Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

Amritpal Singh · 28 Mar 2005

Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told Warning from top religious authority Says marriage backers will be shunned MARTIN REGG COHN ASIA BUREAU AMRITSAR, India—The world's highest Sikh authority has admonished Sikh-Canadian MPs to block the gay marriage bill in Parliament, saying anyone who votes it into law will be ostracized by their community for flouting their religious duty. In a blunt warning to observant Sikhs, with possible repercussions on the Canadian political scene, Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti described the severe consequences facing any MP who dares to defy his directive on "the laws of nature." Interviewed in the revered Golden Temple, where he occupies the highest Sikh temporal seat, Vedanti disclosed for the first time that he personally reminded six visiting Sikh-Canadian MPs during their visit here two months ago of their religious duty to oppose gay marriage legislation now being debated by Parliament. Bill C-38, which has already passed first reading, is expected to become law this spring. "The basic duty of Sikh MPs in Canada should be to support laws that stop this kind of practice (homosexuality) — because there are thousands of Sikhs living in Canada — to ensure that Sikhs do not fall prey to this practice," he said. Dressed in a traditional white kurta cotton shirt and maroon turban, Vedanti grew impassioned as he described his occasionally tension-filled encounter with the visiting MPs last January on the eve of Prime Minister Paul Martin's official visit to nearby New Delhi. Martin had been scheduled to make a personal visit here but it was cancelled to make time for stops in Thailand and Sri Lanka in the wake of the Dec. 26 tsunami. In bypassing Amritsar, Martin avoided a potentially embarrassing encounter with Vedanti, who would have hosted his tour and waded into Canadian domestic politics. But the visiting Sikh MPs were not able to escape the stern lecture delivered by the revered religious figure, who repeated his strong wording during an interview in his private study overlooking the temple precincts where pilgrims come to worship. "I told them about Sikh teachings and how Sikhs should come forward to protect these Sikh tenets," said Vedanti, acting as the Jathedar Akal Takht — the highest Sikh authority. "The Sikh religion would never accept such MPs. Nobody would support such a person having such dirty thoughts in their mind because it is against the Sikh religion and the Sikh code of conduct and totally against the laws of nature." Sikhs around the world must maintain fidelity to these religious teachings, he argued, and no politician is exempt. Anyone who disobeys his directive risks the wrath of all Sikhs. "Most of the Sikh community would resent them, and the majority of the Sikh population living in Canada would boycott them," he predicted, referring to the more than 280,000 Sikh Canadians. Gesturing sharply with his hands, Vedanti singled out rookie Liberal MP Navdeep Bains (Mississauga-Brampton South) for daring to disagree with him during their meeting last January. "There was one Sikh MP who didn't agree," he recalled, citing Bains by name. The other visiting MPs "preferred to remain silent on this issue" and merely listened respectfully to the high priest's message. Vedanti's words were echoed yesterday by Manjit Singh Kalkatta, another highly respected Sikh preacher who sits on the governing body of the Golden Temple, the Shiromani Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee. Kalkatta, a former Punjab state cabinet minister who personally hosted a visit to the Golden Temple by former prime minister Jean Chrétien in late 2004, confirmed Vedanti's account of the encounter with the visiting Sikh-Canadian MPs two months ago. "We expect from every practising Sikh, whether he is a member of a legislative assembly or Parliament, that he would abide by his faith," Kalkatta said. If not, he cautioned, "it might be that they are censured." He described how Bains made his views known and was subjected to strong pressure to amend his views or face the consequences. "I was successful in putting a message to him that he should not espouse this cause publicly, as the Sikh people would reject that and he would lose his own people's support. He is a baptized Sikh, and must adhere to the principles of his religion." Kalkatta noted approvingly that Liberal MP Gurbax Malhi (Bramalea-Gore-Malton) stated his opposition to same-sex marriage, but expressed dissatisfaction that fellow Liberal Ruby Dhalla (Brampton-Springdale) was non-committal during her visit. "The lady MP (Dhalla) she abstained from saying anything" during the discussions in Amritsar, he said. Dhalla is believed to be leaning toward the bill but has said she will consult her constituents. Health Minister Ujjal Dosanjh, also a Liberal, supports the legislation. Conservative MPs Gurmant Grewal (Newton-North Delta) and his wife Nina Grewal (Fleetwood-Port Kells) are known to oppose it. Parliament is expected to have a free vote on the same-sex marriage issue, except for cabinet ministers who must support the bill. But the bottom line is that every vote will be closely watched by Sikh religious figures here and in Canada, Kalkatta predicted. "The advice given by the highest Sikh temporal authority to every Sikh is saying that it is unnatural and ungodly, and the Sikh religion cannot support it. When the appeal is made to every Sikh from the highest authority, then MPs come under the same thing."

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

raman kaur · 28 Mar 2005

http://www.cbc.ca/story/canada/national/2005/03/28/sikhguy-050328.html AMRITSAR, INDIA - The world's highest Sikh authority has admonished Sikh-Canadian MPs to block the gay marriage bill in Parliament, warning it is against Sikh code and "the laws of nature." Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti, the highest Sikh authority, said he personally reminded six visiting Sikh-Canadian MPs of their religious duties when they visited him in January. They were among a group of MPs travelling with Prime Minister Paul Martin. "The basic duty of Sikh MPs in Canada should be to support laws that stop this kind of practice [homosexuality], because there are thousands of Sikhs living in Canada, to ensure that Sikhs do not fall prey to this practice," he said in a report published Monday. Martin had been scheduled to make a personal visit to meet Vedanti and visit the Golden Temple in Amritsar, but it was cancelled to make time for stops in Thailand and Sri Lanka in the wake of the Dec. 26 tsunami. However, the Sikh-Canadian MPs were able to meet with Vedanti, and received a stern lecture about the importance of voting against the gay marriage bill currently being debated. Bill C-38, which has already passed first reading, is expected to become law this spring. Vedanti said he was dismayed that one MP, Ontario Liberal rookie Navdeep Bains, argued against him, but said the others listened respectfully. "The Sikh religion would never accept such MPs," said Vedanti. "Nobody would support such a person having such dirty thoughts in their mind because it is against the Sikh religion and the Sikh code of conduct and totally against the laws of nature."

