Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Duality

Duality

BirRaas Singh · 09 Apr 2005

Bani makes many refferences to "dooja", "doojai" and "dubhida" which in translations comes up as "duality", this term means nothing to me, can the sangat express their opinions on what duality is or what is "living in duality?" Thanks

Re: Duality

etka · 09 Apr 2005

living both the gur-sikh way, along with the wordly ways.

Re: Duality

Boltzmann · 09 Apr 2005

It's a reference to the wave/particle nature of matter. The earliest work was done by Thomas Young in his Double-Slit Experiment where he demonstrated that light had certain wave like characteristics. This eventually lead the way for people like Maxwell, Compton, and DeBroglie to further study matter and find out that it's not just thing we previously thought were particles that could behave like waves, but that waves could behave like particles as well (electrons); ergo there is a 'duality' in life. You might want to read some articles on [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wave-particle_duality]Wave/Particle Duality[/url], [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_Broglie_hypothesis]The DeBroglie Wavelength[/url], and [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_mechanics]Quantum Mechanics[/url].

Re: Duality

Kulbir Singh · 09 Apr 2005

Duality is called Dubidha. To understand Duality, I will narrate a small story of a seeker of Vaheguru: Once a Saayeen Lok, a faqeer was walking by. He approached a village and was slowly walking in a very tight galee (road or street). Both sides of the street had high walls. It was a long street. It was so narrow that hardly one person could pass by at a given time. Since the Faqeer was walking very slowly, a chooRi (sorry for using this word but this is how I heard it from my Farsi Ustaad, many many years ago) who was following him got irritated and said, "Oye Baba, Ikk Paasay ho jaa". This chooRi had big bundle of wet grass on her head and she was worried that she would drop the pand or the bundle of grass on the Faqeer. So she warned the Faqeer about her coming behind her. When he heard the ChooRi speak, her sentence, her words hit her like a sharp arrow. Her words pierced through his heart. He felt his heart bleeding with the blow. He fell at the feet of the ChooRi and started thanking her for giving him divine wisdom. The ChooRi was truly perplexed and could not make anything out of the Faqeer's behaviour. She asked him, "Main kee kar ditta Baba jee?" (What did I do to please you Baba jee). Faqeer said in great ecstasy, "Tu mainu gyaan ditaa hai". (You have given me divine knowledge). ChooRi did not understand anything and wrote-off the Faqeer as "Kamla" and passed him. Did anyone understand what happened here? Why was the Faqeer in ecstasy? What pleased him so much? To be continued after your answers. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Duality

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 10 Apr 2005

my manmukh interpretation on the surface the life of a manmukh and gurmukh are both difficult but in different ways. we might not know it, but walking in a narrow road with a high wall on either side might feel as both walls are horribly hard and daunting. people choose their sides and who knows if one wall is the wall to the house of pain and another is the wall of the mansion of the guru. in order to distinguish you have to "ik paasay noo ho jaa" and chose your side instead of living life in the middle of duniaavee math and gurmath. please forgive my mistakes - just an interpretation vaaheguroojeekaakhaalsaa vaaheguroojeekeefatheh!!!!!

Re: Duality

sikh2b · 10 Apr 2005

wjkk wjkf. my limited understanding of duality: thinking that (perceived) bad things are created by someone other than God. what it means to me is that God created everything whether it is good or bad as nothing is higher than God so nothing else could create anything. just like you cannot experience happiness until you have felt pain, everything has an opposite to teach us right from wrong. Reading the above posts though i don't really understand what sangat have said, would you please explain. thank you. bhul chuk marf karni ji. wjkk wjkf.

Re: Duality

Me · 10 Apr 2005

I guess it means the Faqeer understood that when the ChooRi said 'tu' paasay ho ja, it meant that he had to remove himself from the path before he could merge with the divine, the duality existed as long as 'he' was there. Hope that makes sense.

Re: Duality

...... · 10 Apr 2005

please enlighten us veerjee

Re: Duality

daaas · 10 Apr 2005

Dag Mag Dag Mag Shaad Rae Man Boara

Re: Duality

..... · 10 Apr 2005

Because she said, "Oye Baba, Ikk Paasay ho jaa" Meaning stick to one thing - Maya or Vaheguroo.

Re: Duality

Premi · 10 Apr 2005

I imagine she was saying to him to get to one side i.e God's side and stop living in the "middle of the street" i.e with the 5 vikaars. ????Right?Wrong?? Premi

Re: Duality

Premi · 11 Apr 2005

The answer to Bhai Kulbir Singh's question is that the Faqir realised that altho there are two sides, both are the same. Duality is the notion that there is something separate from God. If the Faqir moved right or left, he would not have moved at all, so there is not two sides, but only one. I'm surprised that your Farsi Ustaad understands this concept. Is this concept prevelant outside of Gurbani too?

