Text of Judgement Between:HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN AGAINST R.S. MALIK & A.S. BAGRI
>><<>><< · 16 Mar 2005
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF BRITISH COLUMBIA Citation: R. v. Malik and Bagri, 2005 BCSC 350 Date: 20050316 Docket: CC010287 Registry: Vancouver Between: HER MAJESTY THE QUEEN AGAINST RIPUDAMAN SINGH MALIK and AJAIB SINGH BAGRI Before: The Honourable Mr. Justice Josephson Reasons for Judgment Counsel for the Crown: R.H. Wright, Q.C. L.T. Doust, Q.C. R.W. Cairns, Q.C. J. Bellows, Q.C. P.K. Cheema, Q.C. G. Matei B. Toy D.M. Wiedemann G.R. Gaul A.M. Loyst M.A. Mereigh M.T. Ainslie W.B. Milman K. Andani M.M.M. Dufresne J.N. Walker C.E. Richardson M.C. Canofari C. Wong K.S. Wikberg Counsel for the Defendant, Ripudaman Singh Malik: E.D. Crossin, Q.C. W.B. Smart, Q.C. S.M. Coristine R.J. Fernyhough J.J. Rai B. Martland Counsel for the Defendant, Ajaib Singh Bagri: R.C.C. Peck, Q.C. M. Code M. Tammen N. Harris K. Hamilton P. Barclay A. Kang J. Dawe V.E. Shillington M. Mann A.G. Lee Counsel for the Court: M.R. Shapray C.S. Judd Place of Trial: Vancouver, B.C. Dates of Trial: YEAR/MONTH DAY(S) 2003 April 28, 29 30 May 5, 6, 7, 8, 12, 13, 20, 21, 22, 23, 28 June 20, 25 September 3, 5, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 15, 17, 18, 19, 24, October 1, 6, 10, 14, 16, 17, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 27, 28, 29, 31 November 3, 4, 5 6, 10, 12, 13, 14, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 24, 25, 27 December 5, 8, 9, 10, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19 2004 January 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 12, 13, 14, 15, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30 February 4, 9, 12, 13, 16, 17, 18, 27 March 1, 2, 3, 4, 5. 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 15, 17, 18, 19, 22, 23, 24, 30, 31 April 1, 2, 5, 8, 13, 14, 15, 16, 19, 20, 21, 22, 25, 26, 19, 20, 21, 22, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30 May 3, 4, 5, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 18, 19, 20, 31 June 2, 3, 4, 8, 9, 10, 11, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 28, 29, 30 July 5, 6, 7, 8, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 22 August 11, 12, 13, 17, 18, 19, 20, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27 30 September 7, 8, 20 October 1, 19, 20, 21, 22, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29 November 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 8, 9, 10, 12, 15, 16, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 29, 30 December 1, 2, 3 TABLE OF CONTENTS I. OVERVIEW........................................................................................................................ 13 II. THE CHARGES................................................................................................................. 14 III. THE FACTS....................................................................................................................... 18 A. Telephone Calls to Canadian Pacific Airlines............................................................. 18 B. The Purchase of the L. Singh and M. Singh Tickets................................................... 20 C. Telephone Call Checking on the Flight....................................................................... 21 D. Baggage Check-in...................................................................................................... 22 E. Movement of Baggage................................................................................................ 24 F. The Kanishka Aircraft.................................................................................................. 27 G. Loading of the Kanishka............................................................................................. 28 H. Arrival of the Kanishka into Shannon Airspace........................................................... 29 I. The Rescue and Recovery Operation........................................................................ 30 J. CP Air Flight 003. ....................................................................................................... 34 IV. THE FORENSIC EVIDENCE CONCERNING AIR INDIA FLIGHT 182............................ 35 A. Background................................................................................................................. 35 B. Qualifications of the Experts...................................................................................... 37 C. Overview of the Experts’ Opinions............................................................................. 39 D. The Evidence of Professor Peel................................................................................ 40 1. Basic Principles.................................................................................................. 40 2. Location of the Bomb.......................................................................................... 45 a. Hole in the Aft Fuselage............................................................................... 46 b. The Longitudinal Crack................................................................................ 49 c. Area of Damage on the Left Aft Fuselage (Targets 656, 1011 and 26)....... 55 i. Target 656.......................................................................................... 55 ii. Target 1011........................................................................................ 58 iii. Target 26 – Radiating Cracks............................................................ 65 d. Matching Bulge Apexes in the Left and Right Aft Fuselage................................................................................................. 69 i. Left Aft Fuselage................................................................................. 69 ii. Right Aft Fuselage.............................................................................. 75 e. Target 653.................................................................................................... 81 f. Why the Explosive Device Could Not Have Been in Baggage Area 51 Left 86 E. The Evidence of Dr. Trimble...................................................................................... 87 1. Targets 24 and 30............................................................................................... 90 2. Target 47 ..................................................................................................... 94 3. Front Fuselage.................................................................................................... 