Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Why do people hide?

Why do people hide?

Kulbir Singh · 15 Mar 2005

I wonder, why don't gursikhs post or express their views under their real names? I understand that some gursikhs maybe apprehensive about speaking in public but when expressing views that can be deemed controversial, 90% people post under anonymous or assumed names. Why? I received a couple of emails from my well-wishers and was told orally as well, that I should not voice unpopular opinions under my real name as this may tarnish my name. I replied in response to my friends and gursikhs who emailed me that I am not in a popularity contest. To say what is Gurmat, whether it makes me popular or unpopular, is utmost Gurmat. To worry what people will say is cowardly (Buz-dilee). Popularity contests, Gursikhs cannot win because many opinions they voice are contrary to the popular beliefs. It would be great if some of our regulars contributors used their real names, especially when debating. Again, this is just my opinion and is not binding on anyone. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Why do people hide?

AnotherSingh · 15 Mar 2005

I've recently come to a similar conclusion. For expressing Gurmat opinion, I use this pseudonym b/c it's gupt seva. For debates, I won't use this pseudonym if I think it's not seva.

Re: Why do people hide?

Manjit Singh · 15 Mar 2005

"I use this pseudonym b/c it's gupt seva." Don't flatter yourself! ;)

Re: Why do people hide?

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 15 Mar 2005

On the eve of New Years 2004, Bibi Parmveer Kaur, whose kirtan has really inspired me, sang a shabad "Sabh jee thaerae prabhoo maerae kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa" The shabad peirced my heart. That was the last "New Years" kirtan program that Bibi Rena Kaur attended while physically on this earth - I remember when the clock struck 12 the sangat did five jakaras and she gave the 2nd jakara and I gave the third and then she was in so much josh she also gave the fourth jakara... haha . Anyway this user-name reminds me of that time and the lessons I learned from her (Bibi Rena Kaur) - especially being humble and not doing ninda of people and not being engrossed in false pride (which I am still working on). I've been using it since that time - so it's been more than a year now, and I guess I'm just accustomed to it. Most people already know who I am posting behind this ID and so they can come and hit me with juthiaa anytime I say something wrong. But i don't deny that I have posted under other ID's on this forum and other forums. Japnaam Singh and Gurjeet Kaur know my other ID's - and I think they also know the main reason was not to "get away with it" or to "protect my privacy" or even to "protect my popularity" (i don't have any) but sometimes you just don't want people to talk good OR bad of you you don't want them to reflect on you at all you don't want to exist as a person - because you don't matter sometimes you feel like you are nothing, and nothing is done through you so why should you attach your name all of the Guru Sahibs and bhagats put their name at the end of their bani but Bhai Gurdas Ji didn't for his vaars and Guru gobind Singh ji didn't for his bani so i don't think there is a "rule" in Sikhi - I think Sikhi is about "bhaavNaa" and sometimes you now in your heart what your intentions are But these are all stages... maybe I am at a very very low stage Even if we are gupt it doesn't make us nehkaamee (free from desires) Some of the gupt people are more kaamee, krodhee But everybody is at a different stage ... We are all learning ... Anyway... someday Paapees like me who should be hiding will be forced underground And the True Bhagats will come out in the open Last comment: Kulbir singh veerjee you said, "Again, this is just my opinion and is not binding on anyone." If it really bothers you - I am not attached to it - If you tell me directly, I will consider it binding as you are a Gursikh and I will stop using this name. I'm not going to refuse a gursikh. vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !

Re: Why do people hide?

kar kirpaa sabh rayN thheevaa · 15 Mar 2005

Another thing Bhai Parminder Singh ji used to tell me the bhaavNaa of gupt seva is not as healthy and gurmat oriented as the bhaavNaa of nishkaam seva nishkaam seva for Guru jee is the real pure prem-bhaavNaa vaalee seva sometimes gupt seva has ego too sometimes we are gupt but we still congratulate or "flatter" ourselves for the seva but nishkaam seva - without desire or ulterior motive, is the best seva just because some of us are gupt does not mean we are humble sometimes even seva out in the open can be nishkaam if your mind is clean. humility comes from becoming nehkaamee, not necessarily gupt. humility comes from extinguishing the flames of thrishnaa inside yourself. i feel like i'm lecturing to myself here.. hehe vaaheguroo jee kaa khaalsaa vaaheguroo jee kee fatheh !!!!

