Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Akaal · 22 May 2005

Dassan Daas! Yo! Lets make a jatha like other sants. Lets get some dholkis, shennas, some chele and become sant babas. It is awesome man! Look at the respect they get. Even if they something wrong, it is always backed up by chele by saying our sant mahapurakh brahmgiani baba ji said so so it is right. There are other things that need to be discussed. A plan is needed but I say become sant baba brahmgiani for sure. Kathavaachaks don't get respect even of they do the greatest katha ever. Sant baba, say history in their own version and still get praises. Awesome! Sant Baba Dassan Daas Ji Mahapurakh Brahmgiani 108 Canadaa Walay! Sant Baba Kulbir Singh Ji Mahapurakh Brahmgiani 108 Canadaa Walay! - Good way to get people to believe that Raagmaala isn't bani. Try it!

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" · 23 May 2005

Dear Akaal jio, Came across this on a net.. apparently dhund is getting less... Qualifications of a Sant: 1. He must be a celibate 2. He must not dress as a householder. He should wear white Khaddar Kurta Pajama/Kachehra 3. He must singh Kachi Bani 4. He must know what people want to hear. 5. He must be a clever psychologist. 6. He must have rural looks, must not be highly educated and analytic because by being the latter a person can read Gurbani with an open mind and come to the conclusion that Gurbani doesnot aim at making us "Sants" but aims at making us Gurmukhs. People are wasting time buying TRUCKS and Lorries Busses etc..to make money ..IN PUNJAB it is much better and faster wealth to just "get one or two SANT BABAS"..and send them out to make money for you..first make about 300 VCD/DVDs of his kirtan/katha/entertaining fables/myths....and then follow up with a TOUR of CANADA ( more interesting if you add a story that he came on FOOT/Bicycle/ etc..)...and you are set...hummers and merc and bmw's plus sacks of money..cold hard cash...more than a fleet of 100 trucks will make in a hundred years...

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

dassandas · 23 May 2005

And Remeber it's all TAX FREE !!!

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

S Singh · 23 May 2005

You forgot to add that you also have to get thousands of colour posters printed which describe you as Mahapursh Sant Baba ________ Singh Maharaj Bramgiani _____wale. Plaster 10 of these on every wall you can find in a busy place like a bus station. Repeat this process until all your posters are used up. Employ a few people good at gossip who can spread rumour quickly. Tell them to spread a rumour how this baba has lived in a pora/cave etc without outside contact for 10 years but is now going to come out and tour the west. Devise a strategy to draw in the crowds. If you are going to Canada or Europe, pretend you was close to Baba Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale and have met him a few weeks ago, make a few statements against the GOI. It works a treat and brings in the moola. The youth in the west get so excited that they will defend you from anyone exposing your misdeeds.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

can't think of a name.. · 23 May 2005

Er, looks like some people have abit too much time on their hands..

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" · 23 May 2005

[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani] Bhai gurdass wrote: Satgur Nank Pargitiya..MITTII DHUND jaag Channan HOIYA.. 500 Years later the DHUND is so much MORE than the Channann.. The other day I was discussing religions with a Christian Minister ( He invited me to attend His church's 75th Anniversary celebrations..as I had sent him a condolence message on John Paul's death..)...and this is what he said.. Mr. Singh, of what you have told me, SIKHE looks like it is a Religion of KNOWLEDGE...unlike other religions i know about... YES...SIKHE is the ONLY religion about GYAN..More GYAN and still More GYAN......And Bhai Gurdass Ji is trying to tell us the exact same thing..Mitti DHUND...( of Falsehood/rituals/emptyness..) and replaced with the SOORAJ OF GYAN...KNOWLEDGE... A SIKH who doesnt LEARN GURBANi and read it for Himself as the GURUS INSTRUCTED, and then Practise its values..and Live the JEEWAN JAACH...is living in DARKNESS...and all those empty RITUALS of... ghee jyots ) SHUDH DESI GHEE NO LESS!!)..red cloths and pitchers of water to make amrit, and coconuts and conches....are all the same DHUND to OBSCURE GYAN of GURBANI.....and no prizes for guessing who INSISTS on all these rituals and darknesses...the same old Brahmin/Mullah/kazi in disguise as a....Chola/ gol pugg /kachhera wearing....GYANI OF BRAHM !!!!...GURU JI the SUPREME BRAHMGYANI joined us DIRECT to BRAHMGIAN through GURBANI...no need for any others to hold our fingers to lead us to the right path... And while i am at it.... ONLY SIKHE...being religion of GYAN..can STAND TALL on the INTERNET....where at the single click of a mouse...EVERYTHING FALSE can be instantly FOUND OUT...ONLY SIKHE/GURBANI stands FIRM and TALL...no false hopes, no false sciences rituals that cannot be explained, no flase promises, no MIRACLES to be accepted on FAITH..NO DHUND..just PURE LIGHT of GYAN..RABBII GYAN direct from SOURCE certified and Stamped "TRUE COPY" by our GURUS. Internet as the New MEDIUM of LIGHT has an effect..so keep at it...keep on spreading GYAN...Do the GURU's WORK... [gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani] PS. in case any of you are wondering why i have been writing [gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani] instead of the ususal Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh... I came across an article that proved that in WRITING this is the accepted fateh while the Complete fateh is a BOLAWA compulsory among TWO SIKHS when they MEET FACE TO FACE...I searched all WRITINGS and came to the conclusion that this is right..ONLy the Internet boards use the full fateh, while Bhai Veer Singh ji and all others used the Ek onkar Waheguru ji ki fateh..and began their writigns. so i made the change.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

