Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

"public nudity"

"public nudity"

confused · 29 Mar 2005

Waheguru jee kaa khalsa waheguru jee kee fateh Just wondering what peoples opinion is on "public nudity" at harmandir sahib and other gurdwaras in india. We ask this because everytime we go to harmandir sahib we find it rather disturbing that there is no private area for men to do ishaan. Instead they do it in full public view, we realise that there is a room for the women, but why not for the men as well? We think the sight of men getting changed in front of the sangat including children goes against sikhi practice of modesty. we feel that only your husband or your wife should see you in that "form" and not for the rest of the sangat! Honsetly its not a pretty sight. We also find it curious why acts of public nudity is acceptable within the premises of harmandir sahib. dont people feel ashamed? we feel you should have some sort of sang to be not so public about it! another point, though the women have a 'room' but there are no cubicles. again we feel its awful for young women and children to have to walk into a room to see naked people! it just doesnt seem logical and where is the sense of modesty? one last point, during the morning sewa my wife was denied entrance. this was because the sewadar at the gate pointed out that she wasnt allowed due to the fact the men would not have their pyjameh on and therefore to stop women 'perving' on the singhs doing sewa. so why is it that all off a sudden men without their pyjameh on is seen as just cause to stop women doing sewa when during the day men without any clothes on is fine! it doesnt make sense and this should be changed. rooms should be made for men and women and inside the rooms there should be cubicles! for the sake of modesty at least. and before people start saying 'just dont look' umm its a bit hard when you have a 100 men roaming around naked and you have to go pass them while doing parkarma. and for the ladies, its damn hard as its such a small room! waheguru jee kaa khalsa waheguru jee kee fateh

Re: "public nudity"

grossed out · 30 Mar 2005

Fateh, With guru jee's kirpa i had the opportunity to stay at darbar sahib for several months, and i tooo wished that their was an ishnaan area for men. Some of the men who do ishnaan really really do require it. And the most disturbing thing is when they go to change their katchera's sooooooo many times they end up having their katchera halfway down their backsides exposing themselves to all the sangat behind them. I felt this was quite disturbing. Also during vasaki last year, after the kar seva the womens ishnaan area hadnt totaly been filled with water and there were bibia doing ishnaan outside of the area during the vasaki celebrations. It was to say the least quite disturbing, and no one attempted anything to stop them.

Re: "public nudity"

can't think of a name.. · 30 Mar 2005

Some very valid points by Confused. I agree it’s about time we had some decent facilities for both men and women where they can have ishnaan in peace without having to worrying about who is watching them. I don't know about anyone else but the thought of people watching me is pretty disturbing. [%sig%]

Re: "public nudity"

HMMM · 30 Mar 2005

Put a towel round yourself when you are changing your Kachere. Personally I don't find it particularly disturbing. If you don't like it, just don't look. If it was good enough in the Guru's days I'm sure it is ok now. Why not stop worrying about who is looking at you and do some Simran. It won't affect your Avastha.

Re: "public nudity"

no worries · 30 Mar 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khalsa Waheguru ji ki Fateh It can be quite disturbing on first view, when one is raised sheltered, taught to be shameful about body. The truth is each and every one is 'naked' beneath their clothes. Why should anyone feel offended to view someone else in their skin? Do feel this way when you see 'naked' animals doing whatever their business? Our creator fashioned these bodies and we are born 'naked' from our moms. Our guru provided us with 5 essentials. Kachhera and loose keski are enough to provide anyone with a measure of modesty should they so require. Any one else is able to avert their eyes if their is something they don't wish to see. Other than that we are one family with GuruGobind singh as our father and mata shaib as our mother and god as our creator. We are all brother sister what ever age. Nothing else should be of consequence. No one does anything another does not do sometime. We are happy enough to watch each other eat. This is filling an orafice. The body has nine holes. What makes anyone of them more shameful than another? It is only dasm duaar which is hidden from view by God.

Re: "public nudity"

Kulbir Singh · 30 Mar 2005

We recently were blessed with Darshan-Ishnaan of many Gurdwaras in India. We did Ishnaan just as everyone else did. We did ishnaan in open and it did not cause any problem for us, except the ones who had some tummies (stomach). By Guru Sahib's kirpa, I lost about 25 lbs there; therefore, there was nothing to be embarrassed about because I had no gogad (big tummy) anymore. hehe! Anyway, coming back to the point, I think such serene and pious is the atmosphere of our Gurdwara Sahibaan there that it does not cause any awkwardness, if you do ishnaan in open. Those who wear a proper kachherra have no problem but ones who had kachharees were definitely on the defensive. Our bhujangans and bibiyaan did ishnaan with all their clothes on. They jumped in the sarovar with all their clothes on and within half an hour or perhaps an hour all their clothes dried. Well, some of the bhujangans who went there can tell their part of tale themselves. I personally don't think there is any need for making separate sections for men now after 400 years. All sarovars have a section for bibiyaan. Kulbir Singh