94 4. Keel Beam Splice Joints..................................................................................... 96 5. Evidence Inconsistent with an Explosion in Baggage Area 51.......................... 98 F. The Reconstruction.................................................................................................... 99 G. Wreckage Trail Analysis........................................................................................... 100 H. Conclusion ................................................................................................... 104 V. BACKGROUND EVIDENCE.......................................................................................... 109 A. The Golden Temple Attack and Khalistan Movement.............................................. 109 B. The Formation of the Babbar Khalsa Sikh Society of Canada................................ 111 C. Talwinder Singh Parmar........................................................................................... 112 D. Inderjit Singh Reyat................................................................................................... 112 1. Mr. Reyat’s Quest for Explosives and the June 4 Test Blast........................... 114 2. Mr. Reyat’s Evidence Regarding Mr. X and the June 4 Test Blast................... 116 3. Mr. Reyat’s Procurement of Bomb Components............................................. 117 4. The Scientific Evidence Concerning the Narita Explosion................................ 119 5. Mr. Reyat’s Actions on June 21 and June 22, 1985.......................................... 120 6. Conclusions Regarding Mr. Reyat.................................................................... 120 VI. EVIDENCE AGAINST MR. MALIK................................................................................ 122 A. Overview ................................................................................................... 122 B. Background Information........................................................................................... 122 C. The Evidence of Jagdev Singh Dhillon..................................................................... 122 D. The Evidence of Mr. A.............................................................................................. 123 E. Defence Evidence Regarding Mr. A’s Allegations.................................................... 128 1. Renovations to the Ross Street Temple........................................................... 128 2. The Location of Mr. Malik’s Stall........................................................................ 129 F. The Evidence of Mr. B.............................................................................................. 129 G. The Evidence of Ms. D............................................................................................. 138 1. Overview ... ………..………………………………………………………… 138 2. Personal Background........................................................................................ 138 3. Contact with Others at the Khalsa School........................................................ 140 4. Relationship with Mr. Malik................................................................................ 141 5. Mr. Malik’s Admissions...................................................................................... 143 a. The Newspaper Confession...................................................................... 143 b. The Cudail Discussion............................................................................... 150 c. The Anashka Conversation........................................................................ 152 d. The Mr. B Discussion................................................................................. 153 e. The Calgary Meeting.................................................................................. 153 f. The Seattle Meeting.................................................................................... 153 6. Evidence Regarding 1996 and 1997................................................................. 154 7. Human Rights Complaints................................................................................ 157 8. Ms. D’s Civil Action............................................................................................ 158 9. Contact with CSIS............................................................................................. 158 10. Dealings with the RCMP................................................................................... 161 11. Delay in Reporting the Newspaper Confession................................................ 162 12. The Journal ................................................................................................... 162 13. Interaction with Mr. B......................................................................................... 166 14. Threats and Life in the Witness Protection Program....................................... 167 15. The Cross-examination of Ms. D...................................................................... 168 a. Emotional Attachment to the Khalsa Pre-school....................................... 168 b. Relationship with Mr. Malik......................................................................... 169 c. The Newspaper Confession...................................................................... 171 d. The Cudail Discussion............................................................................... 173 e. Reading Books about the Air India Explosion............................................ 174 f. The Seattle Trip.......................................................................................... 174 g. The Anashka Conversation........................................................................ 175 h. Dealings with CSIS.................................................................................... 175 i. Dealings with the RCMP............................................................................ 177 H. The Evidence of CSIS Agent Nicholas Rowe.......................................................... 178 1. Direct Examination............................................................................................ 178 2. Cross-examination............................................................................................ 183 a. The First Telephone Call and the Meeting at Starbucks............................ 183 b. The Hotel Meetings..................................................................................... 