indy · 23 May 2005

sant kaa nindak mahaa attaa-ee. The slanderer of the Saint is the worst evil-doer. sant kaa nindak khin tikan na paa-ee. The slanderer of the Saint has not even a moment's rest. sant kaa nindak mahaa hati-aaraa. The slanderer of the Saint is a brutal butcher. sant kaa nindak parmaysur maaraa. The slanderer of the Saint is cursed by the Transcendent Lord. sant kaa nindak raaj tay heen. The slanderer of the Saint has no kingdom. sant kaa nindak dukhee-aa ar deen. The slanderer of the Saint becomes miserable and poor. sant kay nindak ka-o sarab rog. The slanderer of the Saint contracts all diseases. sant kay nindak ka-o sadaa bijog. The slanderer of the Saint is forever separated. sant kee nindaa dokh meh dokh. To slander a Saint is the worst sin of sins. naanak sant bhaavai taa us kaa bhee ho-ay mokh. ||3|| O Nanak, if it pleases the Saint, then even this one may be liberated. ||3|| sant kaa dokhee sadaa apvit. The slanderer of the Saint is forever impure. sant kaa dokhee kisai kaa nahee mit. The slanderer of the Saint is nobody's friend. sant kay dokhee ka-o daan laagai. The slanderer of the Saint shall be punished. sant kay dokhee ka-o sabh ti-aagai. The slanderer of the Saint is abandoned by all. sant kaa dokhee mahaa ahaNkaaree. The slanderer of the Saint is totally egocentric. sant kaa dokhee sadaa bikaaree. The slanderer of the Saint is forever corrupt. sant kaa dokhee janmai marai. The slanderer of the Saint must endure birth and death. sant kee dookhnaa sukh tay tarai. The slanderer of the Saint is devoid of peace. sant kay dokhee ka-o naahee thaa-o. The slanderer of the Saint has no place of rest. naanak sant bhaavai taa la-ay milaa-ay. ||4|| O Nanak, if it pleases the Saint, then even such a one may merge in union. ||4|| I dont know if anyone in this world is a Sant or not, but is it worth the risk? Our people (including myself more often than others) lack the ability to not type/talk when we dont need to.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Khalsa_Force · 24 May 2005

FINALLY !!! jisda dar c ohi hoia. ppl starting comparing this Latest Sensation in SANT world ranjit with shaheed bhai jarnail singh ji bhindraanwaale. ih te ohna di jutti warga v nahi. another thing which is hard to understand 1) why sikh sangat labeled any1 gursikh from times of 10 GURU JIs and even a century after that, even in RAAJ of maharaja Ranjit Singh as SANT. 2) why only when BRITISH were ruling us? 3) why we c BHAI SAHIB or even BABA JI word so LOWER to word SANT when we assign this to PEOPLE we follow and take as our mentors. 4) Sant is not PREFIX which can b used infront of name, its like we say" ih banda rab da roop hai" does tht mean we fix RAB BABA ABCD SINGH JI 108? same way goes for SANT, it was like he is SANT roop. now if i say tht child is sweet like a ROSE, shd i start calling him ROSE AMAN KAUR/SINGH. 5) These so called BABAS of 1900 (+/- 25years) have ruined Sikhi and they call other MALECH khalsa and influenced by British? we can only laugh at tht. 6) Why we celebrate Bdays of these Bhekhis as AVTAAR DIHARAS? on competetion with GURPURBS. these sampradas dont even celebrate GURPURBS with tht intensity and media attention. in last few months it was BDAY of so called founder of DERAWAAD and BHORA/CELEBATE baba and they started advertising abt it atleast 2 weeks in advance and was TELECAST LIVE on a PRIVATE CHANNEL. from where does all this money comes?to pay private channels? and expensive airtime for ads?LAND CRUISERS and 15+ lakh cars r often seen with them. 7) when TATA SAFARI was launched in India, first car i saw was with CHITTA CHOLLA, GOL DASTAR babas. then when FORD launched SUV ENDEIVOUR (14 lakhs) again the first car i saw was same ppl. Aj lai aina hi, Fateh.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Bundha · 24 May 2005

In Kalyug people will do mega kumai of paap. Even those people who call themselves gursikh (or in a lot of cases those who will say they are the lowest of the low) will kumma paap oblivious and blind to what they are doing and all the time they will repeat the matra of “we are rooting out the fakes, the nakkli, the frauds” whereas infact they are the fakes, the nakkli the frauds. To all those I say, carry on with your nindhia and your sarcastic remarks (it must make you feel really good and superior inside) and keep accumulating the pundha of paap. You may have long flowing beards, youe may look the epitome of a Gursikh, you may even do ten Sukhmani Sahibs a day, but in the end your nindhia will bring you down and you will leave this world with nothing.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Khalsa_force · 24 May 2005

Why do nanaksarias have Schools name after ISHAR singh and not Sri Guru Nanak dev ji. one reason i c that these schools r no different from EXPENSIVE but mentally cheap public schools and cant not b named after Sri Guru Nanak Devi ji but ................ ;)

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

A Singh · 24 May 2005

Gur Fateh! The Sant issue is a matter best dealt with care –needless slander and sarcasm doesn’t help the matter nor does gross generalisations. I will openly state from the outset that I do not belong to any Sant-affiliated Jatha, Institution or Taksal, however have on a number of occasions met with “sants”, “Babas” and “Bhai Sahibs” (effectively all the same person given the manner in which their followers speak of them, treat them, their ‘bachans’ and prostate themselves before them). As with anything in life, everything is open to abuse and the title “Sant” is no different –because this term wasn’t in vogue during the Guru period is not necessarily a reason for its dismissal. There are many other terms and customs not prevalent during the Guru period that are now commonplace amongst all Sikhs which do not necessarily need to be removed. More importantly, abuse of title and character is not limited to only ‘sant’, the following terms and positions and titles have been also subject to similar abuse and misrepresentation;- Amritdhari, Gyani, Jathedar, Khalsa, Khalistani, and others. Sants, in concept are simply those who have chosen to live a lifestyle of ‘virakat’ on their path towards Brahmgyan, of course like any nomadic sadhu group, some will be pakhandis unable to forgo of maya and its traps. The lifestyle of a mystic is not anything new, many great Gursikhs of great learning like Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh, Akali Kaur Singh Nihang, (Sant) Teja Singh have led such a lifestyle, leaving their learned professions behind them and devoting themselves entirely to the service of Naam. Today, what we have unfortunately are a whole host of Sants springing up across the Punjab countryside and beyond with no lineage from any Taksal (school of learning) hence the numerous incidents of ‘kachi bani’ and ‘funky ideas’ being spewed out by these characters and coupled with this, an increasing level of befuddled sangat owing to the crusade to “make Sikhi Simple” that we have been witness to over the past 100 years or so. In practice, many of today’s Sant and other personality-based group followers are no different to Namdharis, excepting them not openly referring to their Sant or Baba as (Sat) Guru Sahib as the Namdharis do. It is also, not only simple-minded folk running around behind Sants, but also well to do, middle class Sikh families –perhaps because it provides them a means to maintain the material aspects of their lifestyle with relatively little problem (given instances like the Hummer story above).

