Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Jatha Attacked Again!!!!

Jatha Attacked Again!!!!

Inderjit Singh · 28 Jul 2003

Guru Pyaro The Akhand Keertani Jatha is being attacked agian on what is supposed to be a gurmat message forum at sikhawareness.com. This time rather from members of the group the thread has been started by one of the administrators. You can view it at http://www.sikhawareness.com/sikhawareness/viewtopic.php?t=1512 as you can see they have asked 32 questions. The type which most of have grown accustomed to seeing. Is it not time that these questions where answered plainly and clearly perhaps on this site or the canada/usa/uk AKJ sites??? I see no point in replying on sikhawareness since it is apprarant that the site is anti-akj. They started this thread on the pretext that they are doing a similar thread for taksal and nihangs, however if you look at those threads you will see that they are completely different. http://www.sikhawareness.com/sikhawareness/viewtopic.php?t=1517 http://www.sikhawareness.com/sikhawareness/viewtopic.php?t=1480 So are we going to sit back and take this again or stand up and answer these questions publically on our own sites without the fear of the post being deleted/edited? I hope that the answers to these stupid questions will be put on a jatha site so that those like me with limited gian can point these individuals who persist in attacking the jatha towards the site.

Re: Jatha Attacked Again!!!!

sblk · 28 Jul 2003

I think "Singh132" has answered the questions quite well: http://www.sikhawareness.com/sikhawareness/viewtopic.php?t=1512&postdays=0&postorder=asc&start=30 1) The rehit is a code of conduct which has been passed down from the original amrit sinchaar in an oral fashion. Old rehitnamas, like the Bhai Desa Singh one state, (in the seventh stanza) “that rehit which the five utter, keep that steadfast in your mind” and later in the ninth stanza, “that is the first rehit, the one which the five Singhs said in the Paahul ceremony. The other different rehits which are spoken of, that is which I will go on to explain ”. Clearly the written rehit is secondary to the one which was orally given by the Punj Pyaaray. Now this Rehit suffered some dillution in the 19th century. But it's a fact that Malwa area had some areas where this rehit was preserved. It's not a coincidence that movements like the Namdhari movement, which originally had amazing rehit like Sarbloh, Gurmat Sangeet, etc. and was originally not a Gurudom, came out of Malwa. Deras like Baba Ajaipal Singh were known for strict rehit. So, the original Khalsa rehit was not lost, it was kept in some places. How can the AKJ substantiate that their rehit is right? The answer comes from historical documents as well as comparing to puraatan sources. Keskee is a rehit that is clear due to bhat vehees, which are the most historic and puraatan documents. In these vehis, the records of the original amrit sinchaar list "Kesgee" as a kakaar. Sarbloh is a puraatan rehit in the Khalsa and has support in documents like Bhai Daya Singh rehitnama and just the fact that lots of jatehbandees use it up to this day. I'm not sure what else is different about "AKJ" rehit that can't be found in other Gursikhs. 2)Although I don’t' speak for the AKJ, I can say that as far as I know from experience, any Singh/Kaur is considered a Gursikh if they have received Khanday Batay kee Paahul and keep Guru Saahib's rehit. 