battling evil
? · 10 Mar 2005
Is it wrong to use evil to battle against evil? Because to catch a snake you have to be a snake yourself and if you are a lamb then the snake will eat you alive.
Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton
ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥
? · 10 Mar 2005
Is it wrong to use evil to battle against evil? Because to catch a snake you have to be a snake yourself and if you are a lamb then the snake will eat you alive.khalsa · 10 Mar 2005
Khalsa never uses evil and a Singh can never be a snake.....Kulbir Singh · 10 Mar 2005
Khalsa uses weapons given by Vaheguru i.e. Naam and Shub-gunn (good qualities) and fights evil through goodness and not through evil. And to catch a snake one does not have to be a snake, but be a Garudd. What is Garudd? Garudd is a mystical bird that eats only snakes. Snakes are very timid and scared of Garudd. Talking it is written in Hindu Shasters that Vishnu always rides a Garudd. In Gurbani it has been written that in order to tame Maaiya bhujang (snake) one needs Garud roopi Gur-Shabad. Here is the pankiti to substantiate this: GARUD MUKH, NAHI SARP TRAAS || (If one has the Garudd-roop Gurshabad on lips, there is no need to fear any snake). BISHIYAR BISHOO BHARAE HAIN POORAN, GUR GARUD SHABAD MUKH PAVAGO || (To counter snakes full of poison (venom), put Garud roopi Shabad in your mouth). Once some Singhs who were angry at the atrocities committed by the Muslim rulers of that time, came to Sachay Patshaah Siri Guru Gobind Singh jee Maharaaj and entreated him to allow them to commit excesses to Muslim females caught in battles. They implored before Satguru jee saying that RangaRs and Muslims perpetually outrage the modesty of Hindu and Sikh girls and as such they should be taught a lesson by outraging their women's modesty. Siri Guru jee was greatly disappointed when he heard this plea from some misguided gursikhs. Guru Sahib very sternly and peremptorily affirmed that no Sikh was to treat any Muslim women any differently than their own sisters and daughters. Siri Guru jee said that Khalsa must uphold the golden principles of Gurmat and under no conditions was to resort or degenerate to the level of Manmukhs. Khalsa always remembered this hukam of Guru Sahib and all through the 150 years of battles between Muslim forces and Khalsa forces, never transgressed this hukam of Guru Sahib. Numerous times, Khalsa reluctantly ended up with female captives but Khalsa always treated them with full respect. Sardar Baghel Singh in whose captivity a very beautiful princess of Lahore darbar fell during his youth years, did not reciprocate the feelings of infatuation that she expressed towards him. Sardar jee kept the high ideals of Gurmat and did not yield to her pressure and did not reply to her advances towards him. She was greatly amazed at this because she had always been used to receiving attention from males while she was in Lahore but in Khalsa’s captivity, no one even looked at her. Such was the great character of Singhs. A Gori bibi (White lady) once wrote a very interesting incident of Master Tara Singh, who stayed the undisputed leader of the Sikhs for about 40 years. When Master Tara Singh jee was a young man, he was once travelling in train. In the same train, in his cabin a Goree Bibi came and stayed for many hours. She narrated that while everyone always stared at her and many looked at her in a lustful manner, all through her years in India, she was totally surprised that Master Tara Singh did not look at her even once even though he was sitting right in front of her, in a private cabin. She wrote that Master jee stayed in total oblivion for her and stayed absorbed in reading and doing paath while he was in the train. Such was the character of Gursikhs. So veer jeeo, evil is the way of manmukhs and Naam is the way of Gurmukhs. Since Khalsa is in the ilaahi-Tahaffuz (divine protection) of Vaheguru, it does not need to resort to the ways of evil to fight off evil. You cannot fight darkness through darkness. You need light to drive away darkness. Daas, Kulbir Singh? · 10 Mar 2005
Thank you very much for the insightful reply. Would it be alright to use evil at a specific time if the result was an overall good?Pardeep Singh Bilga · 11 Mar 2005
Khalsa ji wrote: "Khalsa never uses evil and a Singh can never be a snake....." Ever heard of the phrase "Paapi ke maarne ko, paap maha-balli hai" This translates as "To kill a sinner/evil person, it is righteous to use sin/evil" And Singhs can be snakes- when Guru Kalgidhar paatshah' 2 younger sahibzadas were held at Sirhind, Guru Sahib sent somebody (Mahi Halkara) to check on them, how they were doing. When the messenger returned, he told Guru Sahib that Sucha Nand Diwan has called your sons "sapolieh" (sons of a snake) as they refused to convert to Islam. Guru ji replied, I accept this name and when he wrote the zafarnama to Aurangzeb, he quoted "You may have killed my 4 sons and called them sons of a snake, but the kundli wala (main snake) veer Khalsa is still alive and well and will continue his fight against injustice. Bhul chuk maafKulbir Singh · 11 Mar 2005
-------- Ever heard of the phrase "Paapi ke maarne ko, paap maha-balli hai" This translates as "To kill a sinner/evil person, it is righteous to use sin/evil" --------- This is not the correct translation under any circumstances. This phrase clearly means that to kill a sinner or a paapi, his or her own paap or sin is capable of doing so. A sinner's sin is what destroys the sinner. Daas, Kulbir Singh