Favourite Kathakaar
Kulbir Singh · 02 May 2005
1) Who is your favourite Kathakaar and why? 2) What kind of Katha is acceptable and what kind not? 3) What is the difference between lecture and Katha? Daas, Kulbir Singh
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
Kulbir Singh · 02 May 2005
1) Who is your favourite Kathakaar and why? 2) What kind of Katha is acceptable and what kind not? 3) What is the difference between lecture and Katha? Daas, Kulbir SinghSome Singh · 02 May 2005
1) Bhai Pinderpal Singh, because he always backs up everything with Gurbani, and i have not seen many people who have as much Bani memorised than him 2) Katha that is inline with Gurmat is acceptable. Parchaar about Simran, Seva, Amrit, History etc...What is not acceptable?...i would say...when people just talk about their own views and cause problems, or dwell on controversial arguements so much, and cut down people who don't have the same views. 3) Lecture- more of a formal thing, just talking to people, expressing your views Katha- Gurmat based, uses Bani to back up what is said, not your own views- but Guru Ji's views. but i don't really know much, so i may be wrong on these views. [%sig%]fat joe · 02 May 2005
Kulbir Singh wrote: 1) Who is your favourite Kathakaar and why? baba jasbir singh because he is very chardi kala 2) What kind of Katha is acceptable and what kind not? dont know but i think the one without ani kachi bani and anti gururmat is not 3) What is the difference between lecture and Katha? dont knowvaheguru · 02 May 2005
which jasbir singh veerji ru talkin bou singh sahib bhai jasbir singh rode???Akali Gupt Fauj · 03 May 2005
Bhai Pinderpal Singh. Just awesome. Articles by Giani Surjeet Singh of missionary college is also great. Just awesome.Hargurmit Singh · 03 May 2005
Bhai Kulbir Singh asked: 1) Who is your favourite Kathakaar and why? Ans: Bhai Pinderpal Singh as currently he is the only person who exclusively cites the hukamnamas from gurbani while explaining concepts. He is also very very focused. His katha on Ardas (60 hours), jupjee sahib (60 hrs approx) as well as on several other topics are virtual masterpieces. 2) What kind of Katha is acceptable and what kind not? Gurmat based, sharing the Gurus message in the Gurus word is what is acceptable. Sharing trips made to location a or b, or personal idiosycrancies or personal opinions is not acceptable. 3) What is the difference between lecture and Katha? katha is done in the hazuri of sri guru granth sahib and the sangat. lecture may not necessarily be in a gurdwara. Katha by definition implies a sharing of the gurus gyan with the sangat. lecture may or may not be focused on gurmat. Finally let us remember that katha vachaks are also mortals. They are also capable of being influenced by "outside" sources. I personally know of a wonderful kathakar who did a fantastic job for the community in 1984 through his gurmat veechars, but later on outside influences had corrupted him so much that most of his "lectures" were all focussed on manmat. [%sig%]Singh · 03 May 2005
Sant Hardev Singh Lulon Wale Good mix of humour & deep knowledge also Bhai Satnaam Singh of DT/ VERY POWERFULNaamRas Singh · 03 May 2005
I really like HarIqbal Singh Zakhme Bali - real funny guy - keeps the sangat gripped and interested, but through his light and easy to undersand discourse/vichaars, imparts real deep knowledge on Gurmat. This is good for moorakhs like me, who cannot understand real complicated KathaKaars. Also, of course, the irreplaceable Sant Singh Maskeen - what a man (when I can understand him!!!)Jinder · 03 May 2005
It only to be be only one man: Sant Jarnal Singh Ji Khalsa Bhindranwale Mahpurish. He has this thing in his voice that you know it is pure pyaar for waheguru.kaur · 03 May 2005
Some of my favourite Kathavachicks are as follows: Bhai Hariqbal singh Zakhmi (Bali) - i agree with comments made by NaamRas Singh. Giani Thakur Singh (Patiala Wale) Giani Sant Singh Jee Maskeen Giani Jaswant Singh ParwanaDogma · 03 May 2005
Favorite real life kathaavachak: Giani Takhur Singh Favorite cyber kathaavachak: Bhai Kulbir Singh lol...kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 03 May 2005
vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!!!! 1) Who is your favourite Kathakaar and why? there are so many great kathakaars ! Bhai Parminder Singh ji, Bhai Pinderpal Singh ji, Giani Thakur Singh Ji, Giani Sant Singh Ji Maskeen, Bhai Sahib Bhai Jeevan Singh Ji, and Baba Jarnail Singh Ji Bhinderanwale. Bhai Parminder Singh ji was, and still is, without a doubt, the best English-speaking kathavachak that I have ever heard. He was able to explain gurbani and ithihaas with such sincerity, passion, honesty, and humility. Bhai Parminder Singh ji was also able to explain Gurbani and Sikh history in Punjabi and his message reached all generations. He always practiced what he preached and he was never egotistical about all the kirpa that Guru Sahib gave him. I also feel Guru Sahib did so much kirpa on me that I got to have sangat of this great Gursikh. Bhai Pinderpal Singh ji has an ocean of knowledge. His knowledge and his nimarta are seemingly boundless limited only by the Guru's kirpa and that is also increasing daily because this Singh keeps rehit and has so much pyaar for Sikhi - he is a true historian and scholar of Sikhi but he wont' admit it as his mind is at the feet of the Guru. His katha on the Ardaas is so deep and thoughtful. His katha on Baba Buddha Jee is just amazing. Giani Thakur Singh Ji has this amazing ability to reach the soul of a manmukh like me, through his convincing style of katha. He was blessed with the sangat of Baba Jarnail Singh Ji and himself became a Paaras of the Khalsa Panth and now wherever he goes the sangat becomes completely enlightened with his anmol bachans. He does honest, realistic katha on Gurbani and then helps us relate to it by speaking in our language and giving our daily-life examples. Giani Sant Singh jee Maskeen popularized katha in the whole world. His tapes are available in almost every Sikh's house. His voice is recognized by almost every Sikh. No matter who agreed or disagreed with him, it goes without saying that his seva for the panth is absolutely amazing. He devoted most of his life to katha and his katha deevans were always brimming with energy. He never hesitate to speak on Gurmat, and brought many people from different groups together. The true Katha is the Katha of Gurbani shabads. During keertan many times, Bhai Sahib Bhai Jeevan Singh jee has stopped to explain the shabad. These are the most magical moments of the whole smagam - when the whole sangat is silent and the sweet voice of Bhai Sahib is singing Gurbani keertan and then he brings us deeper to the meaning with his katha. Bhai Sahib ji is a nirmolak Panth rattan whose naam abhyaas kamaee and Gursikhi pyaar is unbelievable. His words are like sugar and lightning at the same time. Baba Jarnail Singh Ji Bhinderanwale was a non-stop naam abhyaasee gurmukh sant. He had so much kamaee behind his words, that thousands of people took khande-ke-pahul just from listening to ONE TAPE of his katha. The power in his words is all kirpa from the Guru and the jakaras that the sangat gives in his speeches are full of so much emotion and excitement - his katha deevans, which I wish I had been a part of, seem to be something absolutely unique and exciting. He mobilized a generation of Sikhs through the Guru's kirpa, and all the while remained humble. 2) What kind of Katha is acceptable and what kind not? Preaching to people about how they should practice vikaars, or about how God doesn't exist, these kathas happen all the time and those people will suffer a lot. Preaching to people of good things, but not practicing them, those people will also suffer. Preaching karam kaand / superstition to people is also very bad. Lastly, preaching your own greatness will be the downfall of your avastha. 3) What is the difference between lecture and Katha? meri math thoree - please forgive if i am wrong but i think Lecture is when you are talking about Samaajak / Worldly / Miri topics. Katha is when you are talking about Aatmak / Spiritual / Piri topics. please forgive my mistakes vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!!!!....... · 03 May 2005
any recordings or downloads of this Bhai Pinderpal singh - I have never heard of him?singh · 03 May 2005
Without a doubt, Bhai Parminder Singh ji and Giani Thakur Singh Ji are my favorites. Amazing pyar in thier voices and the ability to explain complex topics in ways that are easier to understand as well as their immense gyan make these two my favorite.Jaspal Singh · 03 May 2005