Re: Why do people hide?

unknown · 15 Mar 2005

Kulbir Singh you are a high sprituial level Gursikh and it does not matter to you, but if i get some appreciation on what i post.....it feeds my Homaey....

Re: Why do people hide?

Kulbir Singh · 15 Mar 2005

------- Bhai Parminder Singh ji used to tell me the bhaavNaa of gupt seva is not as healthy and gurmat oriented as the bhaavNaa of nishkaam seva nishkaam seva for Guru jee is the real pure prem-bhaavNaa vaalee seva sometimes gupt seva has ego too -------- Excellent point Bhai Sahib Parminder Singh jee made. Everytime I read the name "Parminder Singh", his sweet smiling face comes in front of me. I consider it nothing less than a karamaat that short time before he left this world, he came to Gurdwara Tapoban Sahib. We were having Santhiya at that time and he sat with us and even read few shabads. A day or so later, I went to see him at Malton, where he was organising a camp. What a charming personality he had and what beautiful person he was. If he had not come to see us, I would have never had his darshan and I would have regretted rest of my life. Coming back to this topic, Bhai Parminder Singh made an excellent point that what is important is nishkaam sewa. This is the hard part. To be totally nishkaam when doing sewa is very hard. May Guru Sahib enable us to do Nishkaam Sewa. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Why do people hide?

Kulbir Singh · 15 Mar 2005

------- Kulbir Singh you are a high sprituial level Gursikh and it does not matter to you, but if i get some appreciation on what i post.....it feeds my Homaey.... --------- hehe! Very funny!! How would it feed haume, if you were to post your real name when debating? When I posted this post, I was mostly targetting towards debating. When debating, many gursikhs don't use their real name. I have a feeling that when people use their real names, they do a more sensitive debate and we would get a lot less rogue posts. I know many of your are going to write that how come "Kulbir Singh" or "Arshee Giyani" don't do sensitive debate. Well, I would say that we are exempted from this rule. hehe! Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Why do people hide?

unknown · 15 Mar 2005

Again dear Kulbir Singh, appreciation feeds one's Homey.......that is the only reason that i remain unknown...... Might not be your case, because of your Avasta....

Re: Why do people hide?

Abhiyaas.Blogspot.Com · 16 Mar 2005

In Daas' personal case if one always posts in their real name, this can cause ego. You may not notice the ego, however, it exists deep within. Bhai Sahib Rama Singh Ji explained this ego as being like a woodworm. I.E. If some wood is rotting from the inside it will have wood worms inside it, however, these worms will be unseen an you won't know about them until you investigate. Similarly, Bhai Rama Singh Ji linked this to us, we may seem shining and Gurmukh-like from the outside, but inside we may be rotting with subtle Ego. So daas thinks that posting without using your name is OK. One good point daas picked up on is that if one posts without using his/her own name then they are more likely to post silly posts, rogue posts, as Bhai Sahib Kulbir Singh has described it. This is quiet true. A humble Benti is to not spoil such fruitful debates or topics as they can change the life of Manmukhs like me. Another thing with excellent posts is that after reading we must put the Gurmukh qualities read about into our life, only this way can our coming onto this website be fruitful. Even Sri Guru Ji says that anyone can read about Gurmat etc and be inspired, however, VERY few actually practise TAT GURMAT. We should take examples from Gurmukhs such as Bhai Sahib Rama Singh Ji and Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji who were inspired by Japping Naam and nothing else, only this way will our birth in the house of Guru Nanak be fruitful and rewarding. We should look at the Rangley Sajjan that Bhai Sahib Bhai Randhir Singh Ji wrote about and shape our Jeevans so that we can be like them. These Rangley Sajjan never wasted their time just reading and not practising, they were the very embodiment of Gurmat, they practised it with full force and with all their swaas, and thus, they became Brahmgyaanee. I remember one example, Bhai Harbhajan Singh? (not entirely sure on the name), he himself used to make fun of Sikhi, then all of a sudden when he heard the Jatha do Keertan he was wonder struck and immediately went into Samadhee, SreeMaan Baoo Maal Singh Ji picked him up from the path he was sitting in and bought him into the sangat still in this illuminated state. This shows that even we have the potential of becoming Gurmukh and reaching the Dasam Duaar just like these Rangley Sajjan did. From Abhiyaas.Blogspot.Com: Humbleness One thing Daas has noticed in his place of work is that alot of people go around looking like the 'Don'. This is quiet evident in the Youth here. Only that person shines out out of these people who continously carries his Naam-Khanda. These people are such that they shine out. Currently, Daas is listening to the Shabad 'Gursikha kee har dhooR dai' - Oh Lord, give me the dust of the Gursikhs. The currents Daas recieves from this Shabad are unbearable. Aah! Unbearable. The person who does non-stop abhiyaas himself becomes nimaaNa (humble). By becoming the dust of everyone, our Ego is eradicated from our system, and thus Naam coes to abide within the alter of our own heart. So we should all be genuinely humble and become Gurmukh. - Abhiyaas.Blogspot.Com

