Did we originate from baandars?
Kulbir Singh · 16 Mar 2005
Does Gurmat and Darwinism agree?
I personally cannot accept the idea that we evoluted from baandars (monkeys). I think this theory is at odds with Gurmat.
Is Darwinism an atheist theory? I think it is. To believe in Darwinism is to believe in Atheism to some extent. Darwin believed that things happened by itself and nature governed it. Some Gursikhs take the middle path and try to bring Darwinism and Gurmat in harmony. I think it is not possible to do so.
What does Darwinism say about the origin of life? How can life come from pure matter? Is it possible to get life from matter? I personally don't think so.
I know many of my nikat-vartee gursikhs believe in Darwinism. Perhaps this thread will make things clear for me and others.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Did we originate from baandars?
Lakhvir Singh · 17 Mar 2005
I personally think that Darwin was adopted.
Re: Did we originate from baandars?
HEALLOW MOW! · 17 Mar 2005
Where does evolution contradict with Gurmat, Evolution is Graet, Varan doesnt contradict Evolution, people need to study evolution more before they assume its bullquack.
Do your research Pleaze, we shouldn't be anti-intellectual or anti-science, don't get involved in all that Po, Gurbani is 100% Truth and if Science doesnt obviously contradict it we cant be sure that Science is definately wrong.
Evolution = 10/10 Graet.
Re: Did we originate from baandars?
jugroop singh · 17 Mar 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Veer/Bhain 'g' wrote:
'who knows where we came from... aparently sikhi doesnt offer any insight into that'
Although i have not listened or read the whole of Siree Guru Sahib Ji, Sukhmani Sahib comes straight to mind when i try to remember which Shabads/Paath can help us understand the GurMat perspective regarding creation.
Perhaps the learned Veers/Bhains can help here.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: Did we originate from baandars?
can't think of a name.. · 17 Mar 2005
What I've always wondered is that if we have evolved from monkey's, how come there are no 'species' present that are the 'middle bit' between being a monkey and a human..
[%sig%]
Re: Did we originate from baandars?
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 17 Mar 2005
vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa
vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!!!!
for submission to the jaanee jaan guru khalsa
kirpaa karo deen kay daatay mayraa gun avgaN na beecharahu koee
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Darwinism suggests that certain species were created at some time, and those species either remained in their individual forms, or adapted to their surroundings and evolved into more advanced species.
Some of the less advanced species moved from place to place and subsequently evolved into further species.
Out of all of these old and new species, the older and weaker ones genetically could not survive in their environment and they died out.
When I read about Darwin's theory, I am reminded of Sikhi in other ways - not in evolution.
Guru Sahib jee says that our mool is Vaaheguroo.
bhaee praapat maanukh dehureeaa gobind milan kee ayhi thayree bareeaa
This gurbani pankiti clarifies that we were given this dehureea. We were blessed with it. We got it by Guru Sahib's kirpa and by our previous bhagti.
Gurseva thay bhagat kamaaee, THAB EHI MAANAS DAYHEE PAAEE
This gurbani pankiti suggests that after doing Guru's seva, we got the chance to do Bhagti - and in order to do Bhagti we were given this human body.
jo mai keeaa so mai paaeiaa
By our past actions and by Guru's kirpa we are in our present situation.
In Gurbani there is a reference to chauraasee lakh joon.
kee janam bheae keett patha(n)gaa ||
kee janam gaj meen kura(n)gaa ||
kee janam pa(n)khee sarap hoeiou ||
kee janam haivar brikh joeiou ||1||
mil jagadhees milan kee bareeaa ||
chira(n)kaal eih dhaeh sa(n)jareeaa ||1|| rehaao ||
kee janam sail gir kariaa ||
kee janam garabh hir khariaa ||
kee janam saakh kar oupaaeiaa ||
lakh chouraaseeh jon bhramaaeiaa ||2||
Guru Sahib jee says that in so many life times we came to this earth in so many ways.
and it says "bhae" it does not say that we evolved into these - it says "kee janam BHAE"
bhae normally means we fell there, we were thrown in to there
according to our karma and according to God's schedule we were put there
8.2 million life forms were created by Akaal Purakh.
A heavy amount of scientific evidence has caused most of the world to come to a conclusion that at some time there were only cockroaches and sea creatures.
I think - this is where Darwin's theory comes into play.
First cockroaches, then something else, then something else - that was in God's hands - not in control of nature.
