Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 15 Apr 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki Fateh For Bibeki Sikhs - is eating prepackaged food (example: Crunchie bars, Haldirams, gelebis, tea toasts) permissible? What about commercially produced drinks such as Coca Cola or Mango juice (any kind of juice that is not 100% not-from-concentrate juice)? If one maintains Sarbloh, does that mean microwaves are forbidden? How does one make tea or coffee? I'm asking this in all seriousness...not for any particular reason, just genuine curiosity.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Kulbir Singh · 15 Apr 2005

-------- For Bibeki Sikhs - is eating prepackaged food (example: Crunchie bars, Haldirams, gelebis, tea toasts) permissible? ---------- Bibekis Gursikhs consume none of the above mentioned pre-cooked products. ---------- What about commercially produced drinks such as Coca Cola or Mango juice (any kind of juice that is not 100% not-from-concentrate juice)? ---------- No pop or juice from outside. ---------- If one maintains Sarbloh, does that mean microwaves are forbidden? ------------ Sarblohis don't use microwaves. -------- How does one make tea or coffee? ----------- Most Bibeki Gursikhs don't consume tea or coffee. ---------- I'm asking this in all seriousness...not for any particular reason, just genuine curiosity. --------- No problem Bhain jeeo. You are welcome to ask any questions you want. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

anon · 15 Apr 2005

why dont sarblohis use microwaves? i know that sarbloh cant be put into a microwave.... but say if some form of food, like a potato for example, was put into a microwave by itself. Would that still be wrong?

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Healthy Living · 15 Apr 2005

Weather bibeki or not, microwaves should not be used as they are bad for health. http://www.cancersalves.com/articles/Microwave.html http://www.health-science.com/microwave_hazards.html Conduct a search on google with the folllowing words: microwave cooking health

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

... · 15 Apr 2005

so basically all the food has to be home made? so take out your own fresh juice, make your own ice cream, chocolate, bread, jam, cheese? no yummy packaged vegetarian food or canned items, soft drinks, or crisps? no junk food!? Kulbir Singh, could you please take some time out and just fill us in on what food you guys eat? do you make every single thing at home? and do you use sarbloh spoons? last time i tried to get sarbloh items, there were no spoons, just bowls. Sorry if this all seems really silly, but we are looking at keeping bibek rehit and so your response would really help clarify alot of things. I am just trying to understand. Thank you for your time.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

. · 16 Apr 2005

You can buy almost everything of sarbloh. From spoons to cups, to plates to jugs. Everything! We eat normal food. Whats not normal?

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

anonymous · 16 Apr 2005

you shud make ur own bread, gte the milk urself-arrange from a farmer, and get water from a spring. u wud have to make ur own butter, cheese etc. u shudnt eat ''Crunchie bars, Haldirams, gelebis, tea toasts'' too many people call them selves bibeki's but do non the above, they all eat gelebis and buy milk from stores etc. that is not bibek.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

sceptical · 16 Apr 2005

well if you scared of cancer research has proven that cancer is in your genes get rid of your genes aswell how about the wheat every one eats it is well known that the fertilizers have animal products in them so a wheat seed grows on animal products produces more wheat seeds which humans eat where will you stop i wont eat a seed which fed itself on animal products how about the milk you all drink i wont drink it because first it was meant for the offspring of the cow just as women have milk for their babies so if cows milk is ok is it okay to have human milk??????????

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Singh · 16 Apr 2005

skeptical, You are free to eat or not eat all those things. It is your own choice. Drinking milk can't be considered against Gurmat or Bibek because Guru Sahib himself used these products. How would degh be made without milk products? But again, you are free to do as you wish. As for seeds growing in "animal products", what do you think is in soil? Dead animals and their remains turn to soil. Milk should ideally be taken by a Singh but where this is not availabe, each person can make their own choice what they wish to do. Same with water. Fresh water is best, but if its not available, do your best with what you have. Bibek is one of those things that has many levels. Try your best to keep as much as you can and find a level you are happy and comfortable with.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

sikh2b · 17 Apr 2005

wjkk wjkf. sangat ji, whilst reading through this thread it has occured to me that bibek is not present in Gurdwaras then is it as milk for example is from the shop. Don't mean to be rude when saying that but isn't this common in many gurdwaras in the west? your views please. Also isn't life to be enjoyed and to be grateful for what we have, whether food is from the supermarket or direct from the source, obviously making things yourself is highly commendable and will maintain good health but then in today's society is this feasible?? JUST MY MANMUKH OPINION- bhul chuk marf karni ji. wjkk wjkf.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