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

yeo · 28 Mar 2005

Yeo one thing I dont get is how Vedanti says their is no need for Khalistan, ive heard quotes for him saying this..and how Sikhs are willing to live with India yet all the gurdwaras in Canada adorn signs of 'KHALISTAN ZINDIBAD' or 'WE LOVE KHALISTAN' Malton Gurughar and Dixie being the most noticeable around here. So there are so many issues Sikhs in Canada dont agree with him on but he is still telling us we should boycott this bill bla bla bla. I know he should be respected and he is a very intelligent man from what I know, but there are other issues that Sikhs in Canada do not agree with, so why all of a sudden is it a MUST that we must agree with this one, or we will be astrocized by the community and all that like he says.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

Amritpal Singh · 29 Mar 2005

Sikh leader's advice to MPs dismissed Faith officially impartial to gay unions Vedanti has `no understanding' of issue PRITHI YELAJA STAFF REPORTER A top Sikh leader in India who admonished Sikh Canadian MPs to not support same-sex marriage legislation has no authority to do so and, moreover, shows a remarkable lack of understanding of the issue, say some observers here. Giani Joginder Singh Vedanti — acting as the Jathedar Akal Takht, the highest Sikh authority in Amritsar — told the Toronto Star's Martin Regg Cohn this week that he warned six Sikh Canadian MPs visiting India that they would be ostracized from the community if they supported Bill C-38. "With the utmost respect, Mr. Vedanti and the Akhal Takht have no understanding of the Canadian context on this issue and have no jurisdiction to tell Canadians how to deal with it," T. Sher Singh, a Guelph lawyer and trustee of the Sikh Foundation International, said. "He's no more a priest or high priest than I am the Queen of England," Singh added. He noted that Sikhdom does not have a religious hierarchy. The Akhal Takht, whose office is across from the Golden Temple, has no authority on spiritual issues, but rather, rules on administrative and political matters facing the Sikh community in India, said Singh. Same-sex union is not an issue the Sikh religion has an official stance on, so it's up to individual MPs to follow their own conscience, Singh said. In fact, observant Sikhs, because of their religion's emphasis on human rights and tolerance, particularly for marginalized and persecuted groups, have an obligation to support the legislation, he said. "It would be wrong to oppose it because certainly gays have been mistreated and denied equal rights to date." Others point out the proposed legislation is a legal issue and not a religious one. "I'm dismayed that it's being turned into a religious issue," said Sat Gosal, a Mississauga lawyer and founding member of the Sikh Centennial Foundation. "The legislation makes it clear that there is no obligation on religious organizations to sanctify same-sex marriages. Some people who are vehemently opposed to the legislation haven't taken the time to understand that distinction and it has not been made clear to Vedanti or others in the sangat (congregation)." There is a generational divide in the Canadian Sikh community on the legislation, said Gosal. "The people who've grown up here and understand the significance of the Charter generally support it, while the sangat who haven't grown up here, don't." The issue highlights a puzzling dichotomy, said Gosal. The right of devout Sikhs in Canada to wear the five K's required of their religion — the comb, bangle, underpants and most visibly the kirpan and turban — is protected under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Bill C-38 is being proposed under the same Charter. "It's incongruous to support the Charter of Rights in one instance and then wholesale jettison it for other minorities when it doesn't suit your purpose." Liberal MP Navdeep Bains (Mississauga-Brampton South) apparently was the only one of the six MPs to disagree with Vedanti during the meeting. Bains said yesterday he tried to educate Vedanti about the legislation, telling him it doesn't "trump religious institutions" but rather extends civil rights. "We have a very diverse country and the only way minorities can coexist peacefully is (because) we have the Charter. That's what I'm trying to defend here," said Bains. "It would be a different scenario if religious institutions ... the synagogue, the church, the mandir, the gurudwara, if these institutions were not protected" under this legislation. Bains said his reasons for supporting Bill C-38 are rooted in personal experience. Growing up in Mississauga wearing a turban, he felt like an "outcast." "The only thing that allowed me to practise my faith was (the Charter.) That's why I feel very adamant about upholding the principles of the Charter because it has done so much for me on a personal level." The other five MPs could not be reached for comment. However, Liberal MP Gurbax Malhi (Bramalea-Gore-Malton) has voiced his opposition to same-sex marriage, and Conservative MPs Gurmant Grewal (Newton-North Delta) and his wife Nina Grewal (Fleetwood-Port Kells) are known to oppose it as well. Liberal MP Ruby Dhalla (Brampton-Springdale) has been non-committal, saying she will seek the opinion of her constituents. Liberal Health Minister Ujjal Dosanjh supports the legislation.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

sahajdhari · 29 Mar 2005

usuallly we disagree with vedanti, but this time the mass population supports his decision soo were going with it,,,,plain and simple

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

kaur · 29 Mar 2005

yeo jee, this gay thingi is against sikhi, a sikh can't support it. It is not matter of what Singh Sahib Vaidanti says but it is a matter of our religion first and it's big shame for those so called sikh representatives who support this bill.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

Amritpal Singh · 29 Mar 2005

The only person im really concerned with is Navdeep bains...hes the only amritdari out of the list of Mp's.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

.. · 29 Mar 2005

Bains makes a good point, charter has helped us out so many times and than when someone else wants to use it we say screw you its only for us to take advantage of. It should go both ways, if the gay mans wana use the charter and get married, let them thas what canada is about. And the bill protects places of worship from being subject to gay weddings.. so i dont see the big deal. Bottom line without the charter we would not be able to do much, i wouldnt be able to go to school with my kirpan. Man if two gay white guys, even indians wana get married who cares thas ther decision it really doesnt affect us at all. And all that talk about how it will affect society bla bla thas bull, i doubt im gona be seeing gay guys kissing outside in public and all that, they still got deceny to do all that gay stuff inside ther own homes.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

Confused · 29 Mar 2005

when i took amrit i was told by guruji's panj that i was suppose to obey Akal Takht Decision....so now this gay bill and the khalistan thing comes up....we should forget khalistan ??...and reject gay bill?

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

singhnee · 29 Mar 2005

.. jeeo, come on! Can't we keep quiet instead of accepting this bill and ignoring sikhism. Why are you guys trying to make sikhsangat fool by talking about charter charter and only charter. Why don't you ever talk about gurmat? Charter's not going to help us. It's only Waheguru who's gonna take care of his gursikhs. who care about this charter thing. If you guys don't have guts to oppose anti-gurmat issues please keep quiet for Godsake. Don't forget Guru sahib's bachan: "Jab eh gahe bipran kee reet , mai(n) naa karou(n) enkee parteet"

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

kabadi · 29 Mar 2005

pure manmat... people need to give their heads to guru ji for real, and not just pretend

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

... · 29 Mar 2005

Yet we invoke the same Charter when we ask the government to allow us to wear Kirpans...

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

Amritpal Singh · 29 Mar 2005

what if people wanted the right to marry dogs and horses? should we let that into the charter of rights?? The charter shouldnt be a document that allows activity such as homosexuality. its wrong and why should we allow its behaviour to be accepted into our laws? Its against sikhi and its also against most other religions as well.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

.. · 29 Mar 2005

whether the bill is legal or not, the issue is about sikhs falling prey to homism. what diff will the law make? homoism is der in your face as it is. sikhi does not allow it period! but im more interested in why are sikh politics being taken into another country and imposed on canadians most of whom are not sikh. it cant be enforced on society there.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

singhnee · 29 Mar 2005

... , what that mean we should support manmat too? forget charter for a second and think about our great history. Gursikhs sacrificed their lives for sikh principles and we can't keep quiet. It's funny. Asking for practice one's religion and doing besharmi(gay thing) is same for you??? I don't think so. I feel sorry for our sikh veers who are showing lower motality in this case than even christians. Every religious person is opposing this bill and SOME of our siks veers are trying to convince sangat to be agree with manmat.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

an opinion · 29 Mar 2005

What a ridiculous argument. If I allow you to wear a kirpan, what if people want to carry 4 foot swords?What if they want to bring AK-47s to school? I don't buy these "slippery slope" arguments. There is a distinction here between religious practice and the status of marriage - the two are not equivalent nor is that the intent of the bill. It simply affords recognition of a gay union as marriage. I'm an amritdhari Sikh and I have no moral, religious, or philosophical problem with this. If gay marriage was being forced down my throat so that i would have to make allowances in religious insititutions, then I would have a problem With all due respect to Jathedar Vedanti, he has no grounding in Canadian law and the implications of it on this issue. regards... Amritpal Singh wrote: > what if people wanted the right to marry dogs and horses? > > should we let that into the charter of rights?? > > > The charter shouldnt be a document that allows activity such as > homosexuality. its wrong and why should we allow its behaviour > to be accepted into our laws? > > Its against sikhi and its also against most other religions as > well.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

