Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

PAAP - marriages / divorce

PAAP - marriages / divorce

anon · 29 May 2005

Divorce is becoming more and more common within orthodox sikh community Recently i know of two marriages which i see as being bujjar kurehits The first in uk - husband and wife divorced. Wife then found another singh, ran off to india an got married again there, as it was against parents wishes, now theyre back in uk. The second - Bibi in india whos husband died, has married a singh who is already married and has 3 children. So the singh now has two wives although he only lives with one. Is this not wrong? In sikhi when you get married in front of guruji isn't it permanent? There is no such thing as divorce in sikhi, even if couple separate they are still husband and wife. You can only remarry if youre partner dies Any other relationship is like adultery. Can i ask what Bhai Kulbir Singhs Views are on this??

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

............... · 30 May 2005

with all due respect to Bhai Kulbir singh, you should always ask the sangat views, not one individuals. No one individual is higher or more special than the sangat. I am sure bhai Kulbir singh will agree!

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

Manjit Kaur Sidhu · 30 May 2005

[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani] Bhai Kulbir Singh ji is also part of the Sangat...the poster just wants to make sure veer ji responds..it is no way indicated that he/she will regard Kulbir Singh's post as any "higher" or "lower". How about the ACTION of Takhat Patna Sahib jathedar who has TWO WIVES ?? IF a jathedar of a Takhat sahib cannot follow Maryada what about ordinary sikhs...or is NEW MARYADA to take "multiple wives" ( and HUSBANDS too ... dont forget we are all equal ). As for me i am satisfied with my ONE Husband and he is satisfied with just ME alone. [gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani]

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

d f · 30 May 2005

it was written in an article that said marriages 40-50 years ago were 90% purpose and 10 % function. the woman would take care, cook clean, nurture children and the man would work and provide. Today it is the other way around, 90% affection and 10% purpose. This is why there are so many divorces these days, becuase it is difficult to keep up to the constantly changing emotional needs of the person. If there was some type of function each had with a certain amount of mutual respect, then there would be less problems. we are being forced to accept what societies views on marriage are, not sikhi's.

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

Kulbir Singh · 30 May 2005

-------------- The first in uk - husband and wife divorced. Wife then found another singh, ran off to india an got married again there, as it was against parents wishes, now theyre back in uk. -------------- My opinion on love marriages is known to everyone on this forum. I don’t condone love marriages and believe that love marriages are against Gurmat. ----------------- The second - Bibi in india whos husband died, has married a singh who is already married and has 3 children. So the singh now has two wives although he only lives with one. --------------- I don’t know both sides of the story and as thus cannot comment on this. ------------ In sikhi when you get married in front of guruji isn't it permanent? There is no such thing as divorce in sikhi, even if couple separate they are still husband and wife. You can only remarry if youre partner dies Any other relationship is like adultery. Can i ask what Bhai Kulbir Singhs Views are on this?? ------------------- I respect your views and believe that ideally there should be no divorce in Sikhi but we see that in reality things unfold differently. True, one should marry only after ones spouse dies but what happens if one’s spouse runs away and refuses to come back? Is such person who’s spouse runs away or elopes with someone else, supposed to lead a desolate life without a life partner? This does not seem fair to me. A Singh in India narrated his own story to us. This Singh’s wife refused to follow Gurmat and did not want to lead an amritdhari life. When they were married they were amritdhari but later on she could not carry on her life as an amritdhari. This Singhs tried his best to persuade her to follow minimum rehit but she refused and went back to her parent’s house. This Singh was still young and as thus went to Punj Pyaray for permission to get married to someone else in case his wife does not come back. Eventually Punj Pyaray gave him permission to get married again. He was happily married later on. So in such cases as described above, I personally don’t see anything wrong if a Singh or a Bibi gets married again. [b]But the best thing in such circumstance would certainly be that this Singh or Bibi stay celibate rest of his or her life and not get married. But in case, he or she cannot stay celibate, then it is better to get married rather than committing stupid Kaam related mistakes. [/b] Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

dfd · 30 May 2005

kulbir singh, is it ok to talk to the other person before marriage, even if its arranged?