3)So to do keertan, one must be formally trained then? Those poor farmer-Sikhs and Sikh villagers must never have done keertan! But to answer your question, the Jatha came out of the Malwa area which preserved some of the most pure Khalsa traditions. The AKJ has had some of the most famous keertanees and paathees in the Panth. Bhai Darshan Singh jee Dilrubaa was known in the Panth as having the most giaan on raags. When once Dibagh Singh/Gulbagh Sigh went to a keertan darbaar, they were asked to do keertan after Bhai Darshan Singh. Bhai Darshan Singh did keertan in pure raag, and when the two other keertanees were called, they humbly declined and said that in the presence of a raagee like Bhai Darshan Singh, they were nothing. Bhai Gulbagh Singh/Dilbagh Singh are known as being foremost raag keertanees. Master Joginder Singh, Bhai SuraiN Singh jee, etc. were all considered the top paathees in the Panth at their time. They received Santhiya from other Singhs and family. Remember like I said, Malwa preserved these traditions very well, and the original Jatha was based out of Malwa. It's a fact that the Jatha is known for its paathees even today. Santhiya takes place on GurbaaNee as well as training on raag keertan at places like Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib www.tapoban.org . Both are essential. Gatka is also another thing that has been in the Jatha from the very start. Bhai Darshan Singh Dilrubaa, besides being a famous raag keertanee was also an amazing gatka player. Bhai Fauja Singh jee popularised gatkaa in the Jathaa again, and he actually went to Buddha Dal to learn. Jathedar Nihaal Singh jee Hariaan Velaa Valay praise Bhai Fauja Singh's gatkaa on an interview on Panthkhalsa.org. Singhs who learned from these Singhs and others go on to pass this knowledge down to other Singhs in the Jatha. 4) Answered Above. 5) Many AKJ Singhs do historical research. Bhai Joginder Singh jee Talwara is a foremost scholar in the Panth for his study of puraatan Saroops. Giani Gurdit Singh jee is also a well known scholar. Sikh itihaas is a concern for all Gursikhs, so by default it is a concern for Jatha Singhs as well I think. 6) Also answered above. There are Singhs in the Jatha who are experts in all the above things. I don't think any Jatha exists in which all members are super-men with knowledge off all these things, but experts exist in each. Ayurveda and medicine were the speciality of Singhs like Bhai Kataar Singh navan chand, and Dr. Surinder Singh jee. But I think you're missing the point of what AKJ is all about: it is a group of Singhs/Kaurs that get together to do KEERTAN. It is not a samparda or santdom. Singhs within this group possess all kinds of knowledge and pass it on to eachother, but these Singhs have come together for KEERTAN not anything else. Everything else is secondary. 7) Basic tunes: tunes that even children can use to sing keertan. Not everyone can become a skilled raag keertanee overnight and others don't have time to learn due to other responsibilities, so simple tunes are those, which are based on raag, and can be learnt by all without much problem. 8) The Jatha has been known as NirbaaN keertanee Jatha, Akhand Keertanee jatha. Bhai Sahib and puraatan Singhs used both these terms and both appear in Ranglay Sajjan. Akhand Keertanee Jatha appears on First line of 2nd chapter in Ranglay Sajjan. Later, some people began to call this jatha "Bhai Randheer Singh daa Jatha" because he was the Jathedar of this Jatha and was present at all smaagams. But this Jatha is not about any one person, or a santdom, so it is called AKJ and this name is most common. As for Bhai Sahibs mentioning Teja Singh; Teja Singh headed one of the most famous and well known organizations in the Panth i.e. Panch Khalsa Divaan. This organization included diamons like Bhai Kahn Singh and Sant Attar Singh Mastuana valay. It did amazing parchaar. Later Teja Singh lost his head and Bhai Sahib cut off all links. He was a diamond, but went bad. It's like Baba Santa Singh Nihung (who recent was re-admitted to Sikhi) when he was respected by all but then in 1984 betrayed the Panth by supporting Indra's murderous attacks. But what is to remember is that when the Panth broke with Teja Singh, so did Bhai Sahib. 9) I can't speak for the organization, but as far as I can tell, GurbaaNee and Naam are the message of the Gurus along with rehit. Same as any other panthic organization feels. 10) He has written that someone gave him this recipe and he burnt it. How did he believe in the "black arts"?? Ridhi Sidhis are things like becoming big, reading minds, levitation, teleportation, etc. Because they exist and are mentioned in SGGS, do Sikhs also believe in the "black arts"? 