Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

!! · 26 May 2005

Bibi J.Kaur's dastar slowly began to move more to the back of her head with each day. After some months, she didn't stay very strict at all. When she'd go to a kirtan smagam, she'd tie a dastar, otherwise she'd just keep her hair in a fashionable puff at the top of her head. And then, sometimes she'd not do a joora at all and instead put her hair in a ponytail. When someone would ask about it, she'd make some excuse. Without a joora, J. Kaur had trouble fitting her kangha into her hair so she decided to tie it with a string to her kirpan. One day she was going to a kirtan program and had tied a dastar. She was asked to do kirtan. When she finished and was getting up, her kameez lifted a bit and showed her kirpan. A Singh sitting behind her saw the kangha tied to the kirpan and said, "Bibi, maybe you should've tied your kacherra to your kirpan too..." Bibi J. Kaur felt very embarassed after her pakhand was exposed and she quickly decided to leave. Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur ji! Dastar is a rehit, not a fashion accessory!

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

Sister · 26 May 2005

Who are you talking about? The SGPC pardhan doesn't even wear a dastaar, when I saw her on a TV interview, she only had her head covered with a chunni. I was reading the hukamnamas from Shri Akal Thakht Sahib, it lists all the tankhaiye and people who have been removed from the panth, there was a Bibi Jagir Kaur listed as 'kharaj' from the panth, this is not the same Bibi as the SGPC pardhan, is it?

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

Singh · 26 May 2005

I don't think J. Kaur means Bibi Jagir Kaur.

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

kulmohan · 26 May 2005

Rather than the Biby I Would pity the singh who had a comment to make about the bibi's Kacherra

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

stranger · 26 May 2005

I know many Singhnia who are Amritdhari but just because they don't wear dastaars does not make them any less Guru Ka Sikh. Akal Takhat Mariyada does not dictate Dastaar for Ladies. So stop looking at physical features of a person and look inside them before deciding who is bad and good..........! This is the type of accusations that make people run from Sikhi rather then embrace the wonderful path Guru has given the human race.

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

Singh · 26 May 2005

Kulmohan, how do you know that the writer is a singh and not a bibi?...... so much for positivity......

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

Sister · 26 May 2005

Stranger, we project our inside through our outside, the women who are too self-concious about their looks make excuses and don't wear a dastaar as stated by Guru ji "sarab surat dastaar sira", what does that say about their inside?

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

bsb · 26 May 2005

the puff on the head is no good, if you are looking different anyways then at least be keeping rehit and not half way in western looks and half way in sikhi too.

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

Khalsa_Force · 27 May 2005

Inner and Outer Rehits r EQUALLY important.

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" · 27 May 2005

Veer Singh Ji, you have jumped on Kulmohan...for the wrong reason....he is not saying the "writer" is a Singh.... he is s aying a Singh made the comment and it is right. Please re-read the story..Four lines from the Bottom.... A SINGH..blah blah.. Anyway we are ALL SINGHS...SONS of GURU GOBIND SINGH JI. It is positively wrong to foist our own hangups about male/female on to Guru Ji.. to GURU JI all of us are equal.. Anyway we are ALL "WOMEN"..as the ONLY MAN is WAHEGURU.... I have been reading some snide remarks about " in "JATHAS"...where...women look like women" and this implies that in AKJ, the women and men look alike due to the bana.... Question is about DASTAAR....and this is COMPULSORY for BOTH SEXES...None of the PANJ KAKAARS is compulsory for one sex and not for the other..so IF wearing ALL the Five Kakaars makes us all look ALIKE..that is GURU JI's IDEA all along..can you argue with that ?? The FACT of the matter is that ONLy the AKJ have been brave enough to follow this rule to the LETTER and in keeping with its SPIRIT. No other Jatha dare to say it out loud that Dastaar for women is NOT COMPULSORY....but they dont quite enforce it either because their women have dropped it and they cant make them pick it up. All the Taksal Jathedar's wives wore Dastaars..and their women still do.

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

S.K. · 27 May 2005

"singh jee," I think "kulmohan" was referring to the singh who actually saw the bibi's kirpan. He wasn't talking about the writer of the thread. Read the whole sentence "kulmohan" wrote.

