Gurdwara Tapoban SahibBrampton

ਪ੍ਰਥਮਰਹਿਤਯਹਿਜਾਨਖੰਡੇਕੀਪਾਹੁਲਛਕੇ॥ ਸੋਈਸਿੰਘਪ੍ਰਧਾਨਅਵਰਨਪਾਹੁਲਜੋਲਏ॥

Forum

Praise of Guru's in Gurbani

Praise of Guru's in Gurbani

Unsure · 09 Mar 2005

Gurfateh Jee. A question came up in a discussion and has baffled me somewhat. Why has Guru Jee included Shabads in Guru Granth Sahib that are really just praising Guru Jee themselves? Obviousley you can understand Guru Arjun Dev Jee including the praises of the earlier 4 Guru Jees, but examples such as Ramkali Ki Vaar or other compositions by the Bhatts also include the praises of Guru Arjun Dev Jee. So just to reiterate the question that was asked was why would Guru Jee include their own praises? I am sure that the cyber-sangat will have some reasonale resposes to this. I personally could not answer it. Look forward to you responses. Gurfateh.

Re: Praise of Guru's in Gurbani

Mkhalsa · 10 Mar 2005

bani guru guru hai bani.. always the guru has been the jot or the light of gurbani.. such jot was passed from each body/vessel... guru sahib, the vessel, praised guru sahib, the light...

Re: Praise of Guru's in Gurbani

Kulbir Singh · 10 Mar 2005

Dhur kee baani came to this world as per the hukam of Vaheguru. Whichever baani was ordained by Vaheguru to come, came to his Bhagats and Guru Sahibaan. Siri Guru jee has written very clearly that: SATGUR KEE BAANI SATT SATT KAR JANHO GURSIKHO, HAR KARTA AAP MOHOO KADHAAYE|| (O Gursikhs, believe Satguru’s baani to be one hundred percent truth because Vaheguru himself brings Gurbani on the rasna or tongue of Gurus) There are other pankitis too that teach us that Gurbani came in this world as per special hukams of Vaheguru. If Vaheguru ordained that Dhur kee Baani praising Guru Sahibaan was to come, who could have hindered its arrival? One thing Vaheguru did is that most of the baani praising Guru Sahibaan directly, has come from Bhatts; and Satt and Balwand. At few places Siri Guru Arjun Dev jee Maharaaj has written in praise of Siri Guru Nanak Dev jee Maharaaj. To speak the truth cannot be wrong and we should remember that Gurbani came as per hukam of Vaheguru. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Praise of Guru's in Gurbani

dil · 10 Mar 2005

VJKK.VJKF; After reading above post one question came to mind many times. I need answer to my saticfaction. I understand that all these prophets including 10 Gurus came on earth with the comandment from god only. That shabad in praise of Sri Krishan Bhagwan in bhatt di Bani. "KANWAL NAIN MADHUR BAIN -----------------" I do not doubt gurubani but this question is out of my courosity. VJKK, VKKF;

