Re: 1960-Bhai Sahib
Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 16 Apr 2005
and also the newly emerging trend of "MIXING" lines from various shabads all together in one new shabad...
Prof Darshan Singh Raagi Jathedar Akal Takhat i beleive started this trend..but then he does a lot of KATHA in his kirtan...and taking lines from different shabads to explain a line in a certian shabad may be OK...but then the other day i heard a famous Raagi doing this in PURE KIRTAN....one line from one shabad, then the enxt line from a different shabad ( but simialr emaning)...then a third line fourth line from a different shabad..etc etc mixing about five different shabads with ONE RAHAO from the main shabad...I realsied this was happening when the person manning the computer was seen putting up all the "wrong" lines becasue he had to search the new lines in new shabads every two minutes...and then RETURN to the Original shabad for teh Rahao pangktee...
This may be "new" way of doing kirtan to a Raagi..BUT i find it is INSULTING GURU JI...GURBANI should be sung as it is written....how can one start off with Raag Asa Mh 1..then go on to Majh mah 5 shabad line, then a Sri raag Mh 1 line etc...even though A:LL the shabads share a common meaning/lesson/etc.
What do the readers think about this ??
Jarnail Singh
Re: 1960-Bhai Sahib
Jagjit Singh · 16 Apr 2005
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh
Pyare jio, when I asked Giani Amolak singh many years ago, he said he knew of no recording of bhai sahibs kirtan, but had known that All India radio recorded one of his speeches once.
However at this years AKJ UK smagam, when i spoke to Bibi Harjit kaur, she said she had heard of a recording of bhai sahib keertan. So one does exist. It is just about finding it....
waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh