Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Should non-amritdhari do simran

Should non-amritdhari do simran

anon · 01 Apr 2005

vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh kulbir singh on a previous post i remember you saying something along the lines that theres is no benefit for a none amritdhari to do simran, does this mean that a none amritdhari preparing to take amrit should do paath and no simran or less paath then simran or what, thank you in advance vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Singh · 01 Apr 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fetah. Anyone who thinks naam simeran is reserved only for Amrdhari’s has obviously not even bothered to read Gurbani or understood it at the most basic level. How many times does Guru Ji reveal whoever (jo) japs repeats naam, literally thousands of times. It surprises me that someone is foolish to even suggest the idea of naam, and Bhakti in general being reserved for Amridhari’s (obviously such narrow minded peoples concept of Amridhari will also be narrow minded, ie only from this or that Jatha). Will so called Sikhs please start reading Gurbani for themselves rather than idolising people, and taking their opinions and words as Gurmat.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Amritpal Singh · 01 Apr 2005

Naam is instilled into you by Panj Pyaarey through amrit sinchaar. This is the main purpose of amrit, to recieve NAAM and to be taught how to jap it. Without the panj pyaarery instilling naam into you you cant JAP naam. but that doesnt mean you cannot do anything that isnt spiritually uplifting. Do as much paat as you can and start practicing your nitnem everyday. For "singh" above, It seems as though you havent been taught how to jaap naam by panj pyaarey or else you wouldnt be as confused as you are. Please refrain from calling gursikhs foolish you only going to hinder your spiritual growth.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Roopkaur · 01 Apr 2005

What would a non amritdharee do simran of, if they do not even have gurmantr yet from the panj piyaarey? You can only do simran if you have something to do simran on and the technique to do it, but since a non amrit dharee does not have gurmantr, hence, according to logic, they cannot do simran of gurmantr.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Roopkaur · 01 Apr 2005

>How many times does Guru Ji reveal whoever (jo) japs repeats naam, literally thousands of times. < Bani also says that the true gurmantr is given by satguru, and satguru is Sri Guru Nanak Dev Ji, and in present day onlu panj piaarey have power of giving naam in the roop of satguru. Therefore, a person should go to Satguru, get naam, and than repeat naam.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Dalrajkaur Khalsa · 01 Apr 2005

How to jap naam is only taught to us by the punj, so in order to jap naam one must be amritdhari.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

ts · 01 Apr 2005

vaheguru jee kaa khalsa vaheguru jee kee fateh veer singh jee i think it is you that has not understood the basic concepts of gurmatt and gurbani, guru jee has stated in many places that in order to receive naam dhe dhaat one must present themselves to the punj pyare and by giving their heads they receive this blessing. anyone who believes one will achieve the ultimate spiritual stages without amrit/rehit is seriously mistaken and will continue in the cycle guru jee has created. guru jee does reveal that whoever japps naam will eventually if guru jees graceful eye falls on them achieve mukhti but to get that naam we must take amrit as only the punj pyare can give it. it is not totally useless to do simran if one is in preparation of taking amrit as all paath/simran done is beneficial but true benefits begin after enrolling in the school of gursikhi. remain in no doubt that without the true guru we can do what we like, we will one day have to take the step of becoming amritdhari. instead arguing about these things spend time reading books by bhai randhir singh, bhai veer singh, baba harnaam singh rampur kera wale, bhai rama singh and many other gurmukhs who revealed the true path and showed us the way as how to achieve the true blessings from guru jee. vaheguru jee kaa khalsa vaheguru jee kee fateh

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

- · 01 Apr 2005

Amrit is a necessity. But if you want to do simran before Amrit you can and it will benefit you. Bhai Rama Singh ji wrote in his book that anybody from any religion can jaap Vaheguru. It's still good for you. But accepting Amrit opens up your 'bank account' and is of amazing benefit to you. bhul chuk maaf.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

can't think of a name.. · 01 Apr 2005

Kirat Karo, Naam Japo & Vand Keh Shako.. Peace. [%sig%]

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

.. · 01 Apr 2005

Is learning how to 'jaap naam' properly only taught at akj amrit sinchaars.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

? · 02 Apr 2005

so this eans before sikhis there was no way to reach sach khand? what about guru gobind singh ji in his previous life merged with god?

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

anon · 02 Apr 2005

kulbir singh, can i have ur knowledged reply plaez?

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

sahajdhari · 02 Apr 2005

well said "?", i mean i agree amrit is needed, but you can still get ras from simran b4 you take amrit.... before sikhs did ppl not get mukhti??? they must have but i would like it if someone can explain this concept of a "bank account"

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

we`re so lucky · 02 Apr 2005

so all the people who never met the guru, or punj pyare have no hope. Wonder what happened to all the people on the planet before guru Nanak was here? . . .What bad luck to have lived at the north pole in 1700 with only a few days to live- you have to go to india to find punj pyare to get the magic gurmantra- "the only way to god", and that`s on the assumption you have a psychic vision of whats happening on the other side of the planet in the first place ?! er ... no!

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

jeevan · 02 Apr 2005

what is the proper way to do simran. I asked my cousin who is amritdari and asked if the punj pyare taught him how to do simran but i dont think he new what i was talking about.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

etka · 02 Apr 2005

sad guru ji tought as humanity, and recognize ye all man kind as one. not that sikhs are the only ones that have way 2 god. sad......really sad, you ppl need an education

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Sohgani · 02 Apr 2005

----->sad......really sad, you ppl need an education On this website, you'll find that Sikhs have a monopoly on Sachkhand. There's no use in complaining. They will promote their views, all you can do to counter is promote yours. [%sig%]

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

yo · 02 Apr 2005

bani prabh ki sabh ko bolai

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

o · 03 Apr 2005

by saying that non sikhs do not go to sach khand and there was no sach khand avilable before to people this means that we are denieing bachittar natak too very bluntly.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

can't think of a name.. · 03 Apr 2005

A monopoly on Sachkhand.. Oh dear.. [%sig%]

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 03 Apr 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Who is talking about "monopoly" ?? or about what happened to the millions before Guur nanak Ji came along...or the Billion Christians, Muslims, Buddhists etc. NOBODY. What the Singhs are talking about is that WAHEGURU as GURMANTAR is ONLY available from the PUNJ as Ordained by GURU GOBIND SINGH JI at vasakhi 1699 at Anandpur Sahib. This is as CLEAR as anything can be clear. When GURU NANAK JI started this PATH..Gadhi Raah to WAHEGURU....it took almost 250 YEARS of preparation to be Fully completed in 1699. As a simplistic "explanation" to the above derisive posts on Monopoly,exclusive amrit etc.... let me offer this. There are SPECIFIC BRANDED DRUGS made by Certain Pharmaceuticals...and also GENERIC DRUGS made by everybody else. IF a certain Pharmaceutical spends over 250 YEARS preparing a special DRUG to CURE MAYA....it means that is the BEST drug adn it is available ONLY to thsoe who approach that particualr Pharamaceutical.....BUT there are also GENERIC drugs avilable all along that can also achieve the "cure" but may not be the best. GURU NANAK JI's "branded" GURMATT through the PUNJ/GURU GRANTH/KHALSA is EXCLUSIVELY available only to thsoe who WANT it this way. There are other "generic" ways to Waheguru....no body denies this....and everybody who DOESNT WANT the AMRIT of the PUNJ is NOT under any obligation or being Forced to accept it...THAT is precisely WHY SIKHS DONT CONVERT BABIES !!!...One has to be a RESPONSIBLE ADULT of AGE to ACCEPT AMRIT and Commit ones self CONSCIOUSLY. Nothing about Amrit is Automatic/inborn/right of birth etc.. WE DONT say all this because then we would be stuck in the Christian RUTT/Islamic Rutt...to a Christian JESUS is the ONLY WAY to GOD....so what about the MILLIONS who came before JESUS or have never heard of Him ?? According to them they all go to HELL....similar propoganda from Islam. Any two year old can realsie that THIS cannot be TRUE....Waheguru would NEVER be SO EVIL to send everyone to HELL just because they are not christians/islamic/sikhs etc. TO SUMMARISE...there are many ways to GOD/WAHEGURU....BUT GURMATT is the EASIEST, the BEST, the FASTEST and SMOOTHEST....it is a BRANDED PRODUCT. There are a lot of generic no name products out there...and anyone who wants them is free to do so....just remember if it takes LONGER, is HARDER, the way is ROUGHER., the Going is TOUGHER........BLAME YOURSELF....for your BAD CHOICE. Wise people CHOOSE GURMATT of GURU NANAK JI....especially IF you are BORN SIKH because that is a HEAD START....and a HUGE PRIVILEGE. Only Stupid people throw away a golden chance like that. Jarnail Singh

