Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

NOT IMPORTANT THINK AGAIN - UNESCO heritage status of darbar sahib

NOT IMPORTANT THINK AGAIN - UNESCO heritage status of darbar sahib

SIKH · 11 Apr 2005

THIS POST HAS BEEN COPIED AND POSTED HERE FROM A EMAIL DISCUSSION GROUP, PLEASE STOP AND TAKE THE TIME TO READ THIS AND TAKE A STAND, THIS IS VERY IMPORTANT, HERITAGE STATUS FRO DARBAR SAHIB WILL BE DISASTOROUS FOR THE KAUM IF IT GOES THROUGH. dear khalsa ji my fears that India will play games and is already acting as if darbar sahib belongs to it seem to be proven by the letter recieved by wsc from unesco unesco has said that while it has recieved a letter from SGPC, it cannot act on it as the Government of India, the applicant, has not written to UNESCO. As such, according to UNESCO, the process will go ahead as planned and the committee will meet in South africa in July to consider inscription of darbar sahib!!! we seem to have lost control already on events. what further evidence do we need. please, please do not do the usual sikh thing and have a small attention span on an issue. This issue needs to be pursued to it logical conclusion YOU NEED TO WRITE TO YOUR OWN GOVERNMENTS TO GET INTERVENTION THEY ARE THE ONLY ONES THAT CAN PUT A STOP TO THIS MADNESS nothing has been solved by just sgpc agreeeing to withdraw the dossier. it is the Indian government that has to withdraw the dossier, since it is the applicant.. this is proof enough of the troubles ahead if Darbar sahib is granted heritage status. jasdev singh rai

Re: NOT IMPORTANT THINK AGAIN - UNESCO heritage status of darbar sahib

sikh · 12 Apr 2005

i am absolutely gob smacked by the lack of interest this situation has amongst the sangat on this forum...are u people really this niave? does talking about the style of paag, or who can do simran matter more to you than the future of darbar sahib, something which i thought was at the heart of every sikh? if this is the extent of interest which u guys show to our gurdware then we all dont deserve to have anything........ what a sad state of affairs

Re: NOT IMPORTANT THINK AGAIN - UNESCO heritage status of darbar sahib

S Singh · 12 Apr 2005

From what I have seen the Sikhs as a whole care very litte about heritage etc. They complain about how the Akal Takht was destroyed during Bluestar (and this is a view I also subscribe to) but the Kar seva wale have destoyed a lot more thorugh their misguided work. No one gives two hoots about WHS. It will help preserve our heritage but people like Rai are getting their kachere in a twist over it. The SGPC cannot do anyhting without the DC's permission anyway so nothing will change and his continued talk about the GOI getting control is jsut wish wash.

Re: NOT IMPORTANT THINK AGAIN - UNESCO heritage status of darbar sahib

Bored Boy · 12 Apr 2005

What should be done to raise awareness. A number of large scale protests outside the UNESCO buildings wolrdwide???

Re: NOT IMPORTANT THINK AGAIN - UNESCO heritage status of darbar sahib

sikh · 12 Apr 2005

s singh that is the case for most things in india dosent mean that you still dont try and keep control urself regardless of the fact what the state does...... i really fail to see any worth while sense in ur posts? what exactly is ur agenda here? who gives a toss if some sikhs dont care i and many others do. and whether or not we have a brahmin gov in power i still want darbar sahib under the sikhs control. and dr rai is doing his damnest to make sure us idiot sikhs dont lose another part of out history and independance he is getting his kachera in a twist because he cares if u have nothig else positive to say, then please keep quiet.

Re: NOT IMPORTANT THINK AGAIN - UNESCO heritage status of darbar sahib

S Singh · 12 Apr 2005

sikh, The Darbar Sahib is not under Sikh control. The SGPC cannot do anything without the approval of the Deputy Commissioner who is a Government appointed officer. So what has Rai done to raise this issue ? Zilch ! I dont see Rai getting concerned about the bodged up gold plating seva done on Harmandir Sahib or the white washing of frescoes by kar seva wale at Gurdwara Baba Atal. The SGPC has no independence so what "independence" are you talking about ? What is my agenda ? Simply to ensure we do not lose anymore of our heritage. If this means WHS then so be it. The SGPC has had long enough and has failed to do anything to preserve Sikh heritage in fact if anything more Sikh heritage has been lost since the SGPC was set up than at any other time in Sikh history. If you have nothing positive to say about preserving Sikh heritage then please keep quiet

Re: NOT IMPORTANT THINK AGAIN - UNESCO heritage status of darbar sahib

sikh · 12 Apr 2005

s singh are u an idiot? we still have control of our own affairs regardless of the fact that certain people within the sgpc may answer to other pay masters..... akal takhat is still autonomous getting heritage status will strip the entire complex of this position we are all governed in some shape or forum, this is the boundaries we accept to live in when residing in a nation state, that don't mean give up everything.......... the leadership will change in time at darbar sahib and then changes can be made, heriatge status will take all powers away from us........ before asking what has rai done what have u done? apart from talking total rubbish from behind ur pc

Re: NOT IMPORTANT THINK AGAIN - UNESCO heritage status of darbar sahib

S Singh · 12 Apr 2005

sikh your post shows your complete lack of knowledge. Firstly the SGPC does not have any real control. THE DC OF AMRITSAR has more power than the SGPC ! If you think this is control of our own affairs than sadly you are living in dream world. The Akal Takht has not been autonomous for over a century and since the inception of the SGPC the Akal Takht has consistantly been missused and failed to live up to what it was intended for. Again if you think the Akal Takht is autonomous then you need to study the situation in a bit more depth. Heritage status will not take any powers away as the SGPC has no powers anyway. You cannot take something away if it does not exist. Yes I talk rubbish form behind my PC but at least I have been advocating the preservation of our heritage rather than jumping on the anti WHS bandwagon like other people. I have been to the Harmandir Sahib as recently as last month to photograph the destruction of our heritage and will be posting pictures on web sites soon.

Re: NOT IMPORTANT THINK AGAIN - UNESCO heritage status of darbar sahib

balkar · 12 Apr 2005

interesting what you say, let whs sort things out for us. r u so incapable that you cannot take on the sgpc and preserve heritage or r u from that group of sikhs who think sikhs are a mutant species inacpable of managing themselves. they need governments and unesco to look after them. Happily i am not one of those mutants and still believe in the khalsa spirit. now that rai has raised this issue, i am going to take on the sgpc and force it to set up a committee to preserve heritage. Anyone want to join me? As for the wider issue, well, we can start on that as well, i am not so impotent that i want unesco to fight my battles. next you will be saying unesco should setiing us gurmukhi teachers, training our granthis and manage the rest of our gurdwaras , since we have so many fights in gurdwaras. Tell you what, unesco can even change teh nappies of some of us, or we can ask UNICEF have some pride man and learn to fight your own battles. i think if you ask rai, you will probably find he may have taken on the dc and others as well balkar

Re: NOT IMPORTANT THINK AGAIN - UNESCO heritage status of darbar sahib

JSS · 12 Apr 2005

i think it's about time that we sikhs demand that the harmandir sahib complex be soveirgn....like the vatican...how it belongs to no government excep the catholic church...