Re: "public nudity"

Redwhiteandblue Kaur · 30 Mar 2005

If all a Sikh has to worry about is a trim belly and long kachheras, then that Sikh is truly lucky. However, Guruji did not make all of us alike. Some Sikhsor have\physical differences (including handicaps) that they may not want to put on display in front of others. The individuals that have the most dramatic physical differences tend to be the ones that are stared at the most...even by pious people. I've heard many people with "perfect" bodies make a blanket statement to the effect of "well, I have no problem with it, so it should be OK for everyone." I disagree. I think that a person (male or female) should have the choice to partake in an intimate activity such as showering, disrobing, or dressing with a bit of privacy. That's just my opinion though

Re: "public nudity"

gsingh · 30 Mar 2005

i agreee with bhenji

Re: "public nudity"

P Singh · 31 Mar 2005

^ I agree

Re: "public nudity"

... · 31 Mar 2005

i find some of the responses quite interesting...comments such as its just a body, y should someone feel offended to view someone in their skin...and people that have no problem with this..yet these same people are probably the ones that go around saying that the ladies shouldnt wear figure hugging clothes nor should they wear revealing clothes and dont go around with half your body uncovered...we should have respect etc etc.. so its a sin to wear clothes that show half your tummy but all of a sudden its totally fine to watch men and women pretty much naked..interesting we dont want our young children to see women half naked on the beaches yet taking them into a room with fully naked people is fine...

Re: "public nudity"

Singh 1950 · 31 Mar 2005

This never occured to me till I read this post. I think people's perception has changed of human body by watching movies etc... The thinking never used to be like this. WE should clean our minds. I am sure sangat who take the dip in sarovar go there with clean mind. [%sig%]

Re: "public nudity"

grossed out · 31 Mar 2005

FATEH ji, My problem personally wasn't with my body, I like my body. My objection was with the bodies of the men who were doing ishnaaan. You might say im biased. But some of those bodies are kinda nasty, and they wear the smallest most seee through katchera's ever. When they come out ofthe water u can see everything! Then they wrap a towel around themselves before changing katchera, but b4 the process is complete, its halfway down their hairy buttocks. And mind u they are facing the darbar at the time, so their backsides are on view to everyone. For those that say dont look, Try doing the parkarma without looking anywhere... if your eyes accidently fall upon that site, it ruins your whole spiritual state and makes u go :S!!!!!

Re: "public nudity"

when i was lil girl · 02 Apr 2005

Waheguru ji kakhalsa waheguru jiki fateh! well i been to many Gurudwara sahibs back in the days... even three years back when i went back... and to tell u the truth...as a kid i never cared...cuz hey at home my mom gave me a bath or my biji(grandmum) so basically...there was no prob.. and ofcourse you had ur underwearz.. what im trying to say is similer to what Kulbir Singh veer ji, Singh 1950 have said...the experince to me is smilier to taking bath in front of my mum or grandmum...like everyone in that place is my family(all mine...) i have felt, takin ishnaan in the sarovar(bibiya's side), the feelin of community..like we are a big family! also when i was a kid..i have taken bath in men side..and no one looks at u crazy style they see u as their own kid!(as far as my experince) you dont go to Gurdwara with that type of metality...the one you guys have described. i know most of the people in punjab go to gurdwara..do ishan so they can go get dharan of Gurusahib..no one's really there to check out people and about doing Parkaram...i have done it many times...im a woman and have never felt anything...i see everyone as my brothers, babajis(like they all sants, guru piyarey) taking bath... untill now the thought has he never crossedm my mind I NEVER THOUGHT THAT IN MY LIFE I WOULD ever HEAR/READ SUCH A THING. we are made out of mitti(earth/soil) so whats there to worry about? i guess one doesn't see other people as their own...you see "others" not "Ikonkar" ...(i think)may be that was one out of many reason that sarovers were made for...to get rid of "othersness" im disturbed to see the topic as "public nudity" (im not that old...jus between 20-23) change ur point of view..ur prespective! thaz all.. Waheguru but again it only happens when Guru sahib ji does kripa! bhul chuk muaff karni

