Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

Mehtab Singh · 16 Apr 2005

http://www.hindustantimes.com/news/5922_1324089,0015002000000000.htm AS MANY AS 56 expelled employees of the SGPC today abandoned Sikhism and gave up articles symbolic of the faith in protest against their not being reinstated in the committee jobs. The drama was enacted at Goindwal Sahib, also referred to as “Sikhi da Dhura”. Those who rejected Sikhism had all remained baptised for over 20 years. Not only did they abandon the religion, they also announced that due to the indifferent attitude of the SGPC, they, along with families, had decided to join Christianity. “From now on, we are Christians,” they announced in chorus. The development comes soon after the SGPC’s announcement of spending crores on “dharam parchar” in its budget. Earlier, 30 Sikhs from the same area had turned to Christianity. Those who rebelled today were all employed in Gurdwara Bawli Sahib, Goindwal, since 1985 and were expelled by the SGPC in 2003. Led by former granthi of Gudwara Bawli Sahib Ranjit Singh, the 56 Sikhs today abandoned their “kirpan”, “kara” and other articles signifying the faith and placed these in front of pictures of the 10 Gurus. They said they were leaving the Sikh community due to the unhealthy approach of the SGPC that still believed in classes in the religion, like Jat Sikhs and Mazhabi Sikhs. “As we are Mazhabis, we are discriminated against and that is also why we were expelled,” alleged Ranjit Singh and another rebel Kashmir Singh. They said though the conversion from Sikhism to Christianity was like suicide, the SGPC had forced them to commit the act by not hearing their appeal for reinstatement. One Balwinder Kaur announced in front of mediapersons that they would replace the suffixes “Singh” and “Kaur” with “Masih”. She said: “Our families will now look for marriages among the Christian community and conduct the ceremonies according to their traditions.” “We will meet Christian religious authorities to formally join the faith. We will also build a church at Goindwal Sahib,” she said, accusing the SGPC of discrimination against Mazhabi Sikhs. Jobs their only aim: Bibi SGPC president Bibi Jagir Kaur condemned the incident and termed it as a blackmail attempt. She said, “They were never Sikhs, as Sikhism preaches sacrifice and honesty.” “Probably they had joined Sikhism only for jobs. When expelled, they shifted to Christianity for the same purpose.” The incident would not affect Sikhism or the “dharam parchar” movement, she added. [%sig%]

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

Singh · 16 Apr 2005

This is a horrifying story. What kind of Sikhi were they following? They gave up their kakaars in front of pictures??? This is so utterly crazy I can't put it into words. The decison of three students to convert to christianity started the Singh Sabha movement. What will this do? Nothing I think.

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

mirch · 16 Apr 2005

i think they over reacted too much. I think yes they suffered it out but what will changing religion mean? it will not affect sikhi. They just done their own bezati by saying you take our job we give your religion up. Everyone gets discriminated in life here and there how deal with it? why not do someting about it head on? best way to hit all these caste people sgpc is to carry on in sikhi, by giving up they get ultimate satisfaction you admit defeat. These mazabhi brothers and sisters should carry on in sikhi , work together as a unit, and live that unique sikhi and if discrimin ation happen they should go as far as to let people know " we are going to stick to guru jis maryada and make sure no one even looks at your caste here so everybody welcome". Sikhs soon will become more attracted to guru jis maryada than sgpc because sikhi is very attractive like a magnet. This reaction is a rebound from sgpc policies. Should not happen but as sgpc is corrupt mazabhis best way is to hit back through becoming more into sikhi. wrong should be followed by right action. They will have a mental malady because they know bani, they would have experienced some ras in order to have been sikhs for 25 years. Going to masih ji if their new bhagti bears little or incomparable fruit they will regret it and always remember what they lost. The only reason they convert out s pride and frustration. Conversions are not a good thing based on that ground.

