Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 24 Apr 2005

Vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa, Vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!!! In the katha of Gurmukh Pyare Giani Thakar Singh jee (Dam Dami Taksal wale), called "Anand Sahib Viakhia" (www.gurmatveechar.com), there is discussion about the following pankiti: PAAVAI MUKTH NA HORTHHAI KOEE, PUCHAHU BIBAYKEEAA JAAE and also the following pankiti: PAAEIAA AMRIT GUR KIRPAA KEENEE, SACHA MANN VASAAEIAA In addition to the viakhia of these - as the whole viakhia is 12 parts of more than 20 minutes each, there is the full viakhia of anand sahib plus a lot of history. The history that Giani jee discusses includes mention of Guru Gobind Singh Ji. Giani jee says that Guru Gobind Singh jee created such a "PAHUL" called "khande-ke-pahul" which is the final and complete "PAHUL" of all ages. Not to say that "charn pahul" was incomplete, but Giani jee goes so far as to say that all Sikhs, from Guru Nanak Dev Jee's time, to even Guru Gobind Singh jee himself, and his sahibzadas, his mother, etc. etc. all of them had to take "khande-ke-pahul" In Gurbani it is written, "SABH MUKATH HOAA SEHSAARARAA NAANAK SACHEE BAERREE CHARR JEEO" This tells me that eventually all of the Sansaar will get mukt by getting on the real Boat of Truth. The way to get on the boat is to take "PAHUL" So nobody in the universe will be able to get mukath without taking "PAHUL" Yes, they may reach beautiful stages, beautiful places, beautiful heavens and paradises, but those are ultimately limited, and not as real as sach khand, and all will face judgement at some point BRAHM, MAHAYSAR, BISAN, SACHEEPATH, ANTH PHASAE JAM PHAAS PARAINGAE they will not be able to escape the Dharam Raaj, because BHULAN ANDAR SABH KO, ABHUL GUROO KARTAAR but only if they have "guru noo dhaareyaa" or fully accepted a Guru then DHARAM RAAE AB KAHAA KARAYGO JIO PHAATYO SAGLO LAYKHAA but this can only happen if somebody takes PAHUL so EVERYBODY has been or will be sent back to take "KHANDAY KEE PAHUL" because the only "PAHUL" for this Kal jug is "pahul khanday dhaar" KHANDAY KEE VAYLAA This is the "age" of the pahul of the double edged sword. I believe that it is true that all those who have not taken it will have to, but what about those who have taken Charan Pahul - did they all come back? Because there are Sakhis about Guru Gobind Singh jee telling Sikhs that they must take khande-ke-pahul even if they previously took Charn Pahul. Does this mean that Bhai Mardana Jee, Bebe Nanaki Jee, Mata Khivi Jee, Mata Sulakhni Jee, Bhai Gurdas Jee, Baba Buddhaa Jee, etc. etc. etc. all came back and became "Singhs" and "Kaurs" after 1699? and if that is the case, then VAAH! That shows the mahaanthaa of khande-ke-pahul that in this Kal Jug, Guru Nanak Dev Jee came as Guru Gobind Singh Jee in his tenth form, and EVEN GURU NANAK DEV JEE took khande-ke-pahul (as Guru Gobind Singh Jee) and so nobody in this universe can think that without meeting the sathgur pooraa Guru Gobind Singh jee they can attain muktee. I would appreciate the sangat's veechars about this. daas does benti to the sangat that you please forgive my errors, omissions, mistakes, and instead ask bakhshanhaar satguru jee to bless me so that daas might become a gursikh someday vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa Vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!!!!!

Re: did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 25 Apr 2005

anybody have any thoughts on this? vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa vaaheguroojeekeefathehh

Re: did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

Guldeep Singh · 26 Apr 2005

Guru Pyareo Our present Guru Sahib, in Gurbani has Kabir Sahib saying over and over that he is mukat and is not coming back. I don't see where mukat spirits have to return to take pahul. There is praise of Ajamal (paapi) who became mukat. It comes in gurbani over and over and over again. No where does it say that he needs to come back for pahul These are only two examples. How about Prahalad, Sheikh Farid, all the Bhagats? You need to step back and re think your line of reasoning.

Re: did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

Dogma · 26 Apr 2005

alright, since I'm sure this is going to come up anyways.. Singhs, such as Kulbir Singh, have made it known that they believe muktee can only be achieved by following the path of Gurmat/Gurbani. If Gurbani itself shows that Kabir and Fareed are mukt, then doesn't this throw a wrench in that logic? Personally, I have no opinion on this, as I'm so far away from muktee it's laughable...but still I would like to know the " Sikhism only way to Sachkhand" supporters explain this.. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!