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

stranger · 27 May 2005

Dear Sister So now you are saying my mother who is Amritdhari is bad on the inside - she has been doing paat and simran for more years then your age - she has never thought ill of anyone - gone out of her way to help all - never done nindia or chugli - goes to Gurdwara every single day and never misses doing her paat day in day out. In fact she keep a little notepad to remind her of any Sukhmani Sahib paats she misses so she can do them!!! and you say her outward apperance is a means to judge her internal status!!!! My God you truely are far from the Truth - she took Amrit from SGPC appointed Gurdwara in India and they DID NOT STATE THAT WOMEN MUST WEAR KESKI OR DASTAAR so she is not breaking any rules OK!!!!! Your comments are insulting to the God Fearing people who do not follow this rigid practice yet love Guru Ji as much as you!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

stranger · 27 May 2005

Sister To add to my last posting you state: '...we project our inside through our outside...' Then if this true how come no one could see the true state of that chap has raped and abused those Singhnia - discussed in one of the postings while back? How come many in bana go around smoking but yet they are seen as GurSikhs? How come many look at other women with lust yet sit in the sangat doing simran for hours? Justify your words Best Regards One upset person

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

(():)>>> · 27 May 2005

Stranger - no is saying your mum is a bad person... Guru Gobind singh ji himself tied a dastaar on Mata Bhag Kaur ji, so it must have some meaningful purpose in sikhi.

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

stranger · 27 May 2005

(():)>>> If this factor was so important how come it is not stipulated clearly in the Akal Takhat Rehit? Has anyone ever heard of the old saying: 'Never judge a book by its cover' ??

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

kaur · 27 May 2005

Who is Bibi J Kaur

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

singh · 27 May 2005

keskhy is kakar and a rehit every gursikh shud accept. Your mom might be great with her bhagti and she is great, but without keskhy her rehit isnt any good at all. u need to re-search why akaal takhat and SGPC give amrit to ppl without kakars.

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

... · 27 May 2005

stranger, I think you need to calm down. No one is saying anything about your mother. The original post is about someone who was wearing a dastaar and perhaps had a hukam to wear one, who later made it into an optional thing just for show purposes. It is about the absurd practice of tying a kangha to your kirpan. Your mother has nothing to do with any of this, so relax.

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

stranger · 27 May 2005

Sorry Singh I am from the main stream where 5th K is Kesh not Keski hence as far as i am concerned no kakar is missing Just like Raag mala is a part of the Great SGGS Ji is should read. Don;t get me wrong - I like attanding AKJ kirtan programs and the kirtan is uplifting. But I will reemphasise that judging a person based on the outlook is rather shallow and at the end of one persons life he/she will be brought in front of Dharm Raj who will decide if they did right or wrong. Before looking at other people look at yourself in the mirror. Gur Fateh

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

stranger · 27 May 2005

... Please refer to Sister's posting to understand my response. That posting is pointing at all women including our mothers.....!

