Re: Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Dhadrian Vale
shocked singh always miss out · 20 Apr 2005
HE WAS IN VANCOUVER ?!?!?!
HE CAME TO VANCOUVER ?!?!?!!
WHY DID NOBODY TELL ME :(
Re: Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Dhadrian Vale
Amritpal Singh · 21 Apr 2005
Does anybody realize the amount of money he's making from his parchaar?
its a business........
when we turn doing parchaar of sikhi into a business, then how can we get anywhere spiritually.
This guy makes a killling!
but that being said, maybe he donates his money alot and uses his money for chardi kaala of panth. I dont know enough about him except for what i see on TV everday (sur sagar tv)
I look at him as a young singh who is a very good motivator. But most of his show is song and dance and less gurbani
Re: Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Dhadrian Vale
raj karega khalsa · 21 Apr 2005
dus ne1 kno if and when hes comin to alberta?
Re: Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Dhadrian Vale
Amritpal Singh · 21 Apr 2005
Ranjit singh is in a very good position to do ALOT of positive parchaar. People in pinds and all over india play his tapes.
Imagine if he did parchaar of Dastaar for Bibian /larivaar saroop and other khalsa rehits.
SO many people would be able to benefit.
Im just afraid of him turning into another Mann Singh, where people worship him and think hes more then he really is.
Lets not create Sants, thats when people get homai and fall
Re: Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Dhadrian Vale
Singh Akali · 21 Apr 2005
How can he be a sant:
1. He reads kacho bani.
2. He is too young and i have never heard him say a tuk from Gurbani
3. He repeats the same thing over and over again
Being sant is not that simple. He wll be called Brahmgiani in a couple of years. Even though he reads Kachi Bani. His mission shoudl be to connect people to Gurbani. Not to himself or anyone other sant he idolizes. Also, there is no such thing as sant in Sikhism. Was Baba Buddha Ji called Sant Baba Budda Ji? No. Was Bhai Taru Singh called Sant Mahapurakh Brahmgiani Bhai Taru Singh Ji? No. How about Baba Deep Singh, Bhai Mani SIngh, Bhai Gurdass Ji, Baba Banda Singh Ji Bahadur, etc? The answer is no. Labeling people sants and brahamgianias without thinking is bipran kee reeet. No one is higher than Baba Buddha Ji. He was responsible for performing the Turban Ceremony for 5 Gurus. What is more than that? Even he did not get the label Sant. Yet, these days people who can't even diffretiate between kachi bani and sachi bani are given titles such as Brahgiani, Sant, etc. Sorry people but until bipran kee reet isn't removed, Guru Ji will never give us Khalistn and Sikhism won't spread as much as it should be spreading. We are still at 25 million out of which 80% of males are moanay. May Waheguru Ji Akaal Purakh Ji remove us from performing bipran kee reet.
Re: Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Dhadrian Vale
mrsinghsahib · 21 Apr 2005
It is obvious that people have certain issues with Ranjit Singh. Instead of dissing him over the net, why don't you go and talk to him. He seems to be very approachable from what I've seen on his DVD's. The original post that started this off was a request for the AKJ Sangat and Tapoban Singhs to do Bachan Billaas with him. Why don't you do so, rather than speculating on forums?
It would be great if you Sevaadaars could go with an open mind without pre-judging him. Then you can report back to the Sangat your findings.
It is obvious that the issues that need to be discussed are:
- Why does he read so-called "Kachi Bani"?
- Why does he allow himself to be called "Sant"?
BTW, he has answered these questions in his DVD Diwans, if one listened to and saw them. But i'm not gonna bother repeating his answers, which I found to be satisfying enough for me. But I'd urge everybody to at least see his Diwans, either live, or on DVD's. He answers all these questions. You can then make your own mind about him rather than basing it on hearsay.
May Guru Jee all give us Sojhi and Samat to follow his Hukam and be true Gurmukhs. Please Tapoban Singhs do this seva for this forum.
Bhul Chuk Maaf
Waheguroo
Re: Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Dhadrian Vale
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 22 Apr 2005
etka says:
honestly to expect him to go read pure bani in pinds, where ppl are un-educated and cannot understand? his dharna's are just translation to modern punjabi, which gives ppl understanding and the drive to understand sachi bani.
so GURBANI is for the Academics..the BA/MA/PHDs ?? eh ??
is that why most of the "sants" never went to school ??? and cant write a proper sentence in Gurmukhi...let alone English ??