Re: did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

sikhi di shaan · 26 Apr 2005

if all ppl are of gods, i dont' think pahul is the only way

Re: did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

Niranjan Singh · 26 Apr 2005

Regarding the Bhagats, please refer to Bhai Randhir Singh Ji's book "Gurmat Parkash", esp. chapters 9, and 10 that deals with this very subject. Also read Bhai Gurdas Ji's Var 1, Pauri 36, and Bhattan-di-Banee for further details. These Bhagats became Sikhs of Guru Nanak via spirit hence they were Sikhs of Baba Nanak. That is why "their" Banne became Dhur-ki-Bannee. An example of this is Bhagat Kabir Ji's Bannee matching the Bannee written by Guru Sahib, sometimes line by line. Prof. Sahib Singh Ji goes into quite detail on all of this in his works.

Re: did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

cybersingh · 26 Apr 2005

actually, in most buddha dal gutkai, there is something which describes how this bhagat came back to be BHAI DAYA Singh PUNJ PYARA and this other bhagat came back and was another original punj, etc etc. basically some of the bhagats whos bani is included in SGGS ji came back to be the original punj pyarai who offered thier head to Guru Sahib. [%sig%]

Re: did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

Kulbir Singh · 27 Apr 2005

Sikhs who were physically alive in 1699 were required to take Khanday dee Pahul but Sikhs before this time did not need Khanday dee Pahul because they had Charan Pahul. None of the Sikhs, including the Bhagats had to come back to receive Khanday daa Amrit. Bhagat Kabir jee, Bhagat Naamdev jee, Baba Buddha jee, Bhai Bidhi Chand jee and other other Sikhs who reached the pinnacles of spirituality via Gurmat Naam don't have to come back to get Khanday daa Amrit. The requirement to reach the top-level of spirituality is to have Gurmat Naam from Satguru and anyone who has this does not need to come back again. There is no misunderstanding here. I don't know what you were trying to imply Dogma jeeo. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

pyara · 27 Apr 2005

Kulbir Singh Ji, How do you know so much?

Re: did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

Guldeep Singh · 27 Apr 2005

The requirement to reach the top-level of spirituality is to have Gurmat Naam from Satguru and anyone --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Bhai Sahib Ji I have recently become amazed at the amount of times Ajamil's name is offered in Gurbani. Over and over again. Ajamil lived well before the Guru's, and never received Gurmat Naam. How do we reconcile this?

Re: did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

Dogma · 27 Apr 2005

" There is no misunderstanding here. I don't know what you were trying to imply Dogma jeeo." ...WHOA! I wasn't trying to imply anything Singh jee. I said in my post that I didn't have an opinion on this. I'm not educated enough to even offer an opinion on this. I was just looking for clarification. I'm sorry if you thought my post was somehow worded in a teasing or demeaning manner. Seriously Bhai Sahib, I was just wondering...maaf karna if you thought I was trying to stir up something. " Sikhs who were physically alive in 1699 were required to take Khanday dee Pahul but Sikhs before this time did not need Khanday dee Pahul because they had Charan Pahul. " Can I assume that this thukh -> "charan dhhoe rehiraas kar charanaamrith skhiaa(n) peelaayaa" is what you're talking about? To be honest, the thought of Charan amrit never even crossed my mind when I wrote my first post. Feel quite shtooopid now.. To Niranjan Singh...thanks for the info! I still haven't gotten my copies of Bhai Sahib Bhai Randheer Singh's books, next time i'm in vancouver I'll pick them up.. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh

Re: did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

Kulbir Singh · 27 Apr 2005

But Dogma jeeo, you have misunderstood me. I did not interpret your forst post under this thread “ teasing or demeaning” to me. I just thought that you wanted to say something that was not clear from your post. I did not think that your post was negative towards me or my post. Sorry, if I gave that impression. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

jss · 27 Apr 2005

and i'm sorry that dogma veerji misinterpreted thinking that kulbir veerji misinterpreted him as thinking dogma misinterpreted him... wow...that was a lot of misinterpretations... anyhow... giyani takhur singh ji in his katha of sukhmani sahib ...mentions during the brahmgiyani astpadhis that kabir ji came and took khanday battay da amrit and then disapeared again...he was trying to explain the concept of brahmgyianis being able to come and go into this world as they wish... i don't doubt the concept... but i was wondering are these sakhis written somewhere?..like in suraj parkash?..or other ithasic granths?...like is there ONE source where everyone gets the sakhis from??