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Me · 24 May 2005

Khalsa_force which schools cos I dont know of any you talk of, and even if they are named after 'isher' is that a problem? Isher or Ishwar means God anyway. I dont see any of you opening schools, these 'nanaksarias' are responsible for running the very first sikh schools abroad which provide the kids access to Maharaj Ji throughout their day and Sikh Studies education, AND they are named after Guru Nanak Dev Ji. People in glass houses shouldnt throw stones..mate.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Harjinder Singh · 24 May 2005

[gurbani]<>[/gurbani] [gurbani]vwihgurU jI kI Piqh[/gurbani] I respect those who respect the Gurmukh personalities who spent their entire life with extra-ordinary Kamayee of Gursikhi. But Can you answer one simple question WHY(or On what basis you make this distinction) you put or accept the prefix of Bhai with Bhai Randhir Singh Ji (or and all other great Gurmukhs without the prefix Sant) and put or accept the prefix of Sant with Baba Isher Singh Ji (or and all other great Gurmukhs with the prefix Sant)? From what I understand, Gyani Jarnail Singh "Arshi" want that when we have Guru Sahib who is Sun as compared to a Candle or any other great Gurmukh (which you also have confirmed in this post that Guru Sahib is the biggest Sant) then we have no need to feel/call a Candle as the Sun. I repeat again what I posted in another post that Guru Sahib says [gurbani]gurmuK sau kir dosqI siqgur sau lwie icqu[/gurbani] guramukh so kar dhosathee sathigur so laae chith || Make friends with the Gurmukhs, but focus your consciousness on the True Guru Only. But i think most of us today believe and act in fact otherway around in the event of responding to Guru Khalsa Panth Jee and Guru Granth Sahib Jee as compared to a Gursikh we associate with. Just think what is status of any Gurmukh as compared to Guru Sahib in the situation when Guru Sahib is available or present to you all the time. A Gurmukh is our dedicated partner or Humsafar whose company/or friendship we need to move along with him(Gurmukh) towards Gurur Sahib not Move towards him(Gurmukh) in stead of Guru Sahib. To give title of a Sant to any Human is not our right/capability and we should just let it to Guru Sahib to know/decide who has become his most beloved Gursikh or let it be between a Gurmukh and Guru Sahib. We should just love all our Gursikh mates as our Bhai/Bhahen/our Sakhi Saheylees all trying to seek happiness of the same common Kant. we all are deficient in one way or the other and can fall down at any time. Only Guru Sahib is Pooran and eternal. [gurbani]vwihgurU jI kI Piqh[/gurbani]

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Harjinder Singh · 24 May 2005

[gurbani]<>[/gurbani] [gurbani]vwihgurU jI kI Piqh[/gurbani] One more thing, I would like to mention that calling a great Gursikh as Bhai/Bhahen is making him/her feel that he is on going on the Gurmat path and calling a Gursikh as Sant make him/her feel that he has reached perfection which is a final roadblock on his/her continuity in moving further advance in Gurmat. So not calling Sant is a big help/favour we can do to a fellow Gursikh. Furthermore, By avoiding to give title or prefix of [b]SANT[/b] to any of our Gursikh fellow, we can prevent the damage and embarrassment that we face for the entire Sikh nation when we see scandals of those well known as our great Sants. Sant is perfect and let this title remain only to Guru Sahib who is perfect for ever. Bhai Randhir Singh Ji gave the title of Rangaley Sajjan not the title SANT to his fellow great Gursikhs that also only after their death because he did not felt right to take gurantee of any other Gurmukhs (of same or even more Kamayee) who were still alive. Regarding Dharna Keertan, By not promoting the Keertan of Dharna is not going against Baba Attar Singh Ji or Baba Isher Singh Ji rather it is step of improvement from the own methods used by these Gursikhs to preech Sikhi to obey the actual Hukum of Guru Sahib. I think Singing in Dharna can be Approaching Sikhi in our way ( which can be right/wrong or may keep us stuck in between or take us to wrong destination if we put/sing wrong words in dharna as we make the dharna not the Guru Sahib) and on the other side Singing Gurbani is Doing ( or practicing or implementing) Sikhi. [gurbani]vwihgurU jI kI Piqh[/gurbani]

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Harjinder Singh · 24 May 2005

[gurbani]<>[/gurbani] [gurbani]vwihgurU jI kI Piqh[/gurbani] One more thing: I just want make it crystal clear that my intent is not bashing the title Sant rather my sole intent is to keep the utmost significance/sanctity of status of title Sant or BrahamGyani. I can see this same feeling in the posts of Gursikh veers/bahans like Gyani Jarnail Singh Ji. So it is not about hating Sants, it is about whom we can (or have the right to) call a Sant There is no Gursikh so far in the Sikh history to whom all sikhs agree one hundred percent. Sant should be the one who is Pooran or Brahamgyani, to whom’s actions or sayings, no one can disagree which is no other than Guru Sahib himself . And Guru Sahib(Husband) only is capable or has right to measure the level of Kamayee/sincerity of any of his Gursikh (wife). We should always do ardas for all so that we all can live to the expectations of Guru Sahib. Bhul Chuk Maaf Karna Ji.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Khalsa_Force · 24 May 2005

these schools r named SANT BABA ISHER SINGH PUBLIC SCHOOL. (mohali, Phase 7) (amritsar,by-pass) many more r there.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Me · 24 May 2005

whats arong with having schools named after great souls who set an example to the rest of us? would you rather schools be named after you?