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

sikh · 03 Apr 2005

so has the cat got kulbir singhs tongue? funny how he is very selective on what he replies to

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

heyheyhey · 03 Apr 2005

only amrit dhariees can go to sachkhand other relgious people can go to other khands such as giankhand and heaven and all those otherkhands in japjisahib otherthen sachkhand

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

etka · 03 Apr 2005

saachkhand must have b'n empty 306yrs ago.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

ms · 03 Apr 2005

im a non-amritdhari that does lots of simran and i love it, but seriously if someone tells me im not getting anything out of it or i shoudlnt do it i would get sooo offended because lets just say a non-amritdhari doign simran is jsut laying the path for when he/she does become amritdhari so they are used to doing simran then they knwo hwo to properly do simran

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Sohagani · 03 Apr 2005

--->TO SUMMARISE...there are many ways to GOD/WAHEGURU....BUT GURMATT is the EASIEST, the BEST, the FASTEST and SMOOTHEST....it is a BRANDED PRODUCT. <--- Veer Jarnail Singh Jee, This is not the case. What I meant was - according to tapoban sangat (by saying - on this website). And yes from their point of view, from what I've read on this board, only Sikhs can reach Sachkhand, read all their posts, read the gurmat section. There is no alternative path, harder way, nothing generic: Gurmat = Sikhi = Sachkhand. *****Admin cut for nonsense writings and baseless allegations******

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Kulbir Singh · 03 Apr 2005

Why do some people want my views under this thread? Are you not already aware of the fact that I don't believe it is appropriate for non-amritdharis to do Naam Abhyaas because they don't have Naam from Guru yet. They should read more baani and as much baani as they can. Naam can be japped only after amrit-chhak, to have any spiritual results. I repeat spiritual results. And yes Sohagni, we believe and we believe this at the beat of drum (dankay dee chot uppar) that without adopting Gurmat Dharam i.e. without accepting Guru Nanak Dashmesh as your Guru, you cannot reach Sach Khand the the zenith of spirituality. This topic has been discussed many times before. No need to do it again. No one has ever reached the zenith of spirituality without meeting the true Guru. And there is no true Guru, other than Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee. If someone does want to debate this issue, start a new topic. Kulbir Singh

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Sohagani · 03 Apr 2005

--->And yes Sohagni, we believe and we believe this at the beat of drum (dankay dee chot uppar) that without adopting Gurmat Dharam i.e. without accepting Guru Nanak Dashmesh as your Guru, you cannot reach Sach Khand the the zenith of spirituality. This topic has been discussed many times before. No need to do it again.<--- I didn't start the topic Veer, all I did was reply. --->No one has ever reached the zenith of spirituality without meeting the true Guru.<--- I agree with that statement, but not under the conditions you express. At the end of the day Veer Ji, Kulbir Singh & Co. have a belief system. What you get out of Gurbaani may not be what others get out of it. There will be many interpretations and as expected, everyone will feel theirs superior without fail. You'll be arguing and debating this stuff for the rest of your life, but then again, that's what we've always done. We can debate/argue/fight/claw each other's eyes out, but neither will change. We have different translations of Gurbaani, and each of us feels we have the right one - just like the rest of the world. Our last thoughts after reading that sentance will be 'Thank Akaal for putting me on the Gurmat path, and please help the other get on too.' [%sig%]

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Roopkaur · 03 Apr 2005

>'Thank Akaal for putting me on the Gurmat path, and please help the other get on too.'< You are right, this is what we should be saying. But the reason we are saying for others to get on is because we know this is the only way to muktee. First, we admit that Gurbani is perfect, flawless, and the ultimate truth, but when it contradicts what we say, then where does that bani go? You say other dharms can go to Sachkhand, but bani says they cannot. You explain to me how someone who only aims for the worldly pleasures of heaven, swarag and zanat, how they can make it to Sachkhand, where there is Naam and Bani, not gold and beautiful girls for the guys. Yes, all humans have Vaheguru ji in them, but then so do cows, dogs, cats, etc. Will they all being going to Sachkhand as well? If it was that easy to do simran, what would be the need for an amrit sanchaar? Why coulndt anyone just find out what the Naam is and start doing it? If any person can go to Sachkhand, what was the need for Sri Guru Nanak Dev ji to come to this world? If there were already so many dharms on this world, what was the need for another one?

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

o · 04 Apr 2005

bhai kulbir singh from your last post that seems like you would then doubt bachittar natak because Guru Gobind Singh ji was with Waheguru in his last life in a previous yug. Guru Nanak ji came in kal yug. If this is an accepted jatha belief this means akj does not believe in dasam granth ji Dasmesh Pita Jis writings.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Inderpreet · 04 Apr 2005

I think we are getting lost in the view of amrit-dhari vs non amritdhari. Non amritdari sikhs can do simran. There is always a benefit to doing simran, However, the benefit when amrit dhari is much more. Maybe instead of reffering to each other as amrit dhari and non amrit dhari we should look at it as with guru or without guru. I believe it was bhai kabir ji (i could be wrong) who prayed for 13 years with not much to show because they had no guru. He took charan amrit and received a guru. It is important for us to have a guru but we were told as sikh that our guru can only be guru granth sahib ji, and guru granth sahib ji becomes our guru when we take amrit. To answer Sahajdhari's question about the concept of bank account, think of it like the bank account of a blue collar worker vs a white collar worker. Blue collar worker can work only certain jobs b/c of their limited education, thus they have small incomes. A white collar worker has the education backing and thus can earn more. Now lets say the blue collar worker is smarter and knows more about a certain job than the white collar worker, he still can not make as much as the whitecollar worker b/c he does not have the necessary degrees. In that way, having a guru provides one with the 'degree' to 'bank' more naam and simran in their 'bank account'. I hope I helped in the matter and did not add to the confusion. I believe we are arguing about baseless things. With respect to those who say there is no benefit in simran for non amrit dharis, i disagree. there's always a benefit, we just may not see it right away. it could be because of the simran done in this life, next life we meet a saintly person and come to towards the path of the guru and become guru vale. Sikhi isn't just about this life. It's a path of many lives and I believe we do stuff in one life that will help us in the next. In the same way, simran done in this life will get 'banked' and hopefully next life one will bank more and more until they can cash it in to get to sachkand. simran is simran and saying the praises of god and guru will not come without benefit, as long as one is doing it from their heart. Bhai mardana was a 'mona' (never saw them, basing it on pictures and common belief) but Guru Nanak Dev Ji had no problem allowing him to do kirtan with him. Some of the reasons monae guys and girls where i live enjoy sikhi is because gurmukhs like bhai jeevan singh ji didn't look at them different. Bhai Sahib asked everyone to do kirtan. If they didn't know how to he would tell him to just sit with the others and sing on stage and then would teach them afterwards. It's these types of actions we should promote. Sorry this is so long, but i was reading the posts and i couldn't understand why we are trying to exclude people from sikhi instead of bringing them closer. I understand the goal is to become amrit dhari but everyone is not ready for that stage yet. When we say stuff like non amritdharis can not do kirtan on stage we are pushing them away instead of bringing them closer. Who knows that maybe doing keertan in the sangat will turn there life around in the future and guru will have kirpa on them. Instead of having arguements like this we should look at the lives of Bhai Jeevan Singh, who brought many youths closer to sikhi, and Bhai Harbhabjan Singh Khalsa Yogi Ji, who introduced sikhi to a different race, and try to mirror our lives to theirs. We can never be them but that shouldn't stop us from trying. This way we can not only enhance our own lives but we can enhance the panth. [%sig%]