Re: did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

Dogma · 27 Apr 2005

"I just thought that you wanted to say something that was not clear from your post. I did not think that your post was negative towards me or my post. Sorry, if I gave that impression." ...now that we're both sorry for absolutely nothing. Shall we continue? You said that none of the bhagats came back to get Khande kee pahul, but instead had Charan Pahul. Quick two questions.. 1. Is there any evidence (sakhi's, etc) saying that Bhagat Kabeer Jee and others recieved Charan Amrit? 2. Were Bhagat Kabir jee, Bhagat Naamdev jee, Baba Buddha jee, Bhai Bidhi Chand jee all reciting Waheguru gurmantar? Also, one other question totally unrelated to anything...I'm wondering what was Baba Buddha Jee's caste or 'relegion' before he became a Sikh?

Re: did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 27 Apr 2005

Vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa Vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!! but gurmukh pyario, there were gursikhs in the time of guru gobind singh ji who had taken charan pahul but they all had to take khande-ke-pahul as well bhai nand lal mata sahib kaur guru gobind singh ji the punj pyare mata gujri ji all of these people had previously taken charan pahul, but still had to take khande-ke-pahul how are they different from bebe nanaki, bhai mardana, bhai gurdas, etc. ??? please forgive my mistakes Vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa Vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!!!!!!

Re: did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

confused · 27 Apr 2005

could it be possible that Sant Jarnail Singh was a brahmgyani that came back as he wanted to, any views

Re: did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 27 Apr 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa Date: 04-27-05 10:16 there were gursikhs in the time of guru gobind singh ji who had taken charan pahul but they all had to take khande-ke-pahul as well bhai nand lal mata sahib kaur guru gobind singh ji the punj pyare mata gujri ji all of these people had previously taken charan pahul, but still had to take khande-ke-pahul how are they different from bebe nanaki, bhai mardana, bhai gurdas, etc. ??? ____________------------------___________----------------____________ its obvious....Bebe nanaki/Bhai Gurdass Ji/Bhai mardana Ji..were long departed by 1699....the others named were ALIVE. After Vasakhi 1699.... there was this wonderful thing calaled Khande Batte De PAHUL.....which OVER-RODE everything else....and anyone ALIVE could make the CHOICE to partake of this Wonderful GIFT..even though they had already taken charanamrit...and so bhai nand lala ji and all thsoe you named di take this opportunity...BUT Bebe nanaki/Bhai mardana ji etc COULD NOT. TIMES CHANGE....Progress occurs....when Aristotle got known as a "philosopher"..he didnt go to any "university"....as there wernt any....BUT today if one wants to be known as a PHILOSPHER...one MUST go to a University to get a PH.D.....it deosnt mean Arsitotle has to "come back" !!.. By the Time of 1699..GURU GOBIND SINGH JI had completed the Mammoth Task set upon by GURU NANAK JI...all thsoe weho had to go prior to 1699 had to make do with whatever was available ( charanamrit)..BUT after 1699 Khande Batte De PAHUL was COMPULSORY and Charanamerit was DISCONTINUED.

Re: did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

R Singh · 27 Apr 2005

My understanding, which isn't that great... To reach vaahiguru, you need naam. To get naam, you need a satguru. You need to accept the satguru as your guru, offer yourself and the guru will give you naam. To take on a guru, you take pahul. Then you do naam kamayee and kamayee of all the hukams of your guru. Prior to 1699, naam was given through charan pahul. 1699, this changed. The people who had taken naam, done their kamayee and departed, reached their destination and their is no reason for them to come back for naam again (which is what the purpose of pahul is). Those who already had charan pahul but were still alive, had to take pahul again, because it was the guru's hukam. Guru Saahib was ending the dedhari guru ship and passing guru ship onto the Khalsa. To completely stamp out the chance of dehdhari guruship, everyone had to take khanday dee pahul. Just as importantly, in order to ensure that there was only one level of amrit and that khanday dee pahul wasn't turned into some lower status amrit, this was required. Had this not been done, many people may have formed the impression that charun pahul from the guru was superior to khanday dee pahul from 5 singhs. The panth would not have been uniform and some pakhandees related to the guru's may have continued offering charan pahul as an alternative. (Some actually did do this, even up to the 20th century). To ensure uniformity of the panth and the supreme authority of the khalsa, everyone, even Guru Gobind Singh Jee, who was Naam da dataa himself, had to take Khanday dee pahul.

Re: did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 28 Apr 2005

Vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa Vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!!!!! Dhanvaad R Singh veerjee, your response has been most helpful to me in understanding this, and I fully agree with you. guru nanak dev jee daa shukar hai please forgive my mistakes Vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa Vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!!!!!!

Re: did all puratan Sikhs pre-1699 have to come back?

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 29 Apr 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalswa Waheguru ji ki fateh. Veer R Singh Ji has explained some points very nicely. Thanks Singh Ji.