Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

MalaysianBaBa · 20 Apr 2005

Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa...Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh... ..I was just wondering if anyone has any article/information suggesting that The Akhand Path Seva should only be done by an amritdhari gursikhs..Seva as in the seva of reading the Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji during an Akhand Path in a Gurdwara.. ..Please help this manmukh if he is wrong in anyway.. ...Gurfateh... Vaheguru Ji Ka Khalsa...Vaheguru Ji Ki Fateh... [%sig%]

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

Jasvir Kaur Thind · 21 Apr 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. The Sikh Rehat Maryada says " A SIKH" ....... Read the Beginning of the SRM for the "definition" of a SIKH. That said no sangat will ever allow a "sikh" who has cut his hair/doesnt wear a dastaar or has his beard trimmed...... ( but still calls himeself SIKH) ....to do Kirtan, Take Hukam, DO paath in Sangat, be a Panj Piayara, be a Granthi, distribute Degh etc ..all the duties that the SRM reserves for a SIKH as per its definition. Since "everybody" is a SIKH....this is the normal way most sangts behave. Keshadharee/dastaar/untrimemd beard/kirpan/karra etc are the OUTWARD signs of a "SIKH".....and also an "Amrtidharee"....but what people are INSIDE..ONLY GURU JI knows... a Gurdawra Akhand Paath is ususally "free for all" and anybody can take part as the Committee will not want to "annoy" anyone...but a Private Akhand Paath is also under the family..and they may allow a ghona mona to be a pathee as well ( thats their business actually).....so it all boils down to.... ???? I have no idea. IF you want the akhand paath to be really useful....you will have to follow cwerrian guidelines....you must have heard about monkeys and peanuts..sometimes it also happens the other way around...you PAY through your nose ..but you still get "monkeys"..( these are the kattar types of fierce looking "amrtidharees" who will use all your best soaps, oils, shampoos, finish off kilos of badams, barfis, khoya, milk, and use your phone on the sly to call INDIA/CANADA/USA..and you will only realise it when the BILL COMES !!!worse still your handphones may go missing as well.......i am an amrtidharee as well and i am sad to say such types also exist..but i dont beleive in sweeping things under the carpet ( it is already bulging with tons of dirt)..so STAY AWAY from such pakhandees and PRACTISE what GURU JI TOLD US..and this is... THE BEST WAY is to LEARN GURBANI YOURSELF and do the Paath YOURSELF. Jasvir kaur - much wiser amrtidharee

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

. · 21 Apr 2005

Jasvir Kaur Thind ji, do you wear a dastar?

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

jaoks · 21 Apr 2005

"Jasvir kaur - much wiser amrtidharee" wat kind of blatant haumai is this!! lol and why are you going on about kattar amritdharis stealing your housephones....wat kind of rubbish is that youve got issues!!

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

ms · 21 Apr 2005

how could you call yourself a wiser amritdharee you have issues mann and by the way Jasvir Kaur Thind you are not amritdharee unless you have taken taken Khandeh di Paul

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

sahajdhari · 21 Apr 2005

Guru Granth Sahib is open to all to read Mona can- Start a sahaj paat on there own, following that they are respectful (clean, head covered, hazooriah,etc) cuz bani is for anyone to read. Guru is for all, but ppl just need to accept it. Moneh Cant: Do seva of guru ji in congregation, akhand paat, should not be done by moneh, that requires sangat. if there doing it on there own and alone, then i guess you can look at it as a sahaj paat. or simply readin gurbani. that should be fine.

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

Jasvir Kaur Thind · 22 Apr 2005

jaoks......and Author. above whats your problem ?? cant an "amritdharee" be "wiser" ?? after taking Amrit I am definitley wiser than before ?? And why the issue with my dastaar ? do you wear one ? IS the next question about colour of my dastaar ?/ length ?/ cloth ??how i wear one ? do I wear it all the time ? or only some of the time ? is this Forum about Sikhi or about MY DASTAAR ?? Dont take offense at "kattar amrtidharees"..these are actually "frauds" who dress like amrtidharees..but behave very differently.... didnt you realise from my mails that i am also a AMRITDHAREE and quite Kattar myself ( and to you i may be fraud as well )..my issue is with informing people who arrange akhand paaths to be beware and not take everything at "face value"...these holy of holies will actually do all those things..like DEMANDING the best milk, dishes, badams, walnuts, cashew nuts, shudh desi ghiao, kheer, shampoos soaps etc which they all "take away" after the paath is done..and yes..many people have reported thigns like handphones etc missing and the BILLS question is very very commonplace especially if the Pathees are "FOB granthis/raagis from India. Come on man..not every paathi is like the Jatha of Bhai Sahib bhai randheer Singh jis time...no more....there are many frauds hanging around whose livelihood is doing paaths only..no pyaar no sewa nothing just money. Sorry for any offense to anyone..not meant or intentional. Jasvir Kaur