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

... · 30 May 2005

theres no such thing as divorce in sikhism if youre partner commits a kurehit, you stop living with them as a spouse until they go pesh if they refuse, so be it, live according to gods will you cant just go off and find another wife/husband, that can only be done if youre spouse dies. kulbir singh sed - So in such cases as described above, I personally don’t see anything wrong if a Singh or a Bibi gets married again. But the best thing in such circumstance would certainly be that this Singh or Bibi stay celibate rest of his or her life and not get married. But in case, he or she cannot stay celibate, then it is better to get married rather than committing stupid Kaam related mistakes getting married again is a 'stupid kaam related mistake' ive seen buddhists in the west who are celibates and they dont have the support of naam. getting married again in front of guruji, when your spouse is still alive is PAAP. wheres the SHARAM gone????????????

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

vichar · 30 May 2005

how can you go back in front of guruji to get married again, if youre already married ? jus say im married, but i cannot control my kaam for another singhnee, should i go and marry her to stop myself making a 'kaam related mistake' whats happeneing to sikhi nowadays?

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

...! · 30 May 2005

I think that the person that left and refuses to come back has turned his/her back to Guru Sahib and has broken the agreement/arrangement of marriage made in Guru Sahib's hazoori. The other spouse can try to bring them back but if they refuse, I don't think that s/he is wrong if they marry again. They are not the ones that broke the marriage or turned their backs on Guru Sahib, the person that left is. People should put themselves in others' shoes. What if it happens to you? What would you do? Can you be certain you'd have the fortitude to follow your own advice?

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

bending rules · 30 May 2005

...! said ; People should put themselves in others' shoes. What if it happens to you? What would you do? Can you be certain you'd have the fortitude to follow your own advice? nowadays 'sikhs' bend rules to suite themselves. Peoples opinions are based on justifying ones actions. real examples) Singh claims egg is a dairy product, therefore its ok to eat chocolate gateux with egg in. eg2) Bleaching hair is ok, aslong as you dont remove it, just do seva and guru will forgive you. My point is whether or not you can follow advise you give, is irrelevant just cause i cant follow advice i gave dont mean the advice i gave is wrong. yeah it might seem harsh not being able to get married again, but who said sikhi is easy. the author ...! clearly feels advice i gave is too difficult to follow, therefore his mind automatically rejects what i say to try and justify what he would do in such circumstances.

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

...! · 30 May 2005

address my original point that the other person isn't to be held responsible for breaking the agreement. What do you say about that? And my point about following one's own advice is that it's easy to be a hero and much harder to practice practically. I think it'd be best to not get re-married but I dont' know if I could do it, nor do I know if that'd necessarily be any less according to Sikhi

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

bending rules · 31 May 2005

address my original point that the other person isn't to be held responsible for breaking the agreement. What do you say about that? no the other person isn't responsible, therefore will not get punished here or in hereafter. however it doesnt give them the right to go off and find another wife, one must live according to gods will accept what god gives you, do not act against god just to satisfy yourself with another wife. if youre wife leaves, so be it, two wrongs dont make a right. the gurmat way in marriage is to cut marrital relations when youre partner breaks agreement, finding another partner is manmat.

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

Princess · 31 May 2005

///////// wheres the SHARAM gone???????????? //////// It is besharami of that person who runs away from his/her partner and breaks ardaas of Anand Karaj and his/her commitment done in front of Guru Sahib jee. How a person who did not break ardaas or ran away is besharam? Anand karaj is a commitment between two if one of them breaks it and not ready to come back even after many efforts of another parter then it's fault/besharami of just first one who broke the rule. /////// getting married again in front of guruji, when your spouse is still alive is PAAP. ////// If an Amritdhari(Gursikh) leaves his/her Guru jee, is not called alive any more. Same way when a parter breaks ardaas which was done in hazoori of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee, is not alive for other parter who never turned his back towards Guru Sahib jee and Anand-karaj Agreement. In gurmat, one who commits paap is punished not the innocent one. ////// kulbir singh, is it ok to talk to the other person before marriage, even if its arranged? ///// No, it is against gurmat.

