Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Malhi and Grewal

Malhi and Grewal

anonymous · 30 Apr 2005

Wanted to post parts of their speeches against SSM. You could read their whole speeches at the following links. Normally, many would expect these two men to be have rather poor English - but their speeches against SSM were actually quite good: Malhi http://www.parl.gc.ca/38/1/parlbus/chambus/house/debates/074_2005-03-24/HAN074-E.htm#Int-1186884 Same sex marriage is not considered as a human right according to the United Nations Human Rights Committee. Just because differences exist in society, it does not mean that inequality and discrimination exist. Consider for example, that a woman is not entitled to use the men's washroom. This is not a case of her being discriminated against. It is because she does not meet the criterion of someone to whom the washroom is assigned. Likewise, if a same sex couple is not entitled to marry, it is not that those individuals are being discriminated against or that their equal rights are being violated. It is that they do not meet the criterion of a couple to whom that institution is assigned.... Males and females complement each other. Children need the warmth and comfort of the mother and the playful rough and tumble as well as the protection of the father. The law of the land should not deny children the possibility of having both a mother and a father. The great circle of life is male and female. This even applies to the world of man-made objects. A table is not complete without a chair. A picture needs the support of a frame. Opposites come together and complete the circle of life. We need a key to open a door lock. Wheels are needed to drive a car. Likewise, men and women need each other to complete the circle of life. Marriage is an expression of natural and divine law. Grewal http://www.parl.gc.ca/38/1/parlbus/chambus/house/debates/075_2005-04-04/HAN075-E.htm#Int-1194510 I think most Canadians would agree that gays and lesbians should be free to pursue whatever type of relationship they wish. I see no problem in legally recognizing homosexual relationships, but this should not be done by changing marriage. In 1999 homosexual couples were given pension, property and other rights by changing 68 federal statutes through Bill C-23. If there are any pending rights, they should be allowed.... Abraham Lincoln, when debating an individual, sought to resolve the issue with a question, “Sir, if you call a tail a leg, how many legs does a dog have?” “Five”, responded the gentleman. Lincoln corrected the man, “Four, sir. Just because you call a tail a leg doesn't make it so”. The Liberals are committing the same folly. Just because one calls it a marriage does not make it so. It is an exercise in self-deceit, a denial of reality. During my years in elected office I have been involved in a number of debates involving measures that deal with discrimination. I have supported legislation in this House and have spoken repeatedly to prohibit inappropriately unequal treatment of individuals based on race, religion, gender, disability and sexual orientation. I have been outspoken on the need to protect the human rights of all people, whether they be Falun Gong practitioners in China, Muslims in Gambia, South Asians living in Canada, or people in labour camps in Tibet. I have spoken with Chinese officials on their human rights record. I have been an advocate of the Human Rights Commission in B.C. The Liberals are attempting to frame the issue of same sex marriage in the context of justice and human rights. In doing so they are insulting all those people in the world who suffer from human rights abuses on a daily basis. How could the Liberals equate the denial of marriage to homosexuals to unlawful imprisonment, abuse, torture, denying voting rights or freedom of speech? The Prime Minister is playing crass politics when he paints gay marriage as a human rights issue. He knows that Canadians will not accept same sex marriage on its own merits, so he is attempting to tie it to human rights and charter issues dear to the hearts of Canadians. While this may be politically opportunistic, manipulative and beneficial, morally it is dishonest. [%sig%]

Re: Malhi and Grewal

S1ngh · 01 May 2005

Good speeches.

Re: Malhi and Grewal

Kulbir Singh · 02 May 2005

Absolutely beautiful lectures by Malhi and Grewal. It is good to see that these two MPs have actively supported the decision of Siri Akal Takhat Sahib to not encourage the Same-Sex Bill. Kulbir Singh

Re: Malhi and Grewal

Singh · 02 May 2005

I'm glad that the politicians showed some backbone and stood by what was right rather then what was easy. Props to Malhi for standing firm, even though it went against his party's platform.

Re: Malhi and Grewal

Singh · 02 May 2005

malhi is a babbar sher. balay oye babbar shera. tu maa da dudh sachee peetha hai. tu taan mard hain mard! shabash babbar shera!

Re: Malhi and Grewal

singh · 02 May 2005

its probably easier for a sikh mp to be against same sex marriage than it is for a sikh mp to be against it. Just look how well malhi is being treated and how much critiscm Bains is getting. I dont believe Bains is right but he could have easily said he was against it and never had any problems . He is firmly standing up for what he believes even though he is coming under a great amount of critiscm, and i respect that.

Re: Malhi and Grewal

Tout · 02 May 2005

It is very hard for a tout to live in his own comunity but he is well respected in the enemy comunity Yes it is hard to stand for your comunity as it is minority.

