prototypical singhni
confused kaur · 22 May 2005
there are alot of people telling me i should be like this, be like that...that a real singhni does 'this' and doesnt do 'that'...that my thinking is too westernized, that im not traditional enough....
so what exactly is a 'real singhni' living in western society, how should she be? what are her values, what does she do, what are her beliefs, how should she be with her family, parents, friends? should she not speak to guys at all, or can she choose her own husband by getting to know someone? + other things...
i understand she should be the 'best' sikh she should be, but im speaking realistically of someone living in this society with the same problems other girls/women go through....
Re: prototypical singhni
oneandonlyme · 24 May 2005
i think that you should take what u've been taought and try to somehow fit it in to u're own values. Some things can be mordernlizes, and others can't. I think u shouldn't really try to find a guy for your self, but tell u're parents what kind of person u want. Then try and ge to know that guy, and decide if he is right for u.
Re: prototypical singhni
Punjabi Nation · 24 May 2005
see what happens when you drop the punjabiat? you get coconut sikhs who do not know how to be and get confused.
on a side note Dating is maha paap it ruins peoples families, ruins your bhagti, makes one apostate, it brings besti to the whole sikh quam amritdharis doing this it is sick and horrible act, if dating is right, what governs it? liking someone? what would you like from dating someone attraction? outside shell? what about the gursikh rehat? raini baini which is a long term thing that dictates compatibility.
If you wish to marry get fixed the proper sikh way, singhs and kaurs have died for dastars not for us to walk around dating like romeo juliets parading hand in hand hugging and smooching.
Re: prototypical singhni
Harsimrat Kaur · 24 May 2005
Gurfateh ji,
What my dad has always asked me is;
'what is stronger the words of people or the words of god?'
Obviously it's the word of god so follow what guru ji tells you and don't care what others think as your only going to know them for a short period of time during your lif; where as guru ji is always going to be there.....everyday!!!!
Hope this helps and sorry if i said anyhting wrong.
Gurfateh ji.
Re: prototypical singhni
Kulbir Singh · 25 May 2005
--------------
so what exactly is a 'real singhni' living in western society, how should she be? what are her values, what does she do, what are her beliefs, how should she be with her family, parents, friends? should she not speak to guys at all, or can she choose her own husband by getting to know someone? + other things...
-------------
If a rose flower grows in Canada instead of India, would it have a different fragrance and a different form? When the British went to India many hundred years ago, did they adopt the Hindustani culture or did they influence the Indians to adopt their culture? Now that we have come to the Western countries, why should we adopt their culture? Is our Khalsa culture inferior to their uncivilised culture that we should adopt it? We must stick to the Khalsa culture that Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj has blessed us with. This Western culture is a rotten culture that only besharams (ones who have no shame) can adopt.
A Singhnee or a Guru kee bachee (Guru Sahib's daughter) in Canada or UK should be exactly like another Guru kee Bachee in India would be. It does not matter where Khalsa is residing. Khalsa always must stay unique and must not let negative influence from outside infiltrate inside him or her. Khalsa must stay Khalsa no matter where Khalsa goes. Whether Khalsa is living in Congo or Antartica, Canada or India, Bombay or London, Siri Amritsar or Toronto, Khalsa must stay strict in Khalsa rehit and must keep the social values that our Guru Sahibaan and puraatan Gursikhs kept.
As for speaking to guys, there is no need to talk to guys on casual basis. Talking in private to unrelated (related by blood) guys is wrong and must be avoided. If she is working, then there is nothing wrong in carrying out business related conversation with co-employees or the management.
As for finding her husband herself, it is not appropriate for a Singhnee to do so. It is important that she has full say in this matter but this matter must be taken care of by her parents and elder gursikhs.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: prototypical singhni
shera di komb marna ya jeena · 25 May 2005
There is no such thing as a western or traditional singhani.
there is only one singhani she who follows the rightful conduct or aims and agrees to. How can there be a western singhani then such imbalance most likely alter and conflict/transgress values with changing our concepts a shift from the original position. It is upto the western born or cultured person to change from her position towards the culture which comes into sikhi to strive for the right change back to her home.
although i agree minimal change is required for suitability to function in the land . However even Moderating bit by bit can also lead to destruction of our heritage into bigger picture which unfolds later, for whome we have a duty to our offspring to pass forward our pathway laid before us.
WE have started to accept and tolerate too much already that we are now blinded by western moderation that we cannot see certain things are wrong for example the disease of tight robes, too much intermingling of opposite genders under the blanket of equality, this system is also abused by pervy men giving girls hugs and claiming she is "like my sister" then after you realise, to say but a few.
