Forum
NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
BHOPINDER SINGH · 19 Mar 2005
NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Wagah, March 19
The Government of Pakistan is contemplating to allow non-resident Indian Sikhs to construct their houses at Nankana Sahib, the birthplace of Guru Nanak Dev, on a request of the Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Management Committee (DSGMC).
This was disclosed by Mr Paramjit Singh Sarna, president, DSGMC, at the Wagah joint check-post here today. Mr Sarna said he had taken up the matter with Chaudhary Pervaiz Elahi, Chief Minister, West Punjab, and top bureaucrats of Paksitan who had agreed to explore the possibilities of establishing a big colony of NRI Sikhs. At present, there was no provision for allowing any Indian or NRI Sikhs to build their houses in Pakistan. He said if the proposal materialised, it would be a big step in the overall development of Nankana Sahib.
In yet another important move, the Government of Pakistan may open Gurdwara Bair Sahib, Sialkot, to the Sikh sangat. The building of the gurdwara is in a dilapidated condition. Mr Sarna said the Pakistan Evacuee Trust Board might undertake the repair work of Gurdwara Bair Sahib through ‘kar sewa’ as per Sikh maryada. The gurdwara was built in honour of Guru Nanak Dev who had reached Sialkot via Jammu and found the city in the grip of terror at that time. Guru Nanak mitigated the sufferings of residents. Hazrat Hamza Ghaus, a seer, annoyed with a local resident, had cursed that the town would be doomed after 40 days of his meditation. It is believed that Guru Nanak Dev had saved the town from being doomed.
Asked as to why top bureaucrats of Punjab, who accompanied Capt Amarinder Singh to Pakistan, were denied ‘siropa’ (robe of honour) in a gurdwara there, he said it was on account of their being apostate. He said such a development should be an eye-opener for the SGPC, which had been honouring apostate dignitaries and denying ‘siropa’ to Gursikhs.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
etka · 19 Mar 2005
pakistan gives sikhs more privlages then india gives its own residents (sikhs).
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
. · 20 Mar 2005
for sikhs that is good news, but what is pakistan's stance towards other minorities? in particular christians, ahmediyas, shiyites, sindhi hindus?
so why one rule for one another for another?
equality should be for one and for all.
why does pakistan not do the same for churches and invite indian christians over? or shiyite muslims from neighbouring iran.
If pakistan achieves that then it will truly be honoured for its participation in good minority treatment.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
S Singh · 20 Mar 2005
Etka
I think you should visit the Sikhs living around Peshawar and ask them what priviledges they get. Also ask them if the Sikh girls kidnapped and taken away by muslim tribal chiefs have been returned to their parents.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
S Singh · 20 Mar 2005
Ekta
Forgot to mention I would also look how Pakistan has surpressed the Baloochis. The Pakistanis are no better at treating minorities than India.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Bhopinder singh · 21 Mar 2005
s singh
Does pakistan have sects like radhasoamis, nirankaris, kukaas, nanaksaria.
The annswer is no.
Pakistan follows strict islam but does not permotes sects in other religions.
Did the girls taken away by the hindus during the 1984 genocide return ?
So for us pakistan and india are the same
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
S Singh · 21 Mar 2005
There are sects in Pakistan !
There is enough tension between Shias and Sunnis , Mohajirs and Sindhi nationalists etc etc.
What was the point in your post. You say India and Pak are the same, well that is exactly what my post stated. Which was in sharp contrast to what ekta was stating.
>>Did the girls taken away by the hindus during the 1984 genocide return ?
Whats that got to do with what ekta was stating ? ekta was refering to Sikhs having more priviledges in Pakistan.
Why do you always have to try and link 1984 to everything when there is no relevance in the thread ?
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Bhopinder singh · 21 Mar 2005
s singh
I was talking about sikhs are their any sects in sikhs, Please be specific SIKHS ONLY.
Why did you bring up the issue of girls?
Does the genocide of 1984 mean nothing to you?
see i am killing you cause you are not answering me
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
S Singh · 21 Mar 2005
I do not need to answer your irrelevant posts as they are precisely that irrelevant, off the point, not related to threads and a waste of bandwidth.
You not heard of the Vada Gallughara of 1761 ? Your persistance in linking everything to 1984 reminds me off what Dr Chohan used to do till he legged it back to Mohali.
Issue of girls ............. now lets see ekta said Sikhs have special privileges.
Now it is not unknown in the NWFP for tribal Muslims to kidnap Sikh girls. So the issue of girls was raised to counter the point put by ekta about privileges UNLESS you think having a Sikh girl kidnapped by Muslims is a privilege !!!!! Knowing your twisted psyche you will no doubt raise 1984 again as thats all you are good for.
If you knew anything about Sikhs in Pakistan you would know there are so few (excluding Sindhi Hindus who follow Sikhism) that it would be pretty useless to promote sects. The total number of Sikhs in Nankana Sahib district is less than 1000 Sikhs and that is the major concentration area for Pakistani Sikhs. Guess what there are no Pak based Sikh "baba" / "saints" so I guess the glut of "baba" and "saints" in india like the sects are GOI sponsored.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Sanj Singh · 21 Mar 2005
some of you people are so spoiled. Why try to ruin it if we are finally having it good? sure, one or two Sikh girls were kidnapped in NW frontier, but is that any comparison to the fact that India had raped and killed thousands of our sisters since 84? At least the Sikh girl that was kidnapped was covered by the pakistani media and even taken up by the federal government of Pakistan and finally returned to her home. On the other hand, when our sisters were being raped and killed by the Indian security forces, the media ignored it, the ones they didn't ignore were termed as terrorists thus thier gang rape and murder was justified.
[%sig%]
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Bhopinder singh · 21 Mar 2005
S singh
Please give me answer in yes or no please no hotch potch.
Is you e mail adress [address removed]
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
etka · 21 Mar 2005
**** lets not make freinds, lets have all enemies..think wisely for the panth.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 22 Mar 2005
Bhopinder Singh wrote: "Does pakistan have sects like radhasoamis, nirankaris, kukaas, nanaksaria"
I don't know about the rest of you, but I DEFINITELY would NOT even put Nanaksariay in the same sentence as the other cults mentioned above. I know the Nanaksar groups have their different ways of doing some things, but that is also the case with Damdami Taksal, AKJ etc...don't the Nanaksariay believe in 10 Guru's and 11th and FINAL Guru- Sri Guru Granth Sahib? I know the Nanaksar name has been associated with some very dodgy babay of late, but I believe (as far as I know) that the Nanaksar message is one of keeping rehit and being Gursikhs?
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa, Waheguru ji ki fateh
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
sikh · 22 Mar 2005
it is obvious sikhs are getting attension and good treatment by pakistani authorities which is a positive sign for sikhs. But what determines this? and why do other non muslim minorities not have the same privelidges, and equal treatment? So we only look at what benefits us and not for the principle behind it?