Amanpreet Singh Bal · 29 Mar 2005

What's Vedanti trying to prove by degrading homosexuals? People like him should think before they speak. It's normal to have different opinion but opposition must be done in a civilized and rational manner. What is Sikh Rehat Maryada's position on fake Sant Babe? Alcohol is taboo in Sikhism but few days ago State govt in Punjab held the auction of Liquor shops. Why such a double standard? For those people who are trying to equate Vedanti's statements as "word of god", I request them to get a copy of the Gurbilas Patshahi 6 and read it. If we are going to claim that whatever Vedanti says is correct and must be followed then are we going to allow the Katha of Gurbilas Patshahi 6 in our Gurdwaras? Gurbilas Patshahi 6 was edited by Vedanti and one other person and is full of anti-Sikhi material. Amanpreet [%sig%]

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

gurpreet singh · 30 Mar 2005

watever happens, jjust accept it, who cares, take it as paana, stop arguing over it hukam maniyo guru kaira, gavo sachee bani

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

ventura · 30 Mar 2005

these politicians have been democratically elected by masses. Sikhs in canada are not the masses just because a few mps are sikh and canadian. So what counts politically is what most canadians want . If these mps go against that they risk their own seat. Canada is nothing to do with sikh politics it not run according to any religion. The issue of sikhs going astray is directly one that needs to be nipped in the bud. The sikh rehat maryada if followed correctly is a shield against manmut. Most sikhs in canada if following rehat maryada would be unnafacted by homosexuality and lead greest jeevans as prescribed. Putting bans on things like this including the mona marriage bill in calcutta is typical " pindu politics". Failure of sikh gianis, leaders, jathedars, those in responsible position in organised priesthood, and their methods. It takes away the real problem that their methods are outdated in holding the sikh religion down with masses. We need effective real organised people to run the affairs of the panth that help youth. The issue of homosexuality is personally restricted to sikhs and cannot be imposed upon most electorates who do not share the same view as you. What parchar has the sgpc, or any sikh bodies doing to the youth in india or abroad on greest jeevan? or what support have they offered for your children? anyone can point a few fingers this is manmut this is wrong, you are in canada. canada is not khalistan, or punjab get a grip.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

ventura · 30 Mar 2005

to expand upon earlier point here is the current state of inneffective priesthood which is failing the whole global sikh community for many generations. http://www.panthic.org/news/125/ARTICLE/1146/2005-03-27.html?sid=85c9db407d53b27abf87a1d2b0bfcf48 the organised priesthood whos responsibility it is to guide the outside community learn about its sacred marital institituion are too busy doing their own thing. The outside community will hence be vulnerable to external influences where their own infrastructures built to protect the very future of sikhism are now being used and abused. We need effective leaderships, real parchar on the sikh way of life with service with bridges between sikh politics and sikhs. Imposing gay politics by force will create much more damage and turn sikh youths against their religion more as western education and society teaches acceptance of homosexuality. I would urge those who retort back with "dirty washing" answers to rethink about the current state of sikh politics and priesthood upon where the real problem lies.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

tera bhaap · 30 Mar 2005

Amanpreet Singh Bal wrote: > What's Vedanti trying to prove by degrading homosexuals? People > like him should think before they speak. It's normal to have > different opinion but opposition must be done in a civilized > and rational manner. What is Sikh Rehat Maryada's position on > fake Sant Babe? Alcohol is taboo in Sikhism but few days ago > State govt in Punjab held the auction of Liquor shops. Why such > a double standard? > > For those people who are trying to equate Vedanti's statements > as "word of god", I request them to get a copy of the Gurbilas > Patshahi 6 and read it. If we are going to claim that whatever > Vedanti says is correct and must be followed then are we going > to allow the Katha of Gurbilas Patshahi 6 in our Gurdwaras? > Gurbilas Patshahi 6 was edited by Vedanti and one other person > and is full of anti-Sikhi material. > Amanpreet > supporting gays is like saying saying u have a double standard too, so just because someone else makes a mistake its ok to make mistakes too? and how is this not civilized and rational as u put it? what are we animals for being staight? and have u ever seen another gay other then your self? do u kno how they act b4 u open your mouth look at what your supporting. oh and also did i mention i kno ur bains' supportor?

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

Princess of Guru Sahib · 30 Mar 2005

Amanpreet singh Bal jee, don't forget sikhi in try of supporting Bains. Your posts tell us you are a loyal supporter of bains but not a loyal sikh of Guru Sahib jee. On other hand, if you rethink seriously, you are being a big enemy of Bains by misleading him. All of his advisors are playing role of his real enemies at this time by advising him to support gay bill. Religion is above politics. In sikhi Politics without religion is nothing more than dirt. You have no right to insult our Jathedaar like that. What do you know about gurmat?. Did you ever follow it? No one can be a sikh by geting birth in sikh family. You have to adopt it by chukking amrit and offering your head(not monna head but a head with uncut hair). It's funny, you never adopted sikhi and challenging Sikh Jathedaar. I feel sorry for Navdeep Singh who has that kind of manmukh advisors. Any one can see his dark future if he does not stop following this kind of people's advises.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

Singh · 30 Mar 2005

Malhi is a Babbar Sher. Go Malhi Go. You have made all our Jatt-paindoo brothers very proud. Bains has really let the entire Sikh quom down. If he was to uphold only the charter of rights, then why did ask for our votes? Bains should learn from our Babbar Sher Malhi Bhaji.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

? · 30 Mar 2005

malhi could be a jatt or a jubilant jedi a malhi or a massai warrior. Canada is a multi ethnic multi racial country that houses people of all religions and those who do not proscribe to any religion. So perhaps it would be better to conduct a national concensus survey first those for or against the bill.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

General Narender bhullar · 30 Mar 2005

WSO has always tried to use the Sikhs as launching pads.Lets see the history they did the same in malhis nomination. They brought Jagmeet sing brar in Dixie gurudwara where he swore in front of guru sahib that he is true Khalistani and now he is saying captain and maan are Khalistani. They used the sikh vote in the nomination of bains and are now looking for the cabinet post but they will never get it niether did Inderjit bal .Guru ji will help Sikhs. Their leaders play golf with the Indian counslate they even visit their homes i hope you post this

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

kabadi · 30 Mar 2005

60% of Canadians oppose the Gay marriage legislation.. the poll has already been done, and published in newspapers... In Nav Bains riding i bet 90% of ppl oppose the bill, so there are your polls.... now maybe he should try representing Canadians and his riding... and not chasing the minister position...