NO NO NO Guru Ji NEVER wrote GURBANI just for the "school master Ji's" and BA/MA/Dr Sahibs in Universities....GURBANI wasand IS for the COMMON MAN..the PENDU....the PUNJABI on the GROUND....as well as the Vice Chancellor jis....
KACHI BANI is read by the LAZY ONES...who DONT WANT TO or CANT learn GURBANI or are NOT BOTHERED to spend time learning GURBANI....Once Bhai Sahib Bhai randheer Singh Ji who was just a boy had a close encounter with Sant Attar Singh ji reading "kachi bani.....Was Sant Ji surprised when Bhai Sahib jee sitting right in front of the snagat came out with his own Kachi Dhaarna to reply to the one sung by Sant Ji ...Bhai Sahib NEVER condoned kachi bani by any one.....it is an insult to GURBANI.
Jarnail Singh
Re: Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Dhadrian Vale
mrsinghsahib · 22 Apr 2005
Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa!
Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh!!
I am not Ranjit Singh's chela or nothing. And I don't belong to any Jatha either. But I only posted because I found his Parchaar to be really inspiring. I also pray before Guru Jee that he, myself or anyone else does not become hunkaari. Gurmat is a very fine path, and it is very easy to get distracted on it.
BUT the reason I posted was because I'd rather see his good aspects and try and learn from them, rather than searching for his weaknesses. I'm full of hunkaar, ego, and other vikaars myself. I'd rather try and eradicate these from myself, than pointing out others'. Obviously I don't know his or anybody else's Jeevan, but nobody else does either except Guru Jee and Waheguroo.
Bhul Chuk Maaf Jee
Waheguroo
Re: Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Dhadrian Vale
question to arashi · 22 Apr 2005
>>>
KACHI BANI is read by the LAZY ONES...who DONT WANT TO or CANT learn GURBANI or are NOT BOTHERED to spend time learning GURBANI....Once Bhai Sahib Bhai randheer Singh Ji who was just a boy had a close encounter with Sant Attar Singh ji reading "kachi bani.....Was Sant Ji surprised when Bhai Sahib jee sitting right in front of the snagat came out with his own Kachi Dhaarna to reply to the one sung by Sant Ji ...Bhai Sahib NEVER condoned kachi bani by any one.....it is an insult to GURBANI.
>>>>
so jarnail Singh ji,
are you saying baba attar singh ji maustnaeywaley was "lazy" one who started dharna kirtan(as you put it kachi bani) ?
Re: Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Dhadrian Vale
mrsinghsahib · 22 Apr 2005
QUOTE: "Aren't saints irrelevant to Sikhi ?"
How can saints be irrelevant? Guru Gobind Singh Jee wanted us all to be Saint-Soldiers/Sant-Sipahis.
QUOTE: "Even Baba Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale spoke out against people giving him the Sant and Brahmgiani tag. The "Saint" of today are only to happy to have posters printed and flyposted with them described as Saint Mahapursh Mahraj Brahmgiani."
Baba Jarnail Singh Jee spoke against people giving him such titles out of humility. He did not disagree with the concept of Sants. Indeed he thought Sant Kartar Singh Jee, Sant Gurbachan Singh Jee and Sant Sundar Singh Jee were Sants.
Although I agree that we must be wary and careful of fake Sants. A true Sant never goes round calling himself a Sant.
Bhul Chuk Maaf
Waheguroo
Re: Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Dhadrian Vale
Bijla Singh · 22 Apr 2005
It is very easy to pick faults. I do not agree with dharna but at least he has not said anything against Gurmat and is not preaching anti-Gurmat stuff. It is extremely difficult to find a parcharak that everyone likes. I have met people who think Bhai Rama Singh Ji's book is not inspirational at all. I have met people who speak against some of the best parcharaks today. We all agree and disagree on things but why stick to negativity all the time? At least he is doing something for Sikhi in Punjab whereas we are sitting behind our computers writing vulgar language against him. What have we done? Jarnail Singh, I think you decided not to go back to Punjab until there is Khalistan but if every gursikh starts thinking like that there will be no Khalistan. Punjab's situation is very worse. I don't see you out there in villages doing Sikhi parchaar not even with dharna. Same applies to everyone.
