Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

sunny hounslow ealing uk · 30 May 2005

has anyone got imformation or pictures about shaheed bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

Swaran singh ghotna · 30 May 2005

he killed to many innocent labourers

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

..... · 30 May 2005

or pics??

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

Kulbir Singh · 30 May 2005

From what I can remember, Jhamka was active in the Gurdaspur area and was a merciless killer. I think he belonged to Khalistan Commando Force but he operated independently. In his short reign, he killed many innocent persons. This is based on the newspaper reports of late eighties. Many times he killed all family members of suspected informers. I don’t think he was a GOI agent or anything but he certainly lacked Gurmat. The above is based on newspaper reports of the times when he was alive. If anyone can refute this, I will be happy to change my opinion. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

sunny hounslow ealing uk · 30 May 2005

hello kulbir singh have you got any pictures of sukhdev s jhamke

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

Kulbir Singh · 30 May 2005

No I don't have any pictures of Jhamka. What I wrote above was based on my memory. I read about all these incidents in newspapers, as they happened in 1980s. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

ekta · 30 May 2005

obviously the newspapers are gonna call him a murderer of the innocent.

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

indy · 30 May 2005

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh what fools we are first off all wud u believe everything in the news papers????? guess u need to look at the facts and ask the true freedom fighters that fought with Shaheed Bhai Sukdev Singh Jhamka, how dare u say that he killed innoccent families etc the only proof u gave is from GOI newspapers, what a shame its our very own ppl that tarnish the image of the movement. yes Bhai Jhamka killed ppl yes am sure he was not perfect but to say he was LACKING IN GURMAT is a joke Bhai Sukdev singh was with the Taksaal he didn’t work independently first we was under the command of General Labh singh Ji and then after the KCF split up into factions he set up his own group. As far as I know he tired to stick to the agenda set up by the Freedom movement, yes true some of the singhs under him might have done wrong etc but Bhai Sukdev Singh was a hero and a true gursikh The newspapers say that Shaheed Jathadar Sukdev Singh Babbar killed over 1000 ppl wud u believe that ??? they say he did this and that etc but just because he belongs to a certain jatha we don’t question it, yet we ready to take digs first against Mahapursh Baba Takhur Singh Ji and no a Shaheed Singh This is so disheartening to read with out proof and using dodgy newspaper reports too shame shame May guru ji bless us with vision

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

rsingh · 31 May 2005

indy you got wrong info because i know jhamka killed many innocent persons specialy in gurdaspur and amritsar area.bhai heera singhs whole in-law family was killed by him including his 6 months bhujhangan baghel kaur and whole family of sarpanch in dhaliwal I can make a long list. All the groups were after him. they had meeting specially for his activities and they decided to teach him lesson.He ran away from his area I think u r mixing up sukhdev singh sakheera with sukhdev singh jhamka. sakheera was from taksal and he was chardikala waala singh but not jhamka

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

bsb · 31 May 2005

I have to agree here: I've also heard that Jhamka was nuts. He used to kill anyone even associated with his target. He also killed a lot of bhaiya labourers. Agreed that they don't belong in Punjab, but they don't deserve to die for it either.

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

etka · 31 May 2005

lets all believe indian media....and also how they calll sant ji and bhai sukhdev singh ji torrirsts rite... they're all right!!! bhai jamkha killed bhai heera singh's fam? who dah heck told u that homie?

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

sunny hounslow ealing uk · 31 May 2005

hello indy thanks for writing more on bhai sukhdev s jhamke kcf have you got any pictures of him

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

S Singh · 31 May 2005

ekta and indy You have a lot to learn. Not all militants were angels as you appear to think. Some were no better than ruthless bandits and indulged in killing innocent people and it was such actions that turned the people against the militants . Some Sikhs have a problem accepting this but it is true. It is time we stopped pretending that this did not happen and also claiming all such murders were done by GOI agents who joined the militants.

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

rsingh · 31 May 2005

jhamka accepted by himself that he took revenge from heera singhs in laws because his wife was responsible for heera singhs shaheedi ( But what about the whole family and his daughter ?they were innocent right )

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

Seeker · 31 May 2005

Sikh's have been fighting with each other for ages.....and even on the internet now...... now I know why the Shaeed families are left on the road side to cry.....shame....sad

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

kiran · 31 May 2005

leave a note for balpreet singh he might have some pictures, he normally shows some great pictures of shaheeds

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

sunny hounslow ealing uk · 31 May 2005

hello balpreet singh ji have you got any pictures of shaheed sukhdev s jhamke kcf

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

indy · 31 May 2005

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh sangat ji ppl are entitled to their views i know the singhs that fought with General Sukdev Singh Jhamka. I said before that he was not perfect, things happen in the thick off battle am not going to get into a debate with anyone has I respect the Mighty Shaheeds of the Quam. Bhai Sukdev Singh Jhamka ]fought in a battle that was dirty no one knows the Truth but one thing if u can get copies of when Bhai Sukdev Singh got shaheedi u will find that all the groups paid homage to this Great fighter. We can sit here and talk talk and in hindsight say this was wrong that was, but these Singhs fought an honest battle to the best of their ability what r we doing in return ????? the period of 1984-1989 where the best the singhs took out a lot off the enemy a lot was said in them days too about the singhs including Bhai Harjinder Singh Jinda and Bhai Sukdev singh sukha and many more freedom fighters like Bhai Satnam singh Bawa etc but in the end even those ppl who were saying all these things had to bow their heads to these great Sikhs. I’ve got a pic of Shaheed Bhai Sukdev Singh ji will try to scan it in. plus theres a video off Sant ji talking and Shaheed Baba Gurbachan Singh Manochahal and Bhai Sukdev Singh Jhamka are in the back ground souting Khalistan Zindabad.