Re: Duality

Kulbir Singh · 12 Apr 2005

Pretty much everyone has given the correct answer according to my humble opinion. The faqeer was stuck in Dubidha or doublemindedness. Dubidha is a big obstacle in the path of spirituality. Dubidha is the incapability of our mann to indulge fully in Naam Bhagti. Guru Sahib has written in Gurbani that only if the beej or seed is saabat or full, it can grow into a tree (Je ikk hoye taan ugvai). Same way only a united or concentrated mann can do bhagti. When we have dooja bhaao or love/attraction for things of this world, we cannot give our fullest to Vaheguru and this results in we staying stuck in Maaiya or this world. It is important that we give our full effort and our full concentration to Naam. Then alone we can achieve our goal of meeting Vaheguru. The ChooRi in the story above inadvertently helped the faqeer who was stuck in doublemindedness. He probably must have left his house and friends to become a Faqeer but was still not achieving his spiritual aim. What he needed was someone to tell him that “ik paasay ho ja” i.e. get on one side. Stop looking at maaiya and look at Vaheguru alone for Anand. The ChooRi's bachan must have rejuvenated him to do bhagti. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Duality

Kulbir Singh · 12 Apr 2005

------------- I'm surprised that your Farsi Ustaad understands this concept. Is this concept prevelant outside of Gurbani too? --------------- I am a declared proponent of the notion that the pinnacles of spirituality are reserved for Sikhs only but this does not mean that the other seekers of Vaheguru don’t reach high levels of spirituality. They just don’t reach the topmost level since they don’t have the topmost Guru i.e. The Satguru i.e. Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj but they do attain high levels of spirituality. The Sufees and many Hindu sects have reached very high levels of spirituality and I have great respect for these seekers of Vaheguru because they reached so high despite not having the true Guru. Alas, they could not reach the topmost levels. But Guru Sahib may do kirpa on them and perhaps they will be born as Sikhs and then reach their desired proximity and closeness with Vaheguru. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Duality

BirRaas Singh · 12 Apr 2005

Kulbir Singh, is Guru Nanak the only Satguru ever?

Re: Duality

Kulbir Singh · 12 Apr 2005

In my opinion yes. Sach cannot be two. Sach is always one. Gurbani has only called Guru Nanak Sahib and his jyot Satguru. No one else. If there had been other Satgurus, Gurbani would have mentioned at least one of them. But no. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Duality

Gabroo · 12 Apr 2005

------ The Sufees and many Hindu sects have reached very high levels of spirituality ------ Yes, this is agreeable, but which Hindu sects would you say are on roughly the right path?

Re: Duality

BirRaas Singh · 12 Apr 2005

Kulbir Singh please check the Vaars of Bhai Gurdas on the explanation of the origins of "Waheguroo" gurmantar, who else is stated as "satguru"? Its vaar 1 pauri 49 if i remember correctly

Re: Duality

Kulbir Singh · 12 Apr 2005

--------- Yes, this is agreeable, but which Hindu sects would you say are on roughly the right path? ----------- In my humble opinion, Chataniya Mahaprabhu's samprada and the samprada of Sidhas whom Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee met are most elevated spiritually. As for the correct path, I believe that without the true Naam, the Sat-Naam, no one can reach the top zenith of spirituality. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Duality

Kulbir Singh · 12 Apr 2005

------- Kulbir Singh please check the Vaars of Bhai Gurdas on the explanation of the origins of "Waheguroo" gurmantar, who else is stated as "satguru"? Its vaar 1 pauri 49 if i remember correctly ----------- According to Bhai Vir Singh jee this pauri is not of Bhai Gurdas jee since it is not there in older copies of Vaaran Bhai Gurdas jee. Other scholars too unanimously agree that this pauri is not that of Bhai Gurdas jee. The pauri makes no sense at all. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Duality

BirRaas Singh · 12 Apr 2005

According to Bhai Vir Singh jee this pauri is not of Bhai Gurdas jee since it is not there in older copies of Vaaran Bhai Gurdas jee. Other scholars too unanimously agree that this pauri is not that of Bhai Gurdas jee. The pauri makes no sense at all. Daas, Kulbir Singh -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- *sighs*.......

Re: Duality

_/\_ · 12 Apr 2005

------------------------------ Author: BirRaas Singh Date: 04-12-05 17:32 According to Bhai Vir Singh jee this pauri is not of Bhai Gurdas jee since it is not there in older copies of Vaaran Bhai Gurdas jee. Other scholars too unanimously agree that this pauri is not that of Bhai Gurdas jee. The pauri makes no sense at all. Daas, Kulbir Singh -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- *sighs*....... -------------------------- would you please explain to moorakhs like me why you are sighing?

Re: Duality

can't think of a name.. · 13 Apr 2005

Author: Kulbir Singh Date: 04-12-05 17:15 ------- Kulbir Singh please check the Vaars of Bhai Gurdas on the explanation of the origins of "Waheguroo" gurmantar, who else is stated as "satguru"? Its vaar 1 pauri 49 if i remember correctly ----------- According to Bhai Vir Singh jee this pauri is not of Bhai Gurdas jee since it is not there in older copies of Vaaran Bhai Gurdas jee. Other scholars too unanimously agree that this pauri is not that of Bhai Gurdas jee. The pauri makes no sense at all. Daas, Kulbir Singh ***** Bhai Sahib I have that Pauri in the set of Vaar's I have and I have also crosschecked it with some other sources and they all contain that Pauri. Can you point out which 'older copies' do not have this Pauri (i.e. provide references to back what you are saying, where has Bhai Vir Sigh Ji said this etc). To be honest that Pauri makes sense to me but then again I don't have little boxes in which theories have to fit into.. Many thanks. [%sig%]

Re: Duality

really · 13 Apr 2005

I don't have Bhai Sahibs vaars, can you please state the pauri you are refering to here.

Re: Duality

BirRaas Singh · 14 Apr 2005

http://searchgurbani.com/main.php?book=bhai_gurdas_vaaran&action=pauripage&vaar=1&pauri=49

Re: Duality

can't think of a name.. · 16 Apr 2005

Still waiting for a response from Bhai Kulbir Singh :-) [%sig%]