11) Puraatan rehitnamas and bhat vehees as mentioned before. Also the oral tradition. What the AKJ uses is what other Gursikhs use, because AKJ Gursikhs are same as others. Don’t take them to be separate from the Panth. 12) Bhai Sahib states that he was in confusion because during his amrit sinchaar a 3rd party, not the Punj whispered a mantar in his ear and he was shocked and confused. Later, he did ardaas for clarifcation on Naam and Guru Sahib himself manifested it. Very amazing story in his autobiography Naam driR is a concept that is lost in most of the Panth but preserved in some places. Prem Sumaarag Granth, an old puraatan rehitnama describes it in the 4th dhiaaai or section. The Bhai Mani Singh bhagat ratnaavalee descirbes how Guru Nanak did Naam DriR on two Sikhs when they were initiated. The Sau Sakhee aslo mentions how Guru Gobind Singh taught this method. The book "Jeevan Sant Baba Attar Singh jee" by Sant Teja Singh MA (not akj members obviously) has a section on "naam" which gives all historical details for naam DriR. And coincidentally, they not being AKJ also believed in it. 13) Why would you say AKJ doesn't think they were Sants? A lot of Singhs in the Jatha don't like the trend we see today of calling just anybody Sant, and most in the Panth don't. But within the Jatha, there have been Singhs like "Sant Juaalaa Singh jee" etc. There are Sants, but calling just anybody a Sant isn't appropriate. 14) The Gurus gave the Sikhs rehit and one Gurmat. At the first amrit sinchaar, rehit must have been ONE. So if everyone follows the rehit of Guru Sahib and reads baaNee, of course each Sikhs individual experience will be different. Some Singhs will love keertan more, others paath, others will be totally into shastars and others into history. There is room for difference in the Panth, as long as all follow the rehit of Guru Saahib and GurbaaNee. 15) Being a supporter of an insititution doesn't mean one has to support everything that institution does. IT means respect and not preaching against it regardless. Singhs in the Jatha believe that Keskee is a kakaar and meat eating is a bujjer kurehit. But they will work with the Akaal Takhat Sahib. But by not eating meat and wearing a keskee, where is the Jatha violating the order of akaal takhat? Most of the panth believes 5 baaNees are to be read in the morning, but if someone reads the 5, are they going agaisnt akaal takhat? No. Lots of jathebandees are "aligned" with the Akal Takhat yet choose to disagree on some issues i.e. Damdamee Taksaal, Jawadee Taksal, etc. AKJ isn't much different. 16) This question has been answered above. Singhs in Jatha share this stance with a lot of the Panth including Damdami Taksal. Singhs within jatha are well versed in history, but fact remains that the rehit followed is more puraatan and passed down through history. They'd need to search history if this rehit was ever lost in the Jatha, but it hasn't, so they don't need to wonder if meat is alright or not. It's a fact supported by the rehit given at amrit sinchaars and by many many other gursikh organizations. 17) The Original Maryada said "kuthaa" couldn't be eaten. The footnote saying it's muslim meat is a later addition. This is a historical truth. Kuthaa is any meat or animal which has been slaughtered, no puraatan source will say it has anything to do with muslims. But this is a redundant question. If you have questions, go to www.tapoban.org literature section and read on meat. Like I said, AKJ disagrees with meat eating, as do many other Sikh organzations. But disagreeing with the official stance doesn't make one rebellious or apart from the Akal Takhat. IN a family, people can disagree but still have respect and love. 18/19) Please see the section on Naam in Sant Teja Singh jee's book mentioned above. The Mastuana Jatha is a separate Jatha from AKJ and well respected. Those Singhs in their book have written on Naam DriR and given historical proof for it that I listed above. Please see the book for details or look above for answer. 