Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Reflection on Nagar Kirtans in UK

Reflection on Nagar Kirtans in UK

Manvir Singh · 04 Apr 2005

Gurmat Reflection of Southall Nagar Kirtan by Manvir Singh Khalsa Origin Nagar Kirtans originate from ‘Parbaat Pheris’ (Parbaat literally means ‘early morning,’ and Pheri means ‘going around’). The Parbaat Pheri would consist of a Gursikh carrying a vaaja (harmonium) tied to themselves, some people would carry chhainey (bells), and one person would carry a dholki. Early in the morning the group of Gursikhs would walk around the village or city singing shabads and people would join them as they walked past their homes. Leading the jatha (group) would be the people leading the shabad singing and a Gursikh carrying a Nishan Sahib. The processions gave opportunity for people to enjoy the bliss of singing the Lord’s Praises, an opportunity to distribute relevant and useful Gurmat literature to the public and also share a positive image of the Guru's Khalsa. In recent history we have started doing processions which include Guru Maharaaj's Sawaari (without Prakaash) and also Panj Pyaare leading the procession. Benefit of Traditional Nagar Kirtan The traditional Nagar Kirtans or Parbaat Pheris inspired people to sing Gurbaani and gave them opportunity to distribute educational material in regards to Gurmat. Seeing Chardikala Gursikhs in public singing Kirtan provided the public and youngsters with positive role models and good impressions of what and who Sikhs are. The whole event would have a community spirit, gathering the community together and inspiring others to sing and understand Gurbaani. Servant Nanak begs for the dust of the feet of that GurSikh, who himself chants the Naam, and inspires others to chant it. ||2|| (Ang 306, SGGS) Come, O beloved Sikhs of the True Guru, and sing the True Word of His Baani. (Ang 920, SGGS) Today’s Nagar Kirtans What do we learn or take away from Nagar Kirtans organised nowadays? We end up eating loads of delicious food, like pakorae, jalebian, ladoo, sholay bhatoorae and chips etc. It seems there is so much nice food and so many people wanting to distribute it to the Sangat that we end up squeezing as much food as possible into our stomachs. Looking around Southall Nagar Kirtan, I saw large and small Nishan Sahibs everywhere and anywhere. Young children, teenagers and older youngsters were holding Nishan Sahibs and having a laugh with their mates. I thought to myself, “Do they know the value of the Nishan Sahib?’ “How is it that we have made devalued our Nishan Sahib so much that it is found everywhere and anywhere and being treated with little or no reverence or respect?” When the Nagar Kirtan had finished and the road blocks were lifted, youngsters born in Sikh families had decorated their cars with Khandas. Driving up and down the Broadway and Kings Street boys and girls were flirting and making a show and display of themselves. The Gursikhs I was with and myself were disarrayed with how the Guru’s Khanda, bestowed upon us by the Sixth Nanak had been made into a fashion accessory which is commercialised by shopkeepers at Vaisakhi time. How productive are today’s Nagar Kirtans in educating, promoting and highlighting Gurmat Last Sunday’s Southall Nagar Kirtan seemed very minimal in its effect in promoting and educating youngsters and the public about Gurmat. It should be mentioned that were children on floats singing Gurbaani and also children accompanying their parents who were singing along with shabads being sung. However, unfortunately they were a minority. The large number of people were talking amongst themselves, looking for the nearest place to get some nice food or busy looking out to see for people they knew in the crowd. I felt shame and disgust in seeing people dancing, and stupidly waving their arms (similar postures to what Bhangra artists do when singing and dancing to songs) to Dharmic (religious) songs about Guru Gobind Singh Ji and the Khalsa. The float in concern was the Desi Radio float. There is nothing wrong or objectionable about playing Dharmic songs in the Nagar Kirtan procession. However, Dharmic songs are played for people to be educated, inspired and for them to act upon the message in the lyrics. Songs singing about Guru Gobind Singh Ji and the Khalsa are not designed to dance to but to think and act upon. Not being able to tolerate the disrespect of the dancers and the Desi Radio’s float and dancers bringing down the Gurmat tone of the Nagar Kirtan, I approached the clean-shaven dancers and two Singhs (who are Kirtani) who were standing with them. They justified themselves that is part of Vaisakhi culture, and that we are celebrating “kushi” (happiness) of the Khalsa. Myself and two other Gursikhs politely told them that the Nagar Kirtan which is being led the Panj Pyaare and Guru Granth Sahib Ji is a religious event and not cultural event. There is a time and place for doing Bhangra to songs. And that Guru’s Kushi is not in dancing but in taking positive steps in becoming better Sikhs and following the Guru’s Hukam. They persisted to justify themselves by arguing that they had danced in the Nagar Kirtan procession for six years running and no-one ever has stopped them before. This highlights the question of what are the Parbandhaks and organiser doing to maintain Gurmat in the Nagar Kirtan procession and what impression are these types of things setting to our youngsters? Generally the whole atmosphere of the Nagar Kirtan (like in other towns and cities) was of a street carnival. Conclusion of Southall Nagar Kirtan & today’s Nagar Kirtans in general To my experience and understanding, last Sunday’s Southall Nagar Kirtan had no or very little positive effect on youngsters. No one learn anything about Guru Ji, about the Khalsa, about Rehat (Sikh way of life & discipline) or about Gurbaani. There was no person or no thing in the Nagar Kirtan procession or the whole day event which inspiring. Thought to take away We are celebrating 306 years of the Khalsa Panth. We should ask ourselves what do we learn from Vaisakhi of 1699 and the establishment of the Khalsa Panth? How do we improve ourselves, and what steps do we take to change and adjust our lives to become closer to Guru Ji and receiving the True Kushee (happiness) of Guru Gobind Singh Ji. bhul chuk maaf karnee ji

