Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS
Kulbir Singh · 03 Apr 2005
JSS under the thread of UK Nihungs wrote the following:
Author: JSS
Date: 04-03-05 18:55
Jarnail singh ji...
we all have seen the DIRECT sant bashin here on this website...
EVEN our respected brother KULBIR singh is GUILTY of bashing a pooran mahapursh whom he knew nothing about...
note:...i think kulbir singh ji is very learned in sikhi...and applaud his efforts of going to the conference....at the same time...he is ALSO guilty of spreading negative FALSE remarks of great gurmukhs....
i hope he is taking his own advice too...
Re: Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS
Kulbir Singh · 03 Apr 2005
JSS,
-----------
EVEN our respected brother KULBIR singh is GUILTY of bashing a pooran mahapursh whom he knew nothing about...
--------------
I think you are referring to my comments on Babu Jaswant Singh.
I had with my own eyes read a booklet published by Brahm Bunga in which some Swami claimed that Babu Jaswant Singh was an incarnation of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee and had come to fulfill the promise he made to the princess of Sri Lanka. Any gursikh who would read that booklet would be offended, including you too.
After that time, I did not hear of any retraction or condemnation of that booklet by Brahm Bunga society. My comments about Babu Jaswant Singh were in that context. Please explain to me, what you would do if you heard someone claiming to be Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee's avatar?
-------------
note:...i think kulbir singh ji is very learned in sikhi...and applaud his efforts of going to the conference....at the same time...he is ALSO guilty of spreading negative FALSE remarks of great gurmukhs....
-------------
Neither I am very learned in Sikhi, nor I have spread any negative false remarks of Great Gurmukhs.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS
Kulbir Singh · 03 Apr 2005
I am sorry if my use of "Babu" hurt your feelings. I just thought that this prefix was used before his name just as "Bayoo" is used before Bayoo Mal Singh jee.
And what slander are you talking about. I did not say anything about him - good or bad. I just said that I do not think of him as equal to Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh and other Singhs mentioned there.
I will repeat again that I think Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh jee was one of the greatest Sikhs of all times and I don't find anyone equal to him in the last couple of centuries. Again this is just my opinion and you may think Bhai Jaswant Singh to be the greatest Sikh and someone else may think of Sant Gurbachan Singh as the greatest Sikh. These are just our opinions.
----------------
i regularly attend akj samagams in TO...i love the peaceful atmosphere there and the kirtan...i have met people who claim that Bhai Sahib bhai randhir singh ji was an incarnation of Guru Gobind singh ji and that if guru gobind singh ji were alive today he would have made him guru....
now that is a VERY ANTI GURMAT THING to say...
--------------
No Jatha Singh can ever say this. Tell me who said this. If a person did say this, that person should be peshed and severely reprimanded. Bhai Sahib Randhir Singh was a Sikh of Guru Sahib and we cannot even imagine him coming even close to Guru Sahib. Bhai Sahib strongly condemned Guru-dumm tendencies.
No Jatha member ever believes or says that Bhai Sahib was an incarnation of any Guru. Stop spreading such baseless lies, JSS jeeo. Jatha is not a Sant group and it does not believe in any living person as their saviour, other than Punj Pyaray and Siri Guru Granth Sahib jee.
No one can believe that Jatha can ever say such degenerating thing about Bhai Sahib. Please don't drag Jatha in this.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS
Kulbir Singh · 03 Apr 2005
-----------
e tried to imply in earlier threads that bauji didn't believe in upkeep of rehit...he said that when he read bauji's lekhs, all that was in it was justification for not following rehit...and that is simply not true...if you go to dodra pind...you'll see some a lot of chardi kala rehitdhari singhs....
-------------
But did they not allow non-amritdhari and even monnay people to do kirtan from stage? I could not agree to this and this notion is directly at odds with Gurmat and what Gursikhs like Bhai Sahib and other mahapurakhs preached. It is a known fact that once Bhai Sahib refused to do anand kaaraj of a couple which was not amritdhari. Bhai Sahib was very strict in keeping rehit, though he was a player of very high spiritual states.
I just wrote what my impression has been after reading books written by "Khojee". I felt that they were undermining Rehit and the importance of rehit. If you could kindly refute what I have written above, I will be Khima da jaachak i.e. I will seek forgiveness.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS
Gurpreet Singh · 03 Apr 2005
kaur wrote:
> >he tried to imply in earlier threads that bauji didn't believe
> in upkeep of rehit...he said that when he read bauji's lekhs,
> all that was in it was justification for not following
> rehit...and that is simply not true...if you go to dodra
> pind...you'll see some a lot of chardi kala rehitdhari
> singhs....<
>
> THere are some areas where Dodras compromise with rehit, such
> as letting krehitees do keertan.