tera baap · 17 Apr 2005

sikh2b wrote: > wjkk wjkf. > > sangat ji, > whilst reading through this thread it has occured to me that > bibek is not present in Gurdwaras then is it as milk for > example is from the shop. > > Don't mean to be rude when saying that but isn't this common in > many gurdwaras in the west? > > your views please. > > Also isn't life to be enjoyed and to be grateful for what we > have, whether food is from the supermarket or direct from the > source, obviously making things yourself is highly commendable > and will maintain good health but then in today's society is > this feasible?? > > JUST MY MANMUKH OPINION- bhul chuk marf karni ji. > > > wjkk wjkf. ur right it is ur manmukh opinion, so what if milk is from the markket or whereevere, have u ever seen the process it goes through to get to ur grocers shelf? there is no piont where its in contact with humans its all sterlizewd equipment. in this modern society is it feasible to follow sikhi, i mena what the piont of getting up early if u need 8 hours of sleep and also u need ur daily protein so u need ur meats. long hair is hard to to keep so that goes too. whats the piont of doin paath if its not proven by science? todays societ y is run on fundamentals science, where there is no place for religion. Ur piont about life being enjoyed also raises a question whats the piont of sikhi f life is to be enjoyed? guru sahib says the path is sharper thena sword and thinner then a hair and im pretty sure people dont find that kinda path enjoyable. its all the moderates out there that cant take the pressure of bebik that are against it, just because ur to lazy to do it u bash it.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

TruthSingh · 18 Apr 2005

******Admin Cut. This thread is not about whether Bibek is a must or not. This thread involves positive discussions on how and what bibekis eat. Please don't try to turn this thread into a debate on Bibek*********

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

singh22 · 18 Apr 2005

well said singh so that means absolutely NO one can claim that this bibek is better or that bibek is better it will also depend on what kind of environment a person lives in whether he gets pure water or not whether he gets vegetarian food or not? maybe he will need milk from the elephant if there are no cows in the area? just something coming to my mind

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

guru ki Fauj · 18 Apr 2005

I Know that Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh never took milk from the supermarket. I also think you can't have pooran bibek until you get milk from the cow as singhs use to in the puratan times. Bhai Sahib who was a brahmgiani is a witness to that.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

ABC · 18 Apr 2005

Is it necessary that bibekis eat only from other bibekis or can they eat from non-bibeki amritdharis also?

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

singh22 · 19 Apr 2005

there wasnt any supermarket where bhai sahib lived LOLz bhai sahib also owned stainless steel utensils and they were used in the household

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

flora · 19 Apr 2005

there is no spring within distance to me, so i make use of water i get from the tap. there are no cows to get milk from in the city so i get mine from the supermarket. i have no time to make bread at home so its ready made for me. there are no farms or fields here, so i cannot grow my own food to sustain myself, unless i buy a plot of land which i cannot afford. everyones body is complex and has different requierements some need vitamins for sustenance, who prepares and packs these? if food bibek is a requirement it would stand the test change of time and environment around us, it must be able to be followed anywhere and everywhere but can it? do your simran, naam, bani, seva and you will be fine. the harder you make it, the more complicated and paranoid your life will be.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

singh22 · 19 Apr 2005

bibek budh saatgur tey pai that is gurbani right so do what every dhan siri guru granth sahib ji says only when the budh is bibek there is laha you may eat so called 'pure food' but till the time the budhi is bibek nothing will change and dont expect to have any spiritual progress on the basis of things you eat bibio and singho is this shareer (body) not made of mitti??????? why do you empahasise so much on eat this eat that ???? is everything we eat not mitti????? how do you explain the shabad of kabeer sahib where everything is STATED as IMPURE and it is a part and parcel of Dhan Dhan Guru Granth Sahib Ji. Choice is peoples............take direction from LIVING GURU Dhan Siri Guru Granth Sahib Ji or follow a mere MORTAL. The ten Jots and Dasam Pitta had a purpose when the combined dhan guru granth sahib to GUIDE and TEACH us till ETERNITY I will like the learned Gursikhs to shed some light on the shabad I mentioned above. Please donot say that it was for the pandits of that time just to prove your doctrines right.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Kulbir Singh · 19 Apr 2005

Singh22, ----------------- bibek budh saatgur tey pai that is gurbani right so do what every dhan siri guru granth sahib ji says only when the budh is bibek there is laha ----------------- So what happens when you get bibek of budh? Don’t you get the capability to discern right from wrong and pure from impure? This is the whole purpose of having bibek budh and what kind of bibek budh will allow you to eat from the hands of ones who don’t have a Guru i..e niguray? Niguray are such that according to Gurbani even their name is defiled and impure. How can their food be suitable for devotees? What kind of bibek Budh will let you eat without finding out if the source of income used to buy food is according to Gurmat? Did Guru Sahib not refuse to eat from Malik Bhago because his food was contaminated with the bad source of income of Malik Bhago and because he was not a devotee of Vaheguru? ------------ you may eat so called 'pure food' but till the time the budhi is bibek nothing will change and dont expect to have any spiritual progress on the basis of things you eat bibio and singho is this shareer (body) not made of mitti??????? why do you empahasise so much on eat this eat that ???? is everything we eat not mitti????? ------------------- You are asking “Bibio” and “Singho” if our body is made up of mitti or not. I think your line of argument is flawed. Okay I ask you. Is your body not made of mitti? You will surely say yes. I ask you, is tobacco not mitti? You will have to say yes. Then why can’t mitti eat mitti i.e. your body eat tobacco? Come on Singh22. Use better arguments than this. How about this? You are mitti, and paraayee istree (woman not your wife) is mittee. So what is wrong if mittee meets mittee? Your line of argument is seriously flawed. --------------- how do you explain the shabad of kabeer sahib where everything is STATED as IMPURE and it is a part and parcel of Dhan Dhan Guru Granth Sahib Ji. I will like the learned Gursikhs to shed some light on the shabad I mentioned above. Please donot say that it was for the pandits of that time just to prove your doctrines right. ----------------- Why don’t you write the shabad and then interpret the shabad in your words? Then we will “shed light” on it. Kulbir Singh