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Roopkaur · 04 Apr 2005

This subject has been discussed many times before but for the sake of this thread, I will repeat it one more time, the bhagats were not Hindus/Muslims but were Sikhs of Guru Nanak Dev Ji. There are many references in Gurbani that says that you have to get Naam from Satguru, and it is only through Satguru that you can get this Naam. Bhai Gurdas Ji has also told us that this gurmantr is Vaheguru, not Ram or Allah or God, as those are all man made names. I have yet to find a reference that says you can meet Vaheguru without getting Naam, please enlighten me if you know of a reference. If Amrit was not necessary, then why would Guru ji come here in Kalyug and start a new religion? Why would Mahaan Sikhs like Bhai Taru Singh Ji, Baba Deep Singh Ji, and beant other Sikhs, why would they give up their lives for Sikhi if they could have gone to Vaheguru by converting to Islam? Are you now in this modern age of "lets all compromise on Sikhi asools so we are politically correct" more siyaaney then our mahaan Sikhs that died for Sikhi? >I know this because my Guru tells me so. He doesnt lie. He hasn't written conditions with the naam jap he tells me to do. If it was that important he would have said clearly. I'm not saying there is no merit to taking amrit, but to go around trying to put conditions on something that our Guru tells us so clearly about is akin to trying to put our words in the mouth of the SatGuru.< Guru ji says Jis no kirpa kareh tin raam ratan paaeeaa. THe word paaeeaa implies that it is something we have to obtain, not something that is given out at a corner store for anyone to pick up. THe mool manter also says as the last part "Gurparsad" that it is only through the guru's kirpa we can meet Vaheguru, and the the only guru is the satguru, Sri guru Nanak Dev Ji, as bani says Satguru baajo gur nahi koee, nigure ka hai nao buraa. THe only guru is Satguru, Sri Guru Nanak Dev ji, and those who have not adopted him as their guru, even their name is bad (that is how low they are). To merely say that you believe in Guru ji without going through the ceremony of adopting him is putting up a front. If a man and woman live together, but do not go through the marriage ceremony, yet they tell people they are husband and wife, does not make that relationship legitimate. The same people that try to be politically correct by downsizing the high Sikhi asools to meet their own needs, insted of trying to meet the lofty ideals of Sikhi, but when there is talk about RSS and GOI agents infilitrating Sikhi, then they start letting out jaikareys. Why are these double faced actions going on? Naam is not that cheap, you have to give your head for it, and it is time people realise the true price of Sikhi.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Inderpreet · 04 Apr 2005

RE: Roopkaur ji I believe we are somewhat saying the same thing. I agree with you that taking amrit is necessary and that one who has taken amrit is better off with naam. But the original question was whether or not doing simran benfits non amrit dhari sikhs. And I believe the answer is yes, simran benefits those who are amrit dhari, those who arn't amritdhari, those who listen to someone doing simran and those who come into contact with people that have done or are doing simran. The beneficial value will only, however, be realized by those that are true gursikhs. I do not disagree with you. Amrit is necessary,we need a guru. otherwise guru nanak dev ji would not have said "Jay Sau chanda ughvaa, suraj charre hazaar, ethey chanan hundeayaan, gur bin ghor aandhar" and the list can go on and on of quotes from SGGS about the validty of amrit. But again, that's not the point we are discussing. I don't know if you are referring to me in the last paragraph about trying to be politically correct because that was not my aim. I am merely saying that simran is beneficial for everyone, if you don't believe me ask around. We do rehraas every tuesday at our university and most of the punjabi's that come are not amritdhari. There's actually only 2 of the 20 that i know about. A week ago, one of the guys who's not amritdhari asked me if we're going to do the same thing we did last week after Rehraas sahib path (referring to simran). I said yes and his response was "good, it's relaxing and peaceful". What do you think his response would be if i said "man, forget about the relaxing part, it'll do you no good cause you havn't taken amrit. In fact don't even come tonight cause this'll just be a waste of time for you." do you think he'd say "man, i gotta stop drinking and eating meat and become amritdhari" or would he say "screw you and your views, i don't need you guys anyway" Again, I agree with you that there are certain codes and rules we must follow, but one has to be at a certain point in there spirituality before they can adhere to these rules. I'm not downsizing the importance of taking amrit to be politically correct, i'm just saying there are benefits to simran regardless of having amrit or not. I don't think anyone here is questioning the price of sikhi, or how hard naam kamai is. The answers are obvious and well known. With regards to your post about amrit, i agree wholeheartedly but from your post it seems like you are saying simran is beneficial only for amritdharis and with that i have to disagree. Forgive me if I have said anything wrong. [%sig%]

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Sohagani · 04 Apr 2005

--->Roop Kaur Say's: You say other dharms can go to Sachkhand<--- I didn't say other Dharams can reach Sachkhand. The fundamental difference here is understanding of Gurbani. The Bhagats were not all Sikhs of Sri Guru Nanak Dev Jee, non-amritdhari's can japp naam. But this has all been discussed before and if we get into it, it'll just turn into another 'Your wrong. No, Your wrong.' thread, just like the rest of the threads on the history of this message board.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Jasvir Kaur · 06 Apr 2005

waheuru ji ka khalsa waheuru ji ki fateh. 1. IF Non_Sikhs can "naam japp"..why did Guru nanak ji come ? 2. IF Non-Amrtidharees can Naam japp...why did GURU GOBIND SINGH JI introduce the Amrit Ceremony Panj and Gurmantar ? Couldnt the Guru nanak-Guru Teg bahadur "naam" continue to be used ?? WHY CHANE something that works well ?? 3. Wasnt Just Guru nanak Ji enough ....after all He had already given us the MoolMantar...enough "Naam" to japp ?? Jasvir Kaur - Amrtidharee

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

sahajdhari · 08 Apr 2005

penji jasvir kaur Naam was present b4 time, that means b4 guru nanak dev ji was born on this earth.... the reasons for taking khanda da phula are not JUST for naaam/gurmantar and this whole topic is about non sikhs not gettin anand, or any kamai from simran.... soo right now i do my nitnem daily, i do not eat meat, or any intoxicants, i dont go party it up or anything, in fact im always seen with singhs, sooo your telling me that im doing this for no reason?? the nitnem the sangat ....its all uselesss? that i shouldnt do this since have not taken amrit?

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Manvir Singh · 08 Apr 2005

Daas would like to share his humble vichaar. Guru Sahib's Hukam is universal ("Too sanjha Sahib, baap hamaara"). Naam Japna can be done by everyone and anyone. Guru is very important. Guru helps us to achieve maximum benefit of Naam Abhiyaas and Simran. This is what someone told me (right or wrong): "When we take (Khandey Baatey da) Amrit we build a wall around ourselves. Our spiritual bank account (of Naam Simran/ Vaheguru di Sewa) is guarded by our Rehat and oath we take to Guru Sahib. We live a life, and promise our Guru that: 1) I will not do beadbi of my Kesh 2) I will not have physical relationship with anyone other than my wife or husband 3) I will not eat Kuttaa 4) I will not consume tobacca or other intoxicants. By being saved from these Bujjar Kurehats we guard our spiritual bank and we can fully take the reward of our Naam Kamaayee. Those who do not take Amrit or committed to the Guru there is more possibility that they may lose their kamaayee if they fall in the bujjar kurehats. 1) If we dishnour our hair and body as given by Waheguru and yet we doing Simran - the effect of Simran = decreased and our spiritual bank account is plundered. "Rom Rom Har Dhiaave"... with each every hair of your body meditate on the Lord. Our hair is a spiritual gift, tool and mechanism which guides and helps us to reap the full anand of simran through the vibration of Naam through all the body and each hair. 2) If we get caught into sexual relationships outside of marriage then we get caught up the web of Kaam. Our desires cannot be controlled (hence we commit the sexual act outside marriage) and our surti is disrupted. Through this spiritual bank account of kamaayee is lost. 3) If we eat Kuttaa and things which are physically unhealthy that will have an effect on our body and our spirituality and therefore eating the pain and suffering of animal we lose our spiritual bank balance. 4) If we consume tobacco, sharaab or intoxicants then again we lose consciousness, we forget the lord and face the consequences - "Jit peetai kasam visrai, dargai milai sajaae" Therefore to "CONTINUALLY" reap the reward of Naam Simran and to "GUARD" our Sikhi Di Kamaayee - a person who has fully committed themself to their Guru (which for a Sikh is by taking Amrit and living Rehat) one is saved by the Guru and don't have to worry about losing their kamaayee." I don't know how well that washes down with people. End of day we are created by Waheguru, and our Creator Lord Parent resides within us and and all around us... Waheguru has given us so many gifts and treats.... as "HUMAN BEINGS" (irrelevant of sikh or non-sikh, amritdhari or not-amritdhari) we should all remember and praise the lord. "jan naanak tis balihaarnai, jo aap japai avraa naam japaa-e... Servant Nanak is a sacrifice to one who himself chants the Naam, and inspires others to chant it as well." (Ang 140) bhul chuk maaf karnee ji.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Roopkaur · 08 Apr 2005