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 16 Apr 2005

Is this suprising ?I am NOT.It will not be too long before we see more of this happening among ALL SIKHs. The sgpc is outdated and does not know how to handle the situation and yet at the same these used cartoons of SGPC are not willing to have new and educated blood to show them how to run the show! This is just the start. It is ok for us to say, they should not have done this or that.But imagine someone suffering for yras under such conditions....they often have only one choice... I am really sad that for whatever reason, they left Sikhi, the fact they left sikhi will be rememebered more than anything else....yes for three converts we started the Singh sabha movement, what will happen now,,,the wedge between Sikhs and so called majhabis is becomming wider....day by day ......I guess the SGPC will carry on sleeping !! Gurcharan SINGH kulim

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

. · 17 Apr 2005

sgpc = self destruct button for sikhs. their dharm parchar program will be fighting against media influences which are now resident in peoples dimaags for years. But wish them best in those efforts. Its complete butters to give up sikhi for christianity over a job. The central theme of most religions is Waheguru Ji. If they doubted God due to more materialism perhaps i could have understood they are dissollsioned and might come back on track, but converting to christianity is a big statement like " if you do not look after us we will find someone who will". Almost like religion has a price over it. So God in sikhi does not exist but God in christianity does? Maybe i am missing something, prhaps ther are many issues with the majabis or they feel indimitated to a level where they want to change religion and a job is not the only reason. Sikh media should interview them. Sgps is failing yet again. Bibi jagirs typical response speaks for itself. As head of sgpc she should command an inquiry into the affair individually interview each sacked member it is the farz of sgpc to explain to the employees why they were sacked. If this carries on like i suspect we could end up loosing a number of raagis and giani jis over the years ahead.

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

S Singh · 17 Apr 2005

Good riddance. They obviously failed to learn anything from Sikhi and the supreme sacrifice our forefathers gave by not converting to Islam etc. Looks like they were only using the Sikh garb to keep their jobs.

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

jeevan singh · 17 Apr 2005

CONVERTING YOUR RELIGION BECAUSE YOU LOST YOUR JOBS IS NO EXCUSE WHAT SO EVER !!!!! IF THE AKALI DAL BADAL ARE TRAITORS, THERE ARE OTHER SINCERE PANTHIC FORCES TO JOIN !! SGPC HAS FAILED SIKHI IN EVERY POSSIBLE WAY. IT NEEDS TO BE SCRAPED AND A NEW ORGANISTAION NEEDS TO BE MADE WITH MEMBERS ALL OVER THE WORLD !!!!! WE NEED TO KEEP TELLING OUR RELATIVES AND COUSINS IN PANJAB ( WE ALL HAVE THEM ) TO OUST THESE TRAITOR GADDAR KALI BADALS [%sig%]

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

student · 17 Apr 2005

SGPC is in need of some "dharam prachaar". They need to start with themselves.

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

Bhopinder singh · 17 Apr 2005

Gurcharan singh kulim ji What do you have to say about this. This is how India whome you love so much is going to finish you and Pakistan whome you bash so much is same but India will kill you by giving you sweet pioson and people like you will never even come to know in fact you will love and defend the pioson and drink it with impunity . Fools only understand when they get bashing on the face MURAKH GAND PAVAI MOHE MAAR

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

- · 17 Apr 2005

They're not real Sikhs. Now that they've converted, they're not real Christians.