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

bad news · 23 Apr 2005

"Author: Jasvir Kaur Thind Date: 04-22-05 07:41 jaoks......and Author. above whats your problem ?? "cant an "amritdharee" be "wiser" ?? after taking Amrit I am definitley wiser than before ?? "" yes an amritdhari can be wiser but not a rule of the thumb. Juts because you are does not mean thats how it is. You have not taken time amnd maturity into consideration. Frauds were are and will be all over the joint. Sikhi is one of those religions people can abuse anytime, 3 foot long beard, dastaar people can get a gud impression but only God knows whats happening inside. That is why we need to clampdown on camps and rensbhais where a number of youths treat it like a dating event to get to know others, pry on gurls, and abuse the sikhi roop to build up their own name.

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

heyheyhey · 23 Apr 2005

YO, mona shoudnt even be touching the gurus saroop if a mona really wants to why doesnt the mona take amrit the guru didnt crete amrit for nthing what if u start saying monas can do amrit sanchar aat home why would any one want accept that same thing for monas taking gurus saroop at home and reading it why would any one want respect that why dont they just use a gutka intead of direspecting are guru granth sahib by touching them or even taking them home

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

yahoo · 24 Apr 2005

i have to agree with heyheyhey on this one. That is our pura Guru sahib who deserves utmost respect and that too the requirement should not just be an amritdhari but gursikhs with puran rehit.

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

TUF · 24 Apr 2005

SOme of you are too funny. Before Guru Gobind Singh JI, where any of the Gurus amritdhari. So if they came back today, they wouldn't be allowed to do path??? Pleez, our religion is open to anyone. As long as they know what they're doing and they're doing it with a clean heart with their mind on God, I don't have a problem with anyone doing any path, whether they be amritdhari, sahjdhari, jatt, chamar, hindu, muslim, whatever. Lets remember our religion as the GUrus would have wanted it to be, and not the way that some politically oriented people are saying it should be... if thats the case we may as well vote in our own "pope" and set stringent rules for everything so we don't have to use our own minds and commonsense.

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

JKThind · 25 Apr 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Utterly fallacious arguments TUF Ki ?? IF any of the GURUS came back TODAY...the First thing that they would do is to become an AMRITDHAREE. ( IN fact they were ALL AMRITDHAREES as in 1699 all ten of them took Amrit) PRAY tell me...HOW LONG DID "GURU GOBIND RAI" WAIT BEFORE HE went down on Bended KNEES begging the PUNJ for AMRIT ?? Did Guru Ji WAIT..an HOUR,,a DAY...a WEEK... A MONTH...A YEAR...TEN YEARS ?? YOU TELL ME. GURU GOBIND SINGH JI AN AMRITDHAREE...but WASNT HE GURU ?? SO WHY did HE beg for AMRIT from the PUNJ so FAST..IN fact HE was the FIRST IN LINE ?? WHY..... What makes YOU think GURU NANAK would act any DIFFERENT from Gobind Rai ?? ( IF..??? ) What makes you think GURU NANAK-GURU GOBIND RAI was NOT in that SROOP of GURU GOBIND RAI begging for AMRIT..and BECOMING GURU GOBIND SINGH JI in 1699....a FULL 9 YEARS before His Demise in 1708. Dera TUF..quit making all these silly srguments....the RELIGION that began with Guur nanak came to a SOUND CONCLUSIOn with GURU GOBIND SINGH JI and His AMRIT in 1699...one cannot be a HALF BAKED "sikh" of the earlier nine gurus..even of Guru Gobind RAI ( prior to 1699)....a TRUE SIKH is one of AMRITDHAREE KHALSA ONLY. Jasvir Kaur

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

Question Bhai · 25 Apr 2005

Is JSThind Giani Arshi in disguise ?