>the reasons for taking khanda da phula are not JUST for naaam/gurmantar< You are wrong, the main point of the amrit sanchar is to initiate the abhilaakhi into the Sikh dharm by giving them the gurmanter, which is the Naam that guru ji gives us. >soo right now i do my nitnem daily, i do not eat meat, or any intoxicants, i dont go party it up or anything, in fact im always seen with singhs, sooo your telling me that im doing this for no reason?? the nitnem the sangat ....its all uselesss? that i shouldnt do this since have not taken amrit?< No, it is not useless. THat bani and your good sangat will benefit you after you take amrit, and I think even is benefitting you. But Bani is different from Naam, which is only given by guru ji. >Guru Sahib's Hukam is universal ("Too sanjha Sahib, baap hamaara"). Naam Japna can be done by everyone and anyone.< You are right, anyone can do naam japna. And there are hundreds of naams and ways of meditation out there, like the 17th pauri of Jap Ji Sahib says. BUT, if you want the benefit of the Sacha Naam, you must get it from satguru, and that is only through taking amrit that you can obtain it. What would non amritdharees jap on if they do not have any naam do jap on?

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

anonymous singh or singhni or · 08 Apr 2005

i agree with all views that simran can only be done when u have the naam obtained by guru ji in the form of the panj pyare. but some groups such as taksaal dnt recieve naam drir wen takin amrit so they cant acheive guru ji. correct? vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

singh · 08 Apr 2005

Roopkaur, I noticed the word Sachkhand being used a lot on this forum. It's supposedly a place where only bebeki singhs can go. Could you enlighten me where in Gurbani it's written that amrit dhaaries go to sachkhand. Show me a shabad with the word Sachkhand in it that says amrit dhaaries would go n live there. Only Japji Sahib mentions Sachkhand as a realm where Nirangkaar resides. Read the detailed description of five khands mentioned in Japji and see for yourself that it says only formless lord resides in the realm of sachkhand. Read Gurbani and learn for yourself. Don't just idolize individuals.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

sahajdhari · 09 Apr 2005

today i talked to two singhs far more knowledgable about sikhi then i, about this topic soo i raised the point that Naam was present b4 time, and guru gobind singh ji says in bacchitar natak that his soul was liberated while doing abhyas on "MahaKaal" but then it was brought to my attention that there is a tuk in gurbani orr bhai gurdas jis vaaran stating that in this age (jug) u need gurmantar, if this is true i take back most of my case i have made thus far, cuz in bacchitar natak it doesnt say what age liberation occurd for all we know, it happened in Satyug, as for hemkunt sahib, it might just "resemble" the place liberation occured, but may not be it........ so then it raises the question that the Zoroastrians,jewish Tradition have beeen around Christians, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhists, and progressivly sikhs...over the thousands of years that has passed, did one of those souls not get mukhti? and gurbani says: bin sathigur mukath n paaeeai manamukh firai dhivaan || jae ko gur thae vaemukh hovai bin sathigur mukath n paavai || kaethae bandhhan jeea kae guramukh mokh dhuaar || bin gur mukath n paaeeai naa dhubidhhaa maaeiaa jaae ||5|| soo really how can i go againt gurbani, its clear on that.....sorry for being hardheaded [%sig%]

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 09 Apr 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki fateh. Guru nanak Ji in japji Sahib States..IF the Single Tongue becomes LAKHS..and this figure is further EXPANDED to MILLIONS of TONGUES...the Naam japp that this ONE TONGUED HUMAN DOES... will not be enough...( even if the One tongus is CLONED into Millions upon Millions and ALL the CLONED TONGUES "naam japp" it accomplishes NOTHING. ISNT this example an INDICATION that in this Human Life time of JUST one TONGUE.....just "naam japp" without becoming a COMPLEAT MAN..the KHALSA that GURU GOBIND SIN GH JI PARGAT KARO in 1699 ...leaves a lot to be desired ?? THIS is the REASON why GURU NANAK JYOT went on for the next 250 YEARS until the Compleat Man was Brought Forth..and the Formula for Naam japp was REVEALED to this Compleat man. The One Tongue of this "Compleat man" japping the WAHEGURU GURMANTAR then becomes ENOUGH to take him across this Ocean of Maya towards Waheguru and His Sach Khand. A Kindergarten Kid leanrs the ABC s...can he then just rely on thsi "knowledge" to sustain him towards success....obviously he will need to learn how to utilise these ABCs to write Essays and sit for Exams..no one can DENY that the ABCs of a kindergarten kids exercise book are DIFFERENT from the ABCs in a Project Essay of say bill gates..THEY are the SAME...But Bill gates ABCs earns him billions....but the kindergarten kids ABCs just earn him the "admiration" of his MOTHER...the KID has Progressed from Kindergarten to University...Similalry we MUST PROGRESS from the Naam japp of Guru nanak ji to the Naam Dirr of WAHEGURU given by Guru Gobind Singh Ji/Panj Piyaras. NON-SIKHS who DONT even have Naam of Guru nanak Ji..are even more "backward" as they havent even been to Kindergartern yet !!! Waheguru Ji gives us all a CHOICE....no one is FORCING anyone to Naam japp WAHEGURU Panj Piyara style...each one is free to do as he/she pleases...IF you honestly think whatever you are doing is ENOUGH....carry ON and May the FORCE be with YOU !!!..BUT as for me..I Honestly Beleive the basic naam japp Guru nanak Ji brought from Sach Khand is MEANT to be Taken to its Completion at the Amrit Sanchaar ceremony..and then japped as Naam dirred by the Panj...To each his own.. Jarnail Singh

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

anonymous · 09 Apr 2005

i am posting agen wat i put b4 cos it didnt get thru. the main message on this thread is tht naam from the guru is essential and it is recieved thru amrit i agree to this. BUT not all amrit sanchaars giv naam so the people hu take amrit from here cant do naam as they havent had it implated in them so they cant reach sach khand. true? vahigurujikakhalsavahigurujikifateh

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

singh · 09 Apr 2005

yeaa what happens to those who dont recieve naam drir like me?? huhh Like those taking amrit today at dixie gurdwara they also wont be recieving it, what about them??