Re: Reflection on Nagar Kirtans in UK

sj · 04 Apr 2005

i totally agree with you

Re: Reflection on Nagar Kirtans in UK

...... · 04 Apr 2005

I think their should be a meeting about this with the guruduare who organise it, because I have heard that after the nagar keertan in the night people on the broadway drink and do soo much anti gurmat things, im sure some of them still probably havent gone home after the nagar keertan and still have their khande ramaals etc on display. Such a shame, i think the southall nagar keertan should be cancelled next year and explain to the sangath that due to soo much beaadbi happening at our nagar keertan we have decided to cancel it, and then maybe the people who mess it up will wake up at how much disrespect they have bought to our dharam. just an idea

Re: Reflection on Nagar Kirtans in UK

Manvir Singh · 04 Apr 2005

Would be nice if people did the traditional Parbaat Pheris like Bhai Randhir Singh ji used to do. Having Maharaaj's Sawaari in Nagar Kirtan = beadbee of Guru Sahib.... people don't cover their heads, its chaotic and its not a spiritual environment. Ideal to have One Gursikh with a huge Nishan Sahib - Jatha of Kirtans (Vaaja, Dholki, Chhenai etc) leading the procession... no-one else flying some Nishan Sahibs etc (which = beadbee and devaluing nishan sahib)... sing shabads and then stop for refreshments at certain stops or just at the Gurdwaras on the journey. those are my vichaar - don't know whether other people will think i am killing the spirit of Vaisakhi or something. But the purpose is to sing Gurbaani or to inspire others to sing Gurbaani and also educate public on Gurmat through physical impressions and literature. bhul chuk maaf

Re: Reflection on Nagar Kirtans in UK

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 06 Apr 2005

Veer Manvir Singh ji- I was going to say you've hit the nail on the head- but NO - you've actually hit several nails on their heads...very well written and I couldn't agree with you more. Having grown up in the Midlands (UK) and been to various nagar kirtans (or even "jaloos" as they used to be called!- there is thankfully ONE improvement there as nowadays, we seem to at least have the respect to use a decent name) I found that NEVER was there any attempt made by the organisers to even TRY to educate the youth (even the elders needed educating, in the foundry-pub-home-foundry-pub-home culture of comrade clean shaven uncles). I recall on one particular nagar kirtan, some handouts/leaflets were given to people, but these were badly translated into english and littered with spelling mistakes etc- and that was only noticed by the people who actually bothered to read them, the others I think just used them as tissues to wipe the samosa grease off their fingers and threw them on the street. I've never been to the Southall one, but I saw it featured on a BBC documentary about SIKHS a couple of years ago. It had interviews with some youngsters (all clean shaven boys, girls with hair cut/highlighted etc etc) one of the questions the gora reporter asked "what is the significance of this event for you?" - the reply was from a girl who didn't even LOOK like a Sikh, standing with her giggling friends guzzling cans of Coke "well, I fink we shud remember our history an all dat and where we come from innit" Very good explanation of the importance of Vaisakhi (sarcasm on). Today's youth are too ashamed of the Khalsa roop, so they prefer representation from silly excuses for Sikhs. My local Gurdwara is having it's annual nagar kirtan this weekend...probably be the same old story- ganju lads in convertible BMW's, blasting the music (non-religious of course, probably their new-found guru- 50 pence is he called??) whilst waving mini nishan sahibs If I have said anything against GURMAT, then please forgive me with Guru Sahib's kirpa. If I have offended a manmukh, may Waheguru bless me to do so again and again and again....

