Re: nindha vs joking
Kulbir Singh · 25 Mar 2005
--------
If you tell the joke for the purpose of being funny and accidently offend a few people by mistake, can this be nindhia? Or can it be nindhia if you only wanted to tell a joke? everyone has their own sennse of humour but still.
--------
If you think you have offended someone, then the best thing is to apologise. It is quite possible that sometimes we joke and it may offend someone. In such cases, we should apologise.
As for nindiya, it is defined as badmouthing someone when that person is not guilty of that offense.
Kulbir Singh
Re: nindha vs joking
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 25 Mar 2005
Saadh Sangat ji,
follow - up question:
Is Nindiya still Nindiya if you are not aware that you are doing it? (If the Bhaavnaa of doing Nindiya is not there)
vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa
vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!
Re: nindha vs joking
Kulbir Singh · 25 Mar 2005
Someone,
You are right. It is wrong to badmouth anyone regardless of whether that person has committed an offense or not.
What I really wanted to say was that in some cases, it is not wrong to speak the truth and then speaking the truth is not considered as nindiya. Gurbani is full of such truths about pakhandi pandits, pakhandi sants etc.
Kulbir Singh
Re: nindha vs joking
Sinner of Sins · 25 Mar 2005
Kulbir Singh,
Nindha is wrong regardless of if it's the truth or not. And if someone has done summink bad, then talking about them is like putting their sins in your mouth.
Are you saying that it's justifiable to talk about someone when they have done summink wrong just coz' we are meant to speak the truth?
In Gurbani, there are also pangtees about how we should concentrate on ourselves, look at OUR own faults before others.
I feel quite let down by your comment Kulbir Singh Ji. Many people look up to you so you need to make yourself justifiable as to what GURBANI says.
Re: nindha vs joking
Dalrajkaur Khalsa · 25 Mar 2005
I agree with Kulbir Singh. Speaking the truth can mean preaching about something to spread awareness about that paticular thing. Take the Mann Su case, everyone spoke the truth about the type of person he is when they were telling others. Would that be ninda? No! It is telling the truth about the man.
Doing ninda of anyone is wrong. We should not badmouth anyone, but when it comes to stating facts about these pakhandis then it is okay.
Dalrajkaur Khalsa
Re: nindha vs joking
Kulbir Singh · 25 Mar 2005
When we talk about and bring awareness about the sins of KPS Gill and discuss how he tortured our Sikh youth, are we committing Ninda?
When talk about Hitler killing jews and other innocents, are we committing Ninda?
When Gurbani talks about Harnaaksh and Dhrishtbudhi, and condemms them, is it doing ninda?
When Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj calls Jainis (a religion of India) "Sirr khuthai shataani" i.e. skin-head satans, was he doing ninda?
The answer to above questions, in my opinion is "No".
Guru Sahib has stopped us from both Ustat and Ninda.
What is Ninda?
Ninda is to say bad about someone when that person does not have that badness. Such conduct is bad and a Gursikh must avoid it.
What is Ustat that Guru Sahib does not want us to do?
Ustat that is prohibited to Gursikh is the exact opposite of Ninda i.e. to say something good about someone, when that person does not have that goodness.
Having said this, I must also repeat that to publicise innocent shortcomings of others should not be done and is wrong in Gurmat. But if someone's bad conduct is seriously affecting the society or anyone, then it must be stopped.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: nindha vs joking
Sinner of Sins · 26 Mar 2005
Dear Kulbir Singh
How about the tuk :
NINDHA BHALI KISAI KEE NAHI ||
?????????????????????????????????????
Re: nindha vs joking
can't think of a name.. · 26 Mar 2005
Sometimes when I crack a joke some people don’t get it and take it the wrong way simply because their sense of humour is completely different to mine and it’s the same when they crack a joke, I don’t see the humour in it..
It depends on who is cracking the joke and whether the people around have a similar sense of humour or not.. Just because a joke is taken the wrong way, it does not mean that the person who said it means whatever they are on about in a negative or mocking way, its just sometimes we just may not get someone’s sense of humour..
[%sig%]
Re: nindha vs joking
Dalrajkaur Khalsa · 26 Mar 2005
Why would you be making fun of the way Singh's do simran? For making fun of the way Singh's do simran, you will be getting 'pop' from guru ji.
AKJ does Sas garas which is taught by the punj pyaaray. Why do people see the need to make fun of it? Instead people should explain to children about sas garas.
Dalrajkaur Khalsa
Re: nindha vs joking
replying to "question" · 29 Mar 2005
"question" no you are not doing nindya, you are doing something much much worse. you are mocking people who are full of piaar and attempting to connect with their guru.
it doesnt matter if people start screaming, or their dastars fall off in any keertan we should not joke about it because what they do is between them and guroo. maybe you should work on your own spirituality before you joke about how others express theirs.
Re: nindha vs joking
Govind Singh · 29 Mar 2005
Fateh ji,
I too am curious about this as well.. many times i've heard people telling stories about others and joking about it. None of the people know whether its true or not, and not really fussed, they just do it to laugh. And they dont really believe it either.... i guess its not right, but is this really considered nindiya???
Fateh