Re: orange hajooria
Jugraj Singh · 26 May 2005
First of all, let me apologize to the readers... my dislike for all things anti-panthic has leaked into my writing and as I re-read some of the messages, it is clear that the my sentiments have made the thread harder to follow.
In anycase, this apology is most definitely not extended to "A Singh".
Now A Singh,
You said,
>>>>
Those quotes are not from me, there are a number of "A Singh" posters on this forums, so kindly use your "bibek budhi" to understand this and not jump to conclusions.
>>>>
Now you've claimed that those quotes are not from you and you were quick to distance yourself from any implication that you might have written them. This means that you obviously agree that they were written by someone who supports Niddar and is out to hurt the panth (as it is clear from the quotes).
Now keeping that in mind, anyone with even an iota of analyzing ability can decipher your writing style. Those quotes are definitely from you. Though I agree that "A Singh" is probably used by more then one person.
It is simply a matter of comparing an excerpt from one of your messages on this board to some of your previous posts.
Here are some previous posts under "A Singh".
>>>
"
Krishna has also sponsered Nidar Singh's latest article on the traditional talvar. Which you can read in MAI latest march edition.
If Krishna has recognised this deadly art, then why ignore this fact - ask Krishna what his opinion of Nidar Singh is?
"
Here is another example,
"
The UK sikh leaders should hold a National Press Conference and try to undo the negativity that the UK media has cast on a very small minority of protestors.
Perhaps Inderjit Singh,who speaks on Radio 4, or Nihang Niddar Singh?
"
I've also included a subtle insult that you tried to pass off towards bana wearing bhain's and mata's.
"
Why is our AKJ jatha one of the leading jathas where men and women are equal in the khalsa ranks and wear the same bana, not like others where the women look like women!
"
>>>
Now compare those, especially the last one to this:
>>>
Whilst the rehit is derived from the principals of Gurmat, talking about things in terms of “anti-Gurmat†is labelling everything into black and white categories –this is precisely the type of talk one can expect from Mohammedans and right wing Christian and Hindu fundamentalists.
>>>
Your strategy is clear. Here you've tried to associate "bibek buddhi" to Hindu fundamentalis and right wing Christians and in the previous posts you tried to insult bana wearing bibi's.
Let me give a breakdown of how you write. Even if some people want to entertain the idea that you are some other "A Singh" it'll give them a heads up.
It is usually an ambiguous post though you usually include a statement or two to give you an anchoring point when people start to tear apart your messages. You (and some others, eg. Avidya) will usually form your posts around a technical detail (like rehit / rules) and try to confuse readers and plant seeds of doubt.
When someone shows how illogical your reasoning is, you usually make statments like, "you've failed to answer any of my questions" without backing them up.
As for the rest of your post. Its not worth dissecting.
Oh, we agree on one thing. This discussion is dragging a bit.