Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Taking a Human Life

Taking a Human Life

BirRaas Singh · 04 Apr 2005

A question which has been on my mind for several months now is what is the Gurmat stance on taking a human life? If a person killed/murdered another human accidentally or on purpose, is this seen as sinful in Sikhi? - Is it right to take another human life? - If so, in what situations is it viable? - In what situations is taking a human life sinful? - If you take another human life, what are the possible "punishments" according to Gurmat.

Re: Taking a Human Life

yo mama · 04 Apr 2005

-what if you feel enjoyment at the fact that you have taken a life? -what if you feel a spiritual experience at the taking of another life? -what if you develop a hunger to kill and it becomes a part of your jeevan? -what if you enjoy doing it for fun?

Re: Taking a Human Life

BirRaas Singh · 05 Apr 2005

Anyone?

Re: Taking a Human Life

KHALISTANI · 05 Apr 2005

u can kill someone if your life or more importantly your faith is in danger. guru ji said that when all other means have failed it is righteous to draw the sword. if ure attack by like 5 random guys sure if u have to kill one of them or hurt them then its okay. just randomly killing somone is not. killing someone to stop oppresoin and tyrany is okay. and it would be worse if u didnt do soemthing to stop it. but i guess if your going to kill someone like if they attack u and ure gonna die or wat not chatka would be best or atleast some way in which they did not feel any pain. because it would be bad to kill somone slowly and painfully. but really without a reason to kill its a sin. u cant just find some random person and kill them. like some crazied serial killer. Bhull chuk mauff WJKK WJKF

Re: Taking a Human Life

BirRaas Singh · 07 Apr 2005

Thank you for your reply Khalistani veer, it has raised a few more questions in my mind, i would be greatful if the sangat could give their viewpoint. -When can you make the judgement that "all means have failed", what is the process of elimination before you decide to raise the sword? -How did the Gurus deal with oppressive leaders such as Babbar and Aurenzeb? - If you kill someone in revenge is it still a sin, or is it falling victim to krodh?

Re: Taking a Human Life

BirRaas Singh · 09 Apr 2005

anyone?

Re: Taking a Human Life

singh · 11 Apr 2005

is it alright to use ur sri sahib in a one on one fight. Like say if someone is really bothering me at school and he starts a fight would it be ok to use my kirpan then? Maybe not to seriously hurt him but to scare him off and show him i aint joking and wont tolerate being pushed around.

Re: Taking a Human Life

BirRaas Singh · 12 Apr 2005

Taking your Sri Sahib out of its Miyaan in a public place is a crime, your fine to carry it but when you draw it you will be breaking the law unless you have a very good excuse for doing so. Use your brain to talk down any situation and leave, even in a fight dont pull it out, you have fists - use them if needed.

Re: Taking a Human Life

KHALISTANI · 12 Apr 2005

pull it out if u have to. if your fighting like 3 or 4 ppl at once then it would be alrite. or if its one on 1 and he pulls out a knife or an extendo or something

Re: Taking a Human Life

BirRaas Singh · 12 Apr 2005

Can we not give people ideas that its fine to take on 3 or 4 people only with the use of a Sri Sahib, Its perfectly possible to take on a group of people without the use of a sri sahib. Unneccessary use of Sri Sahibs will have a huge impact on the wider Sikh community, id rather take a few punches then forfeit the higher risks such as killing someone, being killed with own weapon, bann on sri sahibs etc. Im guessing no ones got any ideas to the above question :(.....

Re: Taking a Human Life

KHALISTANI · 12 Apr 2005

really u shoudltn have to. u should be able to fite 3 to 4 attackers easily with your fists.

Re: Taking a Human Life

KK · 13 Apr 2005

I don't think you should draw your Siri sahib unless yours or someone else's life or honour is in danger, in these cases you may not only draw your Siri sahib but you may even kill (1 or many).