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" · 25 May 2005

[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani] Guru Arjun Ji Sahib writes: BHAAG HOAA GUR _ SANT MILAYA.... and everybody agrees this Tuk refers to GURU RAMDASS JI SAHIB... Then GURU ARJUN JI SAHIB goes on to write... Sri Sukhmani Sahib...Ashtpadi.. DOES GURU JI have a "human" in mind even "greater" than or EQUAL to GUR_SANT RAMDASS JI SAHIB ?? Gur_Sant Guru Amardass ji ..Gur_Sant Guru Angad Ji Sahib..Gur_Sant Guru Nanak Ji SAHIB ??? Why did Guru Ji write GUR_SANT.... to let us KNOW that GUR-SANT is the GREATEST..and His Ninda etc is maha-attatee etc etc in Sukhmani Sahib... ONLY "NINDA" of a GUR_SANT can lead to that much LOWLIFE..no "human" no matter how holy is "worth THAT MUCH " The GUR_SANT "nindaks" are the Radhasoamis/Namdharees/ etc..and the Sukhmani Sahib Ashtpadi is meant as a warning to those types...certainly NOT for the likes of me who expose the frauds like "Sant Amar Singh Burrundi nanaksar..FOUNDER of so called SIKH SCHOOLS in UK... and "SANT manna Sionh Pehova who chakaaed amrit to MILLIONS !!! ha ha ha sant kaa nindak mahaa attaa-ee. The slanderer of the Saint is the worst evil-doer. sant kaa nindak khin tikan na paa-ee. The slanderer of the Saint has not even a moment's rest. sant kaa nindak mahaa hati-aaraa. The slanderer of the Saint is a brutal butcher. sant kaa nindak parmaysur maaraa. The slanderer of the Saint is cursed by the Transcendent Lord. sant kaa nindak raaj tay heen. The slanderer of the Saint has no kingdom. sant kaa nindak dukhee-aa ar deen. The slanderer of the Saint becomes miserable and poor. sant kay nindak ka-o sarab rog. The slanderer of the Saint contracts all diseases. sant kay nindak ka-o sadaa bijog. The slanderer of the Saint is forever separated. sant kee nindaa dokh meh dokh. To slander a Saint is the worst sin of sins. naanak sant bhaavai taa us kaa bhee ho-ay mokh. ||3|| O Nanak, if it pleases the Saint, then even this one may be liberated. ||3|| sant kaa dokhee sadaa apvit. The slanderer of the Saint is forever impure. sant kaa dokhee kisai kaa nahee mit. The slanderer of the Saint is nobody's friend. sant kay dokhee ka-o daan laagai. The slanderer of the Saint shall be punished. sant kay dokhee ka-o sabh ti-aagai. The slanderer of the Saint is abandoned by all. sant kaa dokhee mahaa ahaNkaaree. The slanderer of the Saint is totally egocentric. sant kaa dokhee sadaa bikaaree. The slanderer of the Saint is forever corrupt. sant kaa dokhee janmai marai. The slanderer of the Saint must endure birth and death. sant kee dookhnaa sukh tay tarai. The slanderer of the Saint is devoid of peace. sant kay dokhee ka-o naahee thaa-o. The slanderer of the Saint has no place of rest. naanak sant bhaavai taa la-ay milaa-ay. ||4|| O Nanak, if it pleases the Saint, then even such a one may merge in union. ||4|| I dont know if anyone in this world is a Sant or not, but is it worth the risk? IS it Worth the "RISK" of EQUALLING a mere HUMAN to the level OF GURU NANAK JYOT??? is the question you MUST ask yourself before you go calling a human being full of all the Five Chors EQUAL IN STATUS TO GURU JYOT...That my friend is the RISK you take ??? ...HOW can we say WE DONT KNOW ??? Bhaag hoaa GUR_SANT Milaya is GURU RAMDASS JI...then the other SANT KI NINDAA..we say we "dont know" ?? The BEST and SAFEST way is GURU JI's WAY.... GURU JI DECLARES Danke dee chot te.. [gurbani]gurmuK sau kir dosqI siqgur sau lwie icqu.[/gurbani] And we can still give LAME EXCUSES like..we dont know, how to know ?? etc etc.. I am following [gurbani]gurmuK sau kir dosqI siqgur sau lwie icqu[/gurbani] to the LETTER and SPIRIT..so dear BUNDHA JI, I have NO FEAR of Jamdoots and such..PLEASE TAKE CARE of YOURSELF..... Danke dee chot te..BHAAG HOAA GUR-SANT MILAYA..GURU SAHIBBANS ONLY. [gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani] Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Bundha · 25 May 2005

Kabeer, it is good to perform selfless service for two - the Saints and the Lord. The Lord is the Giver of liberation, and the Saint inspires us to chant the Naam. ||164|| panna 1373 Here Bhagat Kabeer Ji clearly separates the role of a sant. The lord is the only One who can liberate us from the circle of life and death, the sant inspires/encourages us and shows us the way to jap naam.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

A Singh · 25 May 2005

Gyani Jarnail Singh "Arshi" Dhillon, I recall a lecture by Yogi Bhajan making the same point that if we are really need a 'patron' saint/sant, then we have one, Guru Ram Das Ji, the founder of our spiritual home on Earth at Amritsar. Who's any Sant from "blah blah" pind in front of Guru Ram Das?

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Khalsa_Force · 25 May 2005

for those who says flaane baba ji ne million nu amrit shahaiya. SIKHISM IS ABOUT QUALITY NOT QUANTITY.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Me · 25 May 2005

Jarnail Singh, before slandering people you know nothing about, and basing your posts on rumours, go look at what these 'so called sants' have done, and for your information, the Sikh school in England is a mahan sewa and success and benefits youngsters who need a strong foundation in Sikhi, you have no idea what Babaji went through to make it a success, go open a school yourself and then try to comment on this issue, practise what you preach!

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Me · 25 May 2005

Also, the very first Sikh school in England has been at the top of the league tables of the local council (a fact you can check yourself) and came third in England for producing the highest results in GCSE's. Not only this, a GCSE in Sikhism is now taught there and every morning students take part in the assembly in a GURDWARA. Is this pakhand? How is this against the rules of Sikhi? I want to ask 'Gyani' whether he's even seen the school for himself and the sewa done by the committee and organisers? Reference : http://www.ofsted.gov.uk/reports/index.cfm?fuseaction=summary&id=131928 Excellent points Bundha, I think you summed up the fate of the nidhaks very well.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Bundha · 25 May 2005

