Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

MEDIA COVERAGE BIASED

MEDIA COVERAGE BIASED

RoopKaur · 16 Mar 2005

I was just going through some articles on the verdict released, and have noticed how the coverage is quite biased. What ever happened to the notion of innocent until proven guilty? These people have this presupposed idea that these two Singhs were guilty, just because that is how the media has always portrayed it. I dont think that is fair. I totally understand that the victim families wanted closure to the whole ordeal, but should this be at the cost of innocent people being charged? I think the media needs to shed their bias and present this news in a more professional way.

Re: MEDIA COVERAGE BIASED

Balpreet Singh · 16 Mar 2005

If someone had been reading the newspaper reports on the testimony and trial progress, and relied solely on those, it would have seemed as if this case were a sure thing for the prosecution. Prosecution witnesses were given full coverage and the gaping holes in their testimony as revealed by the defence were ignored. I remember hearing someone say in a docuementary once, something along the lines of "it's easy to be against some guy dressed in 18th Century Sikh warrior robes". That's the truth. It's very easy to automatically assume the guys with beards and turbans MUST have been responsible. Why? Well...they just seem the type. And the ruling makes clear that this case wasn't even a close call. Even if all the witnesses for the prosecution had been deemed credible, it STILL wasn't enough. People that knew the defence case weren't surprised by this finding, but because the media covered this story in such a biased way, everyone else is stunned. People are whining about how justice was denied. How was it denied? Would it have been justice to convict these accused based on such flimsy evidence? Paid witnesses with a background of crime and lying should have been believed? Would this have been "justice"? Throwing some random people in jail might satisfy the blood lust of the mob, but it certainly can't be called justice. Overall, I don't expect much from the media. The Indian government has done an EXCELLENT job in painting us as crazy terrorists and has even managed to cover up the genocide of the Sikh people to such an extent that our own younger generation doesn't know about it. 250 000+ dead, and we're none the wiser. The involvement of the Indian government in this disaster is also completely ignored. Until we have awareness amongst our own community we can't expect fair treatment from outsiders.

Re: MEDIA COVERAGE BIASED

etka · 16 Mar 2005

according tot he mdea they are still guilty...sad....extreemly sad.... My dad has made a phone call, and submitted a letter to cbc...we shoudl alll do the same.

Re: MEDIA COVERAGE BIASED

jagjitsingh · 17 Mar 2005

waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh Pyare jio, much of this is our won fault. From working with sikh campaigns in Uk, I have learned everything in the media is about opinions, rarely about facts. Parties who are against sikhs, lobby the media and mainpulate in their own way. Sikhs, who have been the victims, have been completely incapable of even putting their issues forward. The new generation should learn from this. Media is the real war. Because it is all about hearts and minds. Bagris staments was good, but Malik should have done one aswell in front of media rather than a website. This was their chance to say what they really wanted. Canada youth need to select eloquent and educated youth spokespeople to represent them and speak to the media. Kim Bolan would never have been able to write what she does in UK. We would have in-undated the newspapers and regulating authorities with complaints against bias. Canada youth need to organise themselves into an effective media communication group to push the sikh agenda, as happens in UK. You need to repair the damage of this trial, re-point the finger at the real perpetrators who are Indian intelligence, highlight books like soft target, and active respond and ask for the resignation or at least lobby for a full apology from Kim Bolan. The only reason media is bias, is because there are not enough of you actively emailing and writing to the editors in a constructive manner,ensuring no silly langauage. Sikhs in Uk have a difficult time with Behszti play, but many sikhs worked hard on a media damage limitation exercise. Create a task list, and put on all messagaeboards and co-ordinate a response system via everyone emailing those media stations who are providing bias coverage. - concentrate on the fact that everyone is innocent until proven guilty. - all evidence was circumstantial - all these millions spent could not prove any guilt, so why was it wasted. - why were the indian high commison not questioned when so many parties pointed to their involvement. - why was Kim Bolan allowed to push such a baseless media campaign against sikhs. Will she apologise or resign? - Sikhs have always been sympathetic to the families, many of whom are sikhs. However othercases such the Chattisinghpora massicre and genocide in Punjab and delhi roits prove the Indian government complete willing to kill to defame sikhs and exact their ethnic cleansing policies. waheguru ji kekhalsa, waheguru ji ke fateh

Re: MEDIA COVERAGE BIASED

Learner · 17 Mar 2005

I agree with Balpreet Singh Jee about the media bias. Can the sangat here please write thier views on the following link on the CBC website. http://www.cbc.ca/news/viewpoint/yourspace/air_india.html Canadians out there need to realize that these men are innocent and not stay in denial any longer by listening to the Media bias.

Re: MEDIA COVERAGE BIASED

singh · 17 Mar 2005

The other day I heard Avtar Bhangal, a sikh lawyer speaking about the case. He is a mona and someone i would expect to maybe be against this verdict, but he spoke extremely well. He explained how it took the government 15 years, this is not a short amount of time, and all they could muster was a few really uncreditable witnesses. And than the RCMP for years kept on bluffing saying 'we are close, we are going to charge them soon' thinking that Bagri and Malik saab might run off to India and indicate their guilt. However, this did not happen and now they had no choice to bring it to trial and see what would happen. And obviously with the limited evidence these singhs were not convicted, but had to spend 4 yrs in jail. And he spoke about how the public is really being fed alot of garbage, as people think just because they were charged means they are guilty. He further explained that the judge sees all as innocent, until they are proven guilty and they were clearly not proven guilty, which means they are innocent! This is the beauty of the canadian justice system. He had alot of other great points supporting these Singhs and spoke extremely well.

Re: MEDIA COVERAGE BIASED

Learner · 17 Mar 2005

Can some of the sangat also reply on the following link on the BBC website: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/talking_point/4356175.stm