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

sahajdhari · 09 Apr 2005

they get gurmantar from from the punj at dixie.......sum1 aove asked bout taksal, they give u gur mantar, its kinda different from naam dhird, but jatha differences aside....its the same thing

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 10 Apr 2005

The Most important question..is having a GURU. Gurbani especially that of GURU AMARDASS JI is very very explicit that one NEEDS a GURU....in order to Naam Jaapp...a NIGURA..that is person WITHOUT A GURU is..NOWHERE. Now can nayone just ACCEPT a GURU.....that is jsut decide on his own that so and so is MY GURU ?? Any one care to give a Example from GURU SAHIBAAN's HISTORY ?? Did Bhai Lehna Ji just sit at home and decide that His Guru was going to Be GURU NANAK JI ?? SO can a person "decide" on his own..MY GURU is GURU GRANTH JI ?? How doers he "know" that GURU GRANTH JI has "ACCEPTED him as his SIKH ?? This is the CRUX...in 1699 GURU GOBIND SINGH JI instituted the METHOD and PROCEDURE whereby a person makes a DECISION of accepting his GURU - GURU GRANTH JI...and the GURU then TELLS him that He is ACCEPTED as a SIKH...and can now go FORWARD along the Path of SIKHI. Without going through this PROCEDURE and METHOD of the PANJ PIYARAS....no way anyone can say his GURU is GURU GRANTH JI.... IT didnt happen during GURU JI's LIFE TIMES and it doesnt happen TODAY. Just DOESNT HAPPEN. Jarnail Singh.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

IMHO · 10 Apr 2005

Most people would call me an "extremist" or "fundamentalist" in my views but these are my beliefs. The impression I am getting here is that apparently there is no spirituality before Amrit. Of course you can get to some level before you take Amrit - the whole idea of preperation is to get to a certain level before you take it. This along with your past Karams will decide how strong the foundations of your Amrit are and also how much Anand you get. I agree that we need Amrit from our Guroo to get to Saachkhand but I haven't seen anyone address the questions yet of the Bhagats. My belief is that Guroo Ji came to the Bhagats and did Kirpa to them Himself. The same with Dusht Daman; I think he did so much Bhagti that Vaheguru actually blessed him. I don't think population of Saachkhand before Guru Nanaks time was 0, unfortunately I don't really know who was there and who got Mukti, I am not decided yet.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 10 Apr 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. A student of mine came up with this simple example. A long long time ago....say during times of Aristotle/Socrates...etc the EDUCATION SYSTEM was so LIMITED....like not everyone could get an education...and it wasnt cheap either !!....Comparison to Naam japping..VERY VERY FEW could get this far...You had to LEAVE HOME, go LOOK for a SADHU/BRAHCHARI/SWAMI etc etc..wash His Kachhas for a few decades...sweep his kuttia etc and then IF you were LUCKY he would adopt you and Give you the Naam japp TECHNIQUE...LOok at Krishan Ji...BHAGWAAN..BUT had to Go LOOK for a BRAHMIN ASHRAM, do ordinary things like looking for food, washing clothes, housework chores etc etc..SAME thing happened to Ram Chander Ji....He was BHAGWAAN BUT had to get the Naam japp from a BRAHMIN MASTER !!! Then came better times....Education became a bit more "common"...more people could Naam japp...more ashrams and more masters.. BUT STILL a serious shortage of REAL BHAGATS....you can COUNT the BHAGATS on the fingers of two hands.... FAST FORWARD to GURU NANAK JI....in just a short span of 250 Years this NIRANKARI JYOT established the SIKH RELIGION - and Gave us the Supreme Gift of GURBANI/Naam japp/AMRIT/WAHEGURU GURMANTAR....all avialble in One NEAT PACKAGE in ONE PLACE...who could ask for MORE ??..and the Number of REAL BHAGATS...increased to Hundreds of thousands....ALL those Mahan SHEEDS..from Guur Arjun Ji to Chhotteh Sahibzadehs, to Bhai Mani Singh...to 1984...are the PRODUCT of this SCHOOL of GURU NANAK. In 500 Years the Sikh religion has Produced MORE BHAGATS than hundreds of CENTURIES of the Indian bhagtee Tradition......and still "naam japp" was available BEFORE GURU NANAK !!! but why so FEW bhagats ?? People who INSIST on Naaam japp WITHOUT PANJ PIYARAE GIFT...are trying to emulate ARISTOTLE's times ??? and IGNORING the COMPLETE UNIVERSITY provided by GURU NANAK-GURU GOBIND SINGH JI JYOT to EVERY SIKH....what a group of time wasters and bunch of losers....go back to looking for a bramchari ashram, wash his kachhas for about 50 years and then maybe he will give you naam to japp....GOOD LUCK. I am only 18 years old and have NO TIME to WASTE on such Swamis... Jarnail Singh

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

? · 11 Apr 2005

if SatGuru ji himself came and made sure the bhagats came and got liberation then what was the need of even putting their bani inside Guru Granth sahib ji? For their spirituality until SatGuru ji would have been incomplete until the point of liberation.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Roopkaur · 11 Apr 2005

>I agree that we need Amrit from our Guroo to get to Saachkhand but I haven't seen anyone address the questions yet of the Bhagats. My belief is that Guroo Ji came to the Bhagats and did Kirpa to them Himself. The same with Dusht Daman; I think he did so much Bhagti that Vaheguru actually blessed him. I don't think population of Saachkhand before Guru Nanaks time was 0, unfortunately I don't really know who was there and who got Mukti, I am not decided yet.< Although GUru Nanak Dev Ji only came to this world about 500 years agao, does not mean he did not exist. He is SAtguru, meaning eternal guru, So he has always existed and will always exist.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

punjabiyadibhakarishaanvavah · 11 Apr 2005

then roop kaur do you agree if Guru jis is eternal then so would the concept of sach khand? why would sach khand just suddenly appear out of nowhere?

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

ashamed · 11 Apr 2005

i'm a mona and this is so sad that people would write the things u do. how do u get close to people when u are so far from them. without doing simran i would be still drinking, doing drugs. but i guess i wasnt really doing simran. many things have happened to me which i cant talk about but if there is any people getting into sikhi reading this. keep doing simran it is essential to get amarshak but dont let these people push you away. keep doing simran lots of it and everything will fall into place. i used to have long hair and one day i cut it. that day i realized what i had lost and i wondered why didnt he stop me. and now i know

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Jarnail Singh Gyani Arshi · 13 Apr 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Dear Ashamed Ji, Your sentiments get thrown at every Amrtidharee who says that Amrti is necessary... BUT just stop for a moment and think....is any Amrtidharee saying/insisting that BEING AMRITDHAREE is EXCLUSIVE ?? That people like YOU CANNOT become Amrtidharees ? NO of course not.....BECAUSE NO ONE is a BORN AMRITDHAREE....we all become one through our own determination and progress along the path.....so WHY do you "feel pushed away " just by amrtidharees mentioning about MONAYS. Surely you dont expect an amritdharee to say being MONA is OK/GOOD/ALL RIGHT/NO PROBLEM/CARRY ON ??? OF course no self respecting amritdharee will say those things...BUT then that doesnt mean that he/she is "pushing you away"/insulting you/disregarding you/not loving you ?? I hear this "arguments" from Monas gaian and again....DONT SAY WE ARE MONAS..Just "ignore" the fact that we are MOnas...IF you mention MONA that means you are PUSHING ME AWAY ?? Amrtidharees and strict amrtidharees are often compared to "BRAHMINS"...but that is totally WRONG.....because a BRAHMIN is BORN..and EXCLUSIVE CLUB.....but an Amrtidharee is one who BECOMES ONE BY CHOICE..and anyone even a SAJJAN THUGGH/ KODDA RAKASH can become an AMRITDHAREE...but a Shudar becoming a BRAHMIN...NO WAY. Whats wrong if Amrtidharees and strict amritdharees want to "mix" more with their own kind than with say..monas....DONT MONAS feel "MORE COMFORTABLE" in other monas company ??..I would DEFINITELY feel comfortable if my children AVOID MONAS and mix with Amrtidharees becasue I want them to PROGRESS towards AMRIT and NOT slide downwards to MONASISM...this is just natural...if my son is with monas 24/7 then he may be influenced by peer pressure to become a mona...just like going to discos and doing drugs can lead one that way...and mixing with kirtaniyas/gurmukhs will definitley influence him towards kirtan/ gurbani etc instead of Rap..BUT that doesnt necessarily eman I or my son "hate" rap/despise rap/ignore rap/think rap is bad etc. Similarly i "LOVE" monas just as much as anybody....BUT I wouldnt want my son to mix too much with them. SO MONAS/and others CAN do Naam simran..just like I can STUDY MEDICAL BOOKS ( no body can stop me)....BUT can I really "practise" medicine or treat sick people..even though I may come to the same result as a qualified doctor..I still have to get QUALIFIED to benefit from my study....simialrly any one Doing Naam Simran will have to be qualified to benefit from it. SO stay on the PATH..Waheguru Ji will have His KIRPA on You someday...and I hope it is SOON so that you too can join the Amrtidharee group. Jarnail Singh