20) Akal Takhat Sahib says that a Sikh may or may not read raagmala as there is controversy on this issue. Look it up in the rehit marayada. Only stipulation is that no beeRh be printed without raagmala and this is followed by AKJ. Singhs who came from West Punjab can testify that in akhand paaths in that area ragmala was never read. Read an article on raagmala for more information on who supports ragmala and who doesn't. AKJ are not the only ones out there. Historians like Piara Singh Padam and Harjinder Singh Dilgeer also don’t support Raagmala. So AKJ is not in any violation here. 21) Historical proof was provided from the Bhai DAYA Singh rehitnama not Desa Singh for sarbloh. That's clear proof there. Other groups like Damdamee Taksaal and Nihungs also follow sarbloh. If sarbloh isn't a rehit, then why must amrit sinchaars be done using sarbloh utensils only? Isn't this proof in of itself? Who can do an amrit sinchaar in plastic bucket? No one. Only sarbloh. 22) Old puraatan langars all made food in sarbloh. Look at darbaar Saahib or Hazoor Saahib: big sarbloh cauldrons are still there today. If the rehit of sarbloh is not followed, does this mean it's not a rehit? Many in the Panth believed women didn't need to wear kachheras until it was formally resolved in 1915, when women didn't wear kachheras, did this at the time mean that it was not part of rehit? Sarblohi Singhs will eat from a langar that is prepared in Sarbloh made by Gursikhs, as is the puraatan rehit. If langar is not prepared according to maryada, then they will not eat it. Is this so objectionable? Even the langar in Darbaar Sahib has a sign outside saying only amritdhaarees may prepare food there. If proper langar maryada is follwed, any Singh and any ordinary person can eat there. 23) Please quote your sources i.e. lines, etc. Lots of historical documents have been tampered with. And did Guru Nanak eat from the Cannibal before he became a Sikh or after? Guru Sahib initiated so many people into Sikhi with Gurmantra. I havn't heard of this story quite frakly, but did Guru Nanak eat Kauda's food when Kauda was about to cook Mardana or did he eat the food after Kauda fell at Guru Sahib's feet and became a Sikh? If bibek wasn't important, what was wrong in eating the food of Malik Bhago? It was nutritionally better food than Bhai Lalo's. But no. Guru Sahib chose to eat from a Sikh. This shows that the person cooking food and the money with which it was purchased do have an effect. 24) I mentioned puraatan raagees earlier. Lots of People in Jatha are trained in raag i.e. Bhai Mehar Singh, Bhai manmohan Singh, etc. Ask them about their GharaaaNaas, etc. I wouldn't know. Jatha was a group of Gursikhs who lived simple lives as householders who got together and did keertan. They were not trained raagees. So they did simple tunes. Is it a fact that singing shabads in "Jotteeaa(n)" is a Sikh tradition? It's done in all Gurdvaras. When these Shabads are sung, are they sung in pukka raags? No they aren't. It's an instrument free singing that's done by all. What's wrong with this? It's best if raag is done, but if its not known, then it has been a tradition to just sing keertan. I agree though, raag is essential. I also disagree with dhunee and singing of external lines in a shabad. Many Singhs in Jatha also disagreed with this practice i.e. Dr. Surinder Singh jee, Pr. Gurmukh Singh jee. Some Singhs in the Jatha don't do dhunee and it was not around in times of Bhai Sahib Randheer Singh. 