Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Can Women get Parshad of Punj Piaray?

Can Women get Parshad of Punj Piaray?

hmmm · 30 Apr 2005

Is it ok to give Singhnis Parshad of 5 Piaray when we give out Degh in Sangat? I heard that its not okay, and it can only be given to Singhs because no women stood up when Guru Ji asked for a head... What is the Sangat's view?

Re: Can Women get Parshad of Punj Piaray?

Question Bhai · 30 Apr 2005

Women have been accepted in the "Rehit Mayada" during the Pahul Ceremony. See point B under "Ceremony of Baptism or Initiation - Article XXIV" in this link : http://www.sgpc.net/rehat_maryada/section_six.html You decide for yourself why women can't be given parshad representing Panj Piaray.

Re: Can Women get Parshad of Punj Piaray?

Harsimrat Kaur · 30 Apr 2005

gurfateh ji, i'm not sure but this is my views. i think it is ok becasue guru ji said that men and women are equal. everyone is equal and treated equal. please correct me if i am wrong... gurfateh ji.

Re: Can Women get Parshad of Punj Piaray?

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 30 Apr 2005

Yes. And women are part of the Panj Piaray.

Re: Can Women get Parshad of Punj Piaray?

Dalrajkaur Khalsa · 30 Apr 2005

Singhniaan are allowed to get punj singh-aa dee degh. At Gurdwara Tapoban Sahibs, the Singhnee are given punj Singh-aa dee degh. Women also also allowed to do seva in punj. That is the lamest excuse, that bibian didn't stand up then. Anyone that gives their head can be a punj piyaara, and Singhniaan give their heads when taking amrit so, they can do seva in punj.

Re: Can Women get Parshad of Punj Piaray?

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 01 May 2005

YES YES YES YES YES....How many times are we going to answer this question. ONLY the SADHS and SANTS DERAWALLAHS OPPOSE WOMEN in PUNJ, giving women PUnj Degh etc etc. To them Women are "inferior"... well our GURU KHALSA PANTH PARWANIT SIKH REHAT MARYADA says otherwise. Thus there is no question left to answer. Just read the SRM...approved by AKAL TAKHAT.

Re: Can Women get Parshad of Punj Piaray?