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

billoh · 13 Apr 2005

Guru ji came to earth to remind all man to chant name of God sincerely how can this be only reserved for amritdharis only? Thats very missionary type like saying come this way till then your zero. That resembles christian, muslim religion.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

billoh · 13 Apr 2005

if your son slides towards mnonaism then his foundation in sikhi is not strong enough. it comes down to question of how much a person has inside them even more a reason to prepare for amrit just as bhai sahib did before actually taking it.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Kulbir Singh · 13 Apr 2005

Billoh, ------------------ Guru ji came to earth to remind all man to chant name of God sincerely how can this be only reserved for amritdharis only? ---------------- I think you are misunderstanding here “Billoh”. Nobody is suggesting that we hold tongues of Monnas to prevent them from chanting Naam. The issue here is whether it is appropriate for them to chant Naam, when they have not yet received Naam from Guru Sahib yet. Amritdharis are not monna-haters or anything. Many who are amritdharis today were monnas in the past. There is no question of hating them and this is not about rights either. The question is what is the best thing for monnas to do, till they get amrit and Naam? The Naam given to Khalsa is not a gupt or secret word and is known to everyone. In the light of this, should Monnas go ahead and japp this Naam? Our position is that no they should concentrate on Baani. There is a vidhee or technique to Japp Naam and plus Naam is given during amrit sinchaar to new seekers after they agree to abide by a certain code of conduct. A true seeker who is a monna but wants to chhak amrit in the future should do as much Gurbani paath as possible. Later when they get Naam, they will immensely benefit from the kamaayee of Gurbani. But if some Monnas don’t want to listen to this advice, then it is up to them. No one is going to prosecute them or penalise them from japping Naam they don’t have. They can do as they please. We were only concerned that their time gets properly utilised and not wasted by doing some activity that is not going to reap them any benefit. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

can't think of a name.. · 13 Apr 2005

Author: Kulbir Singh Date: 04-13-05 06:34 The issue here is whether it is appropriate for them to chant Naam, when they have not yet received Naam from Guru Sahib yet. ***** Who said its not appropriate for non-amritdhari's to do simran? Where is this stated and who by? Many thanks :-) [%sig%]

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Harsimrat Kaur · 13 Apr 2005

Gurfateh ji, Alot of history i have read says 'I had to go 5 times to take amrit and still the panj pyare wouldn't let me' This shows that you have to prepare your self first then take amrit. Once you are ready you will feel it, then you will know the right time to take amrit but you can't/shouldn't take amrit till you are fully prepared and have kept your rehit for a fair bit of time. Gurfateh ji.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

question · 13 Apr 2005

I always hear ppl saying that you should just do it, Guru sahib will help you keep rehat because you'll never feel ready.....what is it?

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

sahajdhari · 13 Apr 2005

Arshi: "DONT MONAS feel "MORE COMFORTABLE" in other monas company ??.." being a mona, no i dont feel as comfortable around moneh like i do with singhs now, how can i be cool with ppl who dont have tha same piyar for guru sahib like i do? "Amrtidharees becasue I want them to PROGRESS towards AMRIT and NOT slide downwards to MONASISM" the point of a grist jeevan is that we gotta live thru maya in life, beat it face it head on, not just run away n do bhagti, soo using that as a example i would make sure my son has such a strong foundation that he could help lay the path of another person, that way my son can learn wat maya is, and battle through it, maya is the greatest yudh! "Similarly i "LOVE" monas just as much as anybody....BUT I wouldnt want my son to mix too much with them." yup i can just feel the love, and if you were a doctor, youd have bad bed side manner :P Kulbir Veer Ji: I respect your views, and to a point i agree, you need amrit and gurmantar from punj to have FULLL effects of naam kamaii but " No one is going to prosecute them or penalise them from japping Naam they don’t have. They can do as they please. We were only concerned that their time gets properly utilised and not wasted by doing some activity that is not going to reap them any benefit. " Naam=Waheguru Waheguru= inside all of gods creation, we have it, just need to find it and as far as waste of time, doing simran is thinking of Waheguru, can thinking of waheguru really a waste of time? "Amritdharis are not monna-haters or anything. Many who are amritdharis today were monnas in the past" GOOD THING u mentioned that, after Jarnail singh arshis post i thought they did......maybe i was wrong to generalize that if one hates moneh all do, but then again arshi veer ji a much more learned veer generalized that moneh are all currupt.... [%sig%]

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

singh · 13 Apr 2005

>There is a vidhee or technique to Japp Naam< Does this refer to naam drir that you can recieve at akj amrit sinchaars?

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

heera premi pardesi dcs · 14 Apr 2005

now that it has been asked non amritdharis should do even more simran, fill up the gurdwaras with amritdharis sit side by side they should also go resnbhais and pack the whole darbar out aaanj saanjh singha singhnia naal.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 14 Apr 2005

"Amritdharis are not monna-haters or anything. Many who are amritdharis today were monnas in the past" GOOD THING u mentioned that, after Jarnail singh arshis post i thought they did......maybe i was wrong to generalize that if one hates moneh all do, but then again arshi veer ji a much more learned veer generalized that moneh are all currupt.... You get me wrong veer..how could I say ALL moneh are CORRUPT ?? who am I to see into people's hearts ?? I am just following GURBANI....Udte ko udta milleh, rogi ke janeh sabh rogi..Birds of a feather fly together... I could show you many Amrtidharees who are NOW MONAHS...so IF monahs can turn amrtidharee.. it can also happen the other way around...whats the big deal. ?? I DONT HATE discos/Bhangras clubs or say they are all BAD/CORRUPT...BUT i wouldnt be caught dead within a mile of such places...so while i am not saying all monahs are bad/corrupt....i still wont go out of my way to cultivate their friendship/company...thats my personal choice. NO offense meant to anyone...and I will NOT advocate that monahs be allowed to do degh sewa, chaur sewa/paath sewa kirtan sewa in diwan..all sewa that is proscribed only to AMRITDHAREES in our Sikh rehat maryada....other things they are more than welcome and if any amrtidharee tries to PUSH them away..I will stand up for the Monahs any day. Jarnail Singh.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

bhau · 14 Apr 2005

munney munniyah only you know what you gain by doing simran it is your personal relationship with God Almighty that no man woman can judge by any words, thoughts, methods,assumptions, or deeds.therefore it is your pooran haque to remmeber God under any circumstance. So if it helps do it more and more and more. My best friends munna cousin does simran and very strange things happen to him that will be kept gupt. We need no proofs a lot of things happen but it is the current of God's name that does everything as God's name is the Sustainer of the universe.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

sahajdhari · 14 Apr 2005

Arshi veer: "and I will NOT advocate that monahs be allowed to do degh sewa, chaur sewa/paath sewa kirtan sewa in diwan..all sewa that is proscribed only to AMRITDHAREES in our Sikh rehat maryada" agreed, i myself take tha same stance "I could show you many Amrtidharees who are NOW MONAHS...so IF monahs can turn amrtidharee.. it can also happen the other way around...whats the big deal. ??" now from those guys who did kurehit, how many did nitnem everyday, knew what it meant, and kept decent rehat? how many of those guys were half decent sikhs? i too have seen this, each time it is a person who was forced to take amrit as a kid by family, and they dont know anything bout sikhi, and they give in......i am ia firm believer in tha facct that "once you take guru jis hand, he will never let u go" so im willing to stake alot on tha fact those guys were amritdhari by appearance and not by orthopraxy/orthodoxy [%sig%]