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

an opinion · 30 Mar 2005

Interesting........so the tyranny of the majority is to determine this issue. There is a kirpan case from Quebec going to the Supreme Court of Canada - perhaps they should have just taken a poll of all the citizens in Quebec on whether children should be allowed to carry kirpans - "dagger-like" articles of faith into schools. How fair and reasonable would that be? The Charter protects minorities from the very thing you are proposing. regards... kabadi wrote: > 60% of Canadians oppose the Gay marriage legislation.. the poll > has already been done, and published in newspapers... > > In Nav Bains riding i bet 90% of ppl oppose the bill, so there > are your polls.... > > now maybe he should try representing Canadians and his > riding... and not chasing the minister position...

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

kabadi · 30 Mar 2005

the kirpan issue has nothing to do with the gay issue, the charter expressly has written in it that religious freedoms will be given precedence when itcomes to protect religious rights. same with rights of disabled ppl, etc.... so u cant compare gay rights with religious rights.... the charter expressly protects religious rights.... the kirpan will be allowed by the Supreme Court of Canada... look at the pandori case in brampton and mississauga that happened... the court allowed kirpans in schools in Ontario in that case...

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

kabadi · 30 Mar 2005

and MP's have a duty to represent their constituents... thats why they are elected.... bains has a duty to represent his constituents, who are mostly punjabi's who oppose gay marriages... the Judicial system in Canada is set up to fix any discrimination enacted in law by these MP's... thats the job of the courts... The job of MP's is to make sure there riding is represented in Parliament... The job of the court is that any decision made by MP's is not against the Charter... so stop expecting MP's to do the jobs of the court. MP's have to represent their constituents... otherwise the constituents will have to find someone else to represent their views...

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

Dogma · 30 Mar 2005

i agree with kabadi. It is obvious that bains was elected by the Sikh vote, the same people that he intends to ignore in order to please his party. If you're gonna rely on the Sikh vote to get you into office then you better live up to the expectations and feelings of your constituents afterwards. Also, to say that the kirpan case and same sex marriage is on the same level is absurd. As kabadi said before same sex marriage is NO WAY related to ANY type of relegious freedom. Unless the government chooses to see homosexuality as a relegion. HOWEVER, I fail to see how any of this even remotely concerns sikhs. Mr Paul Martin is not proposing that same sex marriages be carried out in Gurudwaray. He's only saying that the gov't will recognize same sex marriages. No gay man/women will be able to legally force any relegious institution in marrying them. so what's the fuss?

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

tera bhaap · 30 Mar 2005

ok i bet half of u arnt even in canada, but if u think about what the issue is it isnt about the charter its about sikhs and what our duty is. so what if we used the charter to get our religous freedoms, its only a tool and im pretty sure it wasnt the only thing used. this is like saying that women should be allowed to walk bare chested in public because thats what they want to do, because im pretty sure u cant say gayism is a religion. also no where in the candian charter of rights and freedoms does it say we cant discriminate based on sexual orientation, so there fore the charter cant be used as an excuse for gayism.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

tera · 30 Mar 2005

if someone wants to be gay and legally marry a gay partner whats it gotto do with you? wheres the sikh duty in every other problem area? drug wars? caste? gender inequality? youth? need i carry on?

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

Princess of Guru Sahib · 30 Mar 2005

>>>>if someone wants to be gay and legally marry a gay partner whats it gotto do with you? wheres the sikh duty in every other problem area? drug wars? caste? gender inequality? youth? need i carry on? <<<<<<<<< No one is questioning gays, drugies or any other problem creaters here. But Sikhs are not allowed to support above kind of paaps. Sikhi does not allow that. It's so simple.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

.. · 30 Mar 2005

There so many other issues other than the gay thing that should be addressed first. If two gay guys wana get married how in the world does it affect us, let them do what they want. It doesnt affect me directly in nooo way what so ever. Sikhi doesnt support alot things in this society but they still go on, why nto speak out against those as well.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

tera bhaap · 30 Mar 2005

tera wrote: > if someone wants to be gay and legally marry a gay partner > whats it gotto do with you? > > wheres the sikh duty in every other problem area? drug wars? > caste? gender inequality? youth? need i carry on? see wen ur called upon for ur opinion in sucha matter and u can actually effect the outcome( idont see ne vote on drug wars or castes in canada) then its a sikhs duty to stop gayism.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

an opinion · 30 Mar 2005

You're missing the point completely. In your previous post, you mention population percentages of who would support and who wouldn't support the bill in the community. What a majority has to say has no relevance on whether kirpans should be allowed in school, the same way it has no relevance as to whether any right should be denied. By stating the Charter doesn't figure into this, you're wrong. The Charter will and does come into play in this issue. Our Constitution, which includes our Charter, gives an expansive reading to issues which may not be explicitly enumerated. Going back to the Charter and s.15, I don't see how you can say the Charter does not come into play, especially given the jurisprudence on this issue. Go and consider Justice Iacobucci's judgment in Law v. Canada (Minister of Employment and Immigration) and the three step approach taken with regards to discrimination. As Sikhs, we rely on the Charter to protect our rights; it is hypocrisy to deny the protection of the Charter to another minority. We don't have to agree with the morality of gay relationships but that is different than allowing them the same protection we enjoy ourselves. regards.... kabadi wrote: > the kirpan issue has nothing to do with the gay issue, the > charter expressly has written in it that religious freedoms > will be given precedence when itcomes to protect religious > rights. same with rights of disabled ppl, etc.... > > so u cant compare gay rights with religious rights.... the > charter expressly protects religious rights.... > > the kirpan will be allowed by the Supreme Court of Canada... > look at the pandori case in brampton and mississauga that > happened... the court allowed kirpans in schools in Ontario in > that case... [%sig%]

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

an opinion · 30 Mar 2005

On a tangent, Re the kirpan..... I think the kirpan will be allowed as well but you have to keep in mind that Pandori may no longer be considered the leading authority on the case. Pandori was a tribunal decision not a court decision; however, the Ontario Court of Appeal denied leave to appeal thereby upholding the tribunal's decision. In the Multani case, the Quebec Court of Appeal has overturned the trial judgment and upheld the school board's ban of the kirpan. Some would argue that Multani is the leading authority (by virtue of being more recent) in Canada until the Supreme Court of Canada renders its decision. I think the kirpan will be allowed, not because of Pandori, but because s.1 of the Charter, which allows for the violation of rights, also demands justification. The justification is usually, and will be in this case as well, put through an Oakes analysis for justification and here it will fail. Why? Because the school/state has an obligation to minimally impair the Sikh student's right to carry the kirpan and in Multani, absolutely NO accomodation was made. In fact, the accomodation that was accepted by the Superintendant of the school and the trial court was rejected by the school board and the court of appeal. That is the argument that will win the case. regards...... kabadi wrote: > the kirpan will be allowed by the Supreme Court of Canada... > look at the pandori case in brampton and mississauga that > happened... the court allowed kirpans in schools in Ontario in > that case... [%sig%]