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

kaur 123 · 19 Apr 2005

veer kulbir singh jee, i would like to know more on bibek. does the milk have to come from a cow or can we just get it from a supermarket if there are no near by farms? and the same for water, someone mentioned it shud cum from springs wat if ther are no springs near by? is bottled water acceptable? veer ji, what do you do? wer do you get your milk and water from? vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh!

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

singh22 · 19 Apr 2005

i found this on sikhi to max This Shabad is by Bhagat Kabeer Ji in Raag Basant on Pannaa 1195 bsMqu ihMfolu Gru 2 basa(n)th hi(n)ddol ghar 2 Basant Hindol, Second House: <> siqgur pRswid ] ik oa(n)kaar sathigur prasaadh || One Universal Creator God. By The Grace Of The True Guru: mwqw jUTI ipqw BI jUTw jUTy hI Pl lwgy ] maathaa joot(h)ee pithaa bhee joot(h)aa joot(h)ae hee fal laagae || The mother is impure, and the father is impure. The fruit they produce is impure. Awvih jUTy jwih BI jUTy jUTy mrih ABwgy ]1] aavehi joot(h)ae jaahi bhee joot(h)ae joot(h)ae marehi abhaagae ||1|| Impure they come, and impure they go. The unfortunate ones die in impurity. ||1|| khu pMifq sUcw kvnu Twau ] kahu pa(n)ddith soochaa kavan t(h)aao || Tell me, O Pandit, O religious scholar, which place is uncontaminated? jhW bYis hau Bojnu Kwau ]1] rhwau ] jehaa(n) bais ho bhojan khaao ||1|| rehaao || Where should I sit to eat my meal? ||1||Pause|| ijhbw jUTI bolq jUTw krn nyqR siB jUTy ] jihabaa joot(h)ee bolath joot(h)aa karan naethr sabh joot(h)ae || The tongue is impure, and its speech is impure. The eyes and ears are totally impure. ieMdRI kI jUiT auqris nwhI bRhm Agin ky lUTy ]2] ei(n)dhree kee joot(h) outharas naahee breham agan kae loot(h)ae ||2|| The impurity of the sexual organs does not depart; the Brahmin is burnt by the fire. ||2|| Agin BI jUTI pwnI jUTw jUTI bYis pkwieAw ] agan bhee joot(h)ee paanee joot(h)aa joot(h)ee bais pakaaeiaa || The fire is impure, and the water is impure. The place where you sit and cook is impure. jUTI krCI prosn lwgw jUTy hI bYiT KwieAw ]3] joot(h)ee karashhee parosan laagaa joot(h)ae hee bait(h) khaaeiaa ||3|| Impure is the ladle which serves the food. Impure is the one who sits down to eat it. ||3|| gobru jUTw caukw jUTw jUTI dInI kwrw ] gobar joot(h)aa choukaa joot(h)aa joot(h)ee dheenee kaaraa || Impure is the cow dung, and impure is the kitchen square. Impure are the lines that mark it off. kih kbIr qyeI nr sUcy swcI prI ibcwrw ]4]1]7] kehi kabeer thaeee nar soochae saachee paree bichaaraa ||4||1||7|| Says Kabeer, they alone are pure, who have obtained pure understanding. ||4||1||7||

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

singh22 · 19 Apr 2005

************ Is your body not made of mitti? You will surely say yes. I ask you, is tobacco not mitti? You will have to say yes. Then why can’t mitti eat mitti i.e. your body eat tobacco? ********** because guru sahib has told us NOT TO ********* What kind of bibek Budh will let you eat without finding out if the source of income used to buy food is according to Gurmat? Did Guru Sahib not refuse to eat from Malik Bhago because his food was contaminated with the bad source of income of Malik Bhago and because he was not a devotee of Vaheguru? ************ If a someone who has a business involved in any of the vices or even remotely connected to something considered as a vice and does a donation at gurdwara tapoban sahib will the langar not be defiled then? how will you identify the erring dollar???????? what will be your method of purification? and will you be successful that you will be able to totally purify 100%???? ****************** Come on Singh22. Use better arguments than this. How about this? You are mitti, and paraayee istree (woman not your wife) is mittee. So what is wrong if mittee meets mittee? Your line of argument is seriously flawed. ******************* veerji again guru sahib has told us not to. i will say you need a better argument

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Kulbir Singh · 19 Apr 2005

Kaur123 Bhain jee, ------------------- veer kulbir singh jee, i would like to know more on bibek. does the milk have to come from a cow or can we just get it from a supermarket if there are no near by farms? ---------------- Bhain jeeo, I can tell you what we do here. Milking cows directly is not an option here in Canada as we have no means to do so. We buy milk from supermarkets and then boil it in Sarbloh before consuming it. Bibek regarding food is about cooking and raw materials like sugar, milk, flour, grains, vegetables and salt etc can be bought from anywhere. This is what we do currently and if someone can do more, mubarik that person is. ------------- and the same for water, someone mentioned it shud cum from springs wat if ther are no springs near by? is bottled water acceptable? ------------- Many Singhs prefer bottled water while others don’t. I personally don’t use bottled water. ------------ veer ji, what do you do? wer do you get your milk and water from? -------------- I get my water from the tap at my home and milk from the supermarket. Kulbir Singh

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Sister · 19 Apr 2005

Veer Kulbir Singh Ji, I have the same question as ABC, Can bibekis eat from non-bibeki amritdharis?