185 c. Ms. D’s Motivations and Involvement of the RCMP................................... 187 d. Ms. D’s First Contact with the RCMP........................................................ 190 I. RCMP Evidence Regarding Ms. D........................................................................... 191 1. Initial Dealings with Ms. D................................................................................. 191 2. Information Provided by Ms. D – November, 1997 to April, 1998..................... 194 J. Telephone Calls Between Mr. Malik and Ms. D........................................................ 201 K. The Evidence of Narinder Singh Gill......................................................................... 201 L. The Evidence of Joginder Singh Gill......................................................................... 208 M. The Evidence of Mr. Malik’s Financial Support of the Reyat Family........................ 210 N. Evidence of Association........................................................................................... 210 O. The Evidence of Mohinder Cudail............................................................................. 211 P. The Evidence of Inderjit Singh Arora........................................................................ 212 Q. Mindy Bhandher’s Whereabouts in Spring, 1997..................................................... 213 R. The Evidence of Daljit Singh Sandhu....................................................................... 215 S. The Evidence of Satwant Singh Sandhu.................................................................. 218 T. Defence Evidence Regarding the Seattle Meeting................................................... 221 VII. SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES REGARDING MR. MALIK.................................. 222 A. Motive ................................................................................................... 222 1. Position of Mr. Malik........................................................................................... 222 2. Position of the Crown........................................................................................ 223 B. Evidence of Association........................................................................................... 224 1. Position of Mr. Malik........................................................................................... 224 2. Position of the Crown........................................................................................ 228 C. Attempts to Recruit Individuals to Deliver Bombs.................................................... 230 1. Position of Mr. Malik........................................................................................... 230 a. Jagdev Singh Dhillon.................................................................................. 230 b. Mr. A ................................................................................................... 231 c. Mr. B ................................................................................................... 233 2. Position of the Crown........................................................................................ 238 a. Jagdev Singh Dhillon.................................................................................. 238 b. Mr. A ................................................................................................... 239 c. Mr. B ................................................................................................... 239 D. Ms. D and Related Witnesses................................................................................. 241 1. Position of Mr. Malik........................................................................................... 241 a. Overview ................................................................................................... 241 b. Relationship with Mr. Malik......................................................................... 242 c. Ms. D’s State of Mind in 1996..................................................................... 243 d. Ms. D’s State of Mind in 1997..................................................................... 245 e. Ms. D’s Actions Belie Her Words............................................................... 246 f. Destruction of Journal and File Materials................................................... 247 g. The Newspaper Confession...................................................................... 248 i. Information in the Public Domain..................................................... 251 ii. The Bhandher Speeding Ticket........................................................ 256 iii. Response to Crown’s Submission on Delay in Reporting Newspaper Confession.................................................................... 256 iv. Ms. D’s Journal................................................................................. 257 h. The Cudail Discussion............................................................................... 259 i. The Anashka Conversation........................................................................ 262 j. The Mr. B Discussion................................................................................. 263 k. The Calgary Meeting.................................................................................. 264 l. The Seattle Meeting.................................................................................... 264 m. General Issues Regarding Credibility......................................................... 266 n. The Evidence of Mr. Arora.......................................................................... 266 o. The Evidence of Nick Rowe....................................................................... 267 p. Daljit Singh Sandhu.................................................................................... 270 q. Satwant Singh Sandhu............................................................................... 272 2. Position of the Crown........................................................................................ 274 a. Overview ................................................................................................... 274 b. Demeanour on the Witness Stand............................................................ 275 c. The Nature of the Relationship................................................................... 276 d. Telephone Contact Between Mr. Malik and Ms. D..................................... 277 e. The Newspaper Confession...................................................................... 