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 15 Apr 2005

Waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh. Sehajdharee veer:writes... now from those guys who did kurehit, how many did nitnem everyday, knew what it meant, and kept decent rehat? how many of those guys were half decent sikhs? i too have seen this, each time it is a person who was forced to take amrit as a kid by family, and they dont know anything bout sikhi, and they give in......i am ia firm believer in tha facct that "once you take guru jis hand, he will never let u go" so im willing to stake alot on tha fact those guys were amritdhari by appearance and not by orthopraxy/orthodoxy..<<<< I couldnt agree more with you on this one. Thats why I am dead against just having "automatic" mass scale types of Amrit sanchaars where the Abhilakhees are even supplied FREE Kachheras,kanghas, kirpans and karras ( I have a sneaky suspicion they would "supply" FREE KESH too If they COULD....!!!) on the SPOT. What a farce..IF the person cant even have his own kachhera.in time for Amrit.....what rehat is he going to commit to ?? No wonder the kachheras come off once they reach home...Now a days the situation is such that INSTEAD of the PANJ "choosing" the abhilakhees..it is the Abhilakhees who CHOOSE the Panj from which they want AMRIT !!! It has become a ritual....a game of NUMBERS..so many LAKH of Amrit abhilakhees...etc etc....no one bothers to could how many actually LASTED...a Day/week/month/year ??? Amrit is a Very Big commitment....and YES once we take Guru Ji's HAND..He will Never Let go..it is WE that desert GURU JI.....some like the 40 Muktey realise their mistake and come back......others dont .. Jarnail Singh

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

aman · 15 Apr 2005

i was told every time you do vaheguru it benifits u and its like putting money in a bank acount the more simran u do the better u r making ur next life. it does not mater if u r amrtidhari or not, but by becoming amritdhari u will stand a good chance of being 1 with god if u follow what the gurus teach u. but if ur not yet ready 2 take amrit thers no stopping u doing simran

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 15 Apr 2005

dear aman ji, You write: i was told every time you do vaheguru it benifits u and its like putting money in a bank acount ....>>>> YES its MONEY in the BANK ACCOUNT.....BUT does the "Bank Account" have YOUR NAME on it...Can YOU use the WITHDRAWL FACILITIES ??? when the time comes.... can "anybody" just walk into any "bank" and "DEPOSIT" money into "any account".... ????..will that DEPOSIT BENEFIT HIM ?? EVERY BANK in the Wolrd REQUIRES YOUR PARTICULARS, YOUR SIGNATURE, YOUR "COMMITMENT"...before they allow you to OPEN an ACCOUNT...and then only can you begin to DEPOSIT your money... isnt that so ?? MAKING A COMMITMENT to GURU JI by taking AMRIT makes SURE YOUR NAME and SIGNATURE is depositied with the BANK...and ALL the Naam Simran goes INTO YOUR ACCOUNT....and YOU can USE it when the time to withdraw it comes... OF course if you still insist on just depositing your hard earned money into just about any account..in any bank...i suppose thats your right...after all a lot of people i know "drop" coins in "wishing wells" ( a type of "deposit" that doesnt benefit them !!! Jarnail Singh

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

mirch · 16 Apr 2005

we should encourage all to jap nam and read bani without that how will they ever get a chance to have a feel or touch for something bigger? instead we are too busy defining what is and what is not, this does not help. Remember someone else is not the sameboat as you. Only God alone looks after all and His naam benefits everyone. This does not question amrit of course it is important and part of the road a sikh must travel on. So many people enjoy doing naam who are not amritdhari, it has opened their thirst t grow kes, read bani and take amrit. that is why naam simran is such a big thing it takes people away from worldy things and offers something different and draws them nearer to sikhi. One door opens and another opens. People feel peace from nam simran away from stress of material life so therefore that shoyuld be a bridge between them and sikhi. If we go round questioning is it really worth them doing naam if their not amritdhari this will discourage a big number of people getting into sikhi. I look back 9 years ago sikhi was dead in my area i seriously thought we are going to die out. These nam simran kirtans came out of nowehere with the blessings of great chardi kala singhs bhai rama singh and other brothers and sisters. Because of these nam simran periods weekly a large number of youths actually get together, and have become closer drawn to sikhi. This is something we must not let slip, finally our youth are coming together so we should encourage it.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

jagjit singh · 16 Apr 2005

first main app sab nu wadae dena chanda hain ki assi kisey is tra de topic tey gal kar rahey hain ki jis gal de karan naal sanu guru ji yaad tey bani hoe hai..guru charna di i want to know ..jado panj pyare armit di daat dendey ne us time oh simran di vidhi vi dasdey ne?? sikh dharam di khass gal eh vi hai ithey gurumantar luko ke (secret)nahi rakhya gaya....sab nu pata hai ki waheguru guru mantar hai jap haumey khovey panj pyarey vi guru ji da saroop hun par is time hajra hajoor satguru dhan dhan sahib shri guru granth sahib ji hun....tey guru guru sahib sanu keh rahey hun ki simro simar siman sukh pavo,kal kalesh tann mahe mitao ( vaise tey jina nu guru sahib naal pyar hai..tey dil naal simran karna chahndey ne ohna nu sab tarak vitarak chadd ke amrit shak lena chahida hai.kyo ki sanu apney kimti swass gala kar ke waste nahi karney chahidey ..sanu ajj tey time tey kisey hor gal tey yakeen hovey ya na hovey..par sanu apney guru dhan dhan sahib shri guru gobind singh ji maharaj tey ta yakeen hona chahida hai...ki je ohna ne sikha nu amrit shakan lae keha te ta sanu guru tey bharosa kar ke amrit shak lena chahida hai koi tarak nahi karna chahida hai...bec sikh da pehla faraj guru de hukam di palna karna hai is lae je koi sikh jis nu guru sahib naal pyar hai (jis nu guru sahib naal pyar nahi ho sikh hi nahi hai)us nu pehla sarey kamm chadd ke amrit shakna chahida hai) je kisey ne amrit nahi vi shakya hai tey simran karan da mann karda hai ajj to nahi balki huney to hi simran shuru kar dena chahida hai bec sadey guru sahib ke rahey ne ..simo simar simar sukh pavo..tey sadey guru saab hamesha sarbatt de bhaley di gal kardey ne..is lae simran koi vi kar sakda hai.. par assi simran kyo kardey hain??guru sahib diya khusha lein lae..guru ghar diya khsuhia ta hi milan giya je assi guru sahib da hukam manna ga dhan dhan sahib shri guru nanak dev maharaj je 10th saroop dhan dhan sahib shri guru gobind singh ji de roop vich ohna ne spl is gal tey singha nu jor dita ki amrit shakna bahoot jaroor hai..ina jaroori ki ohna ne sab to pehla app 5pyarey sahibaan kolo amrit di daat lae..hor is to wadh oh kis tra samja ke jandey sanu.......... is lae guru ghar diya khushia leinia hun tey amrit shakoo tey phir dekhoo simaran da rass,,dyan kivey lagda simran vich,,is lae jyada time na waste kariye jado jaldi to jaldi amrit sanchaar hovey amrit shak ke guru ghar diya khusia prapatt kariye..hain jiney din takk hajey amrit daat prapat nahi hoe assi simran kar sakdey hain par dil vich eh hona chahida hai jaldi to jaldi amrit shakna jaroor hai ... baki kisey nu puchan nalo ekley beth ke guru sahib da dyan karo tey jiven wal dekho sahib shri guru gobind singh ji de shyad hi koi banda hovey ga ki jehra bina amrit de reh sakey.. app ji naal apney dil de vichaar sajhey kardey je koi bhul galti ho gae hovey..kisey de dil nu dukh laga hovey main doney hath jorr ke mafi mangda tey umeed karda guru sahib tey sangat maaf karey gi waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

can't think of a name.. · 16 Apr 2005

Author: Kulbir Singh Date: 04-13-05 06:34 The issue here is whether it is appropriate for them to chant Naam, when they have not yet received Naam from Guru Sahib yet. ***** Who said its not appropriate for non-amritdhari's to do simran? Where is this stated and who by? Many thanks :-) [%sig%]