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Kulbir Singh · 19 Apr 2005

Singh22, ---------------------- ************ Is your body not made of mitti? You will surely say yes. I ask you, is tobacco not mitti? You will have to say yes. Then why can’t mitti eat mitti i.e. your body eat tobacco? ********** because guru sahib has told us NOT TO ------------------------- Same way Guru Sahib has told us to not associate with non-devotees and niguray people. Guru Sahib has told us to avoid eating from “Greh Saakat” i.e. manmukhs. ---------------------------------- ********* What kind of bibek Budh will let you eat without finding out if the source of income used to buy food is according to Gurmat? Did Guru Sahib not refuse to eat from Malik Bhago because his food was contaminated with the bad source of income of Malik Bhago and because he was not a devotee of Vaheguru? ************ If a someone who has a business involved in any of the vices or even remotely connected to something considered as a vice and does a donation at gurdwara tapoban sahib will the langar not be defiled then? how will you identify the erring dollar???????? what will be your method of purification? and will you be successful that you will be able to totally purify 100%???? ------------------------------- Normally only daswandh from Gursikhs is used to prepare langar in Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib. In some cases if a person is not an amritdhari but is a true seeker and making an effort of coming towards Sikhi, his/her donations for langar are accepted as well. Exceptions are made as sangat decides on case by case basis. We are just following the directions from our history, books of gursikhs like Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee and consultations with many Puraatan Singhs from India. -------------------------- ****************** Come on Singh22. Use better arguments than this. How about this? You are mitti, and paraayee istree (woman not your wife) is mittee. So what is wrong if mittee meets mittee? Your line of argument is seriously flawed. ******************* veerji again guru sahib has told us not to. i will say you need a better argument ---------------------------- By the same token, we have been told by Guru Sahib not to eat from non-devotees. You say that Guru Sahib has asked you not to do adultery. Can you eat from persons who commit adultery? Singh22 jeeo, the shabad you have quoted goes in our favour. Bhagat jee writes that without Naam everyone and everything is joothi. Therefore eating from joothay persons is wrong. In the end of this shabad, Bhagat jee clearly says that only they are free from jooth or contamination who do Sacha Vichaar i.e. do Naam Abhyaas or who have realised the truth about Vaheguru. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Kulbir Singh · 19 Apr 2005

---------- Veer Kulbir Singh Ji, I have the same question as ABC, Can bibekis eat from non-bibeki amritdharis? ----------- Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee used to eat only from Bibeki Amritdharis but he has written that the minimum bibek required in Gurmat is eating from amritdharis. If a person eats from non-bibeki amritdharis, we eat from that person. Eating from non-bibeki amritdharis is acceptable and the minimum bibek required. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Admin · 19 Apr 2005

Singh22, if you have specific questions regarding Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib, you are welcome and invited to come over Gurdwara Sahib to discuss the same. If you don't live here, you can call us at 905-799-8383. Such things cannot be discussed hiding behind a computer. The topic on hand is not whether Bibek is a rehit or not. Please refrain from starting a debate on this issue. Admin

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Amolak singh · 19 Apr 2005

It is also good to clean up before going to washroom and same goes afterwards.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

singh · 19 Apr 2005

Kulbir Singh, some of your beliefs on this rehit are extreme in nature and they are not shared by most of Sikh Panth. Where does it say that Bhai Laalo was an amritdhari. The saakhi is about the importance of hallal versus haraam di kamai, not about food prepared by amritdhari vs not amritdhari. Gurbani doesn't stop anyone from eating from Gurduara langer or degh. Most of the great mahapurakhs, with the exception of very few, ate langer from Gurduaras and took degh. Many mahapurakhs accepted food, money and other offerings from non amritdhari shardaloos. They preached sikhi rehit, didn't dictate it. Can you imagine if SGPC and others stop accepting offerings from non amritdharies. You can't get bad karma by just accepting food touched, bought our prepared by non amritdharies. You can not survive without using stuff made, created, produced or constructed by non amritdharies. [%sig%]