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

????//// · 31 May 2005

what then happens if you do get married more than once????? Both my parnets know have been married before, does that make them wrong????????

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

kaur1 · 31 May 2005

wjkk wjkf How is it against gurmat to talk 2 another person? so that means if ou have an arranged marriage.. the only day would see or talk 2 one another is on your wedding day!!! woo...i think thats how most divorces occur. What if you don't like the person your parents have set u up with? your stuck! correct me if im wrong. bhull chuk maaff wjkk wjkf

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

Princess · 31 May 2005

//// woo...i think thats how most divorces occur. What if you don't like the person your parents have set u up with? your stuck! ///// Many divorces occur because of love marriages not because of arrange marriages. In gurmat, parents or Gursikhs choose partner according to person's wishes or in other words, they try to choose a best match. Even if you talk to your partner few times before marriage, you can't see the real face of that person until you start living together. We all(most of us) don't show our inside to every person we meet for few times. Our family members know more than outsiders about our real nature. Everyone tries to be nice especially with their going to be partner. How would you find the truth by seeing a person before marriage. The secret of happy married life is following gurmat and treating each other as Gursikhs. No other[gurbani] isAwxpW[/gurbani] can help.

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

RoopKaur · 31 May 2005

>How is it against gurmat to talk 2 another person? so that means if ou have an arranged marriage.. the only day would see or talk 2 one another is on your wedding day!!! woo...i think thats how most divorces occur. What if you don't like the person your parents have set u up with? your stuck!< I think you are totally wrong. I have witnessed couples that have arranged marriages and did not communicate before the marriage, and now are happily married. I think this is because they are developing true love for eachother, not the fake lust that people call love involved in finding your own partner. What is the point of talking before? People will argue that you can get to know the person better, but is that really true? When two people communicate with each other, they will be only presenting things pleasing to the other and putting up a front in order to please the other person. When these people get married, and they are exposed to the whole personality of the other person, their original view of that person is broken. I think the opposite is true, it is this false advertisement of personality that is the cause of a lot of divorces in love marriages. Another thing, we all know that just because two parties have agreed to get married, that the marriage will happen. Things happen and situations change, so if you start talking to your fiance and then things dont work out then what? That is why according to gurmat, it is best not to talk freely with the other person until after the marriage.

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 01 Jun 2005

There may be situations where parents (or others in the immediate family) make a decision for a person. That does not guarantee that such a decision is a gurmat one. I have seen many matrimonial advertisements that were written by Sikh parents. Many advertisements mention a clean-shaven person as either the subject or the target object of the ads. Some parents advertise their caste, in the hopes that it will be utilized in the decision making process. Others insist that the target object be of a specificed cast. Nearly all ads mention the astrological sign of the subject. Some parents go as far as believing in the outcome of astrological or numerological rites and readings. And...some Sikhs do not have Sikh parents. Some Sikhs may be marrying at a non-traditional age. Some Sikhs may be in non-traditional situations, such as planning a marriage when there are children involved. That is not to say that I believe that parents should be dissolved from the equation. I believe that the process of seeking an arranged match is a good and a moral one. I just don't believe that talking to a potential spouse is clearly and unquestionably sinful in 100.00% of all Sikh marriages. There may be many situations where such a thing is a darn good idea. There are others where such a thing may not be as wise. A Sikh will never go wrong by turning to Waheguruji and honestly asking Him for guidance.

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

manak/yamla fan · 01 Jun 2005

yeh i kinda agree with roop kaur. Most of our old folks did not divorce they made their marriages work on a different level and built up their bonds in different ways and their marriages really worked much more than we have now. Now i think society is very much more fake than our grandparents generation. average looking people married good looking people. We did not have a bar on looks or anything before, but nowdays the media has stereotyped an image of a perfect persons features before us that stay in our head. If someone was tick they would not be too concious of it, or if someone was not so tick they would not be made to feel out of place, but society now makes u more concious of it ie a bibi having trouble with facial kes or a singh with rounded features or darker than normal while the media bombards us with a perfect european type look. and now media is kind of gripping into our lives in a very snakey way. i once read on an interesting three h o group article that a marriage should be based on long term ideals whether thats love or arranged. Without long term ideals how can a marriage pass? its just nowdays most love marriages happen to be based on anything other than sikhi. red and white kaur what you say is right but they are not sikhs who ask for clean shaven people or someones caste. They have turned their back on Guru ji and are sikh in name only.

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

kaka · 01 Jun 2005

there are breakdowns with pressures in life. i believe finances, communication and time with family are problem areas. people are much materialistic now with less standards. Because both or one side standards are low or they are not willing to work out differences they will keep splitting. Eastern standards need to be maintained above our adopted temporary homeland values in foreign countries where we shall always remain foreigners so why change our stand? we should inpire to higher standards so others may realise the beauty of our eastern values. By changing to society habits we will loose very much. If couples stop chatting or they have issues they gotto sit down and express their feelings and overcome their obstacles. If they fail to communicate then there will be a huge problem which will lead to distance, mistrust, not knowing what your partner is about anymore, edginess and then comes a deeper split. egos goto be put aside sometimes two people think i will fight to the end. thats a sure way to end the marriage, they should analyse the situation instead and try to come to an agreement and compromise to save their marriage. Sometimes they do not get on, and their hatred for each other overcomes their responsibility for dependants ie kids. They ignore the consequences upon dependants children. It is like hell for a child to watch mum dad split. I have seen one 7 year old lifes change and he was short of loosing the plot. How much pain can a innocent child go through? i would advise parents to balance out their decisions and whom it affects put themselves into the shoes of others. arranged marriages gerenally your parents do not force you to marry someone, they find you a suitable match and usually ask you what do you think? then you find out a bit more and make your choise its just like an introduction. Love marriages also involve introduction but involve more interaction to unrestricted or perhaps certain restricted levels in cases. Whichever way, i believe both are hit with divorces if both partners fail to use their akal to resolve matters. BUT where someone marries another for their bodily looks, lust, or material love then i think that marriage will definatly mash up somewhere because the only thing that held the marriage together was a temporary love for the body rather than marriage as a sacred instituition. red and white does have a good point however asking for matrimonial alliances based on clean shaven is usually to do with the girl asking for a clean shaven man. what can the parents do when the children are shaped by society they live in? I do agree that caste is an issue in terms of marriage which we must all let go of. But it is not practiced everywhere, many amritdharis and non amritdharis do marry out of caste and have especially in mixed and city type areas who are less caste concious. One of my friends extended family members were arranged marriages into jatt trkan and nayees while another friends families were extended into saini and jatts. But having said that, historically there are dense areas where one caste dominated and other areas where people lived in mixed ratios which encouraged change of attitudes. Just because a newspaper has these dodgy advertisements does niot mean it is 100% like that in the real world.

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

? · 01 Jun 2005

red white and blue jio my knowledge on american sikhs is kind of zeroish. I have been on the sikhnet site and found tonnes of desi sikhs but comparitively very few european sikhs on the matrimonial search. I am interested in this area as i have heard accounts that over 15 000 european sikhs reside in cali area and about 250 000 european descended americans with allegiance to sikhi which i am happy to hear :-). If you come from there Could you please tell me 1) if european american sikhs do marry with desi punjabi sikhs? 2) if so, is it noticeable trend? like average percentages for example a quarter of european sikhs u met maybe? or less? 3) how do american sikhs on average get married? arranged or love marriages? 4) do they support the concept of no caste/ race in terms of marriage? 5) and finally having not seen many advertisements in sikh newspapers or sikhnet for european american sikh sangata matrimonials then how would they go about marriage? is there a seperate procedure of meeting potential partners? for example like functions, families meeting other families with such prospects? or get togethers? 6) i am interested in marrying a european singhani to help contribute towards breaking the zaat paat even more could you please advise me what to do here?