I think all of the "bringing forward" of a new species is Guru ji's divine play.
In Sukhmani Sahib, Guru ji says:
naanaa roop jio svaagee dhikhaavai ||
jio prabh bhaavai thivai nachaavai ||
jo this bhaavai soee hoe ||
naanak dhoojaa avar n koe ||7||
If we put faith in nature to bring us to this earth, then we are putting faith in the demigods and goddesses.
Of course we should treat the earth with the respect it deserves. However, calling nature the supreme kartaa is to be in duality.
Darwin's theory is that NATURE causes EVOLUTION
However, I think gurbani says GOD puts CREATURES on earth according to his own hukam - whenever he wants.
prabh bhaavai thaa paathar tharaavai
This section of Sukhmani Sahib explains that PRABHOO can do anything in their BHAANAA
If God wanted, he could have made the first creature dogs .. then other creatures could have been created
I think this much is true about Darwin's theory:
[i]as time passed on earth, more and more evolved creatures began appearing[/i]
But this happened by God's control - not nature's. If we were to believe in Darwin's theory of natural selection, then we would have to assume that for millions of years, God did not have control over who God could send to earth.
First God had to send monkeys, then gorillas, then cavemen, then the modern man.
God could not send the modern man in the age of the monkey.
But the truth is - God is in control of everything, nature is not. God did not have to abide by the laws of natural selection.
If God wanted to , God could send creatures however and whenever God wanted.
Guru Sahib says
jag rachnaa sabh JHOOTTH hai, jaan layho ehi meeth
Nature is beautiful, society is beautiful, we should see God everywhere,
but this whole creation is not "thhir" or permanent
Everything could change in just an instant if Guru ji wanted.
(here comes the main point of my post... sorry for the delay)
I think this was God's divine play
What was the intent of this play?
Well, Evolution means something gets better and better.
If we were believing in survival of the fittest - and this is the kaljug - and our human species has been through so much -
Guru Sahib is showing us that now, who is the fittest.
Who, after all these million years is the strongest species?
Guru Sahib has shown us
pragtiyo khaalsaa parmaatam kee mauj
Khalsa of Guru Gobind Singh Ji is the most advanced creation of God. Vaaheguroo jee kaa Khalsa - the Khalsa is the harvest of the Creator. Guru Gobind Singh and Mata Sahib Kaur are the ultimate Khalsas.
Guru Gobind Singh ji - "veh pragtiyo purakh bhagvant roop gur gobind sooraa"
Guru ji says
sabh mukath hoaa saisaararraa naanak sachee baerree chaarr jeeo ||11||
Slowly slowly, Guru Sahib will make all jeevs mukat in his hukam
When we become Khalsa -
eik utham panth sunio gur sangat
Gursangat is the utham panth - the highest path
and it is also the highest species -
When you become a Khalsa you are BORN AGAIN into the Khalsa jeevan
You become the most EVOLVED being
I think this is GOD'S NATURAL SELECTION
From rocks and mountains we became flowers and plants
From flowers and plants we became insects and worms
From worms and insects we became birds and rodents
From those we became dogs and cats
From those we became other creatures
We may have even come as devis, devtas, and other fairies
And finally we came as Humans
But God's natural selection is not over
jinh har meet(h) lagaanaa thae jan paradhhaanaa thae ootham har har log jeeo ||
Guru Sahib jee's natural selection is that the most OOTHAM LOG were created.
This shows that natural selection and time-based evolution is not the case because "OOTHAM LOG" have been coming through many ages
har jug jug bhagat upaaeiaa
And throughout all the ages, despite any hardships,
paij rakhdaa aeeiaa raamraajay
After human beings,
there was the Khalsa
the first Khalsa was Bebe Nanaki
and after millions and millions of years
God created the most evolved being in the universe
the most humble servant of God
"purakh agamaraa"
"bekasaaraa yaar"
"shaaheshanshaah"
there is no body more evolved than my father Guru Gobind Singh ji
Now it is the kal jug - and we must all come into the protection of this MOST EVOLVED BEING
God has caused, by his own natural selection - called HUKAM - given us the Guru Nanak jyot and evolved it into the most amazing King of Kings - Guru Gobind Singh ji
This is my theory.......