A Singh, you miss the point. <<<< Who's any Sant from "blah blah" pind in front of Guru Ram Das? >>>> Guru Ram Das Ji will love the Sant from "blah blah" pind and embrace him with all the love a Guru can give, because these so called sants from "blah blah" pind are putting us murkhs on the path of the Guru. You, A Singh may be a very intelligent person who understands Gurbani very well but murkh paagls like me need guidence, I cannot even understand one pangti of Guru Ji's dhurki bani.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

informed · 25 May 2005

to Bundha & Me... The only 'bachorla' you will ever need is Shiri Guru Granth Sahib jeeo. This path/life is about you freeing yourself from THIS world, and becoming one again with Waheguru. Throughout Bani examples are given about how this path is of an individualistic nature, something only YOU as a single entity can follow/perform/pass. If you begin placing these wannabe's (SANTS) as your guides/bachorla/message men, then please be ready to take a fall, for they are not what they all claim to be (and yes I will use a wide brush to coat them all!) YES they do seem to do Sikhi parchar, YES they do seem to give amrit to thousands, YES they do make the hair on the back of your neck stand up, but do you know there KARAM? Do you know they inner thoughts? Do you know the REAL SANT behind the chorla? The fact of the matter is NO, and it is all too late when there true nature does floats to the top! Give them the respect of a kirtani, yes listen to them if you wish (chachi bani) and then go home, and let them do so, instead of them visiting peoples homes (charan pourn) We are innocent/gullible people. These wannabe gurus's do take advantage. AND I CAN GUARANTEE YOU ONE THING, ALL OF THEM PROPHESISING ABOUT THE SECOND COMING, AND HOW THEY SPENT THERE PAST LIVES BEING EXTREMELY CLOSE TO ALL OUR GURU'S, AND HOW NOW, THERE SANGHAT WILL SERVE GURU JI THEMSELVES, BLAH, BLAH, BLAH. OK. Lets make a truce. Lets have all the sants in punjab/haryana help the Punjabis' become fully fledged Sikhs in Punjab, lets have them bring sincere politicians to run the political parties of Punjab, lets have them define our Anand Karag as a Sikh ceremony, not as a hindu one, lets have them help the young men on drugs, lets have them bring up the literacy rate, not in the uk. but Punjab, and lets have them focus only on PUNJAB (Yes no dollars/pounds, just the rupee!) Yes I know, No chance of that happening...But hold on, there are SO many of them, they even have there own samaj, come on, other than filling there own pockets, and building dhera's they must have some cash spare? PS. And we all know why they refuse to get married. In england they call that kind of a person a STUD MULE !!! enough said.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Harjinder Singh · 25 May 2005

[gurbani]<>[/gurbani] [gurbani]vwihgurU jI kI Piqh[/gurbani] In my humble opinion, it seems too much hard to share/learn Gurmat with locked minds. When it is clear that we require Guru Sahib (in other words Sant) to meet Waheguru and I beleive no one disagree to it. but I do not understand why some veers are bent upon giving this title to other than Guru Sahib. Just simply do your own work, and see if their is anyone other than Guru Sahib who fulfills all the qualifications of the "Sant ". We will definitely find that we are not capable making this distinction and It is not our responsibility/duty as well. We have Guru Sahib (the only and ultimate Sant) who resides in Guru Granth Sahib Ji and Guru Khalsa Panth (ie Any five or more tiar bar tiar Singhs collectively) still among us and will remain forever. Just think if we all believe this truely there will not be any kind of division. Only when we locked ourself to one of our fellow (who may be advance as compared to us) we get ourselves stuck and can not go further. This is the main reason why we can not have Unity, we get discouragement or disappointment. We all want unity but our minds are not controlled by one common control system ie Guru Sahib. Seek the association of Gurmukhs who are very much needed and deserve high respect as they are our dedicated Hamsafars but make sure your mind always focused or controlled not by anyone other than Guru Sahib. No Sikh can sit at higher or better place than his other gursikh fellows. In Guru Sahib's Darbar, Only Guru Sahib sit on the Kursi (or Takhat or Singhasan) while all (with no exception) sit on the same lower level floor. Anyone who violates this, disrespects Guru Sahib. [gurbani]gurmuK sau kir dosqI siqgur sau lwie icqu[/gurbani]

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" · 25 May 2005

Dear Me jio, IF "your sant ji" is such a great guy....why is there a 2000 page depositions agaisnt him in the American Courts....and why is he BANNED from entering MALAYSIA..(by popular request from malaysian sangats) ..Full details about his escapades..on www.rickross.com ( although i am not a fan of rickross either..but some truth is there)???? the entire Sikh school thing is a FRONT..with a Facade of GURMAT/SIKHI..with SANTISM/NANAKSARISM in the background... BTW he is ONE of the SANTS so "HONOURED" in malasyai/Singapore when he first came here that he DREW THOUSANDS.... Thousands lined up to Chhak Amrit from him (panj piyaras.not mentioned)....every one had HISNAME... on their lips even though it was GURU NANAK JI SAHIB's 500th GURPURAB SHATABADI..looked like he was higher than GURU JI...people were pushing and shoving to matha tek to his holy charans....(heck my own mother "saw' a "light/Glow" on his face and we had a most terrible ROW in our house that night...you guessed it..my dad held the EXACT SAME VIEWS I HOLD ON SANTS !!!..finally sanity prevailed..and when the real news came out my mum SAT DOWN and PERFORMED an akhand paath Single handed...(68 HOURS without food/water/getting up)....to thank GURU JI, she didnt matha tek to this man...Manukh ke sewa BIRTHEE JAAN says GURU ARJUN JI SAHIB... then the famous Love story ( Mere Laal ji..Love Poems written in his hand...to a woman in Canada..) broke in the Press. and he was BANNED as persona Non Grata.... was this action based on "rumour" ?? I think the Malaysian Sangat and GOVT have more credibility than that ?? or are you saying even our MUSLIM GOVT relies on RUMOURS ?? and bans sikh SANTS ?? just like that ?? It will need a lot more than a mere "note" from "you..to convince me...??? IF you believe Bundha "knows" my FATE...you need to learn a lot more and do some serious Naam japping instead of sant Lapping..lol. Washing our mann through GURBANI does the trick....not washing a "sant's" kachheras. bhul chuk maaf if a bit harsh..sorry ji.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Bundha · 25 May 2005