Panth ratan Giayni Sant Singh Ji Maskeen. and i think no1 else can match his knowledge. Bhai Pinderpal Singh is gr8 too, but some(only few) of his historical facts r wrong.Akali Gupt Fauj · 03 May 2005
Oh I forgot to mention Prof. Darshan Singh Khalsa (ex-jathedar sri Akaal Takht Sahib)gurmukh · 03 May 2005
Giani Amolak Singh Ji and Sant Kartar Singh Bhindranwale, Giani Amolak singh because where ever he is was he would say the right thing for the right sangat/person. Whether he is in Birmingham, Akhand Paath Bhog (u.k.) with Guru Nanak Nishkam Sewak Jatha sangat, or in Canada with Akhand Keertani Jatha Sangat, or even in darbar sahib SGPC/Akalidal,etc. He wouldn't be scared to speak the truth out. He wouldn't just speak the truth he would get to the point without beating around the bush. Giani Ji was great he had the greatest blessings from various great gurmukhs/sants. Its true what he said in the video. When he sings that shabad 'Har Simari Din Sab Rainn' it is wonderful. I always wonder, if Giani Jis sings the shabad with so much bliss, then what would Bhai Randhirs singh jis version be like? vaah....khalistani · 03 May 2005
no doubbbt i got many favs all taksalee mahapurkh kathas on tape their off the hook crazy depth bhai parminder singh jes english katha is craazy too baba hari singh je randhawae wale got skilzz so does sant baba jagjit singh je sant ishar singh jes katha, well his dharna so many rathans theire all crazy but i listen to a lot of sant kartaar singh jes katha a lot and sant gurbachan singh jes katha on guru granth sahib je is amazing all sant jes speaches its soo much craziness bhula chuka mafGuldeep Singh · 03 May 2005
Guru Pyareo I think one of the best Kathavachaks of the last 50 years was Giani Sant Singh Ji Maskeen. There was always pin drop silence when he spoke. When he spoke of the path to Waheguru, it seemed he was speaking of a path he had travelled not just read about. Recently, I have downloaded alot of Kathas by Bhai Pinderpal Singh Ji. His saakhis are very moving and gives one new energy and Guru pyar. (To "......." you can find Bhai Pinderpal Singh Ji's Kathas at http://www.ikirtan.com/index.php?q=f&f=%2FKatha%2FBhai+Pinderpal+Singh+Ji )ns · 04 May 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh Kulbir Ji , many thanks for bringing up this thread, it 's highlighted to me about Bhai Pamrinder Singh who does katha in English as well as panjabi, I haven't heard his katha and would like to , please post link if it's available on the net. These are the types of people the panth is going to need in the next 50 years if we are to fill our Gurdwaras which are made of gleaming marble and look very pretty on the outside but inside you see a few of the old folk in the morning and evening , but no youth. In my opinion the favourite kathakar is Guru Ji himself, it 's Guru Ji that gives the wisdom, knowledge, humility to sewadars of the panth as mentioned very nicely by "kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa ". We are in dire straits need for katha vachecks, parcharks in English, in the western world. Muslims in the UK have great parcharks fully trained to speak in English. You may wonder why? well their people who are well trained in India/Pakistan come here and they are given free lessons in English so that they can speak in the mosques in English for the youth. How many of our Gurdwaras worldwide provide this facility for our katha vacheks that come here from abroad ? I do also understand that one really needs to learn panjabi/gurmuki to really progress on the path of sikhe, but we have to understand that our Guru sahiban promoted and did parchar in the languages of the people at the time in India. Isn't it our duty to do the same , yes do katha in English /panjabi and many other languages as possible to spread the beauty of Guru Granth Sahib Ji to the world. Is the panth ready to meet this challange ? Sorry for going off topic a bit my favourtie sevadar of Gurbani katha is the likes of Sant Jarnail Singh Ji Bhindrawale/Jaswant Singh Ji Parvana/ Prof Darshan Singh Ji/Sant Singh Ji Maskeen/ Bhai Surjit Singh Zakami what happened to this guy does anyone know?