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

cybersingh · 17 Apr 2005

i think we need dal khalsa to come together and get united. the first thing that has to be done is all the sikhs outside of india organize themselves under ONE organization in which we all agree on the same things. easier said than done , but sikhs abroad need to take a leading role. basically the goal would be a common rehit that everyone agrees on and one which every jatha instills. i think this was the initial goal of SGPC but some ppl wouldn't agree on issues like meat, keski, raagmala etc. wat needs to be done is that EVERY jatha come together to form dal khalsa and each jatha will have to sacrifice something for the sake of ekta. it has to start with sikhs abroad. for example: meat: for the sake of unity with all sikhs, why not give up meat [for those meat eaters, b/c no where does Guru ji say we HAVE to eat meat]. its irrelevant if you believe if its rite or wrong, just agree for the sake of unity. small sacrifice for our meat eating brothers... keski: definately all sikhs should have a dastaar on their heads at all times. this can be easily supported by gurbani and rehitnamas. the question is weather or not its a kakaar. most sikhs beleive kes is kakaar. so why not agree that kes is a kakaar but it goes hand in hand with keski [ie. keski is mandatory, just like it is for every jatha for singhs]. this is just about 'ON PAPER we call kes the kakaar" because in reality it will be the same in practice for those who believe keski is kakaar. Ragmaala: This is a much tuffer issue and requires a dal khalsa consensus. it should be studied. Differences in Rehrass and Chaupai: -no doubt todays SGPC rehrass is mucher shorter than it orginailly was. nihungs have the longest rehrass. we should agree on ONE rehrass common in all gurdwarai. i hope im making sense and everyone understands what im trying to say. unfortunatley some ppl will turn this into a meat,keski raagmala debate which is not the purpose. all im saying is that a compromise must be reached for the sake of unity. united we stand, divided we fall.

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

ms · 17 Apr 2005

i think we dont even need any committee's, sarbat khalsa is enough

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

Tribune News Service · 17 Apr 2005

SGPC gets flak over ‘conversions’ SAD denies conversions; forms 3-member inquiry panel Varinder Walia Tribune News Service Amritsar, April 17 The SGPC today received a flak from rival Akali factions and the Congress following the alleged conversion of sacked employees of the Shiromani Committee into Christianity. The alleged ceremony to join the Christian-fold reportedly took place near Goindwal, called “Sikhi da Dhura” (nucleus of Sikhism), yesterday . However, some of the sacked employees denied that they had abandoned Sikhism to join Christianity. Senior leaders of the Shiromani Akali Dal (SAD) including Mr Manjit Singh, an Akali MLA, and some SGPC members, reached the spot to cross-check the alleged conversions. Some of the sacked SGPC members alleged that they were “mis-guided” by a part-time correspondent of a Jalandhar-based daily that he would be instrumental in getting them jobs in the SGPC again if they would threaten conversion. The SAD/ SGPC leaders claimed that the journalist had apologised before the “Sikh Sangat” for the “baseless propaganda”. They said the SAD/SGPC would take legal action against the “so-called journalist” for the “concocted story”. They claimed that no function was held for the said conversion. Meanwhile, the temporary recruitment and their subsequent sacking has been a burning issue in the SGPC. The large-scale recruitment of the employees by the successors of Jathedar Gurcharan Singh Tohra, who was removed unceremoniously as the SGPC chief before tercentenary celebrations of the birth of Khalsa, had resulted in the current unsavoury situation. The unwanted recruitment and the subsequent sacking took place under Bibi Jagir Kaur, Mr Kirpal Singh Badungar and even during the brief stint of Mr Alwinderpaul Singh Pakhoke as president. The temporary employee, recruited by one president, would be invariably sacked by his/her successor. The situation reached such a point whereby some of the historical gurdwaras were found to be in “red”. The salary bill of certain historical Sikh shrines surpassed the collection of “Golak”. Some of the petitions were filed in the Sikh Gurdwara Judicial Commission wherein serious allegations were levelled. The petitioners alleged that the clauses of Sikh Gurdwara Act 1925 were violated while giving employment, apart from causing un-necessary financial burden on the Shiromani Committee. Instead of any solid requirement, the temporary recruitments were made on either political basis or to strengthen the vote bank. The most unfortunate aspect is that the commitment of the employees towards the Sikh faith was never considered while making temporary recruitment in recent years. While the SGPC has taken a serious note of the alleged conversions, the rival Akali factions and the Congress have held the SGPC responsible for the current developments. In a press note, Bhai Ram Singh, general secretary of the Akali faction, said the three-member committee would submit a report within three days. He said earlier a “Sandhawalia family” had embraced Christianity in Amritsar and the second conversion was a matter of great worry for the Sikh Panth. Mr Harminder Singh Gill, general secretary, Punjab Pradesh Congress Committee, said the SGPC and the SAD, led by Mr Parkash Singh Badal, would have to confess that they had failed in discharging their “religious duties”. The Akal Purkh ki Fauj, led by Mr Jaswinder Singh Advocate, has warned the Christian missionaries against such conversions. He said the Sikh masses would not tolerate allurement “tactics” of the missionaries. In a strongly-worded statement, Bibi Jagir Kaur, President, SGPC, alleged that former employees had resorted to black-mailing tactics. She said there was a time when the brave Sikhs did not abandon their faith and preferred to face the Mughals’ atrocities. However, they (the 56 sacked employees) had joined Christianity for “money”. She said if they had any complaint, they could have moved the Sikh Gurdwara Judicial Commission instead of taking such “black-mailing step”. The SGPC chief sought immediate intervention of the Chairman of the National Commission for Minorities in this regard. Conversions based on greed, says SGPC Tribune News Service Chandigarh, April 17 The Dharam Parchar Committee of the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee (SGPC), which met here today, condemned the reported conversion of 56 of its former employees to Christianity and described their action as an attempted “blackmail”. Bibi Jagir Kaur, President, SGPC, who presided over the meeting, said that history of Sikhism was full of devotion, selfless service, sacrifices and cannot be identified with earning livelihood. She said if any employee of the SGPC had any complaint or grievance, he or she had all the right to go the Sikh Gurdwara Judicial Commission or any other forum or come to her or any other office-bearers or executive of the SGPC. Employment or removal from service does not mean denouncing Sikhism. The committee decided to seek meeting with representative of the Christian community in the state to impress upon them that greed-based conversions should be not allowed. Both Sikhism and Christianity are minorities and as such no conversions should be encouraged. It also appealed to the National Minorities Commission to convene a meeting of the religious leaders of minorities to impress upon them need to discourage incentive-based conversions.