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

noo · 31 Mar 2005

surely it is the human right for a person to choose what they want to do in life, this is the process of democracy. if this crosses against what you believe then fine you do not have to accept it but what right do you have to push it upon anyone else? One of the worlds greatest warriors was gay alexander the great id like to see how many of you would try to force this down his gob if he was here. Just because the position of sikhi FOR SIKHS is clear on homosexuality, it does not mean you can push xyz around to accept something that is part of your religion. Canada is built on freedom, your parents left india, they chose to bring you to a land of freedom. you try to force people around with your own religious views from india thats not on.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

polka dots · 31 Mar 2005

if it is the majority mob rule case. Then how would you feel if you lived in a world full of muslims. You choose to adopt sikhism because your heart tells you to. Muslims start voting to enact laws which curb your basic life rights. All you did was follow your heart and listened to your inner voice and your basic life rights are curbed by a majority. That is grossly violating your rights. You can lift up a kirpan whats a poor gay gonna do? (unless alexander the great reincarnates) In the same way gays are following their own quest in their life, listening to their own inner voice and following their heart. I used to be against gays until i really thought about what sikhs face ourselves as a minority in moghul times and in india pre 1984 well thats not fair on others then when we get a chance to have a majority say over a minority. I do not support homosexuality but believe in acceptance if they are that we cannot hurt them more than they are already shunned by society. Instead we should do parchar on householders life and its benefits. Just like Guru ji didnt go round breaking idols of hindus like aurangzeb did he taught hindus and muslims how to pray through nam to attain salvation. restricting someones rights is wrong. The laws in most western countries were based on christian concepts church n state at the time. But now church has been seperated from state. a lot of people just are not really christian in the sense and gayism is kinda accepted. So if people are not into religion who are we to make it our point to tell them what they can and cannot do?

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

kabadi · 31 Mar 2005

WHOS SAYING TO PUSH AROUND GAYS... WHEN WE ARE ASKED FOR OUR OPINION WE GIVE IT... NAV BAINS IS AN AMRITHARI, WHEN HE IS ASKED FOR HIS OPINION HE HAS TO BASE IT ON SIKHI... BASED ON THE CHARTER, KIRPANS WILL BE ALLOWED... BASED ON THE CHARTER THE COURT LEFT IT UPTO THE COURTS ABOUT GAY MARRIAGES... You cant compare gay marriages with the kirpan issue, thats my point... even in the OAKES test for a s.1 analysis, u cant compare the kirpan issue with gay marriages... they are completely uncomparable... its like comparing a horse with an apple... it doesnt work... if ur living in fear that kirpans will not be allowed if we dont support gays... than you should have more faith in waheguru... its not the point of supporting or not supporting the charter... the point is when Sikhs are asked for their OPINION on a subject they BETTER base it on GURMAT... gay marriage legislation will pass, THATS NOT THE POINT.... the point is SIKHS have to show they are against it, whether it passes or not.. we have to stand by GURMAT... the rest is in wahegurus hands, aslong as we follow gurmat we have nothing to fear.... by supporting g ays that isnt gurmat.. we dont need to get into the details of a charter analysis, under s.15 or s.1 ... that argument will just work on ppl who dont know about the law, ppl who know about the law, know that the gay case has no impact on the kirpan case whatsoever...

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

kabadi · 31 Mar 2005

The Christian Church in Toronto also said we are standing up for our religion, why arent sikhs.... thats pure baseti, our dharm our sikhi is so amazing, but ppl wont make statements in line with Sikhi, we arent forcing anything down anyones throat... this is a democracy, Sikhs have their say, and so do others, we have to say what our religion guides us to say... and other ppl will say what they believe is right... for a SIKH nohting but GURMAT is right... we are relaxing our sikhi so much, its really dissapointing, we dont have to force something down anyones throat, but if we give an opinion it should always be based on gurmat...

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

princess · 31 Mar 2005

Request to gay supporters: Please try to understand what snagat's concern is. A sikh can't vote for any anti-gurmat bills and being Canadian citizens we have full right to reject any bills. By not voting no one is i interfering in any one else's. All other MPs are responsible citizens is Bains Special or what? All sikh jathebandies except one are rejecting this bill what's wrong with WSO members? Any one can see, if you guys don't stop supporting gay thing one day you all would have to accept it in your own homes. How would you stop your own children then? If you would try to teach them gurmat at that time they will teach you charter rights and they gonna remind you your own role played in this issue. A SIKH CAN NOT SUPPORT ANY ANTI-GURMAT ISSUES, PERIOD.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

Sohgani · 31 Mar 2005

If supporting gurmat means not being allowed to have 4 wives, then we should do everything in our power to stop that practice. If supporting gurmat means not worshipping idols, then we should do everything in our power to stop that practice. So let's do it. There's a mandir on Gore Rd., let's go smash it because their practices are anti-gurmat. What about that mosque on Torbram, you'll only see men walking in and out of there, let's go smash it. Maybe we should enforce our views on lesbians and gays too? What do you propose? If you can justify suppressing gays and lesbians by enforcing your beliefs and practices on them, then surely you can justify mughuls for suppressing us when they did for the reasons they did .

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

ok.. · 31 Mar 2005

>A SIKH CAN NOT SUPPORT ANY ANTI-GURMAT ISSUES, PERIOD.< Im not saying im for the supporting gay marriages but Sikhs can support things that are anti gurmat. Guru's openly spoke out against false Hindu rituals and practices, yet Guru Tegh Bahadur died for there right to practice these things that are anti gurmat. He wasnt nessarily supporting it just saying you should have freedom to do what you want as long as you aint hurting anyone.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

raman kaur · 31 Mar 2005

If you don't like Bains, relax. Just vote against him next time with a candidate who is against SSM. What else is there to do?

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

an opinion · 31 Mar 2005

kabadi wrote: > > You cant compare gay marriages with the kirpan issue, thats my > point... even in the OAKES test for a s.1 analysis, u cant > compare the kirpan issue with gay marriages... they are > completely uncomparable... You're just saying believe me cause i'm right - you've offered no argument. > if ur living in fear that kirpans will not be allowed if we > dont support gays... than you should have more faith in > waheguru... You're either purposely misreading what I've wrote or, no offense meant, you need to work on your comprehension skills. I'm not saying a rejection or acceptance of the gay marriage legislation will affect the Sikh right to wear kirpans. However, I have said, and continue to say, that if we as Sikhs seek the Charter's protection for our own rights, it is hypocrisy to deny that same protection to homosexuals. > its not the point of supporting or not supporting the > charter... the point is when Sikhs are asked for their OPINION > on a subject they BETTER base it on GURMAT... That depends on the subject matter. If I'm asked a mathematics question or a physics question, I'm not going to look to gurmat - it doesn't apply. If I'm asked a question on fiscal policy or union involvement in municipal politics, the same holds true. Likewise, if I'm looking to deterimine the ramification of a legal decision on Charter protected rights and freedoms, gurmat plays a limited role if any. If the question is about lifestyle, about my life, about my path and duty to others, then gurmat is the first thing to look to, as I always do. > > gay marriage legislation will pass, THATS NOT THE POINT.... the > point is SIKHS have to show they are against it, whether it > passes or not.. we have to stand by GURMAT... the rest is in > wahegurus hands, aslong as we follow gurmat we have nothing to > fear.... by supporting g ays that isnt gurmat.. Thats where we disagree - you think the issue is religious, I think it's not. I see the issue in light of legality far more than concepts of morality. If your problem is the morality of the issue, then why accept pre-marital sex? Isn't it your duty as a Sikh, and in accordance with gurmat, to argue and petition your MP's to pass a bill banning pre-marital sex? Same holds true for alchohal - isn't it your duty to follow gurmat and petition your MPs to place an absolute ban on alchohal? What about cutting hair? That is absolutely anti-gurmat - why aren't Sikhs stepping up on this issue and demanding legislation which will stop all the manmukhs in Canada from cutting their hair? The fact is, there are many, many things which we do not agree with, either due to our own religious beliefs or personal opinions. However, in a democratic society, which respects the rights of everyone, and affords even greater protection to minorities, we cannot shove our beliefs down anyone else's throat. > > we dont need to get into the details of a charter analysis, > under s.15 or s.1 ... that argument will just work on ppl who > dont know about the law, ppl who know about the law, know that > the gay case has no impact on the kirpan case whatsoever... Well, I do know the law somewhat and would be more than happy to engage you in a discussion of any analysis you wish. regards...

