Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Re: If Raagmala is not baani...

Re: If Raagmala is not baani...

Paapi · 20 May 2005

It is still a big paap to add something and claim it is Gurbani as well as to remove it and say it isnt. To put common poetry on the level of the Words of God is a Beadbi in itself. Sikhs don't work on the principle of "Oh hey what if it is Gurbani, lets believe it just incase" - in Sikhi we do not believe things out of fear we believe out of love! Many Sants of the past have treated things as Bani when they aren't - Sau Sakhi, Nishani Sikhee - however surely souls such as Bhai Randhir Singh, Bhai Rama Singh, Bhai Surat Singh Pooran Ji, could not have reached such awesome Avasthas if they were disregarding Bani? Many people have had first hand witnesses of the spiritual power of the aforemented Singhs.

Re: If Raagmala is not baani...

Bijla Singh · 20 May 2005

"Are you willing to accept that the above story, along with the lies about Bhai Sahib not knowing the Gurmantar, is untrue? Or do you still stick to the story that Bhai Randhir Singh magically changed his stance at the end of his life and no one except for your author and Bhai Hari Singh knew about it?" I believe that Bhai Sahib believed in "Waheguru" as gurmantar. The reason I named these two people is because they claim their presence in the meeting. So asking them would be far better than asking anyone else. Whether Bhai Sahib Ji changed his belief or not makes no difference to me and neither does it make him any less of a gursikh. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: If Raagmala is not baani...

Bijla Singh · 20 May 2005

"We have had several debates on the authenticity of Raagmala and recently a really good book called “Kkasht Raag kin Gaaye” came into market." What is the name of the author? In my opinion these scholars should keep all the material to themselves and when Panth really gets serious about these topics and calls a Panthic meeting then present the evidence. This way regular Sikhs don't do "gutham guttha" with each other. I hope that time comes soon. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Re: If Raagmala is not baani...

ekta · 21 May 2005

EVERY1 HAS STUDIED RAAGMALLA TO THE FULL EXTENT IT SEEMS LIKE! NOT FOR THE PURPOSE OF UNDER-STANDING BANI OR FOR MOST CASES ON THIS BOARD STUDYING IT SO THAT IT CAN BE PROVEN FALSE. WHAT IF ALL THIS EFFORT WAS PUT INTO UNDERSTANDING THE REST OF DHUN SIRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI, WE'D HAVE A BILLION BRAHMGIANIS ON OUR HANDS FOR GODS SAKE PPL FIGHTING OVER THIS...AND STUDYING THIS 2 SUCH AN EXTENT STUDY ALL BANI. quite a shame. Taksaali's will not change their view, and the akj'ers shan't, so what should be done? Edict from akaal takht.......but i have doubts that the youth will bow to ne hukumn concerning raagmala from akaal takht.....as ur 2 stubborn in your ways. If they say no raagmalla the taksaali youth gone be like ehhh akaal takht is wrong, if they say u have to akj youth gone be like akaal takht you wrong! so what is the solution? there is none. We need to learn to co-exist, love, and share sikhi, do bhagti 2gether.

Re: If Raagmala is not baani...

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 21 May 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. veer wrote: Dont' forget, before Jasbir Singh Rode changed the Maryada in the militant days in Panjab, Rag-mala was not read at Akal Takht Sahib.. SEE for yourselves..the HUKMNAMA at AKAL TAKHAT changing this MARYADA..it is the ONE and ONLY "HUKMNAMA" NOT SIGNED by ANY ONE....only the TITLES are given..Jathedar so and so..BUT NO ACTUAL SIGNATURES and NAMES... Every other Hukmanam is Signed and Authenticated by the Name of the jathedar signing it. These Hukamnamas are All available on the SGPC website... Go to SGPC.Net and click on ONLINE PUBLICATIONS..Hukmnameh..and READ this One and Only nameless Hukmnama !!!

Re: If Raagmala is not baani...

Khalsa_Force · 21 May 2005

Gurbani or NOT. Who cares !!! First let urself understand everything else in SGGS JI, then talk abt raagmala. It surely aint Spiritual or GURMAT like other gurbani but lets understand other GURBANi first then decide abt Dasam Granth and Raag mala.

Re: If Raagmala is not baani...

bsgill · 26 May 2005

There must be authentic writeups on this topic, may be some one can guide in general. What I feel the raagmala is the integral part of SGGSJI as the details of raagas is primarily explained in it. As is said kal yuoog main kirtan pardhana, kirtan in proper raag can bring out the real of it, so it is important to understand the raags as clubed in main raags and raginis. Feel more concentration need to be given to under stand it rather than debating the existence.

Re: If Raagmala is not baani...

anon · 26 May 2005

not all raags in ragmala appear in Siri Guru Granth Sahib ji there are 31 in Siri Guru Granth Sahib ji and 84 in ragmala theres very little correlation between raags in ragmala and those in Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji yes doing kirtan in raags is important however Siri Guru Granth Sahib is about PRAISE of NAAM in one way or other, NOT PRAISE OF RAAGS especially not of raags that DONT APPEAR in SIRI GURU GRANTH SAHIB JI.

Re: If Raagmala is not baani...

amardeep · 28 May 2005

Arshi might consider this 'following sants' and what not. But if great gursikhs like Baba Harnam Singh, Sant Gurbachan Singh ( list goes on and on and on) believe in raagmala than that is good enough for me because our knowledge is nothing compared to them. And if they seen flaws in raagmala they would have surely let people know.

Re: If Raagmala is not baani...

Jarnail Singh "Gyani "Arshi" · 28 May 2005

So very right veer anon jio. Gurbani is all about Naam,Naam and Naam ONLY.....and HOW we can achieve the heights of ectasy the Bhagats Sahibaan, Guru Sahibaans, Sheikh Sahibaan, Bhatt Sahibaan...and others attained through Naam simaran. Gurbani has no place for praise of personalities, raags, raagnis, their children, kings and emperors, prophets...whatever. Every panktee of Gurbani is ILAHI NAAM..PYAAR of WAHEGURU JI.. ALL i ask is SHOW me any ONE Panktee of GURBANI that is (empty) of Naam... or SHOW me one Panktee of "raagmala" that has anything about Naam/Simran/Waheguru Pyaar..and I will change my opinion about raagmaala..but that is an impossible dream !!! I went through each pro-raagmala post...not a single one has anything to quote about Naam/Pyaar of Waheguru from raagmala....all they can do is drag down Japji Sahib with their meaningless "slander" of this SHAHKAAR of GURU Ji that is the NEEHN FOUNDATION of the ENTIRE GURU GRANTH JI SAHIB..or quote the word "mundawni" as used as a WORD in a panktee....compared to its usage as a STAMP (MOHR) in a TITLE of a Shabad..or in Final Showdown fall back on the fmaous line..MY BABA JI said it is bani....so hear hear .. sorry i dont hear babajis but GURU JI. GURU JI says..Raagaan wich SRI RAAG hai...and the writer of raagmala says BHAIRO..blah blah blah...