25) Don't warp what was said. It said Khalsa Panth has worked towards getting rid of the grip. Since 1978 how many hundred thousands Sikhs died fighting the Indian Goverenment oppressions? Can you count them? Thousands of Jatha Singhs also died in this fight. The whole Panth fought to free the nation and does so even today. Babbar Khalsa was originally a defence force set up to protect Sikhs from the likes of Narakdhaarees. The founders were indeed members of the Jatha but it is a separate organization. I personally am proud that Jatha Singhs took a stand and created that organzation, but it has no official link the AKJ. 26) I'm not going to even dignify this warping of words. How are all Sikhs by default members of AKJ? Yes, this is true, any Sikh who follows rehit is respected by AKJ. What contributions have been made by AKJ? The revival of keertan among the masses has been credited to this Jatha by the likes of Prof. Of Sikhism Bhai Kapoor Singh in the July 1978 Sikh Review. Keskee revival also comes from the Jatha. Sarbloh revival too. Shaheeds like Bhai Fauja Singh and Bhai Mengha Singh (1st shaheed of June 1984) all are the pride of the Panth. But AKJ is a member of the Panth so please don't try to separate the two with your words. 27) Keskee is a rehit. Many amritdhaaree women who don't wear it don't know about it being a rehit. Many Punj Pyaaray don't tell them to wear keskee. With education perhaps this will change over time. But if women don't wear keskee, then it doesn't mean that it's ok or rehit not to wear it. Just means more education is needed. 28) This question is malicious. The punj Pyaaray chosen for amrit sinchaar must meet highest level of Khalsa Rehit standards. Obviously someone who does something that violates rehit will not be chosen. The chosen person must be a lover of Naam and BaaNee. If someone has a different view on kakaars, or eats meat, why would they want to do punj pyaaray seva at an amrit sinchaar organized by the Jatha? Would Taksaal allow a meat eater to do this seva? There are different views on rehit in the Panth today. I think Jatha's is most historically accurate. But in Jatha amrit sinchaars, that puraatan rehit will be taught, and if someone does not follow it, they will not do this seva of Punj Pyaaray. How now does this go against the Akaal Takhat? If it does, then other jathebandees like Takaal are also to blame and just as guilty as is most of the Panth. 29) Already answered. Raags are best, but tradition of simple tunes is in panth since the start. Hence the tradition of Chaunkees and JoTeean shabads. Same with Parbhaat Fayrees. At Darbaar Sahib, at certain times in the day, the Sangat go in the parkaram and sing shabads together in simple tunes or JoTees. This is a puraatan maryada and at certain times of the day it happens. I've seen this happen at Bangla Sahib, Patna Sahib and other Gurdvaras too. This maryada has carried on from puraatan times. Is this wrong too? At nagar keertans, does sangat sing together in Pukka raag or simple tunes? Are nagar keertans a puraatan phenomenon? Yes. Was this wrong too? Don’t' get me wrong, Raag is BEST. But simple tunes are not wrong either. 30) Done. 31) Question 31 doesn't have a single question mark in it. How is it a question? Reading from an "inccorect" beeR: come on! If table of contents are there, or publisher is there, is it also "incorrect" original sarrop didn’t' have publisher on it! Just because AKJ doesn't believe in raagmala, if raagmala isn't present, it doesn't make the saroop not Guru Saahib, it IS. Ragmala has just been added later. 32) Is the hukumana of Guru Hargobind Sahib which forbids meat wrong? Or is Kabeer Jee's salok "Kabeer, Bhaang Machulee Suraapaan…" wrong? Or are these rehitnamas wrong? These rehitnamas are adultered. Some say that a Sikh should bow to the Sun at sunrise, etc. Is this right? Who should we believe? Guru Sahib or adultered rehitnamas? Please tell me where in Dasam Guru Granth is says Jhatkaa should be done by Sikhs. Give me the line. Please give scriptural quotes in future. You've mentioned Dasam Granth but given no quotes. Hope this helps you answer your questions on AKJ. I'm not a spokesperson, but with Guru Sahib's kirpaa I've tried to answer your questions. May I add though, your questions, in some spots, didn't seem to be asked out of curiosity, but more out of a desire to be malicious. Maybe I'm wrong.