Re: Why do people hide?

J Singh · 16 Mar 2005

I am not for or against posting with real name as long as there is not malicious intent or ulterior motive while using an alias; but we should stick with one ID to identified ourselves to sangat. Using multiple IDs could means that the person doesn't want to be held accountable for what she is saying. Even if Kulbir Singh posted under a different name, we will still have the same love and respect for him. You can call a rose with any name you like, it is still a rose :-)! vjkk vjkf

Re: Why do people hide?

kaur · 16 Mar 2005

Waheguroo Jee Ka Khalsa Waheguroo Jee Kee Fateh I don't want to change the topic, but just a quick question in relation to something Satkaar-Yog Kulbir Singh Jee wrote: "To say what is Gurmat, whether it makes me popular or unpopular, is utmost Gurmat." What happens if you say what you think is Gurmat, but in fact, due to your lack of understanding of Guru Jee, it is not completely Gurmat. Is not the assertion of what you are saying is Gurmat merely Hunkaar? I.e., "I know everything about Gurmat, and the Guru's Mat requires X." How can we entirely be sure, unless one is a BrahmGyanee, what Gurmat is? Surely, for mere beings, our assertions are just interpretations of Gurmat. Of course, a an individual that has more knowledge of Guru Jee is likely to interpret Gurmat correctly, but as Naam Abhiyaasi Jee pointed out, there may be a woodworm of subtle but false ego within us, which deludes us from Gurmat on a particular issue? In this situation, how can we say, "I will say what is Gurmat, whether it makes me popular or unpopular"? Must we not always qualify our understanding of Gurmat, as only BrahmGyanees and Guru Jee are perfect? (AND by definition, a BrahmGyanee will never claim to be one). Of course, in this situation, we can always argue that our interpretation is more correct by showing why our understanding fits more with Gurbani, but one can never assert with 100% confidence. Please forgive this Moorakh, as I do not intend to do Kintoo-Prantoo over Gursikhs such as Kulbir Singh Jee, but I would appreciate a response to this (mis)understanding of Gurmat on this issue. Bhul Chuk Maaf Waheguroo [%sig%]

Re: Why do people hide?

