Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

nindha vs joking

nindha vs joking

question · 25 Mar 2005

I have a question which is bothering my brain and I want an IMMEDIATE answer from all of you people out there in cyberspace / world wide web. If you tell the joke for the purpose of being funny and accidently offend a few people by mistake, can this be nindhia? Or can it be nindhia if you only wanted to tell a joke? everyone has their own sennse of humour but still.

Re: nindha vs joking

Kulbir Singh · 25 Mar 2005

-------- If you tell the joke for the purpose of being funny and accidently offend a few people by mistake, can this be nindhia? Or can it be nindhia if you only wanted to tell a joke? everyone has their own sennse of humour but still. -------- If you think you have offended someone, then the best thing is to apologise. It is quite possible that sometimes we joke and it may offend someone. In such cases, we should apologise. As for nindiya, it is defined as badmouthing someone when that person is not guilty of that offense. Kulbir Singh

Re: nindha vs joking

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 25 Mar 2005

Saadh Sangat ji, follow - up question: Is Nindiya still Nindiya if you are not aware that you are doing it? (If the Bhaavnaa of doing Nindiya is not there) vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!

Re: nindha vs joking

Someone · 25 Mar 2005

Kulbir Singh, your argument is flawed. you say _ As for nindiya, it is defined as badmouthing someone when that person is not guilty of that offense. _ you should not badmouth someone even whey they ARE guilty of an offense. nindiya is telling bad about someone behind their back. no one should ever badmouth someone regardless of their involvment in the offense. thank you. [%sig%]

Re: nindha vs joking

Kulbir Singh · 25 Mar 2005

Someone, You are right. It is wrong to badmouth anyone regardless of whether that person has committed an offense or not. What I really wanted to say was that in some cases, it is not wrong to speak the truth and then speaking the truth is not considered as nindiya. Gurbani is full of such truths about pakhandi pandits, pakhandi sants etc. Kulbir Singh

Re: nindha vs joking

Sinner of Sins · 25 Mar 2005

Kulbir Singh, Nindha is wrong regardless of if it's the truth or not. And if someone has done summink bad, then talking about them is like putting their sins in your mouth. Are you saying that it's justifiable to talk about someone when they have done summink wrong just coz' we are meant to speak the truth? In Gurbani, there are also pangtees about how we should concentrate on ourselves, look at OUR own faults before others. I feel quite let down by your comment Kulbir Singh Ji. Many people look up to you so you need to make yourself justifiable as to what GURBANI says.

Re: nindha vs joking

tera bhaap · 25 Mar 2005

uh cud u tell me the difference between badmouthing and talking bad about someone?

Re: nindha vs joking

Dalrajkaur Khalsa · 25 Mar 2005

I agree with Kulbir Singh. Speaking the truth can mean preaching about something to spread awareness about that paticular thing. Take the Mann Su case, everyone spoke the truth about the type of person he is when they were telling others. Would that be ninda? No! It is telling the truth about the man. Doing ninda of anyone is wrong. We should not badmouth anyone, but when it comes to stating facts about these pakhandis then it is okay. Dalrajkaur Khalsa

Re: nindha vs joking

Kulbir Singh · 25 Mar 2005

When we talk about and bring awareness about the sins of KPS Gill and discuss how he tortured our Sikh youth, are we committing Ninda? When talk about Hitler killing jews and other innocents, are we committing Ninda? When Gurbani talks about Harnaaksh and Dhrishtbudhi, and condemms them, is it doing ninda? When Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj calls Jainis (a religion of India) "Sirr khuthai shataani" i.e. skin-head satans, was he doing ninda? The answer to above questions, in my opinion is "No". Guru Sahib has stopped us from both Ustat and Ninda. What is Ninda? Ninda is to say bad about someone when that person does not have that badness. Such conduct is bad and a Gursikh must avoid it. What is Ustat that Guru Sahib does not want us to do? Ustat that is prohibited to Gursikh is the exact opposite of Ninda i.e. to say something good about someone, when that person does not have that goodness. Having said this, I must also repeat that to publicise innocent shortcomings of others should not be done and is wrong in Gurmat. But if someone's bad conduct is seriously affecting the society or anyone, then it must be stopped. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: nindha vs joking

question · 25 Mar 2005

no no you misunderstood question! i meant if i tell a joke about akj like the way they do simran scares away little kids, would that be nindha if i was only trying to be funny?

