Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

suicide

suicide

Phasthat · 18 Mar 2005

If an Amritdharee, Rehit-keeping Sikh commits suicide, do they get re-born as a Sikh? Just wondering...

Re: suicide

Big G · 18 Mar 2005

NO. In matter of fact, they will get stuck in 8.4 million round of jhoons, again. A sikh is a sikh because of his good karams. And Suiciding is a paap, therefore there would be a big chance of a somebody been reborn as a non-sikh.

Re: suicide

.. · 18 Mar 2005

If you use the tactic of suicide bombing and become shaheed is this against gurmat. I have read stuff before about couple singhs who did this i think, im not positive.

Re: suicide

sahajdhari · 19 Mar 2005

at dardar sahib, goi says it only sent one tank in, actully it was more like 8 in the parkarma alone...to stop them singhs straped bombs to themselves and jumped in the way to stop the tanks......the tanks being stoped 20 meters up the parkarma became an obstacle for other tanks and troops to go around.......this allowed singhs to hold them off even longer......how is this against gurmat?

Re: suicide

etka · 19 Mar 2005

its not anti gurmat in that context...its taking shaheedi... unless ur depressed and commit suicide thats gay

Re: suicide

. · 20 Mar 2005

although i believe suicide from any result even depression is anti gurmat, i feel we should open our hearts and souls a bit more instead of judging.

Re: suicide

ms · 20 Mar 2005

what is 8.4 million rounds of jhoons?

Re: suicide

kaur · 20 Mar 2005

Who are we judge in the circumstances whether a person who gets commit suicide is put into the 8.4 million joon. Only Waheguru Jee knows. Bhul Chuk Maaf Fateh

Re: suicide

Sikhi · 20 Mar 2005

Sat Sri Akaal, And what about Shaheed (?) who killed beant singh in '95? He blew himself and beant to pieces. Is he too a shaheed?

Re: suicide

Pardeep Singh Bilga · 21 Mar 2005

Chandigarh wich mard dalera(n) sohni jago pheri, had julam d Beantay kiti, Singha kar leya dheri, DILAWAR SINGH ne kar qurbani, ous di billi bulai-ah, vey hun jago aya

Re: suicide

hmmm · 21 Mar 2005

Ok - a realted qn that comes to mind....... What if someone tried to commit suicide, but didn't succeed - would this be considered a kurehit?

Re: suicide

RoopKaur · 21 Mar 2005

>What if someone tried to commit suicide, but didn't succeed - would this be considered a kurehit?< Obviously its a kurehit, since you are going against guru jis hukam and trying to take things into your own hands. Imagine if someone gave a really valuable gift (this life) and you spit on it and throw it away (commiting suicide) how would the gift giver feel about this. I would say suicide is a MAHA kurehit

Re: suicide

. · 21 Mar 2005

I think baani tells us that those who commit suicide take on the sins of the entire world. That would be pretty bad in terms of the karma you'd acquire as a result of such an act. But suicide isn't just taking a blade to your wrist etc. Baani also tells us that those who don't meditate on Guru Sahib are aatam ghaati as well. If we don't remember Guru Sahib and don't do naam and baani, we are already in the act of commiting suicide ourselves.

Re: suicide

Sohagani · 22 Mar 2005

I don't know if it's fair to say that the 'giver' would react with the same feelings an ordinary person would. [%sig%]

Re: suicide

amanpreet · 22 Mar 2005

if they have been good in there life then they will stay with god...