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

dhan guru nanak dev ji · 01 Jun 2005

Roop Kaur is totally right. I have known of a situation in which the guy used to visit his future wife and be at each other's house, on the phone etc. They were publiclly engaged. The guy got all close to her and revealed his past to the girl and she left. True love is Spiritual love for one another. For the soul, not the body. In that case the Guy should refrian and not make the same mistakes next time.

Re: PAAP - marriages / divorce

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 02 Jun 2005

Question Mark Singh ji, I'll try to answer your questions as best as I can. Just as all Panjabi Sikhs are not alike, nether are all Euro-American Sikhs. 1) if european american sikhs do marry with desi punjabi sikhs? Yes, certainly. I have had the good fortune to meet several couples where one was of Panjabi origin and the other was European. 2) if so, is it noticeable trend? like average percentages for example a quarter of european sikhs u met maybe? or less? It's difficult to say. I think a lot depends on how the American was introduced to Sikhi, and where that person was in their life (age, marital status) when they discovered the darshan of Waheguru. Most of the European Sikhs that I know are in the 3HO community, where I have noticed that many 3HO Sikhs have married other 3HO Sikhs, and this typically (but not always) means two European Sikhs getting married. 3) how do american sikhs on average get married? arranged or love marriages? My guess is arranged, but I cannot say with certainty. I personally do not like to pry in to another person's private life. When I have met a married couple, it never occured to me to ask what kind of marriage that they had. 4) do they support the concept of no caste/ race in terms of marriage? American Sikhs support the concept of no caste and no race for ANY reason, not just marriage. I would guess that the vast majority of American Sikhs see no reason to pay heed to the caste system. We don't understand it, and have no reason to learn it. Guru Nanak said it is wrong. That's good enough for me. In terms of race, America is a beautifully diverse country with people of many colors, and Sikhs of many colors. The vast majority of American Sikhs do not make race-based decisions for any reason. 5) and finally having not seen many advertisements in sikh newspapers or sikhnet for european american sikh sangata matrimonials then how would they go about marriage? is there a seperate procedure of meeting potential partners? for example like functions, families meeting other families with such prospects? or get togethers? Many of us are on our own to find a match. A large number of us have converted to the Sikh faith. We have family that we love, but not a family that can support us in the steps of arranging a marriage. To make it happen, we must take the steps ourselves. So, we can face our partners ourselves. This has it's advantages. But, the simple fact that many of us do not have Sikh/Panjabi/Desi parents is enough for many Panjabi families to not want to consider us, or it may brand us as people with suspect values by those folks that haven't bothered to get to know our values and piety. Or, we can turn to people close to us to help us in our quest. This has its advantages. But then it means that one's personal life becomes the subject of innapropriate open discussion, or that one's taste in a partner can get horribly ensnared in gurdwara politics. Or, we can date. Not my choice, or my taste, but I'd be a moorakh if I didn't say it was happening across our communities. 6) i am interested in marrying a european singhani to help contribute towards breaking the zaat paat even more could you please advise me what to do here? That may be the toughest question of all to answer. There is no single resource where one can find western Sikhs, and I don't think any of us really want to "groupify" ourselves as "western Sikhs" or "Goray Sikhs" or "Hispanic-American Sikhs that live in Yuba City". We're just Sikhs. It may help if you mention in your ad that you appreciate Americans, and might like to get to know an American Kaur. It may give a shy Kaur the confidence in your progressive attitude to respond. It may help to do seva in different gurdwaras for a chance to get to know people in the community that you have not met yet. There are a lot of Sikhs in California, there are many different gurdwaras to visit. It may help if you reach out and find other progressive-minded Sikhs (of all backgrounds) that are close to your age. Organize a gurbani study. Organize a get-together that is something fun to do but is not indulgent. You may be able to get to know some Sikhs who know other Sikhs... I wish I could provide better information.