Re: Praise of Guru's in Gurbani

Jarnail Singh gyani "Arshi" · 11 Mar 2005

Waheguru Ji ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji ki fateh. Unsure veer/Bhain Ji, How did the very idea like this ever enter your mind ?? Did you for a moment consider that GURU JI.. "doesnt deserve" this Praise ??..for whatever reason ??? A Sikh doesnt "doubt" His GURU....look at how Bhai lehna Ji was TESTED by Guru Nanak Ji Sahib..some of these "tests" were ??? out of this world ??like the one of "eating the corpse"..Bhai lehna Ji ddint even blink an eye and just asked shall i begin eating from the head side or feet side ??..and what was the RESULT ?? Bhai lehna Ji became GURU ANGAD JI SAHIB. Most if not ALL the "problems" we have today are due to DOUBT. IF GURU JI says Keep your Kesh.... we say...ok...but why ?? is it because kesh make Vitamin D ?? or do the kesh make my head cool in summer and warm in winter ??...or prevent injuries to my head in an accident ?/ etc etc etc. A person with DOUBT has his two feet in different boats....a sure fire way to DROWN. We spend so many hours and hours wondering if baba Deep Singh really had his head cut off ??? WHAT happened in the TENT at Anandpur Sahib in 1699 ?? we MUST unravel EVERY thread of "evidence".. "SEE" everything before we BELIEVE ??? EVERY SINGLE WORD in the GURU GRANTH JI is DIVINE GURBANI....Guru Ji tells us so in so many words....as Kulbir Singh ji has explained above. To whom are we "looking" to "convince" us of this...the "scholars", the "academics", the "gyanis", the "sants/babas"...how foolish of us to IGNORE GURU JI and go look for these SANSAAREE BANDEH to lead us out of the woods ?? Do we really need to be "convinced" ??? if that is so then I am sorry because the GURBANI is 1429 AAngs...and it will take a really LONG LONG time to convince one of EACH word's authenticity....and by the time you finish it all..your time may be UP....you would have "counted" all the trees in the forest but MISSED all the WOOD.....just as a small aside....when ever you read a bhatt "praising" GURU ARJUN Ji ( for example)..the PRAISE is for the JYOT of WAHEGURU residing in "Guru Arjun Ji" and NOT praise for the "human Body" named Guru Arjun Ji( born in a certain year....grew up and passed on in a certain year)...the human body is no more..BUT the JYOT of WAHEGURU is STILL with us in the GURBANI we have before us to enjoy its BLISS for ever..and ever. The DIVINITY of GURBANI is ABOVE humans and bodies we see....THAT is WHY GURU GOBIND SINGH JI ENDED the DEHDHAREE GURU in 1708. Jarnail Singh.

Re: Praise of Guru's in Gurbani

Kulbir Singh · 11 Mar 2005

-------- That shabad in praise of Sri Krishan Bhagwan in bhatt di Bani. "KANWAL NAIN MADHUR BAIN -----------------" I do not doubt gurubani but this question is out of my courosity. VJKK, VKKF; ---------- What is wrong in praising the good deeds of Krishna? If Krishna had beautiful kanwal or lotus like eyes, then it was only fair to praise the truth. This shabad "Kanwal Nain, Madhur Bain, Kot Sain, Sang Shobh, Kehat Maa Jashodh jisai, Dahee Bhaat khahe jeeo" is actually praising Vaheguru only. Gurbani here is saying that Siri Krishna had beautiful eyes, his talk was sweet, he had million friends with him and was very great. His mother Jashodhra who was not aware of his powers treated him like a mother treats her child and used to chase him to eat yogurt (dahee bhaat khahe jeeo) and other foods. In the end, the shabad makes it clear though Siri Krishna in had these qualities but Vaheguru alone is eternal force in this world. Krishna came and did good work and then he was gone but Vaheguru is "Satt Saach, Siri Niwaas, Aad purakh sada tuhee; Vaheguru Vaheguru Vaheguru Vahe jeeo". Though Krishna or Rama or other avtaars had done great deeds but their glory was short lived. Vaheguru alone is the "aad Sach" i.e. eternal always. We should realise that Gurbani speaks nothing but truth. At times where Guru Sahib found Krishna or Rama doing good deeds, they were praised but when they did faltered, that too was mentioned. Read Siri Guru Dashmesh jee's Baani: KAHA BHAIYO JO AAN JAGAT MEH, DAS KU ASSUR HAR GHAYE || Next line I can't remember but the meaning of this pankiti is that "So what if Krishna came to this world and destroyed few demons. He however faltered from his maarag and called himself God. Daas, Kulbir Singh

Re: Praise of Guru's in Gurbani

Rain drop · 12 Mar 2005

WJKKWJKF When Guru Sahiban, say MEHMA of GURU in Gurbani; that is for the earlier ONES. Secondly, oneness of Akal Purakh and Guru, also explains "the praises". Thirdly, when Guru says Himself as poor Nanak and praises the Guru; we see the ------ Bhatts and Satta Balwand writtings, praising Gurus are of very practical or physical vision and have historical importance in it. Those writtings are their bowings(Namaskar), before the Guru. And then how we "explain", that Guru Sahiban, allowed Sikhs Chran Amrit and Namaskar. How a father allows his own praises and namaskar by his son. What are those feelings in the fathers. Father has to "behave" and "be behaved", for the benefit of his children.