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

S Singh · 18 Apr 2005

>>meat: for the sake of unity with all sikhs, why not give up meat [for those meat eaters, b/c no where does Guru ji say we HAVE to eat meat]. its irrelevant if you believe if its rite or wrong, just agree for the sake of unity. small sacrifice for our meat eating brothers... For the sake of unity why not drop this brahmin inspired anti meat stance ? Jhatka is allowed. These brahmin inspired influences are spoiling our religion.

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

Bhopinder singh · 18 Apr 2005

s singh For the sake of unity why not drop this brahmin inspired anti meat stance ? Jhatka is allowed ____________________________________________________________ How about cast system child of Hinduism we should also reject system as it is Bipran ke reet.

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 18 Apr 2005

And what happens when a Christian ticks this group off? They will convert then to Judaism and change their last name to Abraham?

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

S Singh · 18 Apr 2005

I also agree with dropping the caste system. But it does not help when the so called mini Sikh parliament the SGPC have reservation seats for so called lower castes when the Sikh religion rejects the caste system. If the Akal Takht Jathedar was of any substance he would take some action against this SGPC reservation. The SGPC colleges etc also have reservation for so called lower castes.

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

cybersingh · 18 Apr 2005

>>For the sake of unity why not drop this brahmin inspired anti meat stance ? Jhatka is allowed. These brahmin inspired influences are spoiling our religion.<< jhatka is allowed. fine. but no where does it say that we HAVE to do jhatka to be sikhs. where as on the flip side, many sikhs believe meat is a kureit. then why can't we give up something as small as meat for ekta and a common rehit? the argument isn't whether we are allowed or not. the argument is about ekta. i think we need to rise above small differences. is our goal to allow meat or is our goal ekta. [%sig%]

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

mr singh · 18 Apr 2005

S Singh, anti meat stances are bahmin influenced (according to you) but jatka is okay. Have you checked the history of jahtka? It's a hindu ritual. Nothing sikh about it.