Why do we boast about standing up for equality when we only look at our own gaining ground? what abou tthe shias that are getting their masjids bombed out? and shot as soon as they come out after prayers? what does the government of pakistan do to stop that? or the christians unfairly sentanced to death? thousands of pakistani females raped and tortured in honour feuds? recently a massiv rally was held in pakistan for womens day, how many sikhs here protested for womens rights then?
has the pakistan government bought back hundreds if not thousands of sikh girls lured by uk pakistanis and then thrown in pakistani brothels every year? it is the local gurdwaras here that try to establish contact with missing girls after recieving letters. Which pakistan authority was helping sikhs in that case? so now you establish when it comes to nri money multiplieing from 1 dollar to 80 rupees "you sikh il look after you".
Pakistan was instrumental in supporting the taliban during its tenure. 50 000 afghani sikhs were made homeless, killed, raped, terrorised, and had their properties confiscated and taken over. Is this a sign of good fellowship with sikhs? sum it up the fellowship sign now is one for nri bucks targetted towards the local economy rather than sympathy for the sikh religion.
besides the The warm gurdwara welcome is over once your of lahore your at your own mercy.
blatently its to do with attracting more nri money power for the economy.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
S Singh · 22 Mar 2005
Having it good ?
Ask the baloochis what pakistan has done to them and you will see that Pak is no better than India.
FYI the case you are talking about, the girl has yet to be returned to her home. This is first hand information I was given by Sikhs in Pakistan last year !
I suggest you also read a few of the posts a few weeks ago about brutality against Sikh women. It was mentioned that cases were highlighted by the Indian media so your media ignorance point carries little weight.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
sikh · 22 Mar 2005
obviously they know sikh girls families from uk will not mean bussiness for them, trauamtised by the fact their kid is sitting inside a muslim country in a brothel so they will not be back for a holiday in pakistan so no point.
they had to save the pakistani sikh girl if its the same 6 year old, because it lands the authorities as incapable, the issue being covered was the height of gross violation of rights with a tint of religious conversion in the background. Had they stayed back that would cause outrage across the diaspora, what would sikh families think of pakistan then? They know we blame westernisation for gurls going astray here but theres no excuse for kidnapping a 6 year old and converting her in pakistan. the move was most likely to reduce political ramifications.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
sikh · 22 Mar 2005
what is sikh nation? sikh quam by any chance?
well 8 years ago the taliban (pakistan isi creation) attacked the sikh quam the sikh nation in afghanistan. 73 gurdwaras were demolished, the afghan sikhs i met in the uk told me just before they left the taliban would not let nishan sahib be raised, the mujahadeen were terrorising and taking ransoms on afghani sikhs way back in 1992, thats how long we ignored them for.
The only sikhs left trapped inside afghanistan were the odl or the very poor who had no money when sikhs began moving out. They had to get women out of afghanistan first because they were molested and raped at gunpoint. Then afghani sikhs sent their fathers out and finally the sons had to haggle their way out after 2 3 years of hiding, if they made it to other parts of the world not knowing wheretheir families were. They were even forced to take their dastars off and have their kes flow, and pretend to be holy muslims in parts of pakistan to avoid being detected as sikhs in which case they were kidnapped and held to ransom. what rights are you on about? the talibans bigger support base was inside pakistan than in afghanistan.
what was the reaction of the west sikhs? "indian propaganda". why? the media sources pointed to tribune. So then why do we have tribune articles frequently on rag mala, taksal, or sikhs escaping out of prisons? why do we have these tribune articles that engineer more divide in the panth?
if tribune is bulling it is doing just that! let us tow the line properly with conviction. Its one way or the other there should be no pakhand about it. Over and above that, we should be loyal to Guru jis principles over and above all else.
nri cash flowing in jullander, the khottis in eastern punjab are matchless in terms of west pakistan punjab. Money is becoming the mans new religion.
Its all to do with power and money. Pakistan is now more keen than ever to have good relations with india. even more surprisingly pro khalistani advocates are even back in india on friendly terms with bjp akalis congress.
nationalism, religion is soon to be out of the window to be replaced by globalism i think sikhs should stop living in the past and face what gwaan right now.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 22 Mar 2005
have we all forgotten that 70% of LAHORE was SIKH OWNED ??
That SIKHS OWNED HUNDREDS of THOUSANDS of ACRES of the Best Land in pakistan Baar area...
What guarantees that the next wave of NRI owned houses wont got eh same waya s Lahore Properties of Sikhs ??
Jarnail Singh
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Bhopinder singh · 22 Mar 2005
Jarnail singh ji
If sikhs choose sides like they did in 1947 surely that is going to happen.It did not happen to parsis as they did not choose side.
IF we do the same now in Kashmir same thing is going to happen.The indian army is putting sikhs on the forefront of the media in Kashmir althoughmost of the army is hindus killing and raping muslim women children and men.
We should have listened to the British in 1947 and got our own country just like pakistan, india and that would have been the guarantee of our property , Language, cultre,religion world wide like the Jews.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Bhopinder singh · 22 Mar 2005
Pardeep Singh Bilga
Do nanaksarias believe in langar?.
Do they believe in bhog rasm of prshad?.
Do they believe in nishan sahib?.
AKJ and TAKSAL believe in them not even in dream would they voilate them.
What is behangam?
Do the priest in nanaksaria believe in marriage?.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
singh · 23 Mar 2005
bhopinder singh nanaksar have nothing to do with nris and pakistan.
parsis look like muslims not as identifiable as sikhs. I am not sure what country you are from, ask any englandwaley sikh what happens to them if their in a pakistani area like chalvey or luton. Why did sikhs in calcutta and bengal get killed too then in 1947?
Your statement does not make sense. Sikhs from baara pakistan in 1947 choosing to go to another place leaving behind their arable farmlands, is no excuse for them to get killed. Leading from that, whos side did afghan sikhs take for them to be kicked out of the country now? if you have correct sources on the ground the taliban are made up pakistan regulars. So in effect the hamla on sikhs in afghanistan was launched and instigated by pakistani regular fighters.
You might need to do some research on the sikh population of kashmir in 47 and 1960s and what they also left behind and who overtook it.
punjabis also wear paghs in punjab police and kill sikhs so whats new in kashmir? Hindus and muslims joined hands in anti sikh riots that does not mean sikhs go and start doing the same to every random muslim or hindu. This is the belief difference. In sikhism you can only defend as last resort, and only pick on oppressor not their religion. In islam you yourself are a kaffar, an infidel, from start to end unless you convert hence if one muslim is attacked thats jihad on your kind kaffar. Ask the slough sikhs what they went through. Or after sep 11 in birmingham most of the racist attacks on sikhs were coming from pakistanis and not the english.