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Jugraj Singh · 19 Apr 2005

I belive that a lot of Sikhs feel comfortable with the mainstream beliefs regarding rehit etc. It is what they have always known and one can't really blame the general population for adhreing to what they know. I can imagine how hard it is to reevaluate what you've always known and adopt a puratan version of Sikhi. But do consider that any progress from our current state requires change. If one wants to move forward then letting go of our "comfort zone" and facing the music is mandatory. Regardless of what anyone else might believe or think...I am certain that any decision made out of a sincere devotion to Guru only helps you move closer to God. But coming back to being comfortable with our beliefs... It is a rather common thing for non-amritdharis to view bibek as an offensive and discriminating practice. But this is hardly the case. Would you be offended if a friend of yours didn't eat meat that you made? You would understand that your friend is staying true to his principles and you might even consider the idea of becoming a vegetarian. If discriminating in eating meat etc. is accetable then why is it not acceptable to discriminate in the preparation of the food one consumes? If I were the friend I would be curious about finding out why someone keeps bibek rather then brand it as a disriminating and "brahmanical" pratice.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

can't think of a name.. · 19 Apr 2005

Who 'made' your sarbloh bata? [%sig%]

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Roopkaur · 19 Apr 2005

>Kulbir Singh, some of your beliefs on this rehit are extreme in nature and they are not shared by most of Sikh Panth.< Just because most of the "Sikh panth" does not follow it does it automatically mean it is extreme? During the gurmat class at Tapoban Sahib this Saturday, a similar discussion occured where one person was saying we should blindly accept whatever the Sikh panth accepts without analysing what true gurmat is. A Singh brought up an excellent point that during the Singh Sabha Movement, most of the panth accepted murtis in the gurdvaras and other Hindu influences as acceptable. They were against the Singhs involved in the revival of gurmat in Gurdvaras and Sikhi awareness in the panth. They were shunned, ostracised and singled out for their adherence to gurmat instead of what was widely accepted. Does that mean that they were wrong because they chose to follow gurmat instead of what the majority was saying? Or was the majority wrong when they supported murtis and other Hindu influences in the panth? >Gurbani doesn't stop anyone from eating from Gurduara langer or degh.< Gurbani does say not to eat the food prepared by saakats. Langar or degh is only than guru ka langar or guru ki degh, when it is prepared with full maryadaa. Otherwise you can just order some Kentucky Fried Chicken or McDonalds into the langar, do an ardaas over it, and say it is accepted by Guru ji. Obviously, this is not the case. >They preached sikhi rehit, didn't dictate it.< What is the difference between preaching and dictating? This forum is simply preaching that bibek is the rehit of guru ji, it is up to the individual if they want to follow it or not. IMHO, the best way of preaching a rehit is to follow it yourself. >You can't get bad karma by just accepting food touched, bought our prepared by non amritdharies.< Bani says otherwise. Just read the article on bibek on this website for more information. >You can not survive without using stuff made, created, produced or constructed by non amritdharies.< Again, as has been stated before, the kachaa saamaan can be touched by non amritdharees, but it must have the khalsey dee morh (stamp of Khalsa) on it when it is cooked to be considered bibeki. It is totally possible to survive on bibek, and the Tapoban Singhs are proof of this, as are the rehitvaan Singhs all over the world. I have never heard of any Singh dying of hunger or something because they kept bibek. THere are many pankitis and proofs from rehitnaamaas and jeevans of puraatan Sikhs that bibek is a rehit, but there is no pankiti that supports eating from saakats or nigurey. Maybe it is time we turn to gurmat for guidance, instead of what the majority thinks is right.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

meee · 19 Apr 2005

So...what are we supposed to do if some...lets say...Christian guy, who does not eat meat, drink smoke etc...and he, out of love, invites you over for dinner, and covers his head etc...how do you tell him that you can't eat his food because he is not a baptised Sikh? Is this right? So when Guru Gobind Singh visited Pir Bhudu Shah, do you think he didn't eat from his house? I'm not trying to be smart, i'm just wondering. [%sig%]

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Sister · 20 Apr 2005

I know it must be sooo hard to tell somebody that you can't accept the food they cooked because they are not amritdhari, you'd feel like you are hurting this persons feelings.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

singh · 20 Apr 2005

Roopkaur, there is not a single pankiti in Gurbani that requires sarbloh cooking or that says you will acquire bad karma by just accepting food touched or prepared by non amritdharies. These are just self made beliefs and they have nothing to do with gurbani. Food is food and it should be prepared in a proper hygienic environment. Do more research yourself on what it means to be saakats or nigurey. Where does it say in Gurbani or rehitnaamas that the kachaa saamaan can be touched by non amritdharees but when cooked in sarbloh, it miraculously becomes bibeki food. You name it, all the modern day inventions you enjoy so dearly are done by non amritdharies. How is food any different that it gives you bad karma? We just have to be discerning enough to follow what gurbani asks and eat food suitable for sikhi. Most mahapurkhs we admire did not share your beliefs on food. They ate degh and langer from Gurduaras that you won't go near. Singh Sabha Movement had nothing to do with these belief you are defending here. If you think strongly that most gurduaras don't prepare langer or degh with maryadaa, why don't you take it up to Akaal Takht?

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

BirRaas Singh · 20 Apr 2005

*hides the packet of crisps and coke* :(

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

D. Kaur · 20 Apr 2005

You never have to tell anyone that you do no eat food from non-amritdharees or non-bibekis. Just say you are not hungry. Eat before you come so you are not tempted. You don't have to hurt anyones feelings.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

tera baap · 20 Apr 2005

singh why are u so against bebik, and why do u dance asround the topic?