Re: nindha vs joking

Sinner of Sins · 26 Mar 2005

Dear Kulbir Singh How about the tuk : NINDHA BHALI KISAI KEE NAHI || ?????????????????????????????????????

Re: nindha vs joking

can't think of a name.. · 26 Mar 2005

Sometimes when I crack a joke some people don’t get it and take it the wrong way simply because their sense of humour is completely different to mine and it’s the same when they crack a joke, I don’t see the humour in it.. It depends on who is cracking the joke and whether the people around have a similar sense of humour or not.. Just because a joke is taken the wrong way, it does not mean that the person who said it means whatever they are on about in a negative or mocking way, its just sometimes we just may not get someone’s sense of humour.. [%sig%]

Re: nindha vs joking

Dalrajkaur Khalsa · 26 Mar 2005

Why would you be making fun of the way Singh's do simran? For making fun of the way Singh's do simran, you will be getting 'pop' from guru ji. AKJ does Sas garas which is taught by the punj pyaaray. Why do people see the need to make fun of it? Instead people should explain to children about sas garas. Dalrajkaur Khalsa

Re: nindha vs joking

Dogma · 28 Mar 2005

I agree with Dalraj Kaur... no need to make fun of someone doing simran. If that's the only thing that you can use as comedy "material"...then honestly you're not as funny as you think. search elsewhere...joking or not joking, making fun of the way someone does kirtan/simran/seva can HURT their progress if they feel hurt...which is a sin that i wouldn't want on MY head.

Re: nindha vs joking

Bamba · 28 Mar 2005

The way akj does simran can be funny sometimes. Like i seen someone shaking his head so much his distaar fell off, im sorry but according to my sense of humour that is joke.

Re: nindha vs joking

replying to "question" · 29 Mar 2005

"question" no you are not doing nindya, you are doing something much much worse. you are mocking people who are full of piaar and attempting to connect with their guru. it doesnt matter if people start screaming, or their dastars fall off in any keertan we should not joke about it because what they do is between them and guroo. maybe you should work on your own spirituality before you joke about how others express theirs.

Re: nindha vs joking

KHALISTANI · 29 Mar 2005

akj simran is different but what ever makes them concentrate and do there simran better cant be bad. i heard that in a smaagam in india an akj singh wearing a chakir in his dastaar hit another man knocking him out. but still we shouldnt joke about such things.

Re: nindha vs joking

SriSahib · 29 Mar 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!! Sangat jee, further questions in response to some of the above that haven't been directly answered: what exactly is 'bad-mouthing' someone? One can state facts of actual occurences. Then other people can go and look too deeply into it to suit their own agendas. This is what bothers me- they are trying to be clever dicks and laugh at innocently made comments. Dar kae bolnaa chaheedaa for the sake of these idiots who think they an speak in their obsessional language all the time?! Don't try and live your sad lives through other people. Duhhhhhhhhhh. Dooae daa dil dukhoanaa changee cheej nahee. Who is it get your own back time for????? Ask yourself whether you're trying in EARNEST to teach yourself something good about life or whether you reckon you've got it all- i.e. the answers to life's riddles- and are dropping sick hints to the riddle. Gursikhs can joke and have a laugh but it should not be at the EXPENSE of another. We are here to LEARN from eachother and NOT 2 take the p*ss. Dis das thinks sum of you will know what I am on about. The other more ignorant ones will probably just stay stuck in their own little ruts. Pathetic IMHO! Respect for individuality and human (yes- not just the Homo sapiens animal species!) rights. Bhul chuk maaf karnee jees, but sometimes the TRUTH hurts especially when you're trying to hide it or disguise it. But beware, at the end of the day the brutal truth will out. The FAITHFUL will be victorious! Chardee Kalaa! Gurfateh!! P.S. 'Khalistani' (does it really need to be highlighted in caps- seems you are locked into that narrow-minded frame of mind)- do I spot jatha bashing there?? Who ju fooling hey?! Why make comments on stuff you 'heard' or even witnessed BUT don't even know, let alone UNDERSTAND those involved. Some people are very quick to make roalaa. Raaaaaaaaaaaaarrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr but WHY?????????????????? and why here???????????????would you say the same to those Singhs faces? Probably not, coz like gutless freaks quake in their bandar kachees (maybe disguised as a kascheraa without the aslee bhavnee) at the mere site of such Naam Raseeaae Gurmukhs. Aap Japo, avreh NAAM japavo. Have you even got that level of Abhyaas or kamaee to control. Seems some/ most peeps cannot even control their mouths par Naam japan valae nindhaa nikal jandee bardee soakee. And like BTW there's no such thing as 'akj simran'. You've just proven you're idioticity by that phrase. Just as Amrit as amrit- Khandae kee pahul. In the same way, 'simran' is remeberence of Waheguru through His Name. Sure, everybody may have different techniues, but that is based on their karam and level of spirituality. It is stoop-Eds who are very quick of the mark to put on labels. That's belittling Guru Sahib as well as His Gursikhs. Anyway, seems we are wasting our time beating about the bush. Now let us ask OURSELVES, have we learnt anything from reading this thread- or are you just gonna go away taking it at face value? Teachings should be TRIED to be applied. Maybe there isn't always 1 tried and tested way though. Open your minds pip-squeaks! Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!

