namdhari's??? amrit???
14 · 20 May 2005
this is goin 2 sound like a realllllly dumb question but can namdharis amritshakna but still be namdharis and can they can they be a part of the 5 pyarai. Thanx 2 every 1 in advance ;)
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
14 · 20 May 2005
this is goin 2 sound like a realllllly dumb question but can namdharis amritshakna but still be namdharis and can they can they be a part of the 5 pyarai. Thanx 2 every 1 in advance ;)ekta · 20 May 2005
nope they belive in a deh dhari guru.... guru ji gave hukumn that guru manyo granth.17 · 20 May 2005
namdharis are amrathari, they too shak amrit and have amrit sanchars, nobody ever researches this stuff,raj karega khalsa · 21 May 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh yes, ppl who were formerly naamdharis can take amrit, but then they giv their heds to sri guru granth sahib ji maharaj, so no they cant b naamdharis aftr that...n bout bein in the punj piare, the punj piare shud b tyar-bar-tyar singhs or singhnis who hav 100% faith in sri guru granth sahib ji maharaj, not sum dehdhari guru...17 yea they may have naamdhari amrit sanchars but its not amrit that guru gobind singh ji blessed us wit, they are not sikhs Bhull Chaak Maph Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fatehkar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 21 May 2005
nobody who believes in any other Guru after Guru Granth Sahib ji is an amritdhari or a Khalsa of Guru Gobind Singh ji guru sahib ji came in only 10 human suroops there is forever "shabad suroop" "aad jugaad jot" "jugo jug attal" guru granth sahib jee maharaj as far as humans now, only the guru's khalsa can be seen as the guru's suroop and even that is Five rehitdharee khalsa in the hajooree of guru granth sahib jee maharaaj no other human suroop of the guru exists on this world. and anybody who follows another human as a "successor" to guru gobind singh sahib jee is going against the hukams of guru gobind singh jee. they are "bikhdhari" (submitted to poison) and "dayhdhari" (belief in human guru) but definitely not "amritdhari" (submitted to the immortal nectar of truth) ohnaa nae "jhootth" noo dhaaryaa hai, "sach" noo nahee. they have become adherents of falsehood, not truth . guru sahib jee kirpa karan naanak naam chardee kalaa thaerae bhaaNay sarbat daa bhalaa vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!. · 21 May 2005
After 1699 The Punj Piaray gave Amrit (Khanday thee Pahul) in The Presence of Siri Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Jee up till 1708. In 1708 Siri Guru Gobind Singh Sahib Jee gave Guru Ga(- thee) to Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee and went to SachKhand on the same Throne as Akaal Purkh. After 1708 The Punj Piaray have been giving Amrit (Khanday thee Pahul) in The Presence of Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee up till now and will carry on doing so in the Future. So Called naamdhaarees do not believe in Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee to be Guru which makes their amrit sanchaars void and who ever takes that amrit does not become a Sikh of Siri Guru Granth Sahib Jee.singh · 21 May 2005
guru maniyo granth is kuchi bani, why reffer to that dohra which was made by some 1 other than the guru. SHABAD GURU SURUT DUN CHELA. naamdharis do beieleve in amrit and they do take it but its nothing to do with the khalsa panth becuz they are not part of it. They do not wear kirpans only a small toothpick of a kirpan in there kangas. WORST THING IS they believe guru gobind singh never took amrit himself... naamdharis shudnt be spoked to at all as they are DUSHTS of the panth such as narkhdharis and darshan dasis. If a naamdhari does talk to u, the only reason he does is to convert - im speaking thru experience. The only TRUE amrit is Guru Gobind singhs amrit - no other amrit can match it. VAHO VAHO BANI NIRAKAAR HE TIS JEVAD AVAR NA KOE. BANI GURU, GURU HE BANI. VICH BANI AMRITSARE DHAN DHAN SATGURU GRANTH SAHIB MAHARAJ!!!!!!! (the only true guru of the universe)a singh · 21 May 2005
is it okay to listen to kirtan done by namdhari's?? afterall, the Gurbani which they are singing is from the King of all Kings. i was just wondering..... thanks.singh · 21 May 2005
no they are not amritdhari, they dont beleive in guru granth sahib as the guru so how can the amrit be true? naamdharis are not part of the panth so how can they be khalsa14 · 21 May 2005
17 wrote: >nobody ever researches this stuff, sorry did not mean 2 offend any 1 was jus interestedsingh · 22 May 2005
I dont think you can listen to them do kirtan. What laha do u get from the person doing kirtan? its like saying reading half of jap ji sahib and thats it. they do not put full faith in they bani they sing so there isnt much laha.34 · 22 May 2005
where is the HARD evidence that there was even an amrit sanchar in 1699, we was no there, how do we know that the guru granth sahib ji was the last guru, and not the namdhari guru, we was'nt there.Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" · 23 May 2005