//bhai Jeevan Singh Ji.. Jaswant Singh Jachek , I think he's in the US at present? 1.Katha of Gurbani vichaar and Sikh way of living according to Gurbani has to be the main theme. 2.Katha using Janam sakhi's and not backed up by Gurbani shouldn't be accepted. Gurbani has all we need there are shabads froma historicial perspective too. 3. Difference between lecture and katha , excellent question Veer Ji, the difference in my opinion is between teacher and Guru. A teacher at a school /universtiy lectures does his job and dissapears, it's up to the students to take it in and digest and delve further that's it. I can't remember any of my university lectures. Where as katha of Gurabni, and when this is being done , Guru Ji develops a realtionship over time with each and everyone that is listening avidly. Hence Guru Ji mentions " Mere man prem laggo her teer" Gurbani is a form of a teer which pierces the heart especially when sevadars as mentioned above do katha with utmost respect. And this indeed does build a realtionship with Guru Ji for the rest of one's life. Guru Ji speaks to us daily.JSBUK · 04 May 2005
Baba Isher Singh RareSahib Walay, Although I never met him as I was born many years after he passed away his kathas have been very inspiring. His voice was very mellow and soothing and his dharna was very uplfiting.Kulbir Singh · 04 May 2005
I have not listened to too much katha as I have always found it too slow. Something that they tell in 1 hour, I can read in 10 minutes. But this does not mean that I am against Katha but it means that Katha is just not for me. Giani Sant Singh Maskeen was a brilliant scholar but the reason why I could not listen to his katha for too long was that he spoke too slowly i.e. the pace of his katha was too slow for me. For this reason, my favourite katha-kaar of all times is Sant Gurbachan Singh Bhindranwaalay. The pace of Sant jee’s katha was really fast and secondly, he only did katha of Gurbani i.e. did not just lecture as most kathakaars do. I love his sweet voice and his traditionalist views. At many times I don’t agree with the meanings he do of Gurbani but despite that, I love hearing his katha. His katha of Bhagat Kabir jee’s saloks is amazing. I have listened to Bhai Pinderpal Singh a couple of times and have found great potential in him. He is good. Difference between lecture and Katha: I think, traditionally, Katha is done of either Gurbani, Bhai Gurdaas jee’s baani or of Gurpartap Suraj Parkash. Lecture on other hand is done on a topic. Katha covers topics related to rehit, day to day affairs, social problems etc, while doing katha of Gurbani. This way you get both – Katha of Gurbani and lecture on social or religious topics. Just my two cents. Daas, KulbirGuldeep Singh · 04 May 2005
Guru Pyareo I concur w/ Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji's view of the speed of Kathas. Most of the audience in Gurudwaras outside (and even inside) India have come out of Modern Education where a concept has to be understood in minutes not hours. Nowadays the student has to understand the any concept the 1st or 2nd time it is explained. Good or bad, the speed our minds work is faster but the speed of the kathas in Gurudwaras are the same. I have brought this point before a few kathavachaks. They argue that the entire Gurbani is a repitition also of the same point. The same concept Satguru has repeated in different ways in 1430 pages. I agree that Maskeen Ji's katha was slow but it was always worth it for me to wait 1 hour for that 15 minute concept. Bhul Chuk MaafKhalistani Singh · 04 May 2005
My favourite Kathakar is Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh And Bhai Gurdas jis varanNaamRas Singh · 04 May 2005
I have to disagree with Bhai Kulbir Singh ... I reckon Sant Singh Maskeen's slow pace, and repetition of ideas was always good ... esp for me, cos I always find it hard to understand. But it might be becos me born outside India innit - BUT then his audience in India was always Punjabi speakers. I think it might be becos most of the time the audience ain't spiritually advanced and it takes time to understand stuff. Whereas on the other hand, you have gurmukhs like Kulbir Singh who can pick stuff up right away. :) sos for going off topic!!!Lord Singh · 04 May 2005