278 i. Ms. D’s Journal................................................................................. 281 ii. Independent Confirmatory Evidence of the Newspaper Confession....................................................................................... 282 iii. Information in the Public Domain..................................................... 283 iv. Delay in Reporting the Newspaper Confession............................... 284 f. The Cudail Discussion............................................................................... 284 g. The Anashka Conversation........................................................................ 286 h. The Mr. B Discussion................................................................................. 287 i. The Calgary Meeting.................................................................................. 288 j. The Seattle Meeting.................................................................................... 288 k. The Evidence of Nick Rowe....................................................................... 290 l. Ms. D’s Dealings with the RCMP............................................................... 291 m. Daljit Singh Sandhu.................................................................................... 292 n. Satwant Singh Sandhu............................................................................... 293 E. Post Offence Conduct.............................................................................................. 294 1. Position of Mr. Malik........................................................................................... 294 a. Financial Support of the Reyat Family....................................................... 294 b. The Evidence of Joginder Singh Gill.......................................................... 296 2. Position of the Crown........................................................................................ 297 a. Financial Support of the Reyat Family....................................................... 297 b. The Evidence of Joginder Singh Gill.......................................................... 299 VIII.APPLICABLE LEGAL PRINCIPLES................................................................................... 300 A. Standard of Proof ................................................................................................... 300 B. Motive.......... ................................................................................................... 303 c. Vetrovec Cautions 304 IX. CONCLUSIONS REGARDING THE CASE AGAINST MR. MALIK............................ 307 A. Cross-examination of Crown Witnesses................................................................. 307 B. Motive........................................................................................................................ 309 C. Evidence of Association........................................................................................... 309 D. The Attempts to Recruit Individuals to Deliver Bombs............................................. 310 1. Jagdev Singh Dhillon......................................................................................... 310 2. Mr. A.................................................................................................................. 311 3. Mr. B.................................................................................................................. 313 E. Ms. D........................................................................................................................ 318 1. Manner and Demeanour................................................................................... 318 2. The Relationship Between Ms. D and Mr. Malik................................................ 318 3. The Newspaper Confession............................................................................. 326 a. Details of the Newspaper Confession in the Public Domain..................... 329 b. The Evidence of Mr. Arora.......................................................................... 331 c. The Bhandher Speeding Ticket.................................................................. 332 d. The Journal................................................................................................. 332 e. The Involvement of Daljit Singh Sandhu.................................................... 335 f. The Involvement of Satwant Singh Sandhu............................................... 335 g. Summary of Conclusions Regarding the Newspaper Confession............ 336 4. The Cudail Discussion...................................................................................... 337 5. The Anashka Conversation............................................................................... 340 6. The Mr. B Discussion........................................................................................ 342 7. The Calgary Meeting......................................................................................... 343 8. The Seattle Trip................................................................................................. 343 9. Final Conclusion Regarding Ms. D’s Credibility................................................... 344 F. Post-Offence Conduct............................................................................................. 345 1. Financial Support of the Reyat Family.............................................................. 345 2. The Evidence of Joginder Singh Gill................................................................. 346 G. Final Conclusions ................................................................................................... 347 X. THE EVIDENCE AGAINST MR. BAGRI....................................................................... 348 A. Motive........................................................................................................................ 349 1. Mr. Bagri’s Speeches........................................................................................ 349 a. Madison Square Gardens Speech............................................................. 349 b. Panthak Conference Speech..................................................................... 350 2. Statements to the Police................................................................................... 351 a. Wilf Bells ................................................................................................... 351 b. Detective Sergeant Keith Weston.............................................................. 352 3. Other Evidence of Motive.................................................................................. 