what happened today at school; muslim girls sayin sikhism made up of lies.
Tarrandeep Kaur · 29 Apr 2005
I go to a girls school were there are alot of muslims girls and no sikhs. Today a moni who claims to be a sikh came up to me quite upset, she was telling me that a strict muslim girl, who wears a hijaab, came up to her and her friends and said that sikhism is just made up of lies and they shouldn't be sikhs, they should look at other religions like islam. They told me to do something about it, i rang up my cousin and asked him if i should speak 2 the muslim girls but he said that he will speak 2 her instead on a mobile fone. So i went up to the girl and told her what the moni had told me earlier, and then i handed over the phone to her. My cousin made a few points that she couldn't argue with so she kept sayin ' i have nothing to say', she then gave the phone back to me. I think he was saying stuuf like why mohammed married a nine year old girl when he was fifty summit. Afterwards her and ten of her muslim friends came up to me, they were very angry, they said tht muslims are always gettin verbal abuse and they are getting fed up of it, they also said i shouldn't have given the muslim girl the phone........there pretty angry now.... and this other girl reckons the muslims are gone get some more muslims to 'sort me out'.
I told the girl after that i dont want to attack her religion, i just think that we all should have respect for one anothers religion..... she then began to lie and say she didnt say anythink bad about sikhism. This is a lie because three people clearly heard her.
Do you think i should not have given the phone to her... and sorted it out myself( that is wat i was going to do but my cousin wanted to speak 2 her) i think i've made things worse by doing this.
vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh
Re: what happened today at school; muslim girls sayin sikhism made up of lies.
Tarrans Cousin · 29 Apr 2005
No, Tanks T! You did the right thing. M did be a bit mean to the Muslim on the phone, sorray. I dont think her muslim friends are really going to sort you out
Re: what happened today at school; muslim girls sayin sikhism made up of lies.
Kulbir Singh · 29 Apr 2005
Approaching your cousin for help was not a bad idea but if your cousin had been a female, it would have been better.
Secondly, before approaching your cousin or anyone else, you should have been able to answer all the questions yourself. I am not picking on you, but just encouraging you to learn more about your religion so that when they attack you, you are able to defend your religion.
Sometimes the best form of defense is attack but still we should be able to fend off attack on our religion through solid arguments.
The questions they raise about our religion can be raised about their religion too. It would be nice if you could list some of the arguments they raised against Sikhi.
It is my appeal to all young and old Gursikhs - please be informed of Sikhi. If anyone asks us a question on Sikhi, we must be able to answer it.
Coming back to Islam, yes they are really susceptible to attacks on their religion. I mean, what can they say when they are told that their prophet should not have married a 7 year old girl, who was the daughter of his best friend? What can they tell you when you tell them that Mohammad got married 11 times? But having said this, if they ask us a question on Sikhi, it does not mean we should get personal and start attacking their prophet. We should debate a based on high principles and if they attack a Sikhi principle, we should refute their claim and then ask them what their belief is on the item being discussed. See if their principle makes sense and if you fiind a loophole in it, attack it. Btw, there are no loopholes in Gurmat.
Kulbir Singh
Re: what happened today at school; muslim girls sayin sikhism made up of lies.
Manvir Singh · 29 Apr 2005
In my experience common questions asked by Muslims which all Sikh children should be prepare for:
1/ Why do you keep your hair but cut your nails?
This makes no sense! Keeping your hair uncut is pointless and unfashionable.
2/ Your religion tells you that you cannot drink, yet all Sikhs drink alcohol.
Listen to Panjabi songs, go to Sikh weddings, or ask anyone, Sikhs are known for drinking. Even your priests drink. What religion is this? You can't even follow it. Islam is the only true religion. We practice what we preach.
3/ Sikhism doesn't believe in caste, yet Sikhs still practice caste.
You have Gurdwaras named after castes, and you marry according to castes. So your religion can't be true, if people aren't even practicing it.
4/ Did you know Guru Nanak was a Muslim.
(i) Guru Nanak ji's best friend was a Muslim.
(ii) Guru Nanak ji went on pilgrimage (Hajj) to Mecca (one of the five pillars of Islam)
(iii) Guru Nanak ji refused idolatory and believed the same things as Islam.
(iv) Guru Nanak ji dressed as a Muslim. When travelled to Arabia he wore a Muslim dress.
(v) Muhammad is the the last prophet. Guru Nanak Ji was a holy man who wanted Muslims to practice Islam.
5/ Islam is the fatest growing religion.
Why? There must be something in the religion, that everyone wants to become Muslim. How many Sikhs are there and look at how many Muslims there are in the world. How many people convert to Sikhism? People are attracted to Islam because it is the truth.
Prepare yourself for those questions AT LEAST.
At school I remember Muslims asking me these questions.
Last year a boy from a Sikh family at my university converted to Islam. He did a lecture in January at our university's Islamic Awareness Week. I couldn't go because I was busy. But few members from Sikh Society went to the talk.
The convert boy said "I used to be Sikh. The founder of Sikhism is 'Guru Nanak Singh'"
THe boy didn't know the first Guru's name properly!! No-one why he became a Muslim with persuasion. (The conversion was aided by the fact that his girl-friend was muslim and wanted him to convert).