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Jugraj Singh · 20 Apr 2005

>>>> These are just self made beliefs and they have nothing to do with gurbani. Food is food and it should be prepared in a proper hygienic environment. >>>> Guru Nanak dev ji himself ate food with discrimination. He refused Malik Bhago's food and yet savoured every morsel of the dry and coarse bread that Bhai Lalo jee prepared. This sakhi leaves no doubt that Sikhs are required to discriminate in choosing who they can accept food from. So now that we know that we can't accept food from just anyone, this leaves the question of how an "average" Sikh is to go about determining who they can accept food from. Your criteria in judging acceptability might be different from mine and knowing that all rehit has to be one and the same for everyone, it is simply logical to assume that the criteria was set by guru sahib. Meaning we are to accept food from other Sikhs ... amritdharis. Who is more acceptable to guru sahib then an amrithdari? Guru sahib has created the standard he believed was necessary to meet God and his Sikhs are on the path he created. So it stands to reason that Sikhs accept food only from other Sikhs because only other Sikhs would meet the criteria and standards set forth by Guru Sahib. Ofcourse this implies that if one makes a mistake of serious enough nature than that Singh/bibi is prevented from doing seva in langar etc. This is ofcourse true. I hope the doubts you have or had have been cleared. If not, we can carry this discussion further. As far as people you admire and other Singhs of the past who didn't keep bibek ... well, only guru sahib is perfect. If the likes of Baba Buddha jee and Bhai Gurdas jee can falter then who is anyone else? Only guru sahib is perfect.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Satpurakh Niranjan · 21 Apr 2005

Oh Khalsa Jeeo! How great to see that we are discussing this matter. I will make only one point: Gursikhs such as Bhai Lalo Jee were not your everyday amritdhari we see today. They had contact with Guru Jee and we know that if Guru Nanak was to say just one Shabad, it would convert an Atheist into a Bhagat. So, please let us not underestimate how great these Gursiksh were and how great their Rehit and Jeevans must have been.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

singh · 21 Apr 2005

Jugraj Singh, I am only against aping hindu brahmin practices when it comes to preparing food. I am a socham freak myself but how can anyone get bad karma by just accepting food when we gladly enjoy countless other things! Most Singhs take degh and eat food from Gurdwara langer. Guru Nanak dev ji didn't discriminate. The sakhi of Malik Bhago and Bhai Lalo demonstrates the importance of halaal vs haraam de kamai, not about accepting food from amritdhari vs non amritdharies. tera baap?, I am not against bebik. Do you know what bebit means? And do something with your id. It's misleading. I am not sure if you are calling me .... .... or what.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Mr. Singh · 21 Apr 2005

>>> I am only against aping hindu brahmin practices when it comes to preparing food. >>> I think that the ritualistic/brahmanical practices you are referring to are most often the cases where the mistakes of a few individuals have been highlighted. I myself have heard countless stories from relatives about "Jatha" Singhs who refused food from a non-amritdhari but were later seen eating at a restaurant. I personally don't belive many of these stories but even if they were true... the mistakes of a few don't necessairily mean that the practice of bibek is wrong. Other then the actions of the "pakhandis", I don't see any other brahmanical practices. Perhaps if you were to give an example and then expand on the specific criteria that makes a practice brahmanical then it would help everyone understand your views better. The only thing I can think of that you might be referring to is the touching of food by non-amritdharis. As you said, "I am a socham freak myself but how can anyone get bad karma by just accepting food when we gladly enjoy countless other things!" What other things do we consume? Would amrit, be amrit, if a mona came in during the amrit sanchar and put the patashay in the water? I mean he only touched them right? The answer is obvious. If you are amritdhari then you know that while one Singh is stirring the bata the rest of the panj keep their hands on the bata. They also keep their eyes on the bata. Touching and looking obviously transfers "something" because the panj pyare don't let go even as they stand up. I understand perfectly that you can't "see" what's happening when a non-amritdhari touches the food but I think the above example illustrates that something is happening. Otherwise how would amrit be made? And if a Gursikh touching something tranfers a positive force into the food then wouldn't the opposite be true for non-Gursikh person. This will undoubtely lead to the argument that their are other people who are good, kind and generous and they do a lot of sewa and have a strong belief in God. But as I mentioned in my previous post, if we are to have ekta in rehit, then the question becomes, how does one qualifify to handle the food we consume? What qualifying factors are we looking for and who comes up with them? I think that Guru sahib created the standard of who qualifies when he created the Khalsa Panth. If being Good, kind, and generous was enough then the Panth wouldn't need to exist. The fact that Gurus sahib created a Khalsa means that he thought the worldly standards were unacceptable and introducing "Akal Purakh key fauj" was the only way to establish the new code of conduct. The divine code of conduct. If any other lifestyle bar the Khalsa rehit was acceptable then why was Khalsa created in the first place? >>> Most Singhs take degh and eat food from Gurdwara langer. Guru Nanak dev ji didn't discriminate. >>> Yes, he did. Discrimination isn't necessarilily a negative thing. You aren't necessairily condeming people, but making a conscious decision on what's right and wrong. Is it wrong of us to not allow Blind people to fly planes? It's discrimination against the blind but it is accepted. Is it discrimination against monay to not allow them to do sewa of punj pyare? >>> The sakhi of Malik Bhago and Bhai Lalo demonstrates the importance of halaal vs haraam de kamai, not about accepting food from amritdhari vs non amritdharies. >>> That is definitely a part of the message but hardly the whole message. In any case, your point only further proves what I was trying to say. How will you determine what is haraam and halaal? Guru sahib knew because ... well ... because he was guru sahib. How will you know? And besides what constitutes haraam for you might not be the same for me. Therefore we must look to Guru sahib for guidance. And as said before, guru sahib gave us a unique and different rehit because everything else available was unacceptable to him. And it would make sense that halaal kamaiee is of those who follow this rehit. i.e. those who are amritdhari. Jugraj Singh