Re: Reflection on Nagar Kirtans in UK

. · 06 Apr 2005

no offence intended but instead of condemning the youth perhaps we should do our bit and help them get into sikhi.

Re: Reflection on Nagar Kirtans in UK

Gatka beginner · 07 Apr 2005

Are the following acceptable: 1. Performing Gatka during a Nagar Kirtan? 2. Having a Gatka demonstration; after the Nagar Kirtan; say for instance at a sports field. Just Gatka; no singing, dancing, etc. GurFateh

Re: Reflection on Nagar Kirtans in UK

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 07 Apr 2005

waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Sadly we had the same type of this...in Kuala Lumpur Malaysia some time ago.....what a complete waste of time and Kaumi energy/resources...putting our Sacha patshah in a helicopter used by "many others"...and bragging about it like a kid takinng a ride for the first..time...forgetting that our Sacha patshah rides the Galaxies and Warp Speed dark holes !!! The money saved could have been used for running/subsidising "gurbani classes"..a much better use...especially now that money is fast running out !!! and "donations" are being solicited.. Strictly my own humble opinion. Jarnail Singh

Re: Reflection on Nagar Kirtans in UK

jyoti kaur dhillon · 07 Apr 2005

Pardeep Singh Bilga Although I agree to many things that you have written. That I must say you have put your point across excellently. However i am deeply offended by the way you put a particular comment that you wrote; below, >>>>>If I have offended a manmukh, may Waheguru bless me to do so again and again and again....<<<<< As a Manmukh learning to be a Gursikh (manmukh as i have yet not taken amrit) I was deeply insulted that a true gursikh could say such a thing, as i am sure you may have been a manmukh at one stage of your life am i right? Surely we should be trying to get our manmukh's brother and sisters to see the true essence of guru ji rather than slating or critising them. People always say the truth hurts. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ke Fateh

Re: Reflection on Nagar Kirtans in UK

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 08 Apr 2005

Bhainji jyoti kaur dhillon ji, I am sorry if I offended you...I could probably have put my point across in a better way. What I wanted to say was, I do not want to offend Guru Granth Sahib Ji or the Gursikh way of life, but offence is something we have to learn to accept if it is in the relevant context...i.e. some veers who come to do katha at a Gurdwara are too afraid to mention what a bad habit drinking alcohol is... because they know that a large proportion of the sangat are heavy drinkers...some stage secretaries will harp on about this that and the other, but when it comes to patitpuna, they will not even utter a word, because there are loads of monay in the sangat...so we need to offend sometimes to get the Sikhi message across. Also, bhainji I am not a "true Gursikh" and not even a Gursikh by any means- I still haven't amrit, but am working towards it with Guru Sahib's kirpa...hopefully I baaja(n) wala will accept me as his son before I am 30. Bhul chuk maaf karni

Re: Reflection on Nagar Kirtans in UK

Rocky · 08 Apr 2005

Pardeep Singh Veerji, There's no better time than now to take Amrit. Vasakhi is around the corner and there are Amrit Sanchars taking place all over.

Re: Reflection on Nagar Kirtans in UK

anon · 08 Apr 2005

pardeep singh, u r completely right by saying >>>>>If I have offended a manmukh, may Waheguru bless me to do so again and again and again....<<<<< and if a manmukh like myself would argue against tht it would just be showing ego because who are we as manmukhs to argue against anybody, us manmukhs should keep our opinions to ourselves if we differ in opinion vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh