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

? · 18 Apr 2005

below is a shabad it does say they cross over when they become gurmukh but dhanna bhagat lived before Guru Nanak ji came, and then the shabad says that indra, shiv, brahma, rishis, balmik etc chant the name of God, but again they are from a different religion and lived before Guru Nanak ji came, so if they are not amritdhari how comes they are doing God name? This Shabad is by Guru Raam Daas Ji in Raag Maaroo on Pannaa 995 mwrU mhlw 4 ] maaroo mehalaa 4 || Maaroo, Fourth Mehl: isD smwiD jipE ilv lweI swiDk muin jipAw ] sidhh samaadhh japiou liv laaee saadhhik mun japiaa || The Siddhas in Samaadhi meditate on Him; they are lovingly focused on Him. The seekers and the silent sages meditate on Him as well. jqI sqI sMqoKI iDAwieAw muiK ieMdRwidk rivAw ] jathee sathee sa(n)thokhee dhhiaaeiaa mukh ei(n)dhraadhik raviaa || The celibates, the true and contented beings meditate on Him; Indra and the other gods chant His Name with their mouths. srix pry jipE qy Bwey gurmuiK pwir pieAw ]1] saran parae japiou thae bhaaeae guramukh paar paeiaa ||1|| Those who seek His Sanctuary meditate on Him; they become Gurmukh and swim across. ||1|| myry mn nwmu jpq qirAw ] maerae man naam japath thariaa || O my mind, chant the Naam, the Name of the Lord, and cross over. DMnw jtu bwlmIku btvwrw gurmuiK pwir pieAw ]1] rhwau ] dhha(n)naa jatt baalameek battavaaraa guramukh paar paeiaa ||1|| rehaao || Dhanna the farmer, and Balmik the highway robber, became Gurmukh, and crossed over. ||1||Pause|| suir nr gx gMDrby jipE iriK bpurY hir gwieAw ] sur nar gan ga(n)dhharabae japiou rikh bapurai har gaaeiaa || Angels, men, heavenly heralds and celestial singers meditate on Him; even the humble Rishis sing of the Lord. sMkir bRhmY dyvI jipE muiK hir hir nwmu jipAw ] sa(n)kar brehamai dhaevee japiou mukh har har naam japiaa || Shiva, Brahma and the goddess Lakhshmi, meditate, and chant with their mouths the Name of the Lord, Har, Har. hir hir nwim ijnw mnu BInw qy gurmuiK pwir pieAw ]2] har har naam jinaa man bheenaa thae guramukh paar paeiaa ||2|| Those whose minds are drenched with the Name of the Lord, Har, Har, as Gurmukh, cross over. ||2|| koit koit qyqIs iDAwieE hir jpiqAw AMqu n pwieAw ] kott kott thaethees dhhiaaeiou har japathiaa a(n)th n paaeiaa || Millions and millions, three hundred thirty million gods meditate on Him; there is no end to those who meditate on the Lord. byd purwx isimRiq hir jipAw muiK pMifq hir gwieAw ] baedh puraan simrith har japiaa mukh pa(n)ddith har gaaeiaa || The Vedas, the Puraanas and the Simritees meditate on the Lord; the Pandits, the religious scholars, sing the Lord's Praises as well. nwmu rswlu ijnw min visAw qy gurmuiK pwir pieAw ]3] naam rasaal jinaa man vasiaa thae guramukh paar paeiaa ||3|| Those whose minds are filled with the Naam, the source of nectar - as Gurmukh, they cross over. ||3|| Anq qrMgI nwmu ijn jipAw mY gxq n kir sikAw ] anath thara(n)gee naam jin japiaa mai ganath n kar sakiaa || Those who chant the Naam in endless waves - I cannot even count their number. goibdu ik®pw kry Qwie pwey jo hir pRB min BwieAw ] gobidh kirapaa karae thhaae paaeae jo har prabh man bhaaeiaa || The Lord of the Universe bestows His Mercy, and those who are pleasing to the Mind of the Lord God, find their place. guir Dwir ik®pw hir nwmu idRVwieE jn nwnk nwmu lieAw ]4]2] gur dhhaar kirapaa har naam dhrirraaeiou jan naanak naam laeiaa ||4||2|| The Guru, granting His Grace, implants the Lord's Name within; servant Nanak chants the Naam, the Name of the Lord. ||4||2||

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Gurpreet Singh · 18 Apr 2005

wot about the bhagats??

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

jd · 19 Apr 2005

maybe non amritdharis can do nam simran after all.

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Blobby · 19 Apr 2005

Bhaji Kulbir Singh, Please forgive me if i am wong. In reference to one of your previous posts and your line of thought, i wish to ask the following questions. 1) Define taking amrit 2) Do you think it is possible to reach sachkhand with taking this amrit? 3) Bulle shah was a Rindi (someone who follows his/her own spiritual experiences of akaal purakh). Do you believe he did not attain bliss or salvation? Phul chuk maaf- vjkk vjkf

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

Jarnail Singh Gyani "Arshi" · 19 Apr 2005

1. No one has "stated" ( at least imho)..that so and so can or cannot do naam simran.... Has anyone seen it "banned" that just about anyone can "read medical books".. Engineering books", "Boeing 747 flight manual"...BUT can this person after reading all the medical books open up a clinic and put up a sign: DR. so and so ?? or go to the nearest airport and fly a Boeing 747 ?? MAYBE...JUST MAYBE....in the olden days BEFORE the Modern MEDICAL COUNCILS and all that just about any "SIANNA" or "VAID" could prescribe medicine....BUT NOT TODAY..no matter if YOU are 100% RIGHT and ahve taken the medicine or drug yourself and know 100% it works..YOU still CANT PRESCRIBE it to anyone !!!! legally....one may be a First Class PILOT...but you just cannot fly a plane anytime you feel liek buying one.. People always bring in the BHAGATS....what makes YOU think you are in the Class of Bhagat KABEER JI/BHAGAT RAVIDASSJI ??? Do you think you are that HIGH ?? BUT yet CANNOT CHHAK AMRIT ?? and keep the REHIT ?? What makes you think Bhagat kabeer IF alive today WOULD say "NO THANKS..to AMRIT...and continue with his style of naam simran ?? Who are we to "judge" Bulleh Shah or anyone else..the QUESTION is about US..SIKHS..Here and NOW !!!! mentioning bhagtas bulleh shahs fakis sheikhs confuscious..etc wont help in any thing..the decision is YOURS. Jarnail Singh

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

jss · 19 Apr 2005

here's my take on things... i could be way off... someone told me once that you can do simran before taking amrit....but it's like accumulating money in a bank...but since you AREN't amritdhari...that currency in the bank isn't really useful....when you take amrit..that currency gets converted and any more siimran you do is direct usable currency going into the account... people mentioned bhagats...i beleive they all attained salvation, however, they were at a different time...a different mantar could have worked for them, following their own spiritual guides...and we respect that... but when guru nanak dev ji came, he brought with him the gurmantar for the kaljug..and to get that we have to take amrit...i mean, ALL the bhagats took some form of amrit from their spritual guides...guru nanak is our spiritual guide and amrit was given to all sikhs since that time and the tenth jot, sri guru gobind singh ji made this into khanday battay da amrit...if we accept them as our gurus, then we should abide by their wishes.. that all said...i would say don't rush into taking amrit...i mean...be focused, be prepared to keep rehit, be prepared to do seva, simran, sangat with love and humility....it's not easy, but it's like the joga singh sakhi goes, once we become the posession of guru ji, he becomes ours too and will guide us every step of the way.... so, to all my veers/bhens who've taken amrit, good luck with all the simran, we still have a long way to go.... to all my veers/bhens who haven't taken amrit, good luck with simran and preparing for amrit, nothing you do in the direction of spirituality can go to waste as long as you have pure heart, but the truly pure of heart will realize what steps they must take in order to become guru walay..

Re: Should non-amritdhari do simran

toombi · 20 Apr 2005

pau gianni seyah is it true when they say if you take amrit it lasts with you 7 lifetimes? or is that a myth?