Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

caesarian operation

caesarian operation

Kulmohan · 15 Apr 2005

I give a call to support the following Akal takhat should order a ban on the practise of branding a woman, one who has had a caesarian operation, as a tankhaiya for the simple reason that she had her hair removed as a part of the caesarian process. Whilst gurbani tells us 'So kyon manda aakhiyey jit janmey raajan' some of us are doing just the opposite. any secondees for this call

Re: caesarian operation

..... · 15 Apr 2005

if a women HAS TO HAVE a caesarian operation as a last resort as ovawise the babys life or the mothers life is at risk, only then is a caesarian operation acceptable, but because the hair has been removed she would have to go pesh.

Re: caesarian operation

... · 15 Apr 2005

Its a lose-lose situation if she has to go pesh... if she doesn't take the C-section - she endangers the health of her baby. if she takes the C-section - she is treated as if she did something wrong and must take pesh. there should be some practicality - if she takes the C-section out of necessity, she shouldn't pesh. It all comes down to choice. She didn't choose to do it. She HAD to do it. Why would you be punished for something that you had no control over? Simple psychology would tell you that punishing someone for something that they had no control over will accomplish nothing.

Re: caesarian operation

Kulbir Singh · 15 Apr 2005

------------- Akal takhat should order a ban on the practise of branding a woman, one who has had a caesarian operation, as a tankhaiya for the simple reason that she had her hair removed as a part of the caesarian process. ------------- I don’t know if woman after caesarean is called a tankhaiya but she surely does bring herself and her newborn baby before Punj Pyaaray. All Sikhs after operation that involves removal of hair, get pesh before Punj Pyaray. As far as I know most Punj Pyaray don’t give out tankhaah to woman in this situation. I don’t understand why getting pesh in front of Punj Pyaray is a bad thing or a negative thing. The sight of Punj Pyaray is an absolutely blissful sight. -------------- Whilst gurbani tells us 'So kyon manda aakhiyey jit janmey raajan' --------------- A woman does not get called a “manda” if she has to get pesh after an operation. All people, men or women, have to get pesh after operation. There is no discrimination here. Kulbir Singh

Re: caesarian operation

Sister · 15 Apr 2005

Yes, I agree with the above, one shouldn't be treated like a criminal for giving birth via C-section or otherwise.

Re: caesarian operation

Kulbir Singh · 15 Apr 2005

"Sister", Who says they are treated as criminals? Why is there so much phobia associated with presenting oneself before Punj Pyaray? Kulbir Singh

Re: caesarian operation

Guldeep Singh · 15 Apr 2005

Bhai Kulbir Singh is exactly right. I know for a fact there is no tankhah for any kind of medical operation. Maryada is that anyone who has kesh removed for whatever reason has to re take Amrit. I don't see anything wrong w/ that. If any Jathedar is giving tankhah for a C-section it is an error.

Re: caesarian operation

Harpreet Singh · 15 Apr 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh Our son who is now 3 years old was born with cesarean section as there were too many complications during birth. Both myself and my singhni along with our new born, went to amrit sanchaar samagam at UK and presented ourselves before guru sahib and panj piaare. I am very happy to write here that the immense blessings and love that was showered on our family by the panj piaare. When we told them about the kes they told us to get the singni amrit di daat again as any single hair removed from body by any means with or without consent requires one to get the amrit again. But during the whole process no one treated her like a criminal. Instead the blessings and the amazing darshan of guru sahib and panj piaare gave us more strength and chardhikala. Also no tankhah was given. People, please stop playing politics with every of the gurmat maryada in name of women's equality etc. If you haven't seen what happens behind the curtain don't start an argument about the unseen. Bhul chuk di khima da jaachak Daas, Harpreet Singh [%sig%]

Re: caesarian operation

. · 15 Apr 2005

If someone has hair removed due to such an operation, can they still do seva in punj pyaaray later after getting pesh, or is it the same as someone who intentionally removes kes?

Re: caesarian operation

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 15 Apr 2005

Am I understanding this properly... That must be EVERY time kesh gets removed for medical reasons? Or just surgery? I understand that surgery involves shaving the body at the point of entry. However, there are other medical practices that also remove body hair that don't involve a person shaving the hairs of the body. If one has to have an IV for example, the IV catheter is typically taped in place with surgical tape. Removing the tape typically removes a bit of body hair that was under the tape. Band-Aids, for that matter, can do the same when they are removed from the skin. I'm not having a dig at anything, just trying to get a grasp of it all.

Re: caesarian operation

BirRaas Singh · 16 Apr 2005

What about in olden days when Singhs went to war, if they took a cut with a tulwar, the hair on their body would have been cut too, would they have taken amrit again?

Re: caesarian operation

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 16 Apr 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. a few too many "suppositions" here... 1. One doesnt get PESH as in a criminal Court...it is out of LOVE. 2. The PUNJ NEVER give out PUNISHMENT under any circumstances.....even for BUJJAR KUREHITS....they dole out loads of LOVE...SEWA/Paath/ etc to bring out the Good GUSIKH in one even more than usual... 3. There is a VAST difference between a normal "court...its procedures..its judges....and the punishment"...and the PUNJ. One DOESNT get arrested and hauled before the Punj.....its purely VOLUNTARY and out of lOVE, then the PUNJ dont behave mighty and superior...they treat you with LOVE..and the End RESULT of a Punj Peshi is a BETTER GURSIKH. 4. People would "die" to get an invite to say the Buckingham Palace for lunch with the Queen...a GURSIKH would do the same for a meeting with the PUNJ..who are the Personification of GURU JI Himself. GO before the PUNJ at every opportunity you get.....you will NOT regret it. ( BUT this is not an open invite to commit the kurehits !!!) Jarnail Singh

Re: caesarian operation

;;;;;;; · 18 Apr 2005

i was doin my nana jis 2 foot gutter last week with superglue desi style method. loads of glue dripped down my arm, anyway i cud not get it off because it was stuck to kes on my arm. so i had to peel it off off came the kes with it. health and safety issue i had to do it