Re: Reflection on Nagar Kirtans in UK

Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 08 Apr 2005

The writer has written eloquently and highlighted very sensitive issues as well as sensitivities hurt by hooligan behaviours,associated with Vesakhi celeberation. I accept that instead of critisizing the misled youth we should influence them to come into the fold of Sikhi.But unless we highlight the mistakes,people will not know the differencei.e.what is right and wrong-because for too long our leadership has allowed these things to creep into our religion. Like someone said that they had done it for the last six years-perhaps there should be groups of briefed Sikh youth in the nager Kirtan going around ensuring people doing wrong were told they were doing wrong. There should also be a strong and repeated anouncem,ent prior to the start of the nager kirtan to what was accepted and what was not.This should be repeated every 15 minutes to remind the sangataan. In Malaysia,it seems to be a new trend starting; where parties are organised in the name of Vesakhi.I recall many years back this same trend started on the island of Penang,Malaysia. I wrote strongly against this in the local Punjabi newspaper,and I know the committee responsible for this was pulled up-as one of the members of this commiittee happend to be a person I know. I was on holidays there at the time-the person turned up at the hotel I was staying and apoligised-that is how I came to know the result of my write up.never again has that organisation organised any such party. But lately the trend seems to be from Kuala Lumpur.The issue Giani Jarnail Singh Ji refers to was another anti gurmat event.Apart from the helocopter show of the Guru swaree,the person on the main stage was a MONA SIKH-what significance of Guru Khalsa can this failed "Sikh" doctor Jaspal S dispense to the non Sikh and the Sikh youth?His chinese type accent was another issue at such a major Sikh occassion!!! I just wondered after seeing the video, what a CON man: he is telling people about Vesakhi!!!!!While there is NOT a single sign of SIKHI ON HIM!!! I understand he is the chairman of the committee organnsing the main Vesakhi even in Malaysia again!!!!! This is a real CON with Sikhs,and the message of Guru Gobind Singh JI. Gurcharan SINGH Kulim

Re: Reflection on Nagar Kirtans in UK

Manvir Singh · 09 Apr 2005

Waheguroo! Gurcharan Singh Bhaji - very good points. Nice to know that your letter had a positive effect. Lets pray that the Panth remains in Chardikala and lets do our small step in the community to make people aware of the problems and help with solutions. Benti is that we also share solutions in this thread. Solutions which daas can think of are: 1/ Asking Parbandhak Committees for 10 minutes (or more if you can squeeze it in) on Gurpurbs (like Vaisakhi) to inspire youngsters in English with explaining Sikh history and Gurbaani (something which the youth sangat may not have been exposed to). 2/ Distributing leaflets (with support of Gurdwaras (financially and morally)) on why we celebrate vaisakhi, the significance and where are we today (in regards to following Guru's Hukam and getting Guru Ji's kushee). - this was done four years ago at Southall, spurred by the effort of Bhaji Jugraj Singh Ji. any more practical solutions or steps which we can all try to take to tackle these problems? please share...