And what is this nonsense about tapoban singhs going to have a "conversation" with him? only because he preaches something similar to akj? what if he didn't? he won't be a Sikh anymore? why not go talk to him like our gursikh brother? I am sure if some people decide to go have a word with him they will try to have a “scholarly” debate instead of a gursikh veechar. Nobody is perfect. if he has faults then removing them is the responsibility of gursikhs. everyone needs sangat. who cares if he is a sant. most importantly he is our gursikh brother and we should encourage him more to do parchaar. go talk to him. give him suggestions. try doing everything he has done, then try doing better than him and then pick faults and point out his mistakes. don't compare one parcharak to the other. as long as all of them preach Sikhi all are good.
You people question the money he is making. ok, true he makes money but who doesn't? Sikhs in western countries make money by working at liquor stores selling tobacco, beer and whatnot. people in these countries, including most of your parents, put the task of making money prior to Sikhi. Many Sikhs are engineers, doctors and lawyers so if they can work and make money then why can't he or any other parcharak preach Sikhi and get paid? doctors and lawyers ask for money first but he doesn't. go to his diwaans and don't pay him anything. pay him nothing then see if he objects or asks for money. if he does then he is no better than lawyers and doctors but no less than them either. Being a Sikh preacher (true and good one) I regard him higher than people with other professions.
We keep talking against gursikhs who actually do something for Sikhi. Most of us on the other hand do nothing except point fingers and pick fault. What is the purpose? To show how “smart” we are or how much we know about Sikhi? If we haven’t given up slandering then we are not even taking the first step. Ninda of a person is very bad and we do ninda of gursikhs. Which face will you show to Guru Ji in His Saccha Darbar? Yeah, tell Him you didn’t like Ranjit Singh because of his clothes, money or dharna even when he was trying his best to preach Sikhi. Good luck to you all.
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Dhadrian Vale
KHALISTAN JINDABAD · 22 Apr 2005
"Does anybody realize the amount of money he's making from his parchaar?
its a business........
when we turn doing parchaar of sikhi into a business, then how can we get anywhere spiritually.
This guy makes a killling!
but that being said, maybe he donates his money alot and uses his money for chardi kaala of panth. I dont know enough about him except for what i see on TV everday (sur sagar tv)
I look at him as a young singh who is a very good motivator. But most of his show is song and dance and less gurbani"
Amritpal veerji i tottally agree with u 10000000%
he states that he is given the expensive cholay and if he dusnt wear them then the sangat gets mad but then thats the same as going 2 him and giving him poison and sayin its my bhayta if u dun take it im gunna get mad
Re: Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Dhadrian Vale
Amritpal Singh · 23 Apr 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh
It is very intriguing to see how you all view Ranjit Singh. However what I have to share with you all today will no doubt shock you like it truly shocked me.
I too first came across him through DVDs wanting to see what the hype was about....I personally thought that is methods of parchaar were questionable, but at least it was in the right direction. Yes, he gives argument that his way is the best way to communicate with the villagers in Panjab, and x amount of people have taken Amrit because of it. However firslty, IT IS kachi bani.... and I ask people.... if people are not allowed to read kachi bani in our Darbar Sahib, why should he??
When I used to listen to his DVDs the thing that used to bring doubt to his real commitment of Sikhi was the use of the word "Mai" (I).... they way he used to big himself up about being a saint and its always "I" this and "I" that. Now I have met people that are soo dedicated and practically practising Sikhi over many years... and you listen to these people.... not once will they talk with "I".... or with hooma (ego). Something which Sikhs would loose they more they practise Sikhi.
Moving on... I also went to Panjab late last year and attended a parcharr he held in Jallandher. He held it for three days and I only went to the first. The reason why... he sits on stage and stops the sangat from donating any money to him... so why at the end of the parcharr do his Jatha go round with hug bags asking for money??? Well seeing this got my pulse racing and questions started flying all over the place... so I did some investigating.
YES it is a business!!! but who is he doing it for?????
All that I have written above have been my own personal views... now the facts...
He is a member of the RSS party in India. A party that started in 1925 primarly to distroy the Sikh faith. It swore to distroy the roots of Sikhi, and promote it as a part of the Hindu religion.
Now this party creates and trains members to become Sikh so they can then use them to tarnish the Sikh Character. (basically become moles within the community).