Natural selection does not apply to the Khalsa and we came from Guru ji and we will go to Guru ji.
basa(n)th kee vaar mehal 5
ik oa(n)kaar sathigur prasaadh ||
har kaa naam dhhiaae kai hohu hariaa bhaaee ||
karam likha(n)thai paaeeai eih ruth suhaaee ||
van thrin thribhavan mouliaa a(n)mrith fal paaee ||
mil saadhhoo sukh oopajai lathhee sabh shhaaee ||
naanak simarai eaek naam fir bahurr n dhhaaee ||1||
pa(n)jae badhhae mehaabalee kar sachaa dtoaa ||
aapanae charan japaaeian vich dhay kharroaa ||
rog sog sabh mitt geae nith navaa niroaa ||
dhin rain naam dhhiaaeidhaa fir paae n moaa ||
jis thae oupajiaa naanakaa soee fir hoaa ||2||
[i]kithhahu oupajai keh rehai keh maahi samaavai ||
jeea ja(n)th sabh khasam kae koun keemath paavai ||[/i]
kehan dhhiaaein sunan nith sae bhagath suhaavai ||
agam agochar saahibo dhoosar lavai n laavai ||
sach poorai gur oupadhaesiaa naanak sunaavai ||3||1||
I hope my post has been coherent and clear - but I am such a pakhandee moorakh I know I must have made many mistakes. Please forgive me. Guru sahib please forgive me.
Vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa
Vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!!!!
Re: Did we originate from baandars?
HEALLOW MOW! · 17 Mar 2005
"chinese man has small eyes" because of what is known as a genetic mutation.
we did not come from monkeys. the species that we evolved from is similar in some ways but not the same as a monkey.
what is so difficult about the idea that guru evolved humans from a different form? because he didnt do it straight away He wasnt able to? guru gobind singh could have destroyed all the mughal enemies by blinking his eye but he still fought them.
come on pleaze. learn about evolution before you try to smash it.
Re: Did we originate from baandars?
Kulbir Singh · 17 Mar 2005
-----------
I don't know what darwin wrote, but do know that the current most credible theory to scientists is that life evolved from matter. Complex chemicals created very simple life forms. this process probably took place at underwater geothermal vents that protected this developing life. UV radiation (there was no ozone layer at the time) helped to cause mutations necessary for life.
I've heard that in experiments scientists had succeeeded in creating the building blocks of life by trying to simulate the hypothesized conditions, but failed to create anything close to life itself.
--------------
This is impossible. Life cannot be created from pure matter. Please provide the details of studies that prove this. They have been talking about how close they are and blah blah blah but they have never been able to create life from pure matter. A stone can sit there for million years and still it cannot create life.
Water too can stay there for million years but life cannot form in there. Only life begets life. Water in essence is H2O i.e. two atoms of Hydrogen to one atom of Oxygen. Water that we see now-a-days almost always has micro-organisms and the presence of these micro-organisms cause more life in water.
Fire cannot create any life, nor can water, or Earth etc.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Did we originate from baandars?
BirRaas Singh · 17 Mar 2005
So what do you believe Kulbir Singh? that Waheguroo put a adamjit and eveinder on the planet and was tempted by a snake to eat the forbidden ladoo? lol
Re: Did we originate from baandars?
Kulbir Singh · 17 Mar 2005
---------
So what do you believe Kulbir Singh? that Waheguroo put a adamjit and eveinder on the planet and was tempted by a snake to eat the forbidden ladoo? lol
-----------
Very funny jeeo. You have been slightly misinformed because I don’t subscribe to the Adam and Eve story. Hehe!
Anyway, coming back to this topic, I think everything came into being all of sudden. Vaheguru wanted everything to happen and it happened:
KEETA PASAAYO, IKO KAVAAYO ||
(The whole creation happened in one instance with his kavaayo or bachan or furna or thought).
The whole srishthee got created just like that and I don’t think this evolution theory that we came from baandars is true.
In many cases we don’t have full account of events that took place very recently. How can we be so sure about events that took place millions of years ago? All they talk about is theories. They claim that life came from matter. How can this be? Have they ever experienced or proven this? Never! But they still insist that life came from matter. First perhaps a micro organism came into being and then everyone else. What non-sense!
You can do as many chemical reactions as you want to but you cannot create life. All these miracles of science are done using what Vaheguru already gave them all the resources and like a child, they discover new things using Vaheguru’s resources and then they want to challenge Vaheguru. Very naïve.
It is totally false that humans evolutioned from Baandars. Who build our Dasam Duaar and Naabh-kamal? Did Evolution do this too? No way. To believe that we came from Baandars is baandarpuna.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Did we originate from baandars?