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 25 Apr 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Guur Gobind Rai Ji could have left things as they were... BUT HE DIDNOT let things to be they way they were...sehajdharees, and chamaars and jattas and shudars etc....GURU JI got everybody together and STARTED the AMRIT of Khanda batta....and was the FIRST to get it...and BECOME GURU GOBIND SINGH ( dropping his RAI Name)... Think about it..for a moment... IS it OK to be sehajdharee/chamaar/jatt/nai/chhimba/// etc etc wehn we can all Follow GURU GOBIND SINGH JI and take the AMRIT of Khanda Batta..and become Amrtidharee Singhs..Doesnt GURU JI's EXAMPLE count for anything at all ?? Are we just arm-chair "sikhs" ??? I am sick to death of hearing these PATHETIC nonsensence excuses of being sikhs of nine gurus ( actually ten Gurus from 1469-1699 !!!)....what a lame excuse ??? like a kid just refusing to grow up...when a kid is enrolled into Kindergarten..he/she naturally goes on progressing UNTIL he passes the Ultimate EXAM and coems out with a DEGREE..a DROP OUT is a DROP OUT - a NON-Amrtidharee is a DROP OUT of Guur Ji's School....plain and simple. Jasvir Kaur

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

..... · 25 Apr 2005

I think Veer Jarnail Singh and Bhain Jasvir Kaur share the same computer!

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

whatever · 26 Apr 2005

Leave Jasvir Kaur Thind alone Everyone is entitled to their views - nobody on this forum or anywhere else has a right to attack anyone elses views At the end of the day worry about your own souls cos Dharm Raj is not going to ask for a character ref when you make your appearance in his court. She made some valid points and as far as I can see too many people are more concerned about what others say and do then about themselves ................

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

TUF · 26 Apr 2005

SOrry, JKThind, I didn't mean to offend you. I just think its good and healthy to keep our minds open about different issues and be able to see arguments from both sides. You could have simply said that it was the same soul through all Gurus so they were all automatically Amritdhari. However, for arguments sake, what if Guru Nanak came back and stated (just as he did when the Brahmins were presenting him with the string to put around his neck) what if he states that all these outward ornaments (eg. 5 K's) are simply ritualistic and have no outcome on a person trying to attain mukti, since there are other internal ornaments one should have instead. This is just a confusion that I have. What is the difference between the thread of those Brahmins and the keeping of the 5 K's... Don't get me wrong, I know the difference, I just want to hear other opinions... pleez enlighten me.

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 27 Apr 2005

Dear Tuf jio, Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. The FUNDAMENTAL DIFFERENCE between the Janeau that GURU NANAK Ji rejected and the Punj Kakaars is that... ANYONE...regardeless of Birth, status, economic standing, race, country of origin...whatever...CAN make the DECISION to be an AMRITDHAREE and RECEIVE the Daat of AMRIT. THis can HAPPEN in any GURDWARA in the World..even in a house where there are FIVE PIYARAAS and GURU GRANTH JI present. However point to one Hindu Mandir where a CHHOORRA/Chamaar/Chhimba/shudar/vaishnav/khatree/muslim/...CAN Make the decison to become a BRAHMIN and be given the BRAHMIN JANAEU.?? The answer is NOT ONE....NO WAY a SHUDAR can receive a BRAHMIN Janaue. Even If like Jagjiwan Raam, a Shudar rises to become a MINISTER of DEFENCE of Hindu India..he will still NOT QUALIFY to enter HINDU MANDIRS..where ONLY BRAHMINS are allowed to GO ( BORN BRAHMINS!!!!) However any "low caste" ( supposedly) CAN become an AMRITDHAREE and BECOME a JATHEDAR of Even the AKAL TAKHAT...If you dont beleive me..GO have a look at the GURU GRANTH JI....you will find supposed chamaars like Bhagat RAVIDASS JI, supposed Chhimbas/Julahas like Bhagat Kabir Ji..etc ON PAR with the SIKH GURUS......ALL SIKHS BOW their heads to them just as they bow to the Ten Gurus Now do you see why GURU NANAK jI REJECTED the janaeu and WILL NOT REJECT the Kakaars ( Read His GURBANI..Guru ji has already Given His ANSWERS to Your doubts.) Well meaning and well rounded people dont get offended easily..

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

TUF · 27 Apr 2005

Thank you Jarnail Singh. I agree with you 100%. Our religion is beautiful in that its open to everyone, no matter their background, and thats what makes Sikhism stand head and shoulders above other religions. In this same way, if we take pride in Sikhi's stance on the equality of ALL people, it would be hypocritical for us to only allow Amritdharis to do akhand paths, don't you think?

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

Dogma · 27 Apr 2005

Jarnail Singh, why are one of your posts on this thread signed at the end with Jasvir Kaur? I believe this is the second time this has happened...is this just the same mistake over again?