Re: Jatha Attacked Again!!!!

SikhSangat.com · 28 Jul 2003

check out www.sikhsangat.com they questions have already been replied to

Re: Jatha Attacked Again!!!!

N30 S!NGH · 29 Jul 2003

To the person above who claim that sikhawareness.com is anti-akj site . That claim is complete bullocks. First thing first. That thread wasnt started by admin but it was supported by mods and admin as you can guys see we want to know the truth instead of mud throwing games. So we edited some of the post as they were an opnion/attack instead of historcial evidence. Now part of being us anti-akj. Thats a complete lie. We dont belong to the jatha but belong to truth and truth only. All we tryin to do is to get truth out of these distorted sikh-history that mainstream sikhism follow. So please post only if you like to debate intellectually. No Slandering/opnions are allowed!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: Jatha Attacked Again!!!!

kookar · 29 Jul 2003

whatever the problem was i hope it gets resolved. but i myself have noticed one thing about the akj mods, in debates they wont always allow your post to come through even when it is within the guidelines, no slander no rude comments or personal attacks. it still wont make the post if the person u dont agree with says summit that tows their line of thought the topic usually ends there thus it appears a certain thoughtline has the final say. its quiet disheartening really considering many of us think its a forum where we can air our views that concern us. but i respect tapoban admins immensly for allowing people tyo talk more openly here with opposing views as long as we are within the restrictions of not swearing and attacking people. i rally really wish the mods on akj wuld allow more freedom on 2 sides of an argument than letting it carry on that way until it reaches a few posts then only allow certain posts through which support something only they agree with. guru rakha :-) peace and love to all

Re: Jatha Attacked Again!!!!

Singh · 29 Jul 2003

this threads have bene started on Sikhawareness to find out the truth why are we looking for the truth in gorups - Nihangs-akj,taksal ertc isn't all the truth in Guru Granth Sahib ji????????/ all this 'prove it' rubbish who cares naam jaap, read bani , do seva keep simple everythign else takes us away from the path

Re: Jatha Attacked Again!!!!

Guru Ka Sikh · 29 Jul 2003

[quote]The Akhand Keertani Jatha is being attacked agian on what is supposed to be a gurmat message forum at sikhawareness.com. This time rather from members of the group the thread has been started by one of the administrators. [/quote] Tell them that "Nihang" thread is also started by administrator as well. Where is he coming from? [quote]You can view it at http://www.sikhawareness.com/sikhawareness/viewtopic.php?t=1512 as you can see they have asked 32 questions. The type which most of have grown accustomed to seeing. Is it not time that these questions where answered plainly and clearly perhaps on this site or the canada/usa/uk AKJ sites??? [/quote] Yes, and not they but one of our site's members and not with hostility but to clarify them. [quote]I see no point in replying on sikhawareness since it is apprarant that the site is anti-akj. [/quote] Yes, if that's the case then we are Anti nihangs, Anti Namdhari, Anti Nirmala, Anti-Khalistan, Anti-Akj. Are we leaving under Taliban or Hitler? Where no one is allowed to question but follow? These members need to grow up. I know A.K.J has so many chardi Kala singhs and they will respond to this thread so members don't worry about these teen agers insecurity. [quote]They started this thread on the pretext that they are doing a similar thread for taksal and nihangs, however if you look at those threads you will see that they are completely different. [/quote] How is it different? There is full thread for him in which Sukhbit and Bikramjit has expressed their views and we have them open for sadh sangat then how can they be different? [quote]http://www.sikhawareness.com/sikhawareness/viewtopic.php?t=1517 http://www.sikhawareness.com/sikhawareness/viewtopic.php?t=1480 So are we going to sit back and take this again or stand up and answer these questions publically on our own sites without the fear of the post being deleted/edited? [/quote] Yes, this is what we want just dont sit back but come out and show us the truth but we don't expect anything from these people because we have requested intelligent members of A.K.J to participate in this thread to enlighten us. [quote]I hope that the answers to these stupid questions will be put on a jatha site so that those like me with limited gian can point these individuals who persist in attacking the jatha towards the site [/quote] Grow up! Questions are not attacks. We even questions our father and its Jatha... If we are not sure for something then what's wrong in questions and asking for anwsers. I think we should start calling Bhai Ghaniya ji Anti-Gurus as well because he served water to soldiers of muslims when sikhs were fighting against them. They need to read our sikh-history with open mind