Re: Reflection on Nagar Kirtans in UK

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 10 Apr 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. An "explanation" appeared on the "most famous".... "Gurmat Zone" that purpots to TEACH our Youngsters about Sikhi...it says: The Picture of the Vasakhi Event shows a Sikh in Full Dastaar Dharra/a second person with Dastaar but TRIMMED Beard/and the Third is a COMPLETE MONA in full "glory"...and THIS REPRESENTS the EXACT SITUATION on the Ground in malaysia....so it is REALITY....What a wonderful and GURMAT type of explanation...precisely the WAY to GET NUMBERS....IF you Dont criticise Alcohol consumers..the DRINKERS will JOIN YOU, IF you dont criticise Beard trimmers....they will join you, if you dont criticise Naii Patrons...the SIR GUMS will join You....if you dont criticise Drug Abusers..they will join YOU...NEED i elaborate how the NUMBERS keep Getting BIGGER as you go along...and this is misinterpreted as Sikhi PYAAR, SIKHI "parchaar".."NOT PUSHING" these sirgums away ( into waiting Christian arms !!)..ON the Other hand IF you CRITICISE all these WEAKNESSES....these people will DESERT you and the KHALSA JI will be left with a FEW ....Others travelling along this same Path to get NUMBERS..advocate Special Eagle Camps and Samagams/Sadh 'Sangats' where Males and Females of all ages HUG each other real tight all over ( Sikhi PYaar...Gurmukhi Pyaar )...sadly this path is a DOWNHILL ONE....definitely NOT what Guru Ji intended for SIKHI which aims for the CLOUDS....and at the VERY APEX of a mountain there are always VERY FEW...while the FOOT of the Pyramid (base) will have the GREATEST of NUMBERS...we seem to be intent on Making PYRAMIDS with BASES up and Down ( no APEX)..because thats the onoly way we can "accommodate" all those great numbers we so desire. Gurcharan Singh Kulim has NEVER been one to mince words..as a result he gets "censored"/removed/barred/banned...in the same boat as yours truly..here who is often branded misfit/has been/lost in the woods old man..one man's opinion etc...but it pays in many ways than one to be on the Guru's Dharra. WHY do I persevere ?? because i know the real reality.... when we "accept" apostates ( no other religion does this..and publicly at thta )...we promote apostacy. When children approach me and tell me their school head is INSISTING why they CANNOT wear a CAP on Sports day...when EVERY OTHER SIKH wears one willingly...it is very hard to convince him/her that "every other Sikh..the MONA KIND " is NOT really a SIKH and he /she is NOT following what our Maryada says...how many sikh children have been 'forced" by peer pressure to remove their karras durign school time as "jewellery" which is banned in certain schools ?? The MONAS happily remove the karra for good...but to a Keshadharee this is impossible ?? but then how to argue that your religion says NO..while the next "sikh" didnt object at all..are we "attracting" Keshdharees or forcing them to JOIN the MONAS as they are more in numbers ?? A few keshadhrees i know have to carry a letter from someone in Sikh Religious AUthority to wear the karra in school as this is listed as jewellery... this is REALITY which our leaders ignore in their quest for NUMBERS..so they can Boast we have the NUMBERS MAN !!! Now YOU ALL listen to me and READ what I write....as I am the MODERATOR and you are just a "member" This type of Sikhi Pyaar is mubarak to them...may the Force of Numbers be with them. Jarnail Singh

Re: Reflection on Nagar Kirtans in UK

sikh · 10 Apr 2005

great post Manvir Singh....... today especially in southall the nagar kirtan and al other important days within the sikhi calendar are used as a fundraising tool, to further fill the gurdwara coffers...... the management dont give a toss about eduacting and setting a good example how could they, only a rehitvale gursikh can do this and nobody in the managementis of this standard........ i personally dont go to, i find it upsetting and very frustrating at the show which is put on by people. who really have no idea as to what is happening.

Re: Reflection on Nagar Kirtans in UK

sunu decuta · 10 Apr 2005

i think we (or at least u sikhs) should do what ever is practically possible to promote the beauty of this young and all accepting faith. but i agree with the jist here that if the faith is to have the right people living the philosphy then they should also live, breath and practice the faith in the dialy business..... even if the business is making money - making it honestly......that is they should also have the true image of Sikhi - other wise how are people like myself to follow it if there are so many hypocritics at the top. i have noticed as a new zealander that Often the Sikhs are let down by their own people......... forgive me if as an outsider i make this judgement. How ever these leaders are a part of a bigger unit; and as such these commitees have members that vote them in.... they are good at selling their views to this sheep (no pun to NZ) and the so call sangaat votes them in. This openly highlights a massive educational opportunity to the faith.......YOU HAVE NOT GOT ONE OR YOU DO NOT CONSISTENTLY APPLY IT. I rest my case on Sikhism; a faith I have fallen in love with as a result of reading the life story of one of the greatest men every to be one this planet. His name was Nanak. I cried my guts when i read the Jap ji and other facts about this wonderfully enlightened person. Well over to you guys. My made my opinions.

Re: Reflection on Nagar Kirtans in UK

whatever · 11 Apr 2005

So much chit chat with little action - gurdwaras have failed the community - trying to build great big building that will one day become unaffordable to run as the sangat whithers away - at prime time on a wekk day in the sangat there may be 10 youngsters and the rest will be OAPs whose kids have dropped them off their early morning to get them (parents) out of their (Kids) hair!!!!! I bet you all one day will come when you will see a For Sale sign posted on a SIkh Temple or even advertised on the web......... :-( In the mean time we have other youth stuck in: AKJ DDTS SGPC Sri Desmesh Pitha once put sweet rice on the ground and had hungry dogs released to feed on the rice - instead these dogs tore each other apart as they could not contemplate on the thought of sharing the rice - not once piece of rice was eaten by the dogs. Thats the state of Sikhs today. If the hunger for power and monopoly for the way to God does not eat us up then the western way of life will do that. Faiths and movements can survive external threats however when a threat from inside rears its head then there is no chance of survival