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

singh · 21 Apr 2005

Mr. Singh/ Jugraj Singh/ K..... Singh, i only said what I felt after being around some singhs. Everybody have their own standards about eating food these days. Some amrit dharies don't even eat from amrit dharies.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

ns · 21 Apr 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ke Fateh Bibek rehit wale Gursikhs and non bibeks , this argument just goes on and on for ever. Everytime bibeki , sarbloh pops up then here we go all over agan. I'm not a bibeki myself, yet still tring to understand. I have read a lot stuff from Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji, and some references from Bhai Randhir Singh Ji on the topic. The only thing contradicts bibek in a way is lines from Gurbani such as: "SABHO SOOTAK BHRAM HAI....." " KHANA PEEN PAVITAR HEHAA...." These shabads make are teaching mankind all of us to be simple and not to confuse issues. Are there refereces such as above existing in Bhai Randhir Singh Ji's works with regards to bibek?

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Singh Akali · 21 Apr 2005

Don't we use sugar? Is it made by Amritdharis and Sarabloh bibekis? How about clothing, electronic media, computers, computer parts, etc. Main thing is cleanliness. As long as the person cooking the food is clean and makes it properly. It is ok. Drugs are no clean so if someone smokes and makes food. Don't eat it. Another example of ...

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

tera baap · 21 Apr 2005

uh no i dont kno wat bebit is, maybe u cud elighten us? i kno what bebik is though. and let me tell u something, there is a common misconception, bebik isnt only for food its also for other things such as dont accept something from a known paapi be a it a lamp or a car. and when u buy something like a car it maybe made by manmukhs but we dont eat cars well i dont but i dont know about u.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Jugraj Singh · 21 Apr 2005

>>> Everybody have their own standards about eating food these days. Some amrit dharies don't even eat from amrit dharies. >>> Once again you are correct in stating that some amritdharies don't eat from other amritdharies. I understand it like this: Guru sahib gave us a baseline, a minimal requirement. For example we have to do panj bania for nitnem in the morning. You can do asa di var if you so wish and sukhmani sahib etc. Same thing for bibek. WE've to eat from amrit dharis but if a singh feels he should only eat from other bibeki or sarblohi singhs then why not? What is wrong with this? We have the right to make our personal choices as along as they are within the guidelines of gurmat. >>>> Don't we use sugar? Is it made by Amritdharis and Sarabloh bibekis? How about clothing, electronic media, computers, computer parts, etc. Main thing is cleanliness. As long as the person cooking the food is clean and makes it properly. It is ok. >>>> Please read the previous posts carefully. In gurmat cleanliness is a small part of the maryada in preparation of food. There is also an excellent article on bibek on this very webiste. Please refer to that.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

? · 22 Apr 2005

well no offence to my dear amritdhari brothers and sisters i love you all. few weeks bak i did some work for an amritdhari singh i myself am not yet. This singh took was in a desperate situation and tried his best to take me off work to do some work for him, the agreement was i work for him for 2 days and he pays me a set wage which covers my usual costs as i am in a situation where i cannot afford to be on less. Now when it comes to payment time the guy wants to pay me a third less than what i wanted claiming he is paying in relation to volumes i did when i actually left at 8pm on one day. To save the friendship with this man i accepted. But inside myself i was reminded of guru nanak and the milk story. Sometimes sikhs do so much paat this singh is on amritvela at 12am daily and still some amridharis can stab a non amritdhari in the back like that. so would you accept food from this singh at a gurdwara or langer? would you accept his daswand? would you drink water from his hands? YES you would because he is amritdhari? would you accepot food and water from me? NO you would not, even if i did not eat meat, no smoke, no sex outside marriage, no hair cutting, did paat, simran, it doesnt matter what i did or did not you would not accept anything from me because i might be corrupt, but the same rule would not apply the other way because it is assumed the amritdhari is flawless but i think you all know better sometimes goes both ways. The standard is inside yourself, by making standards on others we judge. All i can say is waheguru save us. i hope i did not do nindia, but i have bills coming soon responsible for a house, that was why i left mr singh to pay me a few weeks later. If a guru ka singh can skank a person like that and talk about sikhi at the same time then whats the difference between some amritdharis and upper caste hindus who took the khoon out of the greeb too? i feel upset and angry i pray to god this is not nindia.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Jugraj Singh · 22 Apr 2005

