Magistrates Wrong to Clear man Abusing Sikh Officer
huh · 23 Apr 2005
http://news.scotsman.com/latest.cfm?id=4428146 Magistrates Wrong to Clear Man over Insults to Police By Mike Taylor, PA A man acquitted of using religiously aggravated insults towards a Sikh policeman is to be taken back to court to face his accuser a second time. The High Court ruled today that magistrates were wrong to dismiss the charge against Neil Humphrey on the basis that there was no case to answer. Mr Justice Leveson said to use the words “You’re fucking Islam” to any Asian “is almost always undeniably abusive, if not insulting”. The magistrates’ reasoning, including a finding that the only two people to hear the words were two serving police officers, was “flawed” and their decision was unsustainable. The judge ordered a rehearing before a different bench. Humphrey, 43, of Dickens Road, Maidstone, Kent, was cleared by Mid Kent Justices at Sittingbourne last December of using “threatening, abusive or insulting words or behaviour or disorderly behaviour within the hearing or sight of a person likely to be caused harassment, alarm or distress, which was religiously aggravated”. An alternative similar charge, also dismissed, did not refer to religious aggravation. The Sikh officer, Pc Gill, and his colleague, Pc Giles, had been called to Buckland Place, Maidstone, where they found Mr Humphrey under the influence of drink and upset about his children. The officers told him why they were there, and it was then that Mr Humphrey used the offensive words. Among the issues to be decided at the rehearing will be whether the words did actually cause, or were likely to cause, harassment, alarm or distress.