Young Muslims read the Qur'an and know about their religion.
They are taught Arabic as kids and they know the basics of their faith.
Sad fact -- As Sikhs our children are not taught Gurbaani, a lot of children don't even know the ten Guru's name and children don't have the foggiest about x,y, z of Sikhi.
We should use this as oppurtunity as a wake up call!!
1/ Educate yourself
2/ Educate your family and friends
3/ Support the youngsters in your community - be their friends, share dukh sukh, start youth clubs, discuss issues, and let kids be honest about their problems so that we can help (rather than it get's too late and others offer a shoulder to cry on hoping that the vulnerable person will convert)
bhul chuk maaf
Daas, Manvir Singh
Re: what happened today at school; muslim girls sayin sikhism made up of lies.
Manvir Singh · 30 Apr 2005
Possible responses to the questions posed by Muslims:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1/ Why do you keep your hair but cut your nails?
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Covered in the Daas' article "Who Are Sikhs", kindly posted by Roop Kaur penji.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2/ Your religion tells you that you cannot drink, yet all Sikhs drink alcohol.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
There is a difference between a religion and the people who claim to be part of that religion.
Drinking alcohol is part of "Panjabi culture". If you actually bothered to research Sikhi rather than give airy fairy facts which you heard you would know that the drinking alcohol or consuming any intoxicant is one of the Four Cardinal Sins (Bajjar Kurehats).
[i]"jit peetai kasam visrai, dargeh milai sajaa'e"
...Drinking it, he forgets his Lord and Master, and he is punished in the Court of the Lord.[/i]
(Ang 554)
Is it right for me to say:
"Your religion says that you should not murder innocent men, women and children, yet in the Sept. 11 terroist attack "Muslims" murdered thousands of innocents."
"There was a documentary shown two years ago in UK on channel about Imams in mosques across UK who have been reported for child abuse. So does that reflect Islam?"
"I know "Muslims" who drink, have sexual relationships before marriage and don't do their daily prayers - does this reflect Islam's weakness?"
No! I would be stupid to believe these things. Dear friend a true Sikh is a Sikh by action, just as a true Muslim is true by action.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3/ Sikhism doesn't believe in caste, yet Sikhs still practice caste.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Whether someone practices their religion or not is up to them.
Unfortunately people are driven by ego, greed, and attachment to abuse religion and divert from the the Guru/Prophet's message.
For example the Qur'an says:
[i]"Unite and do not divide." (Sura 3:103; 6:159; 61:4)[/i]
Sadly, Muslims are divide in so many groups thats hard to count! Some of the main divided groups are:
(i) Shi'a (ii) Sunni (iii) Wahhabi (iv) Ahmedias (v) Sufi
Then there are further sub-divisions.
More unfortunate Mosques are divided into these groups. A Shi'a muslim won't go to a Sunni mosque and vice versa.
Dear friend, let us pray that the whole humanity sees Allah (God) in all.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4/ Did you know Guru Nanak was a Muslim.
(i) Guru Nanak ji's best friend was a Muslim.
(ii) Guru Nanak ji went on pilgrimage (Hajj) to Mecca (one of the five pillars of Islam)
(iii) Guru Nanak ji refused idolatory and believed the same things as Islam.
(iv) Guru Nanak ji dressed as a Muslim. When travelled to Arabia he wore a Muslim dress.
(v) Muhammad is the the last prophet. Guru Nanak Ji was a holy man who wanted Muslims to practice Islam.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Wow! Isn't that great. Our Guru was so great that the Hindus wanted him to be their Guru, and Muslims wanted him to be the Muslim's Peer. It just show's how the whole world wanted to Guru Nanak Ji belong to their community.
Did you know that in Tibet Guru Nanak Sahib Ji is considered the eighth Buddha (please confirm whether's its eighth buddha or another number), in parts of Russia Guru Nanak Ji is known as a local saint, by Muslims he is their Peer, for Sikhs he is our Guru, Akaal-Roop.
[i](i) Guru Nanak ji's best friend was a Muslim.[/i]
I have a Christian as a friend at school. O and I have a Muslim as a friend as well. Does that make me a Christian and a Muslim?
[i](ii) Guru Nanak ji went on pilgrimage (Hajj) to Mecca (one of the five pillars of Islam)[/i]
Guru Nanak Ji did not perform hajj, he "travelled" to Mecca to spread the truth to those who needed it the most. It is only the "Kaaba" which is restricted to Muslims. If you bothered to even research Sikh religion before embarrasing yourself you would know that Guru Granth Shaib Ji says:
[i]rojaa dhurai nivaaj gujaarai kulumaa bhisath n hoee
Keeping your fasts, reciting your prayers, and reading the Kalma, the Islamic creed, shall not take you to paradise.
suthar kaabaa ghutt hee bheethar jae kar jaanai koee
The Temple of Mecca is hidden within your mind, if you only knew it. ||2||[/i]
(Ang 480)
Did you know that Kaaba of the Sikhs, Sri Harmandar Sahib in Amritsar has four doors which signifies that all people of God, irrespective of religion, caste, gender or race are allowed in.