Re: Malhi and Grewal

Singh4 · 02 May 2005

If these MP's are standing up for what they believe is right than thats very respectable. But, to say that they are being good Sikhs for being against it is wrong. The only true Sikh in the house of commons is for it. Why? They bottom line is that gays and lesbians are born like that. They have as much say over who they are (with respect to this life) as we do over what colour we are born. I think they have bad karma but who are we to pass laws based on levels of karma? No one is being hurt if the definition of marriage is changed. Not changing the definition isn't going to stop them from commiting kurheits. It is against Sikhi to be in a SSM but it also against Sikhi to force your views on others. If forcing your views is right than there was nothing wrong with Taliban ruled Afghanistan or the Mughal rule in India or segregation. The last time I checked Canada wasn't a theocracy. It is the right thing to do to let them marry each other. If I was in Navdeep Bains shoes I would have done the exact same thing and I have even more respect for him now because he did the right thing no matter what the consequences were. He is the the babbar sher not these two. [%sig%]

Re: Malhi and Grewal

S1ngh · 02 May 2005

Singh4, What does marriage have to do with being a theocracy? This is the main thing you guys don't get, people can religiously marry whomever they want in their religious ceremonies; no one is stopping them. This is an issue around whether society should condone and look upon those relationships as "marriages" which is a social term which by definition refers to a opposite-gender relationship. Is Canada a theocracy for not sanctioning polygamy and incestual marriage? I didn't think so.

Re: Malhi and Grewal

Singh4 · 03 May 2005

S1ngh, >>What does marriage have to do with being a theocracy? << Marriage is a religious term. If it were a "social" term than any two hetrosexual couples out there would be "married." Court marriage has come as a result of religious marriage, not the other way around. >>This is the main thing you guys don't get, people can religiously marry whomever they want in their religious ceremonies; no one is stopping them. << We do understand this. This has nothing to do with our argument. >>This is an issue around whether society should condone and look upon those relationships as "marriages" which is a social term which by definition refers to a opposite-gender relationship.<< Like I said marriage is a religious term. We look upon these relationships as wrong because our religions tell us so. How many of us would have a problem with this if it were okay according to our religions? The answer is none of us would and that right there tells us that we are against this because we believe God doesn't want us to allow them to get married. Hence, we are trying to force our religious views on others. >>Is Canada a theocracy for not sanctioning polygamy and incestual marriage? I didn't think so.<< Actually, Canada is against these because they are against Christian belief, so Canada is a bit of a theocracy. And thats where the whole argument about the seperation of church and state comes in. SSM, polygamy, incestual marriage, are wrong because our religions tell us so, and for no other reason. They are not hurting anyone by doing these things. If adults want to practice these things consentually than so be it, its there life and their karma. In my opinion when we see gays and lesbians we are disgusted, its a natural reaction, and because they disgust us we hate them. It is this hatred that is the underlying motive behind not accepting them. I ask you, what catastrophe would occur if Canada allowed same sex marriage? Who will be affected by it? The reason the Conservatives are against it is because they think the same thing will happen to Canada as did with Sodom and Gamora (pardon the spelling). If it were an argument about right and wrong, then according to every religion "premarital relationships" are wrong, so should we go about and make a law that no two people can have "premarital relationships?" This law would fine or through any two people in jail if we think they were having "premarital relationships."? If you are against SSM then you should be in favour of this law. But if this seems a bit too taliban to you than you should maybe rethink your stance on SSM. [%sig%]

Re: Malhi and Grewal

S1ngh · 03 May 2005

Singh4, So let's get this straight. You're not only in favour of gay marriage, but also of polygamy and incestual marriages being legal. Gotcha. Very popular argument you're carrying there buddy. Morality in law doesn't equal a theocracy. Ain't nothing wrong with some morality. Ya'll extreme liberals need some help. We need more common sense liberals like MALHI!

Re: Malhi and Grewal

Singh4 · 03 May 2005

S1ngh, If your morals come from religion than ya, it is a theocracy as per the definition of a theocracy. A "common sense liberal" as you put it is a conservative not a liberal. Don't let your hatred cloud your judgement.

Re: Malhi and Grewal

TUF · 03 May 2005

I agree with Singh4's comments. I personally don't think much of gays and lesbians, nor do I approve of their lifestyle. But if the Canadian Government allows them to join in matrimony, I couldn't care less. As long as it doesn't effect me, then its all fine. Lets not be hypocritical since its the same charter that gives us as Sikhs the right to do so many things we can't in other countries. Why not let these gays have their happiness. Guru Tegh Bahadhur martyred himself for people (kashimiri pandits) whose beliefs we don't necessarily share (eg. idol worship/rituals), but he was attempting to defend a peoples rights. I'm sure he didn't agree with them, but nevertheless he laid down his life for them. In the same way, we have this duty to defend these gay peoples rights, even if we don't agree with them.

Re: Malhi and Grewal

confused · 03 May 2005

hahahaa when i saw malhi is a babbar sher it gave me a big laugh malhi is dont call him a babbar sher

Re: Malhi and Grewal

TUF · 03 May 2005

Is Malhi still a Babbar Sher when he's standing outside Wal-Mart distributing flyers come election time.