354 B. Evidence of Inculpatory Statements......................................................................... 354 1. Mr. C and Related Witnesses........................................................................... 354 a. Overview.................................................................................................... 354 b. Mr. C’s Background.................................................................................... 356 i. General............................................................................................. 356 ii. Criminal History................................................................................ 356 iii. The Deshmesh Regiment and the New Orleans Incident............... 358 iv. The Air India/Narita Explosions......................................................... 362 v. Becoming an FBI Informant.............................................................. 364 vi. Assistance from the FBI................................................................... 366 Financial Assistance................................................................. 366 Immigration Assistance............................................................. 366 vii. Additional Immigration Matters......................................................... 369 c. Mr. Bagri’s Alleged Statements to Mr. C.................................................... 370 i. Post-MSG Conference Statement................................................... 370 ii. Gas Station Conversation................................................................ 372 iii. Stockton Conference Conversation................................................. 376 iv. Richmond Hill Temple Conversations.............................................. 378 “The Walls Have Ears”.............................................................. 378 Reyat Extradition Conversation................................................. 379 v. The Lachine Temple Speech........................................................... 383 d. Mr. C’s Relationship with the RCMP.......................................................... 383 e. Further Evidence of Mr. C.......................................................................... 391 i. Relationship with Mr. Bagri............................................................... 391 ii. Conversations with Kamal Jit........................................................... 391 f. The Evidence of Mr. Parrish....................................................................... 392 i. The New Orleans Incident................................................................ 392 ii. Notes and Telexes; FBI Procedures................................................ 393 iii. September 25, 1985 Debriefing....................................................... 394 iv. Telexes regarding Mr. C................................................................... 398 September 28, 1987.................................................................. 398 January 25, 1988 Telex............................................................. 399 April 13, 1989 Fax...................................................................... 400 July 7, 1989 Telex...................................................................... 401 v. Post-MSG Conference Statement................................................... 403 vi. Memory-refreshing Exercise............................................................ 403 g. Evidence of Defence Witnesses............................................................... 405 i. The Evidence of Jack Cloonan......................................................... 405 ii. The Evidence of Balbir Singh Grahala............................................. 413 iii. The Evidence of Gurmit Singh Kalotia............................................. 416 iv. The Evidence of Kamal Jit................................................................ 421 2. Ms. E and Related Witnesses.......................................................................... 423 a. Overview.................................................................................................... 423 b. The Evidence of Ms. E............................................................................... 424 c. First Contact with the RCMP..................................................................... 430 d. Contact with CSIS...................................................................................... 431 i. September 10, 1987 Interview.......................................................... 431 ii. September 24, 1987 Interview.......................................................... 435 iii. October 7, 1987 Interview................................................................ 438 e. Mr. Laurie’s Reports................................................................................... 440 f. Ms. E’s Evidence Regarding her Interviews with Mr. Laurie...................... 441 g. Ms. E’s Interview with Cpl. Best................................................................. 442 C. Jagdish Johal ................................................................................................... 442 XI. SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES REGARDING MR. BAGRI.................................. 445 A. Motive......... ................................................................................................... 445 1. Position of the Crown........................................................................................ 445 2. Position of Mr. Bagri.......................................................................................... 450 B. Mr. C and Related Witnesses.................................................................................. 455 1. Position of the Crown........................................................................................ 455 a. Mr. C ................................................................................................... 455 i. Relationship with the FBI.................................................................. 455 ii. Mr. C’s Character............................................................................. 457 iii. Out-of-court Lies.............................................................................. 459 iv. Refreshing Mr. C’s Memory.............................................................. 460 v. Benefits for Testimony..................................................................... 461 vi. Mr. Bagri’s Statements..................................................................... 