[i](iii) Guru Nanak ji refused idolatory and believed the same things as Islam.[/i]
Wonderful. It's great how the truth is universal and that no one religion or person has the monopoly on the truth.
[i](iv) Guru Nanak ji dressed as a Muslim. When travelled to Arabia he wore a Muslim dress.[/i]
O Dear, does that mean that you are a Christian? Because you are wearing trousers and shirt which is the dress of the Western Christian countries.
If I go to China and wear Chinese clothes to be integrate into the community, would that automatically make me Chinese? Don't be silly.
[i](v) Muhammad is the the last prophet. Guru Nanak Ji was a holy man who wanted Muslims to practice Islam.[/i]
Dear friend before you tell me what Guru Nanak Ji wanted or said I suggest that you read all of Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Don't say what you have said to me to someone else otherwise they will make you feel embarrassed.
Guru Nanak Ji did tell Muslims be a true Muslim. If you believe this then 'muhbaarak' to you. However, it is sad that you are not a true Muslim.
For Guru Nanak ji says:
Shalok, First Mehl:
mihur museeth sidhuk musulaa huk hulaal kuraan
Let mercy be your mosque, faith your prayer-mat, and honest living your Koran.
surum sunnath seel rojaa hohu musulumaan
Make modesty your circumcision, and good conduct your fast. In this way, you shall be a true Muslim.
kurunee kaabaa such peer kulumaa kurum nivaaj
Let good conduct be your Kaabaa, Truth your spiritual guide, and the karma of good deeds your prayer and chant.
thusubee saa this bhaavusee naanuk rukhai laaj
Let your rosary be that which is pleasing to His Will. O Nanak, God shall preserve your honor. ||1||
(ang 140)
[i]5/ Islam is the fatest growing religion.[/i]
Great to know. What does numbers matter? Millions of people are attracted to clubs, pubs or casinos - does the number of people attracted make the attraction 'truth'?
Be a true Muslim yourself and forget the number game. If i wanted to play the number game I could have loads of children and make a rule that anyone who leaves Sikhi will be killed.
The Hadith says:
Bukhari 4:52:260 Ali burnt some people (Zanadiqa, atheists 9:84:57) although the Prophet had said, "Don?t punish anybody with Allah's punishment (Fire)" if a Muslim discards his religion, kill him"
Come to the Gurdwara for 4 weeks and spend time with the Sikhs. They are a friendly bunch and will respect your beliefs and will not seek to convert. If Islam is the attraction then you have nothing to fear to see what the Gurdwara and Sikhs practice.
I remember and old Baba ji outside the Gurdwara said to me:
"If someone asks a silly question, then answer it with a silly answer and they will shut up"
:)
Guru Raka
Bhul chuk maaf,
Daas, Manvir Singh
Re: what happened today at school; muslim girls sayin sikhism made up of lies.
Tarrandeep Kaur · 01 May 2005
vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh,
kulbir singh jee u said <<<<<>>>>>>
However, i did approach the muslim girl, and asked her why she thought sikhi was made up of lies, i was going to debate with her, however she denied everything, she said she didnt say that sikhi was made up of lies. She was obviously lying becuase there were five other girls who witnessed her saying these things. So although i did confront her, and was ready to answer her questions, she denied evrything, and wouldnt even elaborate on why she thought sikhi was made up of lies, so i couldnt really answer her questions. So my cousin spoke to her, again she denied evrything, so he just started tlakin bout islam and why it was not the perfect religion.
bhul chuf maak karna
vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh
Re: what happened today at school; muslim girls sayin sikhism made up of lies.
Kulbir Singh · 01 May 2005
Bhain Tarrandeep Kaur jeeo,
Thanks for your clarification. When I wrote my original message requesting you to learn more about Sikhi, I was merely using you as the means to appeal to other youth out there to learn more about Sikhi. If I came across as putting your down, I beg for your forgiveness.
The truth is that Sikhs know little about Sikhi and most of the Sikhs who are well into their middle age, have not had darshan of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee. What is darshan of Guru Sahib? It is not just looking at the outer image of Guru Sahib wrapped in expensive rumaalay. The real darshan of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee is to do paath of whole of Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee from start to end. I know of a lot of Muslim kids who have read the whole Koran before age of 10.
Most youth cannot tell names of 10 Guru Sahibaan and many of those who can tell names of 10 Guru Sahibaan cannot tell in the correct sequence. Most Muslims know more about their prophet than Sikhs know about their Guru Sahibaan.
Most Sikh youth does not have any idea about who Bhai Mardana, Baba Budda jee, Bhai Gurdaas jee, Bhai Bidhi Chand, Bhai Manjh, Bhai Gaenda jee, Bhai Gopala jee, Bhai Makhan Shah Lubhaana jee, Baba Deep Singh were.
Most of the Sikh youth cannot translate Mool Mantr or interpret the concept of God according to Sikhi.
No wonder they are being targetted by Muslims for conversion.
Bhain jeeo, gursikhs like you are our hope for a better future. Khalsa jee wake up! Guru Sahib kirpa karan.
Kulbir Singh