Kirtan is for everyone.......gurbani is for everyone...no one has a monopoly on gurbani....guru nanak dev ji went around to teach "krehitees" sikhi.....i don't see anything wrong if people do kirtan....one day with his kirpa they are gonna come around too...and i've been to my first dodra samagam in montreal...and trust me it was one of the most loving enviroment ...there i met so many gursikhs....everyone had love for each other and thats what we need in todays society now....we need love...Jin Prem Kiyo Tin Hee Prabh Paayo....lets learn to love each other...lets inspire each other to love and understand gurbani....to be that sikh of the guru...so when we walk by....people can say thats a sikh of guru gobind singh ji...thats a sikh of guru nanak dev ji.........wahegurooo...dhan guru nana :)
Re: Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS
Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 04 Apr 2005
Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh.
Veer JSS jio,
I too have seen with my own eyes the Book by Swami ji....it was NOT just "somethign said by soemone....somewhere..orally....IT was PRINTED and PUBLISHED.
Secondly when I was Manager of a Gurdawra in KL, we received a HUGE 50 inches by 40 Inches POSTER in ENGLISH from Canada to be passted on the Gurdwara Board. In it were ALL the QUOTATIONS fom that book in which Bau jaswant Singh was claimed to be GURU NANAK JI.
I had a copy of that poster until recently .....until..a dodra satsangee came to join my Gurbani class and took away the poster for "photocopying"....and then he told me He LOST the poster in a INDIAN COFFEE SHOP ( Gursikhs dont go to coffee shops) He never turned up again..and i suspect the only reason he came was to get his grubby hands on the poster.
I would be very glad to receive from YOU a copy of the BAN/CONDEMNATION of the said book and Poster from BB/Dodra....was this ban ever announced in WRITING ?? and was a REBUTTAL PRINTED.?? I would like copies..please. If you dotn have them never mind as I KNOW what I saw and read.
As I have communicated to you.... I will visit a Dodra smagam and see for myself what happens there..beleive me..I can "see" things that even microscopes MISS.
Please guide to any Tapoban post that BASHES a real SANT. This is attae wich loon brabar i think.....if it ever happened..BUT KUSANT BASHING...that happens and should happen all the time. I am never one to hide or sweep things under the carpet...no matter what....and also I am the FIRST in LINE to BHUL CHUK DEE KHIMMA..IF proven wrong.
I am NOT a AKJ memeber ( yet)..but I do not beleive the allaegation about Bhai Sahib Bhai randheer Singh Ji...an AKJ memeber however "naive" WONT be THAT NAIVE to equate a HUMAN to GURU GOBIND SINGH Jis LEVEL...this just doesnt happen lol...I will Never beleive such in a million years. (THIS is MY OPINION) Bhai Sahib Jee would NEVER forgive such a jatha memeber !!! not in a milion years.
Jarnail Singh.
BTW this is the most useless post there ever was on tapoban Forum. I am surprised you wrote it.
Re: Allegation of sant slander on me - Attn JSS
Amritpal Singh · 04 Apr 2005
I"ve gone myself to see dodra smaagams, and I found the sangat misguided, or even at times undermining rehit.
The last time I went to a dodra smaagam. I saw alot of pyaar for sikhi. but it was misguided. I went a few years ago in 2000 before i took amrit.
The whole atmosphere that i saw was one of no rehit.
maybe thats why on a forum based so heavilty on rehit,, dodra is getting bashed.
I've gone to dodra smaagams in toronto and know a few of the inside people who go alot. And their hearts are in the right place, but without any rules and any disipline what is the point of gurmat?
first of all... NOBODy said fateh. Only when people saw me some peole managed to say fateh, other wise it was dhan guru nanak and then straight for a hug.
I dont mind the hugs if its all coming from guys. but at dodra smaagams you see male, females hugging all over the place like TIGHT TIGHt hugs.
I mean I know for 99 precent of the people its PYAAR for them,, But in gurmat i dont think its appropriate for young males to be hugging other young females.
I found the young singhs there, all were filled with pyaar, and most all had good intentions on their mind, but still i dont think hugging the opposite sex (like same age) is appropriate.
The major thing that got to me was that, withouth rehit your jeevan does not go anywhere. You can do as much gurbani and keertan as you want but 'aassurr nehe pehnda" .
What is the point of allowwing a Mona do chaur di sewa, and also LEAD the sangat in keertan?
they themselves do not follow sikhi yet they can lead sangat?
this is the main and most HUGE difference between akhand keertan jatha and dodra.
this is why JSS you complaining about why we cant all get along......its because the idealogies are fundementally different when it comes to parchaar.
And Lastly.....I dont know the answer to this myself, so could JSS please explain to me why dodra smaagams arent held in gurdwara's?