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

manak da fan · 19 Apr 2005

jhatka keski rag mala nothing to do with this. sikhs should break off caste, this is the voice of the punjabi sikh youth too, they are forced to accept what their parents say. This is not only punjabi or indian problem it is rife amongst amritdharis from punjab settled in the west even more. Nearly all youth i know cannot make sense of it. At the same time once the so called lower castes get amrit they have no caste so they should not entertain themselves to belong to any caste or feel inferior. But the truth is they do get thrown around too i dont think the indian tribune reports tell the complete truth. I have seen with my own eyes in my local gurdwara how one sevedar whos seva stretched back 3 decades of even helping to construct a singh sabha and his intentions were just boosted helped open the first ever punjabi school here, from a small hired church room because of this singhs efforts he mobilised enough sangat to get a singh sabha gurdwara which now doing well guru kirpa with sikhi workshops. But what the hurting thing was a group of raagis came from india they are forced into a game of politics between maryada, committees, and sangat. Now they have to take a lot of flack enforced by committee sevedars moderate themselves down to sangat level. The first guy is well out of the comiittee politics due to election proccess of new committees. But anyway some tussle breaks out between raagis and new committee and this long serving sevadar singh who helped open the singh sabha just turned around and shouted " you are like our nokkars ( slaves) you do what we say here" then he procceeded to do a wangaar on the bichara ragi. What a lot of people dont know is there is caste politics going on and the 4 raagis were from scheduled castes and felt they were being thrown around because of that. in punjab they were thrown around doing menial chores all their life. If and when you establish contact with these singhs i bet you will find out a lot more than what the newspapers reports. people dont just convert out over jobs. But i myself never believe in converting out of sikhi but try to understand someone elses position. Maybe we now need a new sgpc system from the youth in north america and europe. [%sig%]

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

S Singh · 19 Apr 2005

Its actually a Rajput tradition. According to historical information commonly available the vegetarain diet in Sikhi is a recent innovation. Sikhs in the past freely consumed meat. One of the reasons cited for the regular Khalsa forces and those who strictly followed Banda Bahadur (Bandeis as they are referred to) falling out was said to have been the Bandeis having their own agenda and following brahmin inspired policies of not eating meat. After a while the regular Khalsa forces prevailed over the Bandeis and everything was fine until all these Sant started popping up all over the place and to make their marke adopted brahmin ideas and told peopel not to eat meat. The Nihangs who have largely stuck to their original values eat meat ! As history proves meat eating is not a "No No" in Sikhism perhaps the brahim inspired lot who say it is a "No No" should climb off their high horses. The Sikhs in Pakistan who have largely escaped the brahmin inspired teachings of Sant still continue to eat meat. It is the eastern Punjab based Sikhs who have been brainwashed into thinking it is a major sin. By all means if you do not want to eat meat dont. But please dont turn it into a religious issue.

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

chonkhithaar · 20 Apr 2005

i do not think sgpc can be that castist because the head bibi jagir kaur herself hails from the lubahna community before she became a daughter of dasam patshah. I have seen some cases of sgpc waley who were from so called lower caste but became singhs do parchar out of passion and life mission many more are sikh in uttar pardesh and delhi. Sgpc has a good and bad side and need to polish up i think. instead of kicking up a huge fuss all sikhs should co operate with each other. where people treat you bad let it rest upon their own karms but we should still carry the sikh torch burning bright into the next millenium. Bring back pagh pride.

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

indy · 20 Apr 2005

yea the sikhs in pakistan who do eat meat where do they get it from?? the local butchers??? guess what thats going to be halal ohh well its just meat. its like the uk nangs they eat meat from macs,kfc any where, they dnt care if its jhatka or not the love the meat. any ways meats not a issue only when ppl make it look like sikhi supports meat eating and veggism is brahmin inspired.

Re: 56 sacked SGPC employees give up Sikh religion

S Singh · 20 Apr 2005

Indy The Sikhs in Pakistan do not go to the local halal butchers but they practise jhatka ! Next time you are in Pakistan visit a few of the families living in Nankana Sahib district and you will see this for yourself. Well its true being a vegetarian is a new concept in Sikhi which is due to the mushrooming of Sant deras and the brahmin inspired practices they like to promote. Strange how Pakistani Sikhs have not fallen into the veggie debate and continue to practise jhatka.