Re: nindha vs joking

anon · 29 Mar 2005

we shouldnt make fun out of simran but if ur dastaar falls off then 2 of ur kakaars fall off and tht isnt so great

Re: nindha vs joking

singhnee · 29 Mar 2005

>>>>> i meant if i tell a joke about akj like the way they do simran scares away little kids, would that be nindha if i was only trying to be funny? <<<<< >>>>> The way akj does simran can be funny sometimes. Like i seen someone shaking his head so much his distaar fell off, im sorry but according to my sense of humour that is joke. <<<<< I have a bentee to above writers to read 'Rangle Sajjan' page 83, third paragraph please. There was a Ganga Singh who used to make fun of abhyaas of AKJ singhs. Please read the rest and learn lesson.

Re: nindha vs joking

question · 29 Mar 2005

i still dont got an answer and don't take that joke literally. i used the example of akjs because i said something previously which was meant to be in humour twas not to belitte jatha in any way, but when i re-read it seen that it could be viewed as offensive. i know you shouldn't do things that offend others on purpose, but the question here was what if you do offend others when you were only trying to tell a joke and did not mean to be offensive?

Re: nindha vs joking

Govind Singh · 29 Mar 2005

Fateh ji, I too am curious about this as well.. many times i've heard people telling stories about others and joking about it. None of the people know whether its true or not, and not really fussed, they just do it to laugh. And they dont really believe it either.... i guess its not right, but is this really considered nindiya??? Fateh

Re: nindha vs joking

Haha · 30 Mar 2005

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!! Why the need to discuss and have 'curiosity' about the issue in the first place. Earn your kamaee through seva, simran and sacrifice- with Amrit being an essential requisite- then das is pretty sure Guru Sahib will reveal His wonderful 'secrets' to 2 u........ IMHO it's pointless for us to try and class what's been said as nindyaa or not. Why not just try to think a little more about what you're gonna say and why and whether there'll be any faida in saying it. Guru Ji tells us about nindha and it's dangers kinda like a warning. But then we are all liable to slipping here and there- it's called being human. A Gursikh piaara said when you feel unsure about this do the shabad: 'Kaam krodh Lobh jchoot NINDAA, in thae AAP schadaavaoe HAR JAN MANGAL GAVOE' Also, 'jokes'- why do they need to be made of obviously religious stuff anyway, where there is a high risk of hurting other people's sentiments. Isn't there plenty of other things to have a laugh about. Hint: take a look in the mirror! LOL. Bhul chuk dee khimaan bakshanee jeeo. Let's stay in High Spirits :@) Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa! Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh!!

Re: nindha vs joking

Premi · 30 Mar 2005

Kulbir Singh is correct. Nindiya is when we speak of somebody with the intention of making them out to be worse than what they actually are - i.e. you are spreading falsehood. But, there is nothing wrong with speaking about somebody if what you are saying is BOTH true AND useful. If it isn't USEFUL then it is considered Chuglee (gossip). A useful test before you speak is to ask yourself whether you would say the same to the face of the person you are talking about. Making fun of somebody isn't necessarily Nindya, but it is coming very close to the mark. A joke from one mouth can be taken as truth by another's ears. Therefore, only joke about something which can not possibly cause offence. Use yourself as the butt of all your jokes - this will actually help you to defeat HauMai. Regarding joking about somebody's Simran - this is worse than Nindiya as it destroys the Pyar and respect you may have had with Guru Ji's SaadhSangat. Without SaadhSangat we are nothing. There are so many people you can point your jokes at, but out of all of them, if you find SaadhSangat to point your jokes at, then your fate is miserable. Such behaviour and thoughts are why we are sheep in lion's clothings, devoid of spiritual ecstasy.