<<< Throughout Bani examples are given about how this path is of an individualistic nature, something only YOU as a single entity can follow/perform/pass. >>> I refer you to Bhagat Kabir Ji’s shabad. Kabeer, it is good to perform selfless service for two - the Saints and the Lord. The Lord is the Giver of liberation, and the Saint inspires us to chant the Naam. ||164|| panna 1373 <<< If you begin placing these wannabe's (SANTS) as your guides/bachorla/message men, then please be ready to take a fall , for they are not what they all claim to be (and yes I will use a wide brush to coat them all!) >>> Do you paint Baba Nanad Singh Ji with the same wide brush, or what about Sant Ishar Singh Ji or Sant Harnam Singh Ji or ever Sant Jarnail singh Ji ??? <<< We are innocent/gullible people. These wannabe gurus's do take advantage. >>> Speak for yourself mate, I am neither innocent or gullible, you may be and you maybe taken in by the fakes. <<< AND I CAN GUARANTEE YOU ONE THING, ALL OF THEM PROPHESISING ABOUT THE SECOND COMING, AND HOW THEY SPENT THERE PAST LIVES BEING EXTREMELY CLOSE TO ALL OUR GURU'S, AND HOW NOW, THERE SANGHAT WILL SERVE GURU JI THEMSELVES, BLAH, BLAH, BLAH. >>> Such a sweeping and nonsensical statement that it merits no response <<< lets have them bring up the literacy rate, not in the uk. but Punjab, and lets have them focus only on PUNJAB (Yes no dollars/pounds, just the rupee!) >>> Who made you the chaudhari? Who are you to tell where someone can or cannot go? <<< Yes I know, No chance of that happening...But hold on, there are SO many of them, they even have there own samaj, come on, other than filling there own pockets, and building dhera's they must have some cash spare? >>> My god, we are being overrun by them, they are worst then the asylum seekers, we are going to be swomped by them …………………………… get a grip! <<< PS. And we all know why they refuse to get married. In england they call that kind of a person a STUD MULE !!! >>> Such a statement does not become a Gursikh. <<<<<< No Sikh can sit at higher or better place than his other gursikh fellows >>>>>>> A Gursikh who spends doing plenty naam simran but also spends time doing nindhia of others, mocks others. Or a gurshikh who does plenty naam simran. Are they the same level ????

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Hey · 25 May 2005

I can't say much about Sant Amar Singh (although the BC Court Trials and Sikh Times articles don't paint a positive picture; however I am in no place to judge) but from what I know about the Sikh School in Hayes is, there isn't really much real Sikhi there at all; there are certainly some negative elements within both the students and the teachers. Being made to or sitting without true passion in a Gurdwara in the morning is not what Sikhi is about; Sikhi is about love for Guroo and enshrining that in every day life.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Harjinder Singh · 25 May 2005

[gurbani]<>[/gurbani] [gurbani]vwihgurU jI kI Piqh[/gurbani] <<< Throughout Bani examples are given about how this path is of an individualistic nature, something only YOU as a single entity can follow/perform/pass. >>> ....I refer you to Bhagat Kabir Ji’s shabad. Kabeer, it is good to perform selfless service for two - the Saints and the Lord. The Lord is the Giver of liberation, and the Saint inspires us to chant the Naam. ||164|| panna 1373.... [b]Two are Saint/Sanits = Guru Sahib[/b] =and Guru Khalsa Panth (collection of atleast five or more or all tiar bar tiar Khalsa)[/b] <<< If you begin placing these wannabe's (SANTS) as your guides/bachorla/message men, then please be ready to take a fall , for they are not what they all claim to be (and yes I will use a wide brush to coat them all!) >>> ....Do you paint Baba Nanad Singh Ji with the same wide brush, or what about Sant Ishar Singh Ji or Sant Harnam Singh Ji or ever Sant Jarnail singh Ji ??? [b]All these Gursikhs falls in the category of our great respectable Gursikhs fellows whose company/friendship[/b] [b]we must always need and seek but never raise their level to Perfection because[/b] [b]even all of these differed with each other on one point or other but[/b] [b]that is not important because all were Sikhs of Guru Sahib not of each other.[/b] [b]The main thing is that they have one common thing in them that[/b] [b]they all did their best to do Kamayee of Guru Sahib's Hukum to their best level[/b] [b](I repeat their best level as per they understood the Gurmat) for their entire life.[/b] [b]They were/are/will be proud Gursikhs but not proud Guru (Sant).[/b] [b]Let us take inspiration from their Jiwan and dream to complete/fix/resolve what[/b] [b]these Gursikhs would have dreamed but is still outstanding. We must not stop at the point where[/b] [b]these Gursikhs reached and left this world. We have to continue and continue to make more and more progress.[/b] [b]Always keep in mind that[/b] [b]REAL SUCCESS IS THE JOURNEY NOT THE DESTINATION.[/b] [b]SET THE GOAL. ACHIEVE IT AND SET THE NEW GOAL.[/b] [b]HE WHO IS ALWAYS IN THE PROCESS OF CONTINOUS ACHIEVEMENT/IMPROVEMENT[/b] [b]IN THE PATH OF GURMAT[/b] [b]IS A SIKH[/b] [gurbani]swJ krIjY guxh kyrI Coif Avgx clIAY[/gurbani] [gurbani]gurmuK sau kir dosqI siqgur sau lwie icqu[/gurbani]

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

indy · 25 May 2005

Apologies for misusing the Sukhmani Sahib Quote, I havent really studied the Guru Granth Sahib so I wont attempt to use it again. However, there are nicer ways of saying things to people through humility Mr Arshi. "<<<<<< No Sikh can sit at higher or better place than his other gursikh fellows >>>>>>> A Gursikh who spends doing plenty naam simran but also spends time doing nindhia of others, mocks others. Or a gurshikh who does plenty naam simran. Are they the same level ????" We should never talk bad about people or make them feel bad!

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Bundha · 25 May 2005

<<< Washing our mann through GURBANI does the trick....not washing a "sant's" kachheras. >>> Speaks volumes about your "avasta" doesn't it aRshi !!!