34 ?? were YOU there when GURU NANAK JI was BORN in 1469 ?? so WHERE is the HARD EVIDENCE ?? How do we know ?/ "we wasnt there" as you said ?? HOW "HARD" do you want the evidence to be... Some one once asked a Prof.where is the Hard evidence that God exists...I havent seen him and you havent seen him and ... The Prof asked him.... Do you have a MIND ? have you seen it ? has anyone else seen it ?? Do you have a MIND ?? Give me some Hard evidence and I will give you mine.16 · 23 May 2005
exactly Singh!!!!!!!!!!!!!, we don't know even if God exsists, I happy that someone actually agrees for a changeKhalsa_Force · 23 May 2005
dear veerji, dont take as insult or something, please but u question guru ji. wht if i ask u , is he whom u call father is ur real father? u were not there !!! ur mom said and u believed it, jst ur mom and so many evidences and gursikhs saying abt amrit sanchar is lie? dont they hv any credibility? fatehTiger_Force · 23 May 2005
But your mother and father are not your real parents, God is your father and mother, the parents we have now just brought us in to life??????????????Khalsa_Force · 24 May 2005
tiger ji, chalo tusi das dio, wht the proof the God is our mother father? were u there? hv u seen God? let 34 answer it.Ex Namdhari · 24 May 2005
amrit of naamdharis is not the same as KHANDE DA PHAUL. i was given naamdhari amrit when i was a little kid and i remember a havan (or barnee as it is called). i remember an axe being used to stir the amrit and then a mala being out over my neck. we never said Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh. i remember saying satgur ram singh chardi kala tere banay sarbat da bhala. i am pretty sure that there were seven naamdharis stirring the amrit and not punj. i think there were more banis done to definetly chandi di vaar. anyways naamdhari maryaday is way different from the KHALSA maryada. i've been there. it's not just about the extra gurus. i had GURUJI's kirpa and last year i was blessed with AMRIT from the PUNJ PYARAY. i was reborn into the KHALSA PANTH.A Singh · 24 May 2005
Namdharis under Baba Ram Singh was part and parcel of the Khalsa Panth and largely responsible for reviving the pristine maryada of Guru Gobind Singh’s Khalsa and in fact amongst the first in the Sikh masses of Punjab to openly rebel against the many un-Sikh practices that had crept in under the Sikh Raj of Ranjit Singh and with it the rise of Jat peasantry to military and landowning pseudo-aristocracy bringing with them their inherent pagan traditions and of course, the presently well publicised “Sanatan†era. In a nutshell, Baba Ram Singh Namdhari sought to reinstall faith in Gurbani, Simran and Kirtan (as per GurMaryada). They strongly opposed all pagan customs such as Ancestor Worship, faith in Pirs and their Samadhs (all ‘accepted’ by the then ‘Sanatan Sikh leaders’) –which they would publicly destroy in broad daylight and a whole host of other ‘ills’ from alcoholism to female infanticide and discrimination against women. Baba Ram was also responsible for mass initiation of women into the Khalsa Panth and also introducing wedding ceremonies which sought to rid the pressures of expense and elaborate functions (one of the many factors which led to people killing baby daughters –foolish peasant folk would deem them as a burden owing to such social pressures). Also, Namdharis of Baba Ram Singh, some 60 years before Gandhi and his anti-British movement had begun the customs of boycotting foreign goods and wearing only homespun clothes, they were bibekis and also fighting for the restoration of Sikh/Khalsa Raj. These were the “Sant Khalsa†under Baba Ram Singh Namdhari, however today their descendents are quite different and many of the theories concerning Baba Ram Singh’s reforms, like other personality cults existing within the Sikh world today, have been altered and adjusted by the katar-followers using a whole manner and host of supposed literature and supporting evidence. The lines “Guru Maneyo Granth†come from the writings of Gyani Gyan Singh, who has also written extensively about Namdharis and speak of them as part of the Panth, clearly however issues such as Dehdhari Guruship etc were not as manifest at the time. Today, Namdharis are perhaps best known for the maintenance of Shudh Kirtan Maryada, Simran (swas-gras) and Santhia –which are worth acknowledging, unfortunately however they have also chosen to maintain their theories on Guruship and history of Guru Gobind Singh giving rise to their presently ostracised position, which of course one should be wary of --however we should be careful to ensure that we apply the correct accusations against them (re: they do not wear kirpans, they don’t take amrit, they don’t believe in Gurbani etc) as to defeat any opponent requires a thorough understanding of both yourself and them. Gur Fateh! A SinghKhalsa_Force · 24 May 2005
have any of namdhari babas written BANI? if yes? where is it and of wht standard? if no? then why not? they r sent by God they shd put forward KHASAM ki bani.