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

tera bhaap · 31 Mar 2005

an opinion wrote: > kabadi wrote: > > > > > You cant compare gay marriages with the kirpan issue, thats > my > > point... even in the OAKES test for a s.1 analysis, u cant > > compare the kirpan issue with gay marriages... they are > > completely uncomparable... > > > You're just saying believe me cause i'm right - you've offered > no argument. > > > > if ur living in fear that kirpans will not be allowed if we > > dont support gays... than you should have more faith in > > waheguru... > > > You're either purposely misreading what I've wrote or, no > offense meant, you need to work on your comprehension skills. > > I'm not saying a rejection or acceptance of the gay marriage > legislation will affect the Sikh right to wear kirpans. > > However, I have said, and continue to say, that if we as Sikhs > seek the Charter's protection for our own rights, it is > hypocrisy to deny that same protection to homosexuals. > > > > > > > its not the point of supporting or not supporting the > > charter... the point is when Sikhs are asked for their > OPINION > > on a subject they BETTER base it on GURMAT... > > That depends on the subject matter. If I'm asked a mathematics > question or a physics question, I'm not going to look to gurmat > - it doesn't apply. > > If I'm asked a question on fiscal policy or union involvement > in municipal politics, the same holds true. > > Likewise, if I'm looking to deterimine the ramification of a > legal decision on Charter protected rights and freedoms, gurmat > plays a limited role if any. > > If the question is about lifestyle, about my life, about my > path and duty to others, then gurmat is the first thing to look > to, as I always do. > > > > > > > > > gay marriage legislation will pass, THATS NOT THE POINT.... > the > > point is SIKHS have to show they are against it, whether it > > passes or not.. we have to stand by GURMAT... the rest is in > > wahegurus hands, aslong as we follow gurmat we have nothing > to > > fear.... by supporting g ays that isnt gurmat.. > > > > Thats where we disagree - you think the issue is religious, I > think it's not. > > I see the issue in light of legality far more than concepts of > morality. > > If your problem is the morality of the issue, then why accept > pre-marital sex? Isn't it your duty as a Sikh, and in > accordance with gurmat, to argue and petition your MP's to pass > a bill banning pre-marital sex? > > Same holds true for alchohal - isn't it your duty to follow > gurmat and petition your MPs to place an absolute ban on > alchohal? > > What about cutting hair? That is absolutely anti-gurmat - why > aren't Sikhs stepping up on this issue and demanding > legislation which will stop all the manmukhs in Canada from > cutting their hair? > > The fact is, there are many, many things which we do not agree > with, either due to our own religious beliefs or personal > opinions. However, in a democratic society, which respects the > rights of everyone, and affords even greater protection to > minorities, we cannot shove our beliefs down anyone else's > throat. > > > > > > > > we dont need to get into the details of a charter analysis, > > under s.15 or s.1 ... that argument will just work on ppl who > > dont know about the law, ppl who know about the law, know > that > > the gay case has no impact on the kirpan case whatsoever... > > > Well, I do know the law somewhat and would be more than happy > to engage you in a discussion of any analysis you wish. > > regards... uh just to clarify nowhere does it say in the charter that candians cant dicriminate based on sexual orientation. therefore that elimantes your claim that its hypocrism. if u were an sikh then gumat wud play the biggest role, if as a sikh you dont base your decisons on gurmat then whats the piont of getting amrit and offering you head to guru sahib even if arnt following guru sahibs teachings. think about it this way i f gay marriges are allowed then in school gayism wud be taught as right, while this infringes on many religous beliefs and wud you want your kids to be taught its ok to be gay?

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

tera bhaap · 31 Mar 2005

raman kaur wrote: > If you don't like Bains, relax. > > Just vote against him next time with a candidate who is against > SSM. > > What else is there to do? this isnt a question of liking, this a question priciples. how does an so called amritdharee defy the akaal takhat and we as sikhs just site there? whats the piont of him having two offices if u cant complain to him against hs goverments policies?

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

tera bhaap · 31 Mar 2005

ok.. wrote: > >A SIKH CAN NOT SUPPORT ANY ANTI-GURMAT ISSUES, PERIOD.< > > Im not saying im for the supporting gay marriages but Sikhs can > support things that are anti gurmat. Guru's openly spoke out > against false Hindu rituals and practices, yet Guru Tegh > Bahadur died for there right to practice these things that are > anti gurmat. He wasnt nessarily supporting it just saying you > should have freedom to do what you want as long as you aint > hurting anyone. do u honestly think guru sahib wud have supported this? while adultery is considred to be a bujjar kureit so is gayism. the only gud kaam there is, is the kaam for reproducing. and im pretty sure gays cant reproduce unless theres a new science maricle. also gets ur facts straight guru sahib gave his life because the kashmiri bahmans asked him to help them and sed a great souls to give up his life in sacrifice, then guru gobind singh then known as gobind rai "who else but you father can give sucha sacrifice?"

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

S!ngh · 01 Apr 2005

"However, I have said, and continue to say, that if we as Sikhs seek the Charter's protection for our own rights, it is hypocrisy to deny that same protection to homosexuals." an opinion, This is a completely false statement. There is no charter protection for homosexuals. How is it hypocricy to deny them protection? Are you equating religious freedom with the freedom to marry someone of the same gender as yourself? That's the whole debate: there is no "right" to marriage. Using your logic, the government should legalize polygamy, incestual marriage, marriage between animals and humans, and so on. (using your logic, of course) Why deny anyone the right to marry whoever they want? Society has an interest in promoting pro-creation and traditional families. Don't kids deserve a mother and a father? Having two fathers to a child could really mess society up. Why experiment with fire? Society has the right to judge specific practices to be "right" and "wrong", we're not a bunch of anarchists. We do have to govern by respecting basic sensibilities. Legalizing gay marriage sends the message that being gay is an acceptable lifestyle. It almost condones gay actions, when gay actions should not be supported by the government. Think about the message it sends. Same thing with polygamy, if the government legalized polygamy, many more people will be living with numerous wives. The government's actions have consequences. Do you know any gay punjabi youths? Probably very few, if any. In 20 years, do you think it will still be that way? No way, no chance. Not if we keep going the way we are currently. Think about your support for this bill! There is no *right* to gay marriage. None. Don't let people confuse you into thinking there is. The charter is being used as an emotional tool to confuse people's feelings. Also, the current alternative gives gay people the same benefits, while still maintaining marriage as a union between a man and a woman. Why can't we accept that compromise position? Why must we support the extreme position as supported by MP Bains? MP Grewal and MP Malhi have much more reasonable positions. We should protect gays and give them partnership benefits, but we should not send the message that there is such a thing as "gay marriage"! (Note: I actually don't mind the bill to legalize gay marriage..... just wanted to play devil's advocate for this post ;))