In the punjab region where some gurdwaras exist the locals are accustomed to sikh history. But the majority outside in mirpur, peshawar, and tribal belts sikhs are treated no better than hindus and christians. The pakistan government is centralised in pak punjab that is probably the only reason sikhs get some ritghs. try talking to some mirpuris the mentality is completly different, youd probably get yourself chopped up in certain areas if they work out your sikh.
take the words of advocates like aulakh, sekhon with caution, some of what they say is backed by human rights and statistics which sikhs have a duty to stand up for human rights. However they are also getting on in age and not understanding this once unity that existed in 84 with pakistan changes with a new government coming in. Peoples loyalty change. zia ul huq sympathised with sikhs, benazir did not, musharraf will not be helping sikhs if another 84 happens due to american policy after sep 11. he is keen to make things work with india, and america has economic ties and interests in india which did not exist in 1984 due to its rival russia its sway as indias ally at the time. The indian stories about pakistan causing ruckus is hokus pokus by indian authorities unless prooved.
There have been serious developments in pakistan after the pan islamic programme in the 80s. Mullahs churned out in factory loads from middle east were sent to pakistan from arabia running madrasas , infilitrated top layers of authority that is why pakistan experienced a religious change. So these stories about sikh muslim allies from amarjit singhs site are not happening now but may have many moons back. If anything sikhs are scorned and asked "where is your land then"?
So while a few naive people get sucked in, sikhs realise the nature of these policies are not related or motivated to religious sympathy its to do with something pretty much lijke when a gurdwara election takes place all of a sudden a rich family down the road starts sweetening you up before handing you their proposed policies and asking you to vote for them. After that kapput! back to normal you do not exist.
nri sikhs in canadaa america are known as affluent bussiness class people with financial clout, in america sikhs are known in many proffessional fields with money. Money talks, the greeb have no johr in todays world. But once in sikhs will always be a tiny minority and get sucked further as islam is missionary by nature.
what you said in your last statement could only have happened if there was a complete power share between all sikhs. Guru sahib has his ways of working things out if we take steps to Him.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Pardeep Singh Bilga · 23 Mar 2005
Bhopinder Singh- thanks for pointing out these things.
I am not really aware of the ins and outs of Nanaksariay- but if you what you have pointed out is true- then I apologise- I mean those who do not believe in Nishaan Sahib cannot be classed as Sikhs.
I know about the langar, because I went with my cousin to the Nanaksar Gurdwara/Dera in Ropar, Panjab a couple of years back- we were only there for about 1/2 an hour and I was absolutely starving, following a long day doing darshan an Anandpur Sahib and other Gurdwaras, so I thought let's have some langar here... my cousin then pointed out that there was NO langar here as they brought it in from outside when needed but langar wasn't actually prepared on the premises (to my shock- every other Sikh Gurdwara I've been to has langar any time).
But I know some "Nanaksar" Gurdwaras in the UK who DO prepare langar, as per normal practice- Nanaksar Thath Isher Darbar in Wolverhampton to name one.
I personally am more slanted towards Damdami Taksal and like I said earlier, my knowledge of Nanaksariay is not great and I have personally seen the corrupt activities of one particular, young and very "famous" Nanaksar Baba.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 23 Mar 2005
I will answer for PS Bilga..THEY DONT....and so they are a SECT..unlike DDT/AKJ which have minor differences in Rehat maryada BUT dont COMPROMISE on NISHAN/LANGGAR/GURBANI.
The nanaksaris Have CUT DOWN most important aspects of GURMATT..and their GUTKAS have the weirdestt sakhis and tall tales..beat Aesops fables hands down...The WORST ONE is where they claim GURU ARJUN JI could not complete Sukhamani Sahib and had to ask Baba Sri Chand Ji to help finish it.( they conveneintly ignore that sri chand was REJECTED by his FATHER GURU NANAK JI...and How could a NON-GURU write GURBANI ??
Beahngam is BRAHMCHARIYAS...Hanuman style...ALL OUR GURU JI's MARRIED and had CHILDREN.......NO such thing as Behamngam....Nanaksaris all are BEHANGAAMM....
Let PS Bilga answer any more with proofs.
jarnail Singh.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
rishetdaria sambhaal · 23 Mar 2005
"Author: etka
Date: 03-19-05 17:24
pakistan gives sikhs more privlages then india gives its own residents (sikhs)."
i would like to see you take a trip on your own to the khyber pass, or "azad" kashmir as it is called and see if you come out alive/unhurt. Then you can talk about privelidges.
mr singh you will dissapear once you are out of pakistani punjab.
The ruthless pathans along the border hate sikhs and punjabis they still remember pre colonial times.
Kashmiris pay usual lip service of twin freedom struggle, mirrored by american khalistanis ( where coincidently the sikhs have not had the misfortune of the presence of pakistani panthers preying on their children).
Now do yourself a favour and come to the largest kashmiri diaspora outside pakistan in birmingham aston. Ask to read religious leaflets, newspapers printed by hizbut tahrir/ khalifa and al mushrooms on the topic of kashmir and partition. " the muslim ummah in india left at the mercy of hindus and sikhs slaughtered the ummah" another headline ran " the sikh maharaja handed over kashmir a muslim nation to india and sealed the fate of all kashmiris" ( author hizbut tahrir fully knowing the raja was not a sikh) print edition may 1996. headlines like this makes pakistanis out here wanna kill sikhs, target our sisters, and hit our kids. If an organisation like that with khalifa and al mushrooms has a 300 000 plus membership in just this country alone that speaks volumes of what kind of opinion must exist in pakistan . ht al mushrooms khalifa are an umbrella sister groups created by one man and split thrice.
American sikhs have no idea what they are talking about dont live in fantasy land go and take a trip outside pakistani punjab and lets see if you walk out alive.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Gurcharan Singh Kulim,MBA,Phd. · 25 Mar 2005
I( find this debate very amusing,immatured except for one or two people , and at the least totally out of context and understanding of the minds that seem to be writing all sorts of irrlevent rubbish into this discussion.
There are on going issues that Sikhs need to handle sensitively, and with caution, given the past history and the fact we are a minority either side of the border, and with NO government of our own.
The pakistanis may be working towards gloablisation with the Sikhs, but I think all this is very superficial.
After all, Jinnah too was trying to appease the Sikhs with gurantees in a partnhership,while his muslim league was actively seeking out Sikhs in peshawar and the outlying areas for stabbing and killings.
They played a double barreled game with the Sikhs.
Today, they have relaised that they need forign currency to lift the pathetic economic state that islamic pakisat is in,therefore lure the Sikhs.The Sikhs will always be a minority that they can handle with ease, should the Sikhs decide to act like the baloochis or Pathans.
I think, instead of rsuhing in like mad, Sikhs should seek international human rights for Sikh way of life within PakistanThey should seek a Sikh minister and an international gurantee of their protection within Pakistan.
The Pakiland government must hand over ALL Gurduaras to the Sikhs and compensate the Sikhs who suffered in 1947. they MUST enact a law, which states that NO Sikh girl or boy can be converted to any other religion in Pakistan.If someone chooses to do so on the own accord once they are 18,that is up to the individual.
Sikhs must have the right to propogate within Pakistan.Pakistan must also declare in the interests of the Minorities that it is NOT an islamic nor ever can be an islamic state. It must restore all Sikh property and history back to its rightful place. Sikhs should be enlisted into its army, and a quota set on percentages with Sikhs protected .
If the Pakistan government can start to handle such serious issues, we can start believing they do mean well.