Kulwinder Singh · 17 Mar 2005
Dear Kulbir Singh Ji,
Jami Jam Ke Beikha Sumast Ek Jot hai
Na Kat Hai Na Bat hai
Na Kat Bat hoot Hai.
Life is just not how human see life, it is far more then that, five elements known to man is not the only thing he use for his creation,
pa-un paanee agnee ik vaasaa.
Within the body of air, water and fire, the One Lord dwells.
He is much bigger, much more creator and far more imaginative then whole human race can comprehend.
Thanks
Kulwinder Singh
Re: Did we originate from baandars?
putt adam dey · 18 Mar 2005
i am not so sure about evolution after reading this.
http://www.sikhitothemax.com/page.asp?ShabadID=4140
This Shabad is by Guru Arjan Dev Ji in Raag Bhairao on Pannaa 1161
chouraasee lakh firai dhivaanaa(n) ||
His beings wander insanely through 8.4 million incarnations.
baabaa aadham ko kishh nadhar dhikhaaee ||
He bestowed His Grace on Adam, the father of mankind,
oun bhee bhisath ghanaeree paaee ||2||
who then lived in paradise for a long time. ||2||
dhil khalehal jaa kai jaradh roo baanee ||
Pale are the faces of those whose hearts are disturbed.
so whats happening with the banders theory now if adam is the father of mankind?
Re: Did we originate from baandars?
Balpreet Singh · 18 Mar 2005
I think a lot of the people that comment on evolution understand evolution to be simply "baandars became humans!!". This is not evolution in its entirety, and is only one theory that has arisen.
Evolution is a reality and a fact. It has been proven over and over again. Evolution simply means that a species adapts to its environment over generations, when it faces certain stresses.
An example I use to illustrate is this: lets say there is a species of butterflies that have both white and black colours. Pollution causes all the surroundings to turn a greyish-black. So, the black butterflies are not very visible but the white stick out very boldly.
The white will get eaten by predators much more than the black. In the next generation, there will be much fewer white butterflies and many more black (who can survive much easier).
Again, in this generation, the white get eaten much more because they are visible and because of this, they reproduce less and give fewer white offspring. Over the course of multiple generations, and continued stress (i.e pollution causing black surfaces), white will eventually disappear from that butterfly species. So there you have an "evolution".
I believe in evolution because it's a fact. This does not mean that someone who believes in evolution has to necessarily also believe that men came from apes.
Re: Did we originate from baandars?
Jugroop Singh · 18 Mar 2005
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Sadh Sangat Jio,
Perhaps the question should not be: Did we originate from apes but rather: Are GurMat and Evoution Theory contradictory?
i.e. where in GurBani do we find Panktis which 'disagree' with evolution and vice versa.
VahiGuruJiKaKhalsa,VahiGuruJiKiFateh!
Re: Did we originate from baandars?
kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 18 Mar 2005
i tried to give a response to this question veerjee jugroop singh jee has asked above,
it got posted above but i don't think it has been noticed yet
could any of the gurmukhs please give your thoughts on this and also please remove any of my misconceptions in my post
Re: Did we originate from baandars?
Kulbir Singh · 18 Mar 2005
------------
just responding to kulbir singh ji's comments about can't create stuff out of gases...
they did experiments using the gases which are believed to exist in primal earth and were able to create proteins and other molecules of life by just using these gases in a chamber with a spark (big bang)..
---------
Jss jeeo, could you please refer me to this study. I don’t believe life can be created from non-living matter. It would be interesting to know what the conditions were when they created this molecule or cell of life.
----------
how do we explain the HIV virus...you guys do know that the only reason why we don't have a cure for it is cuz it evolves really really quickly...that by the time we have a cure for it, it's genome has already mutated and no longer responsive to the drugs...
how about antibiotic resistance among bacteria???...this one follows natural selection theory right to the T....
--------
I think you are mixing up natural instinct for survival that all species have with evolution of an baandar to Human. There is no proof that this ever happened. The divine wisdom that humans are equipped with cannot be a result of evolution. Dasam Duaar and Nabh Kawal cannot be a result of evolution.
---------
Evolution is a reality and a fact. It has been proven over and over again. Evolution simply means that a species adapts to its environment over generations, when it faces certain stresses
------------
No one is talking about this kind of adjustment because of stresses the species may be facing. I was talking about changing from one specie to another specie i.e. from a Baandar to Human.