So to keep the unique path we cannot even think of westernising ourselves then we will be open to suggestion and change dictated by society, market trend setters, and so forth, this is a dangerous step consider the recent gay debate, the attitude of sikhs on love marriages, soon we will start seeing some sikhs campaigning its fine to go clubbing. The day will dawn upon such supporters of these, where maya ensares them by her teeth, then such supporters will come hurrieing back realising their errors.
the only way is to deny western culture then to fight and struggle against it with all your might everyday with the might of the culture you have been born and blessed into. Then to live with what you are at the cost of sacrificing worldly comforts. This life is a test which may come to an end at any time God willing. The lapse begun with those in front of us they felt they need to change and be a little like gorey now we have lost the plot and need return back to our rightful position after we understand that we cannot function without our unique culture.
Gora culture is pure filth, it is the gora themselves who now change themselves fed up of its fakeness yet the mass of our brothers and sisters fall prey to it.
In the land of the Gurus rose millions of martyrs throughout time, self sacrifice, warriors, sages, great people with vision and poets. Our most gallant shaheed veers and bhainjis from the 1980s were deathless beings smiling with supreme confidence in the face of oppression, they as bold as lions and lionesses were reared form the soils of punjab with its unique culture, if such a culture can produce a few hundred thousand such powerful beings that can shake the very foundations of a corrupt state then surely that culture given to us should be a source of strentgh that we should enivsion and carry forward and taste its glory.
Re: prototypical singhni
Gondal Baar · 27 May 2005
of course you can have an education career family and be active in politics pk it is your birthright but obviously we must strike a balance and not become too westernised for our own good. It is not change for good we are worried about its the ganth that comes with it.
Re: prototypical singhni
khokkrah ne sehr baddya · 27 May 2005
love marriages promote lust and make it look like its ok to shag around and freedom to do what we want under a dastaar.
most of these love marriages are not innocent they involve dating anc checking about, but we have to keep our shtum shut because its besti and no one will do anything about it. I know a singh and singhani who even dated and two timed behind their partners backs and now getting married but do kirtan with vaja in the light, how tapped is that? no ones gonna say anything vbecause they know people, but no one will lissen to people like us because we are the minority within a minoirity .
the problem is if our young veer naujwaan ask them about their happy marriages later they will just promote dating as a method for a successful marriage.
but it is wrong, every part of it. daters should stop fooling the rest of us.
how can it be aight to date and then be on the dharnic vibe in front of everyone else?
i would like to say education works but it dont, cos people dont give a tats they laugh at us because they know the majority will turn a blind eye. Why are we not serious enough about it? how can khalsa raj come when we are this pathetic state that we cannot stop our own youth dating and committing krehet?
There has to be serious punishment this should be a crime against sikhi it is oppossing Guru jis gurmat path as one of the four cardinal sins. our gora brains have been changed and made to think its ok. 20 years ago one bandah would get chopped for dating a kurri, 50 years ago they would get chopped for even eyeing up a kurri. Why do you think those days were so good and we had control and guys and gurls did not dare mess around ( ass much as today anyway). so where physical l josh goes down vice will rise cos people will be free physically to do what they want all under their new hippy gora type values.
we have lost our dhamm.
that dhamm needs to come back. education against dating helps only somewhat with few serious people, but most do still date. we need physical power . If we accept dating then we have to accept that sexual attraction has no regional language, or religion, it senses and picks up from habits, which means the day will come when more people will start dating out of religions as is happening in england. we need urgent ways to arrest the process otherwise we will get swallaowed up we minority as it is.
Re: prototypical singhni
tikhee talwaar de otte jeena · 29 May 2005
the singhani should not give into media pressure.
she should read sikh digest and panthic magazines, especially reflecting on sikh itihas, values, and current sikh situation and stop reading western materials like women mags, extreme feminism mags and athiest writers. She should discriminate about the company she has and never bow to society as then her resolve and will in the path to God may become weaker where compromises on a subtle level arise.
she should first reflect upon sikhi live it and speak loud as a sikh and not be afraid to talk. sikhs do not encourage women to be bound or gagged however her speech should reflect piousness, rightesnous dharm, courage, martial spirit, with a balance of her feminity guided by gurmat, and most of all keep bibek of buddhi in all respects, learn off elder gursikh role models such as the panj and try to keep sangat of elder bibia who keep rehat.
I think we should start doing seperate camps for the naujwaan sikh males and females. This will filtyer out serious sikhs who come to learn and hopefully dicourage people coming for dodgy reasons and also keep sikhs singularly focused on their mission with no distractions at young ages. When the mission is clear and nothing remains in the path then the will strengthens to reach the goal.
although the sikh female is equal, she is also a bearer of the future peehri along with that comes a lot of responsibility of passing on her heritage towards the next generation.