Canadian Sikh · 01 May 2005

If u say that "everyone is equal and treated equal" in the eyes of the guru's, and should also be in the taking the concept of a universal supreme being (GOD), then how is it that a significant portion of the Canadian Sikh Community view that Homosexuals should not be treated equally? The original message posted by "hmm" as to whether woman have the same rights is ludicrous!! As some Sikh's take their Rehit to a new level, or others who are just mis-informed, they seem to lose the basic message of Sikh, which is that we are all equal and as such, should be treated equally. Going back to my post on gay rights, the arguments of Kaam and quoting the Dasaam Granth to justify discriminating against a minority is wrong, and as a result were losing the basic message of Sikhi. Is it not enough that we are portrayed as terrorists in the Canadian media, that we have to have religious leaders (Vedanti) who issue decree's to "Canadian MP's" to vote against a Bill that would secure the right of Gays to marry and not have just what is called a civil union. Is it not ironic that the decree comes from a man who is suppose to embody the Sikhi principles the most, yet has done nothing to rectify the issue of woman doing sewa at the Harminder Sahib (and yes some will blame the SGPC, but as they say "birds of a feather, flock together"). To make sure I do not get a flurry of replies to this post, a few things should be mentioned. 1) The new Canadian Bill on Gay marriages will give homosexuals the right to have legally defined marriages and not civil unions, meaning that they will be equal among all Canadians in terms of marriage. 2) The Bill has a clause which basically states the any religious church, gurdwara or institution can refuse to marry a gay couple and not be taken to court on that grounds. This means that all this fear-mongering that has been stirred up by religious leaders oversea's and the Right wing parties in Canada about "gay couples" being married in the gurdwaras and Sikh's having no say to stop them is absurd. 3) We can all say that a Sikh marriage is defined in the religious script between a man and a woman. So why are SIkhs so affraid of gay marriage, a gay Sikh couple could get married, but they could never have a religiously valid Sikh Marriage. 4) It is a well known fact that 1 outta of every 10 humans is homosexual (whether they have come out of the closet or not) and 3 outta 20 experience homosexual tendencies and thoughts on a continuum. Some will say that "hey in India/Punjab" there are no Gay people or just a few, but when we look at North America, the same can be said 100 years ago. Culture and the stigmatization of being homosexual and homophobia all play a role as to why the number remain low. 5) How as "Canadian Sikhs" do we seek to deny that rights that we so freely enjoy in this country (CANADA) of ours. The right to wear turbans in the workplace, army, law enforcement and anywhere we choose is a right we have protected under the Canadian Charter of Rights. The right to wear the Kirpan (not a miniature one that can be worn on a neclace, but a respecatble sized one) is also protected under the charter. Sikhs in some companies such as the financial giant PRICE WATERHOUSE are allowed to take off Sikh holidays as the climate of understanding in this country grows. Sikhs in Canada are so quick to jump on the anti-gay bandwagon, when it is ironic that we were fighting for all the freedoms we so enjoy today in Canada, just like the Gay community is doing today. Whats even more comical is that fact that in Canada our marriage is recognized as a SIkh Marriage, but in India last I knew, our marriages where considered to be one of a Hindu nature. Where do the priorities of the Canadian Sikh community lie!! The Supreme Court of Canada, is currently reviewing a decision on whether a young Sikh boy and all those who follow in his footsteps will be allowed to wear his Kirpan to school in the Province of Quebec. The Kirpan issue was settled as a human rights issue in most provinces of Canada up to this point in favor of a Sikh's religious right. But the Supreme Court Ruling will become the Law of the Land, which will rectify the jurisdictional differences on wearing the Kirpan to school or not, and that decision which is said to be highly favourable for SIkhs should come out soon. ** So my point is, we as Sikh's expect out rights to be respected and to be treated equally, but on the flipside of the coin, many Sikhs feel we should deny others the rights we have, because some feel it does not conform with our views!! Now doesn't that sound hypocritical....Discriminating against another is anti-Sikhi, and yes, some of you will say that Gay people where not around back in the time of the Guru's and that they were not mentioned in the texts, or some will say they were mentioned in a brief quote and it was not favorable"...but how does that really matter, we do not live in the 1600-1700's and society has changed alot since then. Women on the same accord should have equal rights on par with men, but as this forum shows, many people out there still have not grasped that basic concept.*** One finally note to the Canadian Sikhs, the Conservative party seems to have won the hearts of many Sikh community leaders (i.e. Ontario Khalsa Darbar commitee) and other citizens, but many don't see that they are being used. Putting a religious spin on a topic and showing that we are not a tolerant people (which is not true in SIkhi, but what can I say, large % of Sikhs still practise caste/color/and geographical discrimination within Sikhism) emotions are raised and the fanatical side of people come out. Many Canadian SIkhs don't stop to think that, "HEY this is a right wing party, who in their previous form from years back where against RCMP turbaned Sikhs, having Kirpans worn in schools and public, and so on". Many don't realise that this is a party led by a leader who was at one time head of the most right-wing party in Canada (the small and obscure Family coalition). This is also a party who seek to enact the "Notwithstanding Clause" which can be used to TRUMP the Charter of Rights to deny Gay people the right to marry if the bill passes and they come into power. And this Charter of Rights which many of you don't know protects your rights as a Sikh to practice Sikhi, but when one group can be denied their rights, this leaves open the flood gates for deny or taking away others rights that they have already won. WJKK WJKF [%sig%]

Re: Can Women get Parshad of Punj Piaray?

hmmm · 02 May 2005

I know sometimes we quote on saying that, SGPC Maryada says its ok, so it is...but why do we pick and choose? What do i mean?...on some things we say SGPC Maryada is wrong in this and that...(keski, 3 Banis, Halal)...etc etc...but then when it does agree with our views on certain issues, we start saying that SGPC says this and that, so it must be right. [%sig%]

Re: Can Women get Parshad of Punj Piaray?

khalistani · 02 May 2005

no theres even shabads saying panch singh amrit jo devai this is a new thing sant jarnai; singh je even clearly says this is wrong all mahapurkhs have said this is wrong i dont know even one alloweing this this is against maryada even banee says pannch singhs, not panch khalsai, or panch singh and singhneea, but singh bhula chuka maf

Re: Can Women get Parshad of Punj Piaray?

Sikh · 02 May 2005

Singh doesnt only mean a MALE

Re: Can Women get Parshad of Punj Piaray?