Bhindranwale Sant Sipahi, Jihna Suthi Kaum Jugaee!!! Rara Sahib Wale Karde Hiraan, Dekho Baba Isher Singh Ji De Diwaan!!! Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa, Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!! Daas, Lord Singhsingh · 04 May 2005
Bhai Parminder SIngh ji's katha: http://www.gurmatstudies.com/kathact.htmAkaal · 04 May 2005
Giani Bhag Singh Ambala.parminder · 08 May 2005
i totally agree with kulbir singh ji. Bhai pinderpal singh ji' and sant singh ji maskeen's katha are very impressive but go at very slow pace. Even though i have never seen in my real life, but personally i have always loved sant baba Ishar singh ji's katha. It's just amazing.Rav Singh · 09 May 2005
fateh, Panth Rattan Gyani Sant Singh Ji Maskeen was wiked, i had the opportunity to meet him on the last visit to Uk and listen to katha, and it was always an experience. Everyone would go quite and tune in. He went through many rough times but always did parchar of Gurmat in accordance with Panth, and wasnt afraid to speak out on Panthic matters even in 84. He was truly awazing and his katha still is, and will always be a valued asset to fuure generations. all these pakandis feared him because he was on the path of sach. wahegurooGuldeep Singh · 09 May 2005
Well said Rav Singh Ji !Gurpreet · 09 May 2005
Bhai Sahib Parminder Singh Ji...His kathas are the best...I listen to everyone but in my early stages of Sikhi Bhai Sahib Ji's Kathas really helped me pick things up........Ofcourse its all Guru Sahibs Kirpaa but a lotta kirpaa was done onto me thru Bhai Parminder Singh Ji's Kathasharpreet singh · 11 May 2005
Gyani Abinashi singh komal........is my best kathavachak.......becoz. kyoke sirf history sunaai aur katha vaachak ban gai......eh gal theek nahi hai...shayad aapji nu pata howe ke pehela guru granth saheb ji da paath karan tau pehela kai hor grantha di reading karni pendi si.....us reading nu karke hi asi guru granth sahib ji nu samajh sakne haa........any way.....ek katha vaachak wich eh khubi honi chaaidi hai......gyani sant singh singh ji maskeen saheb wich eh khubi si aur hun kisi wich puran tor te eh khubi nahi hai.......lekin phir wi gyani abinashi singh komal da katha karan da andaaz aur knowlage dasdi hai ke oh ek ache kathavachak hun......una nu itni duniya nahi jaandi.......kyoki kai waar kuch hire aise honde hun jo miti wich hi dabe rehe jaande hun..........menu lagda hai oh una hirya wicho hi ek hun.......jo uzaagar nahi ho sak rahe...........any way................G-Singh · 09 Feb 2006
sant gyani kartaar singh jee.........sooo much bir rasss, so much gyan, such a jeevan to back it all up Other kathavachaks tell us about the great kurbaanis purataan singhs did just to obey guru sahib hukams, but a lot of these kathaavachaks just dont seem convincing. but when you hear sant jee talk about dying before cutting hair, or about how important it is to follow hukams, or how life is useless without guru sahib, its just sooooo convincing. and you know sant jee wasnt all talk and nothing to back either. sant jee passes away instead of disobeying guru sahibs hukum. Just reading thru sant jees jeevan makes me think about how great gursikhs really are, full of bir rass, bhagti, bani, seva, pyaar, santokh.........really makes me think about the greatness of purataan gurmukhs........... · 09 Feb 2006
Giani Thakur Singh jiagyani · 10 Feb 2006
1) Who is your favourite Kathakaar and why? Giani Thakur singh ji, coz his katha rox and u can tell everything he sas he has done him self and speak from experience. 2) What kind of Katha is acceptable and what kind not? For me personally katha should be all based on conveying guru jis message and that is acceptable, what is not acceptable is how some katha vachiks twist gurbani to knock certain individuals. 3) What is the difference between lecture and Katha? lecture is something that is more of a western thing, like these camps that are held where "lectures" take place. Katha is more traditional and, in my view, is carried out by raab di pyaara.confused · 10 Feb 2006
bhai pinderpal singhSingh · 11 Feb 2006
Did Bhai Pinderpal do katha in english or punjabi? I want some katha in English, as I don't understand punjabi as much. Could someone please locate me to a website where I can listen to katha of gurbani in English