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

Princess · 01 Apr 2005

>A SIKH CAN NOT SUPPORT ANY ANTI-GURMAT ISSUES, PERIOD.< >>>>>>> Im not saying im for the supporting gay marriages but Sikhs can support things that are anti gurmat. Guru's openly spoke out against false Hindu rituals and practices, yet Guru Tegh Bahadur died for there right to practice these things that are anti gurmat. He wasnt nessarily supporting it just saying you should have freedom to do what you want as long as you aint hurting anyone. <<<<<<<<<<<< Ok jee, Guru jee never preached us to support anti-gurmat issues. Brahmins came to Guru jee's sharan because their lives were in danger. We sikhs are also supose to save someone's life if ever needed. It does not mean if a rapist come to us to help him to rape someone, we will help him. Don't try to misuse gurmat principle of helping a needy. You can help to save someone's life if it is in danger but you can't help someone to do paap. If gays have gone to Guru Sahib to get help, according to your philosophy, Guru sahib was going to sacrifice HIS life to get them right of doing unnatural kaam and ganda stuff??? It 's simple.If anyone of us(sikhs) have guts to go to Guru Sahib jee to do ardas that I want to have sexual relationship with kuttay, billian or with same sex, then supporting this bill is okay, if no one could do it then forget it.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

anon · 01 Apr 2005

haha, good answer by s!ngh... except for that last sentence. :|

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

an opinion · 02 Apr 2005

note: S!ngh, you're stealing my role! I actually don't care which way the decision goes, but don't mind arguing for the sake of debate if nothing else. On that note... S!ngh wrote: > "However, I have said, and continue to say, that if we as Sikhs > seek the Charter's protection for our own rights, it is > hypocrisy to deny that same protection to homosexuals." > > an opinion, > > This is a completely false statement. There is no charter > protection for homosexuals. How is it hypocricy to deny them > protection? Are you equating religious freedom with the > freedom to marry someone of the same gender as yourself? > That's the whole debate: there is no "right" to marriage. I disagree. While the Charter may not offer protection under s.2 - freedom of religion/conscience, it offers protection for discrete and insular minorities against discrimination (s.15). Homosexuals are accepted to be a discrete and insular minority. On a side note - while kirpan cases and the upcoming kirpan case will probably be tried under s.2, the result would be no different under s.15. > Using your logic, the government should legalize polygamy, > incestual marriage, marriage between animals and humans, and so > on. (using your logic, of course) Why deny anyone the right > to marry whoever they want? Well you see, now we come to the heart of the matter - social policy. Our society does not ban homosexual relationships, whether it should, is a matter for another debate. You above argument does not hold any water as polygamy, incestual marriage (we have certain degrees of consanguinity in Canada), union with animals is NOT accepted by society, is banned by our society. You cannot compare these examples with homosexual relationships unless these are examples of unions already accepted by society. Homosexual couples have the same rights as common-law couples. They are seeking same access to the term marriage as straight-couples. The term marriage alone does not impose any obligations on religions or religious institutions. I believe it was the same sex reference, in the SCC, where the court expounded on freedom of religion. > > Society has an interest in promoting pro-creation and > traditional families. Thats a good argument. And so far, in my opinion, the best argument for why the matter is being sent back to the legislators - it's not the court's place to push social policy. However, history has shown that courts are often years ahead of legislators when it comes many issues. ie. segregation of black/white students in the states. > Society has the right to judge specific practices to be "right" > and "wrong", we're not a bunch of anarchists. If by the above you are referring to social policy, then you already have a conservative agreement from above; however, if you are stating a majority rule position, I would have to disagree. We are not allowed to wear kirpans because the majority agrees with us but because the Charter protects us. The protection of the Charter against majority rule is not reserved for Sikhs alone - other minorities fall under that protection as well. Same thing with polygamy, if the government > legalized polygamy, many more people will be living with > numerous wives. A point of interest - polygamy is allowed in Pakistan. While I do not have hard statistics, Pakistani aquaintances have indicated the number of men with more than one wife is less than 1%. Moreover, in Canada, we're allowed to have as many spouses as we want. We can have 20 or 30 spouses, just not at the same time.... lol > > Do you know any gay punjabi youths? Probably very few, if any. > In 20 years, do you think it will still be that way? No way, > no chance. Not if we keep going the way we are currently. Now you're stretching your argument too far :) You've offered a hypothesis free of any fact. First, you're assuming a person can become a homosexual due to social policy. I see no facts supporting this assumption. Second, just because neither you nor I know of any gay Punjabi youths, doesn't mean there are not a large number of them - they may not be public about it. Either way, an assumption. Third, if homosexuality is, and I'm not saying it is, a biological "malfunctioning", by virtue of an increasing population, we are bound to see more gay Punjabi youth. > Think about your support for this bill! There is no *right* to > gay marriage. I'm not sure you're characterizing the argument correctly. Please correct me if I'm wrong, but gays are wanting their already accepted unions to be granted the same designation granted to straight couples. > The charter is being used as an emotional > tool to confuse people's feelings. Some may get confused, but the Charter is being used for legal argument not merely emotional appeal. As far as I am aware, and again, correct me if I'm wrong, but the Charter has not been deemed legally inapplicable to same-sex discrimination. > (Note: I actually don't mind the bill to legalize gay > marriage..... just wanted to play devil's advocate for this > post ;)) I hear ya ;) regards. [%sig%]

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

S!ngh · 02 Apr 2005

[playing devil's advocate - one more time] an opinion, Here's the thing, marriage, by it's very definition, is an opposite-sex institution. It is. It really is. Changing the legal definition of "marriage" (as opposed to simply providing partnership benefits for gay couples) is something called "social engineering". It's creating something that isn't currently a reality. Why can't we just provide them with the same partnership benefits, while we stick with marriage as what it is? (i.e. an opposite-sex institution) It would re-affirm the traditional family, before we slip into the slippery-slope of even more radical attempts to change society as we know it. Polygamy is considered a religious right by some Muslims and even UK Nangs! Who are we to deny them the right to marry numerous wives? Who does it hurt? If the adults consenting to such an arrangement consider it fine for themselves, who is society to judge? Why doesn't society just affirm that decision with a marriage license? You know why they shouldn't? Because it's wrong! Polygamous marriages inevitably hurt women, and gay families inevitably hurt children. We have to examine the social consequences of our actions before simply going "we love the charter! the charter protects human rights! gay marriage is a human right! yeah!" -S!ngh

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

o · 03 Apr 2005

singho ji heres a question i have limited understanding of homosexuality, what do scientific pchycological studies show on the subject in regardes to a person being homo is it natural for them or are these habits taken on from sangat around them?