462 Post-MSG Conference Statement............................................ 463 Gas Station Conversation......................................................... 463 vii. No Reason to Fabricate................................................................... 466 viii. Vetrovec Caution............................................................................. 467 b. The Related Witnesses............................................................................. 467 i. The FBI Witnesses – Mr. Parrish and Mr. Cloonan......................... 467 ii. Balbir Singh...................................................................................... 472 iii. Gurmit Singh Kalotia......................................................................... 473 iv. Kamal Jit........................................................................................... 474 2. Position of Mr. Bagri.......................................................................................... 475 a. Mr. C ................................................................................................... 475 i. Character.......................................................................................... 476 Involvement in Criminal Activities.............................................. 476 Immigration History................................................................... 476 Pursuit of Benefits..................................................................... 478 The New Orleans Incident......................................................... 480 Becoming an FBI Informant...................................................... 481 ii. Bias and Self-interest....................................................................... 482 iii. Mr. C’s Evidence Regarding Mr. Bagri’s Alleged Statements.......... 483 Post-MSG Conference Statement............................................ 483 Gas Station Conversation......................................................... 484 Stockton and Richmond Hill Temple Statements..................... 487 iv. Vetrovec Caution............................................................................. 489 b. Mr. Parrish.................................................................................................. 489 c. Balbir Singh and Gurmit Singh Kalotia....................................................... 493 d. Kamal Jit ................................................................................................... 495 C. Ms. E and Related Witnesses.................................................................................. 496 1. Position of the Crown........................................................................................ 496 a. Ultimate Reliability of Ms. E’s Statements................................................. 497 b. Accuracy of the Record............................................................................. 500 c. Confirmatory Evidence............................................................................... 502 2. Position of Mr. Bagri.......................................................................................... 503 a. June, 1985 and December, 1985 Visits..................................................... 503 b. Ms. E’s Statements Entitled to Little Weight.............................................. 505 c. Ultimate Reliability of Ms. E’s Statements................................................. 506 i. Oath.................................................................................................. 506 ii. Promise of Confidentiality................................................................. 506 iii. Record of the Statements................................................................ 508 iv. Cross-examination........................................................................... 509 v. Contemporaneity.............................................................................. 509 vi. Tainting............................................................................................. 510 vii. Trial Evidence................................................................................... 513 d. R. v. Czibulka............................................................................................ 513 D. Ms. Johal...... ................................................................................................... 515 1. Position of the Crown........................................................................................ 515 2. Position of Mr. Bagri.......................................................................................... 517 E. Evidence of Association........................................................................................... 519 1. Position of the Crown........................................................................................ 519 a. Nature of Mr. Bagri’s Relationship with Mr. Parmar................................... 520 b. Telephone Contact..................................................................................... 521 c. Personal Contact....................................................................................... 522 d. Evidence of Association with the Other Conspirators............................... 523 2. Position of Mr. Bagri.......................................................................................... 524 a. Telephone Contact..................................................................................... 525 b. Personal Contact....................................................................................... 528 XII. CONCLUSIONS REGARDING THE CASE AGAINST MR. BAGRI............................ 529 A. Motive......... ................................................................................................... 529 B. Mr. C and Related Witnesses.................................................................................. 530 1. Credibility of Mr. C............................................................................................. 530 2. Mr. Bagri’s Alleged Statements......................................................................... 538 a. Post-MSG Conference Statement............................................................. 538 b. Gas Station Statement............................................................................... 539 c. The Other Statements............................................................................... 547 3. Summary of Conclusions Regarding Mr. C...................................................... 550 C. Ms. E......... ................................................................................................... 