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

sunny hounslow ealing uk · 01 Jun 2005

thanks indy i look foward to seing your pics of bhai sukhdev s jhamke kcf

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

S Singh · 01 Jun 2005

indy, You rubbish what everyone else has written. What makes you such an expert on jhamka ? How do you know the newpaper reports where not in the Awaze Quam or Des Pardes ? What is wrong is wrong despite what you say. If you kill innocet people that is wrong regardless of whether their relative was in the police etc.

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

Jindo · 01 Jun 2005

Only a moorakh would base their ideas from Indian Media Newspapers. These same papers reported countless lies about Suckdev Singh Babbar, and hundreds of other respected Generals. These people were ALL reported as murderers, rapists etc. Therefore if someone is going to base their opinion about one Singh on what the papers said, they should also accept that Suckdev Singh Babbar etc were also cold blooded murderes’s and rapists. The Indian papers even reported that woman were raped in Darbar Sahib pre 84 and countless other lies. Guess what ever the papers say must be true.

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

indy · 01 Jun 2005

vaheguru ji ka khalsa vaheguru ji ki fateh am no expert just a foot soldier, bhai sukdev singh jhamka may have had his faults etc etc but look at the mans life he lived a life off a freedom fighter his singhs that fought with him are alive and i wud go by what they said then some press reports. wud u believe the babbars planted the bombs in delhi?? i know Bhai Sukdev Singh ji had his enemies they all did, yes sum innocent did get killed by every group but that’s not to say mistakes are not made its easy to look in hindsight. that’s all am saying u never said one good thing about Bhai Sahib there countless stories i can tell u a bout killings etc done by top leaders but whats the point we know they did some wrong things we learn and more forward I just felt sad when someone sad he was anti gurmatt Peace bro May we when in the battle field do our best and live by the code of the Khalsa

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

S Singh · 01 Jun 2005

Jindo Get yourself copies of "Panthic" newspapers dating from 1984 to early 1990s and see for yourself the press releases by the Panthic Committees and Militant groups claiming responsibility for cold blooded murders. Not all militants were the great figures you appear to think they were.

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

kiran · 01 Jun 2005

see www.dalkhalsa.com, still continuing the freedom movement in panjab

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

Seeker · 01 Jun 2005

Dal Khalsa is agians't Bihari labourers which is wrong as they have full rights to move around in the Country same as any Sikh does. Problem with Dal Khalsa is that it was created by Giani Zial Singh, former president of India to fight with other akali dal's which were threat to congress...so they can't be trusted either......

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

Jagjitsingh · 01 Jun 2005

waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, I do not know Bhai Sukhdev Singh jhamke at all, neither heard anything bad about him, but I am no expert. However as far as I am concerned any Singh who takes Amrit, walks the path of a sant spihahi, and in the end leaves this world as a shaheed, deserves the utmost respect. How would any of us wish to die, in our sleep, heart attack, car accident? My wish is when my day comes I leave this world as Bhai Mani Singh or Bhai Anokh Singh babbar. What better shaheedi, that to be a shaheed on the battlefield like Baba Deep Singh ji, or Baba Jarnail Singh ji, Bhai Amrik Singh and General Subheg Singh ji. Since I came into sikhi I have found the pictures of Bhai Sukhdev Singh so enigmatic, but no less than Baba Jarnail Singh ji. His speeches are so amazing, you can still feel the chardi kala when you hear them. How can a person even think not to stand with him. In my early years, I was pained to see khalistani group laud their own shaheeds, and put down others. How can one shaheedi be higher or lower than another? Never, they are all our elder brothers. Every singh is equally worthy of respect, especially those thousands who names we do not know, and will never know. Please those writing on this thread please consider this without prejudice. waheguru ji ke khalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

kiran · 01 Jun 2005

seeker stop talking rubbish, and stop listerning to all the rubbish the govt of india tells you !!!!! dal khalsa was created by sultan-e-quam jassa singh alhuwalia and nawab kapoor singh in the mid 1700's to fight the mogul oppresion and to establish khalsa rajj in panjab ! please read up on sikh history and not the stuff g.o.i feeds you ! if you want more info go on the website of dal khalsa and click on history, it will tell you why and WHO it was revived by in 1978 and what thier mission is !

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

Seeker · 02 Jun 2005

Kiran Ji, I am not expert on Sikh History but I know that the present Dal Khalsa have nothing to do with the Dal Khalsa created by Sardar Jass Singh Ji Alhuwalia. All I know is that everyone in Punjab right now is in a political race to get to power and most Sikh political parties are using Saheed parivar's to gain popularity. Rest is upto all individual's what they beleive in and how they want to approach it, all I am doing is expressing my side of the story. Thanks.

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

HARJ · 02 Jun 2005

I THINK THE WAY THAT DAL KHALSA ARE WORKING IN PANJAB RIGHT NOW IT IS EXACTLY LIKE THE DAL KHALSA CREATED BY JASSA SINGH ALHUWALIA NOTHING DIFFERENT IN MY THOUGHTS !

Re: bhai sukhdev singh jhamke

Admin · 02 Jun 2005

Only posts dealing with the subject will be approved from here on in. Dal Khalsa is not the issue.