Kulbir Singh · 16 Mar 2005

"Kaur" Bhain jeeo, ----------- What happens if you say what you think is Gurmat, but in fact, due to your lack of understanding of Guru Jee, it is not completely Gurmat. Is not the assertion of what you are saying is Gurmat merely Hunkaar? I.e., "I know everything about Gurmat, and the Guru's Mat requires X." How can we entirely be sure, unless one is a BrahmGyanee, what Gurmat is? ----------- Bhain jeeo, please read what I wrote. I wrote that “To say what is Gurmat, whether it makes me popular or unpopular, is utmost Gurmat”. In this sentence, I was not trying to say that what I am saying is Gurmat but what I was trying to say is that if when talking Gurmat, people oppose you or deem you unpopular, you should still continue to uphold Gurmat and continue to speak Gurmat. Of course like everyone else, I may be writing a lot of aal-pataal and it is quite possible that at times I may not be writing Gurmat. Where did I claim that all that I say is Gurmat? If I gave this impression, I apologise for it. ----------- Surely, for mere beings, our assertions are just interpretations of Gurmat. Of course, a an individual that has more knowledge of Guru Jee is likely to interpret Gurmat correctly, but as Naam Abhiyaasi Jee pointed out, there may be a woodworm of subtle but false ego within us, which deludes us from Gurmat on a particular issue? ----------- What to talk about subtle haume or sooksham haume when I am full of asthool haume. Subtle haume is such haume that is present in great Gursikhs before they reach the top state. I personally am not even free from asthool or zaahir haume yet, let alone sooksham haume. --------- Please forgive this Moorakh, as I do not intend to do Kintoo-Prantoo over Gursikhs such as Kulbir Singh Jee, but I would appreciate a response to this (mis)understanding of Gurmat on this issue. --------- You have every right to do kintoo-prantoo (question) over what I write. No problems at all. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Why do people hide?

kaur · 16 Mar 2005

Thank you Kulbir Singh Jee for responding so quickly. Please be assured I did not mean to use you personally as an example, but rather it was a general comment, but thanks for clearing things up anyway. It is just that sometimes you always hear individuals claiming what is Gurmat and what is not unequivocally, on issues in which there is much disagreement, and I feel like, how can he be so certain? Surely, their views are just opinions, which may or may not have credibility. Even in these situations, where the individual feels that he has much evidence and arguments to back him up, is it not the Gurmat and humble thing to state this 'opinion' is just being proffered as an opinion, rather than assert its unequivocal correctness, just in case they are wrong? (since they are not BrahmGyanees and assured of being correct, or if they were, they would still consider themselves as being insignificant and not claim this publicly). Once again, many thanks. Bhul Chuk Maaf Waheguroo

Re: Why do people hide?

Dogma · 16 Mar 2005

"WHY DO PEOPLE HIDE?" ..Because you scare us Kulbir Singh.

Re: Why do people hide?

.. · 17 Mar 2005

A rose by any other name will be a rose; a person by another name will be the same person. Then what is in a name? He has no name, yet His names are countless. If you come across someone that you don't know, you will THINK who is this person? That person will THINK who you are? The thought is there, the name is not. Then does it really matter what the name is? A wise and deep knowledge is held in these words, like most of Shakespeares works (i believe this quote is by him as well) - "I THINK THEREFORE I AM!!" Yet further to this, we must lose the "I AM" in order to learn who the true "I AM" really is...

Re: Why do people hide?

Rain drop · 17 Mar 2005

Yes I hide it, Some benefits I get. I feel free. I do not feel silly, after silly talks. I can jump over to a new name, as if born again. Earlier died, new born born. I am afraid of abuses and curses, which sometimes follow some posters. And also, sometimes, MERI CHHUPE REHAN DI CHAH TE CHHUP TUR JAAN DI-----(Bhai Vir Singh) Yet I am sorry, for the above talk. Bhai Kulbir Singh Ji is correct in his views. Khalsa should "dance in the open" PARGAT HOE NAACHO.

Re: Why do people hide?

/ · 17 Mar 2005

it is the ideas that are more important than discussing who posted what. the only other benefit of using same names would be to match a personality or way of thinking to the name which seems futile unless you know the person. MERI CHHUPE REHAN DI CHAH TE CHHUP TUR JAAN DI-----(Bhai Vir Singh) this is unbelievable way of thinking. i hope i can learn from it.

Re: Why do people hide?

? · 17 Mar 2005

why do you want to know the true names? are you going to send flowers to all the members on tapoban forum?

Re: Why do people hide?

Bachan_Vidiya · 17 Mar 2005

I agree with Kulbir Singh Ji, but often (and I admit to it hands up) the things I say, I would never have the guts to say it to to their faces. Yeh, I guess that makes me gutless. I don't want to reveal my identity as I know it would surprise sum ppl and I would have my face punched!