Gurcharan Singh Kulim
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
gkaur Mba Bse 1st class honour · 26 Mar 2005
gurcharan singh ji the measures you talk about make good sense politically.
But some of what is written in other posts is a fact. Going to a yatra in pakistan is one thing, few regions for sikhs are safe. There are places where you will need armed gaurds to protect you.
It is the nature of porous parts of pakistan. the tribal belt warriors do not even recognise pakistan as their country, they are out of pakistan's jurisdiction.
Sikhs were also killed by punjabi muslims in punjab pakistan during the 1947 riots. However that was then, we cannot hold the newer generation responsible for what happened at that time. For most, pakistani punjabis are actually very friendly with sikhs now, and even in the past the sikh kingdom was boosted by punjabi muslim fighters. And some of us share the same pinds in pakistan where we came from before partition.
so we should not really let one thing get in the way. But as you pointed out if pakistan does more it will help secure the position of sikhs there.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Bhopinder · 26 Mar 2005
Gurbachan singh kulim ji
Are sikhs a minority in punjab,We are not talking about India .But if that is your scale then are hindus a majority in south asia ,No China is .Even muslims are more in numbers , so can we make a hindustan in southasia no only where you have more hindus that to should be Dravidsthan for the achoot as they are bulk of the populus about 70%. nothing was irerelevant here its just your thinking.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Bhopinder singh · 26 Mar 2005
Please it is very important SIKHS ARE NOT MINORITY IN PUNJAB
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 26 Mar 2005
There are facts,but not all are facts.Many are written very immaturedly, without much thought to it.It is like any other country,there will be some places where any one can not be safe.Then (1947)and now (2005), is easy to say than to practice, and livge with the real life consequences.
Until recently, in enlightened Britain, many anti Sikh circulars were going around refering to Sikhs as butchers of Muslims in pakistan in 1947.Sharing a pind and many generations of living to gether was no gurantee to the killings inj 1947.This new found pyar is all fine for short interactions between the communities, but should an issue of sensitive politics arise, I can see the repaet of 1947 happening very easily.Sikhs in karachi still need do not sport their turbans openly.This government in pakistan may have made some progress, but another government may not see in the same light.
After all, Sikhs lived for three over generations in Afghanistan, and even they had to flee with only their lives.The pakistani Punjabi will not feel threatened by the hindu is pakistan, but the Sikh in numbers is a threat))
""It is the nature of porous parts of pakistan. the tribal belt warriors do not even recognise pakistan as their country, they are out of pakistan's jurisdiction.""
((this is not relevant to the issue,that is their own internal matter, we really have no say what they do to their own co-religionists,who are also muslims, but are often killed by Punjabi muslims,and vice versa-however there is alo no gurantee they will not such start such killings of Sikhs,should they find Sikhs becomming a threat in large numbers in their own country)))
The hate spread in UK was by the newer generations who have heard stories from their older genearations and do not know that the killings were carried out by goons-to them Sikhs killed.It is an assumption the newer generation will not hold hate towards sikhs.It did not take long only about three months ago for young holigans to stone the Sikh homes and Gurduara in nanakana sahib.It is an interlude to how fast things can turn nasty,given the climate in Pakistan,after all they kill their own shia and sunnis,the Sikhs are after all the only enemy that has stood in their way for generations.
The climate is friendly at the moment,but it can also turn nasty at a short notice.The loss even one Sikh life is a great loss to the Panth.
The muslim soldiers of the Sikh Kingdom did not have much choice but to serve in the army of their ruler.A soldier has no religion ,except to serve his masters.These days there is also an additional perk, they get paid to fend their families.A soldier has only one religion to kill or get killed for his nation.But if you analyse the fall of Sikh kindom,one of the strongest reasons will come out is the Kingdom also felll quickly because such muslim and other non Sikh soldiers were also quick to change their allegiance, after maharajah Ranjit Singh passed away.The hinndu Soldiers and governors like Dhian Singh were quick to betray the Sikh rule.
In post 1947 present day Pakistan,the mention of Sikh rule and Sikh heritage has completely been wipoed out from Punjab.It is only klately some mooted movements have been made to restore some mention of the Sikh history of Punjab.Until, Sikh history and mention is put back into the pakistani text books, the rest of it is just momental change which can change at any time.A whole two generations of Pakistanis has grown who do not know the Sikhs were once their neighbours and RULED the PUNJAB
Like I have said comming from same pinds did not save the millions of Sikhs who died in 1947, like having suffered the same fates in 1947, the hindu goondas did not stop in 1984.
I agree we should let the times get on, and move along, but we should also learn lessons from history, and move cautiously, so that we do not have another ghallughara.If the government of Pakistan is sincere, than we should ask for gurantees, and as much as we can get, before we pack bag and barrel and move into Pakistan.
To Bhopinder Singh :
I do not know what irrelevant points you are arguing about the chinese,please stick to the issue of Sikhs in pakistan and India.The FACT is Sikhs are a minority in India(and in pakistan even more less)In their own Punjab they are barely in the majority by being 55%.(in fact now in the district of Ludhiana, the Sikhs have been reduced to second place by the bhaiyas)This 55% is only 1.8 % of the Indian population(thanks to the horrible and lowly practice of female infanticide by large numbers of Sikhs).And you insist they are not a minority.
If it is all inn the mind, shall I say we can forget and forgive all the killers of the Sikhs in 1984, because twenty years later we just have it in the mind.....so why worry, it is all in the mind...the killers of Sikhs should be walking free ...is that what you are saying "..being in the mind??"
What you are trying to prove by bringing the chinese. into this discussion.By the way I do speak Chinese fluently.I suggest you look up ,what a minority means.The chinese are not a minority in their own land,but they can be a minority in India,like the Chinese residents of Kolkatta.
Sikhs have a long way to go,growing out of this petty gurduara politics mentality.
I would for once deal with the devil I know, than the one I do not,until I know exactly how far they are sincere.
Gurcharan Singh Kulim
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 26 Mar 2005
Even if Sikhs were a majority in Punjab, it matters not.The government of India controls Punjab, NOT Sikhs.
Even as now, they are barely in the majority at 55%.When the state of Punjab was formed the Sikhs were 64% in 1963.
Now reduced to 55%,so what is so important that the Sikhs are in majority in Punjab?They are in Minority in India-1.8%.
In fact over the last two years ,one of the strongest Sikh majority district within Punjab -Ludhiana-has seen a bhaiya majority emerge.
This is a very disturbing trend.Ludhiana has been seen as part of the Sikh heartland together with the now district of Moga (then Frepozepore,later Faridkot, then now to Moga).
Even in 1947, Ludhiana was the only district where sikhs were in even numbers with muslims, forming about 44% of the population.In every other district the Sikhs were in minority.
Moga and Ludhiana were considered the Sikh heartland in 1947.
Today, we have lost Ludhiana,the next is a domino question, time will tell.
Gurcharan Singh Kulim
PS people must remember, we must not kid that because we are 55% of the Punjab population all is fine.It is a matter of time, this will go down..too,unless SIKHS GET UP AND look around and do something for themselves.