Khatarnak Times · 02 May 2005

>>> no theres even shabads saying panch singh amrit jo devai this is a new thing sant jarnai; singh je even clearly says this is wrong all mahapurkhs have said this is wrong i dont know even one alloweing this this is against maryada even banee says pannch singhs, not panch khalsai, or panch singh and singhneea, but singh bhula chuka maf >>> I humbly request the sangat to help this lost veer. Whomever these perpetrators are who corrupt such innocent and eager Sikhs should face the most severe punishment. I mean here is a kid who has been so overwhelmed with the evils of Santdom that his mind has been trapped behind the bars of Santdom propaganda. He can't look beyond it ... the worst is that he has lost the will to look beyond it. My worst fear is that these kids will eventually lose hope when Baba Jarnail Singh never comes back. It is truly sad that our younger brothers and sisters must suffer from the harsh consequences of the flourishing Santdom business. Oh, the burdens such young minds must bear. Am I the only one who feels concerned at the toll the evil of Santdom is taking on our younger brothers and sisters?? Dear Sangat jee, please hear my plea, the woes of a caring brother. I think that a sincere ardaas from the sangat can help "Khalistani" and others like him. I mean its kids like this who end up becoming suicide bombers. Please... Please... I humbly beg the sangat to do atleast 5 chaupai sahib day paath and do ardaas for this veer and others like him so that they may be freed from this evil. The sants abuse gurbani and misinterpret it to mislead people. We must stand against this and dish out severe punishment for such crimes. Guru Rakha.

Re: Can Women get Parshad of Punj Piaray?

Dogma · 02 May 2005

Khatarnak Times, I have had the oppurtunity to talk to Khalistani on MSN and I honestly believe that he has not been misled by any fake Sant or anything else that you suggest. Just because his views on this topic differ from yours doesn't mean that he's some lost soul in need of guidance. I'm sure his views on Raagmala differs from ALOT of people out there as well...I don't see him making requests to the sangat to do ardaas for these "lost souls". Also, why not speak to Khalistani Veerji for yourself? Why talk on this thread like he's not reading it? You could have posted to him directly. Or you could have emailed him by now as well. "I think that a sincere ardaas from the sangat can help "Khalistani" and others like him. I mean its kids like this who end up becoming suicide bombers." ..Suicide is strictly against Sikhi. I'm positive that Khalistani veerji knows this. Please don't drop Islamic ideology into this thread as it has nothing to do with anything. "Dear Sangat jee, please hear my plea, the woes of a caring brother." ...if you're that caring then how about talking to Khalistani yourself? Email him veerji, I think you'd be pleasantly surprised at his answers. "I humbly beg the sangat to do atleast 5 chaupai sahib day paath and do ardaas for this veer and others like him so that they may be freed from this evil. " ...Veerji, your post seems to stink of EGO. Stop this "Holier than thou" attitude. If you bothered to speak to Khalistani veerji I think you'll see that he considers none other than Guru Granth Sahib Jee as his Guru. He has taken Khande-kee-pahul. He wears Bana. This "evil" that you seem to speak of is nothing but a figment of your imagination. NOTE: JUST BECAUSE SOMEONE DISAGREES WITH YOU DOESN'T MEAN THAT THEY ARE BEING EFFECTED BY SOME TYPE OF SPIRITUAL EVIL.

Re: Can Women get Parshad of Punj Piaray?

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 02 May 2005

khalistani veer, vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!! i have to disagree on this thing - because punj singh means punj khalsa, there is no difference. guru sahib never said "khalsi" therefore there is no such thing as "singhni" - we just made this word up. the word for a khalsa is a singh. a singh is a khalsa and a khalsa is a singh - they can be male or female. when guru gobind singh sahib writes in bhai nand lal jee's vaars about the rehat of a singh, does this only apply to males? when guru ji writes in gurbani "gursikh har bolo mere bhaee" - it says "bhaee" does that mean only the males can speak God's name? No, veerjee, this is not the case. Sometimes Guru Sahib has used the word "avoh bhainay" does this mean he is only talking to the females? No - he is talking to the "jeev eistree." In the same way, we are all Singhs in the Fauj of Guru ji, whether male or female. I think we should not misunderstand - just because Singh means a male lion does not mean that only males have that name. Guru ji gave us this name because of the qualities (strength, power, majesty, prestige) of the male lion, not because of the fact that it is the name for a male animal. In the same way, Kaur means son of the King, but women are not sons - they are daughters. Why did Guru ji give this name? Because guru ji is not gender-biased. He saw the good qualities and he gave those names to his children - both men and women. In Sikh history our family name is Singh first, and Bibia have the additional name of Kaur, because they are like male lions and male children - they deserve same rights. The whole point of this was so that we drop our caste names - not so that we start making differences between Sikh bhai's and bibia. That would be like leaving caste discrimination and going into gender discrimination. We should only discriminate between truth and falsehood, not between jatt and khatri or young and old OR male and female. I cannot say that you have to change your way of thinking. I am a manmukh and I have no right to say this to you. However, if anybody asked me I would tell them that I believe that a bibi in the punj pyare is not against maryada. Same way they can receive the degh / parshad of the punj pyare. I am a manmukh - I don't keep rehit, but on this topic I can say for sure that this is not against rehit to have bibia in the punj pyare. please forgive my mistakes. vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!!