550 1. Re-visiting Threshold Admissibility................................................................... 551 a. R. v. Czibulka............................................................................................ 551 b. Conclusion................................................................................................. 553 2. Ultimate Reliability of Ms. E’s Statements........................................................ 555 D. Ms. Johal................................................................................................................... 561 E. Summary of Conclusions Regarding Mr. Bagri....................................................... 561 F. Charter Remedies 565 XIII. SUMMARY........................................................................................................................... 566 A. Introduction............................................................................................................... 566 B. Tickets and Check-in of Baggage............................................................................ 568 C. Forensics.................................................................................................................. 570 D. Historical Context ................................................................................................... 573 E. Talwinder Singh Parmar........................................................................................... 574 F. Inderjit Singh Reyat................................................................................................... 575 G. The Case Against Mr. Malik...................................................................................... 578 1. The Evidence of Mr. B....................................................................................... 579 2. The Evidence of Mr. A....................................................................................... 581 3. The Evidence of Ms. D...................................................................................... 582 4. Conclusions Regarding Mr. Malik...................................................................... 588 a. Mr. B and Mr. A........................................................................................... 588 b. Ms. D ................................................................................................... 590 H. The Case Against Mr. Bagri..................................................................................... 595 1. Evidence of Motive............................................................................................ 595 2. Evidence of Association.................................................................................... 597 3. Inculpatory Statements by Mr. Bagri................................................................. 597 a. Mr. C ................................................................................................... 598 b. Ms. E ................................................................................................... 605 4. Conclusion Regarding Mr. Bagri....................................................................... 607 I. Final Conclusion ................................................................................................... 608 APPENDIX A – List of Passengers and Crew of Flight 182........................................................ 610 APPENDIX B – Boeing 747-200 Fuselage and Empennage with Skin Targets......................... 616 APPENDIX C – Aft Fuselage Targets Near to Bulk Cargo Area................................................. 617 APPENDIX D – Target T1011 – View from Left Side.................................................................. 618 I. OVERVIEW [1] In the early morning hours of June 23, 1985, Air India Flight 182, carrying 329 people[1], was destroyed mid-flight by a bomb located in its rear cargo hold. Remnants of the plane and bodies of some of the victims were recovered from the Atlantic Ocean off the coast of Ireland. There were no survivors. [2] Fifty-four minutes earlier, another bomb had exploded inside the baggage handling area of the New Tokyo International Airport in Narita, Japan (“Narita Airport”). Two Japanese baggage handlers were killed instantly by the force of the explosion and four others were injured. [3] Through the multinational police investigation that followed, it was learned that two suitcases had been checked in at the Vancouver International Airport (the “Vancouver Airport”) on the morning of June 22, 1985 and loaded onto two aircraft without any accompanying passengers boarding those flights. One of the suitcases had been interlined through Toronto and loaded onto Air India Flight 182. The other suitcase had been located in the baggage container from which the explosion at Narita Airport had originated. That suitcase had been destined for an Air India flight heading to Bangkok. [4] A few days prior to these incidents, two separate airline tickets had been booked on Canadian Pacific Airlines flights originating out of Vancouver. These tickets, subsequently picked up and paid for in cash, corresponded with the tickets that were used to check in the unaccompanied baggage at the Vancouver Airport. [5] The investigation into this matter continues to this day. In October, 2000, Ripudaman Singh Malik (“Mr. Malik”) and Ajaib Singh Bagri (“Mr. Bagri”) were charged with a series of offences alleging their involvement in a conspiracy to commit murder and place bombs on aircraft. The trial commenced in April, 2003 and continued for approximately sixteen months. No forensic evidence was led linking Mr. Malik and Mr. Bagri to either bomb. Leaving aside the issue of the location of the bomb on Air India Flight 182, the determination of guilt devolves to a weighing of the credibility of a number of witnesses who testified during the course of the trial. Neither accused testified in these proceedings. II. THE CHARGES [6] Mr. Malik and Mr. Bagri stand charged as follows: Count 1 THAT between the 1st day of June, 1984 and the 24th day of June, 1985, at or near the Cities of Vancouver, Kamloops and Duncan, the District of Burnaby, the Corporation of the Township of Richmond and elsewhere in the Province of British Columbia and Canada did unlawfully conspire together the one with the other or others of them and with TALWINDER SINGH PARMAR and with a person or with persons unknown, to murder the passengers and crew of an aircraft designated as Air India Flight 301 scheduled to depart New Tokyo International