---------
Again, in this generation, the white get eaten much more because they are visible and because of this, they reproduce less and give fewer white offspring. Over the course of multiple generations, and continued stress (i.e pollution causing black surfaces), white will eventually disappear from that butterfly species. So there you have an "evolution".
------------
Balpreet Singh jeeo, But a butterfly stayed a butterfly and did not become a lizard or a cat or a human. This is where I differ. Minor outwardly changes may occur in humans too but this cannot cause humans to cease to be humans or not having Dasam Duaar anymore or not having Nabh Kamal anymore.
There are four forms of Khaaniyaan. Andaj, Jeraj, Setaj and Utbhaj. If a specie is Andaj, it will never become a Setaj or Utbhaj and vice-versa. And a jooni and a specie don’t mean the same thing. Within a jooni, you can change forms and colours but you cannot create a cat from a dog.
I am not denying the kind of evolution you have suggested is happening. To change hair colour or skin colour because of atmosphere does not mean that apes could have begetted humans or that dogs can become cats over time etc. There cannot be moveover between joonis. If there is a proof, I would love to see it. It would be most interesting.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Did we originate from baandars?
Balpreet Singh · 18 Mar 2005
If the question is "did humans evolve from apes", then I will not argue the point.
But at the same time, evolution is not just about that. A single species can "evolve" so much that the different types cannot interbreed any longer and look very different. This is called "speciation". The finches on the Galapagos Islands come from one ancestory but have developed so differently (due to different stress factors on teh different islands) that they can no longer interbreed.
Re: Did we originate from baandars?
Kulbir Singh · 18 Mar 2005
---------
It doesn't look like you read any posts unless they're specifically directed to you.
I already said "start with the Miller-Urey experiment", now this time maybe you will actually find out something concrete? or maybe you will continue conjecturing?
----------
1953 Miller Experiment did not prove anything at all. Not a single living cell was created and just a few amino-acids were synthesized. All he created were a few inanimated molecules.
More than half a century later, they still have not made any progress after the 1953 experiment and this experment in itself was a failure since it did not produce any living cells.
Daas,
Kulbir Singh
Re: Did we originate from baandars?
Kulbir Singh · 18 Mar 2005
-------
But at the same time, evolution is not just about that. A single species can "evolve" so much that the different types cannot interbreed any longer and look very different. This is called "speciation". The finches on the Galapagos Islands come from one ancestory but have developed so differently (due to different stress factors on teh different islands) that they can no longer interbreed.
--------
Such species when separated and isolated may evolve a little differently but still they do not make a different specie. They still stay the same. Sometimes they are referred to as sub-species. But under no circumstances we can say that birds can become something else and cease to be birds anymore.
As for the reason why they don't interbreed anymore, the reason is not that they don't have the capability to breed but the reason is difference in reproductive behaviours. They are still, genetically speaking, members of the same species.
By breeding within species and creating different looks of the same specie, they think they are producing new species. Can they breed a dog and a cat and get a new specie? No! They have never done it so far and I doubt it can be done.
Kulbir Singh
Re: Did we originate from baandars?
Kulbir Singh · 19 Mar 2005
--------
The easy manner in which you disregard the experiment, and your reasoning for doing so, that "all he created were a few inanimated molecules" reveals your ignorance. You should "Start" with the miller-urey experiment; there is extraordinary progress that has been made, you should check out self-splicing RNA, ribozymes, etc.
-------
Don't get upset my friend. The so called extraordinary progress you have made is nothing at all. How come since 1953, when this experiment was done, nothing has been done? You evolutionists have not created a single living cell. I MEAN NOT EVEN ONE CELL. It has been more than 50 years but still you keep on persisting that you have made progress. Progress is when you can create a living cell.
---------
"The false perceptions of smug, yet naive know-it-alls that allows quick and complete disregard points more to the nature of Indians (and other peoples) because it threatens and puts into self-doubt Indian's narcissism and inferiority complex."
---------
It is not us who are suffering from inferiority complex but you so called modernists are. To deny your father is to become a ............ To deny Vaheguru and give credit to where it does not belong is highly inethical. Where did matter come from? Who created it?
I repeat again. Only life can beget life. Matter is dead and cannot create life. Do whatever you can do. Do whatever chemical reactions you want to do but you will not succeed in creating a single living cell, because it is just impossible. You are not greater than Vaheguru.
Kulbir Singh