Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

MUSIC

MUSIC

jyoti kaur dhillon · 07 Apr 2005

CAN A SIKH STILL LISTEN TO OTHER TYPES OF MUSIC. FOR EXAMPLE THERE WAS A KATHA ABOUT 1984 AND TEH BACKGROUND MUSIC WAS DR DRE-STILL DRE JUST WONDERING.

Re: MUSIC

troubled! · 07 Apr 2005

the raag, naad is the means and not the end. what is important is what is being said!

Re: MUSIC

Manvir Singh · 07 Apr 2005

Music is music. Whatever your aatma says - goes with it. If you don't like a particular style of music or beat - fair enuff - it's your personal choice. Gurmat objection is to obsene lyrics about seducing people, promoting caste and other things which you would feel shame to listen to in front of our Father Guru Gobind Singh Sahib ji.

Re: MUSIC

Dogma · 07 Apr 2005

why does one need Dr. Dre doing background beats during katha? I don't believe in Guru Sahib's time that they asked for a thumbee and dhol to be played while they were speaking...? I'm not really in a position to pass judgement on anyone listening to music. I suppose it's an issue of personal growth. Some people still feel they need to listen to it, or like to listen to it while others don't want to hear it at all. However, I do disagree with infusing katha with background beats...

Re: MUSIC

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 08 Apr 2005

I suppose the youth nowadays find the actual katha boring (if they can understand it at all) so they listen to their rapper friends shouting in the background. We all seem to criticise current parbandhak committees for the way today's Gurdwaray are run, by "old guys who still believe in caste" etc etc etc...but I dread to think what is going to happen 20 years down the line, when we have a whole new batch of people, born and bred in the west (like myself I will add, before I get called an ignorant freshie). Some Gurdwaray will have kala style hip-hop "kirtan" going on...with the sangat guys doing a gangsta style walk when walking to give money to the "raagis".

Re: MUSIC

KHALISTANI · 08 Apr 2005

i listen to dhadi vaaran about 1984 with different backgournd music. its mainly becasue if i listen and i dont understand everything it gets really boring and i tend not to listen

Re: MUSIC

VIVEK · 08 Apr 2005

"KAHNDHE KACHE SUNDE KACHE KACHI AAKH VAKHAANEE" THOSE WHO UTTER FALSE HYMNS ARE FALSE; THOSE WHO HEAR THESE, ARE FALSE, AND THE AUTHOR OF THESE ARE ALSO FALSE SRI ANAND SAHIB JI

Re: MUSIC

etka · 08 Apr 2005

it does'nt matter, music is music, i dont' see how uc an define music as vile and evil. fudge packers.

Re: MUSIC

anonymous · 09 Apr 2005

vivek has hit the nail on the head, music is rubbish whats the point of lisnin to it, it dnt help ur sikhi it jus puts distractin rubbish in2 ur head

Re: MUSIC

sikh2b · 10 Apr 2005

wjkk wjkf. if this dr.dre style music helps to teach todays youth about their history is that a bad thing??? its using an effective medium to reach the youth thats all. if this touches the life of even one person and helps them along the true path is that a bad thing??? if you don't like it then fine thats due to your state of mind, however as we are all at different levels the use of other sources to spread the word may suit some people. if someone feels happy listening to it, closer to God perhaps how is that wrong?? just my opinion. bhul chuk marf karni ji. wjkk wjkf.

Re: MUSIC

gurpreet singh · 10 Apr 2005

whats the point of music?? music is a means to an end, it gets a point across. Why don't you do krtan without any intsruments and just listen to the words, once again the raag is a means to deliver the point. Whats wrong with putting a beat over a dhadi vaar if it gets more people to listen to it and propagates the message more? as long as there is no one yelling Bumbaclot or somthing like that in the background i think its a good way to spread sikhi in youth that are barely into sikhi yet. Look at it from their perspective, they get to learn their history and listen to beats they like at the same time. Mabye over time they will see it like you (a more expierience sikh) but before you become a more experienced and knowledgable sikh, you must first become a sikh, and this is a good way to bring people into sikhi

Re: MUSIC

nibor · 10 Apr 2005

Author: Pardeep Singh Bilga Date: 04-08-05 00:34 "Some Gurdwaray will have kala style hip-hop "kirtan" going on...with the sangat guys doing a gangsta style walk when walking to give money to the "raagis"." i go ther for sure..y not.. the point is to get baani accross ..

Re: MUSIC

nibor · 10 Apr 2005

""KAHNDHE KACHE SUNDE KACHE KACHI AAKH VAKHAANEE" THOSE WHO UTTER FALSE HYMNS ARE FALSE; THOSE WHO HEAR THESE, ARE FALSE, AND THE AUTHOR OF THESE ARE ALSO FALSE SRI ANAND SAHIB JI" thas talking abt kachhee baani my freind ..not music.. listening to beats without lyrics.. i seriously don get u guys..wts rong

Re: MUSIC

Dogma · 10 Apr 2005

"i dont' see how uc an define music as vile and evil" It's not that hard actually veerji. I think even you would agree that having Snoop Doggy Dogg blasting out profanities while someone is giving katha on Shaheeds is not at all appropriate. If you do not wish to see the difference between Gurbani Kirtan and Rap then that's fine. But I think that even you will agree that there is a time and place for the latter. Rap lyrics do not mix well with someone doing katha. Waheguru Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguru Jee Kee Fateh!

Re: MUSIC

etka · 10 Apr 2005

but anonymous, thats a big problem with youth living outside of punjab, they think they're tough, and more pure, because they deny themselves of some wordly ordains. I before visiting these websites never ever heard, of half the bad stuff, like music, movies, or talking to the opposite sex. During the height of sikh raj in punjab during the late 80s and 90s, my familly was very much into sikhi, and i met some very "up there" sikhs, but never heard of such things, untill now! whats the reason? simple gangster sikh attitude. If things like this is what defines a sikh, i guess ur version of sikhi is quite like the fanatical Islam offered by Sheiks. I don't see how a sikh cannot be wordly and at the same time be a abyaasi, guru ji never said leave the worldly elements, we have to live in them, we earn our bread through them, and such. Music is a change sometimes, someone may want to have a different type of fun, or just enjoy some usual stuff.

Re: MUSIC

anon kaur · 11 Apr 2005

I think the whole point is that whatever you listen to eventually affects the way you think. You listen to bani and your mind slowly becomes calmer and the words echo in your head. Same with music, you listen to music about drugs, sex, violence etc and that sticks in your head too. Nothing goes in one ear and out the other, everything that goes in through your ears has a lasting effect and impacts the way in which you think and act. So by listening to rap etc you're having a gradual detrimental effect on your mind whether you realise it or not.