Airport, Narita, Japan at approximately 1:05 A.M. on June 23, 1985 (Pacific Daylight Time) for Bangkok, Thailand, and the 329 passengers and crew (named in Schedule A, attached) of an aircraft designated as Air India Flight 182 which departed from Mirabel International Airport, Montreal, Quebec, Canada at approximately 7:20 P.M. on June 22, 1985 (Pacific Daylight Time) for Heathrow International Airport, London, England, contrary to Section 423(1)(a) of the Criminal Code of Canada, R.S.C. 1970, c. C-34 and against the peace of our Lady the Queen her Crown and Dignity. Count 2 THAT on or about the 23rd day of June, 1985 (Pacific Daylight Time) at or near the Corporation of the Township of Richmond in the Province of British Columbia and elsewhere in the Province of British Columbia and Canada and off the west coast of the Republic of Ireland did commit the first degree murder of the 329 passengers and crew of Air India Flight 182 (referred to in Count 1 above), contrary to Section 218(1) of the Criminal Code of Canada, R.S.C. 1970, c. C-34 and against the peace of our Lady the Queen her Crown and Dignity. Count 3 THAT between the 18th day of June, 1985 and the 24th day of June, 1985, at or near the Corporation of the Township of Richmond in the Province of British Columbia and elsewhere in the Province of British Columbia and Canada, and at or near Narita, Chiba Prefecture, Japan, did attempt to commit the murder of the passengers and crew of Air India 301 (referred to in Count 1 above) by attempting to place on board the said aircraft a bomb intended to cause its destruction and the death of its occupants, contrary to Section 222 of the Criminal Code of Canada, R.S.C. 1970, c. C-34 and against the peace of our Lady the Queen her Crown and Dignity. Count 4 THAT on or about the 22nd day of June, 1985 (Pacific Daylight Time) at or near the Corporation of the Township of Richmond, in the Province of British Columbia, and elsewhere in the Province of British Columbia and Canada, and in Narita, Chiba Prefecture, Japan, did commit the first degree murder of HIDEO ASANO and HIDEHARU KODA, contrary to Section 218(1) of the Criminal Code of Canada, R.S.C. 1970, c. C-34 and against the peace of our Lady the Queen her Crown and Dignity. Count 5 THAT between the 1st day of June, 1984 and the 24th day of June, 1985 at or near the Cities of Vancouver, Kamloops and Duncan, the District of Burnaby, the Corporation of the Township of Richmond and elsewhere in the Province of British Columbia and Canada did unlawfully conspire together the one with the other or others of them and with TALWINDER SINGH PARMAR and with a person or with persons unknown, to commit the indictable offences of causing to be placed on board aircraft in service, namely: an aircraft designated as Canadian Pacific Airlines Flight 003 which departed the Vancouver International Airport at or near the Corporation of the Township of Richmond, British Columbia at approximately 1:30 P.M. on June 22, 1985 (Pacific Daylight Time); Air India Flight 301 (referred to in Count 1 above); an aircraft designated as Canadian Pacific Airlines Flight 060 which departed the Vancouver International Airport at or near the Corporation of the Township of Richmond, British Columbia at approximately 9:20 A.M. on June 22, 1985 (Pacific Daylight Time), and; an aircraft designated as Air India Flight 181 which departed from Toronto, Ontario at approximately 5:20 P.M. on June 22, 1985 (Pacific Daylight Time) travelling to Montreal, Quebec where it was renamed Air India Flight 182 (referred to in Count 1 above); bombs that were likely to cause damage to the said aircraft that would render them incapable of flight or that were likely to endanger the safety of the aircraft in flight, contrary to Section 76.2(c) and 423(1)(d) of the Criminal Code of Canada, R.S.C. 1970, c. C-34 and against the peace of our Lady the Queen her Crown and Dignity. Count 6 THAT on or about the 22nd day of June, 1985, at the Vancouver International Airport at or near the Corporation of the Township of Richmond, in the Province of British Columbia did cause to be placed on board an aircraft in service, namely Canadian Pacific Airlines Flight 003 (referred to in Count 5 above), a bomb that was likely to cause damage to the said aircraft that would render it incapable of flight or that was likely to endanger the safety of the aircraft in flight, contrary to Section 76.2(c) of the Criminal Code of Canada, R.S.C. 1970, c. C-34 and against the peace of our Lady the Queen her Crown and Dignity. Count 7 THAT on or about the 22nd day of June, 1985, at the Vancouver International Airport at or near the Corporation of the Township of Richmond, in the Province of British Columbia did cause to be placed on board an aircraft in service, namely Canadian Pacific Airlines Flight 060 (referred to in Count 5 above), a bomb that was likely to cause damage to the said aircraft that would render it incapable of flight or that was likely to endanger the safety of the aircraft in flight, contrary to Section 76.2(c) of the Criminal Code of Canada, R.S.C. 1970, c. C-34 and against the peace of our Lady the Queen her Crown and Dignity. Count 8 THAT on or about the 22nd day of June, 1985, at or near the Corporation of the Township of Richmond, in the Province of British Columbia and at Lester B. Pearson International Airport at Toronto, Ontario, did cause to be placed on board an aircraft in service, namely Air India Flight 181 (referred to in Count 5 above) a bomb that was likely to cause damage to the said aircraft that would render it incapable of flight or that was likely to endanger the safety of the aircraft in flight, contrary to Section 76.2(c) of the Criminal Code of Canada, R.S.C. 1970, c. C-34 and against the peace of our Lady the Queen her Crown and Dignity. III. THE FACTS A. Telephone Calls to Canadian Pacific Airlines [7] On June 19, 1985, Martine Donahue, a reservations agent for Canadian Pacific Airlines (“CP Air”), fielded a telephone call from an individual seeking reservations for two passengers on separate flights. [8] Ms. Donahue created two reservations for the male caller. The first reservation was in the name of Mohinderbel Singh and was for a round trip between Vancouver and Bangkok, Thailand. The passenger was booked on CP Flight 003 departing Vancouver for Narita, Japan on June 22, 1985, with a connecting flight from Narita to Bangkok on Air India Flight 301. [9] The second reservation was in the name of Jaswand Singh and was for CP Air Flight 086 departing Vancouver for Montreal (Dorval) on June 22, 1985, connecting to Air India Flight 182 departing Montreal (