Gurcharan Singh KULIM
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Dev Raj · 26 Mar 2005
Bhopinder Singh Ji, Punjab is only a state.It cannot do anything, without Innndian central government permission .The fact is Sikhs are a minority.
The total population of Pakistan is today about 190,000,000.
Sikhs in Punjab number only 14,000,000.That is not even 8% percent of the Pakistan population.
Sikhs only about less than 2 % of the Indian population.
In todays Indian Punjab Sikhs are actually barely in majority with 55% of the population as said by GSK.
I think Gurcharan Singh ji spoke with some good sense and facts.I dont think people should rush into Nankana sahib, without more goodwill and political guarantees from the Pakistan government.
The rest of this muslims,hindus and chinese in south asia is all a red herring you are trying to throw about to justify yourself.....I dont think Gurcharan or any reader actually expects you to do that...please stick to facts,..anyway why is it important that Sikhs are majority in Punjab ...????
The fact is they are barely a majority.
DR Sandhu
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
....................... · 27 Mar 2005
why do sikhs end up as minority?
is it to do with migrating out of punjab?
then we finally agree we have to bolster up numbers? so how do we do this? but what i have also heard is there are many bs scheduled sikhs currently benglected by akalis in southern india is this right gsk?
if that is the case why do we not take in sikhs from southern and middle india to punjab.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Bhopinder singh · 27 Mar 2005
Dev raj
I disagree with you in fact i dont agree atall Sikhs are a majority in East punjab for the death of my brother and many more stand witness i defy your indian control .
sarkari sikhs can not understand me and i dont understand them WE ARE A MAJORITY IN PUNJAB
that is a fact today
ARE you hindus a majority in india please check your facts
never count those untouhables as they defy you
never count muslims who have 35 crore today
how was east pakistan and west pakistan created where they had muslim majority in india so where is sikh majority PUNJAB so there is KHALISTAN
You cannot include china in india china has more chinesein that part of the globe and sikhs in that part of the globe
NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Dev Raj · 28 Mar 2005
Bhopinder singh Ji,
It looks like you have a long way to go to grow up.you say :-
"I disagree with you in fact i dont agree at all Sikhs are a majority in East punjab for the death of my brother and many more stand witness i defy your indian control ."
Grow up and stand on your own two feet, and debate like a matured person or man!
So what are you arguing about, you agree that Sikhs are a majority or not a majority?One minute you were arguing that Sikhs were a majority ,and now you are saying they are NOT a majority in East Punjab.
The next minute you are contraditing yourself by saying :-
"sarkari sikhs can not understand me and i dont understand them WE ARE A MAJORITY IN PUNJAB"
That is an old label used by people who loose an argument in the old days.And you are using it like the infant Gurduara politicians.
Then you say :-
"ARE you hindus a majority in india please check your facts
never count those untouhables as they defy you
never count muslims who have 35 crore today"
The majority people of India are Hindus.The untouchables register themselves as hindu for their religion.
The muslims in India number 180,000,000 not 35 crore as you suggest.I have checked MY FACTS.
Finally I may be hindu, but I see my Sikh brother as an equal Indian like me.I would die to defend the right of my Sikh brothers.To me,my Sikh friend is more than a brother than my own brother.SO, I TAKE AN EXCEPTION TO A RACIST SUGGESTION BY REFERING TO ME AS "YOU HINDUS"very poor choice of words.I go to Gurduara more than a mandir.
You say:-
"how was east pakistan and west pakistan created where they had muslim majority in india so where is sikh majority PUNJAB so there is KHALISTAN"
East and West Pakistan was created in 1947.
This is 2005.
Sikhs and Hindus of India will swim or sink together.I believe, as hindus call India -Hindustan:Sikhs can call India -Khalistan-I do not see anything wrong with that.
Bhai sahib, What happened in 1984 was WRONG.many hindus fought hard to save the lives of Sikh friends and strangers.No body wanted that.It was a political game played by the dirty people.
Sat Sri Akal and Gurfateh.
Dev Raj
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 28 Mar 2005
Author writes:
Author: .......................
Date: 03-27-05 02:45
"why do sikhs end up as minority?"
"is it to do with migrating out of punjab?"
It is NOT a question of why Sikhs end up as a minority.The Sikhs have always been a minority for a number of reasons:-
In 1947 Sikhs numbered only 13 % of the total Punjab population.
Muslims numbered 54 %,hindus 30%.
In independent India Sikhs still numbered only 30% of the Punjab population,until Himachal and Hariana were broken away in 1965
Then the Sikhs numbered 65% in the new smaller Punjab.Today they number a simple small majority at 55%,and this is falling rapidly.
It is the youngest religion in the Indian sub-continent.
There is high practice of female infanticide among the Sikhs.
Sikhs appear to have taken to family control naturally.the average Sikh family is smaller than others.
The high education rate among Sikhs have also contirbuted to them opting for smaller famies.
Large number of Sikhs have gone out of the state to other states in india for better prospects etc. esspecially in search of productive lands.
Large numbers of Sikhs have migrated to foreign countries.
In the 1980s, the Sikh restlessness/state barbarism caused death of large numbers of youngmen, who would have been the potential sources for re-procreation in the Punjab.
There are also a number of other socio- econo-political issues that has retarded the growth of Sikhism,either through converts,or natural number progression of Sikh population and finally the Sikhs 'could not care less' attitude is not helping at all.
"""then we finally agree we have to bolster up numbers? so how do we do this? but what i have also heard is there are many bs scheduled sikhs currently benglected by akalis in southern india is this right gsk?"""
Sikhs need to ensure each Sikh family produces as many, and at the minmum five children.Sikh organisations need work to educate Sikhs to succeed,so that others can be enticed to embrace Sikh religion too.
There are rumoured to be 120,000,000 Vanjara and Sikligar Sikhs in the central India.I have travelled through this region, and have not seen many turbanned Sikhs as suggested by some poeple.It is a possibility these Sikhs have lost much of their identity ,hence not very noticable.
Funnily, if they are indeed Sikhs,they are not shown in the national census of India.Why?One can only hide them for so long.
The SGPC is neglecting its own scheduled class Sikhs,in the Punjab itself.Many of these pople are now falling victims to the christian and hindus.
The recent clashes near Ludhiana between jat Sikhs and scheduled people proves this point that they are neglected by both the so called 'high class Sikhs' and the SGPC ,hence the divide led to such clahses, which are a shame to the Sikhs.The scheduled classes have been driven away from sikhi by these 'high class Sikhs' and the SGPC
"""if that is the case why do we not take in sikhs from southern and middle india to punjab"""".
There is not enough land within the Punjab.How do you suggest these people live in the Punjab.Why do you think Sikhs are leaving the Punjab and heading for foreign countries?
Secondly these Sikhs may have nothing in common with Punjabi Sikhs apart from the religion.They are people from central India.Why would they want to uproot from their own lands and go to the Punjab where there is already a shortage of land?People do not just pick up their bags and leave their mother land.