Re: "public nudity"

blah · 03 Apr 2005

you have to realise that everyone that goes to take ishnaan isnt at the same avastaa..i mean alot of and non sikhs go there as well..and thus might find the experience of doing ishnaan quite uncomfortable..as they are simply not used to it.. also as redwhiteandblue pointed out..some people merely arent comfortable with it due to disabilities or any other issues..is that so wrong? whatsmore, everyones upbringing and avastaa isnt like how 'when i was a lil girl' described. i find your opinion extremely closed minded..does that make everyone that doesnt fall is your category a bad person? iam 20-23 as well and i disagree with you and that doesnt mean i need to change my point of view or perspective..because i acknowledge the fact that we are all individuals and are all different and i respect everyones opinions and believe that everyone has the right to their own opinion and right to privacy as much as they like. i am amritdhari and i must say that when i go to do ishnaan i dont feel comfortable..i have hardly seen any amritdhari women there..usually a bunch of punjabi ladies staring right at me the whole time..there are other ways to feel like a 'community' like sitting together in sangat doing simran or doing sewa..than having ishnaan together..i dont see it being related to sikhi or a way to enhance my spirituality..sorry just my opinion..i fully understand that its just a 'body'..doesnt mean i have to feel comfortable displaying it and this isnt gurujees time..i dont understand why people keep bringing up this argument..time has changed..alot of sikhs are now from western countries, thus have had totally different upbringings..furthermore, can we honestly compare to the true sikhs the true khalsa in gurujees time? we are nothing like that. we are full of maya and haumai..i am sure there are sikhs like that still out there but from a post earlier..someone said there are only 1000 true sikhs in the world if not less..so for the rest of us that dont fit in that 1000 have that lower avastaa, we r still trying..and do find it uncomfortable being naked in front of people... [%sig%]

Re: "public nudity"

tera baap · 03 Apr 2005

grossed out wrote: > FATEH ji, > > My problem personally wasn't with my body, I like my body. My > objection was with the bodies of the men who were doing > ishnaaan. You might say im biased. But some of those bodies are > kinda nasty, and they wear the smallest most seee through > katchera's ever. When they come out ofthe water u can see > everything! Then they wrap a towel around themselves before > changing katchera, but b4 the process is complete, its halfway > down their hairy buttocks. And mind u they are facing the > darbar at the time, so their backsides are on view to everyone. > For those that say dont look, Try doing the parkarma without > looking anywhere... if your eyes accidently fall upon that > site, it ruins your whole spiritual state and makes u go > :S!!!!! what r u a pervert, why wud u look at someones ass for sucha long time to notice its hairy? also guys missied one of kulbir singhs suggestions of going fully clothed and then drying up half an hour later.

Re: "public nudity"

when i was lil girl · 04 Apr 2005

waheguru ji kakhalsa waheguru jiki fateh im soo sorry jio@ blah i was jus puttin down what i knew...as ver ji couldnt say anything about bibianz side. im realltysorry..yes i guess i am"close minded"...:( i don't know how or from which view....but i guess i am and im happy with that....at least i dont care about who is lookin at me and who is not...am not the one tryin to have Gurudwaras to SPEND MORE MONEY ON USELESS THINGS LIKE MAKE NEW BATHS FOR INDIVIDULZ? they can go about givin the money to poor peeps man .. if you really dont feel like takin bath in front of others ...like bro ji above said...than tak ishnan in ful cloths..or i have seen some biba(my own biji) rap a clean cloth around you self...a "paran/towel" or something and do isshana. and here is another alterntive...im sure they do have bathrooms in Gurughars, all you gota do is...go take bath there instead of havin the whole Guru ghars model changed jus cuz you can't seem to have the same mentality as them! [address removed] well anyhow..about "private" thing...man if Guru sahib ji has it that way...why try to now make our "own " lil ishann places"private ones"? i thought our pupose was to follow what Guru sahib ji...follow true Gurmukh.. but here we are ...tryin to put our own mut into something thats been there for ages now... im one of thse people who hate change..lol cuz im sick of people changing the histroy of Gurudawars, and sikhi.... things thats been there for ages.. jus cuz they dont fit according to our"differences" which is our own muttt...we want them to be change them instead of understanding them..changing our own mind! (naam daan isshan) anyhow.. can some put a lil history on the sarovers...why they were made? may be than we could all learn somehting. im just talking from my own experince, and my "muut" yup im a manmukh i knwo that.. other wise i wont be here replyin to someone i dont even knwo:P..lol it would really help me! think about having lil privt baths... how many should they make? so many people come for darshan..adn everyone need to do ishhan. if they do make them then there are going to be lines..people waiting ..not knowing when the other person going to come out... ah imagin that? peopel like me wouldjus run ...lol eww the last person left the bathroom so dirty ..ewww ewww...they need some sevadas to come and clean the bathroom..lol jus my though sorry jio bhul chuk muaaf karnii

Re: "public nudity"

behind the times · 05 Apr 2005

Waheguru ji ka Khaasa waheguru ji ki Fateh Harmandir Sahib was constructed By Guru Ram Daas and completed by Guru Arjan. Since then not one of 5 Gurus including Guru gobind Singh thought it necessary to provide "cubicles! for the sake of modesty." So why should we worry about this now. As far as showing tummies...What does this have to do with anything? India is full of Saris... Guru gave us kacherra what else do we need? Prehaps to modify our mind.