Firstly, I just want to say that I sympathize with your sentiments and your situation. In any case, we've your side of it and so lets go with that. So, the Singh cheated you out of your pay. Then what? What does this have to do with food bibek? We follow the hukam of bibek and if we keep the minmum standard and end up eating from a Singh like the one you mentioned, than it is not our fault and I don't imagine that one's avastha would be adversely affected because of this. The Singh who stole your money would be at fault twice. First for stealing and then for not acknowleding it and continuing to do sewa like nothing had happened. Guru sahib will deal the Singh on his own. Our responsibility is to follow rehit. Suppose that you were practicing martial arts and and your kirpan fell off. Then does this mean that we should stop wearing kirpans because their is a chance that it might fall of accidentally? Or do we simply pick up the kirpan do an ardaas and move on. We are responsible for our own spiritual jeeven. We can cry about this and that and talk about "What if's" till the cows come home, or we can do what we know we have to. Jugraj Singh

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

kaur · 22 Apr 2005

The reason bhai Rhandir singh ji did not buy milk from the market was because he lived on a farm. He had a cow in is farm. I don't have a cow or a farm. But if you have access to fresh milk dats brilliant. The thing is if people are too busy trying to make their own milk, bread, flour butter etc then its sometimes possible to forget what other things in rehat we are supposed to practice like naam seva simran, pyar for maharaj, etc. It is also important to get on with life and work so we can afford to help other people if we need to. Im sure guru ji understands if I buy milk form the supermarket as long as I keep to the main rehat and never forget him. Bhai Randhir singh ji was a magnificant person but I know other singhs, singhnia's that buy their milk from the supermarket and are spiritially on another level.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Khalistani Singh · 22 Apr 2005

If you can have milk from the store then you can also have yoghurt, ice cream, butter, cheese, because they are also all proceesed as milk is as well. That does dont constitute proper bibek. If you have a dhil then accept it, don,t try to find excuses for dhilpuna. Bhai Sahib did not allow any of this dhil in his rehat, i think all of you need to get peshed who are drinking this supermarket milk, i think the milk is affecting your judgment of bibek. How can these singhs or singhnia achive higher spiruality by having supermarket milk,if this was not accepted by Bhai Sahib, he abviously had dib drisht at a diffrent level which everybody else is blind of.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

tera baap · 22 Apr 2005

Khalistani Singh wrote: > If you can have milk from the store then you can also have > yoghurt, ice cream, butter, cheese, because they are also all > proceesed as milk is as well. > > That does dont constitute proper bibek. > > If you have a dhil then accept it, don,t try to find excuses > for dhilpuna. > > Bhai Sahib did not allow any of this dhil in his rehat, i think > all of you need to get peshed who are drinking this supermarket > milk, i think the milk is affecting your judgment of bibek. > > How can these singhs or singhnia achive higher spiruality by > having supermarket milk,if this was not accepted by Bhai Sahib, > he abviously had dib drisht at a diffrent level which everybody > else is blind of. in case u have not noticed that milk is not cooked, while the rest of the things are. by cookin things you put the seal on them. also if u read any of the other psots u wud ahve known that it is impossible in some palces to get milk otherwise and the milk is heated b4 concumption. now im pretty sure u cant biol ice cream then eat it.

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Kulbir Singh · 22 Apr 2005

Khalistani veer, ------------- If you can have milk from the store then you can also have yoghurt, ice cream, butter, cheese, because they are also all proceesed as milk is as well. ------------ Out of these items butter all Singhs buy from outside and Gheo too, Singhs used to buy from anywhere and made by anyone. Gheo (ghee) is an exception. As for butter, most Singhs I know make ghee out of butter before using it. Bhai Sahib followed the rehit that he would only eat from Bibekis but he himself writes that the minimum must rehit is eating only from amritdharis, even if they are not bibekis. Same way, Bhai Sahib followed more rehit than normal or minimum acceptable level. Milk is considered pavitter or pure by all organisations including Bibeki Nihungs, Bibeki Taksalis and other jathas. Bhai Atma Singh Panjokhra-Sahib used to say that his father who belonged to an old family of bibeki Singhs used to say that milk is pure. Also being a raw material, it qualifies to be bought from anywhere, so long as it is brought home and boiled in Sarbloh. If it is not good enough for you, we respect your chardi kala. ---------- If you have a dhil then accept it, don,t try to find excuses for dhilpuna. --------- It is not a dhil puna according to our opinion. -------------- Bhai Sahib did not allow any of this dhil in his rehat, i think all of you need to get peshed who are drinking this supermarket milk, i think the milk is affecting your judgment of bibek. ------------- Again, this is what you think and you are entitled to your views. We don't agree with this and you are welcome to come over to discuss this with Sangat. Kulbir Singh

Re: Bibeki and things like...Crunchie Bars, Coca-Cola, and Microwaves

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 22 Apr 2005

So, bibeki Sikhs generally cannot live in college dorms, correct? One must either live in a campus apartment (with a full kitchen), in an outside apartment, or at home?