What happens if the central government picks up 50 million people from other states and plants them in the Punjab?
As I have said, Sikhs in Punjab already see one district where the Bihari bhaiyas have outnumbered the Punjabis.
The only other way is to have honest Sikh organisations and work in earnest for the community, so our numbers can grow..like the muslims!
PS:_by the way Bhopinder please stop racist remarks.
Gurcharan Singh Kulim
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
GANI KHAN NABI KHAN · 29 Mar 2005
Dev raj shambu pandit ji
Bhupinder Singh Ji was telling Sikhs are a majority in Punjab.
and that is fact
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I disagree with you in fact i dont agree at all that is with respect to your 1st post.
Please define racist.
Is it the one who divides humanity in four parts by birth ?
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
You Said that,"Sikhs and Hindus of India will swim or sink together."
But I think Sikhs & Muslims will swim or sink together.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
dust da dust · 29 Mar 2005
gani siyah dont speak too soon evi dekhloh gurdwaras shut down in muslim country even water closed off. yet mandirs and mosques remain free.
http://www.panthic.org/news/126/ARTICLE/1074/2005-02-27.html
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
syed ahmed khan · 29 Mar 2005
respected friends/sirs
i hope u'll get this mail during good health, peace, happiness n progress......
it's very good community site n good discussion board...
i've studied the comments on this message board throlly but sorry to say that we south asian are still backward (not in mental level) but in socila values, accomodation (religious, philosophical, cultural n political) forward look n liberal values.........
sikhs( Nanaksariay Damdami Taksal, AKJ),, buddhist (Theravada, Mahayana, Vajrayana ) hindus( Brahmins,Kshatriyas, vaisnavi, sudra ), muslims(sia, sunny, barali, devobandi) christan(orthodos, prostants, catholic), other religious/regional/national groups r all equal........
as i know/study from mummy-papa/respected scholars n secred books
humanity is the best religion n work is worship (n worships is also a work to make ourself alive spiritually).......
religion is secred lamp of one's heart n we should not burn any one house with this secred lamp but we should sprerad message of love, happiness n knowledge from this secred lamp.......
yes in past n in recent past there r many mistakes created by bad leaders/kings/politicians but we should not froget humanity, we should take lesson from falling water from fountain which doesn't loose it's character afetr fallingt from so much height. we should forget past mistake & keep past golorious era as our guiding asperation..........
we should teach our childern the positive history. we should give them happy n loving future mutual respect n trust. be wise we can't change past but we can learn positive lesson from past n work creativily in present n give a happy future to our nexgen......
we should come out form raj legacy. we should forget 1947 sega, it was just political mistake created by lack of communication n confusion. we should see south asia as garlan of different flowers.........
guru nanak shahib, shree gautam buddha, shree ram ji, jessus christ, hazret muhamed n hundreds of noble souls have taught us the lesson of humanity with different logic/philosophy/teaching methology just as we slove different engineering problems with different matmetical/logical algorithm/way/tools n technology..............
one thing is importan the culture of punjab is vey rich n colorful. people r vey loving/carey n fun loving. they bestwoed by god with vey fretile land n healthy masses, therefore they should not loose these beauties n graces..........
also we should learn from chinese development in different field n we should compete with them positively n share with them the knowledge n art of progress................
as pakistan's government's offer to nri to settle in pakistani punjab n some us based pakistani doctors initative to adopt indian punjab village, is concern, in my openion these r really positive developments.
yes it's natural for the masses who has been ditrusting n fearing with each other on different grounds for so long years, see these +ve development with suspision.
but we should give peace a chance.
we should letn encourage people to meet with eachother. the new settelers'll press the adopted governmnet for l/religious/economical/cultural right as they are economically/educationally advance.
they are west settled south asian with more power to impress respective governments. they'll force to both countries to solve their different disputes for the betterment of common masses of entire south asia (may be it'll hypothetical but the time always teach the lesson but with a slap to foolish politicians).............
the last but not least.............
acomodation, technology n economy let people togethere for ever for ever............
thanking you with best regards.
[%sig%]
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 29 Mar 2005
Sikhs cannot swim with the Muslims,given the past and recent history.If Sikhs attempt that ,it will soon become apparent that the Sikhs will sink.
While individual muslims may be able to get on with a non muslim,generally it is a known fact Muslims and islam cannot live with its neighbours.It is NOT only Sikhs, that islam is intolerant of.It is intolerant of its own shia and sunnis and ahmediyas.Any one cannot see that must be far more blind than a bat, and a total liar.
recent pakistan history tells us how the pakistani punjabi muslims were bombing christian churcues and raping their children,how they are killing each other now on the issue of sunni and shia.they kill ahmediyas.Now they are killing the tribal muslims.
Can anyone calling themsleves SIKH ,and BHOPINDER SINGH trully tell me that they would have not started on Sikhs, should Sikh have been living in large numbers in Pakistan?
There are many cases where sikh girls have been abducted and not returned.The recent attack in Nanakana Sahib on the shrine and Sikh houses are a good indication of what can come.
People like Nobody khan and wally khan are just fictitious names trying to mislead Sikhs.people like BHOPINDER SINGH dont understand the gravity of the situation, and feel comfortable with a mere 55% Sikh majority, which is decreasing daily.
I just think these are children with delusional grandeur thoughts that are not based on facts.
Until we get a substantial gurantee and more from Pakistan,Sikhs would be fools to go and set up homes in Nanakana Sahib.
Gurcharan Singh Kulim
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
GANI KHAN NABI KHAN · 29 Mar 2005
What should people like singhs do?
They tried their best to lick the shoes of Hindus got their daughters raped and thousands murdered in 84 genocide to this day not a single Hindu punished.
Please dont get flatered by Hindus you should have your own country.
Make laws like Himachal . dont allow outsiders to buy land or settle in punjab .
90% percent of the land in Punjab is still owned by Sikhs.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Dayanand · 29 Mar 2005
please dont let people like bhopinder singh misguide you.Father of Guru Nanak was from which faith.Khalsa was created to protect Hinduism and now Hinduism is strong armed with nuclear weapons so now Khalsa must think in terms of situation.
Yes the pujab belongs to us ,Yes we have the responsibility to protect all the minorities Radhasoamis, Nirankaris,Kukas,Dhirmalias and so many to name a few.In 1947 west punjab was given to Pakistan and east was given to India ( mother land vande mataram) .There is only two nation theory as mr.Kulim has written Sikhs were a minority then so no chance of two nation theory are minority now less then 2%.Please lern to live like one.
We have a Sikh Prime minister army general what else you want? Can you do this in Khalis.Please stop talking about bihari bhayias brothers as they have all the right to settle in any part of the motherland ( vande mataram).If you keep on talking about this there may be more trouble as the Hindu will wake up and then you remember what happened in the past.
We respect you and have given you respect more then your due but now the time is changing and we have to change the strategy we will keep on giving the respect but in turn we want you to be a little more faithful.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 30 Mar 2005
Wally and Nobby khoon
The Muslims of pakistan too tried their best to lick the shoes of the Sikhs to ensure whole of Punjab went to pakistan in 1947.