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

S Singh · 25 May 2005

>>, or what about Sant Ishar Singh Ji or Sant Harnam Singh Ji or ever Sant Jarnail singh Ji ??? Bundha What about Baba Deep Singh Ji, Bhai Mani Singh Ji, Bhai Taru Singh Ji, you think your human Sant are higher than these people ? Baba Jarnail Singh Ji told people off for calling him Sant as he rightly knew the true meaning of the word. The use of the word Sant as a prefix was non existant in Sikhi until it started to mushroom in Punjab. There are now more Sant/Baba etc than villages in Punjab, now that is truly amazing.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Bundha · 25 May 2005

<<< IF you believe Bundha "knows" my FATE...>>> I may not know your FATE, Giani Ji but with comments like <<< Washing our mann through GURBANI does the trick....not washing a "sant's" kachheras. >>> [b]*****admin cut: No personal attacks please*******[/b] bhul chuk maaf if a bit harsh..sorry ji

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Bundha · 25 May 2005

There are people who call themselves “Giani” these days, but who are in fact anything but ( GIAN SWAA THA !). I do not recall Giani Gurdass ji ? mahimaa saaDhoo sang kee sunhu mayray meetaa This is the Glory of the Saadh Sangat, the Company of the Holy; listen, O my friends. sant ka maragh dharam ki paudi, koe wadh-bhagi pai The place of a holy person is the first step of Dharam, only those who are blessed can achieve this. Jarnail Singh Ji was a pooran Sant mahpurkh, but had nimarta.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

S Singh · 25 May 2005

I Think Jarnail Singh Arsh has explained things very well with humality. It is obvious that some people are now so brainwashed they refuse to take anything on board and start branding everything as nindia. You see that such people hardly ever post when it comes to beadbi of Guru Ji but say anything as against there whiter than white "Sant" and they go out the way to justify the use of the Sant prefix and to defend the "Sant" they follow.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Bundha · 25 May 2005

Admin Saab Ji, my apologies, it wasn't really a personal attack, I just wanted to point out that some people who will sink to such depths can only be termed as "*" men. bhul chuk maaf

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Me · 25 May 2005

Im actually shocked that this arshi is still allowed to post, compare my reply to his and you'll see what I mean. To actually tell someone they should stop washing kacherey of people and jap naam is really offensive. I was merely trying to point out the good Babaji has done and continues to do. As for the court cases, well you dont even know that the land was donated by the woman who died to the TRUST, not Babaji and the family got it back by circulating dirty rumours about him. Another thing, Babaji went to Malaysia last week so ask your people there and confirm it, he has never been banned. When has a few people barking on the internet been proof? Instead of insulting me and wasting your time writing lengthy posts on this topic, utilise your time doing something useful like educating youngsters about Gurbani. 'Hey' it is very difficult to covert or change everybody or ever child in a school. There are some extremely devoted kids there who do kirtan and paath and some amritdharis, but the majority are from areas such as southall and slough, and they are constantly influenced by television, media and people they hang out with after school. The school can only do so much, no teacher is commanded to be amritdhari before teaching, there are teachers from all different faiths. Half of the 'sikh' parents of the kids in school drink, smoke and are not even close to following gurmat, so what is being done is more than enough. It is the parent's responsibility also to change before giving their kids incentive to do so too. Arshi, I challenge you to present one proof to show sanatanism/nanaksariasm is taught in that school..you will fail. I am not going to post here anymore as there is obvious preferential treatment towards certain people because they think of sikhi in a particularly fanatic way. I request the Admin to filter posts more strictly because insults such as the ones allowed in this forum will be read by non-sikhs and people interested in sikhism which will only repel and disguist them. Wish you the best Mr Arshi, hope Waheguru is able to bless you with some compassion, at the moment I dont see any for anyone.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

can't think of a name.. · 25 May 2005

Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" wrote: 'do some serious Naam japping instead of sant Lapping..lol.' - How about doing some 'Naam japping instead of' Sant bashing.. Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" wrote: 'Washing our mann through GURBANI does the trick....not washing a "sant's" kachheras.' -Hawww this is low, even for you Gyani Ji..

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Bundha · 25 May 2005

S Singh, <<< I Think Jarnail Singh Arsh has explained things very well with humality. >>> <<< Washing our mann through GURBANI does the trick....not washing a "sant's" kachheras. >>> Humility indeed ! Digusting more like just shows where his mind is, and if you think this is humility then you are just as bad as he his !

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

slip · 25 May 2005

*arshi* said: "the entire Sikh school thing is a FRONT..with a Facade of GURMAT/SIKHI..with SANTISM/NANAKSARISM in the background..." *Me* said: "Arshi, I challenge you to present one proof to show sanatanism/nanaksariasm is taught in that school.." santism or sanatanism.....ooooh i see a freudian slip there :) :) :)

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Me · 25 May 2005

'slip' :S

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

S Singh · 25 May 2005

>> <<< Washing our mann through GURBANI does the trick....not washing a "sant's" kachheras. >>> >>Humility indeed ! Digusting more like just shows where his mind is, and if you think this is humility then you are just as bad as he his ! Whats wrong with writing that ? Its true people are more inclined towards doing odd jobs for so called "santa" than showing true faith in our Guru Ji. I know of a so called "sant" and when he has a bath women queue outside to drink the waste water. How sad and disgusting is that. There is a Gurdwara not too far away where they could see the true Guru and all they want to do is drink dirty water. These so called "Sant" are not a patch on Shaheed Baba Deep Singh, Bhai Mani Singh and Bhai Taru Singh.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Me · 25 May 2005

We are not talking about people like that and you know it, stop using extreme cases to try to justify your nindia.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" · 26 May 2005

[gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani] Dear All and especially Me and Bundha Jio, I stand by every word is use.....its NOT the "extreme" cases..i mention..its a very very "common" task the sants set to their chelas... why do they have GARRVAIIS ?? Cant a sant carry his own water to go jungle pani ?? I have personaly seen "sants" hanging their "DRY" kachheras on bathroom doors for their chelas to wash later. WHO let out the Cat out of mannas bag...His "Garrvaii" of course because these "personal chelas" know all their secrets and what "kheh they udaa"... behind closed doors. ECERY SINGLE SANT has HIs GARRVAII.... did GURU JI have one too ?? Guru Nanak Ji caught hold of Bhai Lehana ji's Horse reins and WALKED BEFORE him...is Historical FACT.... and the sants cant even carry their own water pail. Yes I am aware that your Baba Ji "visits" malaysia..BUT CLANDESTINELY and PRIVATELY.... I challenge you to POST his next Visit in advance in the Malaysian Punjabi Press and at which GURDWARA STAGE will his "kirtan" be . I can imagine how many palms must have been greased to have these private visits... a GURBANI PARCHARAK and SANT at that should travel openly and DO PARCHAAR at Major Gurdawras.... I am anxiously awaiting your next advertisement. Bundha ji, you obviously DONT KNOW the difference between a Gyani and a Gyani. ( also spelled Giani) .and have never bothered to or prefer to "ignore" my previously given explanations on this subject..(just do a check of older messages this has ben explained umpteen times). WHY i DONT chose to add PREFIX of BHAI before my name as you suggested that Bhai GURDASS JI did....is precisely because I am NOT even "close" to the BHAI SAHIBS who have this prefix.... I am NOT even the dust of the feet of Bhai Gurdass Ji, Bhai Randhir Singh ji, Bhai Mani Singh Ji, Bhai Taru Singh Ji...therefore my name begins...simply as Jarnail singh..... It is the height of ********* on your part to try and BRING DOWN bhai GURDASS Ji by trying to add a low "sansari university degree of Giani" to His AUGUST NAME. Any student who has completed 10 classes can sit for this "university Giani Exam" and pass...BUT to ATTAIN the HEIGHT of BHAI GURDASS JI ??? and you claim that you "cant recall GIANI GURDASS JI ??" I am wondering how did you get the 'courage" to DEFACE Bhai gurdass Ji's Name like that..what with claims of humility and all that...have you forgotten that jamdoots await us all ?? What will you explain to Bhai gurdass Ji ?? You quoted Bhagat Kabir Ji.... I ask you WHICH 'SANT" has the power to Japaa NAAM ?? Which SANT has written even one Panktee of GURBANI ? This SANT of Bhagat ji is SHABAD-GURU/SADH SANGAT/HOLY CONGREGATION/COMPANY of HOLY Sangat..NOT any individual human being. Even in the Sadh Sangat we INDIVIDUALLY japp Naam on our OWN for OUR OWN benefit...no body can do so for others benefit. Please dont worry about my health, my halath, my mind, my humility, may naam japping, my kamaii whatever..I have MY GURU JI to do all that..I have Given ALL my CHINTAS to GURU JI. [gurbani] <>vwihgurU jI kI Piqh ][/gurbani]

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Khalsa_Force · 26 May 2005

>>> Arshi, I challenge you to present one proof to show sanatanism/nanaksariasm is taught in that school..you will fail <<< so u admit these r WRONG things and shdnt be taught in a SIKHI school? jina ih lok aapne pakhandi baabiaan da saath dende aina kitte Bhindranwaaliaan da dita hunda te hun nu khalistan bannia hona c, darde maare aap amrika/canada daur gaye te hun gallan karde khalistan diaan, hai aina dam te aithe punjab aa k gal karo. kithe c tuhaade baabe jadon kaum nu shaheediaan di lor c? aapne AC bhorre or kutia vich jap/tap karde honne? ohna nu ki lor c fight karan di, bhole bhaale singh jo c is kam lai, ihna ne te bad lokaan nu luttan da theka lia hoia. bhai ik gal hor, sanu guru walon hukam hoia k jhooth de khilaaf bolna hai , par tusi lok aapne santaan naal jiada hi pyar karde ho k Guru ji di beadbi beadbi nahi te aah nakli baabiaan de beadbi aa. mainu kisse ne aje tak jawab nahi ditta k, WHY WE DONT HAVE ANY PERSON WITH PREFIX "SANT" WITH HIS NAME AT TIMES OF GURU JI OR EVEN CENTURY AFTER THAT(UPTO 1900). AND WHY SOOOOOOOO MANY OF SANTS THESE DAYS? EXCLUDING FAKES(WE HV SO MANY SO CALLED AUTHENTIC SANTS OF A SAMPRDA) OTHER HTING WHY DOES THESE SAMPRDAS CELEBRATE BDAY OF THESE SANTS AT PAR WITH "GURPURB" OR EVEN MORE THAN GURPURBS? AND NAME THEM AVTAR-PURB. ? MY QUESTION IS TO "NANAKSARIAS".

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Bundha · 26 May 2005

My last post on this, honest ! I just want to pick up a point earlier by Harjinder singh. <<< Kabeer, it is good to perform selfless service for two - the Saints and the Lord. The Lord is the Giver of liberation, and the Saint inspires us to chant the Naam. ||164|| panna 1373.... Two are Saint/Sanits = Guru Sahib =and Guru Khalsa Panth (collection of atleast five or more or all tiar bar tiar Khalsa) >>> Do you know your Sikh chronology ? When was Khalsa Panth sajhia ? When was Bhagat Kabir Ji around ? Bhaagat Kabir Ji was on this earth at least two hundred years before Sahib Ji created the Khalsa panth, so how can you say that <<< Two are Saint/Sanits = Guru Sahib and Guru Khalsa Panth >>> You sant bashers will twist gurbani to anything other then what it really says. This shabad is very straight forward, a sant is sent to this world by Akalpurkh to japaa naam, but let us see you all line up and give totally skewered interpretations of it.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

S Singh · 26 May 2005

Me, Stop harping on about nindia. Fact is that these "Sant" are a modern phenomena and have not existed in the time of our Guru. You fail to address the point why Shaheed Baba Deep Singh Ji, Bhai Mani Singh Ji, Bhai Taru Singh Ji were never accorded the prefix of Sant. I am more than positive that if this Sant prefix was justifiable in Sikhi then they would have received the Sant prefix. Is it not beadbi when followers of "Sant" rush out of Gurdwara when they arrive in their Mercedes when the True Guru is inside the Gurdwara ? Is it not beadbi that a title that refers to our Guru Ji is being used by people to elevate themselves ?

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Me · 26 May 2005

Firstly, S Singh you need to get a reality check, I am not interested in answering any of your questions because frankly your allegations dont apply to the people I respect and view as true Sants. Secondly, Arshi you have no proof for the vile comments you make and who has meetings in private, maybe you should elaborate when you collect some evidence. Khalsa force can you type in english as most people here use this language to communicate and I cant understand the first part of your post. I didnt say nanaksariasm/sanatanism (if such a concept exists) is bad, I simply asked him to prove this was ALL that was taught there, so read my post properly. Im not going to waste my time on this useless thread any longer, it clearly isnt going anywhere, everyone is just trying to vent their frustration by writing things based on useless rumours.

Re: Justification for Sants in Sikhi?

Admin · 26 May 2005

Topic locked. Admin