He has been in training from the age of 5!! His primary objective to raise as much funds from the people they want to distroy. (also the reason why an attempt was made on his life a while back).
So are his intentions pure.... u make the decision.
If any of you want to learn more.. email me and I'll send you a cd with more facts about the RSS party etc...
What I want you all to remember is Sikhi is 100% practical and until we do it ourselves no one can help us. Bani tells us that a Sant is a person who has found the path to God. He/she is then meant to teach it to others.
Some Saints to reach this position... but then ego sets in and they don't want to share what they have found. It becomes a power thing, and their maans takeover. At all times we are battling to keep our maan under control.
[%sig%]
Re: Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Dhadrian Vale
Harpreet Singh · 23 Apr 2005
I agree with etka still.
Re: Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Dhadrian Vale
soooooooooooo · 23 Apr 2005
So...sometimes i see at Smagams, Kirtanees singing..."DHAN HA DHAN HA DHAN HA...GURU NANAK DEV JI DHAN HA...."...and go through all the Gurus...
my question...Is that Kachi Bani?
Re: Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Dhadrian Vale
Kulbir Singh · 23 Apr 2005
It is pretty childish of some of the contributors on this thread to jump to conclusion that Singhs from Tapoban Sahib have any opinion on Ranjit Singh Dhadrian. Frankly talking most of us have never heard him perform and have no idea what his standing is on different issues related to Sikhi.
If he is inspiring people to not cut hair, not take drugs and to chhak Amrit, then how can we complain? He is doing good work then.
From what I have heard, he is a good speaker, does great parchaar and inspires people to chhak amrit. This is good work he does.
By the same token, I have heard that he wears flashy clothes and sings kachi baani. These in my opinion are violations of Gurmat.
Does not matter what sant used to do dhaarna and sang kachi baani but I bow my head on the Bachan of Siri Guru Amardaas jee Maharaaj who has cleary stated that any baani other than "Satgur kee Baani" is kachee. Just read Siri Anand Sahib for more details. The only Sachi baani is Gurbani or that baani that has been accepted by our Guru Sahibaan. Anything else is Kachee baani.
Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee has written numerous poems and really great poems. I think none of the poet I have read comes even close to the content he has covered but do you ever hear his poems being sung? NO. It is not appropriate to sing some mortal beings poetry and then give it the name Kirtan. Only Gurbani Kirtan or baani accepted by Guru Sahib can be used to sing Kirtan.
Perhaps I will check out Ranjit Singh's performance to form some opinion on him.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Dhadrian Vale
Bijla Singh · 23 Apr 2005
Amritpal Singh, please provide any proofs that Ranjit Singh is an agent of RSS. I see that the government or any hindu orgs have not opposed him yet even when he is inspiring so many people to take amrit but my doubt is only doubt. Until we know for sure we cannot turn against him. Also, when people take amrit, I assume they don't stay at his dera or follow his jatha so how will he be able to turn all those people against Sikhi? If he starts a guru-dum then of course there will be people following him but people will oppose him too. So assuming that eveyrone inspired by him will follow him and listen to RSS crap is false. Do you have the vcd which shows his jatha going around with bags asking for money? Again, I know all about RSS but show me how he is an agent? thank you. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh
Re: Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Dhadrian Vale
Jaideep Singh · 23 Apr 2005
What I heard about Ranjeet Singh that lakhs of ppl use to come to listen him before, but day by day his popularity is decreasing in Punjab and thats why he is in Canada . Also Ranjit Singh use to say in his katha that he would never go abroad.
Re: Baba Ranjit Singh Jee Dhadrian Vale
raj karega khalsa · 24 Apr 2005
Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh
to all the people that r sayin he dus kachi bani....do ne1 of u read translations or gurbani on the internet?...do ne1 of u listen to a sum1 explaining to you wut gurbani means? if i explain to u wut ioankaar means in english or pindu punjabi, shud i b kiked out of the panth n called a pakhandi for singing kachi bani, wut baba ranjit singh ji dus is translate gurbani into pindu punjabi so they pindus in punjab understand wut gurbani is sayin...many people take amrit at smgams where he dus katha, he enourages evry1 to follow rehit n take amrit wuts he odin wrong?
Bhull Chaak Maph
Waheguru ji ka khalsa Waheguru ji ki fateh