One can see how they turned over night to lick the shoes of USA.however many of them call USDA the big devil but do not hesitate to take the monies form USa, which they do not find to be haram suddenly.
The pakistanis rape their own children, that of the christians and sunnis and shias and tribals ,s o what is the difference between the pkaistanis muslims and others.
The pakistanis raped their own and none gets punished either.Women are humilated and yet there is no cry in pakistan.
Wally khaan and nob khan , fakes are seen through easily.
if you pakistanis mean well, introduce the gurmukhi script as the national script of Punjab.After it is the only original script of punjab.
Appoint a Sikhs as the defense minister of pakistan.Open up the gurduaras.
Open investigations into why 900 sikh refugees were massacred in Karachi in 1947 in day light on the way to the railway station , nine months after the partition ended.
Open up the right of Sikhs to settle in the Punjab,and make laws to specially protect their rights.
Make 40% of the army in Pakistan Sikhs.Make a law that no body can convert Sikhs in pakistan.Ensure that jhatka meals are made available for Sikhs in Pakistan
Then we know you all mean honesty and well.
Finally appoint commissions to investigate why the shias and sunnis are killing each other, why the christians are attacked in pkaistan
Explain how do you propose to stop the army taking over and over throwing democratic rule in pakistan forever.
In the mean time please grow up.
GSK
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
ppppp · 30 Mar 2005
what syed ji is saying is ideally how we all should be loving and respecting each other. But in reality, sikhs pack their bags go pakistan. We have already lost a lot of sikhs in recent gallughars. We are close to loosing half a generation of sikh females in uk due to hardcore islam groups. We have to analyse our position for safety and security first. From a nice person like yourself all the way upto perves ji may give sikhs the warmest welcome to pakistan. Its what happens after.
gani ji hindu sarkari arent any better. This is the thing!
The pakistani sarkar may be ok with sikhs, but it is a known fact pakistan is an unstable nation faced with regular coups. Pakistan is different from india and other muslim countries.
Arabs and african muslims are easy to get along with. When it comes to pakistanis, no matter how much they clammer about kashmir the fact is pakistan is a hotbed for religion and hostile tribe culture laced with islam. The worlds nuttiest frontier khoma with fighting culture are thrown into one boundary, pathana, afghana, gilzai, kashmiri rajput/jatt. That is a dangerous combination with a religion like islam.
After sep 11 numerous attempts have been made on perves the ruler of pak. No matter how nice he is or how kosher his sarkar are with sikhs even him or they are not safe from the wrath of pakistanis due to pro american stance sep 11 policies of perves. If that is the result of of pro american what will happen if tens of thousands of sikhs migrate to pakistan? A change of heart?
the pakistani religious sentiment is snowballed effect from the islam programme initiated in the recent past. If that is undone first and allows to accomodate minorities sikhs gauranteeing their saftey as gsk said then we cane make progress.
the pakistani nation is driven by the people not by the sarkara like india.
Pan islamic state stretching from arabia to china was on the agenda which is why pakistan was islamiced. If now millions of sikhs chip off to pakistan its just a matter of time the village mullahs will start giving fiery speeches on minorities as they have done against christians.
Seeing pictures of women with their noses chopped off, burnt acid faces and kidnappings is scary.
The pakistan gov cannot even gaurantee the saftey of its ruler at this moment. there are very nice pakistani muslims from punjab who i feel are some of the most wonderful warm hearted people but they are just one segment of the whole nation of pakistan. Pakistani constituinal rights go across the board in writing , but sadly that will not help sikhs outside punjab.
By speaking this sikhs are not flattered by anyone hindu or muslim. Sikhs have grown wiser and understood that sarkara politics involve baiting down minorities.
Sikhs are caught between a tug of war between indian pak politics. the indians also did something similar to woe sikhs to indian punjab.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Dayanand · 30 Mar 2005
Yes mr Kulim i fully agree with you and also with pppp.As i have written in my previous post you should remember who killed all the gurus and recently they distroyed three gurudwaras in Dubai.Master Tara made a good and wise choice in 1947 , wise because he knew Sikhs are not a majority and Sikhs like Bhopinder are misguiding people Sikhs were not a majority then and are niether now.
Sikhs are a minority in Indian ( vande mataram) Punjab not even 55%.Mr kulim i will give you some facts , most of the sikhs have converted to Radha soamis roughly around 21% as you can see they are around 30% and it is sikhs like Bhopinder who are misleading people.Even though sikhs are less then 1% of the Indian population we have made sikh prime minister and army general can Pakistan do that.
Forget what happened in 1984 and think about the future.The days of Khalistan are over and thier will never be a Khalistan but if you still keep on talking about that then Hindus will get upset and then you know what will happen.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Kulbir Singh · 30 Mar 2005
Sardar Gurcharan Singh Kulim,
It is not fair for you to condemn Muslims while keeping silent on Hindus. Could you also mention how Hindus killed thousands of Sikhs in 1984? You have mentioned how Muslims killed 900 Sikhs in Karachi in 1947 but Hindus killed quarter million Sikhs in the last two decades. To ignore that and to just point out what Muslims did is not a wise thing for us.
The fact of the matter is that Sikhs are a nation and must live in dignity. Without dignity, life is worthless. What kind of government is today that it has failed to do anything about France that banned the Sikh turban? Also, what did the government do kirpans that Sikhs have to remove in aeroplanes while travelling? If no one takes up the issues that are important to Sikhs, then what choice do Sikhs have but to look for alternatives.
Sikhs are neither bodyguards of Hindus, nor allies of Muslims. We are an independant nation that will respect who respects us and give a befitting reply to anyone who tries to harm us.
Kulbir Singh
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
Gurcharan Singh Kulim · 30 Mar 2005
Kulibir Singh Ji, the issue was should Sikhs build homes in Nanakana sahib.I say no, not just yet , until we get full gurantees.
Nobody has forgotten 1984.
Can I also correct you , it was NOT the Hindus who attacked Sikhs, it was the congress workers who quite rightly happened to be more Hindus,that led the attacks with mobs imported from outside.
Can I also remind you that after three days it was also Hindu Voluntary organmisations and individuals who led the PEACE marches against these Killings.
The fight was NOT hindus versus Sikhs.It was Congress goondas, trying to inspire the hindus and imported goondas to attack Sikh homes.
Like any situation, just as the misled Sant Bhindrawala, and the power mad indira blew the situation out of propotion and context trying to out do each other,some hindus fell for this and participated in the attacks,the majority did nOT.That is a fact.Otherwise there would have been no Sikhs left in India ,should the fight have been all Sikhs versus Hindus.
I agree that we must live with dignity etc.But we cannot live with borrowed dignity either.Neither can Pakistan provide us with that dignity.Pakistan cannot even sort out its own dignity, let alone the Sikhs.
The cause of fall of our dignity in the 1980s was not the indian government or the hindu,it was our own insular leadership, which we still have not got right today.Sikh leadership played a big role in bring the 1984s upon the country.