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" · 27 May 2005

Never judge a book by its cover.... YES right..but that cuts BOTH ways..( maybe thats the reason the KHANDA has such a big significance in Sikhe ) ...How ? 1. There is an outer "roop" or Bhekh 2. There is the INNER ROOP...full of Naam kamaai, free of Vikaars like Kaam Krodh, Lobh, Moh , Hankaar, full of humility, Love compassion,capable of "seeing" and yet make "unseen", capable of suffering yet make "unsuffered"...and a THOUSAND other things... WHICH of the 2 above is EASIER ?? Does one have to DO ANYTHING to let the hair grow uncut ? Rather one has to put in an EFFORT to CUT IT. Does one have much effort put in .. in wearing a kangha/karrra/kirpan/kachhera ?? maybe a bit effort in Kirpan and kachera..but KARRA is worn even by many Non-Sikhs..and kangha is used by everyone How about doing Naam kamaii....EASY ?? show me how Get free of hankaar/lobh/moh/haumaiego/anger/ ?? EASY ?? show me how.. Even some of the greatest rishis and holy men couldnt control their kaam, anger and ego...how could that be "easy" ?? YET..people are NEVER tired of saying..DONT JUDGE a book by its COVER ?? I will tell YOU..it is a THOUSAND times EASIER to make a "COVER" than to WRITE the actual BOOK. I can sit at my computer....and using Photoshop/Illustrator/Adobe pagemaker...WHIP up a THOUSAND FANTASTIC "BOOK COVERS" in a week..in fact create an entire Library of Congress in a MONTH...BUT can I "WRITE" even a CHAPTER..let alone a complete bOOK in a day/week/month/year ?? Only God KNOWS..I have been trying for 50 years and still havent written a single book..BUT "covers" ??i have lost count of how many ?? SO who says a "book cover" = "Book CONTENTS" ?? this equation is FALSE...totally FALSE. But it is equally true that IF one deigns the "cover" FIRST.... it will be easier to WRITE the BOOK becasue the COVER in ESSENCE is the entire BOOK..BUT you have to WORK REALLY HARD.... SIKHE is the same...the outer ROOP is the "cover"..easy to ADOPT ( many Amrit Sanchaars worldwide turn people into "INSTANT AMRITDHAREES.... i doubt if anyone on this Board has NOT HEARD the phrase....Flanneh ne Ainey LAKHAAN NU Amrit chhakaiya...flanneh ne 300,000 sikh baniyeh...flanneh ne 1.7 million sikh baniyeh..etc etc..This is Talking about COVERS...When GURU JI INVITED the sangat in 1699...over 80,000 turned up... ( the covers so to speak..)..BUT when the actual BOOK began to be written FIVE stepped forward... How to become an instant "cover".... tie a dastaar ( underneath no long hair..who cares ??), the REMAINING kakaars can be had at the amrit sanchaar place..the entire process just takes about two hours at the most..BUT conquering YOUR Kaam/Krodh/Anger/Humlity/Ego/Lobh/.....even an entire LIFETIME is NOT ENOUGH ?? so you do the MATHS ?? which is easier ?? OUTSIDE or INSIDE ?? MY Conclusion.... anyone who CANNOT keep the OUTSIDE REHIT...CANNOT be a success at keeping the INSIDE REHIT....NO WAY. No body who cant even design a simple "cover".....is capable of "writing" a fantastic BOOK !!! Even GURU JI has given us the Practical Example of a DONKEY in a Lion's Skin..that BOTH outer and Inner rehit must go hand in hand..or one is just a DONKEY in Lion's skin or a LION in a Donkey's skin !!! IN Fact GURU JI began work on our INSIDE...250 YEARS of hard work..1429 aangs of Shabad Guru as the Perfect GUIDE, and Bani of So many Bhagats Bhatts as advice on HOW to Live the INSIDE LIFE....and then CAPPED this all up with Vasakhi 1699 where we received the OUTER REHIT as COMPULSORY. GURU SAHIB and the Puratan Sikhs...our Beloved SAHIBZADAHS have PAID FULL PRICE of this OUTER REHIT/Inner REHIT...our Beloved SIKHI DA MEHL ( Palace of Gurmatt) is FULLY PAID FOR with the BLOOD of these martyrs...with the "mortgage" fully paid for..we the RESIDENTS of this palace just have to keep up with the "maintenance"..?? I am sure we cna do that..or we are most ungrateful sons on this earth. For the Most part..the Akal Takaht Rehit is Complete ( in fact I am a Singh that chhhak Amrit according to AT maryada)..for the sake of "satisfying everybody and ensurign conformity and peace unity in the Guru Khalsa panth, our foresighted forefathers correctly made the maryada "flexible" so that it is accomodating to all..THIS is the BASIC MINIMUM...one can GO BEYOND..BUT NOT LESS than it. Just like in a university where there are 100 places and the Basic MINIMUM entry requirement is 3 A Levels..BUT if there are 150 people with 10 A Levels A Grades... who in his right mind will give entry to one who has only 3 a levels even if THAT is the written entry requirement ?? No body is stopping you from the basic maryada...but you will know the difference of going beyond it.

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

singh · 27 May 2005

I think sikhi in that sence is lost then, no one knows how to research anymore, no one can be bothered, once you research properly u will know the truth... i dont think u have reseacherd anything to make that statement of keskhy not bring kakar and kesh being kakar

Re: Don't be like Bibi J. Kaur!

Sister · 27 May 2005

Stranger Ji, In the above post I am merely refering to women who care more about the way they look, than about rehit. It was not meant to insult your mother or mine or anybody elses, you need to calm down and keep an open mind. Btw my mom doesn't tie a dastaar either and it is for that very reason, in her heart she knows its the right thing to do.....most ppl do but they give into social pressures. If you and your family choose not to tie a dastaar because of the rehit you were prescribed................what can I say................the problem ends up being more than one versions of the gurmat rehit maryada..............and only Guru sahib can fix this problem