..Kirtaniyas, Akhand Paathees, . When my younger brothers began to do "kirtan" we used to be apprehensive..what will the sangat think/do/say..what with my brother on the waja with his arm so short, another had to work the fan for him, another one on the tabla...the tabla looked really huge compared to hsi tiny hand..and the Gurbani...well it was just the Rahao Pangtee repeated many times..BUT the PYAAR the sangats gave them was HUGE..and that same HUGE PYAAR i have always wittnessed ESPECIALLY when the Kirtaniyas are YOUNG CHILDREN...all Betalleh and Besureh, mispronouncing Gurbani and all.....BUT the SANGAT never said anything to discourage them. 50 Years I have OBSERVED THIS..and thats why i WROTE: <<< a betaaal besura singer would be BOOEED off stage or even pelted with rotten eggs and tomatoes...BUT such WILL NEVER HAPPEN in a GURDWARA....no matter how betaal or besura a kirtaniya is. >>>> I have PROOF of the PYAAR the sangats give to betall and besureeh kirtaniyas. Then I went on to give my opinion that it is then the Kirtaniyas RESPONSIBILITY to get himself PREPARED by having Gurbani kaanth..etc etc..it is defintleey not right for a kirtaniya to go on depending on amrit keertan pothis all his life, and get raag vidya, learn Gurbani raag etc etc. The SANGAT will not boo him but he should not "take this is a open license to go on being betalla and besura. So my humble benti to bundha ji, please take the time to read carefully..dont just see the name "arshi" and take out your bandook..sometimes the bandook BACKFIRES. I am Not a Raagi and also Not a Kirtaniya ( not even a betalla besura one..that is because Guru ji didnt give me that Daat..) Sorry if i have wasted valuable time and space on thsi frivolous reply.

Re: BehTaal and/or BehSur

Bundha · 07 Jun 2005

Arshi Ji, You are mistaken, how can I HATE you when you have the jote of AkalPurkh residing within you? By hating you I would be hating the divine spark within you, this was just a misunderstanding. [%sig%]