Can you not see what this leadership is duing on the issue of UNESCO heritage today.They did not even do their home work over it.Now they are blaming each other.
We cannot run our Gurduaras diplomatically and effectively.Leave alone a country.We will probably land up having five different governments in existence and probably be worst off than even the pakistanis.
Now within India, the Sikh has arisen again.We will arise again.Half our community is settlled in the rest of India.Are you suggesting we cause another ghallughara and kill them off as well.That is very innnsular thinking.
India has its faults,but we have also as a Community have opur faulty leadership.We could have had 120,000,000 dalits converting to Sikhism in 1937, but the Sikh l;eadership got scared that the Punjabi Sikhs will be outnumbered so they messed around and lost those converts.
Until such time we mature as a community, we cannot move on.
People like dayanand should also understand we cannot succumb to the threats that he is dreaming about.It is culprits like him, that should be hung sky high.
The issue is not of fairness, it is of facts.Within twenty years we have arisen and today, a Sikh PM leads, if the SGPC and Akali dal have some sense, they should play politics to their advantage, and get all they want.
When Akali Dal was in power, what did Badal do to relesae the Sikh detainees?NOTHING.
THis will not happen in Pakistan.I agreew ith Syed, but saying is another thing from the actual practice and the benefit the ordinary common man on the strreet gets.If the common Sikh does not feel secure,then there is no place in pakistan for non muslims.
I am not suggesting we forget 1984, we should proceed until we get justice.This what the indian democracy is all about.
This will not and cannot happen in Pakistan.Justice will comen in india .The whole indian nation repents it .We CANNOT forget it like RSS choocha Dayanand says.In fact he should not forget,what has happened to Modi, will happen to Tytler, the next time around.The world has found a way round it.
We just have no place for mad hat fanatics like dayanand because I, as a Sikh REFUSE to live or worry what will happen again, cause RSS dayanand should not forget what happened in Delhi in april 1985, when the Sikhs got the upper hand in the renewed riots , and the government had to act quickly to stop the riots.
At least we are able to demand justice for 1984, let us see any one ask for theose who killed nine months after the partition in Karachi.
Gurcharan Singh Kulim
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
ppppp · 30 Mar 2005
to check the instability of pakistan there was almost civil war between balustiani tribesmen and the pakistan army a while ago which lasted many days on end in west pakistan. The only thing that holds pakistan together from becoming another afghanistan is american intervention.
Out there your average guy walks with weopons like ak47s silencers, grenades down a road. its a shasterdhari culture built on war . Whats the gov gonna do to protect sikhs? it can hold back 200 odd semi civilised punjabis in nankana sahb riot, thats all it will ever be able to do for a minority. It can never raise nukes against its own ummah because pakistan is an islamic nation. it will never be able to contain untamed tribals outside punjab their crazy nutcases anxiously waiting for any religious jung. when it comes to non muslims settling in their lands it will be a matter of time something serius kicks off. Especially with high anti indian feeling, a sardar is a common image of india for pakistanis outside punjab.
What happened when america put bases in west pakistan? the media did not fully cover it but the tribals went mad and tried to bomb them out. And you think sikhs will be safe out there?
there is a definate two worlds apart from what pakistans tribal reality and how it will recognise sikhs and what pakistan gov wants to put on paper. the real pakistan is not whats in black and white but what exists out there according to native tribal codes which are written in blood while the gov writes in ink. The gov is incapable of messing with an uncontrolled giant.
Sikhs are not even muslim.
dayanand no offence but hindu opinion does not hold water in this thread purely because of the nature of the subject. It is about sikhs and pakistan today.
Re: NRI Sikhs may own houses at Nankana Sahib
bangdu · 08 Apr 2005
We want a new south Asia, a new south Asian, and a new concept of being in the south Asia.
The old south Asia is dying, and there is no need to help her to survive any more. The old south Asia is on the deathbed: don't mourn for her but help her to die. Because only with the death of the old can the new be born. The cessation of the old is the beginning of the new.
(encourage muzaffarabad-srinagar bus service, support tibet-sikkim trade root, iran-pakistan-india gas pipe line, burma-bengladesh-india gas pipe line, nepal-bhutan-india-bangladesh-china electric greed station, maldives-srilanka-india sea trade root, india-pakistan-afghanistan land trade root)
My message to south Asia is let's design a new south Asian.
My message to south Asian is: Enough is enough. Awake!
See what we have done to ourself. In 57 years we have fought 4 wars n still surviving with civil wars. We cannot call this south Asia healthy place to live. We lag behind many regions in the world.We become illitrate, poor, backward n waek.
Something very basic has gone wrong with south asia.
Each south Asian is born to be a Ram, Jesus, Buddha,Mohammed & Nanak: less than that is not going to fulfill our dreams n requirements.
We require millions of Ashafaquallh Khan(THE FIRST SHAHID OF SOUTH ASIA), Subhash Chandra Bose (salute THE GREAT LEADER of south asia AFTER ASHOKA N AKBER), Shahnawaz, Binova Vawey(the practical reformist), Mao se tung, Deng Siao PingSatya shree sai baba (the living legend the gret danvir karn of south asia n philanthropist), Moinuddin Chisti Rehmatullah Alaih, bulley shah, Rahim Kahn Kahna, Kabir (but not gandhi, jinnah, nehru n patel, iqbal i can respect dogs for their loyality but can't compare the politicians with dogs )
But what has gone wrong with south asia? Why has south Asian lived for years & years in a kind of backwardness n darkness?
For hundreds of years we have lived with a concept of south Asia as a battleground among Hindu, Buddhist, Sikh, Christen, Muslim, Chinese, Indian Pakistani, bangladesi, sri lankan, bhutani , nepali, burmi, afghani, maldipi.
The consequences of such have severely limited the potential of south Asia .
To destroy south Asia, to destroy her power, a great strategy has been used & and that is to divide south Asian in Hindu, Buddhist, Sikh, Christen & Muslim n south asia in whole as china, afgahnistan, india, pakistan burma bangladesh, nepal, sri lanka, maldives, bhutan...... (here never think that i'm supporter of so called AKHAND BAHARAT the fools slogan)
We have tought with the concept of either/or: either be a Hindu or be a Muslim, either be a Sikh or be a Christian, either be indian or pakistani or chinese
We have been told we cannot be equal.
This has been the root cause of south Asian’s misery.
West had looted & still have been looting us on the golden rule “divide & rule” here only china is exceptional (be care i never believe in east or west i just uncover the corrupt one by just reference)
south Asia can become a haven/golden bird; all that is needed is the art of creating a harmony among south Asian. no one is high cast or low cast no one is backward or forward no one has superior religion/culture/philosophy/nationality. all are equal. all are south asian. every one has right to progress, to reach highest post n to earn liveliyhood
BAD POLITICS N RELIGIOUS/CULTURAL/NATIONAL EXTREMSIM NEVER LET PEOPLE TOGETHER BUT TECHNOLOGY, EDUCATION N ECONOMY DOES.
[%sig%]