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

Roopkaur · 27 Apr 2005

>ALL people, it would be hypocritical for us to only allow Amritdharis to do akhand paths, don't you think?< No, this is not hypocritical at all. Being amritdharee is not a birthright or something you have because you are born into it, you have to come into guru jis sharn, accept guru ji as your guru, and then guru ji gives you gurmat naam and amrit. Any person can be amritdharee, not just one jaat or race, therefore Sikhi is open to anyone, but you have to accept Sikhi first and accept the responsibilities that comes with that title, before you can demand equal priveldges or rights.

Re: Non-Amritdhari Doing Akhand Pathi Seva?!!

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 28 Apr 2005

dogma ji, this is due to opening too many "windows", browsers on one too many Forums while I read,think of what to write, cut and paste from other's replies...and append my views.... sometimes it so happens that a particular window freezes/dies..and my "appendation' fails to be sent off or the "POST" button gets pressed accidentally leaving out a portion of my reply. That particualr post was supposed to have a "quote" from jasvir Kaur Bhenji's post.....with my "views" below it....suffice it to say that only the name jasvir kaur got sent off leaving the rest..i have no idea where ?? maybe on a Planet far far away in Galaxy Nine ??? Sorry, to get you all excited over this nincompoop error. I have stopped Signing off my messages....as my Full name and Email address already appears on every mail i write. Dear Tuf Jio, It is an entirely "different" question of WHY we CANNOT ALLOW non-Amrtidharees to do Akhand Paaths/Katha/Kirtan /be Punj...etc. An _NON-AMRITDHAREE is one who is NOT yet fully on the Path of GURU JI, He/she is NOT yet FULLY COMMITTED to GURU ji's IDEALS and PRINCIPLES...in simple words he /she is NOT QUALIFIED to be the GURU's REPRESENTATIVE to OTHERS who are already QUALIFIED/COMMITTED. Actually if you look at it, even the "AMRITDHAREE" status is not that strictly followed in most Gurdwaras....ALL the Sangat requests is that the Paathi/Granthi/Kirtaniya etc "LOOK like" an amrtidharee..that is have full KESH, Beard untrimmed, wear Dastaar, Karra Kirpan. No one is going to check if he/she is wearing a kachhera, or that he/she does Amrtivela, keeps rehit etc. NO SANGAT will alllow an OBVIOUS Non-Amrtidharee/Sikh with Cut hair. trimmed beard etc to do Paath/kirtan/punj seva etc. WHY do we bring in the GREATNESS and OPENnESS of SIKHISM...and then DRAG in this dead meat question ?? Isnt CANADA great open democratic country...then WHY doesnt it allow any tom dick and harry to come in from any country and VOTE/settle as a Canadian Citizen/become its PM etc ?? WONT the person first have to SHOW his COMMITMENT to CANADA, stay there for a while and show that he wants to be a CANADIAN etc and shoulder the responsibilities ?? SO when the Canadian Immigration throw out an ILLEGAL..does that prove how EVIL the canadian Govt is for "denying" that person's rights ?? whatever?? WHICH country hands out its PASSPORTS to all and Sundry....allow them to Vote and become PM/Ministers etc...NOT a SINGLE COUNTRY. Sikhism WELCOMES ALL into its GURDWARAS with OPEN ARMS....LOVE and PYAAR....EVERYONE is free to take part in Langgar chhakna, lsiten to kirayn katha paath, partake of Degh...not even NON-BELIEVERS are DENIED all these RIGHTS.....BUT we have RULES too....and we NEED the COMMITMENT..the PROMISE to FOLLOW GURU JI's TEACHINGS FAITHFULLY from those who seek to be the GURU's REPresentatives....to TEACH to US. Can we have a GHONA MONA telling us about GURU GOBIND SINGH JI's HUKM to Keep UNCUT HAIR ?? Can we have a Non-BELIEVER read GURU Ji's GURBANI to us in an akhand paath ?? His PHYSICAL BODY may be SHOWING AGAINST what GURBANI he is reading to other SIKHS.. Can we go to a Hospital and allow just about any dick to treat us/operate on us ?? anyone would seriously object to an untrained person treating a sick man...why should SIKHS not object to a non-beleiver PREACHING to them about their RELIGION....the "medic" may be half trained/quarter trained"...BUT if NOT FULLY QUALIFIED..will NOT be allowed to treat anybody..simiallrly the "sikh" may be keeping hair half way ( dastaar but beard trimmed) etc...UNTIL he shows his commitment to GURU JI.he will NOT be allowed to PREACH to other Sikhs who have Committed fully. Thats all.