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

Kulbir Singh · 11 Apr 2005

The reality is that the Gay Bill is not about freedom of Gays or anyone else. They have all the freedom they need here in Canada. The crux of the problem is that they want to use a word that is sacred to religions, to define their sexual union. Why do they want to use a heterosexual term to define their sinful relationship? The term "marriage" for centuries, throughout the world has been used to define the union of a heterosexual couple. This term is a sacred term for most religions. Why are they insisting on calling their union a “marriage”? They already have all the rights they need because of the law they have passed for “civil union”. You talk about the rights for Gays. What about the rights of religions in Canada? Today the Gays are asking that the term “Marriage” be used to define their sexual union. Tomorrow they will say that they want “Nikah” (a Muslim religious word for marriage) to define their marriage. Later they may file a lawsuit to have the Sikh holy word for the union of heterosexual couples “Anand Karaj” to define their sexual union. Where will this nonsense stop? Today they are asking us to accept their homosexual sexual union as “Marriage” or “Anand Karaj” or “Nikah”. Tomorrow some perverted people may want to marry their pets like dogs and they may want to call it a “marriage”. Are we going to accept that? It is time to stop this zaleel conduct now. If they want to do something like this they should do it in their bedrooms. Why are they defiling the whole society? Why do they want the society to stamp their abnormal sexual union? Anyway, let us come back to Sikhi. What should a Sikh do today in the light of the government proposal to pass the law to allow the sacred term of “Marriage” to be used to define the sexual union of two homosexual persons? There is no obscurity in Sikhi about this issue. Siri Akal Takhat Sahib has declared very openly that Sikhs are not to indulge in this kind of sexual activity and that Sikhs are not to support any such legislation that may result in the degeneration of the society. Apart from Siri Akal Takhat Sahib, SGPC has openly said that the homosexual conduct is not in accordance to Sikh faith. It is now time for Akhand Kirtani Jatha and Damdami Taksal to issue statements discouraging such conduct in Sikhs. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

gt · 11 Apr 2005

hey guys check this i found it on another website "Religious Faithful Rally in Support of Same-Sex Marriage Legislation" RELIGIOUS FAITHFUL RALLY IN SUPPORT OF SAME-SEX MARRIAGE LEGISLATION Multi-Faith Coalition Issues a Joint Statement to Demonstrate Faith-Based Support for Civil Same-Sex Marriage -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Toronto, Ontario, April 11 /PR Direct/ - "We believe that in an environment where religious beliefs are being used to fuel arguments for and against same-sex marriage, it is essential that politicians recognize the diversity of views that exist within faith communities," says a religious coalition that includes Buddhists, Christians, Hindus, Jews, Muslims, Quakers, Sikhs and Unitarians. The comments were made at a news conference in Toronto today where representatives of the Religious Coalition for Equal Marriage Rights issued a joint multi-faith statement of support for civil same-sex marriage. Today's news conference also highlighted a series of multi-faith events supporting same-sex marriage that happened in cities across Canada this past weekend. These events were held in Halifax, Ottawa, Toronto, Calgary and Vancouver. The Religious Coalition for Equal Marriage Rights includes representatives from liberal and traditional faith communities in Canada, including The United Church of Canada, the Canadian Unitarian Council, the Muslim Canadian Congress, the Canadian Friends Service Committee of the Religious Society of Friends (Quakers), the World Sikh Organization, Canadian Rabbis for Equal Marriage, Metropolitan Community Church, Ahavat Olam Synagogue (Vancouver), Church of the Holy Trinity (Anglican) in Toronto, the Apostolic Society of Franciscan Communities-Canada, and liberal and progressive members of the Buddhist, Catholic, First Nations, Hindu, Mennonite, and Muslim communities. Jane Orion Smith of the Canadian Friends Service Committee (Quakers) says the Religious Coalition for Equal Marriage Rights came together with the common purpose of demonstrating faith-based support for civil same-sex marriage by a wide range of religious groups. "The diversity of opinion about same-sex marriage that exists within Canadian society is also present within many different faith communities in Canada," says Smith. She hopes that today's news conference, the signing of the multi-faith statement and this past weekend's religious rallies will signal to politicians that the faithful do speak with more than one voice on the issue of same-sex marriage. Richard Chambers of The United Church of Canada agrees. "We want to dispel the myth that if you are a person of faith, you must be opposed to same-sex marriage," says Chambers. Rabbi Ed Elkin, of Canadian Rabbis for Equal Marriage, explains that the law already allows for civil marriage for couples that some religious groups would refuse to marry. He says all members of the Religious Coalition for Equal Marriage Rights believe that, as a matter of individual and religious freedom, anyone who wishes to participate in a civil same-sex marriage recognized by law should have the right to do so. "This issue is not a conflict between freedom of religion and secular equality values or between the lesbian and gay male communities and people of faith, but rather it is a debate between people of differing religious beliefs and values," says Elkin. Linda Thomson, of the Canadian Unitarian Council, comments that the coalition is confident that Bill C-38 respects diversity and tolerance and grants religious freedom to clergy and religious groups to make their own choice whether to perform ceremonies equally for all loving adult couples. "The right to refuse is fully protected by Bill C-38," says Thomson. Amanpreet Singh Bal of the World Sikh Organization agrees. "Bill C-38, the Civil Marriage Act, upholds the religious freedom of those opposed to same-sex marriage and will not discriminate against them any more than legal recognition of divorce did in the last century." He says the religious coalition's statement unequivocally supports the right of those faiths with contrary views to continue to refuse to perform same-sex marriages. Tarek Fatah of the Muslim Canadian Congress believes that same-sex marriage legislation is about fundamental and universal human rights. "Members of many of our communities are from racial and religious minority groups that themselves experience discrimination, and we understand that human rights as guaranteed in the Charter of Rights and Freedoms must extend to everyone, including gay men and lesbians. Same-sex marriage is a human right," says Fatah. He adds that the guarantee of freedom of religion in our constitution and in the legislation ensures that every Canadian will continue to have the right to practice their religion as they see fit. "No mosque, church, gurdwara, temple, or synagogue will ever have to conduct a same-sex marriage if they do not wish to," says Fatah. "But freedom of religion cannot come at the cost of limiting the rights of other groups in society." http://www.sikhnet.com/Sikhnet/news.nsf/SikhNetHPNewsHTML/F17F694E76688CA587256FE000669262?OpenDocument

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

sk. · 11 Apr 2005

I agreeeeeee. I think even voting for gay marriage supporters is wrong!

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

@~~~~~~~~~~ · 12 Apr 2005

gays and lesbians have asked to be legally married but not in religious places so far. If they did it would be upto the committees who run religious places to say NO instead of thinking about lining up their pockets.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

singh · 12 Apr 2005

The bill actually protects religious places from having to perform a gay marriage.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

? · 13 Apr 2005

what is a religion? and what right does religion have to lay the law on anyone else? a gay is a gay we have to accept them. If your kid decides to become a bender thats their life why do you fear when Guru sahib is near? if your kid leads rehit then no bending. but still you cannot lay anything onto someone else thats intolerance. if marriage is a sacred instituition of religion only then why do we not stop punjabi sikhs from marriing their cousins to get entry into canada?? why do all religious people not gather to stop 15% of the islamic world marrying according to muttah shiite tradition where a man marries a woman for temporary pleasure and then over in 15 days all guided under religion? all the groom needs to do is buy loads of gifts.

Re: Reject gay bill, Sikh MPs told

S!ngh · 14 Apr 2005

Kulbir Singh has it exactly right. There isn't anything wrong with the government saying that heterosexual relationships are more valuable than homosexual relationships. It's a fact - and we shouldn't be so politically correct to avoid recognizing such an obvious fact. ;)